The Reds Transformed Their Pitching Staff. Now How About Their Lineup?
From 2015-18, the Cincinnati Reds pitching staff was an unmitigated disaster. Their rotation posted the lowest WAR in baseball over that span, and so did their bullpen. Following the 2018 season, there were signs that relievers were coming along, but the rotation was still a tire fire. Luis Castillo, far and away the best arm on the team, was suddenly having trouble keeping the ball in the yard. The second-most valuable pitcher on the staff was Matt Harvey, who was about to leave in free agency with seemingly little fight from the front office. The organization entered yet another winter with the rotation seemingly a gaping hole and with no quick fix in sight.
And yet quickly fix it they did. The team traded for three starting pitchers in the offseason, and even more importantly, they hired Derek Johnson away from Milwaukee to take over as pitching coach. In one season, they went from 27th in the majors in pitching WAR to ninth, and they did so without the benefit of a prospect bursting onto the scene and excelling. It was nothing short of a stunning turnaround, one that should have launched the team into contention. If only the lineup had hit. Unfortunately for the Reds, an offense that had hovered around the middle of the pack the previous two years dropped to 25th in baseball in wRC+ in 2019. Like the pitching staff a year ago, the lineup is riddled with holes. Is the organization capable of another quick turnaround?
In 2019, the Reds ranked in the bottom third of baseball in walk rate, on-base percentage, and slugging percentage in 2019. Statcast paints an even worse picture — no team in the majors had a lower average exit velocity, and only the Mariners had a worse hard-hit rate. Cincinnati was fifth-worst in baseball in expected slugging and seventh-worst in expected wOBA. The Reds’ offense was largely punchless throughout the season, and without a couple of hitters going on power tears late in the year, it could have looked much worse.
| Name | PA | OBP | SLG | HR | wRC+ | WAR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eugenio Suarez | 662 | .358 | .572 | 49 | 133 | 4.5 |
| Aristides Aquino | 225 | .316 | .576 | 19 | 119 | 1.0 |
| Jesse Winker | 384 | .357 | .473 | 16 | 113 | 1.0 |
| Phillip Ervin | 260 | .331 | .466 | 7 | 102 | 0.6 |
| Derek Dietrich | 306 | .328 | .462 | 19 | 102 | 1.1 |
| Joey Votto | 608 | .357 | .411 | 15 | 101 | 0.7 |
| Yasiel Puig | 404 | .302 | .475 | 22 | 95 | 0.6 |
| Josh VanMeter | 260 | .327 | .408 | 8 | 92 | 0.2 |
| Curt Casali | 236 | .331 | .411 | 8 | 90 | 1.0 |
| Nick Senzel | 414 | .315 | .427 | 12 | 90 | 0.7 |
| Jose Iglesias | 530 | .318 | .407 | 11 | 84 | 1.6 |
| Tucker Barnhart | 364 | .328 | .380 | 11 | 81 | 0.7 |
| Freddy Galvis | 116 | .284 | .411 | 5 | 76 | 0.0 |
| Kyle Farmer | 197 | .279 | .410 | 9 | 73 | -0.1 |
| Jose Peraza | 403 | .285 | .346 | 6 | 62 | -0.6 |
Eugenio Suarez was unbelievable in the second half of the season, hitting 33 homers over his last 79 games and slashing .299/.390/.690. Aristides Aquino, meanwhile, shocked much of baseball by going on the greatest career-opening power surge in history, hitting 11 homers in the first 16 games of his rookie season (he also made one plate appearance in 2018). But behind them, little about this offense says it’s ready for contention. Of the hitters who were something resembling average or above this season:
- Jesse Winker’s walk rate dropped five points, and his overall offensive production dipped for the third year in a row. He’s also one of the worst defensive outfielders in baseball, and has missed time with injuries to his wrist, hip flexor, shoulder, and neck throughout his career.
- Phillip Ervin had some of the most dramatic platoon splits in baseball, finishing with a 164 wRC+ against lefties and a 67 wRC+ against righties.
