RosterResource Chat – 11/19/26
Jon Becker
Hey everyone! Let's get started…
David Frederick
Any idea how much revenue (net) the Brewers and Rays got from their post season runs? Enough that they will be more active in the FA market?
Jon Becker
It's really hard to guess but it's estimated the Dodgers made something like $60-$70M last year just from the gate receipt pool that more heavily rewards teams the farther they advance. I'd guess the Brewers and Rays are at quite a bit less than that because the World Series didn't go seven games and wasn't as well attended in Tampa Bay, but regardless it's a big chunk of change, and the Brewers set a record for World Series merch sales. I don't think it'll impact their offseason plans too much, though, as the two teams just don't love to wade to deep into the free agent waters for reasons that go beyond money. I do think this could give more room/desire for extensions for young players like Caminero, Misiorowski, and Turang, though.
mragbayani
If you are David Stearns, how many SPs are you looking for this offseason? In other words, would you be handing rotation spots to Christian Scott and Zac Thornton?
Jason Martinez
edited
My guess is that they add 2 starting pitchers who are capable of being either SP1, SP2, or SP3, which would allow them to pencil Christian Scott in as SP4 and have Thornton, Manaea, Senga, Tong, Santucci, etc. in the mix for the final spot. Senga/Manaea are capable of pitching out of the 'pen. All the young guys have options. They aren't necessarily handing Scott a spot in this case. But it does sound like he's penciled in.
opifijikl
We just saw the ZiPS Royals projections – what would your two big goals be if you were JJ Piccolo, and why?
Jon Becker
A righty middle of the order bat and relief pitching. Even without Maikel Garcia, Witt-Jensen-Pasquantino-Caglianone is a really nice quartet but there's three lefties there, all of whom were below-average against LHP. I floated Alec Bohm as a fit for them yesterday, and his gap power would fit well in that park, and he mashes lefties. As for relievers, Steven Cruz was good down the stretch, Ferrer is a nice addition, and maybe Daniel Lynch IV is back in the 'pen with Bryce Miller acquired, but still a lot more that needs doing there. Having a go-to closer would be nice after a year of turmoil in the ninth.
Dodgers Blue
The Nationals have had 5 different saves leaders over the last 7 seasons. What are the chances they finally lock something down there – say a Raisel, Kenley (or even a Pete Fairbanks) signing? If none of the above, who is the ideal internal option if everything were to fall into place?
Jason Martinez
edited
My sense is that they know they failed last season by completely neglecting the bullpen, which can make a huge difference to a team's floor, and are going to make it a priority for 2027. The challenge will be that some of the top free agent relievers are getting big $ from better teams. So they'll have to add 3-4 reliable guys from the 2nd and 3rd tier of free agents, possibly the trade market, waiver wire, and MiLB free agency. Of course, getting lucky on some MiLB FAs/bounceback candidates will be key.
But it's going to be a combination of all that as opposed to last season when they didn't really seem to try. Kenley and Fairbanks make sense since it might be their only chance to continue closing. Or someone who's coming back from injury like Yimi Garcia or Joe Jimenez makes a lot of sense. Ideal internal option is probably Yovanny Cruz, who has closer potential and has looked good at times. Obviously, Jarlin Susana could be an elite closer but I think they’re committed to him being a SP for at least 2027 and won’t consider moving him to the ‘pen until he’s shown some limitations as a big league starter.
slazer33
Does the flurry of signings we've already seen suggest that owners are confident that they will avoid a terrible, baseball-damaging loss of games next year?
Jon Becker
I don't think so, I think they're just telling their front office heads to operate as usual because at the end of the day nobody knows what's going to happen, and you can't punt an entire offseason and then say "whoops I guess we're playing a full season, wasn't expecting that!" There's certainly a risk with deals like Jake Bauers' because he's not young and coming off his best season so his value is going to be concentrated to 2027-28 and we don't know how many games there'll be, but it's not like you have to pay him if there aren't games, anyway.
Hazmat Corntail
Do you foresee the Yankees adding another outfielder who can play CF to platoon with Jones?
Jason Martinez
edited
Biggest question is whether they even trust Jones, or maybe Cody Bellinger, to make 70% of the starts in CF. I don't think that's the case, but it might be the only option if the plan is to give Jones regular playing time. Adding a RHH who is a very good defensive CF would make sense in that case.
