The Weirdest Trade of the Day (Year?)
The trade deadline always brings us surprises, but man, this one takes the cake for out-of-nowhere deal that no one could have seen coming.
Source: #Twins acquire Hector Santiago from #Angels.
— Ken Rosenthal (@Ken_Rosenthal) August 1, 2016
Nolasco and Meyer from #Twins to #Angels.
— Ken Rosenthal (@Ken_Rosenthal) August 1, 2016
Told #Angels–#Twins trade is cash-neutral. Cash going from MIN to LAA presumably.
— Ken Rosenthal (@Ken_Rosenthal) August 1, 2016
If you had Hector Santiago for Ricky Nolasco in your trade predictions post, you are either Billy Eppler or Rob Antony, or a crazy person.
So we have two sellers swapping big league starting pitchers at a time when most buyers looking for pitching help can’t find big league starting pitchers to trade for. That’s pretty weird!
On the other hand, I can kind of squint and see this. The Twins get a Twins-like pitcher, a guy who has spent his career beating FIP by inducing a million infield flies, and looks like a perfectly useful mid-rotation starter. The Angels get a guy who controls the strike zone a bit better but has underperformed his FIP forever, making him much worse than his peripherals suggest, and is closer to a replacement level arm. In exchange for downgrading their rotation, the Angels get a lottery ticket pitching prospect in Alex Meyer, who is big and throws hard but can’t command the zone.
The Angels will take on a few million bucks in payroll next year, when Nolasco is due $12 million while Santiago will make less than that in his final arbitration season, but financially, there isn’t a huge difference here. So the Angels just make themselves a bit worse while getting a different innings sponge and admitting that they’re looking long-term.
Why the Twins themselves are the ones acquiring Santiago, I’m not entirely sure. Perhaps they’re going to trade Ervin Santana and wanted to have someone around to eat innings, and thought that Meyer wasn’t too high a price to pay for some credible big league pitching over the next year. If he keeps pitching well, he can probably be flipped for an equally decent prospect this winter or next deadline.
So it’s not like this trade is a disaster or anything. It’s just pretty weird to see a 40-64 team trading for a pitcher with some present value by shipping a prospect to a 47-58 team at the deadline.
Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.


It might be even weirder to see where Meyer ranks on an updated Angels prospects list.
Guess the Angels needed a less reliable starter
Colin Rea & Luis Castillo say hi
this, for sure
How about Liriano, Harold Ramirez and Reese McGuire for Drew Hutchinson?
Someone is going to have to explain what the Pirates are doing on that one to me.
Well, Ramirez is surplus with Meadows around, McGuire hasn’t really developed, and Hutchison used to be kind of good in the minor leagues…
No, I don’t think there’s a way to spin that as anything but a terrible trade.
Searage, I mean Pittsburgh has three more years of control with Hutchison. And his traditional stats have been poor enough to keep his arbitration cost low for the next few years.
I couldn’t believe there wasn’t a post about this. Trade makes absolutely no sense to me.
This could end up being a disastrous trade for one of these GM’s.
If you’re Billy Eppler and you trade a #4 starter with a year of control in this market and get absolutely nothing, then that’s a big strike against you. It doesn’t help that he also threw in a minor league RP who can hit 100 mph.
If you are Rob Antony and Alex Meyer somehow finds the strike zone, stays healthy and fulfills that top prospect potential the Twins could really regret this.
Of course when you weigh the probabilities it’s hard to see this one working out for the Angels. In a sellers market you’d expect to get more for Santiago who at the very least would probably make a better reliever than Will Smith. Unfortunately it looks like were more concerned with trading one starter for 2, in 2017, as coming in to today they only had 3 guys penciled in and one of them has thrown 12 innings over the last two years.
This trade is indeed bizarre. But it sounds like Moreno is steadfast against going over the luxury tax threshold. Twins are paying for Nolasco this year and sending $4M next year, bringing the Angels’ commitment down to $8M. Santiago, at $5M this year, and an expected bump up to close to $8M in his last year of arbitration next year, the Angels see no financial change and get a highish-upside/HUGE risk pitching prospect in Alex Meyer.
Their system is barren and guys like Meyer are guys they have to take a flyer on now. Next year is another lost year. “Why not throw Nolasco out there” seems to be the reasoning. It’s not going to really matter.