Eno Sarris Baseball Chat — 1/23/14
11:47 |
: I’ll be here at the top of the hour!
|
12:00 |
You threw me out the building, the middle of the night |
12:00 |
Why are you so good looking? |
12:00 |
: Hah. Hopefully it’s not the hair, thinking of a big cut on Friday.
|
12:00 |
Which baseball player in MLB has the most swag? |
12:00 |
: Well if swag is car-related… Puig?
|
12:01 |
If Barry Bonds were magically signed by a team for this season, what would his line look like? |
12:01 |
: .230/.340/.380?
|
12:01 |
Are they really going to go with Ruben Tejada at short stop? |
12:01 |
: I think he can be a two-win player based on D and patience in the eight hole.
|
12:01 |
Stephen Strasburg signs a contract extension tomorrow, does it look like the Tanaka deal? |
12:01 |
: I think the injury thing with him keeps the numbers down.
|
12:02 |
When looking at a pitcher’s single season performance, the first thing I search for is how his BABIP compares to his career numbers. It occurred to me that it’d be easier if there was a stat for how lucky the pitcher was on the year, compared to his career norms for BABIP, LOB%, etc. What other inputs would go into such a stat? Ideally, how would it be structured? |
12:02 |
: I think you’re looking for SIERA, which uses BB, K, GB rates to estimate what the BABIP and LOB should have been. There are some inter-relations between K and BABIP and LOB (high K% means low BABIP and low LOB).
|
12:02 |
Which living member of the Hall of Fame would do best in MLB TODAY at their current age? |
12:02 |
: Greg Maddux I bet.
|
12:03 |
Best FA left on the market, for what team? |
12:04 |
: Morales, Drew, Cruz, Burnett, Garza, Ubaldo, Maholm… Probably Drew, probably Boston.
|
12:04 |
Curious about your education background. Where did you go to college and what was your degree in? When did you learn the heavy math? |
12:05 |
: I took three years of calculus and some linear algebra in high school in Boston (with Carson at prep school) and never took it again. Took some light statistics at Stanford, graduated with liberal arts degrees. I’m in the liberal arts wing.
|
12:05 |
Enus! Enus! Enus! Enus! |
12:05 |
: Oh god it’s followed me all the way from middle school latin class.
|
12:06 |
Hey Eno, you won’t be able to read through this during chat but I thought I’d share since it seemed to be interesting when paired with your “Building the Perfect Pitcher” piece re: Gerrit Cole: http://www.whygavs.com/pittsburgh-pirates/january-2014/gerrit-cole-and-curveballs.html |
12:06 |
: Oh yeah I saw he posted that and I wanted to read it before the chat but no time. I’ll take a look later.
|
12:06 |
What move are you the most surprised by, good or bad, this offseason? |
12:07 |
: I think maybe Loney signing with the Rays. I just figured they’d continue finding first basemen. And oh yea, Cano in Seattle was a bit of a shocker.
|
12:07 |
Nats really interested in Balfour? Isn’t Storen better or at least similar and for less money? Then the idea has to be to trade Storen right? who can they get for Storen..They need a back up catcher and somebody better than Moore for the Bench and LaRoche problem. Thanks Man. also do you like coffee stouts? |
12:08 |
: I do like coffee stouts but I tend to like them sweet with vanilla or chocolate in there too. As for Balfour/Storen… they don’t seem to love Storen as much as I do. But I guess he could return those kinds of players!
|
12:08 |
If playing in a fantasy league with 10 hitter and 10 pitcher (5 SP and 5 RP) slots does it make sense to spend equally on hitters and pitchers? |
12:09 |
: I wrote a piece about this last week, but I do think that the fact that pitchers are more volatile year to year and hit the DL more often and for longer means you should spend less on them.
|
12:09 |
So now that the NYYs have ended the charade about living on a budget, they rather MUST go trade shopping for a productive but expensive 2B/3B currently rostered by a frigne- or non-contender … yes? Someone like Utley would be perfect, though the Phils aren’t going to move him. Brandon Phillips maybe? Anyone else you can think of? |
12:10 |
: Wouldn’t be surprised if a Phillips deal happens now. They were close to 189 until Tanak so I do think they were trying to build the infield on the cheap. What about Aramis Ramirez??
|
12:10 |
What are your thoughts on Grady Sizemores return? How do you think he’ll do in 2014? .270/.350 25HR a reasonable projection? Any fantasy value? |
12:11 |
: His health particulars scared off a team. I say 250 PAs of .250/.330 maybe.
|
12:11 |
Cashner (16th rounder) or Profar (17th)? Could keep either up to 6 years with progressive round penalties. |
12:11 |
: Even with Profar’s reduced speed upside, I’ll take the second baseman over the pitcher.
|
12:11 |
What types of pitchers tend to end up as low FIP high ERA guys? |
12:12 |
: Hmm, it can’t be a homer problem… someone who consistently gives up bad BABIP or strand rates? Could be someone that is bad out of the stretch.
|
12:12 |
Rockies get off to slow start do Tulo and Cargo become available? If so, as a Mets fan would it require Syndergaard to land either of them? |
12:12 |
: Absolutely would require Thor. AS for it happening… there’s a bit of smoke there.
