Andrew Zimbalist Says What We’re All Thinking
In this article about the Dodgers sale (which raises some of the same questions I’m having about the price), Andrew Zimbalist says this about Frank McCourt:
“It’s problematic,” Zimbalist said. “He was looking for some kind of ongoing income stream and he got it. Here’s a guy who borrowed practically all the money to buy the team for $430 million and now he’s selling it for $2.15 billion and he’s coming out with a healthy capital gain — it’s repulsive. This is someone who doesn’t deserve to walk away with a healthy profit after eight years of running the Dodgers in the most egregious, the most inefficient, the most self-interested, and the most vainglorious, idiotic way possible. It really is repulsive that he will still be making a profit in some way.”
Amen, Mr. Zimbalist. A-men.
Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.


Why should Dodger fans care about the morality of McCourt’s profit from this?
Because Dodgers fans are moral beings, and all moral beings should be repulsed by McCourt being rewarded for his actions.
yankees fans on the other hand…
Don’t care.
I care about the product on the field, not whether billionaires can become even bigger billionaires.
It would have been almost impossible for him to walk away from this at a loss given how valuable baseball franchises has become.
Why bother caring about it? Meh.
Brian Stow would like to have a word with you.
Dodgers fans and morals? Hilarious.
“Dodgers fans and morals? Hilarious.”
Awwww……
pretty sure this has nothing to do with Dodgers fans specifically.
actually I take that back. Dodgers fans were inadvertently accomplices by feeding him money while he drove the MLB team into the ground.
Sure it does, the quote the article is from is about the Dodgers.
I dont think this has to do with the feeling of any fan, but rather just any person, regardless of baseball knowledge or involvement, should be pissed. The man, through money he didn’t have, put a company in danger by running it horribly, and somehow came out more than unscathed, he came out with a cool Billion.
That’s your basic vulture capitalism. It’s how many firms make money in the real (non-baseball) world and I guess it was only a matter of time until someone tried it with a baseball team. My only hope is that this little adventure makes Selig et al. think a lot harder about who they want owning ballclubs.
And now a big IB firm essentially owns the Dodgers. wah wah. :<
Ladies and gentlemen, introducing the new American dream.
I hate to tell you this, Kyle and others of your mindset, but businessmen make billions on financial shenanigans all the time in America.
Look at the Forbes list of the richest people and see how many of them actually did anything that helped provide better products and services to the American (or any other) people.
Get over it.
I’m not a Dodgers fan at all, yet I am still repulsed by the fact that an avaricious slug like McCourt will make an enormous profit from this sale.
Rich guy with extremely valuable asset makes money.
Shocking.
Maybe because he exploited their devotion to this team in order to swindle all this money away? I know if it was me I wouldn’t have wanted any of my ticket price going to some Russian pseudo psychic sending “good feelings” my team’s way.
Why should you care if anybody else cares? By all means, enjoy your orgy of apathy, but don’t feel you have to tell the rest of us all about it.
Extra credit for using “vainglorious” in a sentence.
capitalism at its best…scumbags get rewarded. makes me want to puke.
Absolutely! This is a wonderful example of why their is almost no middle class left in our society. Life is not fair. Anyone who has been waking up daily for 15 years realizes that. Yet this points to a problem much larger than baseball yet baseball is a prime example of it. Example: 5 million dollars/1 WAR on the open market. Some things are unfair and some things are wrong.
“capitalism at its best…”
No. Rather, this outcome was the result of an investment in a government-sanctioned monopoly. This whole arrangement is anathema to free-market capitalists and to liken it to capitalism serves only to reveal your own ignorance on the subject.
Capitalism at its best would see the Dodgers go out of business and a competition amongst multiple newcomers to see who could be the most successful baseball team in LA with the winner continuing to exist and being regularly challenged by more newcomers.
This is how capitalism works in the real world, Surrealistic Pillow. If there weren’t government-sanctioned monopolies, there would be privately-created monopolies (that the government normally works to prevent). Monopolies exist because they’re hugely profitable, and those who profit from them do whatever they can to maintain them. To pretend that “free market capitalism” can work without monopolies springing up is a fantasy.
