Selling Is the Right Move for the Nationals

Bryce Harper might join Manny Machado among those traded before the deadline.
(Photo: Keith Allison)

This post has been updated to reflect the Washington Post’s latest report about Harper’s availability.

Last week, The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal reported that the Nationals, who at the time were 50-51, “might need to win three of its next four games in Miami to stave off growing internal pressure to sell.” While the team trounced the Marlins in the series’ first two games, they lost the final two, capped by a two-hit shutout by Jose Urena and three relievers on Sunday. Now 52-53, they’re 5.5 games back in the NL East and six back in the Wild Card race. On Monday night, MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand reported that they’ve made it known that pending free agent Bryce Harper is available:

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage

[Update] On Tuesday morning, via the Washington Post’s Chelsea Janes, Nationals general manager Mike Rizzo proclaimed the team’s intention to keep Harper:

Harper, of course, is not having his best season. Though he’s first in the league in walks (84) and second in homers (25), he has struggled like never before when it comes to hitting against infield shifts; both his .240 BABIP and 42 wRC+ in such situations are career lows. In all, he’s hit .220/.369/.473 for a 121 wRC+, down from a 139 career mark, and his 1.6 WAR in 103 games is less than half of last year’s 4.9 in 111 games.

Even before Janes’ report, FanCred’s Jon Heyman suggested that Rizzo may not have been earnest about moving the 25-year-old slugger:

That jibes with Rosenthal’s report, which suggested that money is at the root of the Nationals’ concerns, but that not all of the team’s decision-makers were onboard (a situation that may have changed in the ensuing days):

“According to sources, ownership is pushing Rizzo to sell, particularly with the Nationals projecting to be over the $197 million luxury-tax threshold. That ownership preference, first mentioned by MLB Network Radio’s Jim Duquette, is shared by some in the front office who believe it might be time to retool. Rizzo, however, is not inclined to concede, and other sources suggest ownership is simply ‘riding it out’ and waiting for Washington to play better.”

Per Cot’s Contracts, the Nationals’ payroll for luxury tax purposes is $208,548,348. As second-time offenders, they would pay a 30% penalty on the amount over the threshold, which comes to all of $3.46 million, about what they’re paying Howie Kendrick this year — peanuts, by major-league standards. For the sake of comparison, the Dodgers paid $36.2 million in taxes and penalties last year, the Nationals just $1.45 million.

Last week, the Nationals were reported to have begun preparing for the possibility of selling — and realistically, they probably should sell. While injuries to key players such as Sean Doolittle, Adam Eaton, Kendrick, Daniel Murphy, Anthony Rendon, Stephen Strasburg, Matt Wieters, and Ryan Zimmerman help to explain the failure to live up to the lofty expectations that come with four NL East titles in six years, all of the aforementioned except Doolittle (whose toe and foot problems only landed him on the disabled list on July 10), Strasburg (who returned to the disabled list after one start), and Kendrick (who suffered a season-ending Achilles rupture on May 19) are now back. Yet the team has gotten little traction. After a dismal 9-16 June, they’re 10-14 in July and 4-5 since the All-Star break. Neither Harper nor Trea Turner have been as productive as expected, and the surprise contributions of players such as 19-year-old rookie sensation Juan Soto and first base fill-ins Matt Adams and Mark Reynolds haven’t papered over their other problems.

