Proposed Pace-of-Play Rule Changes, by the Numbers

When Rob Manfred officially took over as MLB commissioner, he went on a bit of a media tour, explaining his plans to better the game of baseball. Among the things discussed were pace of play and possibly banning the defensive shifts. The latter has been discussed on these pages already, so I won’t get into that. But I do want to dive into pace of play for a bit.

One of the proposed changes involves installing a pitch clock. In fact, the Arizona Fall League was used as a bit of a test case already. The idea seems simple enough. The time between every pitch should last no more than 20 seconds. So, taking what we know about pace numbers and applying that restraint, what kind of change can we expect?

Looking at FanGraphs data from 2014 alone, I took the total pitches and pace data from every pitcher (minimum 10 IP). I took a weighted average of the pace numbers, to try and get as accurate of a number as I could (more weight to the time taken by the guys who throw the most pitches).

Here’s what was discovered:

  • Weighted average of time between pitches: 23 seconds
  • Total pitches logged by PitchF/X in 2014: 704,974
  • 2430 major league games
  • 290 pitches per game

A 20-second pitch clock means three seconds would be lobbed off of every pitch. That’s 870 seconds saved, or 14.5 minutes, or about 8% of the total game time.

If you wanted to get turbo-aggressive, you could turn to MLB rule 8.04:

When the bases are unoccupied, the pitcher shall deliver the ball to the batter within 12 seconds after he receives the ball.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage

There are a lot of rules that aren’t really enforced these days, but say the new commish wants to flex his newly-found muscle and implement this rule as well.

  • 170,876 total pitches thrown with the bases empty
  • 70 pitches per game thrown with no runners on

If pitchers only had 12 seconds to throw in this scenario, it would knock 11 seconds off each pitch. Over 70 pitches, that comes out to 770 seconds or around 13 minutes. Add in the remaining 220 innings at the usual three seconds a piece, and you get … around 14 minutes. All that math to save about 30 seconds.

So 14 minutes seems to be the magic number — a little less than 8% of total game time. But 8% is 8%, and considering a lot of the other percents (rest of the time to play the game, commercial breaks, pitching changes, etc.) probably aren’t going anywhere, 8% is not an insignificant number. There are certainly other factors to consider, but we’re doing this in a bit of a vacuum.

It remains to be seen what steps will be taken, if any, to increase pace of play. But if it’s done using some sort of time restriction on pitchers, we can expect a maximum of 14 minutes or so to be saved, on average. At least now we know. And I have it on good authority that knowing is around 50% of the battle.





David G. Temple is the Managing Editor of TechGraphs and a contributor to FanGraphs, NotGraphs and The Hardball Times. He hosts the award-eligible podcast Stealing Home. Dayn Perry once called him a "Bible Made of Lasers." Follow him on Twitter @davidgtemple.

22 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Buck Farmer
11 years ago

The savings would likely be even more considering pitchers won’t risk waiting until exactly 20 seconds to pitch. Most will probably pitch within the 15 to 18 second range.

vivalajeter
11 years ago
Reply to  Buck Farmer

On top of this, we’d really need to find the number of pitches thrown above 20 seconds (and the average time of them), as well as the pitches under 20 seconds.

If you had two pitches, one was 15 seconds and the other was 25 seconds, this analysis would say that we wouldn’t save any time because we already average 20 seconds. But the reality is that the ’15 second’ pitch would remain unchanged while the ’25 second’ pitch would be faster, and we’d ultimately save 5 seconds.

This is all partially offset by the comment below though, as some of the time is when the catcher still holds the ball.

Mark L
11 years ago
Reply to  vivalajeter

Why? That’a a pointlessly complicated way of doing things. We already have an average of all pitches and can work from that.

vivalajeter
11 years ago
Reply to  Mark L

How is it pointless? The average doesn’t really help us because it assumes that the fast working pitchers would slow down their pace to 20 seconds in between pitches. If the average was exactly 20 seconds, it would say that the limit wouldn’t save any time. We know that that’s not the case.

The slow working pitchers would speed up, saving time, and the fast working pitchers would continue doing what they’re doing.

DBA455
11 years ago
Reply to  vivalajeter

Good point.

Stealfirstbase
11 years ago

Sounds like a great idea!

Though I think you’ve got a mistake in your analysis. If there’s 23 seconds between pitches, but the pitcher must pitch within 12 seconds of receiving the ball, that doesn’t mean that enforcing rule 8.04 would make each pitch be thrown 11 seconds faster.

You’d have to consider how long a catcher holds the ball for, and whether a batter steps out and asks for time. Maybe you’d save more like 6 seconds per pitch. It’s still worth doing.

The great thing about taking less time between pitches is that it shouldn’t effect the game’s competitive balance. Good pitchers will still be good, bad pitchers will still suck.