- Derek Dietrich followed a three-homer game against Pittsburgh on May 28 by hitting .128/.297/.233 with two homers over the entire rest of the season. He was cut from the 40-man roster last week.
- Joey Votto showed almost no power for the second year in a row, despite getting to swing at a juiced ball and play home games in one of the most homer-friendly ballparks in the majors. Even more troublesome is that he posted a career-high strikeout rate and his lowest walk rate in 11 years.
- Yasiel Puig isn’t on the team anymore.
If that’s your supporting cast, you’re in trouble, especially since Reds position players don’t play well enough in other areas to make up for it when the bats slump. They were the third-worst team in the majors this season by baserunning runs and the ninth-worst by defensive runs above average; Cincinnati’s 75-87 record reflected these shortcomings well.
And yet, partially because of the strength of the pitching staff, and the organization’s willingness last winter to buck the broader trend across baseball of hoarding finances and/or prospect capital at the expense of actual wins, the Reds are already popping up as Cinderella-like picks to win the NL Central next season. It isn’t an outrageous thought — some of the other division favorites don’t seem quite as caught up in winning, and the Reds’ pythagorean record this season was just one game short of that of the 89-win Brewers — but as we can see with the offense, they have a lot of work to do if they want to make that an even more realistic pursuit.
How do they do it? Well, they’ve already set things in motion with a coaching overhaul. After being hired last winter, Johnson, as The Athletic’s C. Trent Rosecrans and Eno Sarris wrote in August, oversaw major strides made by pitchers such as Castillo and Anthony DeSclafani in 2019. With the hiring of new hitting coach Alan Zinter and the promotion of Donnie Ecker — who received a great deal of credit for Aquino’s transformation — the Reds hope to get the same organizational shift on the offensive end.
But even if a few existing hitters break out under new leadership, it likely won’t be enough, necessitating that the club look outward. According to our own RosterResource, the Reds finished the 2019 season with an estimated $132 million payroll; entering 2020, it’s estimated to be about $120 million. According to The Cincinnati Enquirer’s Bobby Nightengale, the Reds front office said they plan to increase payroll going into 2020. Given the current financial picture, there’s no reason to suspect the team couldn’t add $30 million- $40 million in salary this winter.
That means an aggressive approach to free agency should be in the team’s plans, and early rumors seem to indicate that it is. MLB Network’s Jon Heyman has reported that Cincinnati has already communicated interest in shortstop Didi Gregorius, outfielder Marcell Ozuna, and catcher Yasmani Grandal, while The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal linked them to infielder Howie Kendrick. Those first three players all make sense, as they play positions that currently represent the Reds’ three biggest holes, while Kendrick is coming off a career season at age 36. Given the club’s financial freedom, even a deal with one of the three biggest free agents shouldn’t preclude them from making multiple signings.
Free agency is a necessary avenue for the Reds to explore when adding talent, but it isn’t the only option. Over the last year, Cincinnati has built its pitching staff by trading for players who were entering contract years. That was true of Sonny Gray before the team signed him to a reasonable extension as part of the trade, it was true of Tanner Roark, and it was true of Alex Wood. It was also true of Puig and Matt Kemp, and after playing out the string on 2019, it’s now true of Trevor Bauer. The Reds have been able to improve the big league roster with trades that didn’t require overwhelming prospect hauls because the players they landed didn’t come with three or four seasons of team control attached to them. It’s just another way the team has run counter to the approach other front offices have taken in recent seasons.
Are there options available for the team to deploy a similar tactic in the coming months? Certainly. Shortstops Jonathan Villar and Andrelton Simmons are entering contract years, and could be worthy trade targets. As for outfield bats, Mookie Betts has notably been made available by Boston, while the Cubs are reportedly open to shopping, well, everybody. Cincinnati has lived and died by the trade market for the better part of the last decade, and if should-be contenders are willing to abandon ship for the sake of cutting costs, it just might play into the Reds’ favor.
