Arizona Fall League Midseason Check-In

The 2026 Arizona Fall League is three weeks old and I’ve now seen every team at least a handful of times. This means I’ve got a handle on a good bit of the league and also can start to identify what gaps I need to fill in during the second half of the slate.
I’ve updated the Fall League tab over on The Board to reflect what Brendan Gawlowski (during his week here in Phoenix) and I have assessed, using the “Trend” column to draw your focus to whose stock we think is moving (with the up or down arrows), who has popped onto our radar for the first time (with the “New” label), and who I still need to see more of (with the target) to feel comfortable assessing. We have not changed anyone’s FV grade because three weeks of looks is only a slice of the evaluation pie and our thoughts might yet change, though we have given interim grades to the “New” players.
Below I’m going to take you through my thoughts on the most notable names and movers from the six-team league. I’m writing as if you already know a bit about each player’s trajectory and background. If you don’t, go to The Board and read their full scouting report, as they tend to provide the 360-degree view of the player’s career.
Ascending, Star-Caliber Prospects
Sebastian Walcott, SS, Texas Rangers
Dax Kilby, SS, New York Yankees
Both Walcott (internal brace elbow surgery) and Kilby (hamstring) spent a big portion of the season rehabbing from serious injuries. They look like the two best players in Arizona by a wide margin. Walcott stands head and shoulders (often literally) above everyone else in terms of his physical prowess. He has consistently shown all-fields power and has been passable in his return to playing defense at shortstop. That Walcott has a chance to debut as a shortstop, at his size, is remarkable. But players this big tend to move to the outfield, à la Oneil Cruz, and Walcott has begun to work out there a bit during pre-game drill, though he hasn’t yet played on the grass in a game. You can make an argument that Walcott is the best prospect in baseball; he’s going to have plus-plus power, hit enough to get to most of that power, and has a shot to play shortstop into his mid-20s. Brewers shortstop Jesús Made has a more stable contact profile, but Walcott has more power and, even though he’s a bit older than Made, he also has more room left on his frame for added strength. This is a player who could be a 30-homer shortstop at ages 23-25, and then a 40-homer outfielder at age 30.
Kilby is the best pure hitter in the Fall League. His hands just seem to be in the right place a lot of the time, and he can adjust the posture of his upper body to help get the barrel where it needs to go. He peppers both gaps with a lot of hard contact and he still has room for more mass. Defensively, Kilby doesn’t look like a viable shortstop. You could argue this has at least something to do with him returning to action after a serious hamstring issue, but I’ve had Kilby projected to move to the outfield since he was in high school, and the way he looks at shortstop now has just reinforced my priors. He’s still a really exciting prospect, and I think he’s going to hit enough that it won’t matter very much where he plays. Walcott will likely be a top 2-5 prospect for us, and Kilby will probably be top 20.
Super Talented, Considerably Flawed
Jarlin Susana, RHP, Washington Nationals
Bryce Rainer, SS, Detroit Tigers
Susana is sitting 99-102 and routinely bends in a plus-plus curveball. He also can’t throw strikes, and his fastball doesn’t move enough to forgive poor location, even at elite velocity. He has looked like a reliever to me, but I don’t really care to move Susana down because I think elite relievers like the one he’ll be deserve to have top 25-ish placement on the universal prospect list, anyway. If I had known Josh Hader or Edwin Díaz would go on to have the careers they did, they would have been top 15 prospects. Susana is looking at an outcome in the Jhoan Duran realm.
Rainer’s swing is longer and crazier than You Can See Everything. He has a huge arm bar and it takes forever for his bat to enter the hitting zone. He also has some of the best lefty bat speed I’ve ever seen, and his best swings are like watching a lefty-hitting Ronald Acuña Jr. Rainer has already become quite barrel-chested and he isn’t especially range-y on defense, but he has a ridiculous arm that makes up for his other little deficiencies. Same as Susana: I’m not inclined to move where we have Rainer graded. He’s so talented that I’m happy to accept the risk that he won’t hit and am valuing him as a top 25-ish prospect because he has 35-homer upside if he does. If he shows up for camp in February and his physique has continued to trend bulky, I’ll become more apprehensive about this working out.
Good Prospects Reinforcing Strong Pre-existing Evals
Zyhir Hope, OF, Detroit Tigers
Arjun Nimmala, SS, Los Angeles Angels
Eduardo Quintero, OF, Los Angeles Dodgers
Tate Southisene, SS, Atlanta Braves
Caleb Bonemer, OF, Chicago White Sox
These guys are already graded as future everyday players and, based on how they have looked, there’s no reason to change that. Bonemer entered the AFL season as the one of this group I was worried I’d come away feeling more skeptical about because of how much whiffing he did during the regular season. Instead, I think his power is weaponized by sufficient barrel feel. He is likely to be a left field-only defender in the big leagues, but he could have output similar to Teoscar Hernández. Southisense and Quintero feel, to me, like the ones with the best chance of outgrowing the 50-FV tier between now and when they debut. They simply have better tools than the other power-centric hitters here, especially Southisene.
