Crowdsourcing the Value of Trade Targets with Bad Contracts
As in other recent offseasons, FanGraphs once again facilitated this offseason a contract-crowdsourcing project for baseball’s free agents, the idea being to harness the wisdom of the crowds to the end of better understanding the 2014-15 offseason market. The result: a single post featuring the league’s top-55 free agents, ordered by projected size (in dollars) of contract.
The numbers produced by the crowd are imperfect — demonstrating, most notably, a streak of conservatism wherein the most talented free agents (Max Scherzer, Hanley Ramirez, etc.) are concerned. Even with certain biases present, however, the crowd’s estimates are useful for cultivating an understanding of the offseason market as a whole.
What follows is similar exercise as that offseason free-agent one — designed, however, not to estimate the values of the league’s free agents, but rather of those players who are both (a) candidates to be traded this offseason, but also (b) signed to contracts of disproportionate cost relative to the player’s likely benefit to a team in wins.
The purpose of this exercise: to estimate the actual market values (in dollars) of those same contracts for the years that remain on them. So, for example, Dodgers outfielder Matt Kemp is owed $107 million through 2019 — that is, over five years. The question of interest here — and certainly one of interest to those general managers who might consider trading for Kemp — is thus: Were you a GM, how much would you pay for five years of Matt Kemp? Something more than $0, presumably, but also probably something less than $107 million.
Below are 10 players with regard to whom that sort of question is a relevant one.
Mark Buehrle (Profile)
Some relevant information regarding Buehrle:
- Has averaged 202 IP and 2.7 WAR over last three seasons.
- Has averaged 2.7 WAR per 200 IP* over last three seasons.
- Recorded a 3.5 WAR in 202.0 IP in 2014.
- Is projected to record 1.3 WAR per 200 IP** in 2015.
- Is entering his age-36 season.
- Is owed $19M through 2015.
*That is, a roughly average number of innings for a starting pitcher.
**According to prorated Steamer projections available here.
Click here to estimate Mark Buehrle’s actual market value.
Carl Crawford (Profile)
Some relevant information regarding Crawford:
- Has averaged 321 PA and 1.9 WAR over last three seasons.
- Has averaged 3.5 WAR per 600 PA* over last three seasons.
- Recorded a 2.5 WAR in 370 PA in 2014.
- Is projected to record 2.3 WAR per 600 PA** in 2015.
- Is entering his age-33 season.
- Is owed $62.3M through 2017.
*That is, a roughly average number of plate appearances for a starting player.
**According to prorated Steamer projections available here.
Click here to estimate Carl Crawford’s actual market value.
John Danks (Profile)
Some relevant information regarding Danks:
- Has averaged 128 IP and 0.5 WAR over last three seasons.
- Has averaged 0.7 WAR per 200 IP* over last three seasons.
- Recorded a 0.8 WAR in 193.2 IP in 2014.
- Is projected to record 0.4 WAR per 200 IP** in 2015.
- Is entering his age-30 season.
- Is owed $28.5M through 2016.
*That is, a roughly average number of innings for a starting pitcher.
**According to prorated Steamer projections available here.
Click here to estimate John Danks’ actual market value.
Andre Ethier (Profile)
Some relevant information regarding Ethier:
- Has averaged 517 PA and 2.2 WAR over last three seasons.
- Has averaged 2.5 WAR per 600 PA* over last three seasons.
- Recorded a 0.7 WAR in 380 PA in 2014.
- Is projected to record 2.2 WAR per 600 PA** in 2015.
- Is entering his age-33 season.
- Is owed $53.5M through 2017 and then either $17.5M for 2018 or a $2.5M buyout.
*That is, a roughly average number of plate appearances for a starting player.
**According to prorated Steamer projections available here.
Click here to estimate Andre Ethier’s actual market value.
Aaron Hill (Profile)
Some relevant information regarding Hill:
- Has averaged 524 PA and 2.2 WAR over last three seasons.
- Has averaged 2.6 WAR per 600 PA* over last three seasons.
- Recorded a -0.7 WAR in 541 PA in 2014.
- Is projected to record 1.1 WAR per 600 PA** in 2015.
- Is entering his age-33 season.
