Dan Szymborski FanGraphs Chat – 7/28/14
12:00 |
: Come on Barbie, let’s go party!
|
12:01 |
: First off, our usual weekly business.
|
12:01 |
:
![]() |
12:01 |
:
![]() |
12:02 |
will ken be at the party too??? |
12:03 |
: Not sure, but wrapped in plastic, it’s fantastic.
|
12:03 |
Hey Danny Boy, who do you think will get Tulo and what’ll it cost them? |
12:03 |
: The Rockies. For his current contract.
|
12:03 |
Andrelton Simmons, Evan Gattis, Mauricio Cabrera and Lucas Sims for “Tulowizki” Who hangs up? |
12:03 |
: Given the report that the Rockies are apparently insisting on Kevin Gausman for Jorge de la Rosa, I’m not banking on them actually moving Tulo.
|
12:03 |
Several reports now that the Jays have been given $0 to spend from ownership at the trade deadline. Given that this is the first season they’ve been competitive in roughly 20 years, how angry should fans be? |
12:04 |
: Very. I think I said this last week, but a team should never go into a season with 100% of what they’re willing to pay being utilized.
|
12:04 |
: As long as ownership isn’t short on cash, refusing to make marginal improvements with excellent marginal gains is beyond stupid.
|
12:05 |
You think the Peavy deal just set a ceiling or floor for the rest of the mid-tier 1/2 season rental SP market? |
12:05 |
: I think it’s dangerous to read too much into single trades.
|
12:06 |
I’m not seeing a lot/any links between the Tigers and Andrew Miller. Do you think there is a chance they swoop in on him at the deadline? |
12:07 |
: The Red Sox have been getting a lot of interest for Miller. They *should* still look into upgrading their bullpen, but I don’t know if they have the prospects if Miller actually results in a bidding war.
|
12:07 |
dan were you a history major? |
12:07 |
: math/econ
|
12:07 |
Why do people keep calling Heyward a bust? Dude’s on pace for another 6 win season, has 20.4 WAR thru first 5 seasons (almost as much as Posey and Braun over same period and more than Stanton), and is STILL not 25 years old yet. /end rant |
12:07 |
: Mostly because Heyward’s value isn’t obvious at a quick glance of his stats.
|
12:08 |
: And relatively few people think of a corner outfielder as being able to save 20 runs a year.
|
12:09 |
: Given his defensive numbers in right (and enough time that they’re mostly real), he really ought to be in center.
|
12:09 |
What is the maximum haul the Rays can get for David Price? |
12:10 |
: I’ve got this feeling that the Rays don’t trade him until the winter after all. By all accounts (and the inside buzz I’m privy to) they’re still asking for the moon for him.
|
12:10 |
Is Kemp subsidized down to 50 mill and Seager reasonable expectations for a Lester return ? |
12:11 |
: A little much. Kemp subsidized down to 50 is essentially break-even, so that leaves Seager for 2 months of Lester. That’s too much for the Dodgers.
|
12:12 |
: Yeah, maybe you rob them — the last big Red Sox-Dodger trade is still pretty bad for the Dodgers — but I’m not sure you want to go in with robbery being a reasonable expectation.
|
12:12 |
Gotta go with the distant relative here, Adams |
12:12 |
i, personally, find hanging up to be kind of rude. |
12:13 |
: It is! Unless it’s for a big scene ina movie.
|
12:13 |
Dan,do you think that the CHC approach of finding FA SP bargains, which they’ve employed the last few offseasons, will become more difficult to execute on, as other teams grow wise to this approach? At some point they’re going to have to pay up for an elite name(s) or trade some of the prized prospects to build the rotation, no? |
12:13 |
: It’s always difficult, but I think they’ll still come up with names.
|
12:14 |
: Simply because finding these lottery tickets isn’t really a productive game for a contending team, which tends to need to be more risk-averse.
|
12:14 |
: It’s a side-effect of being a rebuilding team.
|
12:14 |
Danny … Jedd Gyorko > Mario Mendoza this time around? |
12:14 |
: Gyorko was nowhere near as good as his 2013 numbers, but I still have hope he’ll be adequate.
