In Search of the High Fastballs
Theory: Players have gotten better than ever at hitting pitches down in the zone. I don’t think this counts as a controversial theory anymore, and it goes hand in hand with what’s been casually termed the fly-ball revolution. Anecdotally, it seems like there are more and more hitters trying to hit the ball in the air. Generally speaking, this is achieved by swinging with more of an uppercut, and, generally speaking, players with uppercuts are more productive down in the zone, instead of up.
Theory: This is one of the reasons why there’s been an emphasis on higher-spin fastballs. Those are the tougher-to-hit fastballs, fastballs you mostly want to be elevated. This past offseason, I put forth the idea that the cure to the home-run spike could involve more fastballs up. If pitchers just focused somewhere else, then hitters wouldn’t so often be able to elevate the pitches at their knees. To summarize, simply: It seems like there would be a pitcher response to the hitter response. It seems like there should be more high fastballs.
But, are there more high fastballs? Turns out this is really easy to check. And the answer is, well, basically, no.
Time for a whole bunch of images, informed by Baseball Savant. For simplicity, I divided all pitches into two groups, setting the midpoint at 2.5 feet off the ground. A fastball above that would count as a high fastball. Here’s the trend in league-wide high-fastball rate going back 10 seasons:
Baseball has achieved its lowest point in the observed decade. At the peak, roughly 31% of all pitches were high fastballs. So far this season, the rate is below 27%. That’s subtle, just a few pitches per game, but the line’s direction is unmistakable. Now, there’s a problem, however. The above data uses all pitches as the denominator. There’s a greater trend actively taking place — league-wide fastball rate is slowly sinking. So why don’t we look at the same kind of plot, but this time dividing by just fastballs?
There we go; that’s something. Through 2015, the average fastball was dropping. Pitchers were working lower and lower, presumably at least in part because the zone was sinking lower and lower. Last season, you see a bounceback in the high-fastball rate, with a jump of a full percentage point. This season, the rate has been essentially the same as last season. So when it comes to the question of whether there are more high fastballs now, there are two parts of the answer. Relative to the overall decade, high-fastball rate remains down. Yet there has been a very minor recent uptick. It’s possibly something to pay attention to, but if this is any indication, teams aren’t exactly instructing their pitchers to panic and keep the ball above the belt. Pitchers look more or less normal.
Now, how about what individual teams have done? Here’s what the 2016 situation looked like:
Compare that to the 2017 landscape. Although, don’t worry too much about trying to do that with your eyes, because I’ve taken care to run all the calculations. That plot comes after this one.
Most teams haven’t budged very much. In both plots, for example, you see the Red Sox and the Nationals toward the left. Out of baseball’s 30 teams, 18 have had high-fastball-rate shifts of less than four percentage points. It’s the exceptions, though, that capture our interest. Here’s how every team has moved, in this particular respect:
The Twins have increased their high-fastball rate from just under 46% to just over 53%. They have a gain of 7.8 ticks, easily the largest out of everyone. And yet, the magnitude of their change is kind of dwarfed, if you look to the right. The Orioles, for example, are down 8.8 ticks. And the Astros are down a relatively massive 12.1 ticks. By high-fastball rate in 2016, the Astros ranked 10th. Now they rank 30th. That sort of change can’t be an accident, as the Astros are leaning into the low-fastball approach.
Speaking of things that probably aren’t accidents, the Twins are using the Astros’ catcher from a year ago. And, on a slightly smaller scale, the Nationals are using one of the Orioles’ catchers from a year ago. But I don’t think the meat of the story here is the backstops. The Astros have had 11 pitchers throw at least 100 fastballs on the year. Nine of those 11 pitchers have reduced their high-fastball rates, and three pitchers have reduced their rates by at least 10 percentage points: Dallas Keuchel, Tony Sipp, and Lance McCullers. Charlie Morton has dropped his own rate by nine percentage points, and Morton was already a sinker-baller. The Astros are making sure their sinkers sink. Keuchel has baseball’s lowest high-fastball rate among starters. Morton, too, is close to the bottom, and McCullers is now keeping the ball about as low as Kyle Hendricks.
I don’t want to act like the Astros are the only team up to something, but theirs is a particularly interesting data point. You’d think that teams would be demonstrating more of a willingness to explore the upper part of the strike zone. After all, the bulk of the recent home-run increase has come lower within the box. The Astros, I’m certain, are aware of where the home runs have been, but they’re staying low, remarkably low, without a care in the world. Maybe it’s as simple as Keuchel improving his command again, and Morton just being a guy who was available for the right price. Maybe the Astros would throw more high fastballs in an ideal world. But you could take them as a sign — there’s no true urgency here. Maybe hitters are better than ever against pitches down, but if you throw the right pitches down, you can win 71% of your baseball games.
Quickly, in closing: Few pitchers have reduced their high-fastball rates by as much as Grant Dayton. For Dayton, that’s a problem. And few pitchers have increased their high-fastball rates by as much as Blake Treinen. For Treinen, that’s a problem. Individual data points go to show that it’s not always about executing a plan; sometimes these data points waver because a pitcher himself is wavering. But on the team level, you expect to find more signal. You expect to find even more still when you examine the league overall. Overall, the high fastballs haven’t surged, not yet. Perhaps they still will. Perhaps the hitters need to do a better job of forcing it.
Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.







