Beware of the Power-Surge Imposters!

It’s no secret that power is up in baseball. While guys like Brian Dozier are hitting their 40th home run and Tyler Naquin are putting up Barry Bonds-type numbers against breaking and offspeed pitches, investigations into the potential of a juiced ball have persisted throughout the analytical community. We can’t say for sure why power is up, but it is. The league’s .167 isolated slugging percentage is the highest the peak of the steroid era in 2000, and the second-highest in the history of the game, and the 14-point increase in ISO from 2015-16 is the 10th-largest single-season in increase since the modern era began in 1921.

Such a sudden and drastic increase can make it difficult to contextualize player changes on the fly. When I wrote about Eric Hosmer’s season two weeks ago, this line from a comment by user “isavage” stuck with me:

It doesn’t seem like Hosmer’s performance has fluctuated too greatly, it’s more that his offense didn’t get better when the league’s offense got better.

It’s not entirely true — Hosmer is striking out more and performing more poorly on balls in play relative to last season. But he does have a point. Royals fans might look at Hosmer’s seemingly increased power — a career-high 23 home runs, up five from last year, and a 14-point boost in ISO — and draw a silver lining that at least Hosmer is finding more power in his stroke. Except, it’s not true. Hosmer’s power, relative to the league, has actually dropped this season. He’s just a power-surge imposter.

I was interested in finding more power-surge imposters, so I grabbed two spreadsheets with every player who batted at least 300 times in each of the last two seasons. I league-adjusted everyone’s ISOs, and I did a rough park-adjustment estimate using our home-run adjustment, too. Then, I filtered for every player who’s seen an increase in raw ISO, but a decrease in adjusted ISO.

Be careful, folks. We’ve got 19 power-surge imposters on our hands:

The Power-Surge Imposters, 2015-16
Name 15 ISO 15 ISO+ 16 ISO 16 ISO+ ISO DIF ISO+ DIF
Chris Carter .228 142 .263 139 .035 -3
Pedro Alvarez .227 163 .253 139 .026 -24
Ian Desmond .151 102 .176 100 .025 -2
Yoenis Cespedes .251 166 .274 162 .023 -3
Asdrubal Cabrera .164 111 .187 111 .023 -1
Brett Lawrie .148 104 .165 91 .017 -13
Matt Carpenter .233 161 .247 157 .014 -5
Eric Hosmer .162 113 .176 113 .014 -1
Kendrys Morales .195 136 .205 131 .010 -5
Dexter Fowler .161 103 .169 99 .008 -4
Mitch Moreland .204 127 .211 120 .007 -7
Brandon Guyer .148 101 .154 95 .006 -6
Odubel Herrera .121 74 .126 70 .005 -3
Eugenio Suarez .167 95 .172 90 .005 -5
Howie Kendrick .114 73 .118 69 .004 -4
Joe Panik .144 109 .147 102 .003 -7
Martin Prado .106 78 .108 72 .002 -5
Josh Harrison .103 74 .105 69 .002 -5
Chase Utley .131 80 .133 78 .002 -2
ISO: isolated slugging percentage
ISO+: isolated slugging percentage, adjusted for league and park

We find Hosmer in the eighth row of our spreadsheet there, alongside teammate Kendrys Morales, whose 10-point ISO increase is also nothing but a mirage.

The top six names on the list are mostly the result of a park change, the best example of this being Pedro Alvarez, who sticks out like a sore thumb as our No. 1 power-surge imposter. Last season, Alvarez ran a .220 ISO while playing his home games in the spacious PNC Park, the third-most home-run suppressant ballpark in baseball. This year, he’s boosted his raw ISO by a whopping 26 points. He’s also gone from the third-worst homer park to the fifth-best homer park in Camden Yards, while playing in a more power-happy environment overall. Voila! That 163 ISO+ last year is actually just a 139 ISO+ this year.

