Chicago White Sox Top 28 Prospects

Below is an analysis of the prospects in the farm system of the Chicago White Sox. Scouting reports were compiled with information provided by industry sources as well as my own observations. This is the second year we’re delineating between two anticipated relief roles, the abbreviations for which you’ll see in the “position” column below: MIRP for multi-inning relief pitchers, and SIRP for single-inning relief pitchers.
A quick overview of what FV (Future Value) means can be found here. A much deeper overview can be found here.
All of the numbered prospects below also appear on The Board, a resource the site offers featuring sortable scouting information for every organization. It has more details than this article and integrates every team’s list so readers can compare prospects across farm systems. It can be found here.
| Rk | Name | Age | Highest Level | Position | ETA | FV |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bryan Ramos | 20.1 | A+ | 3B | 2024 | 45+ |
| 2 | Jose Rodriguez | 21.0 | AA | SS | 2023 | 45 |
| 3 | Colson Montgomery | 20.2 | A | 3B | 2026 | 45 |
| 4 | Oscar Colas | 23.6 | A+ | RF | 2025 | 45 |
| 5 | Romy Gonzalez | 25.6 | MLB | SS | 2022 | 45 |
| 6 | Jared Kelley | 20.6 | A | SIRP | 2025 | 40+ |
| 7 | Wes Kath | 19.7 | A | 3B | 2026 | 40+ |
| 8 | Caleb Freeman | 24.2 | AA | SIRP | 2022 | 40 |
| 9 | Jimmy Lambert | 27.4 | MLB | SP | 2022 | 40 |
| 10 | Sean Burke | 23.4 | A+ | MIRP | 2025 | 40 |
| 11 | Norge Vera | 21.9 | R | SP | 2025 | 40 |
| 12 | Matthew Thompson | 21.7 | A+ | SP | 2024 | 40 |
| 13 | Andrew Dalquist | 21.5 | A+ | SP | 2024 | 40 |
| 14 | Lenyn Sosa | 22.3 | AA | 2B | 2023 | 40 |
| 15 | Kohl Simas | 22.3 | A | SP | 2025 | 40 |
| 16 | Harvin Mendoza | 23.2 | A+ | 1B | 2024 | 40 |
| 17 | Yoelqui Céspedes | 24.6 | AA | CF | 2023 | 40 |
| 18 | Yolbert Sanchez | 25.1 | AA | SS | 2025 | 40 |
| 19 | Jake Burger | 26.0 | MLB | 1B | 2022 | 40 |
| 20 | Cristian Mena | 19.3 | A | SP | 2024 | 35+ |
| 21 | Kade McClure | 26.2 | AAA | SP | 2022 | 35+ |
| 22 | Davis Martin | 25.3 | AA | SP | 2023 | 35+ |
| 23 | Jonathan Stiever | 25.0 | MLB | SP | 2022 | 35+ |
| 24 | Gil Luna Jr. | 22.7 | A+ | MIRP | 2025 | 35+ |
| 25 | Hunter Schryver | 27.1 | AAA | SIRP | 2022 | 35+ |
| 26 | James Beard | 21.6 | A | CF | 2024 | 35+ |
| 27 | Tanner McDougal | 19.1 | R | SP | 2026 | 35+ |
| 28 | Yoan Aybar | 24.8 | AA | SIRP | 2022 | 35+ |
Other Prospects of Note
Grouped by type and listed in order of preference within each category.
More Relievers
Anderson Severino, LHP
Bennett Sousa, LHP
Tyler Johnson, RHP
Jason Bilous, RHP
Theo Denlinger, RHP
Zach Cable, RHP
Brooks Gosswein, LHP
Garrett Schoenle, LHP
Severino signed as a minor league free agent after spending more than a half decade in the Yankees system. He has big time arm strength but scary control. Sousa is more consistent but his stuff isn’t as nasty, a tier below what I typically think of as the second lefty out of a bullpen. Both Severino and Sousa have been in the big leagues this year, which is an indication of the health-related misfortune the org has dealt with already this season. Johnson will also likely be called upon in 2022. He’s a right-handed version of Severino, walk-prone and with gigantic arm strength. Bilous is repeating Double-A as a 24-year-old after he had a 6.51 ERA in 2021. He is on the White Sox 40-man, sits about 93 mph and has an above-average changeup. He’s a spot starter right now but his best long-term fit is as a fastball/changeup reliever. The rest of this group comes from the 2021 draft. Denlinger, a self-taught blacksmith, was hurt a lot at his first college, then transferred to Bradley University and showed big arm strength there, sitting in the mid-90s with a good breaking ball but a really weird, short-striding delivery. Cable was breathing fire at 95-98 mph this spring but he also has rough command and a 40 slider. Gosswein, the club’s fourth rounder, has a good looking delivery and curveball but his fastball lacks explosion and sits about 91-93. Schoenle is a lanky three-pitch lefty who lives in the low-90s. Schoenle and Cable were signed as undrafted free agents.
