It Might Be Time For The Braves To Deal Craig Kimbrel

As November turns into December, we have a pretty good idea of what most teams are attempting to do with their short-term futures. The Red Sox are going for it, obviously, and so are the Blue Jays. The White Sox seem like they’re trying to improve for 2015; the Phillies might finally be ready to accept that they need to start over. Teams like the Cubs, Dodgers and Yankees haven’t yet made much noise, but their intentions are clear. Other than whatever it is the A’s are trying to pull, where most teams are on the success cycle is more or less an open secret.

Other than the Braves, that is. The trade that sent Jason Heyward and Jordan Walden to St. Louis for Shelby Miller and Tyrell Jenkins was largely unpopular in Atlanta, but it made a considerable amount of sense for both sides, because the Cardinals got one year of the best player involved and the Braves got 10 years of two pitchers with upside. For the long term, assuming they had decided that extending Heyward was just not going to happen, it’s a smart move. For the short term, it almost unquestionably made their 2015 team worse, and there’s been at least one recent media report that indicates that “it sounds as if the Braves will make moves aimed toward competing for titles in 2017 rather than the next two seasons.”

If so, that makes sense. There’s obvious appeal in having a winner ready for the new ballpark the club will move into in 2017, and this current Braves team, as constructed, isn’t likely to be particularly good. There’s constant rumors that Justin Upton could be traded, too, and Evan Gattis might follow him out the door as well — or worse, start every day in left field. There’s not currently a second baseman, or realistic hope for B.J. Upton, and the rotation is full of question marks. This was a bad offense last year, and without Heyward, now it looks worse.

With that reality, here’s the question: Why not trade Craig Kimbrel? Like, now?

Before we delve into Kimbrel, let’s qualify the “this team isn’t likely to be particularly good” statement. That’s not just an idea pulled out of thin air. It’s an acknowledgment that a franchise that has won exactly two playoff games in the nine seasons since their endless run atop the NL East came to a close in 2005 just lost more games than they have since 2008, and that their projected WAR position on our 2015 Depth Charts is pretty dire:
projected_war_2015_1201014

Perhaps you think Miller’s projection underrates him (certainly, his inconsistency plays a role here) or that Julio Teheran or Mike Minor are going to be better than Steamer thinks. That’s fine. There’s certainly room to quibble around the small edges of a WAR projection. But the point is that there’s no amount of squinting that’s going to move the Braves from the far right end of this chart to the left end, unless the team somehow manages to fill replacement-level holes at second base (Phil Gosselin), third base (Chris Johnson), left field (Gattis), center field (B.J. Upton), and at the bottom of the rotation. If they trade Justin Upton, add another problem area to the list, dependent of course on what they get back.

It’s not impossible that the Braves pull it all together for a surprise run in 2015, but the facts of the situation and their own move to weaken the offense make it seem unlikely. This isn’t a full-scale teardown either, not with Freddie Freeman and Andrelton Simmons around and Miller joining a relatively young rotation. But it is a situation where you have to ask yourself which scenario is preferable, in regards to Kimbrel:

1) Keep him for a potentially down season or two where a closer — even an elite one — is more a luxury than a necessity and pray that he’s still a valuable piece in 2017, his eighth season, when he’ll be owed $13.25 million, and the relaunch is hopefully ready;

2) Trade him now, add a boost to a limited farm system to aid that relaunch, and pass off the risk on someone else.

And there is risk, of course. This isn’t a piece about how Kimbrel has some warning sign of impending doom or that his velocity is about to implode or anything like that. If you wanted to try really, really hard to do that, you could note that his K%-BB% has dropped from 44.2 to 30.2 to 28.3 over the last three years, but that’s just the difference between “unfathomably, unspeakably great” and “really, truly outstanding.” He’s one of the two best closers in the game along with Aroldis Chapman. It’s not my intention to convince you that he isn’t.

It is, however, worth noting that in order for what the Braves appear to be attempting to work, to build around their closer and hope that he’s still fantastic and worth a high salary three seasons from now and eight seasons in, we’re not just talking about Kimbrel’s place among his contemporaries. The bet would then have to be that Kimbrel isn’t just something special, but that he’s historic in a way that few others have ever been.

