FG on Fox: A Semi-Defense of the Yordano Ventura Decision

The Kansas City Royals just won the American League Wild Card, and advanced to the postseason for the first time since 1985. Congratulations are in order, and yet, had Billy Butler’s baserunning blunder not indirectly led to Geovany Soto’s thumb injury — and the insertion of throwing-impaired catcher Derek Norris — we would probably be talking about a very different game this morning. That’s what kind of game that was; the Royals may very well have won because their lead-footed designated hitter screwed up an attempted stolen base, allowing their track stars to run wild later on in the game. These are the kinds of events that make prognosticating a baseball game feel like a futile endeavor.

But for about an hour or so, the story of this game felt like it was going to be pretty easy to write. The Royals carried a lead into the sixth inning. The Royals had the best bullpen in baseball this year, led by the dominant trio of Kelvin Herrera, Wade Davis, and Greg Holland. And each of those three sat and watched as James Shields put the tying and go-ahead runs on base, and then continued to watch as Yordano Ventura entered the game and promptly gave up a three-run home run to Brandon Moss. Yordano Ventura, a rookie starter who threw 73 pitches two days ago. A right-handed rookie pitcher, working on very short rest, in a situation in which he was not used to being used. This didn’t even require second guessing, as there was plenty of first guessing going on even before Moss crushed the ball over the center field fence.

I’m not here to say that going to Ventura was definitely the right call, or that it was not a strange decision in light of the other available options. Earlier in the day, I suggested that Yost not rely too heavily on Shields pitching deep into the game, and that he should be willing to ask his trio of elite relievers to get the final 12 outs. Had Yost called me at the start of the sixth inning, I’m pretty sure that I would not have considered Ventura as my first option, especially once Shields put two men on base and their collection of left-handers came around to bat.

But was it really indefensible? Was the move so obviously bad that the ensuing result should have been foreseeable? I’m not so sure. Let’s deal with the primary criticisms.

Read the rest on Just a Bit Outside.





Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.

42 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
King Buzzo's Fro
12 years ago

Did Minnesota ever give a defense for their Jesse Ventura decision?

The PCL
12 years ago

As far as we’re concerned, it never happened.

Jimmer
12 years ago

‘The Kansas City Royals just won the American League Wild Card, and advanced to the postseason for the first time since 1985.’

Wasn’t the game between Oakland and KC a postseason game? It wasn’t a game 163 or anything, it was a playoff game. Every outlet I saw said it was a postseason game. The conversations during the game said it was a postseason game, they talked about how Dunn reached the postseason for the first time yet didn’t get to play…

ClayDV
12 years ago
Reply to  Jimmer

It’s a bit of a stretch to call a 1-game series the postseason, despite how MLB and most media hype it up.

Binky
12 years ago
Reply to  ClayDV

Who cares if it’s only one game? Plenty of sports only have one game series’ in the playoffs.

Ruki Motomiya
12 years ago
Reply to  ClayDV

Well considering they said in the Live Blog they considered it the postseason…

tomemos
12 years ago
Reply to  ClayDV

It’s either the season or it’s the postseason, right? Does it count in the final season standings? No. So it’s the postseason.

ZenMadman
12 years ago
Reply to  ClayDV

It’s a stretch to call a 1-game series a series. Because it’s not. It’s a game. But it’s a game that takes place after the season. Ergo, ipso facto, columbo oreo, postseason.

Jimmer
12 years ago

‘Congratulations are in order, and yet, had Billy Butler’s baserunning blunder not indirectly led to Geovany Soto’s thumb injury — and the insertion of throwing-impaired catcher Derek Norris — we would PROBABLY be talking about a very different game this morning.’

From his chat this afternoon…
Q: So if Soto doesn’t get hurt, the A’s win that game?
Dave: Not necessarily. Maybe Soto doesn’t get the RBI single that Norris got. Maybe they still run anyway. Maybe they don’t run and someone hits a HR instead of laying down a bunt. Who knows?

How does that turn into PROBABLY?