The killer hasn’t been the lineup — though the Nationals’ 94 wRC+ is just seventh in the league — but the rotation. During the 19-30 swoon that began in June, every starter save for Max Scherzer has been torched for an ERA of 5.40 or higher:

Nationals’ Rotation Since June 1
Name IP ERA FIP
Max Scherzer 69.0 2.74 3.45
Tanner Roark 50.1 5.90 4.50
Gio Gonzalez 50.0 5.94 5.12
Jeremy Hellickson 29.2 5.46 4.55
Erick Fedde 22.1 6.04 5.99
Jefry Rodriguez 14.0 9.64 7.59
Stephen Strasburg 13.1 8.10 2.86
Tommy Milone 5.0 5.40 0.76
Austin Voth 4.1 14.54 6.86
Total 258.0 5.48 4.52

After missing six weeks with shoulder inflammation, Strasburg lasted just 4.2 innings in his July 20 return before being sidelined again by a pinched nerve in his neck. Despite their rotation woes, the Nationals were on the sidelines as J.A. Happ, Cole Hamels, Nathan Eovaldi, and Lance Lynn changed teams in the past week.

On Monday, the New York Post’s Joel Sherman tweeted that the Nationals “don’t want to blow it up, not with inexperienced #Braves #Phillies ahead of them in the NL East.” Nobody is suggesting a full teardown is in order, but a dose of realism is warranted.

Entering Monday, our playoff odds showed the Nationals with a 33.7% chance of winning the NL East and an 8.8% chance at the Wild Card, largely because of their players’ strong projections and the relatively weak ones for the Phillies and Braves, both of whom are seen as likely to play sub-.500 ball for the remainder of the season:

NL East Playoff Odds Through July 29
Team W-L W% GB Proj W-L ROS W% Win DV Win WC Win WS
Phillies 58-47 .552 0 86-87 .492 45.6% 8.6% 1.7%
Braves 55-47 .539 1.5 83.5-78.5 .476 20.6% 7.7% 0.5%
Nationals 52-53 .495 6 85-77 .578 33.7% 8.8% 3.9%

A 42.5% chance at the playoffs seems overly optimistic, to say the least. But by how much? Via the Baseball-Reference Team Winning and Losing Streaks Analyzer, I pulled the results for every team though the first 105 games of the season (to match the Nationals’ total) from 1996 onward to get a sense of how often teams in the Nationals’ predicament have made the playoffs. First, here’s a breakdown since 2012, the period with two Wild Card spots in each league:

Success of Teams with 50-54 Wins Through 105 Games Since 2012
W Thru 105 Teams Won Div Won WC Avg ROS W Avg Final W
54 8 0 1 29.8 83.8
53 7 1 1 29.7 82.7
52 7 1 0 28.3 80.3
51 14 0 1 26.4 77.4
50 6 0 0 24.8 74.8
Total 42 2 3 27.7 79.6

Just five out of the 42 teams rebounded to make the playoffs, a success rate of 11.9%, roughly a quarter that of our odds estimate. Here are the five teams:

Playoff Teams Who Won 50-54 Games Through First 105, 2012-17
Team Year W PCT RS RA Dif Final W Finish Note
Mets 2016 54 .514 386 378 8 87 2 WC
Royals 2014 53 .505 417 419 -2 89 2 WC, AL Pennant
Blue Jays 2015 53 .505 556 453 103 93 1 Div Champ
Rangers 2015 52 .495 469 508 -39 88 1 Div Champ
Twins 2017 51 .486 474 546 -72 85 2 WC
SOURCE: Baseball-Reference

Only one of the five, the 2015 Blue Jays (who actually met up with the similarly resilient Rangers from the same year in one of the most memorable playoff series of recent times), topped 89 wins. That team had actually outscored opponents by 103 runs through 105 games — yes, nearly a run per game – by far the most of the 42 teams in this group. They were lagging about 9.3 wins behind their .593 Pythagorean winning percentage through their first 105 games; they went 40-17 (.702) the rest of the way. Of the other four teams, only the Mets (+8) had outscored opponents; last year’s Twins had been outscored by 72 runs.

