Author Archive: Michael Baumann

Bednar, Jeffers Accept Qualifying Offers

Brad Penner and Jesse Johnson-Imagn Images

OK, now we can start free agency.

Of the eight free agents who received a qualifying offer, two — David Bednar and Ryan Jeffers — are returning to their previous teams on one-year, $23.15 million deals. Jake Bauers never formally rejected the Brewers’ qualifying offer, but he signed a four-year contract with the Red Sox last week, which would make it kind of awkward if he tried to go back to Milwaukee now. Randy Arozarena, Brandon Lowe, Adrian Morejon, Trevor Rogers, and Seiya Suzuki will sail into free agency. Best of luck to them.

Since Bednar and Jeffers are de facto free agent signings, let’s explore what it means to the Yankees and Twins, respectively, that they’re getting these major free agents back. Read the rest of this entry »


Major League Baseball Knows What Its Problems Are, and It Doesn’t Need a Lockout To Fix Them

Patrick Breen-USA TODAY NETWORK

If you were on X, formerly known as Twitter, over the weekend, you might’ve seen a five-minute video posted to Major League Baseball’s official account.

It starts with a man staring right down the barrel of the camera, like Nietszche’s abyss. You might not know that face, but you should know the name: Morgan Sword. Read the rest of this entry »


Red Sox Ink Jake Bauers, Start Whole New First Base Logjam

Michael McLoone-Imagn Images

Last year, Pete Alonso was second among free agent hitters in wRC+ and seventh in WAR. He signed with the Orioles, entering his age-31 season, for five years and $155 million. In this year’s class, Jake Bauers — another first baseman entering his age-31 season — was second in wRC+ and fifth in WAR in his walk year.

The Red Sox jumped on Bauers early in free agency, signing him to a four-year, $58 million contract on Friday. That looks like a huge bargain at first glance. The big risk with sluggers on the free agent market is that they’re often bottom-of-the-defensive-spectrum guys in their early 30s, and players like that tend to age poorly.

The Red Sox not only got Bauers for less term than Alonso, but they shelled out less than half of the money per year. An AAV of $14.5 million isn’t cheap, but it’s basically the cost of a good setup guy, plus tax and tip. This for a dude who just finished seventh among qualified hitters in wRC+ and third in OBP, and hit in the middle of the order for the World Series champs. Read the rest of this entry »


The Tigers Are Pagán the Future of Their Bullpen on This Offseason’s First Free Agent Signing

Katie Stratman-Imagn Images

In the days before the 2021-22 lockout, there was an unprecedented leaguewide free agent spending bacchanal that set high expectations for this November. On Tuesday night, the Detroit Tigers showed up to the party and picked the first canapé off the tray, signing reliever Emilio Pagán to a one-year, $11 million contract.

Pagán is the first of our top 50 free agents to come off the board, and we’re starting from the bottom of the list: Ben Clemens had him ranked right at no. 50 and predicted a two-year, $16 million contract for the 35-year-old from South Carolina. Our crowdsourced predictions were the same, to within half a million dollars. Read the rest of this entry »


Give Adrian Morejon All the Money in the World, but Don’t Make Him a Starter

Denis Poroy-Imagn Images

I’ve decided that my guy in this free agent class is left-handed pitcher Adrian Morejon. Ben Clemens ranked him eighth on the top 50 free agent list, and predicted that he’d get $72 million over three years. Our readers came to a median estimate of $64 million over four years.

I think they’re out of their minds. Me? I would’ve had Morejon no lower than fifth in this caffeine free Diet Pepsi of a free agent class, perhaps as high as third. I’d give Morejon $100 million over five years without blinking.

I don’t get the sense that I’m sticking my neck out too far by saying this; someone’s going to pay over the odds for this non-closer reliever because they think they can translate his upper-90s velocity and elite groundball rate to the rotation. Morejon got four or more outs in 25 of his 78 regular-season appearances in 2026, and he has the elite changeup that conventional wisdom requires from a lefty starter.

But I don’t want Morejon to start. I’ve got something better in mind. Read the rest of this entry »


What Is Cooper Pratt Going To Do Now?

Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

Cooper Pratt was one of the revelations of the Brewers’ run to the World Series. He hit .354 overall and .421 in the Fall Classic itself, with hits that gave the Brewers the lead in Games 2, 4, and 5. His WPA was the third highest in World Series history for a player aged 22 or younger.