In the last 30 years of baseball, or roughly the era where the modern bullpen has been in use, there have been 176 qualified closer seasons (defined as “10 saves,” and while I despise saves as much as you do, it’s an easy way to define Kimbrel’s closer brethren) worth at least 2 WAR. Four of those belong to Kimbrel. Other than the incomparable Mariano Rivera, no one has topped six:

10 Mariano Rivera
6 Billy Wagner
6 Joe Nathan
5 Jonathan Papelbon
5 Trevor Hoffman
5 Robb Nen

But Rivera, Nathan and Hoffman all took a few years into their careers before they were handed the ninth inning, so let’s look at this another way. Kimbrel just completed his age-26 season, and the chart below shows the top 20 relievers (not closers, this time) by career WAR over the same 30-year span.

Relievers through age 26, 1985-2014
Name ERA FIP WAR
Francisco Rodriguez 2.35 2.84 12.5
Craig Kimbrel 1.43 1.52 11.4
Huston Street 3.00 2.97 9.2
Gregg Olson 2.26 2.61 8.9
Rob Dibble 1.90 1.78 8.9
Jonathan Broxton 3.11 2.62 8.8
Aroldis Chapman 2.32 1.97 8.6
Kenley Jansen 2.25 200 8.3
Joakim Soria 2.01 2.76 7.5
Dan Plesac 2.71 2.64 7.1
Byung-Hyun Kim 3.46 3.47 6.7
Mark Wohlers 3.28 2.84 6.6
Ugueth Urbina 2.94 2.93 6.2
Mark Eichhorn 2.37 3.14 6.0
Juan Rincon 3.23 3.06 5.9
Jonathan Papelbon 1.56 2.46 5.9
Duane Ward 3.63 3.17 5.8
John Wetteland 2.09 2.41 5.7
Armando Benitez 3.15 3.55 5.3

There’s a few success stories for post-26 careers here, notably Papelbon and Street, and some contemporaries in Jansen and Chapman who haven’t written their futures yet. Rodriguez never completely collapsed, but nor has he been anything like what he was as a young Angel, either. Dibble, Olson, Wohlers and Urbina were all basically done by 30. Overall, this isn’t a fantastically exciting group as far as young closers who have succeeded to become old closers.

Obviously, the experiences of others don’t guarantee anything about Kimbrel, and his peak has been higher than most of the other names listed here — and hey, maybe he really is the once-in-a-generation guy he’s looked like, the one who breaks all of the rules we’ve learned to live by. You can’t just cover your eyes and expect that his dominance is going to continue indefinitely. It very rarely works that way, and if it doesn’t, the Braves might find themselves wishing they had sold when his value was its highest. (As for what they could get, coming up with speculative trade ideas is often folly, but it’s fair to note that win-now contenders like the Tigers, Dodgers, Angels, Blue Jays, etc., could all stand to benefit from an elite arm, even if they already have a closer.)

If the Braves were positioned to be a strong contender in 2015, this isn’t a conversation we’re even thinking about. If 2016 was the goal, this isn’t a thought either. But now we’re talking about 2017, three seasons out, and that’s a date that’s fueled more by a ballpark than by a particular group of players all being ready, like you might say with the 2016 Cubs. The question is less about finding reasons why the Braves should trade Kimbrel, and more about finding reasons why they shouldn’t. Otherwise, the plan seems to be cross your fingers and pray that this all works out in three years. That might be the biggest risk of all.





Mike Petriello used to write here, and now he does not. Find him at @mike_petriello or MLB.com.

63 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
haishan
11 years ago

Do closers typically get better returns in the offseason or at the trade deadline? Kimbrel might not be an all-world closer for three more years, but odds are he’ll still be pretty damn good in July. And while it’s not certain that any contenders will have a hole in the bullpen, Kimbrel’s so good that he’s still likely to represent an upgrade for most of them.

Game, Blauser
11 years ago
Reply to  haishan

This is my line of thinking too – closers seems to bring at least as much in return at the trade deadline as they do in the offseason. That would be especially true for Kimbrel, who is under contract through 2017 with a $13M team option for 2018. The Braves can keep Kimbrel to start the year to avoid pissing off the likely dwindling base of season ticket holders, and then wait of the right opportunity to sell him off mid-season. At that point, the Braves will likely be far enough out of the playoff hunt that the GM Hart can sell the move as necessary / logical / etc.