^You really have no idea about what the fuck it is you are talking about, huh?
This is funny. I agree with Surreal Pillow’s talk about how this is not really the capitalist ideal, but I would also love to see what a league created by “startup teams” would look like. I imagine this will be good for team loyalty. All in favor of the “The Capitalist Games”, raise their copy of Atlas Shrugged.
Yes, but it’s government regulation that prevents (or used to) the rise of monopolies. To pretend that without government regulation, MLB would NOT be a monopoly is at odds with the evidence of every other American sport, which are monopolies without any government interference.
So while technically this one is not free-market capitalism, it’s pretty clear it’s not the government sanctioning the monopoly that created the problem.
Does not a person alive still understand the difference between “Free Market” and “Capitalism”
This is very much capitalism, as a group of investors collaborated on a business venture.
What this isn’t is “Free Market.” MLB is essentially a monopoly on professional baseball, and within it, the commissioner is in charge of keeping the league together. If this were truly “Free Market” the dodgers would’ve been allowed to go bankrupt, but, in the interest of MLB, pressure was made to find buyers to protect the identity of the franchise and the league.
Ari, that’s not really how it works. The reason all the major leagues are monopolies is basically the result of legislative and litigative history. Basically, all the younger leagues have fallen under the precedents set by the MLB back in the early 20th century; if you look at “Major League” history prior to that, you’d actually see it was notably not monopolistic. Now you can’t read too much into that, as the conditions of early major league ball were quite different than those that exist now, but it is clear that the monopoly that exists today is fundamentally grounded in government decisions on both the legislative and judicial level.
Of course, if you listen to the X-Clan’s first album, you can hear the word “vanglorious” in nearly every song.
Listen to who’s what?
McCourt’s actions in this whole sad saga are indeed reprehensible, but it’s not like he’s an especially villainous character given the context. Executives fucking things up and then walking away with huge bonuses and severance packages has become the norm (or so it seems). “I was in charge, sure, but you still can’t hold me accountable” seems to be the current zeitgeist in this country.
Have you read up on the whole McCourt/Dodgers saga? His actions WERE especially villainous, far beyond the standard exec who messes everything up and gets a golden parachute.
Perhaps not as extensively as you, but I have read up on the whole 2008 economic crash thing and it’s quite unbelievable what went on in the run-up to that whole fiasco.
Oh yeah, not saying that terrible stuff doesn’t happen in other sectors. There are plenty of instances of people doing heinous stuff there. Just saying that what McCourt did was also heinous.
Emperor PalpatineDan Synder resents your implication that McCourt was especially villainous.He also keeps the parking lots…
this couldn’t possibly be true…is it?
Only half of them…
Isn’t this how big business works? (sadly)
Rich man takes over business, rich man runs business poorly, rich man sells business for profit (or claims bankruptcy) and walks away a richer man.
No, it isn’t.
It’s rich man takes over one division of large business, and runs it very poorly. The rest of the business works well, and the value of the business as a whole rises dramatically. Rich man then sells his one division, which has appreciated significantly thanks to the rise in value of the overall business, and makes a handsome profit despite his ineptitude. It’s basically like buying an oil well when oil was cheap, running it like shit for years, but because oil as a product has become a lot more valuable in that tmie you can still sell that well for a ton of money because if the new owner runs it well, they can make a ton of money off it.
This kind of stuff happens all the time. Just look at all the big investment banks. The only difference here is that people can actually see it in action and out in the open.
Ah, the magic of monopolies and old boy’s networks.
I blame Bud.
Does this make McCourt a modern day slum lord for Sports franchises? The way he was able to profit from this was pretty astonishing.
Of course, had McCourt run the Dodgers well, then he would have walked away with far more money. Don’t forget he still has to pay off over a billion dollars worth of debt.
The fact of the matter is, whether through good business sense or just dumb luck, it turns out he made a very good investment in buying the Dodgers. It was so good that even though he almost ran it into the ground he still made a profit.
well, he should be pretty well able to cover 1 billion of debt using his brand shiny new 2 billion dollars! and that kind of thinking is how you get the pirates of the last 15 years.