Arrow Up Potential Stars
Nathan Flewelling, C, Tampa Bays Rays
Charles Davalan, 2B, Los Angeles Dodgers
Zion Rose, OF, Kansas City Royals
Tai Peete, OF, St. Louis Cardinals
I was apprehensive about stuffing Flewelling during the last list cycle because both his defense and hit tool are 30s on the scale right now. His defense is still a significant issue, but he’s a 19-year-old Canadian kid, so of course it is. Flewelling has such rare lefty power and athleticism (he’s an above-average runner once he gets moving and is such a smooth, graceful mover) that he could profile as an everyday corner outfielder if it comes to that, though I don’t think it will. Davalan is revisiting second base, where he played as a freshman at Florida Gulf Coast, and it’s going well. A long in-person look has also made me confident that he has meaningful juice despite being such a little guy. He’s going to be an everyday player, even if that means playing a mix of second base and left field the way Chris Taylor and Enrique Hernández would in concert with Max Muncy. Zion Rose looks the part of a solid 2-WAR player. His hands are twitchy, he’s fast, and he’s in incredible shape. I’d like to see what he looks like in center field because I think he runs well enough to try it, but he’s only played left so far. Peete may not quite be ready for the 50-FV tier, but he’s close. He’s running really well, looks fine in center field, and his strikeouts have stabilized after they looked like they might be his undoing early in his career.
The Best of the New Names
Joey Dixon, RHP, Houston Astros
Sam Horn, RHP, Los Angeles Dodgers
Maddox Long, RHP, Detroit Tigers
Joe Ariola, LHP, Arizona Diamondbacks
Dixon missed multiple years recovering from Tommy John surgery and then most of 2026 dealing with a shoulder issue, and even when he pitched he wasn’t 100%. His velo is back and I’ve seen him parked at 94-97 while flashing bat-missing sliders and changeups. He’s smaller than most starters and his injury history points to the bullpen, but potentially as a multi-inning, platoon-neutral weapon. He’s getting added to The Board with a 40+ FV, the grade of a good bullpen’s third- or fourth-best guy. Sam Horn was a college quarterback at Missouri who missed time because of an elbow surgery and a fractured tibia. He rehabbed throughout 2026 and was active during Bridge League/Instructs, but I didn’t see him then because on the one day I knew he’d be pitching, Jackson Flora was making his uniformed debut for the Giants. In the AFL, Horn has been 93-96 with a plus slider and changeup. It’s a great starting point for someone who hasn’t pitched consistently since high school.
Long and Ariola look like standard middle relievers who could be ready fast. Long was at three different colleges across five seasons, then Indy ball. He’s 6-foot-5, 290 pounds, has a really loose delivery, a heavy low-90s sinker, and a plus slider that he commands with uncommon consistency. Ariola has a riding 93-94 mph fastball and hammer curveball, pretty standard lefty fare in the Caleb Thielbar mold.
Eric Longenhagen is from Catasauqua, PA and currently lives in Tempe, AZ. He spent four years working for the Phillies Triple-A affiliate, two with Baseball Info Solutions and two contributing to prospect coverage at ESPN.com. Previous work can also be found at Sports On Earth, CrashburnAlley and Prospect Insider.


Curious if you have any thoughts on Aidan Miller? Surprised he wasn’t mentioned!
Didn’t Eric talk about him last week?
Per Friday’s chat…
10:17 AM
How has Aidan Miller looked?
Eric Longenhagen 10:17 AM
Healthy, mobile, fast. Ends up playing next to Walcott a bunch, so also looks more human.
Also worth mentioning Miller’s relative lack of playing time. He has around 25 ABs with other guys approaching 50. When you attend these games, it’s really easy to miss guys who aren’t playing a lot since you’re having to choose what team to see when, and driving between East and West Valley is really painful on weekdays (it actually sucks all the time, roads are lawless).
I’m glad to hear that Walcott still looks good. He more or less picked up where he left off when he got back from injury so it’s exciting to see that his scouting report is still intact. The bat will likely play anywhere, and I think most people had already resigned themselves to him moving to third base, so the idea that he might be able to get by on positioning at short is exciting. Feels a bit like he be in the Kris Bryant / Troy Glaus range as a player at third base, which would be super exciting. I’m definitely on board with him as a Top 5 prospect, potentially a 65. I’d take him over De Vries, Willits, and Josuar De Gonzales, all of whom are excellent prospects in their own right.