Dovif
11 years ago
Reply to  haishan

Team do not pay for closers during the trade deadline anymore. Most contenders have a few closing options, and need to exhaust them before trading and they might trade for a elite middle guy anyway. Maybe phillies is the best option

Conrad
11 years ago
Reply to  Dovif

Huston Street was a significant trade deadline acquisition made by the Angels, and it could be argued that he was a key piece in their stretch run. According to Mike Petriello, the trio of prospects the Angels gave up could have been their top three. There was also a lot of talk surrounding Papelbon. The market depends on need, and closers are among the most volatile players in the game.

MARK LIU
11 years ago
Reply to  Conrad

The thing with the trio of prospects the Angels gave up were that they were like top-10 prospects at best. Nothing too special.

ZiPS
11 years ago

Release me upon the public like a plague and henceforth benefit from my page hits the rest of the off-season!

jtt
11 years ago

endless run came to a close?

Anon21
11 years ago

Based on their public statements, they seem determined to keep him. That could be a smokescreen, but I’m inclined to think it’s sincere. He’s a fan favorite, and obviously in the discussion for best at his position. Now, that position is pretty unimportant, particularly for a bad team, but this was the same team that guaranteed him a bunch of money to fill that relatively unimportant role just last offseason, so I guess it’s not news that they overrate his good qualities and underrate his risks.

Dave Cornutt
11 years ago
Reply to  Anon21

The Braves are at a turning point, where decisions made by the front office are going to have a huge impact on the near future. John Hart said just a few days ago that the Braves are “reloading, not rebuilding”, but that doesn’t appear to be working. As many have pointed out, one thing the current Braves team desperately needs is help with the offense and in the outfield, and said help doesn’t appear to be available in the market right now at a price that the Braves are willing to pay. If they obtain more young pitching talent in an Upton trade, which appears to be the way the rumors are going, that’s great for the future but it doesn’t help the present much.

If the Braves are going to retain Kimbrel, they will need to try to save his arm and limit his appearances in 2015, probably to around 50. For a team that is projected to lose 90 games, that would not seem to be that hard, but Braves manager Fredi Gonzalez is notorioug for his bullpen mismanagement. It’s a big risk. The Yankees, for one, would love to have Kimbrel as a cheaper alternative to re-signing David Robertson, but it’s not clear what they could offer in trade. (They could offer to take B.J. Upton’s contract…) If the Braves figured to content this year, they might go for a package featuring Brett Gardner, but he’s too old now to keep around for a two-year rebuild.

The point about Kimbrel being a fan favorite is a good one, and it’s one of those intangible things that front offices have to keep in mind. They just traded away a fan favorite in Heyward, and they’re talkig about trading Gattis who is another favorite. Fielding a losing team is one thing; fielding a losing team that doesn’t have any exciting players (other than the starting pitchers) and is boring to watch is another. New ballpark, yada yada, but it won’t look very good if only 3000 fans turn up for the final game at Turner Field in 2016. Then again, the point is taken: Even a premiere closer doesn’t really make a bad team much better.

Brooks
11 years ago
Reply to  Dave Cornutt

I don’t know how you support the assertion that limiting Kimbrel to 50 appearances a year would save his arm. Relief pitchers throughout professional baseball follow a cycle where they throw two consecutive days followed by one day of rest. This is why managers loathe to call upon a reliever to pitch three consecutive days. Kimbrel has pitched on three consecutive days only 17 times in his career, and only three times in 2014. And he’s never pitched on four consecutive days.

The pitches on the mound in the bullpen put just as much stress on the shoulder and elbow joints as the pitches on the mound during a game. And by routinely throwing fastballs close to 100 mph and breaking balls at 86 mph, Kimbrel is already pushing the limits that our species can endure.

Costanza
11 years ago
Reply to  Brooks

You seem to indicate that this is fact supported by evidence. Will you please provide evidence that pitches in the bullpen put just as much stress on the arm as in the game? I’m under the impression that pitchers throw 75-90% in the pen, dropping Kimbrel down to a less risky profile.

“The pitches on the mound in the bullpen put just as much stress on the shoulder and elbow joints as the pitches on the mound during a game. And by routinely throwing fastballs close to 100 mph and breaking balls at 86 mph, Kimbrel is already pushing the limits that our species can endure.”

