Eric Longenhagen Prospects Chat: 11/13/26
Eric Longenhagen
Hi from the kitchen island in cloudy Tempe, where the FanGraphs Meteorology Team is monitoring the storm cell that just passed over ASU Spring Break mainstay, Rocky Point.
Eric Longenhagen
I'm gonna hang out here for an hour and then re-evaluate the forecast. If things look dicey for our first AFL semifinal game of the day, I'll hang out a bit longer.
Eric Longenhagen
Good day game pitching matchup there, though. https://www.mlb.com/gameday/desert-dogs-vs-saguaros/2026/11/…
scotth855
Congrats on starting the 2027 prospect cycle! Anything new that you're excited about for these updates?
Eric Longenhagen
Yeah, I think you might see aspects of the format evolve during this cycle. I just think things like the System Overview need a fresh coat of paint. I'm working on Yankees now. I'm excited to go do minor league ST in Florida next year. Usually, MLB Spring Training is prohibitive for FL travel because it's super expensive and crowded. WHy do that when I can stay home for the AZ version. But with Minor League ST essentially immune from the labor strife, getting over there earlier than April/May (which is usually when I go, for the time period when Extended and FSL stuff are going simultaneously) will give us a deeper look at the full season affiliates there.
Eric Longenhagen
Plus, February/March is better for HS scouting in FL than April/May.
Charles Bengal Tiger
Dynasty draft coming up soon and I need a big stick that will provide middle of the order impact down the road. Would either of Taitn Gray or Murf Gray be my man?
Eric Longenhagen
I feel better about Taitn's plate discipline and hit tool.
Definitely Not an AI Bot
How are the minors going to work during the lockout? I think I read that anyone on a 40-man can't play? How is this going to affect team strategy and overall player dev next year?
Eric Longenhagen
It might depend on how teams are informed of Rule 5 Draft changes/cancellations, but if we assume no Rule 5 Draft (which is what happened in '21) then the number of players who'll be new 40-man additions will be low, and the impact will be minimal. The players who'll be impacted are the ones who were put on the 40-man late enough in 2026 that they remain prospect-eligible. Which you can basically see a list of in the right margin here: https://www.fangraphs.com/prospects
Eric Longenhagen
I think a shorter season might end up being good for pitchers' late-season stuff, everyone's work load will be a little bit lighter.
Eric Longenhagen
Teams might try to sneak remote dev programs in for some of the pitchers, or launder them through the third party facilities' people. I would.
ED44
I seem to recall you were pretty high on Serwinowski? Still see him as a starter? Thanks!
Eric Longenhagen
I did and do like him a lot. The chances of his starting are dwindling, but I think his floor is a really, really nasty lefty reliever, and I value him as if he were a BJ Ryan, Sean Doolittle type of guy who is a setup man/closer type.
Charles Bengal Tiger
Wandy Asigen didn't play a lot this season. Does he still project as a "for sure" shortstop? Is he likely to keep his 45+?
Eric Longenhagen
Not a "lock", still so young. On tape, lokay enough to keep developing there, but not great right now.
nicklocarno
No longer a prospect, but have you got thoughts on Triston Casas moving forward?
Eric Longenhagen
I thought he was going to have such big lefty power that the swing and miss, on balance, would be palatable. I saw that Breslow said something like Casas "might" get winter league at-bats. How is that not something you know will happen or not at this stage of the schedule? Why isn't he here in AZ crushing guys and providing some notion of how he looks to inform whether he needs a winter league assignment or not? Is he not healthy yet? I'd assess how he looks when he actually plays before offering an updated opinion, he's in flux.
jimmysharkey35
What is the latest update on Aidan Miller's health and ETA for 2027?
Eric Longenhagen
He's healthy and has been playing in Arizona, where he's walked a ton and has not hit for much power.
Eric Longenhagen
The state of the league at 3B has dipped substantially as Arenado, Machado, Chapman, etc. have aged, and as Devers has moved to 1B, and Ramirez had a down year. Here's the year-by-year, league-wide offensive performance at 3B the last while… https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders/major-league?stats=bat&lg=…
Eric Longenhagen
I think Miller will do enough to profile as an average everyday option, but I'd rather have Maikel Garcia, or Miguel Vargas, McGongile, Josh Jung, and I'd guess at least a couple of the old guys either bounce back or sustain (like Muncy has) enough to be a better producer there, too.
Cromulent
Curious how Made, Morales, Brito, Level and others ended up in winter ball rather than Arizona Fall League. Any insight on how teams decide?
Eric Longenhagen
I think the pitching in those leagues is more challenging than the AFL.
Eric Longenhagen
And the environment is more tense and lively.