Michael
12 years ago
Reply to  Jimmer

Because the game would’ve probably been played differently, with different outcomes and consequences? He didn’t say the Athletics would PROBABLY win, just that the game and decisions that took place, would have been different.

Having Soto in the game the entire time, would’ve had a big ripple effect, and lots of things probably would’ve been done differently.

Jimmer
12 years ago
Reply to  Michael

So even when he continued with, ‘the Royals may very well have won because their lead-footed designated hitter screwed up an attempted stolen base, allowing their track stars to run wild later on in the game.’

you still think that’s not saying he probably thinks the Royals won because of that?

jon
12 years ago
Reply to  Jimmer

You’re splitting semantic hairs here

ZenMadman
12 years ago
Reply to  Jimmer

PROBABLY very different game, but not necessarily one that the A’s win. It seems pretty clear to me. Change one event and everything after it is different.

ralph
12 years ago

Dave says he wants to deal with the primary criticisms of putting Ventura in, then lists just two criticisms:

Yordano Ventura is a rookie, and asking him to pitch in that situation at his age is unfair.

and

Ventura started all year, so he wasn’t used to pitching in relief, especially with men on base.

I really feel like he should have addressed a third criticism: He brought in a RHP to face Moss.

I guess there was a chance Yost didn’t want to get Yosted by Gomes again. (For those who don’t remember, Yost brought in a LHP earlier this season, only to have Gomes pinch-hit and hit a HR.)

Does Dave think that bringing in a RHP was semi-defensible because it avoided a possible LHP vs Gomes matchup? Is Dave just not considering platoon advantages to be very important in this situation? Something else that caused him to imply that letting a RHP face Moss was not a primary criticism?

I guess my thesis is that if there is a clearly better realistic alternative to face Moss (and Herrera, Duffy, and Finnegan all seemed realistic and clearly better to me), it is indeed a bad decision to throw Ventura out there. (With the root bad decision being that Ventura was the only guy warming.)

Jimmer
12 years ago
Reply to  ralph

Brandon Moss hit lefties better this year.

Jimmer
12 years ago
Reply to  ralph

for his career, BA against righties and lefties is the same.

ralph
12 years ago
Reply to  Jimmer

Brandon Moss career wRC+ vs LHP: 101

Brandon Moss career wRC+ vs RHP: 118

You need a lot of evidence to say platoon splits don’t apply to a hitter. And those career splits are right in line with normal platoon expectations.

GH
12 years ago
Reply to  ralph

Ventura has been much better against lefties than righties this year. Herrera’s platoon splits are not favorable to facing left-handed bats. Moss can’t hit a high fastball, and I am sure the game plan was for Ventura to throw Moss high fastballs. He simply missed his spots. Meanwhile, Herrera relies almost exclusively on a two-seam sinking fastball, which plays right into Moss’s strength.

Fred
12 years ago

There’s also the point that he had thrown 73 pitches in a game two days earlier.

Matt
12 years ago
Reply to  Fred

This is the main problem I had with the decision. Why does it seem like barely anyone is mentioning this?

ralph
12 years ago
Reply to  Matt

I guess because it was his throw day?

Dave sort of dances around this in the piece, noting that many SPs have come into postseason games to relieve. I’m not going to check all those instances, but my basic recollection is that in pretty much all those instances, there was a pretty good case that the SP in relief really was the best option… which I don’t think anyone (except Yost… maybe) can say about Ventura.

Essentially, there was just so much uncertainty in how Ventura would perform, even without taking the 73 pitches into account, that I don’t understand why Yost thought Ventura was the best option to save the season.

Cantinflas after every meal
12 years ago
Reply to  Fred

Yeah, Dave C. mentions in passing then glosses right over the single most important fact: Ventura had just ONE day of rest since throwing 73 pitches.

In that game of July 13, Ventura pitched in relief on THREE days of rest. That’s an entirely different situation than one day off. Similarly, exactly none of the other starter-to-playoff-reliever conversions Dave cited include a starter pitching in relief after just one day of rest.

