Joe Musgrove, Padres Agree on Contract Extension

© Orlando Ramirez-USA TODAY Sports

Rumors of a contract negotiations between starting pitcher Joe Musgrove and the San Diego Padres have been percolating for the last month, and those discussions bore fruit over the weekend: With a five-year, $100 million contract extension, the Padres have locked up their best and most dependable starter through the end of the 2027 season.

I discussed a possible Musgrove extension a couple of weeks ago, and not much has changed in the right-hander’s valuation since then, when ZiPS thought that a five year, $126 million contract would be fair for both sides. That makes landing Musgrove for $100 million a nice deal for the Friars, likely the result of some unknown combination of canniness, Musgrove’s comfort at the top of the rotation, and his stated desire to stay with his hometown team (Musgrove is from the San Diego area).

For Padres fans, it must be a relief to get this extension done — even when most of the factors suggest a deal can be reached, there’s no guarantee until there’s ink on the paper. Being from Baltimore, I think back on the acrimonious end to Mike Mussina‘s time in Charm City. Mussina had previously given the O’s a very good deal on a three-year, $21 million contract that bought out a year of free agency, but when he actually did hit the open market, the O’s basically underbid the Yankees, working on the assumption that a hometown discount would be permanently built into his contracts. That the second half of Moose’s Hall of Fame career came with the Yankees still makes me sad! ZiPS projects Musgrove as the best pitcher available in free agency — his projection edges out Carlos Rodón’s — and as with Mussina and the Yankees, all bets are off once the 29 other teams can bid on your franchise pitcher.

Signing Musgrove gives the Padres one less problem to worry about with their long-term rotation. The team still has Mike Clevinger and Sean Manaea hitting free agency this winter, and Yu Darvish and Blake Snell after 2023. The extension also makes Musgrove a significant pitcher in the context of Padres history, especially if the deal works out. San Diego has had a franchise closer in Hall of Famer Trevor Hoffman, but has so far missed out on an equally great starter, one who makes the Hall of Fame or at least comes close. Eric Show remains the only Padre in team history to rack up 100 wins for the franchise, and no pitcher has accumulated 30 WAR while wearing mustard (we won’t talk about those blue uniforms). By comparison, the Royals, who debuted the same year as the Padres, have had six 100-win pitchers and five that passed the 30-WAR mark. The Expos/Nationals have had three in each category, and even the Pilots/Brewers have done slightly better.

If Musgrove meets his projections, he’ll stand at 88 Padres wins at the end of his contract and 25.8 WAR. That already would rank him as one of the team’s greats.

Best Padres Pitchers by WAR
Name W WAR
Jake Peavy 92 28.8
Joe Musgrove (Proj. through 2027) 88 25.8
Trevor Hoffman 54 25.1
Randy Jones 92 23.2
Andy Benes 69 22.6
Andy Ashby 70 18.0
Bruce Hurst 55 15.9
Ed Whitson 77 15.1
Joey Hamilton 55 12.4
Brian Lawrence 49 11.5
Eric Show 100 11.4
Gaylord Perry 33 10.2
Kevin Brown 18 9.6
Tyson Ross 32 9.4
Adam Eaton 47 9.3
Heath Bell 27 8.9
Greg Harris 41 8.9
Mat Latos 27 8.6
Chris Young 33 8.3
Dave Dravecky 53 8.0

That’s right, in more than a half-century, only 12 Padres pitchers have gotten to double-digit WAR.

With just over 24 hours until the trade deadline, the Padres have a lot of work ahead of them, even with their recent move to acquire Josh Hader. But solving one of the team’s pending offseason problems helps trim down their to-do list.





Dan Szymborski is a senior writer for FanGraphs and the developer of the ZiPS projection system. He was a writer for ESPN.com from 2010-2018, a regular guest on a number of radio shows and podcasts, and a voting BBWAA member. He also maintains a terrible Twitter account at @DSzymborski.

20 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
cowdiscipleMember since 2016
4 years ago

Those uniforms are a crime against humanity.

Antonio BananasMember since 2016
4 years ago
Reply to  cowdisciple

How old are you?

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
4 years ago

Younger than Nelson Cruz, but older than Joey Votto.

ClaydvMember since 2018
4 years ago
Reply to  cowdisciple

The crime is that they aren’t their mains.

