FanGraphs Chat – 7/20/11





Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.

14 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
dave
15 years ago

srsly… w-t-f…. u idiots think shields is going to be tradeD this year? did your mom drop you when you were 1 years old or what?

juan pierre's mustache
15 years ago
Reply to  dave

hey dude i was 2, get it right

Guy who likes humor
15 years ago
Reply to  dave

I voted down on this, not because I dislike the sentiment, but simply because it wasn’t funny enough to post. Subtlety sir!

Ray Kroc
15 years ago

So you’ll use our wifi but then eat somewhere else? For shame!

Ben
15 years ago

Anyone got an opinion on Jason Vargas vs Danny Duffy ROS?

joshcohen
15 years ago
Reply to  Ben

read jonah’s espn piece on rookies making a splash. i’ll take the less flashy but more proven vargas.

bill
15 years ago

Madison Bumgardner is the 2011 version of Pablo Sandoval?

DrBGiantsfan
15 years ago

Bumgarner doesn’t just throw strikes. He throws strikes on the edges of the plate with better than average velocity. I mean, 92-94 MPH isn’t chopped liver! He sometimes gets frustrated by umps who squeeze him and then he starts catching too much of the plate, but as long as he stays focused on hitting the corners he’s unhittable. He probably has the best fastball command on a pitching staff that has very good fastball command. In short, yes, he can maintain a very low HR/FB ratio with that kind of command.

Yes, it’s a SF thing, but it’s more than Righetti. I believe it all actually starts with Dick Tidrow and the scouting staff who specifically draft and sign pitchers who cammand the fastball on both sides of the plate.

There has not been much movement of pitchers away from SF, and most of their pitchers are home grown, so who knows if they would take this skill with them to another team. I believe Cain and Bumgarner would because a lot of their success is due to tools and skills they had when they were scouted and drafted.

batpig
15 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

I am SHOCKED to see you defending Giants players

DrBGiantsfan
15 years ago
Reply to  batpig

Watch a couple of Bumgarner’s games on TV. If you have a different take, I’d be happy to read it. If you see enough of his games the stats make perfect sense, just like they do for Matt Cain, Ryan Vogelsong and most pitchers you can name.

Knowing how to interpret stats is essential to understanding the game of baseball, but you don’t really understand the game until you can correlate the stats with what you observe in the games themselves. Everybody is scratching their heads over the Giants stat lines, but if you see them pitch it’s perfectly understandable.

I’m sure that’s true for fans who follow other teams closely too. If you don’t think that’s worthwhile, feel free to keep on scratching your head!

James
15 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

A pitcher throwing to the corners of the strikezone? unheard of!

DrBGiantsfan
15 years ago
Reply to  James

A lot of pitchers try. Bumgarner just does it better than most.

bookbook
15 years ago

Somehow I think the McDonald’s shareholders–mainly mutual funds, pension funds, and public radio stations all around the US–don’t mind a bit.

zhongkul
15 years ago

surprise web: == www jordanforworld com====

very good web,believe you will love it.

FREE SHIPPING,accept pyapal

discount including evisu jeans,watches shirts,bags,hat and the decorations and so on

trust me!

Opportunity knocks but once