- Is owed $24.0M through 2016.
*That is, a roughly average number of plate appearances for a starting player.
**According to prorated Steamer projections available here.
Click here to estimate Aaron Hill’s actual market value.
Ryan Howard (Profile)
Some relevant information regarding Howard:
- Has averaged 419 PA and -0.3 WAR over last three seasons.
- Has averaged -0.5 WAR per 600 PA* over last three seasons.
- Recorded a -0.3 WAR in 648 PA in 2014.
- Is projected to record -0.9 WAR per 600 PA** in 2015.
- Is entering his age-35 season.
- Is owed $50.0M through 2016 and then either $23.0M for 2017 or a $10.0M buyout.
*That is, a roughly average number of plate appearances for a starting player.
**According to prorated Steamer projections available here.
Click here to estimate Ryan Howard’s actual market value.
Edwin Jackson (Profile)
Some relevant information regarding Jackson:
- Has averaged 168 IP and 1.6 WAR over last three seasons.
- Has averaged 1.9 WAR per 200 IP* over last three seasons.
- Recorded a 0.5 WAR in 140.2 IP in 2014.
- Is projected to record 0.6 WAR per 200 IP** in 2015.
- Is entering his age-31 season.
- Is owed $22M through 2016.
*That is, a roughly average number of innings for a starting pitcher.
**According to prorated Steamer projections available here.
Click here to estimate Edwin Jackson’s actual market value.
Matt Kemp (Profile)
Some relevant information regarding Kemp:
- Has averaged 446 PA and 1.5 WAR over last three seasons.
- Has averaged 2.1 WAR per 600 PA* over last three seasons.
- Recorded a 1.8 WAR in 599 PA in 2014.
- Is projected to record 2.4 WAR per 600 PA** in 2015.
- Is entering his age-30 season.
- Is owed $107.0M through 2019.
*That is, a roughly average number of plate appearances for a starting player.
**According to prorated Steamer projections available here.
Click here to estimate Matt Kemp’s actual market value.
Cliff Lee (Profile)
Some relevant information regarding Lee:
- Has averaged 171 IP and 3.9 WAR over last three seasons.
- Has averaged 4.5 WAR per 200 IP* over last three seasons.
- Recorded a 1.7 WAR in 81.1 IP in 2014.
- Is projected to record 2.8 WAR per 200 IP** in 2015.
- Is entering his age-36 season.
- Is owed $25.0M through 2015 and then either $27.5M for 2016 or a $12.5M buyout.
*That is, a roughly average number of innings for a starting pitcher.
**According to prorated Steamer projections available here.
Click here to estimate Cliff Lee’s actual market value.
B.J. Upton (Profile)
Some relevant information regarding Upton:
- Has averaged 554 PA and 1.0 WAR over last three seasons.
- Has averaged 1.0 WAR per 600 PA* over last three seasons.
- Recorded a 0.4 WAR in 582 PA in 2014.
- Is projected to record 0.6 WAR per 600 PA** in 2015.
- Is entering his age-30 season.
- Is owed $46.4M through 2017.
*That is, a roughly average number of plate appearances for a starting player.
**According to prorated Steamer projections available here.
Carson Cistulli has published a book of aphorisms called Spirited Ejaculations of a New Enthusiast.


Buehrle’s contract isn’t all that bad. If he was a free agent seeking a one year deal he could probably get 16 million, possibly more (comparison: Kuroda).
Yeah, I remember looking at that and seriously considering simply clicking $19 million. His projection looks pessimistic to me, he’s an older pitcher so he certainly could fall apart, but he hasn’t yet and its a short contract…
A bunch of the other guys I decided if I were a GM I might take a flyer at a few million based on the upside if they’re healthy. But if Buehrle pitches as well next year as he did this year he’s still a bargain.
There’s also the fact that there’s probably a lot of teams who would be leery of giving a multiyear deal to a pitcher, and would gladly overpay a couple million for a one-year deal. Not $19M, but maybe $15M
Yeah, not even sure why Buehrle is even on this list. Stats have never particularly liked him, and the ceiling isn’t super high. Then again, he’s about the most durable pitcher in the game, a LHP, and on a one-year deal essentially. For a team looking to shore up their rotation for a playoff run, he’d be a great candidate on performance, and maybe only $4-5M high. Very, very tradable with the right partner. I could see him going to Anaheim right now, even for salary relief primarily to the Jays.