ON the other hand JayT, had he run the Dodgers well he wouldn’t be selling at all. The only reason the valuation came out that high was because it was run as an auction related to bankruptcy. Yes another of Bud’s handpicked losers profits, but baseball is entering a big financial upswing and to have the Dodgers sell for much less than they are worth for a second time running would have been worse business.
Yes it is correct to blame Bud for this mess. To claim no one wanted to buy the Dodgers when McCourt did is ridiculous and reveals the machinations. But this price & process has hopefully guaranteed a little sanity for the franchise.
I don’t see how that changes anything I said. If he were running it well, it would have been a massive money maker for him for many years, rather then getting one lump sum that was less then what really should have gotten considering how little he paid for the franchise.
Zimbalist has been the go-to guy for a negative comment about sports-related finance. He’s kind of like a professional “expert witness” for the media. Considering he has none of the particulars of the deal at his disposal, I am not sure how he could come to such a definitive conclusion. Economics is based on analyzing inputs, not making wild guesses.
No, economics is based on spinning everything through your ideological prism and regurgitating whatever comes out to anyone who will listen.
No, that’s politics. Just like economists say the stimulus created jobs, while Republican politicians find the one economist who says it didn’t. (Same with scientists and climate change.) Having an opposing argument does not mean that they must be equal in validity and that we should throw our hands in the air and say, “Oh well, it must all be ideology.”
^That is an amusing place to employ an appeal to consensus.
Well said JayT, for the rest of the comments, McCourt is a douche, no one disagrees, ultimately it’s great for the MLB and all fans of baseball that he’s gone, good riddance, let’s see what this new ownership does for the Dodgermen, could be some fireworks going off in the NL West come free agency and the trade deadline!
Here’s the deal. McCourt deserves the money for one of 3 reasons. Either the Dodgers were worth well below what he paid for them and he was wise enough to see the equity, or the Dodgers were run in such a way to create $2 billion in value, or finally, McCourt was smart enough to dupe a group of wildly successful businessmen into paying 5 times what his horribly run operation was worth. Under any scenario, he deserves what he makes on the deal.
Now, could LA fans have killed his revenue stream by not purchasing tickets? Yes, but they chose not to. Regardless of how horrible of a person he is, the product he was peddling was still immensely valuable. In spite of, because of or indifferent to his decision making as an owner, he held legal title to an operation that generates hundreds of millions of dollars annually, on land worth hundreds of millions, with rights to operate in a highly exclusive industry. You may not like it, he may be the worst person this side of Bud Selig, but in no way, shape or form is he not entitled to the fruits of his labor.
Life isn’t fair. I bought a bank owned house for $35,000 in 2002, rented it for $1400 a month for 6 years and sold it for $205,000 in 2008. I paid 25 cents on the dollar on the front end, made buckets of cash and helped someone else into their dream of bankruptcy. Frank McCourt apparently has done the same.
Or McCourt held said franchise, running it poorly all the while, and then got extremely lucky that right around the time of his divorce and when the crippling debt would have actually crippled the franchise, cable stations started going bananas competing with each other for team broadcast rights creating a huge market upswing.
McCourt dumb lucked his way into an extra billion. Frankly there are plenty of people who make money by doing all the wrong things and having the right thing happen for them in the end. I won’t subscribe to the McCourt ‘deserves’ it mantra but I will certainly say he was in the right place at the right time and capitalized on it appropriately.
I think you’re voting for option 3.
I hope someone helps you into your dream of a premature death.
Some right-wing sociologists argue that the reason for the level of inequality in developed countries (particularly the United States, Canada and the UK) is the immorality of the poor. This is just one more data point for one part of the rebuttal to that nonsense.
Poverty is immoral. Is that what the sociologists meant?
Not exactly.
Conservatives argue that people are poor because they deserve to be. They don’t work hard enough or whatever so they deserve their poverty. That’s pretty much the same thing as saying they are immoral.
In past centuries, the belief was indeed that poor people were poor because they were morally inferior to their betters.
Same thing, different words.
Its called capitalism folks. Deal with it. Maybe MLB will be more cautious about how it chooses its owners, but this sale does nothing but increase the value of its product.