All that, in concert with the eight-year contract Pratt signed before he even made his big league debut, would seem to indicate that the precocious Mississippian is Milwaukee’s shortstop of the future. Perhaps even the far future; a little motivated reasoning and you can get to Pratt being Middle America’s 1996 Derek Jeter.

Except, having seen the best two weeks of Pratt’s life up close, I’m still not completely sure where he fits in the Brewers’ long-term plans. Let’s get dialectical about it. Read the rest of this entry »


Ring Out a Song of Good Cheer: The Milwaukee Brewers Are World Champions

Jonathan Dyer-Imagn Images

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — The past nine years were the best run in Milwaukee Brewers history: eight postseason appearances, six division titles, 869 regular-season wins, for a 93-win-per-season pace over almost a full decade. An MVP, a Cy Young — probably two, by this time next month — and plenty of turnover: two front office bosses, two field managers, 193 players.

But 11 teams had been to the World Series since 2018; six had won. Not the Brewers. Until this year.

The nervous 12-inning staring contest of Game 4 delayed Milwaukee’s coronation by just one day. Cooper Pratt put the Brewers ahead with an RBI single in the second. Jacob Misiorowski pitched the best game of his postseason career — 5 2/3 scoreless innings with just two singles and a walk allowed — before leaving with a cramp after 86 pitches.

The Brewers’ relentless offense tacked on some insurance runs in the middle innings and their indomitable bullpen held the line. The 4-1 final score reflected the Brewers’ most normal game so far this postseason, after a string of nail-biters and comebacks, punctuated by a massive blowout in Game 3. The most routine win of Milwaukee’s postseason didn’t feel it; the first championship in franchise history can’t be taken for granted until it’s in the bag. Read the rest of this entry »


Rays Bounce Into Game 5 After 12-Inning Thriller

Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — It didn’t always feel like a Rays home game. Multitudes of Brewers fans, unable to procure or afford tickets to Wisconsin’s first World Series games in 44 years, had flown to Florida to see their team clinch. But home field advantage played a part in the Rays’ improbable, dramatic 12-inning 4-3 win in Game 4 to extend the World Series at least one more night.

The Tropicana Field turf is one of the fastest playing surfaces in the league, and the Rays are able to derive an advantage from it that no other team can extract from its own home field. So while the Brewers took the lead in the top of the 12th by hitting the ball in the usual direction — up, in the form of Cooper Pratt’s solo home run — the Rays struck back with four grounders and a liner in the bottom of the inning.

The decisive hit, by Ben Williamson, went straight into the turf, bounced over Milwaukee’s drawn-in five-man infield, and landed… who cares where. The Rays are still alive. Read the rest of this entry »


Sink, Florida, Sink: Inside the Rally That Broke the World Series Open

Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — Pat Murphy, face stern and wide as ever, stepped forward and cupped his hands to his ears to signal a replay challenge.

With runners on first and second and two out in the top of the fifth inning of Game 3 of the World Series, William Contreras had just topped a ball to third. Instead of making a throw across the diamond, Junior Caminero went the short way for the force at second.

Caminero’s got a big arm, and Contreras is a catcher, but still — the Rays third baseman was on the move and off-balance after spinning to grab the ball. With two outs, Christian Yelich was running on contact, but the 34-year-old doesn’t run like he used to. Might as well go next door. It was a bang-bang play, but second base umpire Dan Bellino called Yelich out. Read the rest of this entry »


The Brewers, the Rays, and the Pumping of Tires

Jonathan Dyer and Benny Sieu-Imagn Images

MILWAUKEE — You all know the theoretical concept of a replacement-level player. I suspect I’m not the only one who associates that concept with a specific person: The guy who’s continuously mediocre despite repeated exposure to big league competition. The longer he sticks around, the more chances he gets, the more I catch myself thinking, “Why? Can’t they at least try to find someone better?”

Until this year, that guy, for me, was Jake Bauers. In his 20s, Bauers played for seven different organizations, spending six seasons in the majors. In 615 games, he hit .211/.307/.365, which is a wRC+ of 88, with 58 home runs, a 29.0% strikeout rate, and -0.4 career WAR. He was a first baseman, and not an exceptional defender, who hit for neither average nor power, and struck out a lot. He isn’t a great athlete, and as a seventh-round pick out of a high school in Huntington Beach, California, he had neither the prospect pedigree nor the winning collegiate track record that would warrant so many chances.

I didn’t get it, especially because Bauers had toured so many organizations — the Padres, the Rays, the Guardians, the Yankees, and most latterly the Brewers — who have earned a reputation for knowing what they’re doing. Why did this most replaceable of players keep getting chances? Read the rest of this entry »