Some of these other guys are essentially unmoveable in any sane world. The contracts aren’t just bad, they are epics of organizational misery. Howard, Ethier, B. J Upton might seriously get cut in Spring Training if you had them in camp on a minor league deal. Taking on a single dollar of their obligation, let alone trading anything of value for that is head-exploding kind of crazy. If Danks can pitch effectively, he’s tradeable. Since likely he can’t, why would you trade for him. It would take half a season of effective work to create a market for him. They others?: It all depends . . . .
Funny. I selected 16 mil and right after I submitted I felt I should have selected 19. One year, crazy high floor, known quantity. If I was a GM at the right place on the win curve with the need, I would pay 19 mil f one-year of Buerhle. I think with the every team having 5 or 6 guys throw high 90’s – 100+ guys like Buerhle don’t get near the respect they deserve. He’s not a sexy signing, but he is a safe one on that hypothetical one-year. None of the others on this list are anything close to safe..
What? No A-Rod?
He is probably the least tradeable player in baseball, so he doesn’t really qualify.
Except he should be here if this is a list of bad contracts. And I could see a couple of teams taking a flyer on him if their obligation got down to under $30M. For a guy who should be out of the game, he likely does have an actual market. Manny Ramirez got chance and chance again long after it was stone obvious exactly who and what he was, and A-Rod has outproduced Manny in every way.
I’d love to see the Yankees take Alex to court on violating his contract terms. They likely won’t because a) they would most likely lose, while b) they certainly don’t want the negative publicity on this to continue. Then again, the Yankees extended him knowing what he was up to (c’mon, nobody is stupid enough not to know), so they totally deserve having had this bouncing betty go off at gonad level exactly like it has. In the end, I think the Yankees cut him because the only outcome worse is ever having A-Rod walk on the field in pinstripes again.
He may have the least trade value, but that’s not the question here. All of these players have negative trade value. We’re ignoring their current contracts and handing out new hypothetical contracts.
In that sense, I’d rather have Alex Rodriguez than Ryan Howard. I don’t think Ryan Howard is worth a roster spot.
Sure, but these players have at least been talked about as possible trade pieces.
Fair enough. A-Rod’s obviously not getting traded.
But Howard is the only guy on the list that I put 0/0 for.
Yeah. All depends on team need. I tried to be realistic and think like a GM that had some kind of hole at 1B and could use a lefty bat that could hot righties reasonably well. Figured his name value should easily lead to a mil a year in merchandise/ticket sales. And thought if used properly his platoon bat could produce close to 1 WAR. Knocked a half win off for clogging up a roster spot on a platoon 1B with no hope for defensive or base running contributions. I would give him 1/3 or 2/5. Maybe that’s why I’m not a GM 🙂
Buehrle: 1/12
Crawford 3/33
Danks: 2/6
Ethier: 3/18 – 4/20
Howard: 2/2 – 3/2
Jackson: 2/10
Kemp: 5/85
Lee: 1/20 – 2/36
Upton: 3/6
eh.
200 IP is not an average number of innings for a starting pitcher. The last three years, there have been 34, 36 and 31 pitchers logging 200 IP in each of those years. Over the last three years there are only 17 pitchers with 600 IP.
The 88 qualified starters in 2014 averaged 194.43 innings.
Yes, but there’s a natural bias there – looking only at qualified pitchers is saying “the average number of innings pitched by guys who pitched more than 162 innings.”
Every team currently uses a 5-man rotation, so there are theoretically 150 available starting pitcher slots. The fact that only 88 qualified means that 62 SP “slots” didn’t even pitch enough to qualify, and were they included, they would pull that average down significantly. So Mike is correct that 200 IP is not at all an average number of innings for a starting pitcher.
That’s irrelevant from a projection standpoint
I assumed we all understand that WAR per 200 IP is just turning WAR into a normalized rate stat. It’s worth noting, though, that the statement of 200 IP being average was attached the summary of the past three years’ performance, not the projection.