As for the larger set, dating back to 1996, I went through the standings each year to determine who would have won the second Wild Card spot in each league. In several cases, that meant awarding one-half or one-third of a spot due to a two-way or three-way tie (since I had no way of breaking it, lacking the power to reconvene the teams for a playoff game), but oddly enough, none of those fractional spots went to teams in the 50- to 54-win range. So here is the breakdown:

Success of Teams With 50-54 wins Through 105 Games Since 1996
W Thru 105 Teams Won Div Won WC 2nd WC Avg ROS W Avg Final W
54 38 0 3 3 29.1 83.1
53 32 2 3 0 28.5 81.5
52 30 3 0 1 27.8 79.8
51 34 2 1 0 26.1 77.1
50 28 0 1 1 24.7 74.7
Total 162 7 8 5 27.3 79.5

Of the 162 team in the 50- to 54-win range, only 4.3% wound up winning their respective divisions and only 8.0% either claimed a Wild Card spot or would have, had a second spot been available in each league. That’s a 12.3% chance at making the playoffs, not much different than in the actual two-Wild-Card era. Only seven of the 162 teams reached 90 wins; the 12 Wild Card teams averaged 89 wins.

Maybe the Nationals’ +38 run differential (460 scored, 422 allowed) suggests they’re too good to be in this rut. But even if we hone in on the teams in the 50- to 54-win range with run differentials that were within 10 of the Nationals (+28 to +48), just one — the 2004 Astros, who were 53-52 with a +45 differential and finished 90-73 — won a Wild Card spot. Two other teams, the 2000 and 2005 Indians (both 54-51, with differentials of +46 and +36, respectively) would have claimed the league’s second Wild Card spot.

That’s three out of 18, or 16.7%: not great, Bob, and not anywhere close to the 42.5% from our odds page. They do align quite well with the version of the odds based not on projections but on season-to-date stats which “uses current season stats, weighted more heavily towards the most recent games, to calculate the winning percentage of each remaining game in the major league season.” Thus the underperformances that have come, with or without injury, may be what the Nationals are in for.

Harper’s subpar play relative to his own high standards is a big part of the hole in which the team finds itself; he’s about three wins shy of last year in a similar number of games. Add three wins to the Nationals’ total and their outlook improves just a bit; as Dan Szymborski calculated via his ZiPS projections last week, the difference between this year’s Harper and a Harper on a six-win pace adds up to a 10-point gain in their chances of winning the NL East (from 5.1% to 15.2%) and nearly that much again in boosting their Wild Card odds (from 6.7% to 15.5%).

Harper will command a hefty price in return, though perhaps not quite that which Manny Machado fetched, but then the DOA Orioles had no plausible reason to keep their young star. The Nationals aren’t dead yet, and so it would make sense to obtain, say, a club-controlled starter who could help offset the aforementioned showing of Disasterpiece Theater in the rotation. Regardless of what Rizzo seeks, Harper won’t lack for suitors, though both the Dodgers (who reportedly checked in) and the Yankees (who just lost Aaron Judge for a few weeks due to a wrist fracture), two of the most likely ones, are trying to stay below the $197 million competitive tax threshold. The Nationals would like a shot at re-signing Harper, and trading him would probably deal a blow to their chances, particularly if he goes to a clubhouse that’s less dysfunctional than the Nationals’ current one reportedly is. The dismissal of manager Dusty Baker on the heels of 95- and 97-win seasons followed by Division Series exits in favor of Dave Martinez, their fourth skipper of the past six years, simply hasn’t paid off, and it’s not hard to see why the revolving door would turn off any potential free agent.

Beyond Harper, the team has no shortage of other pending free agents: Adams, Gonzalez, Murphy, Reynolds, Wieters, and relievers Joaquin Benoit, Kelvin Herrera, Shawn Kelley, and Ryan Madson. The two part-time first basemen are having strong seasons, but nobody from that group is a game-changer, and Murphy (making $17.5 million this year), Gonzalez ($12 million), and Wieters ($10.5 million) are relatively pricey. Nobody there is going to bring back a blue-chip prospect in trade, particularly if the Nationals’ primary goal is saving money, not eating it to improve the return package.