Catching Depth
Carlos Pérez, C
Xavier Fernández, C
Adam Hackenberg, C
Pérez and Fernández are upper-level depth types who have good feel to hit. Pérez has 40 bat speed and a 30 arm, but he’s a good receiver. He has a 10-to-1 ball-in-play-to-swing-and-miss ratio so far this year. Fernández’s contact rates are merely above average but he has more juice than Pérez. He’s repeating Double-A. Hackenberg is a strong, athletic catcher who had considerable profile in high school, then shared time behind the dish at Clemson because teammate Jonathan French is also pretty good. Any of this group could be a passable third catcher on a 40-man.
Wilber Sanchez
Wilber Sanchez, SS
The 20-year-old Sanchez is a twitchy little middle infielder who could be an above-average defensive shortstop or plus second baseman, but the bat is light and it’s unlikely he develops more than 30-grade raw power. He’s a lot of fun to watch and could be a bench utility guy if he hits enough.
Power-Over-Hit Types
Luis Mieses, OF
Micker Adolfo, DH
DJ Gladney, 3B
Wilfred Veras, 3B
Misael Gonzalez, RF
Benyamin Bailey, DH
This is a pretty self-explanatory group. Everyone here has water-carrying raw power, but in many cases, they have approach issues that limit their ability to make enough contact to really get to it in games. Mieses has the best pure feel to hit of this group, and a huge, impressive frame, but he swings at everything. Adolfo was outrighted this year and seems like a fit in Asia. Gladney (who signed baseballs for my cousin’s kids as they caught him exiting the bathroom this spring — they really appreciated it) hits the ball in the air consistently but ran a K% over 40% in 2021. Veras and Gonzalez put up big numbers on the complex last year but beware of their approaches. Bailey’s athleticism and explosiveness have dialed down.
System Overview
This is the worst system in baseball but it got that way because the White Sox graduated (or traded players for) guys who now comprise the core of a contender. It’s less an indictment of the club’s ability to acquire and develop talent and more an indication that they’ve done a good job. They may be outmuscled at the trade deadline, though, as most other clubs have more ammunition to make a deal, and the team’s array of early-season injuries make it more likely that the Sox will need to make some. This club is not very proactive on the margins and doesn’t scoop up players with workable traits who become freely available via waivers. That’s the way clubs like the Rays and Dodgers find their John Curtisses and Phil Bickfords and manifest upper-level depth out of thin air in a way the White Sox badly need to right now.
New amateur scouting director Mike Shirley has now shepherded two drafts, both featuring lots of early picks in the region of the country where he lives. They’ve taken a shot on an over-slot prep arm in each of his two drafts (Jared Kelley, Tanner McDougal), but it’s probably too early to start finding meaningful patterns in the org’s behavior here, since it’s been just two drafts and one of them was only five rounds.
Internationally, the White Sox continue to be more active in the Cuban market than most other teams, waiting to commit their pool space later than most clubs in pursuit of whichever Cuban players come free later on. This strategy often leads them to put their eggs in just a few baskets during a signing period, but it’s worked out pretty well, and Bryan Ramos, Oscar Colas, and Norge Vera are the next potential wave.
Eric Longenhagen is from Catasauqua, PA and currently lives in Tempe, AZ. He spent four years working for the Phillies Triple-A affiliate, two with Baseball Info Solutions and two contributing to prospect coverage at ESPN.com. Previous work can also be found at Sports On Earth, CrashburnAlley and Prospect Insider.
Tanner Banks would like a word.
Just one small note: Luna was their 9th rounder, not 7th.
Indeed – updated, will be updated on The Board shortly. Thanks!
On the heels of an 8 game losing streak, this is kicking me when I am down.
The whole division sucks and you’re 2.5 games out of first. There’s your pick-me-up
That’s what is keeping me going, but the goal was a deep playoff run or a World Championship and that’s looking less likely.
They have played 6 games this year where they have at least as many errors as runs. It’s been really tough to watch and I may just need to take a week or two off.