Maybe it’s capatilism, maybe it isn’t.
What I can say for certain is: it’s broken.
No, this should not be just blithely ignored under the “Deal with it, it’s capitalism” or whatever other excuse. Jesus Christ. Have you ever heard of justice. Thanks for posting this up, Mr. Cameron.
The fact that McCourt is being so richly rewarded for his terrible actions is offensive to me, as a human being. But as a Dodger fan, I honestly wouldn’t care if he was getting out with $20B, as long as he is getting out.
But yet, he’s not really getting out. As part owner of the parking lot he still gets a piece of (almost) every sucker who goes through the gates.
Not true – per reports, all parking revenue goes to the new owners. McCourt just gets to take part in and profit from any development of that land.
On the plus side, Mr McCourt will realize a capital gains rate of 15% while working stiffs like me pay a marginal rate nearly twice as high.
Yes, but as the Tea Party will gladly tell you, McCourt is a job creator.
Look at all those jobs that wouldn’t exist if it weren’t for his benificence.
Didn’t Babe Ruth get sold to the Yankees because the Red Sox owner had run the team into ground, much like Mr.McCourt? The point is this is nothing new in baseball.
Monopoly or unfettered capitalism would be better terms to describe the state of baseball, rather than capitalism. That’s where most of the more egregious happenings originate, in the monopolistic set-up and the decisions that allows the commissioner and owners to make, and simply saying capitalism does not bring that across to most people who have a more modern and more regulated notion of the term. Baseball is still in the age of the robber.
Robber baron, dammit. Robber baron.
Though I suppose robber works too.
I think in the society we live in right now, the term Robber Baron is really underused and probably should be on the comeback trail.
Unfettered? How do you imagine the monopoly is secured?
http://tinyurl.com/4k6kqj9
A professional economist making that claim disgusts me more than anything McCourt did. McCourt acted out of pure self-interest like he’s been doing his entire professional life. Zimbalist substituted his capacity to render professional moral judgments when he took the Ph.D. in economics. The enthymeme of professional economics is that the judgment of the market trumps all other forms of judgment in its implacable clarity and access to platonic truth. Hypocrites like Zimbalist exploit their social standing, credentials, and expertise to advance ideological agendas cloaked in market truth and then try to turn the bag inside-out when they get a result they don’t like? I hope he breaks his neck choking on his own dork.
Economics is a substitute for morality since when? What economic program anywhere makes that claim? It’s a field designed to describe what does happen not what should happen.
Furthermore, typing psuedo death threats really does not get your point across.
“The enthymeme of professional economics is that the judgment of the market trumps all other forms of judgment in its implacable clarity and access to platonic truth.”
You know Karl Marx was an economist, right? There are many schools of economic thought out there, and free market capitalism is but one.
Agreed BDF. As someone with a degree in economics, it’s disheartening to hear the most mainstream “baseball economist” react in this manner. The primary criticism of McCourt shouldn’t be that he made money on this deal…it’s that he should have made a ton more money than he did!
If a terrible landlord makes a lot of money selling an apartment building because the area the building is in has appreciated considerably since they bought it, even as their property has fallen apart, the logical criticism isn’t “he shouldn’t make money, he’s a bad person” it is really “what an idiot, he would have made a ton more money if he’d just done a better job”. If a new owner than comes in and turns the property into a set of highly profitable condos, it doesn’t mean they are a better person, it just means they’re a better businessman.
Frank McCourt is a bad businessman, and by all accounts a pretty miserable human being. That doesn’t mean there’s anything wrong with him making some money in selling his most valuable asset.
You know how we stop such crap from happening. We stop going to games, watching games, buying merchandise and supporting Major league teams and their minor league affiliates. Go watch a high school game.
I stopped paying as much as a penny on MLB a few years ago. I watch free games on TV and participate in free blogs.
I watch the games exclusively on DVR, so I can fast forward thru the ads. If I do happen to see who’s advertising, I tend to avoid dealing with that company.
Somehow, MLB has prospered without me.
Why would I let a bad owner prevent me from watching something I love?
I can participate about something AND complain about parts of it that I don;t like or agree with, right?