Weeks ago, trading Harper would have been unthinkable. Even now, it’s a bit hard to believe. But after so many other dominoes have fallen in the trade market, the lingering prospect of his sudden availability and the Nationals’ potential reversals of course should spice up the countdown to 4 pm ET on Tuesday.





Brooklyn-based Jay Jaffe is a senior writer for FanGraphs, the author of The Cooperstown Casebook (Thomas Dunne Books, 2017) and the creator of the JAWS (Jaffe WAR Score) metric for Hall of Fame analysis. He founded the Futility Infielder website (2001), was a columnist for Baseball Prospectus (2005-2012) and a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated (2012-2018). He has been a recurring guest on MLB Network and a member of the BBWAA since 2011, and a Hall of Fame voter since 2021. Follow him on BlueSky @jayjaffe.bsky.social.

33 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Aaron (UK)
8 years ago

Thanks for the overview, and I tend to agree they should sell.

But, with respect to your third table, surely analyzing the Games Back is more important than the win total? Lots of the 52-53 win teams will have been 10 or more games out of first place.

stever20Member since 2017
8 years ago
Reply to  Aaron (UK)

I don’t know how many 52-53 win teams would be 10 games out.
last year- 1 52-53 win team 10+ games out(Sea)
2016- 0
2015- 1 (Cubs)
2014- 1 (Seattle)
2013- 1 (Wash)
2012- 0

so all of 4 teams in that situation in the prior 6 years. Not even 1 per year. Normally 52-53 win teams are close.

Part of that is there aren’t that many 62-43 teams or better to be 10 games up of anyone.

I’d be curious to see how many teams 5-6 games back after 105 are able to make a comeback(regardless of record).

Free Clay Zavada
8 years ago
Reply to  stever20

The Rays, at 53-53, are 21 games back in the AL East right now.

stever20Member since 2017
8 years ago

Right. But that is an anomoly and not normal by any stretch.

I mean there’s been 62 teams according to the chart that were at 52 or 53 wins at 105 games since 1996. i’d venture a guess maybe a dozen of those were 10 games back at that point. We’ve had 4 in the last 6 years.

Johnnie TMember since 2024
8 years ago

The salary cap … uh, wait, the LUXURY TAX… strikes again. Please, players, negotiate a better arrangement next time!

Johnston
8 years ago
Reply to  Johnnie T

“The salary cap … uh, wait, the LUXURY TAX… strikes again. Please, players, negotiate a better arrangement next time!”

You really want to see the Dodgers play the Yankees in the World Series every year that badly?

Max.Miceli
8 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

Maybe I’m not understanding your argument Johnston, but last I checked – of the top 12 highest payrolls in the MLB – you have teams like the Giants, Nationals, Angels, Cardinals, Blue Jays and Mets. All of which are borderline or complete sellers.

On the other hand, the lowest 12 payrolls includes teams like the Braves, Phillies, Brewers, Athletics – all of which are contenders this year.

So, if your point is a lack of salary cap / luxury tax / competitive balance tax would mean Dodgers and Yankees can spend their way to the World Series every year, I’d contest that isn’t exactly true. Far too much variability in baseball and, as the last few years have proven, too much importance in developing talent from within.

Anyway, I’m generally fine with the way things are now, but don’t think it’s completely out of the conversation to consider something different.

willl
8 years ago

Is it really in the Nationals interest to resign Harper? Their outfield is stocked for years to come: Soto, Eaton and Taylor are signed for several more years. Then Robles in waiting in the wings, along with substantial minor league depth: Daniel Johnson (Nats’ #9 prospect, CF) has returned from injury and been hitting well. Yadiel Hernandez, a 30 Cuban corner OF, is hitting .300/.380/.490 between AA and AAA. Even Andrew Stevension (#11 prospect, CF) is useful as a defensive CF with speed.

