Does Ronald Acuña Jr. Help His Teammates See More Fastballs?

Ronald Acuña Jr.
Isaiah J. Downing-USA TODAY Sports

As somebody who grew up playing baseball and continued to play through college, I’m familiar with all the old school adages that this game has. As I tried to develop my own abilities, I needed to figure out which were true, which were false, and which had some grey area. Swing down, for example, is not necessarily what hitters do in practice, and I had to relearn that. Then there is the “squish the bug” cue for your back foot. That actually makes most hitters get too spinny and reinforces an incorrect interaction with the ground. These are just a few hitting examples. But for this piece, I’m going to focus on stealing bases.

When an aggressive base stealer is on first, they command a level of mental real estate in a pitcher’s mind, though it’s important to note not every pitcher is the same. Some are more equipped to handle a runner than others. That could be due to a good pickoff move, quick time to the plate, or simply because a guy remains unfazed no matter the situation. This is all common knowledge. What isn’t, and what I’ve been pondering as one of the grey area tropes, is whether pitchers change their pitch mix when there is a threat to run. In general, I always thought this was true, but I never went back and looked at any data to confirm it. But we live in a baseball world with solid data accessibility, and luckily, this question can be answered thanks to Baseball Savant.

What makes this relevant is the conversation around Ronald Acuña Jr. and his potential impact on what pitches his teammates see when he is on base. To be clear, this exercise can be done for any player or across the league, but I’m using Acuña as an example because nobody has stolen more bases (or attempted more steals) than him this season. The context of the team matters a ton here, too: If Acuña creates a competitive advantage (even if it’s small) by being a threat to run, then he should absolutely exercise that.

The theory or expectation is that if a pitcher is concerned a runner might take a bag, they’ll want to give their catcher a better chance to catch that would-be base stealer, and the best pitch to do so with is a fastball. Breaking and offspeed pitches move in different directions and create more room for error on a transfer.

Let’s get to the data. I’ve chosen an arbitrary cutoff point of 100 pitches seen when Acuña was on base. That left me with three talented hitters: Ozzie Albies, Austin Riley, and Matt Olson. Those three all typically hit in the three spots after Acuña. I’ll start by showing you how pitchers attack each of them overall:

ATL Hitters Pitch Mix
Pitch Matt Olson Ozzie Albies Austin Riley
Fastball 57.5 53.5 58.3
Breaking 27.7 25.9 31.7
Offspeed 14.8 20.5 10.0

This is just to create a baseline for how each of these hitters is attacked. Albies sees the most offspeed pitches, Riley sees the most breaking balls, and Olson sits in between each of them in every category.

Next, here’s what each of these hitters see when there is only a runner on first base, not including Acuña:

Not Acuña on 1st
Pitch Matt Olson Ozzie Albies Austin Riley
Fastball 56.1 56.2 56.4
Breaking 27.1 20.6 32.2
Offspeed 16.8 23.2 11.4
Total 298 185 239

Comparing to their baselines, only Albies sees an increase in fastball usage when there is a runner on first. Both Olson and Riley see slight decreases, but nothing significant. For Riley, breaking balls are the most effective way to get him out, so you might not want to stray from that plan too much. The same holds for Olson and offspeed pitches.

Let’s shift to when only Acuña is on first base with no other runners:

Acuña on 1st
Pitch Matt Olson Ozzie Albies Austin Riley
Fastball 63.9 63.8 57.9
Breaking 24.0 17.2 28.5
Offspeed 12.1 19 13.6
Total 263 185 102

That’s a hefty difference compared to when other runners are on first, or in any situation for Olson and Albies. Riley’s mix is anything but crazy, looking similar to the other scenarios already presented, but he also has seen far fewer pitches than the other two with only Acuña on first. And he may not have seen a pitch group change, but the share of sinkers shoots up a ton from 20% at baseline to 27.5% with Acuña on. I can attest that four-seamers are much easier to catch and throw than running sinkers, but that doesn’t make it an advantage for Riley.

Either way, the case for Albies and Olson is undeniable: they’re seeing more fastballs compared to the other two scenarios. That’s a good advantage for both, since they’re best against that pitch group. It’d be nice if they were clearly hitting better because of the higher fastball rate, but we can’t just assume so.

Now let’s look at each player’s performance in the presented three scenarios:

wOBA/xwOBA Splits
Player wOBA/xwOBA All wOBA/xwOBA No Acuña wOBA/xwOBA Acuña
Matt Olson .401/.390 .288/.363 .509/.459
Ozzie Albies .349/.333 .564/.471 .380/.312
Austin Riley .355/.365 .396/.377 .456/.362

If you were expecting fully conclusive numbers here, sadly, that is just not how this sport works.

Let’s go player by player. Olson has had a strong preference for Acuña on first versus any other Atlanta position player. He has also been better than his overall baseline from an expected and actual outcomes standpoint. Albies is a bit different. His wOBA with Acuña is better than his baseline, but his xwOBA is .021 ticks lower, and for some reason, he has been absurdly good with non-Acuña runners on first. Is this a second or third time through the order thing? Could it just be random noise? It’s not clear. For Riley, his wOBA is also significantly higher with Acuña than the other two scenarios, but his xwOBA stays steady across the board. I wonder if the favorable gap between wOBA and xwOBA when Acuña is on for all three has anything to do with him also taking up mental real estate in infielders’ heads, but that’s a question for a different piece.