EonADSMember since 2024
4 years ago
Reply to  Claydv

I’ll be honest, I’m no old biddy and I hate them too. The colors just clash. I’m all for fun unis, but those just look like they threw paint at a uniform.

FrancoeursteinMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  EonADS

I’m young too and the uniforms are ugly. Awful color scheme. You’re not old or out of touch if you don’t like everything new and groundbreaking. Sometimes shit is just atrocious.

tbwhite67Member since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  cowdisciple

I love them, I have two. Picked up a Crockett jersey first, and then later broke down and bought a Tubbs jersey too.

Roman AjzenMember since 2020
4 years ago

My favorite fun fact is now that Kevin Brown’s 1998 season is the 11th best pitcher in Padres’ history.

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
4 years ago

It’s hard not to like this contract for everyone. Musgrove is more of a second-division ace or a really good #2 than a league ace. He could’ve done better in free agency, but probably not a lot better. He’s where he wants to be, and his career earnings go from $16m to $116m.

Jose Berrios and Eduardo Rodriguez are both pretty similar pitchers who got pretty similar contracts

Last edited 4 years ago by cowdisciple
sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  cowdisciple

He’s more of a #3 for me outside of his fantastic but abbreviated 2020. But he’s given out a SIERA in the 3.50 range pretty consistently in San Diego, and it’s not like he was bad before that. I think he’s a rather good bet to hold his value, even if he’s not likely to bust out suddenly. A good, solid playoff-worthy starter.

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

My standards must be lower than yours, but I watch a lot of Twins pitching.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  cowdisciple

I generally use the 5-4-3-2-1 rule, where a #1 is a 5-WAR type of pitcher, a #2 is a 4-WAR type of pitcher, etc.

It’s a bit more generous than Eric and Kiley’s listing on their 20-80 explainer but generally accords with what you’d feel good about going into the playoffs with.

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Fair enough. The guys projected at 4.5 WAR or more are what I call league aces, and my criterion is basically the 5-8 or so guys who are Cy Young favorites.

Cole, Wheeler, Burnes, and Bieber were the only pre-season projections (ZiPS DC) above 5 WAR. Woodruff, Giolito, Scherzer, Nola and Buehler were between 4.5 and 5.

Musgrove isn’t in that class, but he’s somewhere in the next blob down.

Domingo AyalaMember since 2024
4 years ago

You know what they say about pitchers that sign five year deals…

Mean Mr. Mustard
4 years ago
Reply to  Domingo Ayala

… that they’re free agents again in year six?

Domingo AyalaMember since 2024
4 years ago

Lol. I read an article on here that pointed out that mid-level contracts for non-elite pitchers tend not to work out.

dodgerbleu
4 years ago
Reply to  Domingo Ayala

I think we can find articles that show every type of contract for every type of player often doesn’t work out. They don’t ALWAYS fail – Wheeler and Eovaldi contracts come to mind of mid-level contracts that turned out pretty good for non-elite pitchers (though Wheeler is probably elite, he wasn’t considered elite at the time and the Phillies were expected to spend stupid money or whatever Middleton said).

I would think that something like for every one that works out well, three turn out bad and one turns out nominally fair-ish – so 5 contracts, hit on one, push on another, lose on three – but I think that’s true-ish for most contracts.

tung_twista
4 years ago

I’m a little surprised at ZiPS projecting 3.9 WAR for 30 year old Musgrove given that his previous career high was 3.3.
This year, he is on pace to have the best season of his career but ZiPS still expects him to finish with 3.7.
How often does ZiPS project a pitcher to have his best season at 30?

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  tung_twista

There was something similar going on with Kyle Gibson a couple years ago, although at a lower level. A lot of people, including me, thought that projection made no sense. IIRC Gibson was absolutely terrible on year one of the deal but made good on that projection in year 2. Probably just a lucky guess but I can’t shake the idea the projection saw something we didn’t.

Given all that…I’m with you. If he hits that projection I don’t think he will consistently stay there. It’s a lot to ask.

dodgerbleu
4 years ago
Reply to  tung_twista

Good question, thanks for asking.

I think age is less important for pitchers – they don’t age, they break, yada yada. If something in the underlying metrics has improved – spin/velocity/movement – I can see projections improving.

I don’t understand how 2023 projections would be higher than 2022 if the system is buying the improvements. Hopefully we get some color on this – I highly respect ZIPS, not a matter of disagreeing or arguing – just would like to understand!