Since 2016, Harper has been worth 9.5 WAR over 361 games. That’s a 4.0 WAR pace for a 150 G season (expand it to his career and he’s been worth 29 WAR in 871 games, that’s 5 WAR pace). Do you spend $300-400m on a 4-5 WAR player?

Do you spend $300-400m on a 4 WAR player, when you have a potential 4+WAR player waiting in AAA in Robles? Robles also better suits the Nationals OF, because Eaton is a flawed CF and Soto a below average corner OF. Robles is a plus, plus defender, and makes a neater OF trio for the Nationals. Plus, if Robles isn’t immediately ready, Michael Taylor is a perfectly adequate fill in/4th OF.

To compound matters, if the Nationals don’t resign Harper this winter, they will only get a 4th-5th round compensation pick (around the 130th overall pick), because they’ve exceeded the luxury tax limit. Therefore, there’s extra incentive to deal Harper ASAP.

Yesterday, I’d have advocated trading him to the Braves for one of their wealth of SP prospects (Allard or maybe Wentz?), but with Duvall that’s no longer a need.

Could the Nationals pry Albert Abreu or Chance Adams from the Yankees or Keibert Ruiz or Will Smith from the Dodgers?

Ivan_GrushenkoMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  willl

Eaton and Taylor are much worse than Harper, and there’s no real evidence that he’ll cost $400m.

Johnston
8 years ago
Reply to  Ivan_Grushenko

“Eaton and Taylor are much worse than Harper, and there’s no real evidence that he’ll cost $400m.”

Two words: Scott Boras.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 years ago
Reply to  willl

Robles is widely considered to have the physical talent to be a plus defender, but he needs some more reps. Right now his defense isn’t that great.

My take on it is the following:
1) No, I would not sign Harper to a long-term contract. The future is Robles in center, Soto in left, and Eaton in right. However, it’s not clear that Harper is going to get the $300-500 million dollar contract he was in line for before the season began. If you want to load up for a run before the rest of your team ages out of contention, then it might be worth it to hang on to him.
2) However, there are a ton of reports that the Nationals’ clubhouse is a disaster and it’s hard to believe that Harper isn’t part of that. It may be time for him to go.
3) There is no way they would have gotten Wentz or Allard out of Atlanta. There is no way they’ll get Ruiz out of the Dodgers–maybe Will Smith, but only if they pick up the rest of Harper’s salary. Abreu or Adams from the Yankees is a possibility, again provided they pick up the rest of Harper’s salary. Honestly I wouldn’t be surprised to see Oakland or Cleveland make a run, although neither one is overflowing with blocked prospects and I don’t think Bobby Bradley or Jorge Mateo are of interest. Yankees are probably the best bet.

willl
8 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

To get someone like Ruiz or other higher regarded prospects, they could add in Kelvin Herrera, Daniel Murphy or someone else the Dodgers need (Adams, Reynolds, Madson, Kintzler, Gio Gonzalez?)

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 years ago
Reply to  willl

There are two problems with this scenario:

1) They’re pretty stingy with their guys. They told the O’s no to Ruiz and May and Lux already, and they actually needed another shortstop. They find guys they think are expendable and try to trade him (think a couple years ago with Jose de Leon). Smith and Ruiz are not expendable. Smith might actually be up with the Dodgers next year. I bet they’d trade DJ Peters or Yadier Alvarez or Edwin Rios, but I’m not sure why the Nationals would want them.

2) The Dodgers don’t need another outfielder. Joc Pederson, Kemp, and Taylor are all having better years than Harper, and Puig’s defense has been terrible but so has Harper’s and Puig’s picked up on offense. Plus Bellinger can play outfield with Muncy sliding to 1st, and they still have Enrique Hernandez and Alex Verdugo splashing around somewhere in there. I know they said they’ve checked in on Harper, but I can’t imagine they’d send out

I think that they’d have better luck with the Yankees, who have a bunch of Rule 5-eligible arms that aren’t progressing (Abreu, Tate, Acevedo, maybe even German).