|
12:14 |
Most dysfunctional front office in baseball? Gotta think that Rockies, Phillies, Mariners, D-Backs are all possibilities |
12:14 |
: Phillies are the *worst* but I’d put the Rockies as the most dysfunctional.
|
12:15 |
: Now, I know that doesn’t make a lot of sense, but I’ll explain. The Phillies are just out-and-out incompetent. I have no faith in Ruben Amaro and his staff adequately appraising the value of any player in or outside the organizaiton.
|
12:16 |
: The Rockies aren’t full of numbskullery — Dan O’Dowd is actually a fairly smart guy by all accounts — but there’s always this organizational stasis in which there never seems to be a goal or a purpose to anything they do.
|
12:16 |
: The Rockies are like an otherwise competent chess player that simply goes around making decent looking moves as the mood arises.
|
12:17 |
: And against the better competition, which is selectively making incremental gains for a unified strategy, they lose in the endgame.
|
12:18 |
: I’ve made this comparison a lot, but I stick by it. The way the Rockies operate is the Homer Simpson Plan of hiding under a pile of coats and hoping somehow, everything will just work out.
|
12:18 |
Fredi Gonzalez isn’t batting BJ Upton at leadoff today! Hooray! But he is batting Jordan Schafer at leadoff. Unhooray. |
12:18 |
: At least Upton has more than a month of his career that doesn’t indicate he completely sucks.
|
12:19 |
In terms of Win Probability, is a 1-run game the same regardless of the overall score? Or is a 9-8 lead in the bottom of the ninth less safe than a 1-0? |
12:19 |
: As far as I know, they’re still using Tango’s chart, which focuses on the differential.
|
12:20 |
: Though a 9-8 lead is likely less safe in reality than a 1-0 lead, simply because of the slightly increased likelihood that the 9-8 score is taking place in a context in which runs are easier to score.
|
12:21 |
DET/BOS: Johnathon Crawford for Andrew Miller. Who says no? |
12:21 |
: I’m not sure the Tigers don’t say no to that.
|
12:23 |
how is jake peavy even considered an ok pitcher? |
12:23 |
: He’s had a lousy season, but he has a history of not being lousy.l
|
12:23 |
: ZiPS gives him a 90-something ERA+ in SF>
|
12:24 |
Ha! The thought of a history major creating one of the top projection systems around. Hilarious! – a history major |
12:24 |
: People learn stuff later in life.
|
12:24 |
Which team lines up best with the Rays needs and assets, assuming Price, Zobrist, and Joyce are on the block? Do you think teams may be interested in slurping up a guy like Hellickson? |
12:25 |
: I think Joyce will be an easier sell than the top two. Hellickson is a real possibility.
|
12:25 |
Is there any chance that Dylan Bundy gets called up this year or is it more likely it will be next season? |
12:25 |
: I think he’ll pop up in September, though I think they’re oging to use him in lower-leverage situations.
|
12:25 |
Do you ever find TF2 to be too addictive? I know personally I had to stop playing because I couldn’t put it down when I knew I really should |
12:26 |
: I don’t know if it’s too addictive, but TF2 is a game that if you have a good community to play in, there’s a lot of synergy
|
12:27 |
: TF2’s more of a “fun” FPS type game relative to Battlefield or Call of Duty.
|
12:27 |
So you’re saying Jason Heyward’s defensive numbers are real and they’re spectacular? |
12:27 |
: Yeah, his numbers don’t have that awkward wrinkliness when you squeeze them.
|
12:27 |
: By which I mean, “explore mathematically” of course.
|
12:28 |
Now that Chris young is suddenly striking people out, is he suddenly more legit? |
12:28 |
: Certainly more interesting, though I wouldn’t get *that* excited yet.
|
12:29 |
There’s a lot of variance between the BaseRuns record on fan graphs, and the projected finish in season to date stats mode. Why? What formula does season to date sats mode use? |
12:29 |
: You gotta ask one of the Davids (Cammy or Apples) for that kind of info on FG inner workings.
|
12:29 |
Is Stephen Drew going to be sneaky good for the Sox ROS? |
12:30 |
: No. And he ought to be in a new uniform in the next few days or nothing he does will be sneaky good for the Red Sox.
