What If Boston Traded Hanley Ramirez and Pablo Sandoval?
On Friday, Ken Rosenthal of Fox Sports wrote an article titled “Red Sox need to dump Sandoval, Ramirez, like, now.” He states, in essence, that the Red Sox need to dump Pablo Sandoval and Hanley Ramirez, like, now. He states that they’re bad fits for Boston and that the Red Sox should have known that and the only way forward for Boston is to send both elsewhere and pay whatever it costs to do so. Suppose the Red Sox did trade Sandoval and Ramirez. Suppose they followed Rosenthal’s plan and got rid of both. What would happen then? Would Boston be better off? Let’s find out!
First, we’ll try to figure out if Sandoval and Ramirez have any value to other clubs. Would the Red Sox be able to receive anything valuable in return for dealing them or would they have to pay the vast majority of their salary simply to make them leave? Sandoval is due $95 million over the five-year life of his contract which runs through 2019. Ramirez will be paid $88 million over four seasons through 2018. Could the Red Sox get anything back for either player? Let’s go back to Dave Cameron’s piece from this past November when the Red Sox signed both players. Dave concluded that, although it was difficult to foresee exactly what value Sandoval and Ramirez would bring to the Red Sox for myriad reasons (read the piece if you’re curious), starting them each off as +3.5 WAR players and adjusting downward the standard half-a-win-per-season for each season under contract is reasonable. So, that being reasonable and I myself being also reasonable, I used those numbers. That methodology suggests Sandoval ought to be worth about 12.5 WAR over his five seasons and Hanley about 11.0 WAR for his four. That’s what Boston looked to be buying six months ago and that’s what teams would be looking at in acquiring those players now.
Except, not really. We now have more information than we did back in November and much of that information points towards less value for each player. We now know Hanley is such an atrocious outfielder that despite a 114 wRC+ (not counting Sunday’s game in which he homered), he has actually cost Boston half a win this season as his poor defense has overwhelmed his offense in much the way that drinking a whole six gallons of milk can overwhelm the fun of a 300-mile car ride. That means to provide positive value to an acquiring team, Hanley has to DH, and that limits the available teams to which he could be dealt. That is, unless there’s a National League team blacked out from watching Boston’s games, and thus still under the impression that Ramirez can play left field at a semi-competent level. In which case, see? The blackout rules could be good for something after all!
Sandoval has also had defensive problems, though his are a bit easier to brush off as something less than career threatening in consideration of his reputation and defensive numbers prior to this season. But that doesn’t put him in the clear. The problem with Sandoval is that, in addition to lousy defense, he’s not hit particularly well. He’s not exactly hit badly either, posting a wRC+ of 103, but for the money he’s making you’d like to get more than three percent above league average at the plate with lousy defense at a non-premium defensive position.
It’s not hard to see that since the Red Sox signed these players, their value has dropped, possibly substantially. It’s not that Sandoval and Ramirez couldn’t step in and help other clubs right now. Quite possibly they could. They’re but a few months past being desirable free agents. The problem is that they don’t appear like they will come close to providing the value for which they’re being paid. If the Red Sox are going to give these contracts away, making the players essentially like free agents to the acquiring team, that acquiring team isn’t going to want to pay them their current salaries. This means the Red Sox will likely have to kick in money to make them leave. How much is difficult to say, but if we assume it’s some substantial figure for each, that leaves the Red Sox having paid substantial money to sign Ramirez and Sandoval and then, not three months into the first season of their deals, paid substantial money to get rid of them. That makes a bad public statement about the people running the team, and it effectively hangs a large banner outside Fenway Park saying “Free Agents Shouldn’t Bother.”