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 years ago

So I saw a report yesterday by Passan suggesting that the clubhouse is a mess.
https://sports.yahoo.com/10-degrees-underachieving-nationals-reached-point-trading-bryce-harper-make-sense-164438671.html

And then, as Dan (s)Z points out, the projections are claiming that both the Braves and Phillies are sub-500 teams and that the Nationals are going to have a winning percentage of .565 going forward:
https://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/lets-make-some-trades/

So yes, selling makes sense. The big question is whether they’re going to try and bring any of those guys on expiring deals back. With Harper, do the Nationals want to try and bring him back on a pillow deal? I certainly wouldn’t give him the mega-contract that he will assuredly seek, not with the clubhouse issues, not with his inconsistency. What about Gonzalez? He’s going to be one of the better starters on the FA market, and they know him pretty well. How about Murphy? Do they have someone at 2nd base? You could always trade them and try to re-sign them later, but if you’re dead set on keeping them, I wouldn’t let them experience another place.

Those guys might have value. The others, not so much. Wieters wouldn’t bring back anything. If they sell relievers, they could only sell one or two or else they’d flood the market…maybe they could flip relievers upper-minors reliever prospect types.

Ivan_GrushenkoMember since 2016
8 years ago

Whether the chance of winning a division is 1 in 3 or 1 in 7, why shouldn’t the Nationals try to win it? It’s silly to punt playoff opportunities just because the odds are less than 50% or some high number. I wasn’t that impressed with the Machado auction return. Unless the Nationals get a Top 20 prospect and a Top 100 back, plus other stuff, why would they trade Harper? I’d rather they brought back Baker.

stever20Member since 2017
8 years ago
Reply to  Ivan_Grushenko

But the odds of winning the division aren’t really even 1 in 7. I mean, if the Phillies play .500 rest of the way, they win 86 games. For the Nats to just tie that right now, they have to go 34-23 rest of the way, a 96 win pace. To win, it’s 35-22, or a 99 win pace. What exactly have the Nats shown this year that they’re capable of going 35-22 over the next 9 weeks?

And the Wild Card is just as out of reach.

But I totally agree with you on Baker. That was a huge mistake. Nats aren’t anywhere near 52-53 with Dusty in charge(not to mention Mike Maddux- something folks forget).

Ivan_GrushenkoMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  stever20

I was referencing the odds from the article. Obviously if you believe the odds are 1 in 100 or something, selling makes a lot more sense. I don’t see why the Yankees would trade anything of value for Harper unless they think Judge is either done for the year or will be badly compromised.

stever20Member since 2017
8 years ago
Reply to  Ivan_Grushenko

Well it being a wrist injury, it wouldn’t be a surprise if he was badly compromised.

jgrub7
8 years ago
Reply to  stever20

Based on this analysis:
https://www.fangraphs.com/tht/finding-clues-to-hitters-wrist-injuries/

It would seem that the effect of the wrist injury on Judge would be dependent, in some part, on his swing pattern through the zone.

EasyenoughMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  Ivan_Grushenko

I agree that 20% odds aren’t really that bad, if those are the odds the team gives themselves. It’s expensive for any team to get to 20% playoff odds after 105 games. But with the current condition of the rotation, relievers actively talking to the press about being mismanaged, and ownership treating the luxury tax as a cap (maybe because they want to sign Harper?), the team’s internal assessment of their likelihood to get to the playoffs must be lower. They are not a Lance Lynn away from making this work, though he would have slotted as a #2 in this rotation. The on-the-record complaints by several pitchers about pitching management is astonishing. When was the last time a playoff team had something like that happen after the all-star break?

