FanGraphs Baseball

Sonny Gray Goes Back to Minnesota To Help Twins With Their Pitching Needs

Jesse Johnson-USA TODAY Sports

Who doesn’t love a reunion? Sonny Gray, who spent 2022 and 2023 with the Minnesota Twins, has agreed to return to the organization on a two-year, $55 million deal. According to ESPN’s Jeff Passan, the contract also comes with an opt-out clause after the first year.

The terms of this agreement are right there in the neighborhood of our median crowdsource estimation of two years, $52 million, a palatable deal for a pitcher who is 37 years old but has also never had a serious arm injury. Not counting 2020, Gray has made at least 24 starts in each of the last seven seasons. Dependability is an enticing quality for the Twins, who used 11 different starters in 2026. Pitching for the Boston Red Sox last year, Gray showed that his dependability doesn’t mean refusal to change. Coming off two straight years of 200 strikeouts and a strikeout rate north of 25%, Gray settled in at 149 and 21.8% in 2026. This didn’t impact his ability to record outs, though, as he traded strikeouts for non-threatening contact. His sinker — a trusty steed he’s ridden since the Obama administration — returned to form in a big way, producing a 56.6% groundball rate, highest in six years. Paired with a 15.4% whiff rate (a decent drop from its career average of 18.4%) Gray has clearly entered the phase of his baseball life where he’s okay with his sinker being put in play.

His sweeper remains a reliable swing-and-miss offering, and Gray also used his cutter much more with Boston, even though it got regularly lambasted. Jumping from a 12.6% usage rate in 2025 to 18.8% in ’26, Gray’s cutter had a .286 batting average against (.302 xBA), .446 slugging percentage (.482 xSLG), and .353 wOBA (.369 xwOBA). With a 7.9% putaway rate, it’s also not a pitch that gets him many strikeouts. In fact, just three of his 149 strikeouts in a Boston uniform came on the cutter. How the Twins instruct him to throw that pitch will be one of the more amusing subplots of his second stint in Minnesota. Read the rest of this entry »


RosterResource Chat – 11/19/26

Hey everyone! Let's get started…

Any idea how much revenue (net) the Brewers and Rays got from their post season runs? Enough that they will be more active in the FA market?

It's really hard to guess but it's estimated the Dodgers made something like $60-$70M last year just from the gate receipt pool that more heavily rewards teams the farther they advance. I'd guess the Brewers and Rays are at quite a bit less than that because the World Series didn't go seven games and wasn't as well attended in Tampa Bay, but regardless it's a big chunk of change, and the Brewers set a record for World Series merch sales. I don't think it'll impact their offseason plans too much, though, as the two teams just don't love to wade to deep into the free agent waters for reasons that go beyond money. I do think this could give more room/desire for extensions for young players like Caminero, Misiorowski, and Turang, though.

If you are David Stearns, how many SPs are you looking for this offseason? In other words, would you be handing rotation spots to Christian Scott and Zac Thornton?

My guess is that they add 2 starting pitchers who are capable of being either SP1, SP2, or SP3, which would allow them to pencil Christian Scott in as SP4 and have Thornton, Manaea, Senga, Tong, Santucci, etc. in the mix for the final spot. Senga/Manaea are capable of pitching out of the 'pen. All the young guys have options. They aren't necessarily handing Scott a spot in this case. But it does sound like he's penciled in.

We just saw the ZiPS Royals projections – what would your two big goals be if you were JJ Piccolo, and why?

A righty middle of the order bat and relief pitching. Even without Maikel Garcia, Witt-Jensen-Pasquantino-Caglianone is a really nice quartet but there's three lefties there, all of whom were below-average against LHP. I floated Alec Bohm as a fit for them yesterday, and his gap power would fit well in that park, and he mashes lefties. As for relievers, Steven Cruz was good down the stretch, Ferrer is a nice addition, and maybe Daniel Lynch IV is back in the 'pen with Bryce Miller acquired, but still a lot more that needs doing there. Having a go-to closer would be nice after a year of turmoil in the ninth.

The Nationals have had 5 different saves leaders over the last 7 seasons. What are the chances they finally lock something down there – say a Raisel, Kenley (or even a Pete Fairbanks) signing? If none of the above, who is the ideal internal option if everything were to fall into place?

My sense is that they know they failed last season by completely neglecting the bullpen, which can make a huge difference to a team's floor, and are going to make it a priority for 2027. The challenge will be that some of the top free agent relievers are getting big $ from better teams. So they'll have to add 3-4 reliable guys from the 2nd and 3rd tier of free agents, possibly the trade market, waiver wire, and MiLB free agency. Of course, getting lucky on some MiLB FAs/bounceback candidates will be key.

But it's going to be a combination of all that as opposed to last season when they didn't really seem to try. Kenley and Fairbanks make sense since it might be their only chance to continue closing. Or someone who's coming back from injury like Yimi Garcia or Joe Jimenez makes a lot of sense.

Does the flurry of signings we've already seen suggest that owners are confident that they will avoid a terrible, baseball-damaging loss of games next year?

I don't think so, I think they're just telling their front office heads to operate as usual because at the end of the day nobody knows what's going to happen, and you can't punt an entire offseason and then say "whoops I guess we're playing a full season, wasn't expecting that!" There's certainly a risk with deals like Jake Bauers' because he's not young and coming off his best season so his value is going to be concentrated to 2027-28 and we don't know how many games there'll be, but it's not like you have to pay him if there aren't games, anyway.

Do you foresee the Yankees adding another outfielder who can play CF to platoon with Jones?

Biggest question is whether they even trust Jones, or maybe Cody Bellinger, to make 70% of the starts in CF. I don't think that's the case, but it might be the only option if the plan is to give Jones regular playing time. Adding a RHH who is a very good defensive CF would make sense in that case.

Maybe Myles Straw or Tyrone Taylor would be a good complement in that scenario. Adding someone like Luis Robert Jr. doesn't make much sense if they want Spencer Jones to play more often than not and I don't think a healthy Robert is going to be a 4th OF/vsLHP guy at this point of his career.

I'm expecting the Yankees to make some trades. Not sure moving Jones would be part of that, but I also don't know if Bellinger/Jones/Judge is ideal OF alignment. So it wouldn't be a huge surprise if they added a legit CF.

Do useful-but-not-quite-worth-their-arb-value players ever have any trade value at this point in the year? I'm thinking Adell, Larbach, Ober, et al. Are these types automatic cuts or can they be moved somehow?

Yeah they don't have much value because their current team has very little leverage: you take the best you can get before the non-tender buzzer or you non-tender the guy and get nothing. For what it's worth, I'd be fairly surprised if any of the three was non-tendered, though I think a trade of any of the three (Adell is least likely, Ober is likeliest, maybe?) is plausible. But with any of the three (and any other arb-eligibles) you can tender them now and trade them later if you're fine having them on your team come Opening Day. The real lack of leverage comes with a guy like Jarren Duran, who I think has to be gone one way or the other tomorrow.

Are the Cubs really thinking Matt Shaw is a fix to their OF dilemma with Suzuki and Happ both departing? Or, is he a candidate to get traded for a SP like Gore?

They might trust him to be a good defensive OF. Not sure they trust him enough offensively to just hand him a corner OF spot, especially when they have 2 holes to fill out there. He's done enough to lock him in as a super-utility guy who gets 350-450 PAs. Other teams that value him as an everyday infielder might want to trade for him.

So, I'm sure the Cubs are listening, but won't sell low on someone with his upside because his role (if it stays the same) is super valuable on a contending team. TBD on if they think that upside would show up in 2027, in which case they might just hand him the RF job.

All else being equal, I feel like a lineup benefits more from upgrading an 80 OPS+ batter to a 90 OPS+ than they would from upgrading a 110 OPS+ guy with a 120 hitter. Am I right that from a pure math point it should be a wash, but in the real world scrub batters hurt team offense more than good hitter help?

Yeah, that should be a wash, though that's a better chat question for Ben on Mondays. It's also easier to make the 80 to 90 upgrade than the 110 to 120 upgrade because players are going to be clustered around the average.

Do you envision Murf Gray to get a similar path to Pittsburgh as Esmerlyn Valdez got? Feel like there's a slightly different need at 3B than the Pirates outfield last season, but they can be hesitant on prospects at times, so wanted to hear your thoughts

Things can change based on what the Pirates do this offseason. But, as things stand, I think he's on the same path as Valdez. If Gray continues to mash in AAA and Jacob Gonzalez gets a shot as the everyday 3B and struggles, I can see them making a move as early as mid-May.

Gonzalez was a former 1st Rd pick and will probably get a long enough leash to show why he was a 1st Rd pick and why the Pirates acquired him last season. But unless Gray takes a step back in 2027, it's going to be difficult to keep him in AAA for very long.

Do you expect to see any surprises when the non-tender lists are released?

I like to think I pay too much attention to be super surprised, though there are always a few unlikely ones that happen. So I think I will reframe this into "who are the highest-impact players that could be non-tendered?" To that my answer would be:

Jake Burger
Royce Lewis
Matt McLain
Jo Adell
Jarren Duran

Luis Gil
Tanner Houck
Camilo Doval
Tony Santillan

Jordan Beck and Jimmy Herget obvious non-tenders for the Rockies? Any others?

I think they tender contracts to all of their guys. Beck's $1.2MM projection isn't much at all even if he spends a lot of the season in AAA. He has options remaining and plenty of teams would be willing to take a flyer on him if he was available. Herget also won't make much ($2.4MM projection) and his unique delivery and prior success at Coors Field are probably enough to keep him. Not sure why he struggled last season but he's only 1 year removed from a 2.48 ERA in 80+ appearances. If he stays, I don't think they're counting on him being a high-leverage guy. But he could still be an innings-eater who matches up well against certain types of hitters.

The Giants have so many pitching holes and don’t seem like they want to spend much money. Are they going to use trades or just basically punt the season?

It's weird to me that all the reporting has said that they only see themselves paying for one starter when they pretty clearly need at least two, but they also don't want to break up the farm with trades. So 2027 is understandably going to be a transition year for them, though it wouldn't surprise me if they made a somewhat-significant SP add anyway, more so than Houser and Mahle last year. Not Skubal, Peralta, or King, but maybe someone like Holmes or Imanaga.

Atlanta obviously has a need for more starting pitching. How many cromulent starts do you see in their current organization, between Holmes, Elder, Smith-Shawver, Ritchie, Murphy, Lopez, the Spencers, and anyone else I haven't mentioned? Due to injury and stuff concerns, I can see a compelling case for *all* of those guys to move to the pen. Are there 60 starts in that list? More? Fewer?

A lot of options, but not much certainty outside of Chris Sale. And even Sale is going to be 38 next year. I'd feel pretty good about all of those guys you mentioned, as well as a few other prospects (Murphy, De Grandpre, Sinnard), stepping up and filling 2 spots. But adding a reliable SP2 and SP3 should be the priority. How much do they trust Didier Fuentes if moved to the rotation? Ideally, he'd stay in the bullpen. My guess is they add 2 reliable mid-rotation guys (someone like Tyler Mahle, Matthew Boyd, Nick Martinez) and then hope you get some bounce-backs from guys like Strider and Schwellenbach. Bullpen would remain a strength with Fuentes in either the closer or setup role.

Will the Angels and Mozeliak make any non-trivial moves this month or are they waiting for the sale to close and the new front office to be hired?

If the new POBO/GM was in place I think they'd have the authority from new ownership to make a not-insignificant move, but Mozeliak is in a very weird spot where he's on the way out and just holding down the fort until Kroenke comes in and officially makes the hire (which still has to happen before the sale goes through in January). Would be weird for Mo to commit anything beyond a one-year deal to a player and then say "okay peace out guys, it's your contract now!" Even a one-year deal for, I dunno, $10M+ doesn't seem likely pre-lockout.

If you had a gun to your head, what’s one move you are most confident the Yankees make this offseason. Framing it like this because it feels like there are a million different routes they can go at this point in time

It probably won't happen because it makes too much sense, but I've been saying that Luis Campusano will be one of their top targets this offseason. Campy and Austin Wells in a 52/48 split would be a very productive catching duo. Additional players might have to be included to balance out the deal, but I think one of Will Warren, Ryan Weathers, or Elmer Rodriguez would end up in the Padres' rotation as part of the deal.