Giolito, Kopech, and Cease will be fine, and Lance Lynn will be back. A lot of their hitters are hurt or underperforming by a lot–Robert, Grandal, and Jimenez won’t be this bad. Vaughn looks like he’s taken a step forward, and Anderson’s bat (although not his defense) seems like it’s still working (something that’s always worth monitoring). And Moncada will be back. It’ll be okay.
Keuchel is washed, though.
They did sign him a year after he posted a 24% HR/FB rate. And he was going into his age 32 season. But amazingly, this is the highest K/9 he’s had since he joined the White Sox.
The whole concept of signing Dallas Keuchel was flawed, on every level. If you sign a guy who is putting the ball on the ground 60% of the time you need Carlos Correa or Francisco Lindor behind you…and definitely not Tim Anderson.
Eloy out until ~ASG is definitely non- optimal in aid of getting on track. Starting to wonder if he’s becoming a perennial injury magnet or if this is just a young player still acclimating to the rigors of MLB life. Hoping it’s the latter but fearing it’s the former.
This system is akin to getting a flat tire and finding out that there’s no spare in the trunk, so one just has to keep on driving in the hopes that the tire re-inflates itself a bit.
But there is a patch and spray fill that are over 15 years old. Big gamble…
Eh, tough to complain when the cupboard’s bare for all the right reasons. Their PD seems to have been pretty darn good for several years now and they’ve had a good stretch of getting value from guys who don’t rank super high on prospect lists and getting darn near max-value out of their pitching talent.
I just don’t think the “They graduated a lot of guys” is a great excuse, when there are a good number of teams with better MLB clubs and much better farm systems.
The way you describe their processes in pro scouting (aren’t proactive in adding depth), amateur scouting (they take the guys near where the scouting director lives, plus taking older prep players that the best-in-industry clubs shy away from), and international scouting (they wait for a Cuban to defect, otherwise they trade away pool space to get out of paying the buy-outs for Nate Jones/Wellington Castillo) paints a really negative picture. And you’re the one trying to be nice about it, the fans aren’t as forgiving.
Agreed. I think when you get to the top of the division like they did, it’s important to be sharp on the margins (adding depth) to help stay there. Especially since that shortcoming is magnified with the rash of injuries they currently have. It kinda gives off the vibe that “ok cool, we’re at the top of the division now, we’ll be here for five years because most other teams are rebuilding.” Well…the Twins and Tigers may be in various stages of rebuilding, but they’re a much more aggressive organization with a much better farm system.
And the Tigers are likely a contender after this year. Miggy comes off the books after next year so they have $30M (or more if they believe now is the time) to make a splash.
Very solid points MP. The fact this franchise’s payroll has jumped by $70M in the blink of an eye is suggestive of its front office’s true (only?) intended path to improvement. Obviously ownership’s willingness to spend big is a good thing for Sox fans, but relying on outbidding the league for middle-tier free agents in perpetuity is a dangerous game. Reinsdorf is 86 years old and can’t take it with him so perhaps he firmly resides in two-middle-fingers-up territory from here on out. Knowing that for certain would lessen my concern.
Because the Sox were/are in win-now, they already used up Vaughn and Crochet’s rookie eligibility. For most (all?) MLB teams, Vaughn would still be prospect eligible and I believe Crochet is the only pick from the 2020 draft who is no longer prospect eligible (though obviously he’s now getting TJ). Add those two to this list, and it looks a bit better, especially at the top.
Depth is an issue as you point out and that’s due in part to the teams curious international approach — though that has improved slightly in recent years — but still not nearly as strong as basically every other team not named Baltimore.
Couldn’t agree more. Their 40-man is good and fairly deep (though they leave a lot to be desired defensively), but nowhere near GREAT, and they should be if this is the state of their farm system. With a farm like this you should look more like the Braves who have an even better, younger roster and look to be good for years to come, giving them time to improve their farm during that contention window. This team could look downright mediocre in a year or two and I don’t see the farm improving enough to buttress it.
The Braves managed to dupe two young players into underpaid and terrible contracts, respectively. That helps.
I want to argue with this, but I think you’re right. It’s just so striking because they executed one of the most successful rebuilds in recent memory. But they did it almost entirely through scouting other teams’ farm systems. Moncada, Jimenez, Giolito, Cease, Kopech, and Lynn (indirectly via Dunning) came from just three trades. Abreu and Robert were signed as Cuban defectors. They signed some good free agents, but Vaughn and Aaron Bummer are the only guys who were drafted (or signed as an international teenager) who is good (Madrigal, potentially, but potentially not; also, he’s a Cub and AJ Pollock is hurt; maaaaybe Crochet).