Aspects of real life don;t have to mimic bipolarism.
It’s not an all in or all out proposition.
Rather than going to watch a high school game, I recommend coaching a youth team or volunteering to play catch with some kids that don;t have a willing adult available.
But, we all know that nothing compares to MLB baseball, and overall, it’s worth our investment … warts and all.
I hate it when people just shrug and say, “Hey that’s capitalism man.” Capitalism and morality and accountability and justice shouldn’t be mutually exclusive things. Executives who run their companies into the ground and cause untold damage and suffering to others shouldn’t be rewarded with golden parachutes and indifference. I am not suggesting that Mr. McCourt did anything illegal, I know very little about the details in this case, but he seems at the very least to be negligent and irresponsible, characteristics that don’t deserve massive compensation.
The problem I have with all these arguments is that they are treating the profit earned on his investment as if it were a performance-based salary. What kind of human being he is or how capably he handled his responsibilities is irrelevant — his asset sold for what the market allowed it to sell for. That’s it. The market doesn’t care about the quality of his tenure (obviously). There are countries where the enlightened/moral get to manipulate the market to decide which types of humans profit from what and by how much, but I doubt you would want to live in any of them. None of us wants to see this man enriched for any reason, but it’s not injustice. It’s an investor gaming a system for max profit potential, which is what a good investor will do every time.
Yeah. I guess the part that surprises me about the comments is that this appears to be some sort of revelation for a lot of folks. Have you all not paid attention to, like, everything going on in the country for a while now? In 1998 the congress repealed a decades old law specifically so that the sitting Treasury Secretary could resign and go make billions running a company that was essentially created by the repeal of that law. For crying out loud, what Frank McCourt essentially flipped a really big house. Your government is literally giving away billions of dollars of your currency every single day, to people a lot richer than McCourt. Wake the hell up.
People are complaining about this but no one is paying attention to the ownership debacle happening in San Diego.
Did they just sell the Padres for 2 billion dollars?
Don’t worry, if McCourt is the bumbling idiot he’s been reported to be, this money will be gone in no time.
He made a good investment using leverage. That’s it. Why the hate? Most billionaire gained their riches this way.
If you can’t hate Frank McCourt, who can you hate?
Seems MLB is being bought out by investment bankers. Trickle down effect of the huge bailouts.
Lots of money in this country floating around among the top 0.1 %, what doesn’t end up in China goes into buying sports teams.
How is it a good thing for Dodger fans for their team to be bought at a price almost 2.5 times what any other team has sold for. Owners might want to squeeze the budget to make sure they get a decent ROI. Alternatively, they could raise ticket prices and parking fees.
You should read the book “Why Good Things Happen to Bad People.” If there is no such book, you can write it.
Are the Yankees still evil for putting money into player payroll and “buying” championships?
What most people are failing to realize is that the price of the Dodgers has more to do with the Federal Reserve than Baseball. Just wait another 10 years when a team sells for 20 Billion.
It has nothing to do with the Fed. I’m assuming this is some kind of Ron Paul “INFLATION!” thing (just guessing, feel free to correct me if I’m wrong), which, as someone with an economics background, is always hilarious because it’s just so nonsensically wrong.
The price of the Dodgers has increased because MLB revenues have grown significantly, and that revenue growth has far outpaced inflation (which has been minimal over the past few years; my off the cuff recollection is ~2% annually in the past 3-4 years). If MLB revenues continue to grow at an accelerated rate, it’s quite possible the Dodgers could be worth many billions more in 20 years, although it’s also quite possible that the value will plateau in the next decade or so as TV revenues plateau across the industry.
2.15 billion – 430 million = 450+% return. Subtract inflation and you’re saying that MLB revenue has increased by approximately 400% over the past decade?
I don’t have an economics background, but I do know that that’s an even better return than the Dow increase from 1995 to 2008. Or average home prices in the Vegas market during that same period. Those are the biggest bubbles we’ve seen in decades.
So if you are correct, can we at least make the “government sponsored monopoly” argument without you smearing us as Ron Paul acolytes?