|
12:12 |
Hi Eno. Thoughts on Joc Pederson? I know Joc seems blocked at the ML, but… thinking I may take him in my Dev draft, over say, Maikel Franco… Insane? Would you take him over Khris Bryant or Owings? |
12:14 |
: I’m in a dev draft over at BP with a good list of people and I took Franco three before Pederson (end of second, beginning of third), but Bryant went eighth overall.
|
12:14 |
How many questions do you have in a queue at any given moment? Say, right now? |
12:15 |
: I’m looking at 11:57 and I’m maybe 9/10 of the way down to the bottom of the queue… oh boy.
|
12:15 |
Salazar or Gausman in a dynasty? |
12:16 |
: Love this question. Both have the great splitter, great velocity. Gausman better history of command. Now the question is, whose next pitch is better? I’ll go with pedigree and the former first round pick in Baltimore, especially since Gaus is probably cheaper right now.
|
12:16 |
K’plah! |
12:16 |
You and Pod really like looking at batted ball distance. How stable is that year to year? |
12:17 |
: Check out his three part series with Chad Young on the subject. Some interesting observations. It’s not rock solid, but I find it interesting to look at, and there is a link between batted ball distance and expected HR/FB.
|
12:17 |
Tanaka will finish up 2014 as a fantasy SP # ___ ? |
12:17 |
: Two. A younger Hiroki Kuroda.
|
12:17 |
: Good news in my chat box!
|
12:18 |
: Jeff Zimmerman thinks he’s found a usable xBABIP which beats last-year BABIP in predictability …. that’s something we’ve been looking for for a long time…
|
12:18 |
Hey Eno, If MLB were to expand to 32 teams, where would you suggest adding teams? |
12:18 |
: Montreal! Vegas!
|
12:18 |
There is a ghost ship full of cannibal rats headed straight for the UK. This is neither a drill nor the plot of Michael Bay’s next movie; it is wholly real. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/mystery-of-the-lyubov-orlova-ghost-ship-full-of-cannibal-rats-could-be-heading-for-british-coast-9080103.html |
12:18 |
: Wow I thought that was a joke I’m honestly a little scared right now.
|
12:19 |
In a keep forever dynasty, Liriano for Gausman? I can likely contend now, is Gaus too risky short term, overall? |
12:19 |
: Liriano scares the crap out of me. Just look at his career!
|
12:19 |
Welcome back Nyjer Morgan! |
12:19 |
: Oh he’s got some swag.
|
12:19 |
I took a tour of Flying Fish Brewery in NJ the other day. Flying Fish extra pale ale is criminally underrated on Beergraphs! |
12:19 |
: Beer is always at its best straight from the teat.
|
12:20 |
Expectations of an Kennedy?? |
12:20 |
: I like him better than some of the rankings I’ve seen.
|
12:20 |
are you at all concerned that cutting your hair will lead to a Samson-esque situation in which you lose most of your writing ability? |
12:20 |
: Yes.
|
12:20 |
Any suggestions for good local Washington D.C area beers? |
12:20 |
: DC Brau, but I know there’s others.
|
12:21 |
Projected line for BJ Upton? |
12:21 |
: .230/.330 15/20
|
12:21 |
Utley or Granderson a safer bet?? |
12:22 |
: Utley’s problem is degenerative, so if you’re only talking health, I’ll take the guy that was just beaned twice last year. On talent, Utley.
|
12:22 |
The Rays have scheduled “a significant baseball announcement” for late this afternoon with Sternberg, Friedman and Maddon on hand . Any guesses what it might be? Thanks, Eno! |
12:22 |
: Price trade? Myers extension.
|
12:22 |
hi eno, do you ever use r in your ANALysis? |
12:22 |
: I want to, but might just settle for tableau on the mac.
|
12:22 |
Brandon Belt or Ortiz, 2014 only? |
12:23 |
: Ortiz. .275/18/5 is still a very strong possibility for Belt, as much as I like him and the swing changes he’s made.
|
12:23 |
Hi Eno…in 12 team leagues where you have 3 OFs, if you had to guess which offensive positions do you think you are most/least likely to find a startable alternative on the waiver wire. I’m assuming OF is one of the most likely kind of like SPs/closers. |
12:24 |
: yes in three OF leagues, the replacement level outfielder will look really nice.
|
12:24 |
Does Sierra just assume minus .300 BABIP and 71% LOB, or does it adjust for strikeout guys, flyball guys, etc |
12:24 |
: It’s Skill-Interactive, so no, it adjusts for those things more than any other ERA estimator.
|
12:24 |
Ubaldo: Cubs or Jays – 4/64M? Garza: Halos, O’s or Braves 3/45M? Santana – M’s or ‘Stros 4/60M? |
12:25 |
: Ubaldo to the Jays, that number looks okay. Garza to the… Angels? Santana to the Mariners?
|
12:25 |
Yes, but your fancy SIERA stats haven’t yet been able to calculate TWTW. |
12:25 |
MADDAWG |
12:25 |
wow, you’re really drinking the Tejada Kool Aid. That’s a shame. |
12:25 |
: Have you looked at his two good years recently.