CJ Abrams. What percent would you put on him a) being the Nat's Opening Day SS, b) being the Nat's Opening Day 2b, and c) being on another team's Opening Day roster entirely?

I'll say 5%, 75%, 20% off the top of my head. Would be a really weird pivot to create that friction last season with the midseason position switch only to move him back. As for a trade, I think it's tougher for the Nationals to get something resembling a franchise-altering package when he's a 2B and not a SS, so they lowered the chances just by moving him off short, I'd say. Though I'm not sure how many teams would want him as their SS anyway.

If both Adell and Duran are nontendered what kind of deal do you see them getting? I could see the Cubs trying to plug the OF holes with a couple 1/$10m deals to save cash for the rotation and hold out for Hartshorn to make it to the Bigs.

I think 1 yr, $10MM makes sense for Duran. Maybe 1 yr, $8MM for Adell. But those are close enough to their arb projection so trades are very possible. Wouldn't surprise me if there was interest on multi-year deals for either player, but both are capable of increasing their value heading into next offseason.

That will do it for today. We'll be off next week because of Thanksgiving. But we will continue to chat throughout the lockout, so we'll be back in 2 weeks. Enjoy the rest of your week.


Scott Boras Stanzas for Non-Scott Boras Free Agents

Jerome Miron-Imagn Images

According to one (1) story I recently found on Medium, published in 2025, poetry readership is on a steady rise. Alex Curle, the post’s author, offers a variety of explanations for why, but I am choosing to believe it’s because of baseball super agent slash poet laureate Scott Boras, a man of many talents.

The 74-year-old Boras, who has helped negotiate many of the largest contracts in sports history, has an annual tradition of greeting reporters at the offseason’s various gatherings (the GM Meetings, the Winter Meetings, etc.) with grandiose speeches about his clients who have reached free agency. They are usually full of eye-rolling puns and extremely flowery language. I personally think it’s one of the highlights of the year, mainly because it offers us a fascinating glimpse into Boras’ mind. While the stereotypical sports agent comes across as a sentient bottle of cologne driving a sports car and would likely list The Art of War or something from the self-help genre as their favorite book, Boras clearly has wide-ranging tastes.

This year, he dropped this banger when asked about Ryan Jeffers, who recently returned to the Twins after accepting the qualifying offer and is one of several Boras Corp clients whose contracts were up this winter. “A right-handed bat and a catcher, it’s kind of a constellation of talent. It’s something that creates a star-skill market for players at that position. A lot of teams are going, ‘Oh, Ryan is certainly something that will put more championship notches in my belt.’” Read the rest of this entry »


Dan Szymborski FanGraphs Chat 11/19/26

And here we are! I think. Unfortunately, I don't think question queueing works the same way it used to? I went back to the traditional structure format; from the comments, it was not popular to do it more chaotically and open.

How bad is the Garcia trade for the Royals? Can they possibly think Loftin is a good option to replace him?

I don't hate it as much as many do. Loftin's projection is at least interesting and Garcia does come with some injury risk. But I'm not sure Miller is really all that good, which is kinda the crux of the issue. I think they have the right idea, but I think I'd rather just go and sign a pitcher and keep Garcia.

I think this is a trade you make that feels better if it was March 20 (or a week before whenever we have a season). But it's a lot for a risky pitcher and a good reliever. Dunno.

As a Twins fan, I'm unsure how to react at this point.

They're actually spending money, so take the win I guess? Seems reasonable to be cautiously optimistic.

IIRC, ZiPS uses an in-house formula for projecting defense. Is there a publicly available defensive stat you would say it most closely resembles?

Well, for MLB, it's mostly a blend of mostly FV and some BIS. Minor league, I have a Total Zone-esque thing that uses play by play data and coordinate to data to give a rough probabilistic estimate of every ball hit in the play.

Milwaukee nets a Comp Pick on Bauers deal? Milwaukee mind tricks Dodgers into trading farm for Skubal and still wins World Series? Has Milwaukee solved for baseball?

I mean, I hope they do because I already can't figure out what they're doing, so I rather it be them than a second team I appear to just suck at projecting.

What are some landing spots for a potential Casey Schmitt trade? What about Yankees? Could they get Elmer Rodriguez or Lagrange back?

I don't think that spicy. I think the Pirates could be interesting if they balk at giving Lowe 4/80 or something. You get three years of Schmitt.

Also, I would generally make fewer trades post CBA. While I think it's probably there's at least most of the 2027 season, it's a big enough risk that you have to downgrade the value of 2027 assets a bit relative to 2028-2029 assets

Can zips run a projection on how Barry bonds would do if he came out of retirement

At this point, I don't think ZiPS really has interesting to say! There's stretching a model a bit and stretching it like Stretch Armstrong. And even Stretch Armstrong only stretches into next week.

Does ZiPS think we're more likely to see a return to form for Willy Adames (dingers, excitement) in the bay? Or a continued slump into his Bill Adams (strikeouts, sluggish) form?

ZiPS isn't super optimistic and he's within five points of OPS from the Steamer proejction.

Last three years the Brewers had 80th percentile ZiPS of 87, 92, and 94 wins in the preseason articles. They actually won 93, 97, and 103 games for an extra 20 wins over their 80th percentile projections (+46 wins over their median projections). At what point does regressing them down to a 50% median become counterproductive when they've demonstrated that even an 80th percentile projection is selling them short (& by no small margin)?

I mean, last year inputs aren't an input in the projections. They're generate à la minute

Sonny Gray is expensive, yes, but on just two years aren't there a lot of teams that could have offered that? Did he just like playing in Minnesota or is it really that over the top

Not sure honestly. I'd think someone would offer him a third year around that price.

What teams' analytics departments are the most interesting to you? Which teams do you align with and not align with the most?

Unfortunately, I don't have sufficient information to answer this! While I'm friendly with a large percentage of front offices, since I'm not "family," there are a lot of specifics they'd prefer to keep from me. I can't even assume front offices that use ZiPS for whatever purpose they're using ZiPS for are necessarily more in agreement with me than the ones that aren't (or at least aren't getting the full runs from me).

First off, I have to admit that I’m from Anaheim, so I really don’t know what a good owner looks like, but having said that, I really don’t trust that owners or the union to settle things in our (the fans or whatever you want to call “us”) best interest. I think the two side should present their case to an arbitrator and let them have at

I mean fundamentally, both owners and players are going to look out for their own interests.

Arbitration is better at addressing specific questions of dispute, within an existing framework. Less so at actually MAKING the framework.

As long as both sides feel they can survive a work stoppage, then they're not going to want to give up leverage.

I assume you process a ton of yearly data from every player for input to ZiPS. Have you ever looked at year-over-year trends of key inputs by team? It probably is not very black-and-white, but analyzing how players over a team change year-to-year could be interesting and add some extra color to prospect overviews.

I've never really thought of looking at that data in that way.

If Clase is found innocent, will any team sign him or is he just blacklisted forever?

I think it depends on *how* he's found not guilty? Like, if it he was found guilty because the perception of observers was that the case just fell apart under heightened scrutiny, I think he'd be back in baseball.

But if he looks guilty and the jury just disagrees, I'm not sure he ever gets signed again.

My takeaway from the Bryce Miller trade is that even oft-injured #3/4 starters are super expensive if they're still young and flash #2 upside. See: Dustin May signing, Shane Baz trade

How many years would Zips have given Bednar? How much is the QO an overpay in raw expected performance terms for next year

3 years and a lot less per, but projecting reliever contracts is a giant dodgy mess.

Am I crazy to pretty much just like the Bauers deal? I feel like the answer to the logjam Baumann sees is pretty simple: yes, they see Mead as a second baseman, at least for next season; and yes, they will trade or release either Duran or Yoshida and possibly both.

I think it's a pretty reasonable deal. I suspect they're doing to do more too

With Connor Wong’s DFA the direct Mookie Betts return is finished in Boston. How many years should we wait before trying to parse who ‘won’ this unbelievably balanced and wise trade?

I think you already can. It's not like the Dodgers got a decade of Betts in the deal, they got the right to negotiate to get a decade of Betts in the deal. Which is still good, but not quite the same thing

The blurb noted you are pumping blood through your circulatory system. Have you always used a pump system? If not, for how long have you been using one, and how effective has it been versus other systems you have tried?

I mean, that's how the heart works, right? I took physics for my physical science credits in college.

I feel like every bad thing you can say about Maikel Garcia (injury-prone, down year, bad away splits), Bryce Miller has it worse

Since Stearns / Arnold arrived in 2016 the Brewers ERA has beaten their FIP in every full season with a -0.16 differential from 2016 to 2022 and a -0.39 differential from 2023 to 2026 combining for a -0.25 differential over the last decade. Does ZiPS take any of that into consideration? A quarter of a run per game over the course of their last 1,681 games (& almost 2/5ths of a run over their last 648 games) seems like a lot.

ZiPS *does* consider historical FIP/ERA difference for pitchers relative to team defense and park. So ZiPS always projected Marco Gonzales better than most. But I wish it were that easy to project the Brewers

What is the advantage of locking out players on 12/1 vs mid January or sometime close to P&C reporting? Seems like a waste of an artificial deadline.

I think a few things are going on here. I think the owners want to put as much uncertainty onto the players as much as possible and have more time to start trying to wear down some of the players who may be more willing to discuss a cap system.

Also the more time you go, the more transactions happen that could make any kind of system changes more difficult.

Interest arbitration is a process used when two sides are trying to create a new contract and cannot agree on its terms.

Instead of a strike, lockout, or endless negotiations:

The union presents its proposal.
Management presents its proposal.
A neutral arbitrator or panel reviews the evidence.
The arbitrator decides what the new contract will be.

Assuming Gunnar and Alonso start every day, and Basallo gets a chunk of DH, what are you doing with Westburg, Holliday, Mayo, CES, and Alexander for 2.5 lineup spots?

I actually think SOMEONE gets traded this winter. I think Mayo is considered the 3B starter, Alexander a supersub type, and CES a bench bat part time. I suspect Westburg gets a lot of time at DH until/if he's healthy. If the O's have a surplus, I think they'll deal with it then.

Trout has four years left on his contract, if you were the new Angels owner would you go "all in" one last time to try to win something with Mike, or just tear it down and get started with the much needed rebuild now?

Tear it down I think. I'm not sure the Angels and free agency have enough combined talent to make an all in push very potent

We only have two players remaining in free agency with a three-WAR projection!

Does Altuve's Zips fall off a cliff this year? The Astros have no choice but to throw him to the wolves at 2B with Yordan the DH. That said, should they do the unthinkable and trade Yordan?

Altuve's projection doesn't drop off a cliff – it thinks 2026 is his baseline, so he's already fallen

The Bauers deal reminds me how scary it can be to play in FA, and how non generalizable my MKE perspective is. I felt it was kinda dubious for Boston for the commitment length and uncertain track record, but I think that’s just the uncertainty-reward tradeoff of any major FA signing, especially if you’re a smaller team.

So, since Cincinnati is next (assuming your hint was interpreted correctly), what big deal comes through for them early tomorrow that heavily throws off their summary right before you publish?

OH NO DONT SAY THAT

That was really annoying. I talked a lot about Maikel Garcia in my draft! There was a lot of rewriting and since both pitchers and hitters were involved, I had to remake all the tables

And I was especially annoyed because I wanted to get the Reds filed this afternoon so that I was free to play GTA VI

Historically does an early moves like Seattle made increase their chances of signing competitive free agents? Basically if you improve your team early in the off season are free agents more inclined to sign with your team?

I've looked a little at this, though not as comprehensively as I could, and didn't find much of an effect.

If ~8% of the current top 100 free agents are signed/QO'd, what do you think is the final percentage number that sign before the lockout?

25%?

What remaining player who isn't skubal has a 3 war projection? And which already signed free agent has one?

Gray and Rogers. We have the current depth chart projected WAR on the free agent tracker! https://www.fangraphs.com/roster-resource/free-agent-tracker

That's Steamer, not Steamer and ZiPS, and I don't have ZiPS cross-referenced to FAs at the moment

Brady House gettable via trade? Seems like lots of teams need 3B enough to overvalue him enough to make it worth Nats’ while

I would assume the Nats are not particularly attached to House.