Maybe Myles Straw or Tyrone Taylor would be a good complement in that scenario. Adding someone like Luis Robert Jr. doesn't make much sense if they want Spencer Jones to play more often than not and I don't think a healthy Robert is going to be a 4th OF/vsLHP guy at this point of his career.
I'm expecting the Yankees to make some trades. Not sure moving Jones would be part of that, but I also don't know if Bellinger/Jones/Judge is ideal OF alignment. So it wouldn't be a huge surprise if they added a legit CF.
Cris E
Do useful-but-not-quite-worth-their-arb-value players ever have any trade value at this point in the year? I'm thinking Adell, Larbach, Ober, et al. Are these types automatic cuts or can they be moved somehow?
Jon Becker
Yeah they don't have much value because their current team has very little leverage: you take the best you can get before the non-tender buzzer or you non-tender the guy and get nothing. For what it's worth, I'd be fairly surprised if any of the three was non-tendered, though I think a trade of any of the three (Adell is least likely, Ober is likeliest, maybe?) is plausible. But with any of the three (and any other arb-eligibles) you can tender them now and trade them later if you're fine having them on your team come Opening Day. The real lack of leverage comes with a guy like Jarren Duran, who I think has to be gone one way or the other tomorrow.
Broken Bat
Are the Cubs really thinking Matt Shaw is a fix to their OF dilemma with Suzuki and Happ both departing? Or, is he a candidate to get traded for a SP like Gore?
Jason Martinez
edited
They might trust him to be a good defensive OF. Not sure they trust him enough offensively to just hand him a corner OF spot, especially when they have 2 holes to fill out there. He's done enough to lock him in as a super-utility guy who gets 350-450 PAs. Other teams that value him as an everyday infielder might want to trade for him.
I'm sure the Cubs are listening, but won't sell low on someone with his upside because his role (if it stays the same) is super valuable on a contending team. TBD on if they think that upside would show up in 2027, in which case they might just hand him the RF job. If it was 2B or 3B that was open, my guess is he’d be locked in. But might be looking for some more power from LF/RF.
Ice Cream Helmet
All else being equal, I feel like a lineup benefits more from upgrading an 80 OPS+ batter to a 90 OPS+ than they would from upgrading a 110 OPS+ guy with a 120 hitter. Am I right that from a pure math point it should be a wash, but in the real world scrub batters hurt team offense more than good hitter help?
Jon Becker
Yeah, that should be a wash, though that's a better chat question for Ben on Mondays. It's also easier to make the 80 to 90 upgrade than the 110 to 120 upgrade because players are going to be clustered around the average.
barondionis
Do you envision Murf Gray to get a similar path to Pittsburgh as Esmerlyn Valdez got? Feel like there's a slightly different need at 3B than the Pirates outfield last season, but they can be hesitant on prospects at times, so wanted to hear your thoughts
Jason Martinez
edited
Things can change based on what the Pirates do this offseason. But, as things stand, I think he's on the same path as Valdez. If Gray continues to mash in AAA and Jacob Gonzalez struggles (assuming he’s the Opening Day 3B), I can see them making a move as early as mid-May.
Gonzalez will probably get a long enough leash to show why he was a 1st Rd pick and why the Pirates acquired him last season. But unless Gray takes a step back in 2027, it's going to be difficult to keep him in AAA for very long.
bosoxforlife
Do you expect to see any surprises when the non-tender lists are released?
Jon Becker
I like to think I pay too much attention to be super surprised, though there are always a few unlikely ones that happen. So I think I will reframe this into "who are the highest-impact players that could be non-tendered?" To that my answer would be:
Jake Burger
Royce Lewis
Matt McLain
Jo Adell
Jarren Duran
Luis Gil
Tanner Houck
Camilo Doval
Tony Santillan
Phillip Denny
Jordan Beck and Jimmy Herget obvious non-tenders for the Rockies? Any others?