This complicates things when you remember the Red Sox will need to replace Ramirez and Sandoval. But it kinda doesn’t. This is where Rosenthal’s idea starts to make a bit more sense. We’ve read incessantly about Boston’s numerous outfielders, so losing Ramirez wouldn’t really be that big of a problem, at least right now, as the Red Sox have other potentially capable outfielders who could assume left field. For example, Boston could pull Rusney Castillo off the bench and put him in right field and slide Brock Holt to left. Castillo has looked like a mess at the plate this season, but presumably if Boston is dealing their starting left fielder and their starting third baseman for essentially nothing, they’re not trying to win the division this season anyway, so playing a struggling player shouldn’t be an impediment.
The problem comes when you get to Sandoval. Ramirez was a luxury when he was signed, but Sandoval was signed because the Red Sox hadn’t gotten production out of third base in a couple years. The Red Sox farm system isn’t deep at third base, either. Garin Cecchini was a promising player with the ceiling of a starter at third if his defense could ever catch up to his bat, but that was a couple seasons ago. This season Cecchini has been batting around the Mendoza line for Triple-A Pawtucket and while his defense is improved, it’s not enough to justify playing him at the position without an above-average bat, which he doesn’t appear to have. Beyond Cecchini, the Red Sox have Travis Shaw who recently has been playing some third base after spending his career at first. Shaw might be a fine backup first baseman at some point, but playing him regularly at third base in Boston would be the equivalent of playing “on hold” music for the remainder of the season anytime the ball was hit to third base.
There is also Brock Holt, who has shown amazing versatility in playing every outfield and every infield position for Boston this season. What’s more, he’s hit .318/.407/.486 in 200 plate appearances while doing it. It’s hard to believe Holt is that good a player, but even if he isn’t, giving him more playing time might not be the worst idea. But then, as good as Holt looks now, it’s important to note he did this last season as well. In the first half of the season he put up an .834 OPS and slumped to a .548 OPS in the second half. Another problem is, though he is quite versatile, having him play two positions at the same time is probably outside his defensive abilities. Boston could play him at third and go with an outfield of Mookie Betts and Castillo, and then rotate Daniel Nava, Shane Victorino, and Alejandro De Aza through as needed. That isn’t terrible, but the problem there is Nava and Victorino are both hurt, and De Aza is bad.
But then this idea was never about getting better on the field. It’s possible dumping Sandoval and Ramirez would improve the clubhouse, and I’m quite prepared to believe it would improve the team defensively. Perhaps the Red Sox season is sunk and they should get on with rectifying the mistakes of this past off-season, no matter the cost. But considering where Boston is now, that seems presumptive. In other words, it’s not at all clear yet that Sandoval and Ramirez are mistakes. What’s more, the Red Sox don’t have talented enough players at present to replace Sandoval and Ramirez, unless you assume the way they’ve played so far in 2015 is the way they’ll continue to play more or less throughout their contracts. But if Boston has to pay their contracts to make them go away, those are mistakes that are going to linger seasons into the future, no matter when they admit it.


Sandoval is exactly what he was with SF. A streaky hitter who gets stupidly hot and was an overrated defensive player because he isn’t terrible for a fat guy. All his skills have declined the last few years and that’s not going to change.
Yep, we all know how biased UZR and DRS are towards boosting fat guys’ defensive numbers.
Hm? UZR and DRS never overrated him, and Ryan doesn’t say they did, either.
Fans have overrated him.
His career UZR/150 coming into this season was 1.8.
His career DRS/160 was 1.
That’s very good for someone his size. Because the internet, though, “Very good for someone his size” somehow turned into “very good.”
I took Ryan’s comment to mean that we should have expected Sandoval’s defense to be this poor (-11 DRS and -9.5 UZR already) and the only reason people expected more was because they overrated his defense.
My comment was replying that he’s been basically an average defender, as you also pointed out. It would have been outlandish to expect his defense to be this poor.
Yeah, I think he was just saying that it’s more a case of not-unexpected decline (although the degree is even surprising to me, and I hated the signing from jump).
The guy’s always had issues with being motivated to stay in shape, though, so it does make sense that getting $95m guaranteed has resulted in him totally falling apart, physically.
I don’t see many Red Sox games, but by the numbers he’s gone from average defensively to very bad.