If anything happens re: Cincinnati, I give you permission in advance to entirely blame me. On a serious note, though, on the Braves’ summary you had mentioned how Lopez projected if he moved to the pen; how do Strider and Holmes project in similar moves there?

Strider 4.03 ERA in bullpen, Holmes 4.19

What's the hardest — projecting relievers, prospects or international signings?

Prospects for sure, especially when they're low level!

I have a 1:10 appointment to get to, so I have to cut things slightly short this week. Thanks for coming all!


Elly De La Cruz Is Less Unscoopable Than Previously Thought

Aaron Doster-Imagn Images

Right around this time last year, I wrote an article about Elly De La Cruz’s arm. It’s a fantastic arm, long and powerful, and right off the bat this article is getting weirder than I intended. Sorry. This long, powerful arm has its drawbacks. Since De La Cruz debuted in 2023, it has been the source of 39 throwing errors, tied for the second most in baseball. I was writing about all those errors last year because I had a theory that maybe De La Cruz’s arm wasn’t as bad as the numbers made him look. Learning from other conspiracy theories, I figured that starting with a YouTube video might help my cause gain traction:

“You see what I’m getting at, right?” I wrote.

These throws don’t look that bad. De La Cruz throws the ball so hard that first basemen don’t have enough time to react. They’re getting handcuffed over and over again. None of these throws is perfect, but they’re not all that far off target either. Six of the seven hit leather. Were they thrown by a shortstop with a lesser arm, at something a bit further below the speed of light, the first baseman might have picked them cleanly. Instead, they went uncaught. De La Cruz is getting dinged for errors on balls that aren’t all that far off target, and maybe that’s a little bit unfair.

In order to test my theory, I watched every single error De La Cruz made, not just the throwing errors. And there were a lot to choose from. He may be tied for second in baseball in throwing errors since his debut, but his 47 fielding errors put him in first place by a wide margin and make him the overall error king of the mid-2020s. However, as we all know, errors are not the best way to measure defensive prowess. Read the rest of this entry »


JAWS and the 2027 Hall of Fame Ballot: Chase Utley

Benny Sieu-USA TODAY Sports

The following article is part of Jay Jaffe’s ongoing look at the candidates on the BBWAA 2027 Hall of Fame ballot. For a detailed introduction to this year’s ballot, and other candidates in the series, use the tool above; an introduction to JAWS can be found here. All WAR figures refer to the Baseball-Reference version unless otherwise indicated.

When the Phillies returned to contention following a slide into irrelevance in the wake of their 1993 National League pennant, shortstop Jimmy Rollins, first baseman Ryan Howard, and lefty Cole Hamels gained most of the attention. Howard all but ran Jim Thome out of town after the latter was injured in 2005, then mashed a major league-high 58 homers in ’06 en route to NL MVP honors. Rollins, the emotional center of the team, carried himself with a swagger, declared the Phillies “the team to beat” at the outset of 2007, then won the MVP award when the team followed through with a division title. Hamels debuted in 2006 and became their ace while making his first All-Star team the next season. In the middle of all that, as part of the nucleus that would help the Phillies win five straight NL East titles from 2007–11, with a championship in ’08 and another pennant in ’09, Chase Utley was as good or better than any of them, though the second baseman hardly called attention to himself.

Indeed, Utley seemed to shun the spotlight, playing the game with a quiet intensity that bordered on asceticism. He sped around the bases after hitting home runs, then reluctantly accepted high-fives in the dugout. “I am having fun,” he told the Philadelphia Inquirer’s Andy Martino in 2009. “When I’m on the baseball field, that’s where I love to be. I’m not joking around and smiling. That competition, that heat-of-the-battle intensity, that’s how I have fun.” Read the rest of this entry »


2027 ZiPS Projections: Kansas City Royals

For the 23rd consecutive season, the ZiPS projection system is unleashing a full set of prognostications. For more information on the ZiPS projections, please consult this year’s introduction, as well as MLB’s glossary entry. The team order is selected by lot, and the next team up is the Kansas City Royals.

Batters

Even as they were coming off back-to-back winning seasons for the first time since they won the World Series in 2015, the Royals didn’t face sky high expectations entering 2026, but they were widely considered to be a playoff contender. Instead, Kansas City fell permanently below the .500 mark by the second week of the season. It looked a bit like the Royals were getting back on track in late April for a stretch when they won nine of 11 games and creeped up to only a half game out of first place, but they fell apart in the second week of May and never recovered. From mid-June on, the Royals were the sole residents of the AL Central basement.

Taken as a whole, the lineup wasn’t really all that bad in 2026. Their 20.6 total WAR was 12th in baseball, and their 98 wRC+ was far from a liability. But look deeper and you’ll see some real problems that were disguised by the fact that the Royals employed Bobby Witt Jr., who led the American League with 7.0 WAR. If you think of an average lineup as consisting of nine 2-WAR players, being average is pretty disappointing when you start off with one guy who gets you nearly 40% of the way there on his own.

The good news is that a lot of positions have solid coverage. Witt is of course an absolute baseball beast, and Carter Jensen was the second-best catcher in the AL in 2026 by WAR. Vinnie Pasquantino isn’t a star, but he’s a solid starter (and fun!). Michael Massey is at least serviceable at second.

But the offense was burdened by carrying pretty awful performances in center field, left field, and at designated hitter. These positions combined for -1.3 WAR in 2026. The Royals seemed to sour on John Rave after a poor 2025 debut, but he acquitted himself well in 2026, hitting for a wRC+ of 105, enough for 1.0 WAR in 52 games. Hopefully, the Royals won’t end up going into the season with Isaac Collins and Kyle Isbel as two-thirds of the outfield. A far better option, at least according to the projections (I agree with them in this case) would be for the Royals to look at Rave in center field, show more interest in Carson Roccaforte than they have displayed to date, and seriously go after one of the top free agent outfielders, like Ian Happ.

Improvements in the outfield are important because the lineup got a little bit worse on Wednesday — helpfully after I wrote this piece and made all the charts and a graphic — with Kansas City’s trade of third baseman Maikel Garcia to the Mariners. Nick Loftin is a solid glove at third and hits enough just enough to be a reasonable starter if his defense sticks, but the Royals are losing Garcia’s upside.

That leaves the Salvador Perez question. If he wants to stick around as a traditional backup at catcher and first base, sure. But if he gets 82 starts at DH again in 2027, and not as a result of the rest of the roster coming down with a case of the plague or the lemurpox or whatever, something’s seriously wrong with the team’s priorities. Like Miguel Cabrera at the end of his career, Perez is actively preventing his team from winning more games. As a significant player in Royals history and a great teammate and leader, Perez deserves a grand sendoff, with the Royals putting their imaginations to work to honor him. But it has to be a sendoff that sees him get 80 plate appearances or so as the 26th man on the roster. Moving Jac Caglianone to DH would allow him to solely concentrate on mashing baseballs rather than catching them, and the outfield opportunities this winter could give the Royals a better-rounded offense that has less need for Witt to be an AL MVP candidate in order for them to just be average.

The Royals have some solid prospects, but they’re mostly in the lower minors, and not likely to have much 2027 impact outside of Roccaforte.

Pitchers

Now that we’re onto the pitching staff, this is where the Royals went splat in 2026. The quietly competent pitching is one of the big reasons Kansas City was a winning team in 2024 and 2025, with the pitchers combining for a 3.76 ERA and 21.1 WAR in 2024 and a 3.73 ERA and 18.6 WAR in 2025. Both those WAR totals ranked in the top five in baseball. In 2026, that ERA sagged to a 4.78 ERA (27th), and with 5.1 WAR, they ranked 29th in the majors, ahead of only Washington Nationals. Basically, the decline in the team’s pitching chopped 15 wins out of the standings column, and few teams can endure that kind of sudden loss.

Can they reverse their fortunes? It’s going to require some work, and more than just hoping for a lot of bounceback seasons. For one, Kris Bubic is gone and Cole Ragans is out until at least the midseason due to UCL surgery. Michael Wacha ought to be his typical boring-but-dependable innings-eater self, and ZiPS sees Noah Cameron as fairly dependable, but the rotation after those two is riddled with question marks.

Or, at least, it was until the Royals traded Garcia. The Royals are rolling the dice more than they usually do, banking on Bryce Miller to get back to his 2024 form. It’s not the craziest gamble in the world, as his mediocre numbers the last couple seasons are mitigated by his elbow and oblique issues, and his high-end projection is probably the highest of any pitcher currently employed by the Royals. Miller also had much sunnier Stuff+ and PitchingBot numbers than his 2026 results.

Beyond Miller, Seth Lugo at this stage of his career does nothing more than serve as a late-inning sponge. Randy Dobnak’s low ERA in 2026 falls apart pretty quickly at the slightest scrutiny, like the time I got out of a day in school when I was nine by adding “swelling” to a spider bite I got with a small amount of red poster paint and some nail polish remover. (Luckily, Mom didn’t figure it out until the afternoon.) Luinder Avila and Stephen Kolek aren’t 2027 factors due to injury and Daniel Lynch IV is best suited to be emergency starter IV.

ZiPS would prefer just putting Lucas Braun, one of the players acquired in the Lane Thomas trade, in the rotation to replace either Lynch or Dobnak. Tony Gonsolin is an interesting reclamation project and a good keep at his $2.5 million option, but you can’t be banking on him in 2027. Just as they should do to improve the outfield, the Royals will likely need to open their wallets quite a lot in free agency if they want to make the starting pitching a plus again. We have 22 remaining starting pitcher free agents projected to put up 1.5 WAR or more in 2027. The Royals aren’t going to sign Tarik Skubal — though I checked, and based on current rosters, they get the biggest playoff boost in baseball by adding him — they really ought to start the season with one or two of the other 21 guys, preferably two.

The bullpen is a serious weak spot for the team. ZiPS likes Steven Cruz and new acquisition José A. Ferrer and is lukewarm on Lucas Erceg, Angel Bastardo, and Lynch if used as a reliever. Then, the void beckons. ZiPS doesn’t think any of the Royals’ spare starters would be particularly notable relievers — Avila has potential, but he just had Tommy John surgery — and the projections don’t really think any of the team’s fringe high-minors arms are terribly interesting. Getting Ferrer is a good start, but he’s not going to fix the bullpen by himself, so the Royals will likely need to spend money here.

Could the Royals contend? Yes, the projections, as of right now, look like those of a .500ish team, perhaps a skosh worse. But the Royals play in a weak division, and if they put together an 86-win type of team, they might actually go into the season as the mild favorites. Kansas City has clear strengths and obvious needs. Whether the Royals address the latter fully this offseason rather than go with half measures is up to them.

Ballpark graphic courtesy Eephus League. Depth charts constructed by way of those listed here. Size of player names is very roughly proportional to Depth Chart playing time. The final team projections may differ considerably from our Depth Chart playing time.