To be fair, a lot of the draft stuff isn’t entirely the fault of the current guy heading up that department. The worst stuff happened earlier. In 2015 and 2016, the best players drafted were Seby Zavala, Zack Collins, Danny Mendick, and Jimmy Lambert, and they are way ahead of anyone else on those draft classes. And those guys are only big leaguers on a technicality.
The big issues are, as far as I can tell:
1) The Kath and Kelley picks became huge misses almost immediately (which does happen, but maybe not two years in a row).
2) Trading a lot of potentially useful players (Luis Gonzalez, Codi Heuer, Connor Pilkington, Nick Madrigal)
3) Garret Crochet is hurt (which happens, but also, most guys from his draft class have not come close to hitting the majors yet, so that actually looks like a success)
Luis Gonzalez wasn’t a trade, they put him on release waivers rather than putting him on the 60-day IL so they wouldn’t have to give an extra 1 player a league minimum salary. Which is…. uh….
Calling a guy who was drafted less than a year ago a “huge miss” is, in fact, a take.
I think we were all just wrong before. I thought he had a chance of being a Kyle Seager, Mike Lowell type guy before, and the tools he has do support that possibility still. But I don’t think there are any realistic comps for him anymore because it looks like a 20-grade hit tool, and guys like that don’t make it to the majors very often.
Eh, they’re second round picks, and one’s battled shoulder problems.
Even if you consider their prospect status fully baked, I’d never judge an organization on the results of two second-round picks.
What I’ll give the front office credit for: They are very good at picking the right players to sign to extensions, and getting those players to sign, both with this generation of players and the previous generation. They nailed the Sale, Eaton, and Quintana (even if Eloy is basically Mark Trumbo) trades. Ethan Katz seems like a very good pitching coach.
Abreu and Robert were consensus top international prospects, few doubted their ability. The White Sox had the relationships to get the deals done, to their credit, but that’s at the expense of getting deals done with good prospects from any other country. They are completely closed off from a Jose Altuve or Jose Ramirez type who signs for nothing and produces a ton of value. Vaughn was likewise a top draft prospect, no one doubted he could hit. You can’t say those aren’t wins, but it took very little special acumen relative to what other front offices routinely do.
It’s hard to find what else they are good at, other that timing this window well and spending more on payroll than the cheapest division in baseball.
I think it’s a tad harsh since it’s a mix of a number of things. As I stated previously, Vaughn and Crochet would be on almost every teams prospect list but the Sox rushed them for win-now reasons (right or wrong).
They were also unlucky in that the rebuild occurred during two pretty poor drafts (16 and 17) AND the Sox never bottomed out to the point where they picked top 3 for a few years. The Sox highest pick during the rebuild was #3 in 2019 and while I like Vaughn, I like Rutschman and Witt a lot more and they go 1/2. The 2016 draft they flubbed (Collins) but that draft looks brutal right now. The 2017 draft they picked Burger, and while injuries derailed him, that also doesn’t appear to be a talent rich draft. They play it very safe in 2018 taking Madrigal, but even this draft isn’t crazy talent rich though obviously having Kelenic or Rodriguez approaching or on the MLB team would change things a bit.
The Sox have struggled to develop position players, though Anderson is probably one of the better success stories from a ‘raw tools’ to ‘All-Star short stop’ stories in the game. And they do seem to max out pitching.
I think were they should get the most scorn is their international spending and development, but they broke the bank for Robert and things have legitimately gotten better there in the last few years (evident of the list above, even if it is Cuban heavy, its a strategy that’s working).
The Sox haven’t gotten many late round picks to pop and turn into solid major leaguers other than Engle (now 30) and maybe Mendick (who is more of a AAAA player). The roster is an (imo impressive) collection of high end international signings or first round draft picks/over slot early round guys (Cease). Sure they aren’t the Dodgers (who is?) or the Rays (who would have traded Moncada/Anderson/Giolito etc in 4 for 1 deals years ago now), they’re more in line with the Brewers or Phillies (which is a much worse outcome) and I don’t think the Brewers would get much push back for having a poor system.
Yes, this. All the guys they acquired turned out well, but almost non of the high draft picks from the years they were bad have panned out. Some have been injured and some just haven’t developed, but it is shocking how little they have benefitted so far from all those high picks.
