The Surprising Best Hitting Team of 2014
If I asked you to guess who has been the best hitting team in baseball this year, who would you answer? Before writing this post, I probably would have guessed the Angels, though they actually don’t lead the league in any category one might consider a decent measure of team offense. If you just wanted the answer to be simple, you could go with the A’s, who have scored the most runs (650) of any team in the game, though there’s a traffic jam at the top, as the Tigers (649), Rockies (647), and Angels (642) are all close enough that they could take the lead with one big blowout.
But run scoring is hitting and baserunning and the order in which those events occur, so if we were just asking about which team has hit the best this year, using total runs scored might not give us a great answer. The next simplest answer would be to use something like wRC+, which focuses solely on a team’s performance at the plate and is agnostic about how they sequence those hits, so it is measuring what we generally think of as hitting talent. It also adjusts for park effects, which we want to do. By this measure, the best hitting team in baseball this year has been the Detroit Tigers, with a wRC+ of 109.
But even that’s not really looking at things on a level playing field, because the Tigers are in the AL and get to use the DH, while NL teams have to let their pitcher hit, which drags down their overall totals. So, what we really want to use is wRC+ with pitcher-hitting excluded, so that we’re just evaluating one team’s hitters against another. And if you use the toggle to look at team batting with pitcher’s excluded, you’ll find the best performance by a team’s hitters this year comes from the Pittsburgh Pirates, with a 113 wRC+.
Yeah, I was stunned too. Very quietly, the Pirates have really hit the ball this year. We know about Andrew McCutchen, but Russell Martin is basically hitting like Buster Posey, Neil Walker has been the best hitting second baseman in the NL, and play-everywhere-guy Josh Harrison has hit better than Robinson Cano this year. Toss in an improved bat from Starling Marte and a couple of okay platoon-types in Ike Davis and Travis Snider, and the Pirates line-up has performed better than any other in baseball this year. Who knew?
Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.


And yet… and yet… (1) pitcher hitting matters because it is, what 1/10th or so of your at-bats … and our pitchers are uniquely horrible and (2) this team may be the worst RISP team I’ve ever seen.
My point is that I’m going to throw myself off of a bridge.
Funny Dave that as soon as I saw the title on the main page I knew the answer. Its remarkable how much complaining is done here in Pittsburgh about the offense. I suppose most of it is tied to classic talking points like situational hitting and such.
Except the situational hitting thing really isn’t true either.
The non pitchers have a 111 wRC+ with RISP 4th best in all of baseball. In high leverage situations they also have the 4th best mark at 113.
One situation I see people complain about a lot is runner on third less than 2 outs but the Pirates have a 130 sOPS+ in those situations best in baseball (I wasn’t sure how to find wRC+ for this situation).
I really don’t understand what it is.
Oh I know, its a classic knee jerk response to remember all the times they fail to move a runner and forget the times that they do. Its kind of like the 1 run game fallacy. Most fans accept 1 run wins as being deserved, but 1 run losses are epic disasters and games that got away. In the one run loss its always the line about how one key hit or out would have made the difference, which is likely true. This is then interpreted as the team failing to get the big play. However, most fans forget that they did get the key hit or out in the 1 run win.
Noodle around with the columns here: http://is.gd/RISPstats
The Pirates have a ton of GIDP and walks with runners in scoring position and almost no sac flies. Walks are good for OBP/OPS (and objectively good!) but they usually don’t push across a run. And while I don’t have the stats for it, the Pirates just don’t seem to get those hits when the game is late and close.
I *confess* that I am watching this with a fans eyes, so my memory may be selective but it isn’t THAT selective. For whatever reason, accepting that “clutch” isn’t a moral attribute or an individual skill, the Pirates just haven’t clustered their hits very well all that often.
Martin, McCutchen, Harrison, and Marte, by the eyeball test, have been excellent in RISP situations. given how many at bats these guys get relative to the rest of the lineup, it doesn’t seem so outlandish to think they’ve been good, overall, at pushing runs across.
Regardless of how they perform on average in those situations, though, they have simply generated so many baserunners that they can score a lot of runs without even being all that good in RISP situations.
Baseball Reference has that stat, runner on 3rd less than 2 outs in the form of success rate. The Pirates success rate is 52% in the situation, league average 51%.
http://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/MLB/2014-situational-batting.shtml
Though less HRs than last year,
One of the worst obp teams last year, now one of the best.
Wow
Starling Marte’s bat has improved?!
Yeah his wRC+ is identical to 2013, wOBA is .001 point different. He basically has had the same above average year at the plate. I think Dave is referring to his improvement in the 2nd half of the year.
I think they’ve gotten unlucky overall as far as stringing together good batting events. Or maybe more accurately not very lucky. The Pirates are a good example of why baseball is hard to predict. The whole ‘bring Polanco up immediately’ didn’t turn out as well as sticking with the rest of the team, and specifically the player that stepped up in RF before he came up, while the solid pitching from last year faltered.