One Night Only: Smorgasbord of Wonders
Tonight’s array of games might best be described as “dizzying” — or, if not “dizzying,” then “wicked dizzying.”
Seriously, the five games below (analyzed in depth via the wonder of bullet point) are only the tip of the NERD iceberg, and completely omit tonight’s highly anticipated showdown between Scott Baker and Chris Narveson. Ya heard!
(Totally infallible NERD scores in parentheses.)
Jaime Garcia (8) at Brett Cecil (7), 7:07pm ET
• Startling fact: Between them, Garcia and Cecil are younger than Jamie Moyer.
• Likely occurrence: Jose Bautista hits an a-million-foot home run.
• Word of warning: The Rogers Centre, or whatever you wanna call it, is un peu de sad and depressing — on TV, in person, whatever.
Justin Verlander (8) at Jonathon Niese (6), 7:10pm ET
• Not-that-startling-but-still-true fact: Justin Verlander throws his fastball at an average of 95.8 mph.
• Additionally: He often follows it up with a curveball best described as “stoopit.”
• In conclusion: It’s a little bit mystifying that he’s only running an 8.2% swinging-strike rate. Not that I’m complaining.
Tim Lincecum (10) at Roy Oswalt (9), 8:05pm ET
• Direct quote: “Hi, my name’s Tim Lincecum. I have kinda a dumb haircut. But also, guess what? I’m about to throw you my changeup and you’re going to (a) swing at and (b) miss it.”
• Other direct quote: “Hi, my name’s Roy Oswalt. You may have forgotten about me, on account of I play on a team that blows. But guess what? I’m averaging more strikeouts per nine innings (8.68) than I have at any other point in my career, save my very first season in the majors, 2001, when I also threw a whole bunch of relief innings.”
• Jason Castro and Chris Johnson are the closest things the Astros have to bone fide prospects. They’re also very likely to play tonight.
Jon Lester (8) at Jhoulys Chacin (7), 8:40pm ET
• Some people — including resident philosicator Matt Klaassen — have suggested that lefties deserve a velocity adjustment of sorts for NERD. Like, lefties should get 3 mph added to their fastballs, or something. In fact, Lester already has one of the league’s fastest fastpieces
• Startling fact: The Red Sox are only a game out of first place. Say wha-?
• Shocking discovery: Ryan Spilborghs is not related to a certain, incredibly famous Hollywood director.
Andy Pettitte (5) at Dan Haren (9), 9:40pm ET
• Dan Haren might be the single most interesting fantasy trade target right now, given how far his ERA (4.71) is above his xFIP (3.43). His BABIP and HR/FB are way higher than in previous years. His LOB% is way lower. Carpe the diem outta that crap, is what I’m saying.
• Cole Gillespie will probably start in left for Arizona. He’s youngish and worth a damn.
• Adam LaRoche. What? I like Adam LaRoche. So sue me. (Actually, on second thought, maybe don’t sue me. That’s not gonna work out well for anybody.)
Carson Cistulli has published a book of aphorisms called Spirited Ejaculations of a New Enthusiast.


Just traded for Haren in my 12 team mixed league. I had to give up Shane Victorino and Colby Lewis to get him, but I’m jumping for joy right now.
Woahwoahwoah, I said “target” Dan Haren, I didn’t say “give up well-known deity Colby Lewis for him.”
I’m just hoping that Lewis doesn’t smite you. From what I’ve read and heard, smiting hurts real bad.
I believe the Red Sox are .5 games out, I know this because I have been watching the standings since April 20th praying for a turn around. My prayers were answered.
And you said the Rays had enough wins in the bank and wouldn’t get caught…so there.
Why is it that lefties supposedly can’t throw as hard?
I believe it’s because statistically, only around 7-10% of the population is left handed. That makes finding a lefty that can throw ~98mph about 10x harder to find than a righty that can throw that fast.
Although there may be a statistical reason that I don’t know about.
It’s largely a selection bias I’d imagine. There’s a lot more people who can throw 85 than 90+, and a lefty who can throw 85 is more likely to get a job due to the scarcity. There’s fewer lefties who throw hard because there’s fewer lefties period, and the soft tossers lower the average.
I’m wondering why isn’t Tommy Hanson v. John Danks on this list.
The cumulative (sp?) total has to be more than Pettitte v. Haren.
Verlander v. Niese as well.
Verlander/Niese is actually part of the write-up. But otherwise, you’re right: there are other noteworthy match-ups tonight. Kershaw (8) v Santana (6) is above average, Hanson (8) v Danks (6), and also Baker (8) v Narveson (5).
Baker should maybe get some credit, I think, on account of he K’d 12 in his last start.
Latos (9) v Wade Davis (4) doesn’t have the cumulative score of other games, but offers a chance to see Latos, who’s got a 3.71 xFIP and 93.7 mph fastball as a 22-year-old. Plus the Pads’ story this season — young, seemingly in transition, atop the NL West — is compelling.
M’kay makes sense, I was thinking that somehow Danks’d be 7 and Hanson 8. So I won’t argue with that.
Forgot about Kershaw v. Santana, because you reminded me I won’t miss the game locally on KCAL. Thanks.
I mentioned Verlander v. Niese as something Hanson v. Danks should have more NERD than, didn’t make that clear.
“I’m wondering why isn’t Tommy Hanson v. John Danks on this list.
The cumulative (sp?) total has to be more than Pettitte v. Haren.”
because he knew Hanson would take a dump on the mound tonight and ruin my entire fantasy week.
well, you sure were right about a bomb from Bautista
his 2nd HR travelled even further
might even add up to about a million feet total
Just wanted to say I enjoy your writing a great deal Carson. With all the negative nelly’s roaming the FG comments these days, I thought I’d share a little love.
And yes, I’ve been trying to pry Haren away from his owner for the past month. My latest trade offer (in a keeper league that counts the standard 5×5 plus OBP and QS) was Rausch and Posey for Dan The Man.
I was hoping that a Haren pasting tonight would push his owner over the edge and force him to hit “accept.” Dan hung tough in spite of the rocky start. Maybe I’ll have to sweeten the pot.