Going a step further, one might point to Alvarez’s average exit velocity, up to 94.0 mph this year from 92.7 last year, as a sign that he is, in fact, hitting the ball harder, contrary to his 34-point drop in ISO+. However! Correlating with the league-wide increase in power production is, of course, a league-wide increase in exit velocity by a little more than half a mile per hour. That makes up half of Alvarez’s exit velocity boost. Then, work done by Jonathan Judge, Nick Wheatley-Schaller, and Sean O’Rourke at Baseball Prospectus led to park adjustments for exit velocity, while controlling for pitcher and batter, which found that Camden Yards, Alvarez’s home park, inflates exit velocity by nearly a full mile per hour, while PNC Park, his previous home, is closer to neutral. These two adjustments now more than make up for his perceived increase, leading us to a similar conclusion as the one found in the preceding paragraph — that the power increase exhibited by Alvarez on the surface is simply a delusion.

Which is particularly interesting in this case, because Alvarez was somewhat surprisingly non-tendered by the Pirates this offseason after they were not able to find a trade partner for him. Alvarez agreed to a one-year, $5.75-million deal with the Orioles, hoping for it to serve as something like a pillow contract while he rebuilt his value. By some of the raw figures that best measure Alvarez’s strength, he might’ve done exactly that during his time in Baltimore. Dig a bit deeper, though, and we find that not only is Alvarez really no better off than he was before being non-tendered last season, he might have actually taken a step back.

More cases like Hosmer’s — where the imposter label is simply a product of the changing batted-ball environment and not a change in home park — exist, too. Like Matt Carpenter, who’s seen his ISO+ drop by five points, despite a 14-point boost in raw ISO, or Dexter Fowler, whose eight-point ISO increase is actually a four-point ISO+ decrease. These aren’t monumental changes; you’re probably not looking at Carpenter’s season any different now than you were before you read this post. But they’re real, and this all can help serve as a reminder that every number ought to be viewed in the context of those around it, similar to Neil Weinberg’s recent piece on how the home-run spike has fooled managers. Don’t be like those managers who were fooled. Don’t get trapped by the power-surge imposters.





August used to cover the Indians for MLB and ohio.com, but now he's here and thinks writing these in the third person is weird. So you can reach me on Twitter @AugustFG_ or e-mail at august.fagerstrom@fangraphs.com.

20 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
dl80Member since 2020
10 years ago

A more tightly wound ball is the simplest, easiest answer. It may not be the correct one, but it seems like the answer until someone finds a better one.

Slacker GeorgeMember since 2016
10 years ago
Reply to  dl80

This is the classic “baseball of the gaps” fallacy made famous by Henry “Catfish” Drummond.

JoserMember since 2021
10 years ago
Reply to  dl80

That’s not an answer. That’s a hypothesis. Until testing proves or disproves it (and proves something else) we don’t have an answer, simple and easy or otherwise.

TraBuch
10 years ago

So is Freeman’s power surge for real?

swingofthings
10 years ago
Reply to  TraBuch

He didn’t appear on this list, so he at least broke even. Considering his ISO jumped by .67 points, and the largest increases on the imposters list were about half that, from guys moving to friendlier parks, there’s definitely a lot of legit power increase with Freeman.

bigriggs42
10 years ago
Reply to  TraBuch

Yes. Less grounders, more fly balls, hitting it harder.

London Yank
10 years ago

Tony Blengino showed recently that power increases with temperature. Might we expect some of the power increase to be climate change related, and might we then expect the trends to continue?

LHPSU
10 years ago
Reply to  London Yank

MLB is rigging the weather. It’s the only explanation.

JoserMember since 2021
10 years ago
Reply to  London Yank

I don’t know if that question is serious or not, but Alan Nathan addressed it four years ago (and then refined it earlier this year). A 10ºF (that’s 5.6ºC for you London Yanks) rise in temperature results in an average increase in fly ball distance of 2.5′ (that’s something less than a meter), which in turn results in about 6% more home runs. Average gametime temperatures have not increased anything like 10ºF (average global temperatures have increased about .8ºC, or 1.4ºF, since 1880, though most of that happened in the past four decades; that’s a global average, so local temperatures may have increased more than that, but nothing like 10 and certainly not in the past year or two). Even if we assume gametime temperatures are a degree or two higher on average (which is not a supported “fact” AFAIK) we can’t reasonably attribute more than maybe 1% of the increased slugging to higher temperatures.

Beer
10 years ago
Reply to  Joser

Don’t forget the shorelines creeping in closer from the rising sea levels. That adds humidity to teams like San Diego and Miami.

Doorknob11
10 years ago

I feel like it’s just the way guys hit not, much more all or nothing guys and very few put the ball on the ground and beat it out guys.