|
12:27 |
: “drinking the Tejada Kool Aid” like there’s a bunch of analysts out there that love the kid and have been pushing for this. Like saying he can be a representative shortstop is crazy talk. Like I have to be in the pocket of the team to say that a guy with a career 24% line drive rate and decent glove could be above replacement.
|
12:27 |
Can you throw harder than 65mph? |
12:27 |
: No, I’m terrible at baseball.
|
12:27 |
How much would you have to get paid to manage a team of your choice for a year? How good of a job would you do? |
12:28 |
: Based on the fact I couldn’t write and would have to be away from my young son… a good amount. High six figures. I’d bring in some hard-line sabr ideas just to see if they could work over the course of the year. Some players would like me, some would hate me, and I’d probably do a bad job because they wouldn’t respect my place in the game.
|
12:28 |
I think Burnett would be a bigger sign for Pittsburgh than Drew for Boston… |
12:29 |
: I do actually think that Burnett will return, but I don’t get the dance. And yeah, they could use a veteran.
|
12:29 |
Do you ever deal with writer’s block? |
12:30 |
: Rarely. Baseball’s pretty awesome for providing content.
|
12:30 |
Stanford, very impressive. Can you provide references? |
12:30 |
: Sure I’ll walk over to campus and see if any of my favorite teachers will provide one.
|
12:30 |
Obligatory Lucas Duda in the outfield question. Will he have learned anything to make him less horrible? Will Granderson/C. Young at the other positions minimize his deficiencies? Is this just a bluff to try to get Juan Lagares to walk a little bit? |
12:31 |
: God he can’t play in the outfield… I think this is just a way to keep him in the bigs while they try to get the most out of Ike.
|
12:31 |
Most surprising offseason move: Fister for a pack of Big League Chew. |
12:31 |
: Oh yeah, I didn’t get that. I guess they wanted to spread the money around the rest of the team…
|
12:32 |
I grabbed a Goose Island Barleywine based solely on its BAR rating- what did I do? I’m not sure I liked it. They’re great for getting you warm on a winter night- but was that beer? I liked it by the end, but I think it was just the 15% ABV telling me that- what’s your take on barleywine? |
12:32 |
: Hate it, for the most part. The only Barleywine I’ve really liked was Hog Heaven from Avery, and most people think that’s just a double IPA. My ABV limit is right around 13%. Woulda bought wine if I wanted wine.
|
12:33 |
Draw me a map to the 2015 NL Central Champion Chicago Cubs. |
12:35 |
: I see it. An ace. They need to get an ace. That pushes the shark down to second spot, and takes the pressure off guys like CJ Edwards. And you can sign a four/five for decent money. Bryant/Almora/Lake in the outfield. Trade Soler for that ace, with other parts — maybe either Starlin or Baez. Olt does power/patience at third. Rizzo emerges this year. Welington is fine.
|
12:35 |
AJ Burnett is a FA? isnt he the lowest risk, close to highest reward FA pitcher left. |
12:35 |
: He also wants to retire.
|
12:35 |
The best part about your article yesterday, IMO, was all the evidence and links you provided. I humbly request more fangraphs articles that are like “review papers” that assemble known knowldedge. |
12:36 |
: I enjoy doing those. I used to do a column on Getting Blanked like that. Might reprise it for RotoGraphs.
|
12:36 |
Who wins this fantasy trade: Goldschmidt and Scherzer for Stanton and Grienke? |
12:36 |
: Goldy side.
|
12:36 |
Why aren’t straight, cash for players trades more common? Beyond fan outcry at an alleged fire sale, is there any strategic reason? |
12:36 |
: Probably because the chance at a controllable asset is worth more than a few bucks in the hand.
|
12:37 |
I understand the thinking most people have with comping Japanese players to other Japanese players, but when real live paid analysts compare Tanaka to Irabu and Igawa, isn’t that just bordering racism? I mean, if someone said not to sign Yasiel Puig because Yuniesky Betancourt is terrible, we’d all laugh because different players are different. So why the double standard w/ Japan? |
12:38 |
: I think you can look at it less cynically: when we make major league equivalency lines in stats, we use players that played in the same leagues as comparisons. It’s the league that matters. You could talk Colby Lewis in that way. And I do use Hiroki Kuroda, but that’s because they both have low-90s fastballs (kuroda a little less so these days), good control, and a wicked splitter. I prefer to base comps on that sort of thing.
|
12:38 |
I’ll spare you the intricacies of my league’s draft but what it boils down to is I can keep Matt Cain or let him go and draft Tanaka? They would have same keeper value going forward. |
12:39 |
: Tanaka may only be Cain in terms of Ks. But the years you’d get probably make it worth it.
|
12:39 |
As an Orioles fan, I kind of love the Yanks’ signing Tanaka: (1) if he’s great, I get to watch him play a lot; (2) if he’s not great, the Yanks just blew the luxury tax, and I get the satisfaction of watching them misallocate their resources. |
12:39 |
Do you/Would you share your untappd username? I require more instantaneous Eno beer recommendations. |
12:39 |
: Believe it’s just enosarris or Eno Sarris. no mystery!