Youppi!
8 years ago

of course the lerners want to save money, that’s why they low-ball and change managers every other year. we see how that’s worked out.

but selling may be more about rebooting the image and clubhouse than getting back future value. all the numbers aside, the eye test doesn’t lie – this team is not playing well. it’s been in a funk since June. something is rotten.

sometimes breaking up is hard to do….

rhdx
8 years ago

Not sure why people think the future is so bright for the Nats. Strasburg might have 1 healthy year left in his career. Eaton is almost 30 and been hurt for 2 years. Murphy is old. Turner is good but it isn’t clear he is great. This team was built to win now and has a couple of nice pieces for the future in Robles and Soto. Their pitching is an abomination after a 34 year old Scherzer with no help coming. I think you need to try and catch fire unless you get blown away with an offer.

willl
8 years ago
Reply to  rhdx

They have a core of Turner, Soto, Robles and Scherzer (all of whom featured in the top 50 most trade value last week) locked down for at least 5 more years. Plus good players like Straburg (with opt outs), Eaton and Taylor locked down for several more years. Carter Kieboom, a top 50 prospect, should be arriving to play at 3B or 2B in the next year or two. They have $100m coming off their payroll this year, and Zimmerman’s bad contract expiring the following year. If they extend Rendon, they have 6 of 8 positions nailed down until 2022. There’s a hole in their pitching, but a re-tooling right now could go a long way to plug some of those holes. Acquire a few nearly big league ready relievers and a SP or two in exchange for short-term rentals on Harper, Gio Gonzalez, Herrera, Murphy, Adams and others, and sign a SP, decent catcher, and some bullpen help this winter, they could immediately return to make an even better run next year for cheaper than they currently are. Plus, there isn’t a dominant team in the NL East.

stever20Member since 2017
8 years ago

just saw this from the Washington Post Chelsea Janes on Twitter

Mike Rizzo just reached out with this message:
“Bryce is not going anywhere. I believe in this team.”

v2miccaMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  stever20

Yeah, was about to post that Rizzo has apparently reneged on the whole Bryce Harper is available statement.

RJSSURFER
8 years ago

They have the biggest star in the league and the 6th newest stadium (96% publicly funded) in baseball, and ownership is worried about $3M in luxury tax payments.

stever20Member since 2017
8 years ago
Reply to  RJSSURFER

It’s not just the current payment- with 30% payment for amount over threshold. Next year, their payment would go up to 50% payment over threshold. If they got down under the threshold this year, it would be only a 20% payment.

Ivan_GrushenkoMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  stever20

OK but any percentage of a small number isn’t that important to a team with a budget as big as the Nats.

stever20Member since 2017
8 years ago
Reply to  Ivan_Grushenko

considering what it would take to resign Harper, that could make a huge difference. If they were 20 million over the threshold next year- instead of it being a 4 million penalty, it’d be a 10 million penalty.

Why do you think teams like LA and NY are hellbent at resetting their tax number this year?

stever20Member since 2017
8 years ago

I guess the question is, if they’re going to not deal away anyone, should they go out and get somone to help out? IMO doing nothing here would be the worst answer.

francis_soyer
8 years ago

I’m surprised more teams don’t want Murphy for a rental. Flat out post season beast.

John Autin
8 years ago

The Nats’ problems aren’t games behind a playoff spot, but number of teams to pass. By my research, through 105 games in the wild-card era:
— No division winner was more than 4 games out of SECOND place, and just one was 4 games from 2nd. Nats were 5 out of 2nd.
— No wild card ranked below 8th in its league. The Nats were 11th.

stever20Member since 2017
8 years ago
Reply to  John Autin

the number of teams though is a bit deceiving. Right now it’s 6. BUT- of those 6-
tied in loss column with Cardinals
have 1 fewer loss than Giants- just fewer games played
1 game in loss column behind Pirates

So really only 3 teams are ahead of the Nats by more than just games played so far.

And nats only 5.5 games out of the division, with 2 teams ahead.

nats still have 9 with Philly and 7 with the Braves. And get the Mets/Marlins for still 16 games combined.