Dave Cornutt
11 years ago
Reply to  Brooks

Well, even if they’re only 75%, that’s not nothing. However, what I was trying to say by saying that the Braves need to limit Kimbrel’s appearances is that they need to limit the number of pitches he throws anywhere, whether it be in a game, in the bullpen, or on the side. The FO would have to lay down a rule that, say, Kimbrel can only be used in a maximum of two games a week, and with at least one game in between appearances. That means that for the other games he’s not available — no throwing in the bullpen, nothing.

buzzdeadwax
11 years ago

As a Braves fan, it’s been extremely frustrating to see the front office give 40 million to a Proven Closer™ and guaranteed money to a below average 3B, but turn right around and cry poverty when it comes to Heyward and good Upton, who are both legitimate difference makers. It certainly doesn’t inspire confidence that this team has a plan, or at least not a good one.

Dave Cornutt
11 years ago
Reply to  buzzdeadwax

I’m really starting to think that Liberty Media has instructed John Hart to cut payroll. All last year Braves fans operated under the assumption that if one of Heyward or Justin Upton was traded, the team could afford to extend the other one. Presumably a main reason why Heyward was traded was that he was not open to an extension, and Upton was. Now it appears that there wasn’t money to extend either one, despite Santana’s contract coming off the books. Apparently they aren’t going to allow the Braves to spend again untl the Uggla and BJ Upton contracs expire.

Brooks
11 years ago
Reply to  Dave Cornutt

I agree. Liberty Media/Liberty Capital has sound financial reasons to decrease the Braves payroll until they move to their subsidized palace in Cobb County. I expect there to be some lean years for the Braves until 2017.

Free_AEC
11 years ago
Reply to  Dave Cornutt

If Ted Turner were the owner instead of that bloodsucker John C. Malone the Braves would have a $200 million payroll, and the Braves would be profitable.

The information floated about the Braves supposed limitations is a big lie.

_

Highlight and Google: John Powers Middleton Felony Fraud

_

NickB
11 years ago
Reply to  Dave Cornutt

Team CEO McGuirk stated that team payroll will be right around the $112m mark of last year. and Liberty doesn’t intrude into team affairs as long as they don’t lose money, which they never have. remember, with the re-worked local TV deal and the extra $25m fron the national MLB TV deal, the Braves have enough $$$ to increase payroll without maintaining at least break even if not profitable status.

Dave Cornutt
11 years ago
Reply to  NickB

They say that, but according to MLBTR their committed+arb payroll was at $101M before the Heyward trade. That trade lowered it to $94M, and if they trade Justin Upton and don’t take any salary back, that lowers it to $80M. I know it’s early in the winter yet, but I don’t see where they are going to spend it.

Michael Procton
11 years ago
Reply to  Dave Cornutt

Can you blame them? They jacked up the payroll big time last year to buy Santana and give the 2014 Braves a chance to win, and they totally shit the bed. Liberty runs the Braves as a line item, and it’s not one they’re willing to lose money on.

Wren's Bleeding Hart
11 years ago

The Braves should absolutely deal Kimbrel, he is an unneeded asset for a rebuilding team.

Kyle
11 years ago

What kind of trade value does an elite reliever already being paid significant coin have?

The money remaining on his deal (3/34 without the option, 4/46 with) seems pretty in-line with what free agents Andrew Miller and David Robertson are poised to receive, but one costs only money and the other costs money plus a draft pick.

Are we talking about a high-end prospect in a system, or does his salary cancel out much of the production value and it’s more of a mid-tier prospect? Off the top of my head I can’t think of a reliever with a big contract getting traded in the offseason; normally it’s a deadline deal for a pitcher on an expiring contract.

Walter
11 years ago
Reply to  Kyle

Very much otm. That the Barves moving Kimbrel makes sense is obvious. Less obvious is that they’d get anything of value in return — every other team can logic through this as well as Mike P. says the Barves should here, and even without these concerns Kimbrel’s still an expensive RP, which few teams think is worth rostering.

JaxFalcon/DogFan
11 years ago
Reply to  Walter

If you want to be taken seriously, then perhaps you should cease the sarcastic (not to mention irritating) reference to the team name.

vivalajeter
11 years ago
Reply to  Kyle

I don’t know what type of prospects they’d receive, but if money is comparable, I’d think Kimbrell is easily worth a terrific prospect over Miller. As good as Miller was last year, it came out of nowhere. There are plenty of relievers who had a great season out of the blue, and then never maintained it.