|
12:39 |
How many times does Cano reach the playoffs over the duration of the Seattle contract? |
12:40 |
: Maybe once or twice down the road with a new leadership team and plan in place?
|
12:40 |
Otto LWTS SP Keep or Cuts: Brett Anderson (7), Dan Straily (6), Erasmo Ramirez (5), Garrett Richards (3) |
12:40 |
: Cut, keep, keep, keep as lotto ticket
|
12:41 |
Do you think the Mets FO is considered difficult to deal with now? Why have they found it so difficult to deal with the roster redundancy they’ve got and not brought in any players to compete at SS with uber-stud Ruben Tejada? It seems the FO is just so anti-incremental steps forward. |
12:41 |
: I know the Rays’ FO is considered difficult to deal with.
|
12:41 |
How jealous are you of my outfield: Alfonso Soriano, Grady Sizemore, Carlos Beltran. Pretty sweet, right? |
12:41 |
: LOL
|
12:41 |
As far as arbitration goes: don’t most of the denigrations of Arb really just come down to how people value and present stats whether that be the team, player or arbiter? |
12:42 |
: Yeah, so I think just a simple tweak — a little education for the arbitrators — would do wonders.
|
12:42 |
You have made me a very K-phobic fantasy player (especially in 5×5) for offense. Thank you. It has made my player valuations almost dead easy: If I like two guys similarly it’s just a matter of who makes more contact. |
12:43 |
: It’s good for batting average leagues. You have to un-learn it for your OBP leagues though.
|
12:43 |
Can you give an example of a player whose batted ball distance correctly predicted a change in power? |
12:44 |
: I hope I’m summing up the research right, but a large increase in batted ball distance (15+ feet) makes a power surge more believable (more sticky).
|
12:44 |
I tried Bourbon county from 09 while brewing yum. When do you suppose Tanaka starts coming off the board in keep leagues? |
12:45 |
: I had an industry non-keeper draft where he went near 100. But he’ll go higher in keeper leagues, probably somewhere around the fifth or sixth, after the young aces are gone. And BCBS is so much better aged!
|
12:45 |
I just dusted off my Expos hat! Who |
12:45 |
That rat thing is terrifying |
12:45 |
When are you and Pod gonna get around to talking about the Indians? |
12:45 |
: Me and Collette? We’re doing it alphabetically by team name!
|
12:45 |
best bet for very deep OPS league in 2014: Sizemore, Ibanez, Ludwick, Byrd? |
12:45 |
: Byrd the only every-day player for me, at least from the get-go. And the youngest?
|
12:46 |
Say, through an entirely unlikely miracle of modern science, Billy Hamilton ends 2014 with a .350 OBP. How many steals does he have? |
12:46 |
: 85
|
12:46 |
re DC area beers… try Atlas Brew Works. Solid new brewery–only available in tasting room (incl. growler fills) and on tap at local restaurants. |
12:46 |
How do you feel about Alex Gordon for $25 in otto points? |
12:46 |
: good. really good.
|
12:47 |
best guess on how many PA Marcell Ozuna gets in 2014? Full-time player? |
12:47 |
: I think he’s full-time! I kinda like him.
|
12:47 |
Can the Mets contend (longterm, not in 2014) with Tejada at SS and Davis/Duda at 1B? |
12:48 |
: If a couple of two-win guys at first and short are their worst regulars, yes.
|
12:48 |
How many 5-win seasons does Ian Desmond have to put up until I believe in his ability? |
12:48 |
: I feel you. I even own him in an 18-team keeper (OBP!) and I really feel you. He scares me.
|
12:48 |
Ever think about having Fantasy BeerGraphs? $ values based on popularity. Get points for # check ins, weekly rating improvement %age, there must be more |
12:49 |
: WE just debuted Fantasy Beer this week on BG. You pick a brewery from a couple of tiers and then you get credit for their rookie beers this year.
|
12:49 |
At this point, how many SPs would have to come off the board in a deep fantasy draft before you’d take Miguel Alfredo Gonzalez? any guess what we can expect if he even pitches? |
12:49 |
: I’m really only going to take him in reserve rounds.
|
12:49 |
Give me a High K reliever that might step forward this year in leverage situations – closer or late innings…Cody Allen? |
12:50 |
: Sure, but giving young guys saves makes them expensive and the Indians haven’t done it much. There could be a new guy in Seattle, they have lots of arms and like to run through them. Maybe Cishek goes and Ramos or Capps step forward. Sergio Santos?
|
12:50 |
What’s your favorite and least favorite part of a draft (and a drought)? |
12:51 |
Love love the first sip. The last one.. eh. at least there’s hope for another. |
12:51 |
What top 3 prospects are worth drafting late? Addison Russell? Baez? Springer? Buxton? Any of these guys getting decent time this year? |
12:53 |
: Springer should be up, batting average tbd. The rest, probably not. Top prospects.. Sano if no TJ and you’re talking September. Polanco could be up soonish? It’s only Byrd, after all, and he’s close. Appel will be up at some point. Taillon?