Jason Martinez
edited
I think they tender contracts to all of their guys. Beck's $1.2MM projection isn't much at all even if he spends a lot of the season in AAA. He has options remaining and plenty of teams would be willing to take a flyer on him if he was available. Herget also won't make much ($2.4MM projection) and his unique delivery and prior success at Coors Field are probably enough to keep him. Not sure why he struggled last season but he's only 1 year removed from a 2.48 ERA in 80+ appearances. If he stays, I don't think they're counting on him being a high-leverage guy. But he could still be an innings-eater who matches up well against certain types of hitters.
cluckett
The Giants have so many pitching holes and don’t seem like they want to spend much money. Are they going to use trades or just basically punt the season?
Jon Becker
It's weird to me that all the reporting has said that they only see themselves paying for one starter when they pretty clearly need at least two, but they also don't want to break up the farm with trades. So 2027 is understandably going to be a transition year for them, though it wouldn't surprise me if they made a somewhat-significant SP add anyway, more so than Houser and Mahle last year. Not Skubal, Peralta, or King, but maybe someone like Holmes or Imanaga.
Alex Remington
Atlanta obviously has a need for more starting pitching. How many cromulent starts do you see in their current organization, between Holmes, Elder, Smith-Shawver, Ritchie, Murphy, Lopez, the Spencers, and anyone else I haven't mentioned? Due to injury and stuff concerns, I can see a compelling case for *all* of those guys to move to the pen. Are there 60 starts in that list? More? Fewer?
Jason Martinez
edited
A lot of options, but not much certainty outside of Chris Sale. And even Sale is going to be 38 next year. I'd feel pretty good about all of those guys you mentioned, as well as a few other prospects (Murphy, De Grandpre, Sinnard), stepping up and filling 2 spots. Adding a reliable SP2 and SP3 in front of them should be the priority. And how much do they trust Didier Fuentes if moved to the rotation? Ideally, he'd stay in the bullpen and that part of the roster would continue to be elite. My guess is they add 2 reliable mid-rotation guys (someone like Tyler Mahle, Matthew Boyd, Nick Martinez) and then hope you get some bounce-backs from guys like Strider and Schwellenbach.
Cris E
Will the Angels and Mozeliak make any non-trivial moves this month or are they waiting for the sale to close and the new front office to be hired?
Jon Becker
If the new POBO/GM was in place I think they'd have the authority from new ownership to make a not-insignificant move, but Mozeliak is in a very weird spot where he's on the way out and just holding down the fort until Kroenke comes in and officially makes the hire (which still has to happen before the sale goes through in January). Would be weird for Mo to commit anything beyond a one-year deal to a player and then say "okay peace out guys, it's your contract now!" Even a one-year deal for, I dunno, $10M+ doesn't seem likely pre-lockout.
Eshan Mehere
If you had a gun to your head, what’s one move you are most confident the Yankees make this offseason. Framing it like this because it feels like there are a million different routes they can go at this point in time
Jason Martinez
It probably won't happen because it makes too much sense, but I've been saying that Luis Campusano will be one of their top targets this offseason. Campy and Austin Wells in a 52/48 split would be a very productive catching duo. Additional players might have to be included to balance out the deal, but I think one of Will Warren, Ryan Weathers, or Elmer Rodriguez would fit great in the Padres' rotation.
Dodgers Blue
CJ Abrams. What percent would you put on him a) being the Nat's Opening Day SS, b) being the Nat's Opening Day 2b, and c) being on another team's Opening Day roster entirely?
Jon Becker
I'll say 5%, 75%, 20% off the top of my head. Would be a really weird pivot to create that friction last season with the midseason position switch only to move him back. As for a trade, I think it's tougher for the Nationals to get something resembling a franchise-altering package when he's a 2B and not a SS, so they lowered the chances just by moving him off short, I'd say. Though I'm not sure how many teams would want him as their SS anyway.
war2d2
If both Adell and Duran are nontendered what kind of deal do you see them getting? I could see the Cubs trying to plug the OF holes with a couple 1/$10m deals to save cash for the rotation and hold out for Hartshorn to make it to the Bigs.
Jason Martinez
I think 1 yr, $10MM makes sense for Duran. Maybe 1 yr, $8MM for Adell. But those are close enough to their arb projection so trades are very possible. Wouldn't surprise me if there was interest on multi-year deals for either player, but both are capable of increasing their value heading into next offseason.
Jason Martinez
edited
That will do it for today. We'll be off next week for Thanksgiving, but we will be back in 2 weeks and continue to chat throughout the lockout. Enjoy the rest of your week!