SimonSays
11 years ago

Your math… makes my head hurt.

You can’t say “14 minutes is the magic number” when you’re comparing two very different scenarios. One situation involves all pitches in a game; one involves just pitches with the bases empty. On has 4 times as many data points as the other; one takes off about 4 times more time. Of course they’re going to be the same number: they cancel each other out!

You can’t put a timer with runners on base. Pickoffs are time between pitches, so pitchers couldn’t pick off after the 10 second mark and still be able to deliver a valid pitch. You can only put a strict timer on pitchers with the bases empty.

If we eliminate that difference and use your 70 pitches without runners on base, we get (wait, what’s 14 / 4…?) about 3 and a half minutes of savings in your first example, only 2% of a current game time.

vivalajeter
11 years ago
Reply to  SimonSays

Do you know how many times I missed BART by less than 3 1/2 minutes after leaving a Giants game though?

Plucky
11 years ago

I have a subtly different idea: instead of a shot clock on when the pitcher has to pitch, instead put a shot clock on when he has to be on the rubber. Particularly with runners on base, an expiring shot clock would give runners an enormous advantage on getting a jump on an SB attempt. A must-be-on-the-rubber-clock would accomplish a similar speed improvement, while still allowing pitchers to vary their rhythm in the normal way to keep runners off balance.

Walter
11 years ago
Reply to  Plucky

what if an expired pitch clock didn’t end in an ump calling time out though and a runner could be out on a pickoff after the pitch clock expires? The runner and pitcher would essentially be in a game of chicken, if the runner goes when the clock is about to strike zero, assuming the pitcher doesn’t want to give up the penalty to the pitch clock violation (a automatic called ball, i don’t know), then the pitcher could have the option of trading ball for an easy out on a runner that assumed he’d go to the plate.

It would add another aspect of game theory to baseball. Where runners should just take off every once in a while, as the clock strikes zero, and pitcher should similarly throw over every once in a while as the clock strikes zero.

I’m not sure I’d like that version baseball more or less than the current version, but it would help solve this pitch clock with a runner on base issue.

Plucky
11 years ago
Reply to  Walter

The purpose of adding a shot-clock rule is simply to make the game go faster by having less “stand around and do nothing” time. The ideal is a rule that speeds things up without introducing any novel strategy gimmicks, making structural changes, or tilting advantages one way or another. I made my suggestion because I think it would achieve the speed-things-up goal with fewer unintended consequences

Nick D
11 years ago

Assuming 20 seconds is assuming everyone is going to use Max a lot of times but not every pitcher would i.e. Mark Buerhle
so it’s probably even a more significant impact Then 8 %

Larry Bernandez
11 years ago
Reply to  Nick D

In the case of Buerhle, it would be less significant, since no real time would be saved when he’s on the mound.

Larry Bernandez
11 years ago

I would think that with runners on base, the pitcher would throw over more to keep the runners honest, which could actually increase the timing of the game.

boomer
11 years ago

Another way to speed up the game…just throw strikes more often even pitching to contact.
Some of the most enjoyable games I watched were like when Greg Maddux pitched a 85 total pitch complete game in about 1:53. That is sweet to watch in my book.

om
11 years ago

You get 13 minutes and 14 minutes, and then you take the average?! No, it’s 14 minutes saved on bases-empty situations and 13 minutes saved on bases-occupied situations–you ADD the savings, to get 27 total minutes, or about DOUBLE the effect you claimed. 30 minutes chopped from every game, for the same amount of action! Yes, please.

chuckb
11 years ago

Strikeouts lengthen the game as well. Fix the strike zone and the pace of the game will pick up and the pace of play will quicken.

phoenix2042
11 years ago

Shorten commercial breaks by 20 seconds. Wait, can’t do that! That would, uh, um, sacrifice the integrity of the game!

baycommuter
11 years ago
Reply to  phoenix2042

I’m against shorter breaks …I can just make it to the (awful) bathrooms at the Oakland Coliseum and back between innings.

JasonBVT
11 years ago

The 23 seconds mark is the average across MLB. The point of this exercise is to estimate minimal savings per game; meaning that some games involving quicker working pitchers wouldn’t change, but that the average of all games over the whole season would see a reduction in game time.
Also, 220*3+70*11=1430 seconds per game, or ~24 minutes saved per game on average over the course of the entire season.

LARRY PFEIFFER
11 years ago

I HAVE A GREAT IDEA!!! Leave baseball alone. It’s not broken, so, don’t fix it.Their is always someone trying to get their name in the history books for some great achievement.

william mitchell
11 years ago

(why not? ) pitch 4 straight ball to put batter on base.just give batter straight walk. GOT TO SAVE MORE TIME. THANKS