Kimbrell has been elite since he was first called up. His FIP has been under 2.00 every year of his career. His career-high ERA is 2.10 in 2011, and it’s been under 2.00 every other year. His xFIP has only been above 2.00 once (in 2014, when it was 2.24). The only way Miller is comparable is if you look at 2014 and ignore the rest of their careers.

tz
11 years ago
Reply to  vivalajeter

And like Haishan pointed out above, they might do well to wait until mid-season. If you consider what the Tigers gave Texas for Soria this past season (two useful pitching prospects), Kimbrel could snag a real good haul from a contender that’s grown weary of their struggling closer.

TKDC
11 years ago
Reply to  Kyle

The idea that signing a free agent version of Kimbrel would cost you 3/$34 million is absurd. If he for some reason wanted a three year deal, he could easily get over $50 million, and the 4th year option is worth something. There is probably around $20 million in excess value in his contract in a vacuum, he’s just not nearly that valuable to a likely struggling Braves team.

In addition, for teams that are better, it can be hard to increase value, but having a top-2 closer is one way every competitive team in baseball could get better next year. Even without the “Proven Closer” nonsense he would be on the radar of virtually every good team if the Braves dangled him.

Free_AEC
11 years ago
Reply to  TKDC

More than $16 million a year for Kimbrel on a three year deal?

Sorry, the Phillies have Papelbon and even they wouldn’t go that high for a reliever. No one in their right mind would.

If Kimbrel is worth that much than Kershaw and his type would be worth $50 million a year and so would Mike Trout.

Of course, Trout probably is worth $50 million per year but that’s another subject.

_

Highlight and Google: John Powers Middleton Felony Fraud

_

vivalajeter
11 years ago
Reply to  Free_AEC

I don’t think it’s that outlandish. I read that Robertson had offers of at least $39MM/3 years. Kimbrel is a good deal better than Robertson. He wouldn’t necessarily be worth $16MM/year from a WAR perspective, but I wouldn’t be surprised if he got that offer.

TKDC
11 years ago
Reply to  Free_AEC

If Trout were a free agent right now asking for a 3-year deal, he would get $50 million per year.

There is a point where it doesn’t matter what teams think of a guy they simply won’t pay. Trout’s market would be very limited, but one of the big market teams would pay. Paying $16-17 million per year for a closer is probably stupid, even for Kimbrel, but someone would do it. Remember, the crowd is pretty much always short on these things.

Marsupial Jones
11 years ago
Reply to  Kyle

The Royals just traded Aaron Crow (a not very good reliever) for a couple mid level prospects so I would assume Kimbrel could net at least something decent in return.

Vlad
11 years ago

I think this article is a little premature. The Braves are a very fluid team right now. If J. Upton and/or Gattis are traded, the returns from those deals may jumpstart the Braves into 2016 as fringe contenders.

Uggla expires after this year. BJ will linger like an anchor thru 2017, so they’ll just have to work around him.

I’m loathe to pay closers the kind of money Kimbrel gets, but he could still be valuable the last two years (plus option, maybe) of the deal.

tomemos
11 years ago

“Before we delve into Kimbrel, let’s qualify the “this team isn’t likely to be particularly good” statement. That’s not just an idea pulled out of thin air.”

Wait, “qualify” doesn’t mean “justify,” it means “limit” or revise.”

Frank Wren
11 years ago

I made a lot of money mistakes guys, for the sake of the future Braves fans who are our children, please tear it to the ground and start over. Nothing good will come of the Braves for the next 2 years, someone smarter than myself should at least position this team to be competitive from 2017 to 2027. We all know I did my best to keep that from happening.

P.S. Bj, if you’re out there, I love you man.

bvillebaron
11 years ago

Seems to me Hart was the one who persuaded Wren last offseason to include Kimbrel in the group of core players to sign long term. My guess is the Yankees could have gotten a lot for Rivera if they wanted to trade him after a few good years.

Free_AEC
11 years ago
Reply to  bvillebaron

No team gets a lot for a reliever.

Go find two deals in MLB history for relievers where the team “got a lot”.

_

Highlight and Google: John Powers Middleton Felony Fraud

_

ReuschelCakes
11 years ago
Reply to  Free_AEC

Red Sox gave up Jeff Bagwell for Larry Andersen
Mariners gave up Jason Varitek and Derek Lowe for Heathcliff Slocumb

chuckb
11 years ago
Reply to  ReuschelCakes

Maybe he meant where the team getting the reliever “got a lot.”