|
12:53 |
Thoughts on Cellarmaker, Almanac, and The Rare Barrel as UTL in the brewery fantasy league? |
12:53 |
: Almanac gets decent distro and their sour porter really was great. They might come up with a nice beer this year, and don’t live in IPAs, which are a tough category.
|
12:53 |
: I JUST ANSWERED MY FIRST FANTASY BEER QUESTION
|
12:54 |
any crystal ball projections on who signs Rodney? Does he close again? |
12:54 |
: Rodney signs with O’s, which would make him the favorite?
|
12:54 |
SABR-minded people talk like TWTW and grit, hustle, determination, etc. don’t exist. But isn’t it more accurate to say this: (1) these are hard to measure; and (2) even if they do exist, it’s likely that the variance among MLBers on these “metrics” would be very small? |
12:54 |
: yes
|
12:54 |
You estimated similar slash numbers for BJ Upton and Grady Sizemore…who hasnt played in 2 years. That’s funny. |
12:55 |
: more PT for the younger one at least
|
12:55 |
“I’m the best writer on the internet, that’s what’s gon happen is you throw a sorry question at me like that!” – Eno |
12:55 |
Stanford? Oh, so you’re a thug? (j/k) |
12:55 |
The Jamaican Bobsled team made the Olympics!! |
12:55 |
: Thank you for a proper lude. Yes, I’m a rude dude and y’a cyan talk pan me boblsed team!
|
12:55 |
Are with Dave and Sulli that Cruz ends up a Mariner? |
12:56 |
: I think they’re just resigned that the worst possible free agent will show up in Seattle. We’ll see. If Cruz does go there, they suddenly have like four iffy 1b/dh types.
|
12:56 |
Now that the cubs have tied for second place in the Masahiro Tanaka Sweepstakes, will Jeff Samardzija get a new uniform before spring training starts in two plus weeks? |
12:57 |
: Only reason to trade the Shark is if you get a few ace-upside lotto ticket pitchers back. But yeah, they’re probably closer to trading him now than before.
|
12:57 |
As a craft beer drinker, how do you manage going back to your favorites vs. trying new ones? |
12:57 |
: I usually try to get new ones. But I’ve tried out most of the beers at my beer store, so now I pick a few greatest hits when there’s nothing new.
|
12:58 |
Do beer people like New Belgium? |
12:58 |
: Dunno. Don’t think so. I hate Fat Tire. I’ve liked some of their other stuff. sort of.
|
12:58 |
Do we have any idea what kind of defense and pitch framing D’Arnaud will provide? Might one dream about improvements in the Mets pitching staff from full seasons of Lagares and D’Arnaud in the field and subtractions of Duda and Buck? |
12:58 |
: He looks like a good framer. I think his defense is good. There will be some ancillary benefits, even if I don’t think he’s going to be an elite bat.
|
12:59 |
About to go pick up some Hopslam. What’s your thoughts on it? |
12:59 |
: Someone has tried to send me that beer three times and some postal worker somewhere is drinking it all.
|
12:59 |
Best way to go about digging into the FIP v. ERaA problem? That is, is there an easy way to see who has the highest ERA-FIP? |
12:59 |
: ERA-FIP is on our sortable leaderboards!
|
1:00 |
Will the short porch in NY hurt Tanaka 1st yr? |
1:00 |
: I think he’ll give up a homer per nine, yes. Some call his fastball flat, too.
|
1:00 |
Jeff Samardzija is sort of a changeup away from your perfect pitcher, right? |
1:01 |
: The splitter is a changeup, but I’d rather have a guy with great control.
|
1:01 |
Keep one of the following: Hosmer, Pujols, Puig, Scherzer. |
1:01 |
: Puig for me. Hosmer’s steal totals should decline. I like Puig to hit at least .270 with 25+, 15+
|
1:02 |
Not. eno. ugh; weird, |
1:02 |
Who’s your #1 prospect in baseball right now? |
1:02 |
: Taveras. Like his contact rate over Buxton. Bogaerts is there, but I’m unsure if it’ll be more real-life than fantasy greatness.
|
1:02 |
Eno what are your top 5 metrics to determine a hitter’s probability of progression or regression? |
1:03 |
: K%, GB%, FB%… the bag of tricks is small for hitters. Have been looking at batted ball distance recently. All the other power metrics — ISO, HR/FB, take forever to become reliable.
|
1:03 |
Ike Davis’ dad is difficult to deal with haha |
1:03 |
How would you rank Grandal, Zunino and d’Arnaud? |
1:04 |
: Grandal, TdA, Zunino. Really worried that Zunino’s K% is here to stay. He can’t hit the curve, yes, but his whiff rates on all breaking pitches are super high.
|
1:04 |
Coming from Toronto, what beers are available and delicious in Haines City, Florida? I see some Cigar City Brewing beverages on the Beergraphs rankings, but can I get them in Haines City??? Thanks Eno!!! |
1:04 |
: Gotta get Cigar City, it’s the jewel of Florida. Might get some Terrapin from GA down there.
|
1:05 |
When you’re talking about OBP leagues, would you consider a points league that values a walk as a single to be an OBP league? |
1:05 |
: Yes.