Might be noise, but man that’s a lot of noise.
Ugh, not you too, fangraphs.
I thought we were gonna save this idiocy for the Boston tabloids.
They are. They’re dissecting the idiocy.
Thanks to 2012, a lot of Boston writers and fans now have this notion that teams can fix their problems by dumping their enormous underperforming contracts.
Where is Ned Colletti when we need him?
To answer my own question: maybe Ned Colletti is now occupying the body of AJ Preller.
AJ Preller probably thinks Hanley Ramirez is a pretty darn good hitter for a shortstop.
He very well might think Hanley’s the solution to the Padres 3B problem.
They’ve received -0.1 WAR out of that position so far this year, and while Hanley was never a very good 3B, he certainly wasn’t a horror show out there, either.
Want Kemp and Melvin for Hanley and Pablo???
Why not market Hanley Ramirez as a shortstop or second baseman? He really wasn’t that bad in the infield.
He was atrocious in the infield and put on 25 pounds of muscle in the off-season. He’s really a DH now, but for whatever reason plowing his surgically repaired shoulder into a wall slowed down his ridiculous offensive first month.
From 2012-14, Hanley was at -7.7 UZR/150 at shortstop. That is quite a step up from Asdrubal Cabrera, and sandwiched right in between Adeiny Hechavarria and Everth Cabrera.
And it’s not just UZR. He was at -8.3 DRS/150, right between Starlin Castro and Jimmy Rollins.
Hanley was widely viewed as a 3B during the offseason. Couldn’t he be marketed that way? There are plenty of heavier and slower third baseman, such as the one on his current team.
Guys don’t put on 25 lbs of muscle over an off season.
At DH, platoon Ortiz and Ramirez and let him continue to butcher LF against lefties. When Ortiz sits, you put Castillo in right and Holt in left. Sandoval is basically an average to slightly below average fielder who will get crazy streaky at times as referenced above.
No need to sell low on every asset that isn’t immediately performing. If you are going to sell because they are almost out of it, they should focus on the 1yr to 2 yr contracts like last year. They will absolutely need to get more starting pitching for next year, but selling low is just dumb.
Ill just assume you meant have hanley play left against righties because otherwise you are platooning ortiz wrong…
That means to provide positive value to an acquiring team, Hanley has to DH, and that limits the available teams to which he could be dealt.
I don’t see why this would be the case. Hanley wasn’t a good defensive 3B, but he was un-bad enough to have positive value overall. He is clearly an infielder (at least by virtue of being even more clearly not an outfielder).
It’s not clear that Hanley has much value at all as a DH, so bundling him with Sandoval erases his value.
I think if Boston were to try to go down this somewhat crazy path, they’d have to pursue two separate heavily-subsidized trades. That’s pretty far-fetched and as long as those two players aren’t blocking premium talent, it probably makes sense for them to suffer through it – or at least hope the players regain some value before trying to cut bait.
But really, I think the whole thing is a red herring from Rosenthal. They’re just a couple bad contracts. The players aren’t helping the team much, but they’re not ruining it either. If Boston had pitching, they’d be in contention even with these two. Pitching is the issue and that’s a much harder fix.
otm re: positioning of Hanley. Dump Sandoval, slot Hanley at 3B.
OtM is, as usual, right.
Yeah they aren’t going to get lucky and get bailed out on both.
I always thought it was amusing that the Sox and RSN just thought they’ll stick Hanley in LF and he’ll be fine. LOLOLOLOL
I thought a recently-signed free agent couldn’t be traded in the first year of the contract.
I believe June 15 is the date they can be traded. Plus, they can be traded earlier with their consent
That restriction no longer applies once we are past June 15 of the first year of the free agent’s contract. See p. 90 of http://mlb.mlb.com/pa/pdf/cba_english.pdf
Sorry, I didn’t see McNulty’s response. His reply is correct.
Playing Hanley at 3B is an answer. Although trading either contract might be fools gold, only trading one is at least a little less foolish to hope for. Did I say that right? Ha!