Thanks for writing this. I’ve definitely noticed more work upstairs in Minnesota, particularly when they were playing Texas. I’m wondering if there’s an uptick in usage with 2 strikes? I’m intuitively thinking high heat is used more as an out pitch and more randomly located earlier in counts, but I don’t know if the data backs me up.
The Houston Astros have had 0 pitches by Colin McHugh, the resident high-fastball thrower. Him and Fister not throwing pitches for the Astros this year might explain it.
The high fastball is a great pitch if it is called a strike. The proverbial “high hard one” was the stock in trade of many of great pitchers from my youth, Reynolds, Raschi, Feller, Wynn, Roberts, Newcombe, just name a few, but in those days the zone was several inches higher than it is today. For the high heat to return to its past glory the pitchers have to get the call on the ball above the waist. Another side of the same coin involves the approach that pitchers are asked to implement. In my long, long history of avid baseball fandom,”Keep it Down” has been the mantra of every pitching coach who ever opened his mouth but I know I have never heard those same men ever say “Keep it Up”.
It is not that easy. The last 15 years every coach told them “throw at the knees, throw at the knees”. Their whole mechanics have been geared toward throwing low and every time someone hit a homer the coach said you left that up. Throw it high, say good bye.
So mentally and mechanically it is not easy because you have been geared toward throwing low.
Also not every higher fastball is good and locating them well has to be practiced. And not everyone has the high spin rate to make it work and there are still some traditional hitters that can punish the high FB (for example adrian beltre or mike napoli) and every time one of them hits a bomb those pitchers hear the voice of their HS coach “you left that…”.
And lastly umpires are less likely to call the high strike, partly because it is rarer.
The high heat gets mixed in as a shake up but pitchers are not fully committed to it as a go to approach yet. Yes you will throw the high heat but you are not yet living there all day in the way the 00s sinkerballer lived at the knees.
Maybe that will change but it needs time.
Players have gotten better than ever at hitting pitches down in the zone. I don’t think this counts as a controversial theory anymore, and it goes hand in hand with what’s been casually termed the fly-ball revolution.
Whoa. Back up a bit. Maybe they WERE better at hitting pitches down but that has dropped a lot in the last couple years precisely as the HR rate has risen. Just looking at the leaguewide plate discipline numbers:
O-contact rate peaked at 68.1% in 2011 – was 65.7% in 2014 -and is 62.8% now. That is the weird series anyway since both chase and contact rates (and presumably pitch frequency rates) rose really fast before then.
Z-contact rate has been much more stable over time – 87-88% – but has dropped significantly over the last three years – 86.7%, 86.3%, 85.4%.
This doesn’t look to me like it supports – better than ever at hitting pitches even if you are splitting zone into different sections
How do you know the Z-contact drop isn’t from more swings and misses up in the zone? Those numbers don’t do anything to refute what Jeff said. I have no idea why you quoted O-contact rates since, by definition, those pitches are not down in the zone.
I don’t think he means the league got better on pitches below the knees (unless mike trout who crushes them:)) but pitches in the whole lower half of the zone (knee to upper tigh)
You’ve entirely missed Jeff’s point. It’s not about making contact. It’s about expected wOBA (or whatever measure) by region of the strike zone. All these new fly ball hitters mash sinkers and other low fastballs.
I’ve not missed his point. I’m challenging the use of the word ‘better hitting’ to describe a much narrower thang (increased HR’s thru whatever) offset by a slew of other things (like EVERYTHING else) which would fit into the bucket of ‘worse hitting’.
And if that means I have to use wOBA (not ‘contact’) as the single measure of ‘better hitting’ – well hey that’s ok too. Because:
a)wOBA merely burped a bit last year. It’s still at the low end of all post-WW2 seasons and
b)wOBA itself is a moving goalpost because the numerator events change their weights (both absolutely and relative to other numerator events) each year and the denominator events are fixed weight – and some of those events have little to do with ‘hitting’ – and others (eg SF) are events which are clearly contingent on context of other events in the same formula – and all of those are being forced to track something else that is only partially about ‘hitting’.
Is the answer to the question Jason Castro?
I wouldn’t think so but the results are the results and Castro is the common denominator.
Jeff, for a given pitcher, it’s not as simple as saying – time to throw more high fastballs. Obviously, the aptitude has to exist too. Guys who get to the big leagues working low in the zone often don’t have the ability to succeed with high fastballs (and vice versa). There are exceptions.
It takes 3 to 8 years to develop a typical pitcher. It was observed just last year that high pitches may be ideal to counter the home run surge. So we’re probably 2+ years from the first wave of developed-from-scratch high fastball pitchers. Add in training biases/stickiness to old ideas, and the high fastball revolution may never happen.
Also, Collin McHugh is a high fastball guy. He’s conspicuously absent from the Astros rotation.
The Pirates in particular have made a concerted effort to pitch more up in the zone, which for them is more startling as they were evangelists of the low-pitch/ground ball philosophy
More on the Pirates and their high zone work:
http://piratesbreakdown.com/2017/03/30/pittsburgh-pirates-upper-third/
http://piratesbreakdown.com/2017/05/02/pittsburgh-pirates-pitchers-high-strikes/
I think the more interesting question is about FB usage relative to off-speed pitches (Hill, Shoemaker, Devenski, to name a few off the top of my head), and how, perhaps, the notion of “pitching off the FB” is changing and how that might be affecting the current environment, particularly increased K rates.