For Kilby I think the question is whether he can stick at second or third base or if he has to move to the outfield. If he has to move to the outfield then I think there’s a lot of risk there, but he will probably hit enough that if he’s an average defender at second or third base he could sneak into some all-star games based on his hitting.
He hasn’t just picked up where he left off; he’s made swing improvements that significantly improve his outlook. Walcott’s EVs were already elite in 2025 but too much of that hard contact was going straight into the dirt. During the time off, it looks like he adjusted his bat position to be more vertical as well as being slightly more open in his front foot placement in order to increase his launch angle. He still chases too much and he hits more infield flies than any other prospect in recent memory, but getting more of his hard contact into the air makes him dramatically more dangerous at the plate.
I realize Kilby is just turning 20 and may end up in the OF but as a Yankee fan a hitter who walks more than strikes out would be welcomed. Not to mention he seems to have excellent hitting skills. He might arrive just as Aaron Judge & Cody Bellinger are no longer Yankee outfielders.
I watched a lot of Kilby playing shortstop and he looked very solid and comfortable on routine plays playing alongside Crisantes at 2B. There are so many strikeouts and popouts at the AFL, I saw few middle IFs getting a lot of chances and never saw Kilby have to make a tough play. Davalan also made the routine plays, but I never saw him get a tough play.
I still think Susana needs another pitch to get lefties out to get to true elite reliever status
Plenty of precedent for elite relievers with only a fastball/breaking ball.
If both pitches are elite. The problem with Susana is that his four seam velocity is elite but the shape and lack of command make it play down.
Yeah, it may not be an elite fastball, but sitting 100, you’d expect it to be north of average at least. And you don’t necessarily need two elite pitches to be an elite relief pitcher if you have one pitch that’s amazing enough. Bryan Abreu comes to mind.
I’m waiting for someone to tell Susana that it’s ok to throw a sinker. Imagine Abner Uribe with an even better breaker!
Attending these games is fantastic. The steady march of mediocre talent (relative to the league) can kind of lull you into passive watching, and then a guy like Long comes in the game with no info available than than he was a recent Indy signee, and he shows something that makes you think this could be a guy. Long played at Ouchita Baptist, Harding Univ. and Arkansas Rich Mountain – fairly off the radar. As a Tiger fan, seeing a relative unknown Tiger pop-out in this crowd was damn fun. If you haven’t gone to the AFL, highly recommended. You can easily sit behind home plate or wherever you want.
Excellent analysis. Top notch work.
Surprised that Welbyn Francisca didn’t merit a mention. He’s 1st in batting average, 3rd in OBP, 3rd in SLG%. Has 7BB vs 7Ks. On top of that he’s only 20 years old, one of the youngest players in the AFL.
Not Eric, but Francisca was just unconscious the whole time I was there getting constant hits. That’s fun to watch, but how instructive can it be when nearly any hitter can run really hot? He wasn’t flashing unexpected power while doing it. I thought he still looked more like a second basemen and his hitting did nothing to invalidate a bounce back year. He was fun to watch.
Thanks, I appreciate the input. Of course, I know this is all built on small sample sizes and you have to be careful to read too much into it. But Francisca is a former top 100 prospect (IIRC) who’s still only years old. Just seems odd not to mention him at all.
Feels like Wyatt Sanford is making loud contact, including a 454 foot home run, and reinforcing that up-arrow in power may be real for a middle infielder. Surprised he didn’t get a mention
Thanks for the update. You mentioned Susana has a plus plus curve. Previously, you and others have called his plus plus breaking ball a slider. Has the shape changed? Did you find out more about the grip?Brendan’s last chat said he throws his breaking ball at 2 distinct velocities. Are you seeing something different since he came back from injury?
Had expected to see Tekoah Roby get a mention after his three appearances showed some optimism with the control. 13 K/1 BB in 9 IP after all the missed time at least gives some room for hope he will get back to his previous 50 FV levels.
He hasn’t pitched in a bit, so perhaps Eric just didn’t get a chance to see him?
Glad to see Southisene excelling. So far I’m pretty excited about him and Mackenzie.
What does the “Christmas Ornament” indicate under trending on The Board?
For which players? I don’t see anything that looks like that. Could a weird browser thing?
Owen Carey for one, Chase Harlan is the next one. I am in the AFL tab and using Chrome.
Also using Chrome, in the AFL tab for me these guys have an icon of a dart in a bullseye. I’d guess this indicates the current grade aligns with recent evaluation, but no idea why this shows up as a Christmas ornament for you
Probably the same icon, just the dart is outside the bullseye, makes it look a bit like a Christmas Ornament Bulb