Batters – Standard
Player B Age PO PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS
Bobby Witt Jr. R 27 SS 664 594 101 172 37 5 25 85 59 113 36 9
Carter Jensen L 23 C 613 539 79 132 29 3 24 84 64 164 4 1
Jac Caglianone L 24 RF 573 523 76 147 30 2 26 84 40 137 6 2
Nick Loftin R 28 3B 439 381 47 93 22 2 9 48 44 70 5 2
Jonathan India R 30 2B 519 439 69 107 25 1 12 50 61 97 6 2
Vinnie Pasquantino L 29 1B 550 487 58 125 27 1 24 80 51 84 3 0
Carson Roccaforte L 25 CF 578 517 68 114 24 5 18 70 49 186 17 10
Michael Massey L 29 2B 433 402 46 102 20 1 13 50 21 75 3 1
John Rave L 29 CF 496 433 65 101 22 4 10 52 51 117 15 4
Blake Mitchell L 22 C 500 427 69 82 14 1 15 56 59 200 11 4
Salvador Perez R 37 C 573 531 50 130 24 0 22 75 26 118 0 0
Kyle Isbel L 30 CF 377 340 45 81 14 4 6 34 22 79 7 2
Alejo Lopez B 31 2B 391 349 43 93 17 2 3 39 32 50 8 4
Tyler Tolbert R 29 2B 374 331 54 81 13 2 4 34 25 93 30 5
Drew Waters B 28 CF 440 402 56 95 23 5 10 48 32 126 13 4
Luke Pelzer L 24 LF 489 453 54 126 19 7 2 45 31 122 21 6
Isaac Collins B 29 LF 476 406 52 93 22 4 8 44 59 105 11 5
Brett Squires L 27 1B 499 452 52 107 24 3 15 64 38 149 13 2
Ramon Ramirez R 22 C 380 344 51 78 18 1 10 45 27 99 4 1
Sam Kulasingam B 25 2B 539 473 63 111 21 5 6 49 50 114 13 5
Abraham Toro B 30 1B 482 437 53 107 24 4 12 54 36 103 3 2
Josh Rojas L 33 3B 360 326 36 75 18 1 7 35 28 75 4 1
Matthew Lugo R 26 CF 450 412 50 97 25 6 11 55 28 133 7 5
Nolan Sailors L 23 CF 517 446 58 98 16 6 6 45 39 140 18 6
Elih Marrero B 30 C 143 134 16 30 11 0 1 13 8 41 3 2
Dustin Dickerson R 26 SS 363 315 37 62 11 1 3 29 39 100 7 2
Austin Charles R 23 3B 322 292 34 66 12 2 5 33 19 88 9 3
Luke Maile R 36 C 146 127 12 26 5 0 2 12 15 41 1 0
Starling Marte R 38 DH 286 259 30 67 11 1 5 26 17 65 8 2
Peyton Wilson B 27 2B 436 391 45 90 22 2 6 44 37 114 11 4
Javier Vaz L 26 2B 425 366 48 82 15 2 3 38 40 58 13 1
Connor Kaiser R 30 SS 282 245 28 44 10 1 3 22 29 98 3 2
Colton Becker R 26 SS 395 335 43 74 13 2 2 33 35 89 17 6
Justin Johnson R 27 2B 368 331 36 65 15 0 6 36 25 96 6 3
Luca Tresh R 27 C 362 334 33 75 15 1 8 40 21 106 1 0
Jorge Alfaro R 34 C 322 304 31 64 12 1 9 35 10 131 4 1
Kevin Newman R 33 3B 258 235 26 54 13 0 1 20 17 54 3 0
Daniel Vazquez R 23 SS 503 457 48 103 21 1 2 38 34 136 10 4
Gavin Cross L 26 RF 472 437 55 97 19 4 12 54 28 154 15 3
Chris Brito R 27 1B 197 172 19 37 7 0 3 18 20 57 1 1
Omar Hernandez R 25 C 322 295 33 65 9 1 3 26 14 74 9 4
Spencer Nivens L 25 LF 465 416 47 97 21 3 8 46 42 102 8 3
Jacob Berry B 26 2B 462 414 48 97 23 3 9 51 36 86 11 4
Jose Cerice R 22 3B 532 479 56 111 17 3 8 55 25 97 9 4
Andrew Velazquez R 32 SS 342 310 37 68 14 1 5 28 21 103 14 2
Tyriq Kemp L 24 2B 445 391 47 78 12 5 7 41 38 102 14 8
Hyungchan Um R 23 C 396 354 34 71 11 2 7 38 25 110 4 1
Canyon Brown R 23 C 315 288 31 56 9 1 4 26 16 94 5 2
Brandon Drury R 34 DH 317 282 29 60 14 1 6 31 29 85 1 1
Angel Acosta L 24 2B 273 242 24 57 8 1 2 23 15 45 3 3
Asbel Gonzalez R 21 CF 589 510 68 112 16 3 6 48 33 156 33 10
Connor Rasmussen L 23 2B 350 311 35 64 13 3 3 31 33 78 6 3
Diego Guzman R 23 3B 162 147 16 25 6 1 1 10 9 68 3 2
Derlin Figueroa L 23 3B 488 448 51 93 18 2 13 51 32 149 9 4
Trevor Werner R 26 RF 357 321 36 61 15 3 8 35 27 131 5 3
Alberto Rodriguez L 26 RF 312 285 29 62 11 3 3 29 19 96 2 2
Erick Torres R 22 LF 408 371 34 88 10 2 2 32 21 74 7 5
Stone Russell R 23 1B 416 374 30 76 15 3 3 34 29 113 4 3

Batters – Advanced
Player PA BA OBP SLG OPS+ ISO BABIP Def WAR wOBA 3YOPS+ RC
Bobby Witt Jr. 664 .290 .355 .495 136 .205 .322 12 6.8 .362 133 115
Carter Jensen 613 .245 .325 .443 113 .199 .308 1 3.4 .333 119 79
Jac Caglianone 573 .281 .340 .495 131 .214 .336 -8 2.2 .359 134 90
Nick Loftin 439 .244 .330 .383 100 .139 .278 6 2.0 .316 98 50
Jonathan India 519 .244 .351 .387 108 .144 .288 -6 1.9 .330 105 62
Vinnie Pasquantino 550 .257 .329 .464 120 .207 .266 -1 1.8 .340 117 75
Carson Roccaforte 578 .221 .291 .391 89 .170 .307 7 1.6 .297 94 66
Michael Massey 433 .254 .292 .405 94 .152 .283 3 1.3 .302 91 49
John Rave 496 .233 .315 .372 92 .139 .297 0 1.3 .304 95 55
Blake Mitchell 500 .192 .297 .335 78 .143 .316 3 1.2 .284 85 46
Salvador Perez 573 .245 .291 .414 95 .169 .276 -5 1.2 .304 87 64
Kyle Isbel 377 .238 .291 .356 81 .118 .294 7 1.0 .285 78 37
Alejo Lopez 391 .266 .338 .352 95 .086 .304 -2 0.9 .310 92 45
Tyler Tolbert 374 .245 .306 .332 80 .088 .329 1 0.8 .285 80 42
Drew Waters 440 .236 .296 .393 92 .157 .320 -2 0.8 .301 91 51
Luke Pelzer 489 .278 .326 .364 94 .086 .377 2 0.8 .305 93 61
Isaac Collins 476 .229 .333 .362 96 .133 .290 1 0.8 .312 95 53
Brett Squires 499 .237 .301 .403 95 .166 .319 3 0.8 .307 96 58
Ramon Ramirez 380 .227 .288 .372 84 .145 .289 -2 0.7 .289 93 38
Sam Kulasingam 539 .235 .312 .338 83 .104 .297 -2 0.6 .291 84 55
Abraham Toro 482 .245 .309 .400 98 .156 .295 2 0.6 .311 95 56
Josh Rojas 360 .230 .291 .356 81 .126 .279 2 0.5 .285 77 35
Matthew Lugo 450 .235 .292 .405 94 .170 .321 -6 0.4 .303 94 52
Nolan Sailors 517 .220 .289 .323 72 .103 .307 3 0.3 .273 77 48
Elih Marrero 143 .224 .273 .328 68 .104 .315 3 0.3 .266 66 13
Dustin Dickerson 363 .197 .292 .267 59 .070 .278 4 0.3 .259 60 27
Austin Charles 322 .226 .280 .332 71 .106 .307 3 0.2 .271 75 30
Luke Maile 146 .205 .303 .291 69 .087 .286 0 0.2 .274 64 11
Starling Marte 286 .259 .316 .367 91 .108 .328 0 0.1 .302 85 32
Peyton Wilson 436 .230 .303 .343 81 .113 .310 -4 0.1 .289 83 45
Javier Vaz 425 .224 .310 .301 73 .077 .259 -3 0.1 .279 76 37
Connor Kaiser 282 .180 .273 .265 53 .086 .285 5 0.1 .249 54 19
Colton Becker 395 .221 .307 .290 69 .069 .295 -3 0.0 .274 70 36
Justin Johnson 368 .196 .265 .296 58 .100 .258 6 0.0 .253 58 28
Luca Tresh 362 .225 .272 .347 73 .123 .305 -4 -0.1 .272 76 32
Jorge Alfaro 322 .211 .248 .345 65 .135 .335 0 -0.1 .260 59 27
Kevin Newman 258 .230 .285 .298 65 .068 .294 1 -0.1 .262 62 21
Daniel Vazquez 503 .225 .281 .289 61 .063 .317 2 -0.2 .257 65 41
Gavin Cross 472 .222 .274 .366 78 .144 .314 3 -0.2 .279 81 48
Chris Brito 197 .215 .306 .308 74 .093 .304 2 -0.2 .280 76 17
Omar Hernandez 322 .220 .264 .288 55 .068 .284 2 -0.2 .247 59 26
Spencer Nivens 465 .233 .302 .356 84 .123 .291 -1 -0.2 .291 86 48
Jacob Berry 462 .234 .304 .370 88 .135 .276 -11 -0.2 .296 89 50
Jose Cerice 532 .232 .296 .330 76 .098 .275 -4 -0.2 .281 81 50
Andrew Velazquez 342 .219 .269 .319 65 .100 .312 -3 -0.3 .261 62 30
Tyriq Kemp 445 .199 .276 .309 64 .110 .252 2 -0.3 .263 68 40
Hyungchan Um 396 .201 .266 .302 60 .102 .270 -3 -0.5 .256 65 30
Canyon Brown 315 .194 .244 .274 46 .080 .274 2 -0.5 .232 49 21
Brandon Drury 317 .213 .293 .333 76 .121 .283 0 -0.6 .280 72 28
Angel Acosta 273 .236 .288 .302 66 .066 .282 -3 -0.6 .264 67 23
Asbel Gonzalez 589 .220 .280 .298 63 .078 .305 -2 -0.7 .260 67 53
Connor Rasmussen 350 .206 .289 .296 65 .090 .265 -5 -0.8 .265 70 29
Diego Guzman 162 .170 .223 .245 32 .075 .308 0 -0.9 .211 34 9
Derlin Figueroa 488 .208 .262 .344 69 .136 .280 -5 -0.9 .265 75 44
Trevor Werner 357 .190 .257 .330 64 .140 .291 1 -1.0 .260 66 30
Alberto Rodriguez 312 .218 .274 .309 64 .091 .317 -2 -1.1 .260 68 25
Erick Torres 408 .237 .281 .291 62 .054 .292 1 -1.2 .257 65 34
Stone Russell 416 .203 .268 .283 55 .080 .283 4 -1.4 .249 60 30