We’ll done, Rick.

Free_AEC
11 years ago
Reply to  ReuschelCakes

Fair enough. I forgot about the Heathcliff Slocumb deal to Seattle.

Larry Andersen has been a Phillies broadcaster for more than a dozen years so I’m well acquainted with that one.

However, you see the time distance between those deals and now? The MLB culture has changed since that time. The Phillies can’t get someone good for Papelbon even by eating a lot of money since no team gets a lot for a closer anymore.

Even starting pitching doesn’t have anywhere near the value it did ten years ago since hitting dominated the game ten years back and that has flipped 180 degrees since.

_

Highlight and Google: John Powers Middleton Felony Fraud

_

Dan
11 years ago
Reply to  ReuschelCakes

The Phillies can’t get anything for Papelbon because of his declining peripherals/age/velocity questions all combined with his high salary.

Comparing Kimbrel and Papelbon is like comparing Clayton Kershaw and Doug Fister, and then concluding that Kershaw isn’t worth very much because Fister only netted Robbie Ray.

Foz4
11 years ago
Reply to  Free_AEC

Dodgers traded Paul Konerko for Jeff Shaw.

Joel
11 years ago
Reply to  Free_AEC

Ugueth Urbina for Adrian Gonzalez

Aduhey
11 years ago

I don’t think the Braves will have many leads going to the ninth inning to give to Craig Kimbrel.

The Braves will not be able to get many wins against teams with losing records as well.

Free_AEC
11 years ago

Why not trade Craig Kimbrel? Like, now?

The Phillies have been trying to unload one of the best closers in MLB in Jonathan Papelbon for two years now with no takers, even if they eat money.

What do you think the Braves are going to get for Kimbrel, Nick Castellanos? They’ll get a sack of Scott’s Humus and manure which they could just buy for $2.49 at Home Depot.

Braves fans weren’t happy about the Heyward trade? No s__t. Imagine that, they get a perfectly solid fifth starter with fading command who is headed to the bullpen in the long run in exchange for one of the best young outfielders in MLB and Braves fans aren’t happy? Just an ungrateful bunch huh?

Did you know that Atlanta is the ninth largest market in MLB? You’d never guess that from the way the Braves operate would you?

_

Highlight and Google: John Powers Middleton Felony Fraud

_

BipMember since 2016
11 years ago
Reply to  Free_AEC

Their TV contract is the worst in baseball.

Also, I’m not going to google that, care to summarize?

Free_AEC
11 years ago
Reply to  Bip

“Also, I’m not going to google that, care to summarize?”

Is this some kind of sabermetrics humor?

_

Highlight and Google: John Powers Middleton Felony Fraud

_

vivalajeter
11 years ago
Reply to  Free_AEC

Papelbon isn’t nearly on Kimbrel’s level though. Kimbrel routinely has his ERA, FIP and xFIP under 2.00. Papelbon almost never does, and his velocity is rapidly declining so teams are seemingly waiting for him to implode.

Papelbon just surprised everybody with a 2.04 ERA. That’s just a hair away from Kimbrel’s career-worst ERA.

chuckb
11 years ago
Reply to  vivalajeter

The difference between Kimbrell and Papelbon is huge. Not only is Kimbrell much better — clearly at least a top 3 closer — but he’s also much younger. The market for Kimbrell, if the Braves decided to shop him, would be substantial.

Big Hungry Joe
11 years ago
Reply to  chuckb

Didnt the Marlins just give up their 10th rated prospect and another guy for Aaron Crow? The same Aaron Crow that posted nearly a -1 WAR last year?

Yeah, I gotta believe Kimbrel would get them something good.

Free_AEC
11 years ago
Reply to  chuckb

“Marlins just give up their 10th rated prospect ”

You just said nothing.

Every team has a “tenth rated prospect”

The 15th best rated prospect in the Cubs system might be number one if he were in the Angels system.

_

Highlight and Google: John Powers Middleton Felony Fraud

_

Aduhey
11 years ago
Reply to  Free_AEC

Thank you Free_AEC

I did the search and was enlightened.

Free_AEC
11 years ago
Reply to  Aduhey

If you follow those links well they will lead you to John Middleton’s still under contruction Palm Beach, Florida castle along with pictures from his architect’s website.