However, I wouldn’t entirely agree that it’s irrelevant anyhow. Buehrle has been one of the most reliable pitchers in terms of actually providing 200 IP, which alters his projected actual value (rather than rate of value) relative to less durable starters.
Starting pitchers averaged 5.9 IP/game in the AL and 6.0 in the NL last year, one fifth of a full season would give a pitcher 32.4 starts, coming out to 191-194 IP. With those number always including starts by traditional non-starters evening it up at 200 makes a simple visual and mathematical number. (all numbers courtesy baseball reference.)
This really isn’t that complicated, folks. When you sign a starting pitcher, you hope he’ll give you 200 innings. And 200 innings is probably the average for a pitcher who stays in the rotation for a full season.
Just like 600 PA’s is not “average” for a position player. It’s just a baseline because we’re used to judging full-season stat lines on a ~200 IP / 600 PA basis.
Lee isn’t a bad contract… he’s an injury risk.
Those two things aren’t mutually exclusive.
Lee will end up being a comparatively good contract in the end. He gave max value for the majority of his contract length. And if he is 80% as good as he was in 2013, he’ll still be worth his current price.
Buehrle: 1/13
Crawford: 3/39
Danks: 2/10
Ethier: 3/20 or 4/25
Hill: 2/14
Howard: 2/4 or 3/5
Jackson: 2/10
Kemp: 5/75
Lee: 1/20 or 2/33
Upton: 3/10
Let’s be honest. How many of you selected 0/0 for Ryan Howard?
Eh, I did $1/$2 figuring that he might be able to be a pinch hitter or maybe a change of scenery would lead to something, and at that price you could drop him in Spring Training if he still looks lost.
it was quite satisfying
I put 1 / 0 just to signify that I would rather have him for one year instead of two.
I did, even though he might be above replacement level if used appropriately.
I just don’t think the ~0.5 WAR he could produce is even worth a roster spot. Can’t stick him anywhere but 1B/DH, can’t let him see lefties, can’t use him as a defensive replacement, can’t use him as a pinch runner.
I don’t understand Jason Giambi’s employment over the last 6 years either.
No Jose Reyes on here?
Stayed healthy, made 655 PAs and accumulated 3.0 WAR this year, projects for 3.4 next year. Tulo’s well tradable, and Reyes should be too.
you got that backwards. He had a 3.3 WAR this year and projects for 3.0 next year.
Besides, the question isnt “is he tradeable” its what is his actual worth if he were signing whats left of his current contract today. And I have a hard time saying Reyes is currently worth a 3 year $66 million contract.
Andre Ethier is projected to be worth 2.2 WAR in 600 PAs, not 0.3 war. On his player page it even says 0.6, but that’s only for 152 PAs.
http://www.fangraphs.com/projections.aspx?pos=cf&stats=bat&type=steamer600&team=22&players=0
Not sure what happened there. Thanks for the note, though. Duly edited.
One important question about this type of project:
This question can be approached two ways. One is to assess a player’s per year value to find that player’s AAV, and then multiply that by the number of years. So maybe I expect Crawford to be worth about 14 million per year over the next three years, so I say he’s with 42 million in that time.
The other way to do it is to ask how much I would pay to have that player if that player could only take a contract of the length of their remaining contract. Let’s say Miguel Cabrera had one year left on his contract. I could assess his value to be equal to 1 times his current true AAV worth. However, what if Cabrera was a free agent, and he only wanted a 1-year deal. His value for that year would definitely be much higher.
The second way is really what we should be doing. Miguel Cabrera on a 9-year $28M AAV contract has little to now surplus value. Miguel Cabrera on a 1-year $28M contract has a ton of value. In this way, all our estimates are likely to be very low – not just because the crowd tends to underestimate free-agent value, but because we’re likely further underestimating the value of having quality players on short contracts.
Many of these players are not quality players. Lee, Hill, Crawford, Buehrle, Kemp and perhaps Ethier are quality players, but four to five of them are not at this stage. Howard, Upton, Jackson and Danks are basically deadweight with minimal chance for varying degrees of bouncebacks.
What about Ross and Hill to ATL for BJ, Mike Minor, and Aaron Northcraft?