|
12:31 |
: There is zero reason for Bogaerts, as long as he’s healthy, to get a single start anywhere but short for the rest of the season
|
12:31 |
What happened to the Pitcher GIFs website? |
12:32 |
: Did you ask them on Twitter? I’m the Mayor of the Internet. I didn’t even run in the primaries.
|
12:32 |
Hello Dan, Do you think the Phillies will actually do the right thing and sell? If so, who would they sell? |
12:32 |
: No.
|
12:32 |
: Because it’s the right thing to do.
|
12:32 |
: And Phillies.
|
12:32 |
Has Francisco Cervelli’s past few weeks made him a valuable trade chip for the Yanks? |
12:32 |
: It shouldn’t.
|
12:32 |
If Gallo were to start 2015 with the rangers and get 600 ABs regardless of performance, what would his overall line look like |
12:32 |
: It’d be fun, probably an impressive number of homers and strikeouts.
|
12:33 |
: Probably look like a Rob Deer year.
|
12:34 |
Jacob deGrom the real? |
12:34 |
: I’m increasingly inclined to think that he is.
|
12:34 |
: The Mets are such an interesting team
|
12:35 |
: Like I said in a conversation witha friend recently, the Mets really have all the pieces they need, the question is when they’ll figure out how to put them all together.
|
12:36 |
: With Terry Collins and the Wilpons, they’re like a guy who bought some badass furniture, but some assembly’s required and the instructions are all in old norse or something.
|
12:36 |
How do you see Billy Hamilton’s zips shaking out next year? |
12:36 |
: Projection of projections? That’ a bit meta!
|
12:36 |
i dont think you posted the dodgers/boston/lester/kemp question |
12:36 |
: Did I?
|
12:36 |
Hi Dan, do you think Jon Schoop will hit in the future? His glove has been great, but the bat… |
12:36 |
: I’m still confident, but he’s been quite meh.
|
12:36 |
Some speculation that Kemp would have to DH if he went to the Red Sox given the clusterfuck that is his OF play. Wouldn’t positional adjustment for the DH hurt his value almost as much as negative fielding numbers in the OF? |
12:36 |
: Probalby not, he’s *atrocious* in the outfield lately.
|
12:37 |
: You kinda look at a bad centerfielder and think “hey, maybe he’ll be an OK corner guy”
|
12:37 |
: But nope. Kemp’s been playing in the outfield like Kevin Reimer wearing snowshoes after winning a chili-eating contest.
|
12:38 |
What level of belief do you have in Tyson Ross? |
12:40 |
: He’s punching the [firetruck] out of guys with that slider, which you can see in his strikeout rate, so I’m a strong enough believer that I may buy some books or attend an open house, but not enough that I’d do anything ritualistic involving my genitalia.
|
12:40 |
how are the astros not on that dysfunctional front office list? |
12:41 |
: They’ve had some issues recently, but they don’t have the long track record of dysfunction as those other teams.
|
12:41 |
Who do you think has the best front office then? |
12:41 |
: A’s or Cardinals.
|
12:41 |
Should the Cubs just go out and sign Lester and Scherzer this offseason? $250M or so and their pitching questions and mostly solved. |
12:41 |
: That would be fun and to be honest, I think I’d actually push for the team to do that sort of thing. I think a splash like this might be another year off
|
12:42 |
Why wouldn’t the Padres trade Kennedy? Value at its perceived highest and the team wont be competing for 2-3 years. Same goes for Cashner honestly. |
12:42 |
: The Padres only like trading guys at the lowest point of their value.
|
12:42 |
Now that he’s back in AAA, can we expect anything from Alexander Guerrero this year? Think he’ll get enough playing time to be relevant in 12-team leagues? |
12:42 |
: In 12-teams? I don’t think he’ll get the time.
|
12:42 |
Re: worst/dysfunctional front offices – while I love the Phillies having entirely incompetent management, they haven’t signed about 40 first basemen to play for them this year alone |
12:43 |
: Yeah, the Mariners skills of collecting seemingly thousands of mediocre 1B/DH types are unparalelled.