|
1:05 |
When did the big books start to embrace Saber philosophies? Before or after the big league clubs? IS there any history of Saber-guys making decent cash handicapping anyone behind the curve? |
1:05 |
: Great questions. There are people using saber stats to win cash.
|
1:05 |
If the Mets have another mid 70s win season, will things begin to get ugly for the FO? I know there is some degree of built in excuse with Harvey lost for the year but it’ll be 4 yrs with no improvement and with graduations still a mid tier farm system. The media honeymoon will be long gone. |
1:06 |
: They have at least one manager firing before the FO gets on the chopping block. Remember that Bud was behind the hiring.
|
1:06 |
Why trade Soler when Cubs may be able to sign Scherzer as a FA? Would likely cost them cash and a 2nd round DP only. |
1:06 |
: Eh that was just my plan. I’m a little worried about Soler’s plate discipline making him a possible bust. He’s huge though.
|
1:06 |
I DEMAND MORE INTERLUDE!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!??!?!? |
1:06 |
I think I fear your Pitcher McPitcherson creation. His desire for perfect pitch sequencing is only matched by his desire for MURDER! |
1:07 |
SUP ENO HOWS IT GOING |
1:07 |
Great BP articles on understanding SIERA: http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=SIERA |
1:07 |
Doesn’t it make sense to nominate popular sleepers early in an auction draft so to inflate their draft cost, leaving the more established players cheaper? |
1:09 |
: I think so and I wasn’t bowled over by Larry Schechter’s response as to why not to do it. I guess the point is, you might have a plan for your team, with plans a-d. If you throw a guy you don’t want, maybe later it turns out you might have liked him at that price. And he did say that ‘nomination is an advantage’ which is true. You get to decide the player being bid upon. But sometimes, the best move is to throw someone you don’t want.
|
1:09 |
What kind of guys tend to have good Clutch scores? |
1:09 |
: Hasn’t really been shown to exist, reliably.
|
1:09 |
Any thoughts on Scott Baker? Does his value depend on where he ends up due to his fly ball tendencies? |
1:09 |
: yes. Would love him in Florida.
|
1:09 |
Are there any beer styles that, if a brewery has them, really impress you? |
1:10 |
: Always look to see if they have saisons and sours.
|
1:10 |
Getting old must suck. |
1:10 |
WATS UR FAVE BODY PART? |
1:10 |
TROUT |
1:10 |
Have you had that Winter Porridge Brown Nutsac Dry Wheat Germ Molasses Goulash Spaetzle Ale? |
1:10 |
Garza to Brew Crew is being reported. |
1:10 |
: Deliciously weird! The medicals must have scared everyone off.
|
1:10 |
That ship doesn’t really scare me, it’s really just an empty ship full of rats. No reason to think they’ll carry worse diseases than any other rats found in every major city. Then again if you have a phobia of rats it would be an awful thought. Now, if the ship had been a floating lab for the CDC, then we’d have something. |
1:10 |
re Rodney–but does he pass his physical with the O’s? |
1:11 |
: oh god, that thing.
|
1:11 |
Polanco is behind only Tabata/Snider = less than Byrd |
1:11 |
: yeah I think he’s a decent bet for production this year. I really like him. And in batting average leagues, he could give power and speed with a better BA and more PA than Springer…
|
1:11 |
Cashman has said that the yanks are done with big spending this offseason — do the yankees really go to ST with the bullpen/infield they have now? |
1:12 |
: Bullpens are whatever, they can build one with spare parts and what they have. Kelley, Robertson, Thornton… sure. Second base seems okay if it was KJ and Roberts. But third base, Nunez? yeah the infield is iffy.
|
1:12 |
Do you like Lawrie over 3B such as Asche, Frazier or Moustakas? |
1:13 |
: Very much so. Good contact rate, good power, some speed.
|
1:13 |
working on selected brewery scouting reports now, if people have other breweries they want profiled |
1:13 |
Steamer and Oliver both put Gardner at ~100 wRC+. That’s harsh, right? WHY ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT BEER AND LUDE AND COOL RUNNINGS INSTEAD OF BASEBALL |
1:13 |
: shh, we mustn’t upset Jake.
|
1:14 |
Hey Eno – Who do you think out of Dickey, Morrow and Buehrle has the best bounce-back season? Who out of Happ, Hutchison, Rogers, Redmond and Stroman makes the biggest contribution out of the back end of the rotation? |
1:15 |
: Dickey. I think being removed from WBC will be good for him. health will allow him to throw the hard knuckler. Morrow… I’ll never trust him again. God I love Stroman. Unreasonably. He might not get the bulkiest chance, but in terms of upside/ elite impact, he’s the name I’m looking at.
|
1:15 |
Dynasty league…give up Sano, and Teheran or Minor to get Puig. Yay or nay? |
1:15 |
: I would. Maybe you can get a pitching flier back, a young guy. Wood! lol.
|
1:15 |
R U OVERCOMPENSATING FOR MASCULINITY WITH BEER & BASEBALL |
1:16 |
: I’m not the most masculine guy actually!