Charles Bengal Tiger
He's post-prospect now, but do you think Zac Thornton will be in the rotation full time for the Mets this coming season?
Eric Longenhagen
In a universe where most of their guys are healthy, I bet he's up and down.
StuShea
Hello. Thanks for chatting. Anyone who has knocked your socks off so far?
Eric Longenhagen
Lena, the 42-year-old reiki healer in Sarasota.
jdbolick
While command was always a weakness for Luis Morales, did you ever hear an explanation for why he completely lost the ability to throw strikes last season?
Eric Longenhagen
When it's that bad, I don't think there's an autopsy you can do perform to identify some lone, definable cause.
liljebbie10
After his first season in the majors, has your opinion changed at all on Konnor Griffin? Or do you still see him as a future superstar?
Eric Longenhagen
The 20-year-old who just posted a league-average batting line? He's good, chatter. Give it a second.
Eric Longenhagen
"Would you give it a second? It's gotta go to space."
drplantwrench
any player that has surprised you this AFL?
Eric Longenhagen
Whelk
I love Santiago Suarez. He is a pitcher that throws a ton of strikes but his arsenal is seemingly slow to develop. Do you feel that he'd stick on a big league roster if taken in the Rule 5 draft?
Eric Longenhagen
Tampa really only has guys in the minors throw two pitches. Like an overwhelming majority of their prospects are two pitch guys, there's barely a hint of a third let alone serious usage of it. I think it's more to do with org dev style than Suarez himself. I think he'd stick in a relief role, yeah. It's tough for a guy like him to stick in a *rotation* all year without being optioned, though, and so you're kinda goofing his development some to deploy him, say, like the Jays masterfulluy deployed Spencer Miles this year.
drplantwrench
also do the saguaros have the best hats in the AFL?
Eric Longenhagen
AFL Hat Pref List and Grades:
Surprise (70) – Kelly green brim, the cactus is wearing a bandana, awesome
Glendale (60)- Orange brim, cool idea but coyote silhouette isn't drawn well
Scottsdale (50)- Red/black scorpion, average in every way
Salt River (45)- Love the brim color, miss the old logo. The new one looks like a toothpaste brand
Peoria (40)- Grey and lime green just doesn't play, best team name tho
Mesa (30)- I think the logo is way too big
riibett
Brendan mentioned the Braves list is due up next, who is "your guy" in that system?
Eric Longenhagen
Sears, Carey, Sinnard
Neil Baumgarten
Hey Eric – Great work at FPAZ last week. I got to see Tate Southisene a few times. I know you have been (correctly) critical of his defense in the past. I think you were easy on him. Will he be the major league's first mini-sized DH? Thanks!
Eric Longenhagen
TY, I'm comfortable speaking in front of however many people but less so individually afterward for whatever reason. 70 runner, try CF proactively, please.
Petey Bienel
Any new thoughts on Bazzell's defense after his AFL? Really started with a poor caught stealing performances. Is that just a quirk of the AFL (runners being very good, not being comfortable with pitchers, etc…)?
Eric Longenhagen
Throwing well for me, receiving and block not so much. Pitchers here are mostly 1.70 to the plate, the CS stuff isn't his fault.
Phil
Is it reasonable to conclude that A, the Red Sox will only trade Arias for a shortstop, and B, they don't have enough top guys left for a splashy deal that doesn't involve Arias? (Meaning C, unless they trade for a top shortstop, they're mostly looking at free agency and getting their current guys healthy to improve.)
Eric Longenhagen
That's probably too narrow. They have enough depth that they can make a big deal, still. It might limit their partners to teams who seem to prioritize depth in their returns, like Miami or Baltimore seem to. There are enough lemons with a good data point or two in that system who you can trick Miami's formula into thinking might be good.
Eric Longenhagen
Not great, folks https://www.accuweather.com/en/us/tempe/85281/weather-radar/…
Chris B
Assuming Seaver King comes up in 2027, would you anticipate he would play at SS with Abrams at 2B (assuming Abrams consents)?
Eric Longenhagen
On my looks Seaver has had some pretty severe throwing accuracy issues, he's a guy who I'll wipe the chalkboard clean for this offseason. As I'm sitting here I'd expect him to be up mid-year only if a) the team is playing well enough to feel like they're in the playoff mix AND b) Seaver doesn't regress. Otherwise he's a Sept add.
apeloton
Post prospect question – if you were evaluating Roman Anthony today, where would he land? How much if at all would the nagging hand/wrist issues be a factor in that?
Eric Longenhagen
Same grade: 60
nicklocarno
So, since MLB players are apparently allowed to play in foreign and/or indie leagues during a lockout… who would you most want to see suit up for the Savanna Bananas?
