Contract Crowdsourcing 2024-25: Ballot 1 of 10

Free agency begins five days after the end of the World Series. As in other recent seasons, FanGraphs is once again facilitating a contract crowdsourcing project, with the idea being to harness the wisdom of the crowd to better understand and project the 2024-25 free agent market.
In recent years, we’ve added a few features to these ballots based on reader feedback. You now have the option to indicate that a player will only receive a minor league contract, or won’t receive one at all. If there is a player option, team option, or opt out in a player’s contract, you’ll be able to indicate whether you think he will remain with his current team or become a free agent. Numbers are prorated to full season where noted. The projected WAR figures are from the first cut of the 2025 Steamer600 projections.
Below are ballots for 10 of this year’s free agents — in this case, a group of position players, including the winter’s top free agent.
Meg is the editor-in-chief of FanGraphs and the co-host of Effectively Wild. Prior to joining FanGraphs, her work appeared at Baseball Prospectus, Lookout Landing, and Just A Bit Outside. You can follow her on Bluesky @megrowler.fangraphs.com.


I’m not sure my ballots are submitting, hitting submit doesn’t seem to change anything. (Chrome on Windows if that matters.)
I’m probably way off this year, but looking at these, I wanted to give Soto 16 years (yes, that’s absurd, but the team will want to defer money and a longer contract is one way to do that).
On the opposite side, I had three of these players accepting qualifying offers, which strikes me as very unlikely to happen, but just looking at the numbers felt right for each of the players in question.
It should be working now – sorry, there was a backend glitch.
This time they submitted, thanks.
Soto isn’t in Ohtani territory in as much as he’s not so talented and valuable a player that he is constrained by what teams are willing to pay a single player, irrespective of what they’re actually worth.
Still, I’d be shocked if he doesn’t beat Ohtani’s NPV (he’s unlikely to beat the sticker price).
Like Ohtani, Soto is one of the very best players; unlike him, he’s also among the youngest free agents in history. He’s at least a head, if not head and shoulders, above similarly-aged Bryce Harper when he got 13/$330m, so I’m going with the same deal but 66.66% more money ($550m). That leaves the AAV at $42m which is around the upper limit right now.
I went with 14 years, $40M, for a total of $560M. This is what I think the largest possible contract for the Yankees is. I think it is possible he doesn’t get that offer from the Yankees, but in that case I think he’ll get that or a similar offer from the Mets or some other team looking to make a splash (Phillies, Blue Jays, maybe even the Nationals).
I think it is also possible that he gets a bigger offer from the Mets or some other team–say, maybe 12 years at $50M. But I am less certain about that.
The Yanks can’t give Soto more than Judge’s $40m/per, can they?
I don’t know if it’s that or if it’s because they want to spread out the money so their tax hit is less, but I seriously doubt they go higher than that. There’s a reason why teams haven’t gone higher than that on a super long deal so far, with the one exception being Ohtani and his contract is structured strangely.
Why not? Judge knows how this works. I doubt he’s going to complain about his team retaining another great player.
Why not?
Don’t forget San Francisco.
They can afford $40M a year easy and Soto as a lefty should enjoy the short rf porch.
Sooner or later *somebody* has to take their money.
I think Soto wants to live on the east coast. And he will have plenty of options on the east coast alone around that level of compensation.
I expect the Giants to retain Snell, and go hard after some subset of Adames / Alonso / Kim.
Maybe but Boras will at a minimum use them to jack up other bids. And remember, players don’t sign with Boras if they don’t want max money.
$550M strikes me as the ante.
I went 15/$35M for $525M total.
I was in the same ballpark – shorter deal but higher AAV – I went 12/42 for $504M total
Years is all amortization and the league thinks 41 is a valid terminal age, so I don’t see why Soto wouldn’t go 15 years. I also think he might start at 37m and have it increase over time. Finally, 44M is too much for next year, but in 5 years seems like it could be right. So, $44M AAV. But the $50M or whatever in his last year will have an NPV of $35M @2.5% so there’s a substantial time benefit to the team. I doubt he gets the biggest offer from Yankees.