A lot of possibilities have been listed here, and for good reason. The fact is, if the Reds are really going to compete for a division title and beyond in 2020, it is going to take several of these options becoming reality. According to our Depth Charts, the Reds are projected to have starters at catcher, second base, shortstop, and right field who finish with less than 1 WAR. That’s an abysmal expectation for what amounts to half the lineup, and yet, thanks to the pitching staff, the team is still projected to finish 19th in total WAR. Using the resources at their disposal to add even eight wins this offseason would make them essentially equal to the Cubs, Twins, and A’s, according to projections.
It’s a daunting task, but the team also doesn’t really have a choice. Trades and prospect graduations have depleted the farm system significantly in the past year, with only Bauer and Kyle Farmer still in the organization to show for them. At the end of 2020, Bauer could be gone too. In a weird way, even though the Reds are entering their seventh year of rebuilding, they’ve actually shortened their window of contention. The time for this team to win is now, and the next few months must reflect that.
Tony is a contributor for FanGraphs. He began writing for Red Reporter in 2016, and has also covered prep sports for the Times West Virginian and college sports for Ohio University's The Post. He can be found on Twitter at @_TonyWolfe_.


Adding eight projected wins in an offseason is a pretty lofty goal, especially for a team in a market like Cincinnatti.
The Reds have put themselves in a bind of sorts by trading Trammell away in the deal that brought in Bauer, so all of a sudden their long-term outlook has one less possible piece and their short-term output is better. That’s a bind because their long-term outlook was always looking better than their short-term outlook, so now they’re stuck in limbo for a while.
My take on this is that the team has two roads they can take:
1) Sign Ozuna, Will Smith, and maybe someone else with a QO. Punt on getting much out of next year’s draft, and get guys whose market will be hurt a bit by the QO. Trade some prospects away for guys who are already here. Push all the chips in for the next 3 years or so.
2) Forget long-term, expensive deals and just plug holes. Bring back Iglesias and Scooter Gennett, see if you can hire Eric Sogard and Robinson Chirinos, see if Avisail Garcia or Kole Calhoun see their market collapse and need a 1-year deal. Trade for Wilson Ramos, who the Mets would probably give away at this point.
Yeah, signing Ozuna/Castellanos or Gregorious would help them, but they would need to sign both to have a shot, and then plug holes at all those other positions too. I’m not seeing this as a good road for them. They’re at least 3 very good players away, maybe more.
While I think they’ve shortened their window, I think saying “they’re at least three very good players away, maybe more,” is a tad confusing. Are you talking about them adding like three four-win players? More than that? They don’t seem THAT far away. Three two-win guys (average regular) seems doable (or more likely two three-win guys) . Signing Didi and exploring the trade market for someone like Marte might help them a lot. While I admire their gumption when so many teams seem content to sit on their hands, their execution was head-scratching.
In fairness, the Reds did have some unexpected brutal performances last year. Scott Schebler, not a star but certainly average offensively, completely fell off a cliff and was demoted to Triple-A. Jose Peraza, entering his age 27 season and coming off of a decent-to-very-good year, all of a sudden couldn’t hit water if he fell out of a boat (and was likewise demoted). The Reds pursuit of Gregorius seems to indicate that they have given up on Peraza and Schebler looks like he is following the Adam Duvall path into oblivion, so, yeah, free agency it is.
Free Agency or trading for soon to be expired contracts isn’t the only way to go. The Reds need some depth, and I think the Rays would make a good partner. The Rays have too many good but not great prospects like Nick Solak and others who are MLB ready. Perfect depth for the Reds, and the Reds would send…lower level minor leaguers or international money back? It’s a combination of free agency, trading for MLB players and trading for 40 man roster depth.
I understand the Rays don’t have Solak anymore, he was just an example of a 40 man player that the Rays didn’t need because he was too similar to other 40 man players.
“The team traded for three starting pitchers in the offseason, and even more importantly, they hired Derek Johnson away from Milwaukee to take over as pitching coach”
I think it might be a stretch to say that hiring Derek Johnson was more important than bringing in Sonny Gray, Tanner Roark, Alex Wood, and (eventually) Trevor Bauer. Sure, Wood got injured early and Bauer wasn’t added until midseason, and neither of them pitched all that effectively for the Reds, but Gray and Roark were important additions. As for Castillo and Desclafani, how much did Johnson actually do to improve them? And did Johnson also help make Roark and Gray better after they arrived?