One thing that I keep coming back to is that most draft picks bust. In fact, most high draft picks bust. So it’s not entirely fair to say they got nothing out of it, without remembering that the baseline is so low. For example, the skeptic might note that Shane Baz, Jake Burger, and Nick Pratto were all picked directly after Jake Burger in 2017. But since the picks immediately before him were Austin Beck, Pavin Smith, Adam Haseley, Keston Hiura, and Jo Adell, it’s a little more understandable. And while the fact that they got basically no one out of the 2015 and 2016 drafts is bad, that was also a long time ago.
All that said, having two high-profile second round picks (Kath and Kelley) that require such a dramatic reassessment so soon is not normal. With one, you chalk it up to bad luck. With two, it’s hard to rationalize it away. Maybe they should just stick to picking polished college guys from here on out.
Jake Burger was drafted directly after Jake Burger?
Whoops, that should have been Trevor Rogers.
Sure, but this is a longstanding problem through several regimes going back decades after I was spoiled by consecutive years of Jack McDowell, Robin Ventura, Frank Thomas, and Alex Fernandez with other drafted players turning out good as well.
It is especially bad with position players. If you go back to 1990 after that run of successes ended and look at guys who were drafted and developed by the White Sox and went on to post 10 WAR over their career (with any team, they just had to be drafted by the White Sox and spend all their minor league career with them), you have Tim Anderson, Joe Crede, Aaron Rowand, and Mike Cameron. There might be one or two others I am forgetting, but it is a very short list. There were guys they drafted and traded away before they were fully developed and guys who were drafted elsewhere and acquired by them later, but they have been very poor at identifying guys and then developing those same guys for a very long time. I don’t know what kind of record other teams have if you apply the same criteria, but it has to be better than 4 guys in 30 years.
cough*Marcus Semien*cough
Honestly building through prospect trades seems faster. More data, closer to the bigs, etc.
It’s why Id like the Rule 5 to be anyone under 22 not on the 26 man roster. Rebuilds would take nowhere near as long.
This may actually be almost as good as the Angels’ system.
The bad: I think there are only single digit actual prospects in this system–the Top 4, and Norge Vera are the only players that definitely look like real prospects. Everyone else looks like an org guy or, if they’re lucky, the kind of player who hangs around on the 40-man until they run out of options and get DFA’d. Kath and Kelley, in particular, look so much worse than I remembered them. I just don’t see paths for them or Cespedes, Sean Burke and Dalquist are never going to throw strikes, Mendoza looks like he belongs down with Adolfo and Benyamin Bailey, etc.
The good: I’m way more convinced that Oscar Colas is a legitimate 45 after reading this. He’s only had 70 PAs in the minors and he had a long layoff but it sure seems like the scouting report backs him up making good quality contact. I think he looks like a possible 2-win right fielder, which isn’t a star but also is a guy who will be fine if you have to play him every day. I was also very skeptical on Colson Montgomery and Bryan Ramos, and I’m less so now. Both of them have high bust probability but there’s enough upside to keep an eye on them. Rodriguez looks like a possible solution at second base, and I still like Vera a lot, despite the risk involved with a pitcher that far away from the majors. That group is probably similar to the Detmers / Bachman / Paris / Ky Bush / Alejandro Hidalgo group from the Angels, although risk profile is totally different.
I think this organization has a lot of bust potential, and the “good” is definitely consolidated into a limited number. And based on previous draft/sign guys who have moved through this org, it feels almost every single one will “bust” while here. If a handful to hit, then it is not so bad. (One rotation SP out of Vera, Thompson, Dalquist, Burke, McDougal, Simas, Kelley, Mena; 1 actual 6th SP out of Lambert, McClure, Stiever, Bilous; 1 3B bat out of Ramos, Montgomery, Kath, Burger; and cheap 2B/UT depth in one or 2 of Rodriguez, Romy, Sosa, Yolbert,
The OF depth that used to be in this system in now consolidated into Colas and Cespedes. (Even with Adolfo, Rutherford, Basabe all still in the system,
I think that Eric was grading a bit on a curve here. This looks more like a Top 20, and at least 10 of them are 35+’s. But…there’s enough in 5 or 6 other prospects that I think it’s not completely barren. Which is where I thought it was earlier.
Bal: 375
TB: 362
Pitt: 326
Cleveland: 319.5
CHC: 271.5
AZ: 255.5
NYY: 253
SF: 248.5
Boston: 237.5
Det: 221
Min: 205
Cin: 194
Oak: 178.5
Tor: 148.5
Phi: 141
Mil: 137
Colorado: 112
LAA: 79
CHWS: 60.5
Angels gang our day is here!!!!