Batters – Top Near-Age Offensive Comps
Player Hit Comp 1 Hit Comp 2 Hit Comp 3
Bobby Witt Jr. Alan Trammell Charlie Gehringer Hanley Ramirez
Carter Jensen Gene Tenace Gary Allenson Bill Sudakis
Jac Caglianone Greg Walker Del Ennis Ellis Valentine
Nick Loftin Larry Fobbs Alex Taveras F.P. Santangelo
Jonathan India Dan Rohn D’Angelo Jimenez Willie Kamm
Vinnie Pasquantino Jim Spencer Tino Martinez Dave Nilsson
Carson Roccaforte Mike Cameron Blake Tekotte Matthew den Dekker
Michael Massey Devon Travis Kevin Burdick Jack Dittmer
John Rave Matt Long Mike Humphreys Oddibe McDowell
Blake Mitchell Clifton Matthew Mike Napoli Kurt Kingsolver
Salvador Perez Bo Diaz Gary Carter Rod Barajas
Kyle Isbel Terry Blocker Chris Frey Joe Simpson
Alejo Lopez Will Rhymes Jamey Carroll Jack Perconte
Tyler Tolbert Micah Johnson Pat Listach Elliot Johnson
Drew Waters John Shelby Nic Jackson Eddie Miller
Luke Pelzer Jarren Duran Joey Gathright Luis Mercedes
Isaac Collins Brady Anderson Eric Stuckenschneider Tommy Harper
Brett Squires Rob Mackowiak Doe Boyland George Metkovich
Ramon Ramirez Edward Cannon Jimmie Schaffer John Hughes
Sam Kulasingam Pumpsie Green Andy Stankiewicz Mark McLemore
Abraham Toro Ray Barker Jon Weber Mike Krsnich
Josh Rojas Bobby Malkmus Jose Pagan Chuck Cottier
Matthew Lugo Mark Little Jason Repko Sean Ross
Nolan Sailors Quincy Foster Ted Wilborn Jeramie Simpson
Elih Marrero Scott Hemond Howard Wood Brian Peacock
Dustin Dickerson Pfilip Hunt Eddie Joost Antonio Nunez
Austin Charles Dillon Hazlett Jason Van Kooten Jason Christian
Luke Maile Jack Paepke Joe Kmak Drew Butera
Starling Marte Jim Piersall Dee Moore So Taguchi
Peyton Wilson Corey Toups Trent Durrington Nate Oliver
Javier Vaz Justin Henry Jose Macias Michael Dobbins
Connor Kaiser John Sullivan Tim Torres Buddy Biancalana
Colton Becker Juan Castillo Terrence Freeman Tommy Watkins
Justin Johnson Mike Horning Teuris Olivares Felix Santana
Luca Tresh Otis Thornton Craig Faulkner Chris Howard
Jorge Alfaro Louis Heyman Jack Paepke Miguel Olivo
Kevin Newman Adam Everett Felix Martinez Thomas Silicato
Daniel Vazquez Jolbert Cabrera Joe Demaestri Wade Robinson
Gavin Cross Carlos Duncan Rich Gomez Chick King
Chris Brito Juan Pautt Jim Bishop Mike Mordarski
Omar Hernandez Miguel Fermin Felix Minaya Rob Johnson
Spencer Nivens James Ramsay Armando Rios Ka’ai Tom
Jacob Berry Chuck Cottier Stu Martin Kelvin Chapman
Jose Cerice Ed Pacheco Lenny Harris Julio Gonzalez
Andrew Velazquez Jackie Hernandez Brian Bixler Kevin Polcovich
Tyriq Kemp Scott Pratt Donnie Sadler Kevin Castleberry
Hyungchan Um Ronald Jacobs Jim Gaudet Nick Trzesniak
Canyon Brown Patrick Arlis Sonny Ruberto A.J. Johnson
Brandon Drury Webster Garrison Jack Voigt Travis Snider
Angel Acosta Alejo Lopez Thomas Boyles Evel Bastida
Asbel Gonzalez Joe Fernandez Jiwan James Marion Hunter
Connor Rasmussen Eric Garcia Jamodrick McGruder Austin Elkins
Diego Guzman Tony Rasmus Roosevelt Turner Juan Mejia
Derlin Figueroa Dan Uggla Duncan Campbell Ryan Radmanovich
Trevor Werner Marty Watson Terry Banderas Randy Simmons
Alberto Rodriguez Mike Rohde Chris Van Rossum Mark Thomas
Erick Torres Andy Sugilio Carlos Arroyo Nelson Samboy
Stone Russell Manny Olloque Weston Wilson Tom Duggan

Batters – 80th/20th Percentiles
Player 80th BA 80th OBP 80th SLG 80th OPS+ 80th WAR 20th BA 20th OBP 20th SLG 20th OPS+ 20th WAR
Bobby Witt Jr. .317 .382 .558 159 8.7 .266 .330 .449 116 5.2
Carter Jensen .272 .354 .499 136 5.1 .221 .298 .388 96 2.1
Jac Caglianone .306 .366 .553 153 3.6 .248 .309 .427 106 0.3
Nick Loftin .272 .358 .432 119 3.0 .218 .300 .334 80 1.0
Jonathan India .271 .377 .435 126 3.0 .218 .323 .340 87 0.6
Vinnie Pasquantino .281 .359 .524 141 3.2 .234 .306 .412 100 0.5
Carson Roccaforte .245 .314 .435 108 2.9 .190 .268 .340 70 0.2
Michael Massey .285 .319 .465 116 2.6 .226 .265 .358 74 0.3
John Rave .257 .339 .417 107 2.2 .206 .285 .324 71 0.1
Blake Mitchell .222 .328 .399 101 2.6 .162 .267 .283 54 -0.1
Salvador Perez .271 .316 .468 114 2.5 .214 .266 .359 74 -0.4
Kyle Isbel .265 .319 .403 101 2.0 .211 .263 .311 63 0.2
Alejo Lopez .301 .368 .395 115 1.8 .239 .314 .312 78 0.0
Tyler Tolbert .274 .336 .381 100 1.8 .214 .277 .288 60 -0.2
Drew Waters .266 .324 .447 113 2.0 .205 .262 .340 68 -0.4
Luke Pelzer .311 .359 .415 116 2.1 .245 .297 .319 74 -0.5
Isaac Collins .254 .363 .407 114 1.8 .202 .307 .315 76 -0.4
Brett Squires .263 .325 .454 115 2.1 .210 .271 .354 74 -0.5
Ramon Ramirez .259 .317 .431 104 1.6 .202 .260 .321 63 -0.4
Sam Kulasingam .258 .336 .376 101 1.8 .210 .288 .296 67 -0.4
Abraham Toro .272 .339 .449 117 1.8 .218 .282 .351 79 -0.6
Josh Rojas .258 .320 .400 99 1.4 .206 .264 .309 63 -0.3
Matthew Lugo .263 .319 .451 113 1.4 .207 .263 .356 73 -0.7
Nolan Sailors .246 .313 .367 90 1.4 .196 .266 .281 56 -0.8
Elih Marrero .259 .308 .381 91 0.8 .193 .239 .273 44 -0.2
Dustin Dickerson .225 .320 .308 77 1.1 .168 .267 .226 40 -0.5
Austin Charles .253 .311 .384 92 1.1 .196 .252 .285 51 -0.6
Luke Maile .237 .334 .335 89 0.5 .173 .273 .248 49 -0.2
Starling Marte .295 .349 .418 114 1.0 .220 .284 .320 68 -0.7
Peyton Wilson .262 .333 .392 102 1.2 .204 .274 .301 61 -1.0
Javier Vaz .251 .339 .344 92 1.0 .201 .283 .266 56 -0.8
Connor Kaiser .209 .308 .318 76 0.9 .147 .243 .216 35 -0.6
Colton Becker .248 .333 .332 87 0.9 .194 .281 .256 54 -0.8
Justin Johnson .225 .293 .343 78 0.9 .172 .239 .252 40 -0.8
Luca Tresh .255 .304 .390 92 0.8 .192 .243 .299 52 -1.0
Jorge Alfaro .239 .278 .402 87 0.8 .182 .219 .293 45 -0.9
Kevin Newman .258 .317 .340 84 0.5 .199 .257 .262 46 -0.7
Daniel Vazquez .252 .308 .329 79 0.9 .199 .257 .254 46 -1.2
Gavin Cross .250 .302 .418 100 1.1 .195 .247 .323 61 -1.2
Chris Brito .244 .339 .350 92 0.3 .188 .275 .268 53 -0.6
Omar Hernandez .250 .297 .332 76 0.7 .185 .237 .252 36 -1.0
Spencer Nivens .260 .330 .399 101 0.8 .204 .273 .309 64 -1.3
Jacob Berry .261 .331 .424 108 0.9 .208 .278 .328 69 -1.3
Jose Cerice .258 .325 .372 94 1.1 .204 .273 .282 57 -1.4
Andrew Velazquez .252 .303 .366 86 0.8 .193 .242 .275 44 -1.1
Tyriq Kemp .228 .301 .360 83 0.7 .177 .252 .271 48 -1.3
Hyungchan Um .231 .294 .353 81 0.6 .170 .238 .260 42 -1.4
Canyon Brown .231 .278 .325 69 0.3 .162 .218 .231 26 -1.3
Brandon Drury .244 .324 .397 98 0.3 .185 .263 .285 53 -1.5
Angel Acosta .267 .316 .343 84 0.0 .208 .262 .262 49 -1.2
Asbel Gonzalez .247 .303 .336 80 0.7 .196 .257 .264 48 -1.8
Connor Rasmussen .239 .320 .344 84 0.0 .181 .262 .254 46 -1.6
Diego Guzman .203 .255 .291 51 -0.6 .145 .196 .204 13 -1.3
Derlin Figueroa .231 .288 .396 89 0.3 .183 .237 .296 51 -2.1
Trevor Werner .219 .291 .382 85 0.0 .162 .232 .277 45 -1.8
Alberto Rodriguez .243 .301 .352 82 -0.4 .190 .250 .264 45 -1.8
Erick Torres .266 .308 .332 80 -0.3 .208 .255 .261 46 -2.1
Stone Russell .234 .295 .328 74 -0.4 .180 .242 .245 37 -2.3

Batters – Platoon Splits
Player BA vs. L OBP vs. L SLG vs. L BA vs. R OBP vs. R SLG vs. R
Bobby Witt Jr. .295 .360 .500 .287 .354 .493
Carter Jensen .239 .310 .394 .247 .331 .464
Jac Caglianone .268 .325 .477 .286 .346 .503
Nick Loftin .246 .338 .406 .243 .325 .370
Jonathan India .246 .359 .377 .243 .349 .391
Vinnie Pasquantino .248 .317 .416 .260 .334 .485
Carson Roccaforte .213 .280 .360 .223 .295 .402
Michael Massey .244 .283 .361 .258 .296 .424
John Rave .225 .303 .357 .237 .320 .378
Blake Mitchell .176 .280 .294 .197 .303 .348
Salvador Perez .247 .297 .432 .244 .289 .408
Kyle Isbel .237 .294 .323 .239 .289 .368
Alejo Lopez .272 .339 .368 .264 .338 .345
Tyler Tolbert .250 .313 .337 .242 .302 .330
Drew Waters .237 .291 .374 .236 .299 .403
Luke Pelzer .263 .310 .331 .284 .332 .376
Isaac Collins .240 .331 .387 .223 .334 .348
Brett Squires .218 .282 .353 .243 .307 .420
Ramon Ramirez .231 .304 .385 .225 .282 .368
Sam Kulasingam .228 .308 .339 .237 .314 .338
Abraham Toro .260 .321 .402 .239 .304 .400
Josh Rojas .217 .275 .337 .235 .296 .362
Matthew Lugo .241 .297 .421 .233 .290 .398
Nolan Sailors .207 .279 .279 .224 .293 .337
Elih Marrero .227 .277 .318 .222 .271 .333
Dustin Dickerson .204 .299 .280 .194 .289 .261
Austin Charles .218 .279 .321 .229 .280 .336
Luke Maile .220 .319 .341 .198 .296 .267
Starling Marte .257 .312 .343 .259 .317 .376
Peyton Wilson .232 .310 .339 .229 .301 .344
Javier Vaz .214 .294 .286 .228 .316 .306
Connor Kaiser .190 .297 .266 .175 .262 .265
Colton Becker .225 .319 .314 .219 .302 .279
Justin Johnson .194 .259 .306 .197 .267 .292
Luca Tresh .238 .284 .376 .219 .267 .335
Jorge Alfaro .213 .245 .360 .209 .250 .340
Kevin Newman .240 .301 .307 .225 .277 .294
Daniel Vazquez .228 .288 .299 .224 .278 .285
Gavin Cross .220 .265 .350 .223 .277 .373
Chris Brito .220 .328 .320 .213 .297 .303
Omar Hernandez .228 .276 .293 .217 .259 .286
Spencer Nivens .226 .286 .339 .236 .308 .362
Jacob Berry .239 .306 .367 .233 .303 .370
Jose Cerice .231 .297 .328 .232 .296 .330
Andrew Velazquez .227 .276 .309 .216 .266 .324
Tyriq Kemp .192 .266 .303 .202 .279 .312
Hyungchan Um .204 .271 .316 .199 .264 .297
Canyon Brown .195 .253 .264 .194 .241 .279
Brandon Drury .224 .302 .341 .208 .290 .330
Angel Acosta .220 .277 .254 .240 .291 .317
Asbel Gonzalez .226 .287 .321 .217 .278 .290
Connor Rasmussen .202 .277 .298 .207 .293 .295
Diego Guzman .167 .216 .208 .172 .226 .263
Derlin Figueroa .200 .252 .336 .210 .265 .346
Trevor Werner .189 .267 .322 .190 .253 .333
Alberto Rodriguez .216 .271 .307 .218 .276 .310
Erick Torres .240 .287 .300 .236 .279 .288
Stone Russell .200 .267 .286 .204 .268 .283