There are plenty more ways to analyze this situation, but to be honest, I was most interested in answering the question of whether a pitch mix change exists or not. For the hitters who are up the most when he’s on base, there is no question it has. But I’ll continue to stress that this is highly context dependent. What we see for Acuña may not be the case for other players. For now, at least we have an answer: Acuña is most likely helping his teammates see more heaters. What they do with those pitches, though, is completely up to them.





Esteban is a contributing writer at FanGraphs. One of his main hobbies is taking dry hacks every time he sees a bat.

15 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
3 years ago

This is absolutely awesome stuff, Esteban!

Really cool to see data-driven analysis of what we take as “givens.”

Urban Shocker's JockstrapMember since 2020
3 years ago

Seems to be an error in the “Matt Olsen” column in the “Not Acuna on 1st” table, unless I’m misunderstanding what this shows. If my arithmetic is correct, those values add up to 109.8% of his pitch mix.

Urban Shocker's JockstrapMember since 2020
3 years ago

*Olson

Urban Shocker's JockstrapMember since 2020
3 years ago

Very cool!

With a sample size this small, there could always be some switch-hitting weirdness going on with Ozzie given how much better he is as a righty. Not sure if that’s something you could easily split out in the numbers.

MikeSMember since 2020
3 years ago

There are a lot of possible confounding variables and relatively small sample sizes would accentuate that.

6 run game in the 8th? Pitcher is less likely to care if somebody gets a good jump.

Two outs as opposed to none out. Pitcher can focus more on the hitter and not care as much about a SB.

Handedness splits might play into both hitter succes like you said, and pitch selection. As could each particular pitcher’s arsenal.

The catcher has some influence too. Ivan Rodriguez was famous (maybe unfairly) for calling for more fastballs with men on base.

Jake SchultzMember since 2020
3 years ago

I will absolutely read every article you write about proving/debunking tropes.

tdees40
3 years ago

My question after watching Acuna all year is how much his xwOBA/wOBA underperformance is based on the fact that the dude just straight up refuses to leg out infield grounders. Just in the last two games there’s been ~2 hits he could have gotten if he had ran all out.

CousinNicky
3 years ago
Reply to  tdees40

Probably none, the guy is coming off of major knee surgery and is 113th out 512 people in sprint speed to 1b. He does however lead all of baseball with 23 barrel outs at 23 with the next closest player at 19. The average player has 4-5 but Ronald hits the ball harder than nearly everyone so he should have more but it he had a league average rate 0.4% instead of his 0.9%( Tatis Jr and Vlad JR also have 0.9%) he would be sitting around 12 barrel outs meaning he should have 11 more XBH

hughduffy
3 years ago
Reply to  tdees40

Of Acuña’s 63 batted balls this year with an estimated wxOBA over .500, all but 4 were over 90 mph, and all but 16 were over 100 mph in exit velocity. For classification purposes, there were 26 line drives, 23 fly balls, and 14 ground balls. The average wxOBA on these balls hit into play was .870.

My answer: none of his wxOBA/wOBA underperformance is due to not legging out infield grounders. Most of the underperformance is due to the fact that he hits the crap out of the ball so often.

If you look at a spray chart of his outs hit at over 90 mph, launch angle less than 45 degrees, you see clusters on the right side of the infield, on the second base side, and one ball snagged by a first baseman. Then almost everything else is out by the outfield fence.

He’s got fifteen outs on batted balls over 110 mph, because they were hit right at the third baseman, shortstop, second baseman, or left fielder or center fielder. The average wxOBA on those balls was .664.

In contrast, on the 310 balls put into play with an estimated wOBA under .500, Acuña has 60 singles, 6 doubles, 2 triples, 1 home run, 1 sac fly, 3 reach on error, and 237 fielding outs. The average wxOBA on these balls was .192. If my math is right, he’s outperforming the expected batting average on these balls by about 30 points, so he’s running out infield singles that others wouldn’t get.

I’ve read elsewhere that this year, the team told Acuña to save his legs for the times when it really matters, and that they’ll trust him to know when it is time to turn on the afterburners. If that gets him a full 162 game season, I’m all for it.

NathanMember since 2018
3 years ago

I looked into this a while ago and found that the wRC+ of a hitter isn’t improved if the person on base infront of them is an elite basestealer (as opposed to any other guy on 1B) when I controlled for needed factors. This was contrary to what I expected and my theory was that the base stealer is also distracting to the batter and that counteracts the benefit.

hughduffy
3 years ago
Reply to  Nathan

Is it possible that there are two buckets of batters? Ones who are easily distracted, and for whom it is a detriment, and others who aren’t as easily distracted?

I ask because I know that some teams don’t have base runners try to run in front of certain batters because they know it distracts them at the plate.

Ivan_GrushenkoMember since 2016
3 years ago
Reply to  Nathan

If this was pre-2023 the giant bases wouldn’t have been there

dukewinslowMember since 2020
3 years ago

I’d be interested to see Corbin Carroll as a control here, great baserunning without the steals, do the guys following him see more fastballs?

Ivan_GrushenkoMember since 2016
3 years ago

The pitch mix conclusions are awesome. The outcome numbers are noisy as the author says