|
12:43 |
: paralleled
|
12:43 |
Anything truly wrong with Bryce Harper? Or just a young player working through holes in in his swing and much ado about nothing in the DC media? |
12:43 |
: Much ado about nothing.
|
12:45 |
Lucas Sims’ K-rate has gone down from 10.34 last year to 6.03 this year. Any reason why? And should I be concerned? |
12:46 |
: It’s a bigger drop than you like, but unless I’m missing something, there hasn’t been any whispering of serious underlying issues.
|
12:46 |
: Just increased difficulty of putting away guys sometimes after advancing in minors. Does probably lower his ceiling at least slightly as it wasn’t a huge level jump
|
12:46 |
Man, the “Come on Barbie, Let’s Go Party” line takes me back to freshman year, where three guys from UAE lived next door to me. They blasted that song all day and night for about a month. Mark Prior was on the other end of the hall. I think I got stuck on the wrong side… |
12:47 |
: It’s in my head because playing TF2 last night, we were trying to sing the song in Louis Armstrong’s voice, completely with scatting.
|
12:47 |
Did you watch the Hall of Fame ceremony? Did you notice the GLARING grammatical error on Greg Maddux’s plaque? |
12:47 |
: Oh, the half-artist?
|
12:47 |
Happiness is to good stuff as Dan Szymborski is to _____. |
12:48 |
: poopface.
|
12:48 |
Denard Span has a .457 OBP in July. Unsustainable, I know, but I am greatly enjoying it. |
12:48 |
if you had to seize control of the Rockies what are the first 5 things you would do? |
12:49 |
: Execute dissidents, place trusted figures in power positions, prepare possible exile location when US counterattacks, reassure people that there is no coup happening, chat about the trade deadline.
|
12:49 |
: Oh, the *Colorado Rockies*
|
12:50 |
: Well, I think the first thing the Rockies need to do is sit down and realistically plan out their short-term and long-term goals.
|
12:50 |
: And make moves based on achieving the specific goals, not simply because you “like” a player or not.
|
12:50 |
Carlos Santana – the poster child for not putting too much stock in Average? |
12:52 |
: I think I had to answer a “give up on Santana?” question each of the first 8 weeks or so of the season. Again, a .170 BABIP is not remotely sustainable for a major league-quality hitter and for those that thought it was, you are ordered to make a dunce cap and sit in the corner and read all of Murray Chass’s blog entries.
|
12:52 |
We talk about component vs. result stats. What is the ultimate result stat? A win? A championship? A dynasty? A lifetime of fitful nights’ rests? |
12:52 |
: Depends.
|
12:52 |
The Pirates have (arguably) the most assets of any contending team. What’s one move YOU would make if you were in charge? |
12:52 |
: I’d love to bring in Cliffly, though it depends on the Phillies being reasonable.
|
12:53 |
Top 5 managers in mlb right now ? I say francona, Maddon, girardi, bochy, showalter. |
12:54 |
: Mostly agree except Bochy
|
12:54 |
Talk to me about front office “competence.” I hear a lot of blind faith in CHC circles in Epstein as simply “good” at what he does, but what does that even mean? So far imo the approach hasn’t been terribly creative. |
12:56 |
: Putting together the best minor league system in baseball and continually getting value from buy-low guys like Arrieta and Valbuena isn’t terribly creative? Sign me up for a front office full of banalities and pabulum.
|
12:56 |
How important is it for the Phillies to trade Hamels in the next 6 months or so? Seems like getting a haul for him may be their last opportunity to avoid a complete Cubs/Astros-like rebuild. |
12:57 |
: Yeah, the playoff core of the Phillies is done. The only question is if they want their next GM to take over before the team hits Astros depths.
|
12:58 |
: If the Phillies were a wartime regime, Albert Speer would already be formulating his excuses.
|
12:58 |
How come Jake Peavy isn’t considered a future hall of fame pitcher? 33 years old, 37.6 WAR so far. |
12:58 |
: Doesn’t seem to be in a great position to add to those bulk numbers.
|
12:58 |
: A lot of that is play he’s done a long time ago.
|
12:59 |
: Plus, even if he deserved it, the BBWAA voting is comically terrible.
|
12:59 |
: So bad that first it was funny and then not funny and then all the way around to funny again.
