Godzilla in Green and Gold: A’s Sign Matsui
After breaking it off with Jack Cust, being spurned by Lance Berkman and getting the feeling that Adrian Beltre’s just not that into them, the Oakland A’s are expected later today to announce the signing of Hideki Matsui. Assuming the 36-year-old’s achy knees check out during his physical, Matsui will take over as Oakland’s designated hitter.
Following seven seasons in the Bronx, Matsui signed a one-year, $6 million deal with the Angels last winter. Mercifully kept out of the field for the most part (his career UZR/150 as a fly catcher is -17.6), Matsui hit .274/.361/.459 in 558 plate appearances. As usual, Matsui did a good job working the count by drawing a walk in 12 percent of his plate appearances. And his .185 Isolated Power was solid, considering that Angel Stadium wreaks havoc on left-handed power. According to Stat Corner, the park played neutral overall for lefty batters due to an increase in singles and doubles. But it depressed homers for southpaw swingers by eight percent compared to a neutral venue. He’ll face even less hospitable conditions in Oakland, as the Coliseum saps lefty offense by five percent overall, and homers by eight percent.
As a player entering his late thirties, Matsui carries risk. But even so, he looks like an upgrade over both the departed Cust and Oakland’s best internal option, Chris Carter. Dan Szymborski’s ZiPS projects Cust (now a Mariner) to bat .230/.362/.411 in 2011. Carter, a twice-traded 24-year-old slugger without a defensive home, projects as a .229/.314/.427 hitter. There’s no ZiPS forecast yet for Matsui, but even with some decline he should eclipse those slash lines.
Overall, Matsui projects as a 1.5 to 2 WAR player — not spectacular, but certainly still employable. The terms of Matsui’s contract aren’t yet known. But if reports are correct that the deal is worth about $7 million, then the A’s are seemingly getting Matsui for less than market value during an offseason in which a win above replacement level is going for upward of $5 million. One could argue that Jim Thome, Manny Ramirez and Vladimir Guerrero, other free agent DH options, project as well as or better than Matsui and could be had for similar cash. By inking Matsui, the A’s appear to be choosing the guy they deem more likely to provide 500-600 plate appearances next year.
UPDATE: ESPN’s Buster Olney reports that Matsui’s contract is for $4.25 million, which makes this an even better deal for Oakland.
A recent graduate of Duquesne University, David Golebiewski is a contributing writer for Fangraphs, The Pittsburgh Sports Report and Baseball Analytics. His work for Inside Edge Scouting Services has appeared on ESPN.com and Yahoo.com, and he was a fantasy baseball columnist for Rotoworld from 2009-2010. He recently contributed an article on Mike Stanton's slugging to The Hardball Times Annual 2012. Contact David at david.golebiewski@gmail.com and check out his work at Journalist For Hire.


Now put ManRam in RF and call it an offseason.
Obviously the A’s are all about defense, so at their the offensive-only position I think they could have done a lot better. I know Berkman didn’t want to go there, but there are just so many other DH options better than Matsui. Maybe they feel like he’ll bring in more revenue, i.e. people from Asia, but I doubt that would be a significant enough difference.
I disagree. I don’t know who is out there who would both 1) be a better player and 2) willing to sign a 1-year deal with Oakland.
Vlad had a similar value season (less OBP, more SLG in a better hitters environment), but tanked in the second half.
ManRam and Jim Thome both both want to play beyond 2011, but having their numbers deflated in Oakland could hurt their chances of finding a good home in 2012. I guess we’ll know more when we see what they sign for.
The market is pretty bare after that: Johny Damon? Jason Giambi? Nick Johnson on an incentive-laden deal?
Now that I see the cost – seems like a very good deal.
Both Thome and Manny would be fine in Oakland. Manny showed he can succeed in a big, sea level park and Thome’s massive shots aren’t getting contained there. It is marginal/line drive power hitters like Holliday that have problems in Oakland.
Now it’s looking like the contract is only $4.5MM, plus a little extra for a translator and a PR guy. Wow. Fantastic deal for Oakland.
Lyle Overbay is getting paid more than Matsui next year, that is very odd.
And I agree the A’s should have went after Manny or Thome to DH.
It’s basically, give or take a few hundred thousand, what Jack Cust would have gotten (although retaining Cust, because he was under 5 years’ service time, would have given them an implied option on his production for 2012 as well).
So: Is Hideki Matsui better than Cust? I don’t know, but I doubt it given their respective ages and health statuses. It’s a fairly good deal in a vacuum, but I think the A’s came out a loser on the sequence of moves.
Given his recent history of decline, Cust isn’t as valuable as Matsui. Plus, Matsui has a much more neutral platoon split, making him far more valuable in an offense only position. If he was forced into the field, Matsui is also the better fielder, though neither Matsui nor Cust should be playing the outfield for different reasons.
Finally, and this is one of the few insightful things I have ever picked up from Harold Reynolds, Matsui is significantly more marketable than Cust. He will carry a halo (no pun intended) effect that likely helps drive revenue beyond his marginal WAR value.
Matsui is if anything: consistent. His lifetime OPS+ is 123 and his last 2 seasons have been 123 & 124. He went berserk in the 2nd half last year, his sOPS+ in the first half was 100 and it rocketed up to 163 in the second, which is not how he usually works.
Another thing is he hits very well at all four AL West parks, owning a career OPSs of 985, 954, 840 & 815 at all 4 parks in decent sample scales.
Hey, if he somehow figured it out and is going to be a 950 OPS guy like he was in the second half, then Beane found his next Big Hurt and the A’s are going places. I personally hated on Matui for quite some time, but he really isn’t a bad signing at all. The $4.25MM/1 year deal makes it very easy to stomach. I like that Harden, Duschcherer and McCarthy might all going to be in the mix next year. If only Beltre would come to them…