|
1:16 |
I have no idea where to draft Jose Abreu in a Keeper League, but I know if he is going to be great I want him with how scarce HR can be. When are you drafting him? |
1:16 |
: He’s a bit older than young guys, and him and rizzo might both hit .275 with 25+ homers this year. Maybe that’ll help.
|
1:16 |
Hopslam is fantastic!!! |
1:16 |
I think people ask you about Hopslam just to make you mad now |
1:17 |
Agree about Fat Tire. * barf * |
1:17 |
“y’a cyan talk pan me boblsed team” Your mayorship! |
1:17 |
: At least I was born in Jamaica.
|
1:17 |
Do we believe in Jiminez’s…err Jiminez’ errr Jiminezezezez first half or second half from 2013? Wherever he signs… |
1:18 |
: He added the splitter, and I think that’s been huge. But there was some luck involved in the second half. I’m not hugely excited to sign him. If the Jays sign him, surgery coming.
|
1:18 |
whats a good way to cleanse your pallet between beers? always disappointed when i try a second style at how muted it is compared to the first |
1:18 |
: Tasters do it with bread…
|
1:18 |
What is Longoria’s upside? I’m wondering if Beltre’s age and Wright’s legs push him into consideration after Cabrera’s gone as the next third baseman. He has a high floor. |
1:18 |
: High floor, but the ceiling seems lower than I thought. .280/30… can he do much better? Beltre seems a better bet for batting average.
|
1:18 |
Puig’s .383 BABIP should fall, correct? |
1:19 |
: yes and his K rate should go up with that swinging strike rate.
|
1:19 |
Answer one of my questions and you’ll get your beer. |
1:19 |
: The truth comes out.
|
1:19 |
I like misleading fantasy opponents that are just catching up on the SABR wave w/ FIP and xFIP as appropriate (I am selling you someone who plays in a hitter’s park: xFIP! I am selling you someone who gives up tons of hard contact and has been HR lucky: FIP!) Folks need to learn that these stats especially in-season aren’t really all that predictive vs. core skills like swSTR, velo and batted ball profiles |
1:19 |
Who’s the top defensive infielder coming up (no majors experience yet) who has a legitimate shot at the majors? |
1:19 |
: Francisco Lindor. Russell is going to make the majors but his defense a bit behind.
|
1:20 |
Remind me… a metric becomes reliable when the best projection is mid-way between actual performance and the mean. Is that right?? |
1:20 |
: yes. 50% regression to the mean = reliable. amazing!
|
1:20 |
“Bud was behind the hiring.” Of who? Alderson? Collins? Why would that give the Mets’ front office a longer leash? |
1:20 |
: Alderson. I think it does, because the Wilpons and Selig are BUDDIES.
|
1:20 |
Do you live near the Stanford campus? |
1:20 |
: Feet.
|
1:21 |
Re: Comping Japanese players. On the BP Podcast, while recounting his experiences at scout school, Ben Lindbergh said that they explicitly instructed them to make comps within race/heritage because it would make it easier for higher ups to imagine a player they had never laid eyes on. |
1:21 |
: Scouts do fall into it a lot.
|
1:21 |
I’m really interested in doing an auction draft, but my usual leaguemates all have different schedules. Is there any method to doing an auction draft offline? |
1:21 |
: Blind bids? Everyone submits a list of bids for a list of players?
|
1:21 |
What happens with Craig Kimbrel? You and Jeff have both said he might not get as much on the trade market as most would expect, yet he might get like ~9mm in arb? Where’s the middle ground for the Braves? |
1:22 |
: Keep him until he’s an FA and thank him for his services.
|
1:22 |
Cubs give up Samardjiza, Castro and Schierholtz for Syndergaard, Wheeler and Duda. Thoughts on fairness and probability? |
1:22 |
: Not the right fit. Shark has two years of eligibility? He needs to go to a contender.
|
1:22 |
You taking Estrada this year at right price? |
1:23 |
: yes. good offspeed stuff and control. Fastball is only 90, and he’ll give up homers, but I like him.
|
1:23 |
I know auction values can be even more volatile and league-dependent in ottoneu points/dynasty leagues, but do you know of any resource that provides any type of guide? I’m experimenting with things like the value of a roster spot and replacement level value, but I’m starting to think this is too league-dependent to be of any value outside my league. |
1:23 |
: FanGraphs plus has some strategy stuff on that sort of thing this year. We’re working on the calculator.
|
1:23 |
New Belgium has had a few tasty sours in the Lips of Faith series. |
1:23 |
: true
|
1:23 |
DUCKRABBIT |
1:23 |
I wish there was a way to find the most thumbs up and thumbs down comments on these comment boards. There is some great commentary. We need CommentGraphs! |
1:24 |
Grant Balfour signs with the Rays.. |
1:24 |
: Hello. Very interesting. I had Bell penciled in for 30 saves. Now… you’d have to think Balfour is in the lead.
|
1:24 |
Strasburg is still awesome, right? Brian Kenny’s show “Top 10 Right Now” didn’t have him listed as a top-10 starting pitcher for 2014. Huh-what? |
1:25 |
: I actually think he could have a monster year this year. Dunno why people denigrate him.
|
1:25 |
🙁 Seriously, Gardner tho |
1:26 |
: I like Gardner, but a lot of his value is glove-related.