|
1:00 |
: Coming into the season, ZiPS had Peavy finishing 195-150 with a 113 ERA+ in 2968 IP and 14 WAR remaining in the tank. Taht wouldn’t get it done, even in a “deserving” sense.
|
1:00 |
Sale. Kershaw. Respective cy youngs. Everyone else go home. |
1:00 |
: Yes
|
1:01 |
Has Josh Donaldson overtaken Evan Longoria as an elite 3B? |
1:01 |
: I think so, though I think Longo will have a bounceback year.
|
1:02 |
Dan, as a fellow long-named “….(s/z)ki”, how offended would you be if your bosses misspelled your name on the website and refused to change it? |
1:02 |
: Heh.
|
1:03 |
: My name is still occasionally misspelled, which I understand, but I’ve never been in a position in which someone *refused* to change it.l
|
1:03 |
Chance Sisco is a cool name. How’s he doing this year in the SALLY? |
1:04 |
: Solid season, though he’s still a work in progress defensively
|
1:04 |
So WoW released Siege of Orgrimmar almost 11 months ago, and by all viewpoints they’re about to break the record of 12 months with no new content back when they did Icecrown Citadel. Is this delay killing their game? |
1:04 |
: Doubt it’s killing the game, there’s a natural showing of age here
|
1:04 |
Where are the Hearthstone cards today? And what do you think of the new expansion cards? |
1:05 |
: Oh, did I not do any hearthstone cards this week? HOld on
|
1:05 |
:
![]() |
1:06 |
:
![]() |
1:06 |
: Since we’re past the 1 PM time (allow more random off-topic questions)
|
1:06 |
: The Nerubian Egg is great.
|
1:07 |
: Loatheb is great against a miracle deck
|
1:08 |
: I can see an occasional priest playing zombie chow+riverndare with soulpriest and maybe velen if they can get it on the board
|
1:08 |
Jon Lester to the Orioles for Hunter Harvey and a C-prospect, who says no? Maybe the Red Sox can try for Gausman said something to make the Orioles hate him |
1:08 |
: I would hope the O’s say no. I like Lester, but it’s not worth it for 2 months of Lester.
|
1:08 |
: That’s why you increasingly see teams trading a year and two months of their future FA pitchers rather than two months. Pure rentals are a dying market.
|
1:08 |
If you’re the mayor of the internet what type of pull do you have to #KeepNotGraphs? |
1:09 |
: I said I wasn’t the mayor of the internet! I think
|
1:09 |
If San Diego doesn’t have a GM, who made the Street trade? |
1:09 |
: I suspect Street did and someone signed the paperwork.
|
1:09 |
I saw your tweet about the Elvis Andrus contract — that’s a hot-button issue with Ranger fans right now. If he hadn’t been extended and were to hit the market this offseason, what kind of contract would you expect him to get? |
1:09 |
: Probably less, but he’s legitimately a 2-3 WAR SS for half a decade. I dont’ think the Rangers should be that unhappy
|
1:09 |
What’s with the Dbacks’ stubbornness to not move so many average and below average players as they start to get more expensive? |
1:09 |
: Well, for one, they’re not terribly well-run
|
1:09 |
: They’re well terribly-run.
|
1:09 |
% chance Nick Franklin is a Mariner come Friday |
1:10 |
: 65.241098824%
|
1:10 |
What do you think 2015 portends for the Rangers — back to being a contender, or another season or irrelevance? |
1:10 |
: Kind of a season at the crossroads – if they’re unlucky and/or not able to buttress the core, they’ll be on the downswing.
|
1:11 |
Who are your top 5 sneaky pickups for saves in the event of a trade? |
1:12 |
: Hmm, thinking really quckly, Thayer, Giles – I can’t see a lot more closers being traded
|
1:13 |
Admit it Dan, you love Ruben amaro. Since the demise of bill bavasi hes the new comedy gold in boneheadedness |
1:13 |
…Like Kevin Reimer wearing snowshoes after a CINCINATTI chili-eating contest? |
1:14 |
: I would imagine most people would sign up for the army before participating in a cincinnati chili eating contest.