Apologies for the pedantry, but the Bryan Ramos writeup includes the word “wreckless,” which I assume was supposed to be “reckless.”
As an editor, I appreciate both your pedantry and keen eye. Goof is fixed.
No way, his swings just do not cause wrecks, that is all.
“This club is not very proactive on the margins and doesn’t scoop up players with workable traits who become freely available via waivers.” This to me is the biggest indictment of Hahn and his front office. Being able to identify talent, fix said talent and turn that talent into effective MLB players is something the Sox have been unable to do. I truly believe the Sox have the worst major league scouting department in baseball.
Not being able to do so coincides with $20M of their 2022 payroll being tied to the likes Josh Harrison, Leury Garcia, and Joe Kelly. While still having enormous holes at 2B and SP.
When you work for a team that will never be players at the top of the free agent market, you have to be privy on the margins. Hahn has shown no capabilities to do so.
That may be true, but at least he traded Semien and Tatis Jr. before they got too expensive. And then he (perhaps forcibly) hired a manager willing to do the dirty work no one before dreamed of doing, which was bat Leury Garcia in the No. 3 spot in the order. That probably isn’t possible without giving Semien and Tatis Jr. away for basically nothing.
Interesting to see Ramos described as a free/erratic swinger given his decent walk rates up to this year. If it’s an issue I wonder if he’ll need to move up before there’s any chance of addressing it. Tough to tell a guy his approach is a problem while he’s hitting .418 with power.
Cespedes was Successful in A+ and AA, but did not play well in AZFL. But I agree. Hell, Adolfo hit well in AA/AAA last year
I think Adolfo’s value is summed up by the fact that 29 teams passed on claiming him. Same with Rutherford.
Yeah, I really don’t get how anybody could be on the Adolfo bandwagon when 30 GM’s decided he wasn’t worth a 40 man roster spot when they could have had him for free.
Cespedes swings at everything. I realize that the White Sox have had surprising success with this archetype but it is not wise to bet on it.
The write up for Ramos sounds better than a 45 and his Top 20 ZiPs status makes him sound a lot better than a number of 50s. A toolsy guy with performance is about all one can ask for. If I hadn’t seen the 45 I’d have guessed more like 55. It seems like he’s being penalized for weirdness.
I don’t believe this was the intent but the write-up for Ramos gave me the impression that there was a preconceived notion that Ramos had plate discipline issues and even though the numbers don’t fully support it, he was docked for it anyways. I think it’s kind of hard to tell at his current level if he has those issues or not because the pitchers just aren’t advanced enough to consistently take advantage of holes in batters’ swings.
Ya it sounds that way
A non-miniscule walk rate in the low-minors doesn’t mean a prospect isn’t a free-swinger and/or doesn’t make bad swing decisions. This is where scouting looks tell you a lot more than just looking at a guy’s BB/K. Hitting involves a lot more events that don’t create a measurable result (i.e., results on pitches that don’t end a plate appearance) than ones that do, and awful hacks that take a player to a 1 or 2-strike count don’t get recorded in a statline. IOW, unless other evaluators are saying things directly contradicting it, I’m more inclined to credit the writeup here than to reject it because dude had a BB% over 10 last year.
Agreed with slamcactus. Also, Low-A pitchers aren’t known for throwing tons of strikes, especially to physically maxed-out dudes, so you don’t have to have a great approach to walk a decent amount
The write-up is much more important than the grades to me. I think the 45+ FV is just baking in more bust potential.
The write-up doesn’t specify the reason for unusual bust potential other than weird swing selection.
Small editing note: Kelley’s blurb has a reference to “what he looked like in college”, I believe he was drafted outta HS?
Simas is the son of former MLB reliever Bill Simas, I believe. He’s blowing away low-A hitters so far, I imagine he’ll get promoted soon.
Perez has shown a lot more pop on paper last year and now this year as well than he has in the past. He’s struck out just once in 71 PA. I think third catcher might be light, that much contact with even just 40 pop and good receiving sounds like at least a backup C, maybe low-end regular C?
I’m not sure I like the “they graduated the core” excuse. I know their farm wasn’t going to reach the levels it was at when they were making a bunch of selloff trades, but to be last in baseball is still an indictment of the front office. Every team graduates prospects, and sure they can’t re-stock with trades, but their drafting and development has sucked of late.