A’s Sign Rich Hill, Because Of Course They Do

According to Jeff Passan, the A’s have signed left-handed pitcher Rich Hill to a one year, $6 million deal.

This morning, I ranked Hill at #4 on my Free Agent Bargains post, and wrote the following.

#4: Rich Hill, LHP
Crowd’s Estimate: 1 year, $6 million
Dave’s Estimate: 1 year, $7 million
2016 Steamer Projection: +2.5 WAR

Probably the hardest guy on the market to value, Hill went from a non-roster invite to a fascinating test case in extreme performance in small samples with his dominating September run for the Red Sox. His success came out of nowhere, and it would be irresponsible to expect those four starts to represent some kind of new level of ability that he reached at the age of 35, but at the same time, we also don’t want to entirely ignore the fact that he put together a 29 inning stretch of Kershawian performance.

Over that four start stretch, hitters made contact on only 75% of their swings at his pitches in the strike zone, which is the kind of number that tends to identify skill more quickly than a lot of others. He’s not going to sustain that number — Max Scherzer led all MLB starters at 79% last year — but given that his lack of a track record is going to keep the commitment short, I think it’s worth betting a decent amount of 2016 salary on the chance that there Hill’s crazy finish to 2015 suggests that he’s figured something out.

No one should expect ace-like performance, and you’re basically buying a lottery ticket, but we’ve seen enough Cliff Lee transformations to not entirely discount the idea that Hill could be a quality arm for the team that takes the risk. Maybe he won’t be able to stay healthy; maybe it will turn out to be a colossal fluke. But for the kind of dollars that get you a mediocre bench player with some clubhouse chemistry voodoo, I’d take a flyer on Hill and just see what I get. If there’s even a 20% chance he’s a quality starting pitcher next year, throwing $5 to $10 million his way is a worthwhile use of funds for a team that needs to buy upside on the cheap.

The A’s are the embodiment of a team that needs to buy upside on the cheap, and this is exactly the kind of risk that makes sense for a team in their position. This is similar — though even more risky — to the Scott Kazmir bet they made two years ago, and that turned out quite well for them; it’s not a huge surprise to see them go back to this well. Hill’s upside makes this kind of gamble worthwhile, even if there’s a pretty high likelihood that he doesn’t really give them much value next year. It’s probably best to look at Hill kind of like a prospect, with an absurdly high bust rate but also a chance of returning a lot of value if he pans out.





Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.

25 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Keanu Kalawaia
10 years ago

But who is the A’s best offensive player at this point? Josh Reddick?

Mark Canha
10 years ago
Reply to  Keanu Kalawaia

Me.

Spa City
10 years ago
Reply to  Keanu Kalawaia

Probably Danny Valencia, who is better than many people give him credit for being.

A's Fanatic
10 years ago
Reply to  Spa City

Depends, Billy Burns is a incredibly speedy and dependable leadoff hitter, especially for a rookie. In terms of power it’d be Canha, Reddick, and Valencia with Stephen Vogt being the offensive MVP For 2015.

Mac
10 years ago
Reply to  Keanu Kalawaia

Fair point, but depth can also be a weapon. The A’s had two offense black holes last year: Eric Sogard and Sam Fuld. And Sogard was a bench bat before the Zobrist trade. The third worst regular by WRC+ was Brett Lawrie at a 94!

The A’s best hitter was only at 117 (Reddick). But the A’s have been built this way for years. They really do need that one power bat in the middle of lineup, but not have auto-outs in the lineup is also pretty potent.

BengieStacks
10 years ago

That’s a lot of money. Rich is rich!

30 innings or not, Rich Hill earned a chance to prove himself. Good move for the A’s.

Greg
10 years ago

O/U 100 innings?

DavidBowser
10 years ago
Reply to  Greg

Under. He has not hit a combined minors-majors 100 Inn since 2010, and he only did it a few times prior to that.

Greg
10 years ago
Reply to  DavidBowser

It’s a fair concern. Makes him more difficult to flip.

someone
10 years ago
Reply to  DavidBowser

To be fair, he has been relieving the vast majority of that time, and generally only pitched to one batter when in the majors.

Still a good point however

DavidBowser
10 years ago
Reply to  someone

Frankly, I didn’t even look at his game starts, so good catch.

On that note, he had 11 starts last year between minors/majors. He made 6 in 2012 and 10 in 2010. He has not been a “full time” starter since 2009 when he made 17 starts and one relief appearance.

I think I will stick with my under 100 innings, simply because I doubt he will make more than 13 starts.

DavidBowser
10 years ago

@Dave

Why does the Steamer 2016 show me 1.5 WAR when I click the Rich Hill link and your note shows 2.5 WAR?

Paul Kasiński
10 years ago
Reply to  DavidBowser

It shows me 2.0 WAR, bizarrely

John C
10 years ago

Billy Beane might as well rename the team as the Oakland Athletic Sox.

tz
10 years ago

Why do I feel like this is one of those GEICO ads?

But seriously, this is what Billy Beane does (except for a bunch of blips the last few years). A low-cost gamble with upside, kind of like Kazmir was, or Kang was last year with the Pirates.

GEICO
10 years ago
Reply to  tz

When you’re the Oakland Athletics, you sign Rich Hill. It’s what you do. If you want to save a lot of money on Free Agents, you use Dave Cameron’s Free Agent Bargain Post. It’s what you do.

PS4
10 years ago
Reply to  GEICO

[creepy baby crying]

L. Ron Hoyabembe
10 years ago

Good for Hill, hope he keeps it up. He was an absolute joy to watch down the stretch. Nasty curveball from multiple arm slots.

Baseball Guy
10 years ago

Ha! I can think of at least 20 teams that, if they had signed Rich Hill, this author would be lambasting for wasting $6m on a guy with four good starts.

JorgeFabregas
10 years ago
Reply to  Baseball Guy

No.

Antonio Bananas
10 years ago
Reply to  Baseball Guy

Yea that’s why he was on a list of top bargains (with a spot on crowd estimate) before the deal…

RadermecherMember since 2018
10 years ago

Totally agree,Baseball guy,and L.Ron.Hill is the Edison Volquez of 2016.
Great story,surprised the BoSox passed.

ASK
10 years ago

Well, this author did include Hill in his top bargains article before he signed, so I think that’s pretty unlikely.

ASK
10 years ago
Reply to  ASK

This was meant as a reply to Baseball Guy above.

Doug Lampert
10 years ago
Reply to  ASK

I almost replied to Baseball Guy yesterday to ask if he was a stupid troll, or merely illiterate. But decided not to feed the probable troll.