I think the reason he doesn’t go to 15 years (or 16, which would take him to his age 41 season) is because he doesn’t have to and it’s even less of a value to teams (outside of just deferred comp) than with older free agents because there’s even more uncertainty.
There’s not a lot of evidence of this, but for the life of me I can’t understand why a player would want a deal that goes past 37/38 aside from just money. They very frequently end up with a messy PR situation and a shell of a player gutting out horrible seasons on a crappy team. Or getting benched and just sitting and watching. It’s painful to watch and I wouldn’t go through that if I could get my cool half billy and potentially just ride into the sunset when I’m not good anymore.
I went with 12 a 42 for a total of 504. Someone in another thread made a good argument that SF has money that they’ve been trying to spend and will almost certain drive his numbers beyond reason, perhaps in the 600 range.
I think the Mets will certainly offer more than that, and I think that Soto would rather be on the east coast.
What makes you think that?
it doesn’t matter. he’s not going to leave the Bronx now.
That was exactly my guess too! We can be equally wrong together 😀
I usually guess too low, but I never learn. 🙂
It’s a little hard to shift your thinking from “what would I do?” or “what do I think he’s worth?” to “What will one sucker be willing to pay?”
Exactly.
One thing that makes me think I might still be right is that 12/504 is still a record-breaking contract. And it’s not like he’d be topping Manny Machado, Bryce Harper, or some other run-of-the-mill future Hall-of-Famer. He’d be topping Ohtani, a player who’s pretty widely seen as a once-in-a-generation talent with insane marketing value.
I went 14 years, $560M
Adames seems like he’s somewhere in the Javier Baez to Dansby Swanson range. I picked something closer to Baez, but I wouldn’t be surprised at all if he winds up with a Swanson-type contract.
Before the Giants hired Buster Posey I thought Pete Alonso was going to struggle to break $100M on his deal. He looks like he’s already in decline. Now I think the Giants are going to either offer him more than that (I put down $120M) or spur the Mets to re-up with him at that level because, why not, Steve Cohen doesn’t care.
I think Bregman gets 5 years, $150M. I think Jim Crane is terrified of losing the offseason.
I think the Mets are going to give Pete Alonso an indefensibly large contract.
I don’t know. He looks like a DH now.
Is Martinez guaranteed to come back?
If everybody sees Alonso as a DH it’ll limit his market and he might prefer whatever the Mets offer.
I think it’s almost guaranteed that if Alonso doesn’t break $100M in total dollars he takes a pillow deal. And I think there are definitely teams that would be willing to give him $100M, I’m thinking the Mets, Giants, and Mariners. I don’t see $160M on the table at this point from the Mets.
He definitely won’t need to take a pillow deal.
I don’t know how that affects my prediction. If anything, it seems to bolster it.
What?! He always looked like a DH.
I thought they kind of went with their best offer and he turned it down. He’s not really the face of the team anymore, is he? So losing him wouldn’t be the end of the world. And Stearns seems like he’d be happy to let him go.
Even though Lindor has built a tremendous fan base, and very rightly so, Alonso is still the home grown hero and is of equal stature in the hearts, eyes and minds of Met fans. If the numbers that I see being tossed around here are even close to reality then Cohen shouldn’t even have to blink to sign him to a lifetime contract
Don’t discount the “he’s our Aaron Judge” effect. Homegrown slugger, the inherent provinciality of New Yorkers — we brought him up, he’s our guy — and his general affability will mean the price goes up.
I think they’re willing to overpay slightly on a short term deal; I put him getting 5 years at $25 million per. There is no world where the Mets give him 8 years at the same amount or something like that… but I wouldn’t put it past, like, the White Sox.
Maybe if Stewart buys them fast.
Otherwise, if they are really looking to sell, they’ll sit on their hands.
It’s all about the yrs for Pete. I don’t see him getting more than 5 years. But there will definitely be teams in on him so it’s no lock he returns to Queens. Cards, Stros, M’s, Cubs are all likely in on him with the Mets. I think it will get up to 5/140.