It’s amazing that the Giants wouldn’t think to trade their Panda replacement, Matt Duffy, for the Panda now.
Strictly speaking, didn’t they replace Panda with Casey McGehee, and then replace McGehee with Duffy?
I hope the journalism professional eventually returns to using traditional syntax and grammar. Mostly, however, I’d like to exterminate all sentences that begin with words or phrases like “Oh,” “Ah,” and “You bet.” (Each of these examples was taken from Rosenthal’s article.)
Blogger style need not infiltrate all writing published on the internet.
I’m also more than ready to ignore your rebukes, readers, and to withhold all stickers that I might have otherwise used to praise the textualized screeches and grunts you try to pass off as written English.
Shut up, give me twenty and get to band class.
My actual 8th grade English teacher hammered something home for me: don’t try to sound smart. Your whole last paragraph is a massive run-on sentence that jumps all over the place.
You say “I’m also more than ready..” – also in addition to what? Were you anything before? You certainly didn’t use any other descriptors of yourself, so why include ‘also’?
“Blogger style need not infiltrate…” – this is unclear. Your thesis is about Matt and Ken’s writing, but you switch around to making “blogger style” the subject of this sentence. It’s important to be clear here since this the crux of your argument. You lose a lot of impact writing it the way you did.
you care way too much about some random joke
I apparently care as much as you, Mike Anderson, to reply.
“Blogger Style” existed on the sports page long before Cerf and Kahn plugged two computers together. Rosenthal’s style is more than acceptable for the media and topic. He’s writing about baseball, not trade negotiations with Turkmenistan.
Jeezusss…..
How the Hell am I suppose to pass this class?
Were they to trade Sandoval and Ramirez they could put Holt at 3B and JBJ in center with Betts moving to right and Castillo or whomever in left.
Anyhow tho won’t Sandoval and Ramirez make for a decent platoon at 1B next year, with Hanley picking up some additional ABs at LF and DH, and Sandoval sliding over to 3rd to free up Holt to sub elsewhere?
A $45M, defensively-challenged, 125 wRC+ 1B platoon, sure.
Boston, Boston, Boston!
I can’t wait for some team to bail them out of their free agent decisions so the Red Sox can sign more players until they masterfully when a World Series
Unfortunately for Boston, Ned Colletti had his AmEx card taken away.
win a World Series*
Hanley Ramirez…I’ve heard of him.
I bet we can play him in CF.
It’s funny, because Cherington effectively spent more money to do the same thing as Preller, and his team has a worse record!
I’m enjoying this.
You and a lot of others.
” We’ve read incessantly about Boston”
Could have stopped right there
Essentially they have too many DH/1B types with Sandoval, Ramirez, Napoli and Ortiz. Napoli is gone next year which will allow them to either put Ramirez at third and shift Sandoval to first, or move Ramirez to first. The key being that they get him out of LF so his overall value is restored. I don’t see Sandoval and Ramirez being long term problems for them if they are able to deploy them effectively which they should be able to do next season.
Eno wrote this last year: http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/which-pablo-sandoval-did-the-red-sox-buy/
It includes Jeff’s research on aging curves for heavy ballplayers, and it doesn’t bode well for Sandoval long-term.
I didn’t mind Boston signing HanRam, despite his oft-injured status. But I thought signing Sandoval was a bad move, especially since it meant HanRam would have to be moved defensively from 3B.
Yeah, I really liked the Hanley signing when it was for him as a 3B.
I still don’t understand the Sandoval rationale. It was like a redux of the Carl Crawford deal.
But then they’re paying a man who has been David Freese/Dustin Pedroia/Brett Gardner offensively over the last 3.5 seasons $19m AAV to be their starting 1B from 29-33.
Sandoval has been more of a name brand than an impact player since 2011, but he was still above average because he had a decent bat and decent defense at third base. If you take either of those things away, he becomes average. If you take both away, you get what we’ve seen this season.