“It was his throw day.” That’s a tortured rationalization, if anyone uses that argument. Hell, if that made any sense at all, any, then we’d see MLB managers bringing in their one-day-of-rest starting pitchers from the bullpen on an almost nightly basis — instead of, you know, never. Managers, even the most daring headstrong managers, do not do this.

Yost showed smarts & brass balls in the 8th and 9th innings, letting his speedsters run wild despite trailing in the contest. He played to his team’s strength and profited by doing so.

You know what his other team strength is? A smoke-throwing Cerberus in the bullpen. If you’re gonna take Shields out after just 88 pitches, at least go to one of your known strengths.

If there’s no three-headed monster available in the KC bullpen (all three relief arms actually had more rest than Ventura did!) and if you have Randy Johnson ready to pitch in relief, then yeah, go for it. But such was not the case, not by a longshot.

Eastside Crank
12 years ago

This is a solid effort to defend two on no out in the 6th and your 3 top relievers rested and ready to go. Ventura was not exactly electric in his last outing giving up 8 hits and one walk in 4 innings. However, as you point out, why would the A’s be concerned about saving a reliever in the 8th to see if Lester could give one more quality inning? It was fun to see which manager could out old-school the other. Yost gets the Lasorda small ball award for most bunts in a post-season game. Melvin gets to go home knowing that he could not have squeezed another out out of Lester.

Royals/Chiefs/Kauffman/Sammy Hagar
12 years ago

I really don’t understand the Yost hating here, guys. Yostie is Professional Major League Manager. He had more balls last night than anyone else, and got The Win. Enough. Said.

Royals/Chiefs/Kauffman/Sammy Hagar
12 years ago

Above all the weird stats and stuff like that, the most important part of winning a ball game? Winning, duh.

Mark
12 years ago

None of those criticisms are the issue. The problem is Yost had a pitcher this season who was doing his best Mariano Rivera impression, posting a 3 WAR season with a sub 2 FIP. The game was on the line, and two left handed hitters were due up. One of whom already hit a 2 run homer this game.

The only defensible options are:

Bring in a LHRP, someone capable of having the platoon advantage against multiple LH batters.

OR

Bring in your 3 WAR RP who is NOT the closer and will not cause outrage if he’s brought in before the 9th (or 8th). They’ve got their cleanup hitter coming up with 2 guys on, and this is likely to be the biggest situation in the game.

Someone could argue it’s the 6th inning and why would they have Davis warming up? Well, you had someone warming up in case Shields falters, and if he did, then you have to bring in a reliever with the middle of the lineup coming up with men on base. If there’s a high leverage spot do you want to go to your second best arm here? Absolutely not. You warm up Davis, and best case scenario he throws 2 innings with nobody on base and bridges the gap to Holland who pitches one or two innings.

Worst case scenario? You’ve got Davis up in the bullpen, Shields allows a few base runners, and the middle of the lineup is up. But, being the smart manager you were, you anticipated this, and had YOUR BEST RELIEVER warming up in the pen.

That’s what it comes down to. Yes, Ventura is a good pitcher. Yes, it’s defensible he had him warming up in case Shields ran into a problem. It stops being defensible when you take into account who was coming up in the lineup, the fact that Moss is one of, if not Oakland’s best hitter, and that he’s going to have the platoon advantage.

When you throw in the fact Ventura threw 70+ pitches only a few days ago, the decision looks worse. But really if you anticipate there being a problem with Shields you have to game plan for who is coming up. Which means a LHRP for Moss/Reddick, or an elite reliever like Davis who will probably get you out of any jam for the next inning or two. And really, asking Holland to pitch the 8th and 9th of a do or die game when they’re not playing the next day is not that much to ask.

As far as I’m concerned, if Shields gets you to the 6th inning, the plan should have only been Davis for innings 6 & 7, and Holland for 8-9. Only change to that plan should come if you feel like throwing out a LOOGY and THEN going to Davis.