Eric Longenhagen
zapper
Does Zion Rose have the speed and the power to comp to Carl Crawford in leftfield?
Eric Longenhagen
Nah
Eric Longenhagen
Crawford was a 1 of 1 type guy, skills-wise and swing-wise most alike to Kenny Lofton. Zion is a nice player but he's not *that* talented, K-Lo/Crawford had multiple 5-7 WAR seasons
R.B. Urgess
How concerned are you about Edward Florentino's lower contact rates after promotion?
Eric Longenhagen
Not any more than we were before, the whiffing was always happening. Greensboro is a spot folks need to learn to take offense with a grain of salt. Big time lift/launch prospect who K's a ton is Florentino, there was an initial overreaction to his breakout I think.
rosineater
Emmanuel Rodriguez. I have no idea what to make of this guy. Is the top-100 prospect still in there or are we looking at a 4th OF at this point?
Eric Longenhagen
He could have a season or two like James Outman's rookie year, and then several seasons like Outman's sophomore season and beyond
Charles Bengal Tiger
Does Braylon Doughty have the upside of the guys like Messick, Williams, etc. who have graduated from the Guardians pitching development machine?
Eric Longenhagen
Not Williams', maybe Messick's (to be clear, what I think Messick's overall output will be , which I don't think will be prorated '26).
Michael
Tony Blanco Jr upside Giancarlo Stanton or can he fake it in the field? Who's you best case comp?
Eric Longenhagen
When Stanton was Blanco's age, he had 85 career big league home runs and halfway through his second consecutive 35-homer season. Blanco has played 80 games above low-A. Blanco's future is probably more like Chris Carter's.
Charles Bengal Tiger
Is there a verdict yet for the Charles Davalan infield experiment?
Eric Longenhagen
Positive, wrote about here: https://blogs.fangraphs.com/arizona-fall-league-midseason-ch…
nicklocarno
In a previous chat you said you liked the Tigers' draft, specifically mentioning a "kid from AZ who throws 100 and was kept pretty well hidden". Is that KJ Ward? And is he, like, a good arm strength RP flier, or is there more there?
Eric Longenhagen
Yes. Probably a RP but let's see. Gorgeous arm action, up to 100, sitting 98. Got in way better shape from '23 to '25 and '26
Anonymous Member #46
Speaking of knocking off socks, any prospects of note out there still rocking stirrups?
Eric Longenhagen
I haven't seen anyone wearing the Wimberlys
Toby Keith Whitley
I read an excerpt re: Joniel Hernandez, essentially downplaying some of his DSL performance because he was signed out of Cuba, suggesting he was more advanced for an age because of the Cuban background. Do the int'l kids signed out to Cuba tend to have more experience seeing high level velo and spin? I would have assumed the kids in the DR and VZ are seeing every bit as good talent.
Eric Longenhagen
More than anything I think Joniel crushed the DSL because he has ridiculous bat speed.
InsertWittyNameHere
If you had to continue your work during the lockout, which league would you want to do instead of MLB? NPB, KBO, LIDOM, MLB The Show, Little League?
Eric Longenhagen
I still have to continue working, for the record.
Eric Longenhagen
Send me to Japan. DR no. 2, little league last.
BKhipsterball
Did you read about the MLBPA's so-called nuclear option? What are your thoughts?
Eric Longenhagen
Decertification is not uncommon. Tough to file antitrust when the justice department is overtly sympathetic to the owners, might have to wait until that changes a bit early '27. I wouldn't decert unless that had already happened. I'd want it to feel actually threatening. Right now it doesn't.
ethanlowe
assume everyone in your current top 10 has graduated by this time next year (won't be the case, i know, but rock with me here), who do you think are some of the most likely prospects to have vaulted into those slots?
Eric Longenhagen
Josuar
New Brit Fan
Say more about "lemons with a good data point"?
Eric Longenhagen
https://www.fangraphs.com/players/dillon-lewis/sa3025515/sta…
Baseball Learner
Is there a gap between you and Brendan about Dax Kilby sticking at short? If there is, do you know who is closer to consensus?
Eric Longenhagen
Gap closed when I did film study this week. Was better regular season than here, which I'm inclined to lean on.
triplesandtea
What prospect's name sounds most like a piece of kitchen equipment?
Eric Longenhagen
procters1
Did you know Lawr Michaels?
Eric Longenhagen
Not well, intro'd through JGrey and the first pitch crew. Nice guy who people loved.
grandbranyan
Cam Wagoner (35.1 K% and 58 FIP- coming off two missed seasons), Jose Meneses (31.4 K% and 63 FIP- plus an AFL nod as a 21yo), and Braylon Owens (29.9 K% and 73 FIP- as a 10K sign) going to be getting some digital ink on the Brewer list?