To me Sandoval has been a bum for half of each season and then gets his profile raised during the World Series only to remember he isn’t that good the next year
no these players are “untouchable”
This is an extremely well-written and informative article, and quite frankly I love reading fresh takes on the Boston Red Sox.
I also enjoyed the article!
“starting them each off as +3.5 WAR players and adjusting downward the standard half-a-win-per-season for each season under contract is reasonable.”
the starting point the projections gave us there were always a bit weird.
Previous 5yrs (in reverse order):
Panda (28): 3.0 1.9 2.6 5.3 1.2 (2.7avg)
Hanley (31): 3.3 5.1 2.5 0.9 4.2 (3.2avg)
really hard to see why we’d start them at 3.5 this year.
Because the article about the signings is biased.
And no, Dave and the other writers at the site do not have a specific Red Sox bias, they, like all other humans, have their own opinions and then make the numbers fit their narrative.
Starting Ramirez and Sandoval at 3.0 WAR would not have fit the narrative that Dave wanted and the opinion he had when he first read about the signings.
The Steamer 600 projections had them at 3.8 and 3.9 in 2015.
as far as i’m concerned steamer pooped all over themselves this year and have a lot of explaining to do, especially re: boston. in fact, steamer might be the most responsible entity for how overrated the sox were coming into this season. they had every single red sock far better than they were last year.
zips was much more sensible in their red sox projections, and had panda and hanley at 3war each.
Yeah, the Pablo “projections” from those articles never made any sense to me.
(The ZiPS projection, which used actual numbers, made perfect sense, though).
“If we assume that Pablo will have his best season since 2011 in 2015, and that that will be his baseline going forward, then this deal makes perfect sense!”
Pablo may be salvageable to some extent, but Hanley has to go. And even if they paid ALL his salary just to get rid of him, who cares? They’d be paying him anyway. So replace him with someone making the minimum, and that’s their extra cost – the minimum. I think they can afford it.
If they were going to do that, why not just bench him and put someone else in there? He’d surely be a more valuable bat than any other pinch hitters.
I am curious how much of Hanley’s negative defense is due to his inability to play (or adjustment to) left field, and how much of it is due to the smaller dimensions in Fenway. I can’t really find anything discussing this topic, but does anybody know if, or how, UZR and DRS adjust for ballpark dimensions? A defensive Park Factor or equivalent if you will.
DRS has a monster adjustment. UZR does not.
That’s why Manny’s career DRS is 30 runs higher than his UZR.
They’d need to pay a decent chunk of his salary to get rid of Ramirez, but they should explore a trade with the Mets. Who knows when Wright will be back, so Hanley can play 3rd until (or if) he returns. In the event that Wright does come back, he can play SS. The team clearly doesn’t worry about infield defense, and Hanley’s bat would be a big help for the Mets.
A meaningful player wouldn’t head to Boston in the deal, so it would be a matter of how much money has to change hands.
It’s probably never a good idea to trade a player when his value is at its lowest point in 3+ years. To do that with two players because the team has “chemistry” or “clubhouse” issues…beyond idiotic. Let’s at least take some time to see if the new, massive Hanley can maybe put up a 130+ wRC+ and play a half-decent left field (still totally reasonable to expect). Sandoval should be fine, albeit somewhat overpaid.
Why on earth is it “still totally reasonable” to expect Hanley to play a half-decent left field?
Not only does he simply not know how to play the outfield, after having exclusively played on the left side of the infield for the past 27 years of his life, but he clearly has no interest in learning…because Hanley.
“Why on earth is it “still totally reasonable” to expect Hanley to play a half-decent left field?”
Probably because we’ve got 60 games worth of data that can’t be discarded, for sure, but that shouldn’t obscure the fact that he’s a tremendous athlete who might take a while to get his ego around the fact that he doesn’t get to play shortstop anymore, and who might take a while after that to actually learn how to play.
Once Boston starts winning some games (which, make no mistake, is bound to happen – this team isn’t as bad as they’ve seemed the last few weeks), Hanley may decide he wants to be a positive contributor to the team.