Pitchers – Standard
Player T Age W L ERA G GS IP H ER HR BB SO
Michael Wacha R 35 9 8 4.09 27 27 160.7 155 73 22 47 127
Noah Cameron L 27 8 8 4.13 28 27 152.7 146 70 21 48 134
Bryce Miller R 28 7 8 4.26 26 25 133.0 123 63 20 41 110
Cole Ragans L 29 6 6 3.92 20 18 98.7 83 43 13 40 119
Lucas Braun R 25 8 9 4.46 24 23 123.0 127 61 16 35 91
Stephen Kolek R 30 5 6 4.22 24 19 102.3 105 48 11 29 68
Seth Lugo R 37 6 8 4.70 25 25 141.7 149 74 21 49 109
Randy Dobnak R 32 6 8 4.65 26 23 122.0 136 63 15 44 70
Daniel Lynch IV L 30 5 5 4.31 46 11 87.7 86 42 11 28 64
Ryan Bergert R 27 3 4 4.59 22 19 86.3 85 44 12 37 70
Luinder Avila R 25 4 5 4.61 25 17 84.0 81 43 9 40 71
Justin Lamkin L 23 3 3 4.32 13 13 58.3 55 28 7 24 50
Hunter Owen L 25 4 5 4.88 23 17 90.3 93 49 13 35 71
Steven Cruz R 28 3 3 3.98 57 2 61.0 53 27 8 23 63
Angel Bastardo R 25 3 4 4.42 30 6 59.0 55 29 8 30 58
Drew Beam R 24 7 11 5.09 24 24 115.0 128 65 16 33 66
Mitch Spence R 29 4 5 4.96 24 17 98.0 105 54 14 32 69
Logan Evans R 26 4 5 4.91 19 16 77.0 84 42 11 28 51
José A. Ferrer L 27 4 3 3.94 67 0 64.0 63 28 5 22 52
Henry Williams R 25 5 7 5.09 23 21 111.3 118 63 16 46 78
Steven Zobac R 26 4 5 4.97 18 17 63.3 68 35 10 20 47
Matt Strahm L 35 3 4 4.21 46 1 47.0 43 22 7 15 43
Easton McGee R 29 3 3 4.53 37 4 59.7 60 30 7 20 45
Tony Gonsolin R 33 3 4 5.10 12 12 54.7 52 31 9 23 45
Mason Black R 27 3 4 5.00 33 12 93.7 97 52 14 40 69
Ryan Ramsey L 26 4 7 5.25 24 18 97.7 100 57 13 47 75
Lucas Erceg R 32 4 5 4.22 53 0 53.3 51 25 4 25 44
Grant Gambrell R 29 3 4 5.09 14 11 58.3 63 33 9 21 37
Connor Thomas L 29 3 4 4.69 34 4 63.3 68 33 8 21 43
Spencer Bivens R 33 3 4 4.65 38 4 71.7 76 37 10 28 55
Tyson Guerrero L 28 2 4 5.16 20 11 61.0 61 35 9 29 50
John Means L 34 1 1 4.81 6 6 24.3 26 13 4 7 16
Vince Velasquez R 35 2 4 5.20 20 15 72.7 76 42 12 36 60
Hunter Patteson L 27 4 7 5.31 23 19 96.7 108 57 15 39 61
Augusto Mendieta R 22 6 6 4.45 38 0 62.7 60 31 8 24 57
Ben Kudrna R 24 3 6 5.35 16 16 75.7 83 45 11 35 52
Ben Sears R 27 3 4 4.84 40 7 61.3 65 33 8 22 41
Carlos Duran R 25 2 3 4.80 40 5 54.3 50 29 7 34 56
Nick Mears R 30 3 4 4.35 45 0 41.3 40 20 5 18 37
Scott Alexander L 37 2 2 4.68 29 2 25.0 27 13 3 11 18
Oscar Rayo L 25 3 3 4.88 27 3 62.7 66 34 9 21 42
Nate Pearson R 30 3 4 4.69 49 2 55.7 53 29 7 29 52
Carlos Estévez R 34 3 4 4.57 48 0 45.3 42 23 6 18 36
Felix Arronde R 24 4 7 5.48 22 20 95.3 104 58 15 40 58
Luke Jackson R 35 2 2 4.64 32 0 33.0 32 17 4 17 28
Aaron Bummer L 33 2 3 4.84 36 1 35.3 35 19 4 15 33
Anthony Gose L 36 3 3 4.63 41 0 44.7 44 23 6 23 42
Connor Seabold R 31 2 3 5.25 27 7 60.0 65 35 8 24 47
Hobie Harris R 34 2 3 4.91 27 2 33.0 35 18 5 19 27
Craig Kimbrel R 39 3 3 4.75 45 0 41.7 38 22 5 24 39
Shane Panzini R 25 3 5 5.37 19 10 60.3 64 36 9 32 46
Matt Moore L 38 1 2 5.13 26 1 26.3 27 15 4 13 22
Beck Way R 27 4 6 5.00 41 3 63.0 62 35 8 31 52
Andrew Morones R 26 2 2 4.88 21 0 27.7 28 15 4 15 24
Nolan Hoffman R 29 3 4 4.86 46 1 53.7 53 29 7 27 48
Scott Barlow R 34 2 2 4.79 49 0 47.0 41 25 5 29 45
Chazz Martinez L 27 2 3 4.81 36 0 48.7 48 26 6 26 42
Génesis Cabrera L 30 2 3 4.95 41 0 43.7 44 24 7 22 38
Zachary Cawyer R 24 4 5 4.88 44 0 59.0 60 32 8 28 48
Alex Lange R 31 3 4 4.86 48 0 50.0 46 27 7 28 50
Chase Jessee L 28 2 3 5.34 32 4 57.3 57 34 7 37 45
Aaron Sanchez R 34 2 3 6.09 12 11 44.3 50 30 7 26 28
Jose Cuas R 33 2 4 5.03 47 0 48.3 49 27 7 28 44
Luke Little L 26 3 4 4.97 42 0 50.7 45 28 5 32 47
Caden Monke L 27 2 2 5.04 36 0 44.7 43 25 5 31 41
Anthony Simonelli R 28 2 3 5.35 28 0 35.3 37 21 5 18 26
Ethan Bosacker R 26 3 5 5.63 25 10 72.0 81 45 12 29 39
Andrew Pérez L 29 2 5 5.40 29 2 41.7 42 25 6 25 34
Dan Altavilla R 34 2 3 5.40 35 0 38.3 39 23 5 22 27
Frank Mozzicato L 24 3 5 5.76 27 13 70.3 71 45 11 53 59
Helcris Olivárez L 26 1 2 6.16 22 2 30.7 28 21 4 28 28
Brandon Johnson R 28 2 3 5.25 47 1 58.3 60 34 9 31 48
Christian Chamberlain L 27 1 3 5.73 32 0 33.0 30 21 4 25 29
Dennis Colleran Jr. R 23 2 3 5.54 42 0 50.3 51 31 7 31 37
Tommy Molsky R 24 2 3 5.68 39 0 50.7 51 32 6 30 37

Pitchers – Advanced
Player IP K/9 BB/9 HR/9 BB% K% BABIP ERA+ 3ERA+ FIP ERA- WAR
Michael Wacha 160.7 7.1 2.6 1.2 7.0% 18.9% .282 105 99 4.32 95 2.2
Noah Cameron 152.7 7.9 2.8 1.2 7.5% 20.8% .286 104 106 4.22 96 2.1
Bryce Miller 133.0 7.4 2.8 1.4 7.4% 20.0% .274 101 101 4.44 99 1.6
Cole Ragans 98.7 10.9 3.6 1.2 9.6% 28.6% .291 110 109 3.72 91 1.6
Lucas Braun 123.0 6.7 2.6 1.2 6.6% 17.2% .289 97 100 4.33 104 1.3
Stephen Kolek 102.3 6.0 2.6 1.0 6.6% 15.5% .289 102 101 4.24 98 1.3
Seth Lugo 141.7 6.9 3.1 1.3 7.9% 17.6% .295 92 84 4.70 109 1.1
Randy Dobnak 122.0 5.2 3.2 1.1 8.1% 12.8% .297 93 90 4.90 108 1.0
Daniel Lynch IV 87.7 6.6 2.9 1.1 7.5% 17.2% .283 100 99 4.41 100 0.9
Ryan Bergert 86.3 7.3 3.9 1.3 9.8% 18.5% .287 94 96 4.72 106 0.7
Luinder Avila 84.0 7.6 4.3 1.0 10.7% 19.0% .289 93 98 4.45 107 0.7
Justin Lamkin 58.3 7.7 3.7 1.1 9.5% 19.8% .284 100 106 4.33 100 0.7
Hunter Owen 90.3 7.1 3.5 1.3 8.7% 17.7% .291 88 93 4.81 113 0.5
Steven Cruz 61.0 9.3 3.4 1.2 8.9% 24.5% .282 108 109 4.06 92 0.5
Angel Bastardo 59.0 8.8 4.6 1.2 11.5% 22.2% .289 97 103 4.57 103 0.5
Drew Beam 115.0 5.2 2.6 1.3 6.5% 12.9% .290 85 89 4.88 118 0.4
Mitch Spence 98.0 6.3 2.9 1.3 7.4% 16.0% .294 87 87 4.73 115 0.4
Logan Evans 77.0 6.0 3.3 1.3 8.1% 14.8% .291 88 92 4.96 114 0.4
José A. Ferrer 64.0 7.3 3.1 0.7 7.9% 18.6% .294 109 111 3.80 92 0.4
Henry Williams 111.3 6.3 3.7 1.3 9.2% 15.6% .289 85 88 5.09 118 0.3
Steven Zobac 63.3 6.7 2.8 1.4 7.2% 16.9% .292 87 91 4.85 115 0.3
Matt Strahm 47.0 8.2 2.9 1.3 7.7% 22.2% .284 102 95 4.40 98 0.2
Easton McGee 59.7 6.8 3.0 1.1 7.7% 17.3% .291 95 95 4.37 105 0.2
Tony Gonsolin 54.7 7.4 3.8 1.5 9.9% 19.3% .280 84 81 5.07 118 0.2
Mason Black 93.7 6.6 3.8 1.3 9.6% 16.5% .288 86 89 5.12 116 0.2
Ryan Ramsey 97.7 6.9 4.3 1.2 10.6% 16.9% .290 82 85 5.06 122 0.2
Lucas Erceg 53.3 7.4 4.2 0.7 10.5% 18.4% .294 102 99 4.16 98 0.2
Grant Gambrell 58.3 5.7 3.2 1.4 8.1% 14.3% .291 85 84 5.17 118 0.2
Connor Thomas 63.3 6.1 3.0 1.1 7.5% 15.4% .295 92 92 4.57 109 0.2
Spencer Bivens 71.7 6.9 3.5 1.3 8.8% 17.2% .298 93 88 4.76 108 0.2
Tyson Guerrero 61.0 7.4 4.3 1.3 10.5% 18.2% .289 83 86 5.15 120 0.1
John Means 24.3 5.9 2.6 1.5 6.8% 15.5% .287 90 82 4.95 112 0.1
Vince Velasquez 72.7 7.4 4.5 1.5 11.0% 18.3% .296 83 76 5.21 121 0.1
Hunter Patteson 96.7 5.7 3.6 1.4 8.9% 14.0% .293 81 84 5.23 123 0.1
Augusto Mendieta 62.7 8.2 3.4 1.1 8.7% 20.7% .287 97 104 4.37 103 0.1
Ben Kudrna 75.7 6.2 4.2 1.3 10.1% 15.1% .294 80 86 5.17 124 0.1
Ben Sears 61.3 6.0 3.2 1.2 8.1% 15.0% .290 89 91 4.78 112 0.1
Carlos Duran 54.3 9.3 5.6 1.2 13.6% 22.4% .290 90 95 4.97 112 0.1
Nick Mears 41.3 8.1 3.9 1.1 9.9% 20.4% .293 99 96 4.31 101 0.1
Scott Alexander 25.0 6.5 4.0 1.1 9.6% 15.8% .300 92 85 4.71 109 0.0
Oscar Rayo 62.7 6.0 3.0 1.3 7.6% 15.2% .289 88 93 4.96 113 0.0
Nate Pearson 55.7 8.4 4.7 1.1 11.6% 20.9% .291 92 91 4.69 109 0.0
Carlos Estévez 45.3 7.1 3.6 1.2 9.5% 19.0% .281 94 89 4.60 106 0.0
Felix Arronde 95.3 5.5 3.8 1.4 9.3% 13.5% .288 79 84 5.45 127 0.0
Luke Jackson 33.0 7.6 4.6 1.1 11.6% 19.2% .292 93 86 4.66 108 0.0
Aaron Bummer 35.3 8.4 3.8 1.0 9.4% 20.6% .299 89 86 4.36 112 -0.1
Anthony Gose 44.7 8.5 4.6 1.2 11.5% 21.0% .297 93 85 4.69 108 -0.1
Connor Seabold 60.0 7.1 3.6 1.2 8.8% 17.2% .300 82 80 4.81 122 -0.1
Hobie Harris 33.0 7.4 5.2 1.4 12.5% 17.8% .297 88 80 5.21 114 -0.1
Craig Kimbrel 41.7 8.4 5.2 1.1 13.0% 21.1% .290 91 87 4.78 110 -0.1
Shane Panzini 60.3 6.9 4.8 1.3 11.5% 16.5% .292 80 84 5.30 125 -0.1
Matt Moore 26.3 7.5 4.4 1.4 11.0% 18.6% .293 84 78 5.04 119 -0.1
Beck Way 63.0 7.4 4.4 1.1 10.8% 18.2% .289 86 89 5.00 116 -0.1
Andrew Morones 27.7 7.8 4.9 1.3 11.9% 19.0% .288 88 93 5.02 113 -0.1
Nolan Hoffman 53.7 8.0 4.5 1.2 11.1% 19.7% .295 89 89 4.84 113 -0.1
Scott Barlow 47.0 8.6 5.6 1.0 13.8% 21.4% .285 90 84 4.78 111 -0.2
Chazz Martinez 48.7 7.8 4.8 1.1 11.7% 18.8% .291 90 92 4.87 112 -0.2
Génesis Cabrera 43.7 7.8 4.5 1.4 11.2% 19.4% .289 87 87 5.14 115 -0.2
Zachary Cawyer 59.0 7.3 4.3 1.2 10.6% 18.1% .289 88 93 4.70 113 -0.3
Alex Lange 50.0 9.0 5.0 1.3 12.4% 22.2% .291 89 86 4.95 113 -0.3
Chase Jessee 57.3 7.1 5.8 1.1 13.8% 16.8% .288 81 83 5.36 124 -0.3
Aaron Sanchez 44.3 5.7 5.3 1.4 12.4% 13.3% .296 71 67 6.03 141 -0.3
Jose Cuas 48.3 8.2 5.2 1.3 12.5% 19.6% .297 86 80 5.26 117 -0.3
Luke Little 50.7 8.3 5.7 0.9 13.7% 20.2% .283 87 89 5.00 115 -0.3
Caden Monke 44.7 8.3 6.2 1.0 14.7% 19.4% .291 86 88 5.12 117 -0.3
Anthony Simonelli 35.3 6.6 4.6 1.3 11.1% 16.0% .290 81 82 5.21 124 -0.3
Ethan Bosacker 72.0 4.9 3.6 1.5 8.9% 12.0% .286 77 80 5.65 131 -0.3
Andrew Pérez 41.7 7.3 5.4 1.3 13.0% 17.6% .291 80 80 5.40 125 -0.3
Dan Altavilla 38.3 6.3 5.2 1.2 12.6% 15.4% .289 80 77 5.31 125 -0.4
Frank Mozzicato 70.3 7.5 6.8 1.4 15.8% 17.6% .289 75 80 5.89 134 -0.4
Helcris Olivárez 30.7 8.2 8.2 1.2 18.4% 18.4% .284 70 73 6.44 143 -0.4
Brandon Johnson 58.3 7.4 4.8 1.4 11.7% 18.0% .291 82 83 5.25 122 -0.4
Christian Chamberlain 33.0 7.9 6.8 1.1 15.8% 18.4% .284 75 78 5.87 133 -0.5
Dennis Colleran Jr. 50.3 6.6 5.5 1.3 13.3% 15.9% .285 78 82 5.51 129 -0.7
Tommy Molsky 50.7 6.6 5.3 1.1 12.6% 15.5% .285 76 80 5.53 132 -0.7