Eric Longenhagen
Yes, Laurila turned me on to Wagoner. He's good.
Sonny L
What orgs have proven the best abilities to help prospects like Rainer fight their contact issues? He’ll never win a batting title, but if he was with org X you’d arrow up on reaching a useable baseline.
Eric Longenhagen
LA. See: Harlan, Chase.
higginsford
Bauers to Boston…maybe that's why Breslow gave a weird answer on Casas? But regardless, will be interesting to see how Bauers' games by position ends up next year. Think he or Contreras log more games at DH?
Eric Longenhagen
Oh shit, really? Hold please…
Eric Longenhagen
OKay yeah, gotta showcase Casas now.
Nils
Who are some prospects that could improve their stock the most by spending the offseason in the weight room?
Eric Longenhagen
Eric Longenhagen
framed mogged by Walcott all fall. get stronger!
Brendan Smith
Are there any plans to pivot content during the lockout? Similar to how COVID content looked with the daily prospect notes video series?
Eric Longenhagen
I bet the other writers will have to drum up more than me. Like I'd expect Michael to do college coverage because he naturally follows it and has experience doing it.
Cromulent
I asked a Made vs Pratt question but what I really want to know is how does Made’s defense look after a season that began with a widely noted weight gain, particularly in the lower half.
Eric Longenhagen
Ok SS in a vacuum but worse than Pratt, so 3B for Milwaukee.
rosineater
Follow up on Emmanuel Rodriguez. Fantasy question. Would you take him in a minor league draft (late first round, pick 10-15) over some of the FYPD guys either college or High school?
Eric Longenhagen
Depends on the guy. Gimme Grindlinger before ERod
BKhipsterball
Project Flewelling's FV if he is a catcher vs if he isn't
Eric Longenhagen
60 if he is, 50 if he isnt
Aaron Orheim
Any reaction to the news that the Mariners have made Ryan Sloan "untouchable?" As an Ms fan, I'd personally do Sloan for Gunnar Henderson, but maybe I'm in the minority.
Eric Longenhagen
Six years of Sloan for three of Gunnar? Tough to do that when your payroll seems like it can only be so much. I'd rather move Gilbert/Kirby for a bat and have cheap homegrown arms.
Eric Longenhagen
Like if Sloan is Gerrit Cole, you wanna have that guy
drplantwrench
can you bring up with the fact that is impossible to get a saguaros hat with the higher ups??
Eric Longenhagen
You've gotta get the good merch early on . I have a Sags hat that sits on a light up cactus which I've also adorned with its own bandana
Brendan Smith
What player archetype do you find yourself biased towards? Sort of how orgs tend to find players with similar traits throughout their systems
Eric Longenhagen
Switch hitting MIFs, big-framed catchers with power
Troy McKevitt
Did you get any looks at Carter Graham in the AFL? Had a bit of a breakout in 2026 but seemed to swing and miss a lot in the fall.
Eric Longenhagen
Darin Ruf 러프 type role
abaseballfan
will Oda have a FV after he signs or does he count as an international amateur who hasn't played stateside yet
Eric Longenhagen
the latter, Int'l amateur
wheelhouse
if you were brian cashman, what would you do with anthony volpe? what would you make of his wildly shapeshifting skillset that nonetheless results in an ~85 wRC+ year in year out?
Eric Longenhagen
You keep him as a part time 2B and reserve infielder behind a nomadic Cabby and Lombard on the depth chart, and see if he plays himself into having trade value
Eric Longenhagen
Just play him as if he were any other guy at this point
Eric Longenhagen
Which is worse than lombard and cabby
grandbranyan
Brewers have been playing match ups based on swing path versus the opposing SP's arsenal. With Bauers gone could Vaughn (flatter swing) and Luke Adams (more of an uppercut I believe) still make a decent platoon despite both being righties?
Eric Longenhagen
Just gimme Burke/Vaughn at that point
rsimmons07
If (when?) Ketel Marte ends up traded, do you think Demetrio Crisantes is ready to slide in at 2B? Do you give Troy a shot there first? Move Lawlar back to the IF?
Eric Longenhagen
Pretty underwhelming, I'd rather try Troy/Lawlar
Eric Longenhagen
Okay sluggers, nice long chat today. Great questions as always. I'm gonna take one more hard look at the forecast and decide whether to run all the way out there. I was only going to stay for the entire first game because I have comedy show tix in town tonight (star-studded weekend here for that) Take care, see you next week