|
1:14 |
: Who thought that chili that tastes a bit like pumpkin pie was a good idea?
|
1:14 |
Are you surprised the Rockies have explored trading CarGo? I get not wanted to trade Tulo, but CarGo is often injured,is set to make $7M more next year, and seemingly be on his way out when the window of contention begins to open for the Rockies |
1:14 |
: I remain unconvinced how serious they are about it.
|
1:14 |
I think Scherzer/Lester is more like $350M |
1:14 |
: I think $300 gets the pair.
|
1:14 |
Your top 3 buy low hitters for ROS value. Thanks. |
1:15 |
: Didn’t I do a piece on this?
|
1:15 |
: YOu can probably still get Headley
|
1:15 |
No rays in the best front office discussion? |
1:15 |
: Up there, but slightly behind – the prospect treadmill has slowed considerably and I still think they should have traded Prcie last winter
|
1:15 |
Phillies need to sign a player called “the hills.” They can use this guy as an age rreference in the clubhouse. |
1:16 |
I see that guests of your chats frequently ask about video games. Do you play Wave Race 64? |
1:16 |
: I have a lot of interests, baseball, football, gaming, pro wrestling, classical music, nerdy indie pop.
|
1:16 |
: But that’s quite a random game to pop up
|
1:17 |
: I remember playing it on the N64 and I’m sure I have the ROM, but I doubt I’ve played it since, oh, 1998 or so.
|
1:17 |
What kind of beer should I pair with Cincinnati chili? |
1:17 |
: Brooklyn Brewery’s Cyanide Stout.
|
1:18 |
With the president fight today im imagining a weird Muppet / sesame street crossover fight between Grover and amy adams |
1:18 |
^^^^^^ Would have answered “..good stuff as Dan Szybmorski is to” Jello. Everyone loves Jello… |
1:18 |
The Rockies spelled troy tulowittskis jersey incorrectly for his jersey giveaway night. Great example of Rockies cluelessness |
1:18 |
Tyson Ross has a 27.1% K-BB % in the past 30 days. Having said that, boogerbutts are to fartfaces as peebrains are to _______ ? |
1:18 |
: diarrheaburgers
|
1:19 |
ROS: Mookie Betts or JD Martinez? |
1:19 |
: Betts if he gets the time.
|
1:20 |
: J.D. Martinez is like the Patron Saint of Buying High
|
1:20 |
: Yeah, he’s gone past that 1 month line where he usually becomes J.D. Martinez again
|
1:20 |
: But if you want to bank on him keeping a .370 BABIP and a 13% HR/FB rate, that’s fraught with risk
|
1:20 |
Will Alfredo Simon get Cy young votes because of how voters still put faith in traditional stats? |
1:21 |
: I suspect his stats will decline enough the last couple of months that probably not
|
1:22 |
My friends call cliff lee “the adverb. ” |
1:22 |
: I make a lot of Cliffly jokes
|
1:22 |
Dan Simborski. I am the guy at the docks at Ellis island shamelessly changing the spelling of your name. |
1:23 |
: In interviews, the difficulty of my last name comes up. I frequently will joke that my last name was probably Simmons but someone at Ellis Island dropped something on the typewriter and tehy decided to just go with it
|
1:24 |
Why would you take chris Sale over Felix for the cy young? Just park factor? |
1:24 |
: I’m assuming by the end of the year, Sale’s IP gap is made up for by the park difference.
|
1:24 |
: A .510 OOPS in the Cell is badasserous.
|
1:25 |
where do you create the custom Hearthstone cards? |
1:25 | : |
1:25 |
Blizzard is foolish if they aren’t working on a WoW2. People like me that considering going back and turned off by the age and how hard it is to get into again |
1:25 |
: It’s hard to plan something that may kill off your current cash cow.
|
1:25 |
: Even below its peak, it’s still tremendously profitable.
|
1:25 |
: They *ought* to be working on the eventual successor (and for all I know, they may be – I have much better baseball connections than game industry connection)
|
1:26 |
Lester and Willingham to Cleveland. Its official! |
1:26 |
: Wait, really?
|
1:26 |
: That sounds like a lie.
|
1:26 |
: I’m here chatting, I have no idea what’s going on in the outside world!