_

Highlight and Google: John Powers Middleton Felony Fraud

_

Smurf
11 years ago
Reply to  Free_AEC

I’m not convinced that RAJ is really willing to eat all that much of Papelbon’s money.

Plus, Papelbon’s a giant, giant, GIANT dbag. So, there’s that.

Free_AEC
11 years ago
Reply to  Smurf

Amaro doesn’t own the Phillies. He’s a salaried employee.

Owners decide whether and how much money is going to be eaten.

_

Highlight and Google: John Powers Middleton Felony Fraud

_

Antonio Bananas
11 years ago

Honestly not sure Hart knows what he’s doing. Over the last few years the Braves look like the old guys at the table getting passed up by the game. I wouldn’t be surprised if they try to keep “RBI guys” and “proven closers” and continue to trade guys like Heyward because they “have a low batting average” or whatever. It’s depressing.

I’m not sure if I would trade Kimbrel. I didn’t think they were all that far from contending in 2015 (healthy SP+young guys getting better, some positive regression, etc), but then they traded their best player.

A trade like maybe Gattis to KC for Dyson and Colon, then JUpton to TEX for Profar and Gallo or Choice could set the team up for a solid 2016. Really depends on what Hart thinks he’s doing. Billy Beane reloads, I trust Billy Beane. I don’t trust the Braves yet.

Brandon Ensley
11 years ago

I would make Kimbrel a starter before I traded him if I was concerned about Atlanta not being in position to have games saved in the 9th. An arm like his is really hard to come by. You guys might change your mind if Atlanta does have a good season and we have to use David Carpenter to close out games instead of Kimbrel.

Dave Cornutt
11 years ago
Reply to  Brandon Ensley

I don’t think Kimbrel would work as a starter. He really only has two pitches, and the value of his knuckle curve or whatever it is comes mainly from velocity, which he would not be able to keep up into the higher pitch counts. It would be kind of like when the Braves tried to make Steve Bedrosian a starter.

jrubyMember since 2016
11 years ago

Holy cow is the NL East going to be bad. Four of the worst nine teams by projected WAR.

In a related note, the Phillies should take a page from the 76ers. Call up two dozen minor leaguers, trade all their starters, and stock up on first-round draft picks, which are sure to be future Hall of Famers. That’s how the MLB works right?

Dave Cornutt
11 years ago
Reply to  jruby

That’s why the Nationals are figuring that they can trade away some wins… they’ll still win enough games to win the division.

vivalajeter
11 years ago
Reply to  Dave Cornutt

On the one hand, I can see them giving up wins for the future. If it puts them in a better spot for 2016 and beyond, it could be worth the trade-off. If I was them, I’d probably take that path.

On the other hand, it’s tough to give away wins when the season hasn’t even started yet. If you polled GMs, scouts, etc, the Mets would most likely be ranked as a top-10 pitching staff next year. I vaguely recall Keith Law saying they were the ~5th best rotation, but don’t quote me on that. Steamer has them as the third worst rotation. I don’t know if a single GM would think they’re in the bottom half, let alone the bottom 10% of the league. Give them the WAR of the 10th best staff (which they probably deserve) and suddenly they’re not so awful.

The Marlins are a young team with a high variance. They could tank, or their young guys can develop well. Their ‘average’ year might not be great, but they’re capable of competing. And the off-season isn’t over yet, so maybe the Braves have a pretty good strategy to make them better next year. Phillies are pretty much a guarantee to be awful, but the other three teams at least have a shot at being good.

Strasburg or Harper get hurt, Werth goes back to his 2011-2012 levels, and they trade away a starter – maybe they’re no longer a lock.

But as I said, chances are they’ll be fine, and they should at least explore giving away current wins for future wins.

Aduhey
11 years ago
Reply to  Dave Cornutt

The Nats only would have needed 80 wins last season.

Smurf
11 years ago

After last season, I could absolutely see DET going after Kimbrel. TOR, too.

What would a package of JUP + Kimbrell to DET look like? Gose and some pitching prospects?

Same question if they sent those dudes to TOR. Pompey, maybe?

doktrt
11 years ago

The Cubs need a closer. They should trade Kris Bryant to Braves for Kimbrell and C. Johnson. A win-win for both teams.

Esam
11 years ago

John Hart is that you?