Both Swanson and Story were 29-year-old SS with good gloves. Swanson was coming off a peak year, Story a down year with some injury questions. Swanson got 7/177 and Story 6/140. I guess Adames is closer to Swanson and gets about that.
Adames had an uncharacteristically bad year on defense, and it had to do with errors rather than range. He hit well–nearly had a 5 win year! I don’t know what he gets but it seems implausible it’s less than 7 years, $140M, and he comps nicely to Swanson.
Yeah, that’s kind of what I did..6 years, $168M was my guess. Could see it being 7 years, but, a lower AAV like 7 years, $185M or something like that.
Story and Baez signed virtually identical contracts 3 years ago and the funny thing is that Story, even though he has hardly on the field at all, has been of more value than Baez who has been about as poor a performer as it is possible to be and still be rostered. There is still hope that Story can valuable but it is difficult to see Baez bouncing back. Adames will get more than the 6/140 that these men received.
I haven’t followed Bregman but is his market that weak? Does 5/150 represent an overpay? He puts up numbers every year and I assumed he’d get something over $200 million from someone who wants to ignore his BB dropoff this year. What gives?
He’s 31 in March and his power is more 20 Hr’s than 30.
He should beat Chapman’s extension but not by much.
I was going to say he’s a product of Minutemaid, but I looked at the numbers and he’s nearly identical at home vs. the road. He’ll get paid.
I think Bregman will age like milk. I’ll give him props: he seems to get the very most out of his abilities, but he’s a tick or two of lower bat speed away from being a below average hitter. I think when his decline comes it will come hard. And he’s already 31. I do think he’ll still get a big, 9-figure contract, but I think it might be lower than expected (under $150m) and I think even at that he will end up being a crushing disappointment.
Not sure what reason there is to think that. Had a solid 2nd half. Has been very consistent. Is a great 3Bman. 5 years seems like solid value.
The delta’s gotten bigger since the death of the rocket ball.
I don’t think there are a lot of teams that have both the means and the motive for a third baseman. Maybe he gets to $200M because Crane is a meddler and they might circumvent Dana Brown entirely.
I basically gave Bregman the Chapman extension..Seems like they’re similar players.
Whether that comes from Houston or Detroit decides they’re sick of the hole at 3B (& his old Mgr is AJ Hinch) is a ???
Comerica seems like a death trap for him, along the lines of YS3.
Yeah, I think Comerica plays a little better offensively than its dimensions and reputation would suggest, but Bregman needs a true (homer friendly) hitters park more than just about anyone.
While its overall park factor is 98 while Houston is 100, for homers it is 86 while Houston is 107.
That’s what Bregman needs.
Maybe Cincinnatti?
Bringing in Francona suggests they want to build around what they have and while he’s used to working with a… low budget team, he could really use an added bat or three.
They do seem to like to sign 3B..
How much better is Bregman than Vierling? $150M better?
Vierling is bad defensively at 3B & 3B only accounted for about 1/3 of his defensive innings last year.
His value is as a utility guy- 3 of the the Tigers 4 main OF(Greene, Meadows,Carpenter..& Wenceel Perez is a switch hitter) are left handed, so you sprinkle Vierling in there 2-3 days a week to give them a rest..esp vs LHP..then occasionally at 3B. Can also play 1B in a pinch
Guess what I’m saying is IF you think Bregman is the guy, Matt Vierling isn’t the reason you DON’T do it.
Maybe if you think Jace Jung is the guy or Bregman will not hit well at Comerica, those are solid reasons not to go after him.
I think Bellinger should opt in. This is a bad time to be hitting the market with the TV deals up in the air. But maybe he wants to keep playing CF to keep his value high.
I think Ha-Seong Kim doesn’t get the QO from the Padres. I think both he and teams would prefer to have a 1-2 year commitment given the circumstances. AAV probably is around $15M.
I think Gleyber Torres gets a one year deal in the $12M-$15M range from a non-Yankees team (assuming they keep Soto).