Since McCourt bought the Dodgers, MLB revenues have grown from ~$4.5 billion to somewhere over $7 billion (no 2011 figures have been released that I can find in a quick search). In truth, I was talking about MLB revenues as a whole just as a simplifying assumption to make the comparison to inflation easier to understand, as the specifics of the Dodgers’ case is a little more complicated (if still entirely unrelated to inflation).
The very simplistic explanation of why the Dodgers’ value would grow so quickly relative to the MLB as a whole would be to point out local television revenue streams. Those are particularly lucrative for the Dodgers, thanks to their market, and if exploited properly could make the Dodgers one of the highest revenue teams in the MLB. It also has to do with the fact that valuation is not strictly tied to single year revenue, but rather projected revenues over a longer stretch of time (which is why I was mentioning that values may plateau over the next decade, as there are only so many new TV deals to be signed).
As for the monopoly argument…I’m not sure what the point would be. Everyone knows they’re a monopoly. Are you saying you’d prefer they not be?
I butchered the point I was trying to make on valuations, so just ignore that. This is why you don’t do back of the envelope economic analyses while at work…you end up writing something completely different than you were trying to say.
Another point to remember, as has been mentioned a few times already, is that McCourt bought the team for what was probably an under-market amount at the time. He sold it for what is likely substantially over-market. so, while you can do the basic 2b – 400m math, it’s probably much closer to 1.5b – 750m, or approximately 100% rate of return. Which, as Sean pointed out, can easily be accounted for by the increased television revenue, combined with the overall growth of MLB as a whole.
@Sean: How could you not know what the point would be? Unless you can account for a couple hundred percentage points of growth in the price of that franchise, it’s either the Ron Paul inflation/free money argument or that values franchises in major sports leagues are artificially high because they have no competition, by force of law.
And please stop with the “future earnings potential” point. Nobody in this ownership group is putting up 100% of their own money. Because to do so would be damn foolish, considering how much cheap money they all have access to. To their banks, present value of the franchise is what it is, future value represents their ability to pay it back (in part).
The bright side is that guys like Magic Johnson and Peter Gruber got fleeced.
It’s kind of like the housing boom of the last 10 years, except with sports franchises. Regardless of market, regardless of the quality of management, valuations have risen steadily higher. It’s a rich man’s game of musical chairs. The L.A. investors are betting that they’re getting in the middle of the game, not at the end when everyone decides the games are too damn expensive to watch. We’ll see if they’re right, and what happens after the first sports franchise is sold for less than it was bought for. It’s not really an ‘if’ question, it’s a ‘when’ question..
I don’t think anyone is talking about Ron Paul except yourself. Baseball is an international product, why would you compare it to a housing market? My point is that anything that is in demand in other parts of the world is going to look like an amazing investment when you compare it to dollars. The guy bought a good product, why criticize him for that?
That makes no sense whatsoever. What does the fact that the MLB has international popularity have to do with making the Dodgers more valuable? Hollywood movies are an international product, does that make them an “amazing investment when you compare it to dollars” (whatever that’s supposed to mean).
Your last point is right. How you got there…not so sure.
This is no difference than what Red McCombs did with the MN vikings. It is called smart business. The only difference is today, everyone wants to hate on the guy who made any money.
Guarantee that you could find hundreds of American businessmen who are far more slimy and ethically challenged than McCourt. People seem to regard McCourt’s ouster from baseball as some sort of divine act of banishing an evil wrongdoer; but there is absolutely no doubt that if his divorce had not shone a bright light on his finances, McCourt would still be firmly in control of the team today.
My point is this, gold has tripled since 2004. The dodgers value in gold terms, is not as impressive as in dollars. A lot more of the Dollar value of the sale has to do with outside influences, such as loose fiscal policies by the Fed. I am not getting political, I am just stating a point. If something in the US has international appeal, chances are, it is going to become more valuable in dollars than any rational estimate. Look at stocks like Nike and Apple that have doubled in 9 months. I would argue with anyone who doesn’t think the NY franchises haven’t all doubled in dollar terms in the past 3-4 years? Whatever your opinion was of him as a GM or owner is irrelevant to the money he made, and I, for one, am sick of american’s attacking anyone who is successful or made a successful investment.