It’s too early to cut bait on these two players.
And when in his career has Hanley Ramirez ever show a willingness to get his ego around any fact?
And why should the Sox start winning games, other than regressing closer to .500 than .400 ball? Other than Hanley and Holt’s bats, who on the team is doing anything outside the realm of reasonable expectations?
Kelly and Miley are exactly who they’ve always been. Buchholz is better than usual, and Porcello’s worse. Masterson is absolutely cooked. Sandoval got his money and doesn’t give a shit anymore (shocker), and Ortiz is turning 40 in November.
This is a middling ballclub, even when regression is accounted for. Why do you think that Hanley is going to put in an effort when he never did so for similar Marlins teams, even before he had $88m guaranteed no matter what he does?
I don’t know why decent defense from Hanley is reasonable to expect. It’s only expected because he was a not-the-worst-ever defender at short, and we assume anyone who can play short must be ok everywhere else. However, Hanley is instinctually-challenged. He probably just doesn’t know how to play the outfield, and I don’t know how open he is to learning. He’s not that athletic anymore, so he’s also not a guy you would expect could make up for his mistakes with his tools.
should have refreshed the page before commenting
Can Hanley play 3B better than Panda?
If so, that opens up more options, including…
-trading only Panda
-platooning Panda & Napoli at 1B
-cutting Ortiz and DHing Panda
-putting Ortiz and Panda on a seesaw and see if it breaks
-moving the green monster up to the 3B bag
I haven’t watched many Red Sox games so I have no eye test, but why are we putting so much stock in 466 innings of UZR for Hanley’s overall LF defense?
I have witnessed many innings of Red Sox baseball this year and Ramirez has been, unquestionably, the worst professional outfielder I have ever seen. He looks like an emergency outfielder who was plucked from the bullpen in an 18 inning game and was told “just don’t let the ball roll past you.” I would like to believe that someone who played shortstop at the Major League level for so many years could, in time, become an adequate outfielder, but Ramirez has been so poor that it’s hard to imagine he’s that guy. Not only does he he look like someone who has never played the outfield a day in his life, he looks like someone who has never once even wondered what the game must be like for an outfielder.
Honestly, I highly doubt that Hanley ever had wondered what the game must be like for an outfielder.
He never had any reason to, until the Sox were silly enough to sign Sandoval for 5 years after already having locked Hanley up.
I think of BJ Upton who made a clean transition to Center Field from second base. Adam Jones was a shortstop and plays a gold glove (yes I know) center field. I have to think it’s desire and not a physical limitation. Granted, these transitions occurred earlier in these players career, but my point is that if a player can physically play shortstop, he should be able to transition to the outfield and at very least, keep his head above water. When infielders get big, they are transitioned to the outfield because it is easier. I don’t think it was completely unreasonable for Boston to expect that Ramirez could play LF. That being said, if knowing his questionable attitude, they signed him with out first asking if he would be willing to make the transition, Boston deserves lots of criticism.
I don’t think Andrew Friedman could unwind this mess, but here is what I would do with the position players. Bradley in center. Betts is decent there, but this lame pitching staff would benefit otherworldly by an improved defense, and Bradley is the best. He’s finally shortened up his swing as is hitting .330 in AAA, so he may now hit a weak .270 in the show. Betts in left. Immense improvement there. Ramirez to DH against lefties, 3B otherwise. Napoli needs to be cut loose. That’s concussion syndrome or something like it from the damage sleep apnea has already done. No sign of life there. Sandoval may or may not take to that position, but the Boston’s have nothing to lose at this point except leaving last place. And Sandoval-Ramirez will have trade value if they can handle first and third at shouting distance of average. Castillo-Victorino in RF.
Nobody is escaping that pitching staff, though. Porcello was advertised as a ground ball sinkerball pitcher. Can someone tell me why he thinks he is a power pitcher?
This organization is also badly in need of a different tv team.