Any other plan is risking far too much, and showing a lack of understanding for how important this game is, how important that individual situation is, and a lack of foresight for who is coming to the plate if Shields allows even one base runner.

ralph
12 years ago
Reply to  Mark

As far as I’m concerned, if Shields gets you to the 6th inning, the plan should have only been Davis for innings 6 & 7, and Holland for 8-9. Only change to that plan should come if you feel like throwing out a LOOGY and THEN going to Davis.

Yeah, this is the thing that gets me. As you say, Rivera was a shining example for teams looking for an excuse to pitch their best relievers for 2 IP in a playoff game. It was never going to happen with Yost, but I completely I agree that Davis should have been warming to start the 6th with the idea that Davis and Holland could go 2 IP apiece.

geo
12 years ago

What gets me is how everybody is all over Yost, the manager of the WINNING team, while Bob Melvin gets a pass for staying with Lester too long. Example: Dallas Braden on ESPN, when asked directly if he could point to any errors Melvin made, said “nope, he did everything right.” Really, Dallas? Everything? All night? I guess being a former Athletic gave him blinders or something.

ralph
12 years ago
Reply to  geo

Yeah, that’s a weird comment from Dallas Braden. I think the FanGraphs/analyst crowd pretty much all agrees that Melvin waited way too long to take Lester out.

And so there’s a lot of discussion about the Ventura move, because there are some widely varying thoughts about it within the FanGraphs/analyst community — a community that I think has rightly mostly gotten bored with straight takedowns of opinion-wielders like Braden.

Mark
12 years ago
Reply to  geo

I think one of the reasons for the Yost hate is that it actually did cost them the game based on that specific move, right in the first at bat. Whereas with Melvin, leaving Lester in didn’t cost them in that inning.

Pretty much the moment the Yost thing happened I said that’s a fireable offence right there. How do you not have Davis or a LOOGY warming up in case a runner or two get on for Moss/Reddick?

Mark
12 years ago
Reply to  Mark

Sorry, I meant to say it LOOKED like it cost them the game, and gave the A’s a lead. Obviously it didn’t cost them the game, but it could and potentially should have.

Cantinflas after every meal
12 years ago
Reply to  geo

Great point about Melvin and Jon Lester. Instead of managing “postseason style” and going to the excellent A’s bullpen at the first real sign of trouble in the 8th, Melvin stayed with his ace just a batter or two too long — which led to just one or two runs too many. Which led to extra frames, which led to….

It’s easy to see the temptation, what with Lester’s tremendous playoff history (career ERA a whisker over 2.00 in a dozen or so starts), but that’s a temptation he really, really needed to resist. Might be worth going back over the past two postseasons to see if Bob M. has fumbled away other opportunities. What the heck IS it about the A’s and the playoffs — I know there’s an element of randomness, but it ain’t all dumb chance.

Marsupial Jones
12 years ago

When I saw Yost come to the mound I was shocked. I thought maybe some weird alien with logical baseball strategy had possessed Ned and forced him, for once, to make a prudent move.

Then I saw Yordano Ventura walk through the bullpen gates and I just put my head down and closed my eyes…

Jonathan Sher
12 years ago

Cameron: Yost had some justification in using Ventura because the Rangers did the same with Derek Holland in 2011.

Hmm.
(1) Holland in 2011 was in his third season and not a rookie.
(2) Holland had been used in relief in the 2010 playoffs and had pitched 11 1/3 innings out of the pen and gave up 6 earned runs, not exactly a ringing endorsement.
(3) When Holland came out of the pen in 2011 three days after pitching 5 innings in a start, he did so at the beginning of the 6th inning with no one on base to face Damon, Kelly Shoppach and Sean Rodriguez, not exactly a murderer’s row. And it was game 4 of the series with Texas up 3 games to none. He pitched in relief in game 6 of the World Series too, with Texas up 3 games to 2, and gave up one run in two innings as St. Louis clawed back to win the game.
(4) Not sure the best defense for Yost is, “But Ron Washington did it.”