First,
Did Johnson help Gray? Maybe, but Gray is a talented pitcher fully capable of righting the ship himself. He really didn’t pitch as poorly in 2018 as his numbers would indicate, and before that his down turn could have been attributable to injuries. His pitch mix in 2019 was pretty similar to 2018, and who knows if Johnson did anything for him.
Did Johnson help Roark? No. Roark was the same pitcher in 2019 that he’s always been. Similar rate stats, FIP, ERA ect…
Did Johnson help Castillo? Maybe, but how do we really know how much to credit him with? Castillo upped his K-rate, certainly, but in 2019 he was only replicating his 2017 FIP and ERA. This could just be a case of a young guy finding his way in the league (alone, or with minimal input from coaches).
Did Johnson help Desclafani? No. His rate stats, across the board, barely budged from where they were in 2018. He pitched more innings because he was finally healthy, but I don’t see how he showed better stuff.
Plus, did the SPs in Milwaukee ever really show sustainable improvements under Johnson? Not really, not that I can think of.
So people really think Derek Johnson is super important? Most of these pitchers either stayed the same from a rate perspective or bounced back to previous (and recent) performance levels. I’m not saying Johnson wasn’t useful, and I’m sure Tony didn’t literally mean he was more important than adding Gray and Roark, but I’m feeling there’s still a big discrepancy between my evaluation of him and others (or pitching coaches in general)
Desclafani and Roark did not change. Period. Same guys they’ve always been.
Castillo struggled a little bit in 2018 and bounced back big this season. He only added one K/9 over 2017, though. Otherwise he’s the same guy he was in his debut. One K/9 is certainly significant, but c’mon, that’s just a young player developing. He’s young and has a lot of basic things to learn, and I’m sure a whole bunch of different coaches could have coaxed that extra bit out of him (if he didn’t coax it out of himself).
Gray learned how to strike people out. That was big, and it was a real change. Johnson may have been a big part of that, but what about the analytics team, other coaches on staff, other pitchers, random people in Gray’s life (anecdotally, didn’t Carrasco start throwing more breaking pitches and breakout because his kid’s friend’s dad?)? And was Gray incapable of making any adjustments himself? Would a different pitching coach have been any less successful?
$20-40M in FA might bring in the likes of Gregorius and Grandal and a full year ofBauer on a salary drive might add up to 8 WAR but some internal growth on the offense might be needed to challenge for the division.
A better start would also help.
It’s not hard to envision a Reds run.
Right and they may get that internal improvement from Senzel bouncing back and Aquino for a full year.
But then again, how much worse is Votto going to get as he continues to decline and is essentially untradable?
If they are able to strike a deal with Grandal he would figure to fit in to the top third of the Reds lineup, patching multiple holes with one signing.
I think he’s going to be the number one target, possibly followed by Kendrick.
Out of all the FAs, the Grandal one is the one (as a Reds fan) I would prefer the least. We’ve got two MLB Cs on the 40-man now and Tyler Stephenson on the way.
Grandal is likely looking for a 3 or 4 year contract and the Reds can’t be paying a 35 y/o catcher $17M in 2023. It might make the 19-20 offseason look great, but it would be a wreck in a few years.
As a Reds fan, I would love to see them
-heavily pursue Didi
-bring in a Dickerson/Gardner type on a 1-2 year deal and push Winker/Aquino to a 4OF role
-bring two top RPs in
This takes no prospect capital other than making moves to get under the 40-man which would help our long-term health as well. Maybe in shifting players around, we find an actual MLB CF and can push Senzel back to 2B
I highly doubt the Reds will be able to win the division as soon as next year no matter what they do this offseason. Still, I suppose there’s a non-negligible chance they could pull it off.
But whatever happens with the Reds, there is one 2020 NL Central prediction that’s I’m fairly confident in making at this point: the Pirates will repeat as the cellar dwellers.