How much of Bradley’s AAA “improvements” can be ascribed to the fact that he’s a 25 year old in his third stint there and is currently enjoying a .365 BABIP?
I think it’s much more likely that he has another 80 point drop from his AAA BA (down to .230, which would be a vast improvement) when he comes back up than that his average jumps 80 points and he transforms into a .270 hitter.
Hard to tell without batted ball data.
The optimism regarding Bradley has less to do with the batting average, though, than the K-rate – which has dropped 11%.
Roger Maris for Pablo and Han-Ram,KC Athletics live.
I enjoy reading the vast majority of articles on Fangraphs and refrain from giving negative criticism to the writers as I find that even with the occasional wart, the articles bring insight into each topic of discussion (plus they’re free).
However this is one of the worst pieces of writing I have ever read. Not only is the ‘writing style’ something I would expect from a teenager but there is barely an effort made to provide information of the various options (no specific team proposal; no mention of Craig, Bradley, Brentz, Coyle), the little information given is dated/wrong (Shaw’s recent scouting reports rate him as an average to above average fielder at 3B) and at the end of the article it’s clear that there was nothing actually proposed….no insight given in an way aside from ‘these signings no longer appear to be good’; which everyone reading already knows.
Put a catchy title out there and then fill the article with absolutely nothing a la ESPN. But at least with ESPN it would be 1/3 the length and would be better written.
Come on Fangraphs – you’re better than this!
Why should Craig be mentioned? He is no longer on their 40 man roster.
Bryce Brentz, meanwhile, is a 26 years old with a 100 wRC+ in Pawtucket. What should they expect from him?
Coyle’s interesting on the rare occasions he’s healthy, but a 23 year old 2B with a 70 wRC+ in AAA shouldn’t be counted on for any sort of impact at the MLB level, either, especially considering that he can’t play on the left side and the OF is already flooded.
The problem with the Red Sox has been the starting pitching and Papi /Napoli along with Pedroias decline in defense and inability to hit with RISP or away from friendly Fenway, and a mediocre bullpen.
Hanley was great until he got hurt. Pablo is about what he was with the Giants. The position adjustments all said that moving to LF is a piece of cake for a SS, even a bad one. Hanley should be a league average LF’er they said. He makes Manny look like a Gold Glover. Still, that only costs them 1-2 wins over the course of a season. Not their biggest problem.
I think their offense may come around, but they got to get another SP’er, preferably an ace
I know you don’t like positional adjustments, but Hanley is a real poor tentpole for you to build a case with. Hanley has no interest in learning how to play left field, or (frankly) in playing defense at all at this point. If he was interested in playing defense, he may very well have turned into a solid OF.
We don’t know, though, because he didn’t even try.
But beyond that the positional adjustment should not be used to project how good a player will be at defense if moved to a different position. Would Juan Lagares be a good defensive shortstop? No, of course he wouldn’t be.
And he would probably be worth another 10 runs in LF or RF, just like Hanley would likely have been 5 runs better at 3B than he was at SS.
Last year, I warned the Red Sox (pleaded with them) not to buy players by the pound: aka Pablo “I never passed a Taco Bell without stopping” Sandoval.
“drinking a whole six gallons of milk can overwhelm the fun of a 300-mile car ride.” Got me good. Great stuff.
People may be forgetting that there will be openings at 1st and DH after this season (2016 option likely won’t be picked up on Ortiz). These two would slot pretty well at those positions and their defensive inadequacies would be mitigated. Pablo is pretty quick and has a decent glove, most of his errors come on throws. He might be a good 1B. Hanley at DH sounds OK to me.
It seems to be the red sox’ defensive issues can be traced back to weight gains for 3 players.
1. Panda clearly came into camp at his fattest.
2. Hanley clearly jacked up over the offseason.
3. Pedroia seems to have also jacked up, though it’s a bit harder to tell with him. He did seem obsessed with proving he still had power over the offseason, though.
all 3 have taken a big step back defensively and it might not be just small sample fluke.