Pitchers – Top Near-Age Comps
Player Pit Comp 1 Pit Comp 2 Pit Comp 3
Michael Wacha Ervin Santana Jeff Samardzija Dave Stewart
Noah Cameron Tom Browning Frank Viola Dave McNally
Bryce Miller Matt Garza Ervin Santana Marty Pattin
Cole Ragans Rudy May Ted Gray Tom Underwood
Lucas Braun Daniel Mengden Chad Kuhl Terry Doyle
Stephen Kolek Iván Nova Brad Penny Chien-Ming Wang
Seth Lugo Al Gettel Jeremy Guthrie Red Munger
Randy Dobnak Jason Johnson Scott Erickson Murray Wall
Daniel Lynch IV Ross Detwiler Mike Montgomery Guy Hoffman
Ryan Bergert Gordon Rhodes Jared Mortensen Keith Creel
Luinder Avila Tony Runion Jefry Rodriguez Alex Colomé
Justin Lamkin Frank DiPino Greg Millikan Russ Swan
Hunter Owen Curt Young Tim Kalita Roenis Elías
Steven Cruz Pedro Báez Justin Speier Ron Davis
Angel Bastardo Johnny Barbato Ronald Uviedo Ricky Torres
Drew Beam Raúl Alcántara Zach Eflin Walker Lockett
Mitch Spence Drew Gagnon Kendall Graveman Mike Wright
Logan Evans Parker Bridwell Evan Greusel Luis Andújar
José A. Ferrer Jim Crawford Roberto Ramirez Ken Frailing
Henry Williams Jackson Stephens David Hess Heath Fillmyer
Steven Zobac Ben Ally Cory Satterfield Ben Thurmond
Matt Strahm Greg Swindell Craig Lefferts Brian Duensing
Easton McGee Anthony Bass Pedro Villarreal William Wolfe
Tony Gonsolin Red Munger Ike Delock Ray Phelps
Mason Black Brock Stewart Paul Clemens Heath Fillmyer
Ryan Ramsey Trevor Lubking Ben Braymer Kramer Sneed
Lucas Erceg Ronald Belisario Jim Johnson Luis García
Grant Gambrell Greg Gohr Jim McGlothlin Paul Rigdon
Connor Thomas Rowdy Hardy Larry Jaster Virgil Conley
Spencer Bivens Frank Sullivan Dave Wehrmeister Jackie Brown
Tyson Guerrero Bill Pulsipher James Leverton Rob Henkel
John Means Hal Newhouser Fernando Valenzuela Eric Milton
Vince Velasquez Mel Harder Vic Sorrell Dwight Gooden
Hunter Patteson Ryan Spille Thomas Dorminy Keith Ramsey
Augusto Mendieta Eduardo Paredes Alex Pacheco Andy Kimball
Ben Kudrna Albert Guenthner Mike Keirstead Andrew Thurman
Ben Sears Anthony Bass J.R. Graham Chris White
Carlos Duran Brian Akin Isidro Marquez Corey Copping
Nick Mears Chris Ray Logan Ondrusek Jairo Asencio
Scott Alexander Steve Frey Darold Knowles Ramon Hernandez
Oscar Rayo Matt Crouse Efrain Nieves Carlos Pulido
Nate Pearson Tom Wilhelmsen Mike Overy Bill Kelso
Carlos Estévez Jumbo Diaz Tom Wilhelmsen Dale Thayer
Felix Arronde Emmanuel Ramirez David Scranton Michael Kraich
Luke Jackson Don Aase Bob Babcock Felix Rodriguez
Aaron Bummer Scott Aldred Vic Darensbourg Rich Rundles
Anthony Gose Dave Tomlin Jerry Don Gleaton Mark Guthrie
Connor Seabold Roy Wilkinson Mike Johnson Chris Leroux
Hobie Harris Mike Koplove Jim Ed Warden Miguel Duarte
Craig Kimbrel Grant Balfour Don McMahon Jose Valverde
Shane Panzini John Bilello Andrew Moss Steve Delabar
Matt Moore Grant Jackson Joe Gibbon Bob McClure
Beck Way Austin Brice Tom Wilhelmsen Victor Alcántara
Andrew Morones Steve Larose Daniel Gorden Kevin Meistickle
Nolan Hoffman Gerald Herron John Pawlowski Bob Scott
Scott Barlow Louis Coleman Mike Williams Scot Shields
Chazz Martinez Atahualpa Severino Mike Dalton Jordan Mills
Génesis Cabrera Josh Osich Mike Willis Edgar Huerta
Zachary Cawyer Dovydas Neverauskas Jay Aldrich Angel Nesbitt
Alex Lange Justin Grimm Dick Radatz John Purdin
Chase Jessee Mark Freed Dave Walsh Phil Nastu
Aaron Sanchez P.J. Ochoa Marco Quevedo Ryan Harris
Jose Cuas Jim Brower Ron Piche Jose Alberro
Luke Little Frankie Griffin Dave Geisel Hipolito Pena
Caden Monke Julio Jimenez Todd Rizzo Matt Purke
Anthony Simonelli Jeff Williams Bill Snyder Hunter Davis
Ethan Bosacker Jose Reyes Matt Peacock Josh DeGraaf
Andrew Pérez Jordan Harrison Michael Strong Terry Hill
Dan Altavilla Tom Wilhelmsen Felix Rodriguez Alexi Ogando
Frank Mozzicato Jairo Labourt Richard Licklider Phil Harrison
Helcris Olivárez Matt Bullinger Bill White Ritchie Moody
Brandon Johnson Jordan Milbrath Paul Thornton Tyler Bremer
Christian Chamberlain Matt Bullinger Sean Runyan Tyler Ybarra
Dennis Colleran Jr. Alex Farfan Bill McGilivray Chip Cunningham
Tommy Molsky Dave Rooker Heathcliff Slocumb Jon Keller