If the Braves don’t easily outbid 2/$30m for Kim, I will be extremely upset.
2 years, $30M with an opt out is what I was thinking. I am sure if any team wants to pay him $100M he would take that instead, but I think teams are going to be wary of his injury and he is going to (rightfully) expect a big payday if he can show he is healthy.
Of course, If a team wanted to offer him 3 years, $60M with an opt out after year one…he would take that instead.
I ended up saying Bellinger would stay another year. He didn’t exactly light the world on fire so he seems unlikely to get a massive deal as a FA after not getting one last year.
Ditto..Just seems like the best move for him.
I think some team is going to give Kim 5/80 or something in that range and in two years it’s going to be a steal.
I agree that if someone did give him 5 / $80M it would be a steal. I’m not sure a team will.
So do I..I think i had 4 years, $70M..I could also see a lower AAV, but, a player option after year 2.
I.E. Kim gets multi-year at lower AAV, but, if he proves he’s healthy, he can opt out & go for a bigger payday. Kind of a pillow deal on steroids.
Kind of like Bregman, I could see Detroit being interested.
How are we considering deferred dollars, if at all?
I’d be interested in an article on why Soto’s improved so much offensively this year. People skirt over it b/c he’s been seen as great the entire time but from 2021-23 he was a great hitter but much worse than this year (wrc+ 154 vs 180) and “only” a ~5 WAR player. He was a star but not a superstar.
His plate discipline has regressed a bit since its 2021 peak (10.9 oswing 2021 to 15.9 to 17.2 to 18.4 in 2024 w/ similar zswing) and his contact’s down a bit from 2020-23 (88.5 vs 86.1 zcontact), but he’s done so much more damage on contact.
He’s always crushed the ball but was awful at hitting it at a good launch angle (10th, 9th, and 5th percentile 2021-23). As such he didn’t even rank in top 10% in xwoba on contact any year over that span.
This year he’s top 1%, w/ LA sweet spot a solid 65%. He was also solid in that stat in 2019 and 2020, which was his other superstar season.
I’d imagine there’s been some change in his approach to provoke such a change, and perhaps a reversion to his approach in 2020. If it holds and MLB inflation trends continue w/ his skillset he could honestly make $500-600mil look like a bargain if he’s aging well in 5-7 years, sort of similarly to what Harper and Betts have done.
Maturity?
Better support (coaching, video, etc)?
Salary drive?
Hitting in front of Judge?
I’d go with maturity; he’s gained a better understanding of his ability. At 25/26 he is at a peak mix of health, talent, skill, and experience.
This is the key question. Is Soto at his peak or do his skills have a slightly later peak than other skills like speed. He definitely has the skill of staying healthy. He doesn’t get 600M if a team thinks he peaks before 30. More like 32 with gradual decline.
Can you imagine how hard this is being modeled?
Maybe selling out a bit in an unsustainable way in a contract year? Swinging more to boost his numbers but knowing that it’s something that the league will adjust to over time. Just a guess.
I am by no means a scout, but based on watching him this year, I’d say he’s done a really good job of amping up his swing early in the count, particularly hunting high cheese to smash. He’s been more contact-oriented in two strike situations.
His improved performance on batted balls is almost entirely due to improvement on fastballs, from mid-400’s xwOBA his whole career to .538 this year. His 2020 was due to flukishly good performance on breaking balls (.200 points of xwOBA over any other year).
I can’t really tell at a glance how he managed this. His swing % on FB’s has steadily risen since 2021 but not by much (38% vs 42%). His higher chase rate’s almost all due to FB’s (25% this year vs 11% 2021).
But these have both been steady and consistent changes since 2021, not a big jump from 2021-23 to 2024.
His in zone swing % is almost totally consistent throughout his career for every pitch type.
He pulled a lot more breaking and offspeed pitches but his performance on them didn’t change much as I said, it was FB’s which didn’t change in this respect.
I am really intrigued to see what Soto gets crowdsourced at.
I went 13 yrs 52m a year.