Jim S.
12 years ago

Dave, you’re a bright guy and you are usually correct. Not this time.

thecodygriffin
12 years ago

Dave, I love your work and appreciate the effort in the attempt at a counterpoint, but just no. Anyone with half a brain watching that game last night thought “Why is Shields coming back out for the 6th when they have 4 really good relievers (albeit Finnegan in a small sample size)?” and then “Why is Ventura replacing Shields?”. These two questions led to a great game, but did not help in the effort of winning it for Kansas City which should be Ned Yost’s main objective.

Bobr
12 years ago

But Dave, wasn’t there an article recently that pointed out that Shields has always been a better pitcher with men on base (or in scoring position, I don’t remember which) than with the bases empty? And not just this year, or in a small sample, but throughout his career.

If this is true, then why replace him at all with fewer than 90 pitches thrown and having just retired 6 straight in the last two innings on 2 groundouts and 3 strikeouts? I understand your point about not going too far with Shields, but the two men on were on a bloop and a walk, not on some evidence that he was breaking down or the A’s were getting to him. Even the walk was on close pitches.

I know the manager has to balance many options, and in an elimination game cannot rely on “trusting the veteran” when the situation demands a change. But in this case, it seems to me experience, history and the odds suggest Shields was the best option.

haishan
12 years ago

I do wonder how different the narrative would be if Ventura had gotten five quick outs, setting up Davis and Holland for the 8th and 9th. Would people be praising Yost for his gutsy, unconventional move? Or would we say, well, it was a bad choice that happened to work? I feel like there wasn’t much consensus — nor time for consensus — before the Moss HR, which is disappointing, because we shouldn’t judge an individual managerial decision based on its outcome.

Mark
12 years ago
Reply to  haishan

It would have been a bad move regardless of the outcome. If Ventura gets Moss out and the A’s don’t score, then Yost made an awful move that had a successful outcome.

All you can really do as a manager is put the best players on the field and maximize their potential and the team’s potential for success. You’re not giving your team the best shot of getting out of that situation unless you throw out a LHRP to take away Moss’s platoon advantage, or you use your 3 WAR RP with a sub 2 FIP to get you out of a tough jam.

haishan
12 years ago
Reply to  Mark

I’m sympathetic to this argument, but not 100 percent. If Ventura went out and threw 1.2 perfect innings, say with 3 strikeouts, shouldn’t we update our beliefs to take into account that maybe Yost knew something we didn’t, re Ventura? I’m guessing that nobody in Oakland had been watching film on Ventura, for instance, which could be advantageous. And maybe there was reason to believe that his command issues wouldn’t be a problem. If he’d given Moss a steady diet of high fastballs, as Cameron suggests, he probably could have gotten the out.

I don’t want to go overboard defending Ned Yost here. (Although at least he used Wade Davis and Greg Holland while down 4 runs and 1 run, respectively, so he’s not completely brain-dead.) But he also bunted a lot, and won doing so, and people like Cameron are saying “hey, maybe Ned Yost bunting wasn’t so terrible after all.” I think that, had Ventura pitched without incident and the Royals held their 3-2 lead for the rest of the game, the narrative would be much more like that one.

Z.....
12 years ago

I still cant believe they took Shields out, after they made that horrible trade for him, specifically for him to pitch in that moment…That was the first mistake. Things were just compounded by going to Ventura in that spot, with all of the variables surrounding it, instead of Herrera or Davis…I think wahat then makes it EVEN WORSE was Yost’s explanation of “wanting gas out there.” What does that even mean?! Herrera throws 100. How much gas do you need?!? A ridiculous move, with an even more ridiculous explanation. Ned Yost is really lucky the Royals came back and won that game b/c that was the type of decision that would have been spoken about for years. I can only imagine how Royals fans would have felt after waiting 30 years, making that trade for Shields, and then watching him walk off the mound in the 6th inning, with the lead, only to never see him in a Royals uniform again, while the best bullpen in baseball watched a kid that should have never been put in that spot, lose the game…

Cantinflas after every meal
12 years ago
Reply to  Z.....

Well said, Zed, on all counts.