Pitchers – Splits and Percentiles
Player BA vs. L OBP vs. L SLG vs. L BA vs. R OBP vs. R SLG vs. R 80th WAR 20th WAR 80th ERA 20th ERA
Michael Wacha .234 .294 .379 .263 .314 .445 3.1 1.4 3.64 4.64
Noah Cameron .227 .291 .393 .255 .313 .421 2.9 1.1 3.68 4.72
Bryce Miller .245 .310 .437 .240 .292 .401 2.5 0.8 3.72 4.84
Cole Ragans .245 .316 .422 .213 .292 .364 2.4 0.6 3.18 4.87
Lucas Braun .248 .306 .404 .270 .320 .440 2.1 0.5 3.91 5.04
Stephen Kolek .262 .319 .395 .260 .316 .411 1.8 0.7 3.80 4.76
Seth Lugo .268 .339 .460 .261 .317 .426 1.8 0.1 4.13 5.42
Randy Dobnak .279 .355 .456 .273 .333 .419 1.6 0.4 4.21 5.15
Daniel Lynch IV .247 .317 .376 .254 .313 .423 1.4 0.1 3.80 5.09
Ryan Bergert .253 .335 .424 .250 .322 .417 1.2 0.2 4.05 5.13
Luinder Avila .248 .344 .383 .245 .327 .399 1.2 0.1 4.08 5.21
Justin Lamkin .236 .309 .361 .247 .324 .409 1.0 0.2 3.81 4.99
Hunter Owen .246 .315 .360 .264 .339 .463 1.0 -0.2 4.43 5.59
Steven Cruz .218 .298 .356 .238 .310 .415 1.0 -0.2 3.34 4.94
Angel Bastardo .238 .336 .400 .242 .326 .403 1.0 0.0 3.74 5.10
Drew Beam .263 .325 .426 .281 .332 .462 1.0 -0.3 4.59 5.66
Mitch Spence .266 .327 .435 .268 .329 .445 1.0 -0.2 4.45 5.58
Logan Evans .255 .327 .441 .281 .344 .443 0.8 0.0 4.45 5.42
José A. Ferrer .244 .317 .356 .252 .320 .374 0.9 0.0 3.32 4.61
Henry Williams .253 .344 .414 .274 .343 .459 0.9 -0.3 4.68 5.67
Steven Zobac .274 .336 .469 .262 .323 .433 0.7 0.0 4.47 5.56
Matt Strahm .262 .328 .410 .235 .305 .435 0.7 -0.3 3.40 5.38
Easton McGee .277 .351 .436 .237 .297 .378 0.6 -0.2 3.90 5.23
Tony Gonsolin .252 .336 .439 .250 .327 .450 0.5 -0.2 4.54 5.86
Mason Black .245 .340 .442 .274 .343 .438 0.7 -0.4 4.50 5.64
Ryan Ramsey .250 .355 .408 .261 .346 .429 0.7 -0.6 4.73 6.01
Lucas Erceg .253 .359 .384 .236 .315 .336 0.6 -0.4 3.63 5.08
Grant Gambrell .273 .348 .465 .269 .331 .440 0.5 -0.2 4.63 5.71
Connor Thomas .256 .309 .407 .272 .337 .432 0.5 -0.3 4.17 5.38
Spencer Bivens .279 .361 .465 .252 .314 .415 0.7 -0.4 4.01 5.39
Tyson Guerrero .254 .338 .388 .254 .350 .445 0.5 -0.3 4.61 5.90
John Means .276 .323 .448 .273 .329 .485 0.3 0.0 4.25 5.36
Vince Velasquez .282 .371 .466 .245 .324 .447 0.6 -0.4 4.60 6.01
Hunter Patteson .238 .302 .389 .292 .363 .491 0.6 -0.5 4.84 5.99
Augusto Mendieta .228 .321 .395 .258 .322 .402 0.5 -0.4 3.82 5.23
Ben Kudrna .266 .344 .417 .274 .351 .470 0.5 -0.4 4.85 6.01
Ben Sears .255 .320 .418 .270 .340 .423 0.5 -0.3 4.30 5.41
Carlos Duran .239 .377 .380 .237 .341 .407 0.6 -0.4 4.06 5.55
Nick Mears .260 .333 .425 .236 .317 .382 0.4 -0.3 3.71 5.14
Scott Alexander .256 .326 .436 .270 .347 .429 0.2 -0.3 3.86 5.72
Oscar Rayo .266 .337 .392 .263 .332 .456 0.5 -0.4 4.31 5.58
Nate Pearson .253 .364 .424 .239 .323 .385 0.5 -0.5 4.01 5.56
Carlos Estévez .260 .337 .429 .239 .317 .413 0.4 -0.5 3.92 5.51
Felix Arronde .267 .358 .455 .275 .342 .459 0.4 -0.5 5.05 5.98
Luke Jackson .222 .323 .333 .270 .353 .473 0.2 -0.3 3.96 5.54
Aaron Bummer .255 .328 .418 .244 .340 .384 0.3 -0.4 3.97 5.94
Anthony Gose .224 .297 .328 .265 .365 .462 0.4 -0.7 3.70 6.09
Connor Seabold .271 .351 .449 .262 .338 .413 0.3 -0.5 4.58 6.04
Hobie Harris .233 .333 .383 .288 .369 .493 0.2 -0.4 4.16 5.75
Craig Kimbrel .243 .364 .446 .238 .337 .357 0.3 -0.6 3.90 6.45
Shane Panzini .267 .371 .448 .261 .340 .428 0.3 -0.5 4.81 6.05
Matt Moore .286 .355 .429 .250 .341 .461 0.2 -0.5 4.21 6.77
Beck Way .280 .381 .449 .229 .327 .379 0.3 -0.7 4.47 5.84
Andrew Morones .245 .351 .429 .262 .343 .443 0.1 -0.3 4.23 5.61
Nolan Hoffman .260 .368 .448 .241 .326 .379 0.3 -0.6 4.15 5.68
Scott Barlow .237 .376 .421 .230 .339 .340 0.2 -0.8 4.09 6.29
Chazz Martinez .246 .347 .344 .250 .346 .432 0.2 -0.6 4.22 5.60
Génesis Cabrera .258 .361 .403 .255 .336 .464 0.1 -0.6 4.28 5.89
Zachary Cawyer .264 .347 .434 .244 .315 .397 0.2 -0.7 4.30 5.55
Alex Lange .232 .337 .402 .245 .359 .409 0.3 -0.7 3.97 5.76
Chase Jessee .243 .357 .371 .256 .371 .423 0.1 -0.7 4.71 6.05
Aaron Sanchez .279 .394 .500 .280 .370 .441 0.0 -0.6 5.48 6.89
Jose Cuas .280 .410 .488 .239 .328 .385 0.1 -0.7 4.32 5.96
Luke Little .231 .375 .308 .236 .364 .402 0.1 -0.7 4.35 5.78
Caden Monke .228 .371 .316 .252 .366 .429 0.0 -0.7 4.42 5.85
Anthony Simonelli .254 .353 .407 .265 .347 .458 -0.1 -0.7 4.75 6.26
Ethan Bosacker .273 .352 .430 .282 .350 .509 0.1 -0.8 5.06 6.16
Andrew Pérez .246 .347 .385 .260 .370 .460 0.0 -0.7 4.76 6.24
Dan Altavilla .270 .370 .444 .250 .350 .409 -0.1 -0.7 4.70 6.45
Frank Mozzicato .272 .394 .420 .247 .370 .449 0.1 -1.1 5.14 6.83
Helcris Olivárez .205 .404 .333 .256 .416 .449 -0.2 -0.8 5.52 7.37
Brandon Johnson .262 .353 .437 .256 .349 .434 0.0 -1.0 4.64 6.15
Christian Chamberlain .233 .389 .349 .241 .390 .422 -0.2 -0.8 4.97 6.64
Dennis Colleran Jr. .289 .386 .495 .225 .339 .363 -0.3 -1.0 4.96 6.27
Tommy Molsky .253 .377 .391 .259 .373 .429 -0.4 -1.1 5.19 6.36

Players are listed with their most recent teams wherever possible. This includes players who are unsigned or have retired, players who will miss 2027 due to injury, and players who were released in 2026. So yes, if you see Joe Schmoe, who quit baseball back in August to form a post-industrial, Gregorian-chant, bubblegum-Reggaeton band that only performs at rural zoning board meetings, he’s still listed here intentionally. ZiPS is assuming a league with an ERA of 4.18.

Hitters are ranked by zWAR, which is to say, WAR values as calculated by me, Dan Szymborski, whose surname is spelled with a z. WAR values might differ slightly from those that appear in the full release of ZiPS. Finally, I will advise anyone against — and might karate chop anyone guilty of — merely adding up WAR totals on a depth chart to produce projected team WAR. It is important to remember that ZiPS is agnostic about playing time, and has no information about, for example, how quickly a team will call up a prospect or what veteran has fallen into disfavor.

As always, incorrect projections are either caused by misinformation, a non-pragmatic reality, or by the skillful sabotage of our friend and former editor. You can, however, still get mad at me on Twitter or on Bluesky. This last is, however, not an actual requirement.


Effectively Wild Episode 2559: Did Fortune Favor Our Bold Preseason Predictions?

EWFI
Ben Lindbergh and Meg Rowley welcome FanGraphs’ Ben Clemens and Michael Baumann and EW scorekeeper Chris Hanel to review the results of the fourth annual bold preseason predictions game. First, they round up recent Hot Stove activity, including qualifying offer acceptances, the Maikel Garcia trade, and the Sonny Gray signing. Then (24:14) Baumann subjects Ben to a game of “College Baseball Player or Video Game Character?”, followed (33:11) by a brief discussion of minor league free agent draft results. Finally (36:20), they recap their 40 bold preseason predictions, announce a winner, and share assorted competition fun facts.

Audio intro: Kite Person, “Effectively Wild Theme”
Audio outro: Xavier LeBlanc, “Effectively Wild Theme”

Link to Kreidler post
Link to Baumann on QO acceptances
Link to over/under draft leaderboard
Link to Clemens on May
Link to lowest strand rates
Link to “WDJDD?” (short)
Link to “WDJDD?” (long)
Link to Clemens on Garcia trade
Link to 2026 team 3B WAR
Link to MLBTR on Gray
Link to MLBTR on Fortes
Link to Baumann competitions wiki
Link to MLFAD results
Link to all-time MLFAD results
Link to EW guest appearances
Link to Manfred quote
Link to preseason predictions
Link to 2026 knuckleballers
Link to 2026 Royals WAR leaders
Link to 2026 2B IP leaders
Link to Lynn’s Halloween costume
Link to Jed York article
Link to Mattson video
Link to Mattson press release
Link to Mattson Reddit post
Link to Brewers OF WAR ranking
Link to Benge walk-up songs
Link to Ben on transaction trees
Link to AO3 restoration news
Link to Vitello/Shanahan fic
Link to QuizCentral
Link to title dispute story

 Sponsor Us on Patreon
 Give a Gift Subscription
 Email Us: podcast@fangraphs.com
 Effectively Wild Subreddit
 Effectively Wild Wiki
 Apple Podcasts Feed 
 Spotify Feed
 YouTube Playlist
 Facebook Group
 Bluesky Account
 Twitter Account
 Get Our Merch!

01:50:22

Mariners, Royals Kick Off Trade Season With Blockbuster Six-Player Swap

Denny Medley and Stephen Brashear-Imagn Images

The offseason is off and running earlier than normal this year. Several top free agents have already signed, and more seem likely to follow. Today, the trade market got started as well. In the first big deal of the offseason, the Mariners and Royals linked up on a six-player trade. As ESPN’s Jeff Passan first reported, Maikel Garcia is headed to Seattle along with James McArthur and relief prospect L.P. Langevin, with Bryce Miller, José A. Ferrer, and Logan Evans going back to Kansas City in the deal.

I’ve never understood the obsession with “winning every trade.” Playoff spots aren’t determined by who racked up the most trade points in the past year. But in this case, I’ll make an exception. I understand what both teams were thinking when making this trade. Each is improving upon a perceived weakness without breaking the bank or trading any of its top minor leaguers. But I like the Mariners’ side a lot more, because they got the best player in the deal and also the longest-controlled player (Garcia in both cases). Still, it’s worth looking at the deal from both perspectives to see why this swap happened, and how it could pan out for each team.

Let’s start with the Mariners, who have been linked to a pitching-for-hitting trade for years at this point. And while their 76-86 disappointment was as much a failure of run prevention as run scoring, they came into the offseason with clear holes on the position player side and a pitching surplus. Randy Arozarena is a free agent after a career year in Seattle. J.P. Crawford also departed, and while his defense has been declining for years at this point, his steady offense was quite valuable.

But the Mariners don’t just need offense from their hitters. They were the worst defensive team in baseball last year, and the problems started in the infield. All told, they were 55 runs below average by FRV or 28 below average by DRS, and whichever of those metrics you prefer, they’re both stunningly bad. None of the 15 Mariners who played the field most frequently last year ranked as above average in both systems; only two (Cole Young and Josh Naylor) got positive marks in even one of the two. Read the rest of this entry »


The Most and Least Accurate Infield Arms

John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images

Yesterday, I wrote my second article exploring Baseball Savant’s new first base receiving leaderboard. Today, we’re going to explore a different side of the leaderboard, because as is so often the case with new Baseball Savant tools, it provides way more information to us baseball nerds than the name would lead you to expect. We’re going to take advantage of the fact that it also allows you to look things up in the other direction. That is, we can do more than just look up the stats of first basemen. We can also look up which infielders got the most help from their first basemen, and we can use that information to learn all sorts of things.

In 2026, Brayan Rocchio and Mookie Betts were tied at the top of the leaderboard. Their first basemen saved 4 Outs Above Average by scooping their throws well, which shouldn’t be surprising, seeing as they spent much of the season throwing to Freddie Freeman and Kyle Manzardo, who both graded out very well. Matt Chapman is at the very bottom of the leaderboard, and Phillies Alec Bohm and Trea Turner are also in the bottom four. Again, this is only logical, as those players were throwing to the two worst receiving first basemen in the league in Rafael Devers and Bryce Harper. However, the leaderboard lets us do more than see who got help and who didn’t.

It also lets us see who’s giving their first baseman a chance to make the play in the first place. Each player is given an average expected out rate based on their throws, and if you dig into the numbers further, you can find the players who rack up the most on-target throws. For example, Dodgers second baseman Alex Freeland led all qualified players with a 99.8% expected out rate. He had a smaller sample size, and he was throwing from the easiest position, but he was still pretty impressive. Ninety-five of his 99 throws were classified as on target, and even those that weren’t were catchable. So far as I can tell, this is the throw that Statcast considered his worst of the entire season.

Read the rest of this entry »