|
1:26 |
Kipnis or Carpenter this year for a points league? |
1:26 |
: Without seeing your specific points… I take Kipnis. I think he could be the #1 2B this year. Love love.
|
1:26 |
Is wRC+ adjusted for players at the top? I feel like many players that I would consider “average” have a below 100. Is that because the few players are above 100 are way above 100? |
1:27 |
: No, it’s just relative to league average. If you leave pitchers in, the ave wrC+ is 96 or 97.
|
1:27 |
1 year of Rizzo in the last round, or 2 years of Starling Marte in the 15th? |
1:27 |
: I love Rizzo, but an extra year of control is big.
|
1:27 |
RE Gardner. Projecting a 30 year old with a career wRC of 101 to put a 100 wRC sound pretty much the opposite of harsh! |
1:28 |
I’m in drama class ENO! also – who do the Blue Jayz sign to their rotation now that tanaka-san has landed? |
1:28 |
: Ubaldo, the signs are pointing to Ubaldo I think.
|
1:28 |
Matt Moore – any reason for optimism? His fastball is fading, his command is somehow getting worse, and then his elbow starts barking. What’s your read on his 2014? |
1:28 |
: yeah I’m officially worried. The DL thing might be the worst, it predicts more DL in the future.
|
1:28 |
Have you taken the boy to a baseball game yet? I’m thinking of taking my now-8-month-old to a minor league game this year so we can sit kinda close (and behind the screen!) without breaking the bank accounts. |
1:29 |
: yeah he’s been to a couple Padres games, where we sat far away and he ran around the concourse and spent about five minutes looking at the game.
|
1:29 |
How DOES Oakland do it? |
1:29 |
: Depth. High variance FA signings. Churn and burn the arms.
|
1:29 |
Carlos Gomez does it again in 2014? Or was he a mirage? |
1:29 |
: Power, speed real. Batting average might fall a bit.
|
1:29 |
Eno – i made it! |
1:29 |
: congrats!
|
1:29 |
What Ace would you see the Cubs trying to acquire? Price? |
1:30 |
: That’s the one they keep getting linked to.
|
1:30 |
Heady Topper or Zombie Dust? |
1:30 |
: Zombie for me.
|
1:30 |
Do you like Maholm, Capuano, baker or Arroyo as a consolation prize for Cleveland? |
1:30 |
: One of the first two. All seem like injury risks other than Arroyo.
|
1:30 |
Panda, Lawrie, or Seager – next three years… |
1:31 |
: Seager for safety, Lawrie for uspide. Panda for first base at the end of it.
|
1:31 |
Will Jaso get enough innings behind the dish to qualify as a fantasy catcher/will he be worth a look in a deepish league? |
1:31 |
: He should be a catcher in 2014 based on his 2013 work, but if not, no, I don’t think he gets much catcher work this year. The other guys are better defensively.
|
1:32 |
When I lived in Colorado I was pretty meh on Fat Tire. Now that I live in New York, all I want is a nice bowl of green chile and a Fat Tire, two things you absolutely cannot get in this great city. |
1:32 |
well anyone who can be sold on just one stat in a fantasy is a suck to taken advantage of anyways. |
1:32 |
Go Bears! |
1:32 |
4/$52 for Garza. Seems like… a bargain? |
1:33 |
: Probably because people didn’t like what they saw in his elbow.
|
1:33 |
which of the Cubs big prospects do you think has the greatest chance to be great in MLB? which one has the greatest chance to bust? |
1:33 |
: Soler for bust. I think Bryant for best. Real power even if I don’t think he’ll be a 3B.
|
1:33 |
Are you spelling Erasmo with two “S”s or will be actually be decent this season? |
1:34 |
: I dunno about him. Big velo bump was part of his helium as prospect, and the erosion has begun. Needs the slider to be better.
|
1:34 |
I would like to nominate Eno Sarris for the Eno Sarris Leadership Award. |
1:34 |
MMMMOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO |
1:34 |
where do you stand on tyson ross? I’ve seen a lot of hype on him this year and wondering if you think it’s warranted? |
1:34 |
: Park and league and velocity make him interesting. Lack of changeup limits his ceiling considerably.
|
1:35 |
Ross’s mechanics are just awful. |
1:35 |
: That too
|
1:35 |
: Hey guys! kid’s home sick. Gotta go!
|
1:35 |
: Thanks for chatting!
|
1:35 |
The big Alex Torres/Logan Forsythe trade seems to be going totally ignored today. Why do you people hate America? |
1:36 |
: We’ve got a piece coming!
|
1:36 |
save the child! |
1:36 |
good luck with that |
1:36 |
Thanks for chatting with us |
With a phone full of pictures of pitchers' fingers, strange beers, and his two toddler sons, Eno Sarris can be found at the ballpark or a brewery most days. Read him here, writing about the A's or Giants at The Athletic, or about beer at October. Follow him on Twitter @enosarris if you can handle the sandwiches and inanity.
Eno! Now that the sad, sad, sad Cubs have lost Tanaka to the Yankees, do they go drunken whoring trying to forget the one that got away. Jiminez maybe?
Chats=Great