JoserMember since 2021
10 years ago
Reply to  Doorknob11

Except FB% averaged across all teams this year is no higher than last year; likewise GB/FB rate is essentially unchanged. (I reached that conclusion by doing a simple calculation last week averaging the team stats across the entire league)

jfree
10 years ago

It is only HR’s that are driving the power surge this year. There is no increase in doubles or triples. And HR/PA is actually higher than it was in 2000 (3.07% v 2.99%).

Just looking back in time at those three types of hits, it is really stunning to see the impact of the 1994 strike. Every year since then (compared to before then) is a big increase in HR’s, a decline in triples, and a moderate increase in doubles (presumably a changing mix of more standup doubles and fewer sliding doubles). And far fewer singles now than at any time since the end of WW2. So the (successful) contact/spray hitter and the stretch hitter/runner are kinda gone. What fills the vacuum is the swing-for-the-moon players.

I actually wonder whether the emphasis on saber has created this – by deemphasizing game context and emphasizing swing-results/outcome. The combo of young players now who never saw 1980’s/before baseball and teams which post-strike have incentivized the long-ball hitter

D.K. Willardson
10 years ago

In terms of the general ISO increase, in addition to the .5 MPH increase in EV, launch angles are up 1.5 degrees on average for LDs and FBs and more FBs are being hit – GB/FB ratio from 1.32 to 1.28. It would appear organizational philosophies of “more loft” are having an impact. The big unknown in the equation is spin and what is happening there. IFFBs are up only fractionally. It will be an interesting trend to watch going forward because past a certain point, loft is not “free”.

JoserMember since 2021
10 years ago

Actually, if you look at the past three years the GB/FB hasn’t changed much since 2014 (it’s up from 2015, but that was down from the year before) and FB% has remained pretty much constant. What has really jumped is the HR/FB ratio, and Alan Nathan and others have shown, that seems to be primarily a result of exit velocity rather than angle.

That said, I haven’t seen a study that puts all flyballs into launch angle buckets and then compares year to year to see if the relative proportion in each bucket is shifting over time (which would reflect the result of a quest for “more loft”). Would be a pretty straight-forward exercise for somebody to do.

D.K. Willardson
10 years ago
Reply to  Joser

Thanks, appreciate the Nathan reference. If I get a chance, I’ll look into the buckets. Since launch angles are definitely higher, I think it is critical to understand if they are being hit there – i.e. more swing loft or spun there – ie. hitting below the equator. The second way is going to give you significantly more carry but yet nobody seems to be looking there. Maybe the spin rate data on the hitting side is just not available.

D.K. Willardson
10 years ago

Looking at the buckets, the percentage of higher lofted balls is definitely increasing. They are moving from the lowest fly ball groups to the highest. So there may not be a lot more fly balls but the ones that are being hit are higher than last year. From a swing loft standpoint, you can’t really hit a ball square at 40+ deg so it must be from ball contact point and spin.

Launch Angle 2015 2016
10-20 33.5% 31.0%
21-30 27.4% 26.6%
31-40 19.2% 19.2%
41-50 11.0% 12.1%
>50 8.8% 11.1%

Also, the std dev. of the launch angle is up 1.5 from last year which indicates less square contact this year overall.

JoserMember since 2021
10 years ago

Interesting. That’s a really subtle shift, though — most of the change is a couple of percent taken away at the bottom and added in at the top. So there isn’t much of a shift from GB to FB, but we might be seeing an effort to get away from line drives and aim for the fences with that optimum launch angle.

Thanks for following up on that. (Not sure if anybody is still reading the comments here — maybe you should write this up and submit it as a community research article)

D.K. Willardson
10 years ago

Looking at the buckets, the percentage of higher lofted balls is definitely increasing. They are moving from the lowest fly ball groups to the highest. So there may not be a lot more fly balls but the ones that are being hit are higher than last year. From a swing loft standpoint, you can’t really hit a ball square at 40+ deg so it must be from ball contact point and spin.

Launch Angle 2015 2016
10-20 33.5% 31.0%
21-30 27.4% 26.6%
31-40 19.2% 19.2%
41-50 11.0% 12.1%
>50 8.8% 11.1%

isasson
10 years ago

Can u post the other side of this list? the biggest increase