|
1:27 |
“Buttress the core” sounds like it ought to be a euphemism for something. Or at least a regularly used turn of phrase. |
1:27 |
Favorite TF2 class/hat/weapon combo? |
1:28 |
: I enjoy hats/misc combinations that work poorly with each other that valve didn’t think to disqualify
|
1:28 |
: For soldier, I like to wear the big daddy/menpo/founding father combination. Makes the soldier look like a horribly disfigured george washington
|
1:29 |
: You guys might appreciate what I named my huntsman
|
1:30 |
:
![]() |
1:30 |
Who is “Jason Lane” and why is he being allowed to ruin my Ervin Santana vs. San Diego start? |
1:30 |
: It’s *that* Jason Lane
|
1:30 |
Do you think we (FG dwellers and such) are starting to put too much weight behind WAR? Because, all it really is, is a stat that takes leverage and situations out of it completely. So its saying ‘theoretically, if every play was the same, player A is better than Player B’. And we all know not every play is worth the same and game are worth the same. |
1:31 |
: It always depends on the question. Every stat can be misused, but it’s best to deal with specific context than making a blanket statement
|
1:31 |
: Leverage and situations is a philosophical thing
|
1:31 |
: Personally, I’m unconvinced a player should get more “credit” based on that stuff
|
1:31 |
The Jays are owned by a multi billion dollar media corporation.. They have money coming out the ars… Fans should be livid.. this is bad ownership. |
1:32 |
There’s a minor Razzball invasion in your chat right now. Shore up those defenses. |
1:33 |
: Why would I need defenses? Is there any indication that I don’t love randomness and crazy questions?
|
1:34 |
Settlers of Catan. Cities and Knights. Best game ever? |
1:34 |
: Catan is amazing.
|
1:34 |
Just looked up Hearthstone for first time…life will never be the same 🙁 |
1:34 |
: Magic is deeper, but Hearthstone is more elegant in an internet format and easier to pick up and go.
|
1:34 |
I think the Mariners have a celebratory dance in the outfield that could be described as buttressing the core |
1:34 |
Has Francisco Cervelli’s past few weeks made him a valuable trade chip for the Yanks? 12:32 Dan Szymborski: |
1:34 |
: Because teams are generally not dumb enough these days to get excited over a few weeks.
|
1:35 |
Do teams reinvest the money they saved during rebuilding years? If a team that could have a $100M payroll only spends $60 while rebuilding, will they use those savings to have a $140M payroll? |
1:35 |
: They should, but many don’t.
|
1:35 |
Cities and Knights is a terrible expansion that overcomplicates a beautifully simple game. |
1:35 |
WHOA… *THAT* JASON LANE???? |
1:36 |
: Yes, *that* Jason lane.
|
1:37 |
: The 37-year-old that was an outfieflder with the Astros
|
1:37 |
Was just offered Miguel Cabrera for Lester and B. Hamilton… should I leave chat immediately to accept? |
1:37 |
: I would.
|
1:38 |
: Once teams stopped giving Lane AAA jobs, he went to indie ball and started pitching full time
|
1:38 |
: He’s not actually goign to be any good in the majors or fantasy-relevant even with the Padres, but it’s still really cool
|
1:39 |
damn you, Gareth! damn you to whichever circle of hell makes you the most damned! My heart skipped 13 beats (which took about 6 seconds because I’m really out of shape) after your post about the tribe. If they got ’em for As-Cab, that be fine, sir. But otherwise, nunhuh |
1:39 |
Have you seen the catan cook book? No lie this is something that exists |
1:39 |
: I have not. But today, everything that exists, does.
|
1:40 |
ESPN.com, projections and chats here, and DSzymborski on Twitter (and Steam, some of you TF2 guys should come play with me and occasionally Wiers and hear a baseball writer say horrible things)
: On that note, time to wrap it up for another week. Thanks for joining me everyone! As hte usual reminder, you can find my work at |
1:40 |
Should the Mets be afraid of the Tulo splits? |
1:40 |
: Yes, but only the dancing kind, because he can be injury-prone and that may result in groin issues.
|
Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.
Don’t the Rays have to be in the conversation for best front office?