Jason Castro Is a Step in the Right Direction for the Twins
Ah, the Twins. So often over the past few offseasons the Twins have been the club whose moves cause a scratching of the head and subdued “Oh, honey” under one’s breath. The franchise has long been stuck in the traditionalist mud. Until this season, at least. In the middle of another poor year, general manager Terry Ryan was finally dismissed, replaced by the dynamic duo of Derek Falvey and Thad Levine, the sort of expensively educated types populating other front offices. The moved marked a time for change… and sweet, sweet analytics!
So, naturally, the Twins’ first move this winter was to sign a light-hitting catcher. Earlier today, the club agreed to a three-year, $24 million deal with Jason Castro. But Castro’s not like the other light-hitting catchers with whom the Twins have burdened themselves in recent years. Whereas Kurt Suzuki and his fellow Minnesota backstops have been bad both on offense and behind the plate, Castro is actually very good at being a catcher. Like, really good. Hence the three-year, $24.5, million contract.
“Nick!” you exclaim, bewildered. “That $24 million is a lot of money for a guy who’s been a below-average hitter for three seasons in a row!” And you have a point, reader. Castro posted a wonderful 129 wRC+ in 2013, and then quickly fell right off the table. Catcher isn’t exactly a premium offensive position, but you’d like to see that 129 again. It’s probably not coming back. That’s more than okay, given how much value Castro provides with his framing.
Yes, there it is: framing. That invisible dragon of catching value that we’re all chasing in our imaginary general manager’s office. Sure, it’s nice if your catcher can sock some dingers, but can he steal strikes? Castro steals them in bunches. Right around the same time as his offensive value tanked, Castro’s glove went bananas. Let’s take a look at Baseball Prospectus’ framing runs metric and compare Castro and Suzuki.
| Year | Castro Framing Runs | Suzuki Framing Runs |
|---|---|---|
| 2013 | -1.0 | -8.3 |
| 2014 | 11.5 | -19.5 |
| 2015 | 11.0 | -8.8 |
| 2016 | 17.0 | -7.1 |
Castro appears to have made some manner of adjustment to his game, and is now one of the better framing catchers in baseball. Suzuki’s own framing, meanwhile, has hurt his pitching staffs. The upgrade is immediately apparent. Paying out for framing is a relatively new concept. Hitters of Castro’s quality aren’t usually given roughly $8.2 million for three years straight. What Castro brings to the table is something that the Twins have sorely been lacking. It’s something that can help elevate their middling pitching staff to another level.
As things stand right now, Minnesota will bring a rotation of Ervin Santana, Hector Santiago, Kyle Gibson, Phil Hughes, and (insert some other pitcher here) into 2017. Santana is a fine enough starter, and the other three have had fits and starts of success at times in the past. It’s not a rotation that will instill fear into other teams, however. The benefit of playing in cavernous Target Field helps, yes, and life is always easier when Byron Buxton is roaming around in center field. But so does a good framer behind the plate. None of the Twins’ starters last year were big strikeout guys, and Minnesota will feel the effects of its organizational fascination with pitching to contact for years to come. Castro is an excellent first step in counteracting that.
Still, it’s $24.5 million for a guy who can’t really hit all that well, and who also has what appear to be the makings of a platoon issue, having slashed .190/.249/.287 against lefties over his career. That’s, err, not great. He’ll need to be platooned, likely with John Ryan Murphy, who struggled so badly that he spent most of the year in Rochester. Murphy hasn’t been that bad in the past, though, so the Twins may have something here.
Sure, they just threw $24 million at a guy who hasn’t topped two wins in three years. But our WAR metrics here at FanGraphs don’t incorporate pitch-framing, and that’s literally where Castro makes his money. The Twins aren’t a win-now team, and probably won’t be for some time. They’re a team in transition, from both a generational and philosophical standpoint. They’re likely going to lose their best player in Brian Dozier. The Twins aren’t trying to win a championship right now.
Even if they were, Castro would be a fine choice behind the plate. He gets the job done, and then some. And, not for nothing, he’s a slightly above-average hitter against right-handed pitchers. That’ll do more than fine for now. Sign me up.
Nick is a columnist at FanGraphs, and has written previously for Baseball Prospectus and Beyond the Box Score. Yes, he hates your favorite team, just like Joe Buck. You can follow him on Twitter at @StelliniTweets, and can contact him at stellinin1 at gmail.


Not going to mention that he’s a league average hitter against righties? Or that catcher is the easiest position on the diamond to platoon? He’ll be worth 5-6 wins over the next three years and get paid like he produced three. Great job, Twins.
As a Twins fan, I see this as a great first step towards helping one of the worst pitching staffs on the majors. If the market values wins at 7-8 $M/Win then the contract seems fair.
In Falvey we trust.
1) Target Field is not cavernous. It’s about average as far as in-play acreage goes (and nearly identical to the Metrodome in dimensions).
2) For all his struggles offensively last year, Murphy has proven himself to be somewhere between slightly above average to a fairly good pitch framer. If he can stick, you could see a pretty meaninful upgrade to the pitching staff before you even consider what the pitchers do.
A move was definitely in the cards after his arbitration. The eye test and the data on his blocking and throwing, however, showed meaningful deterioration in the back half of last season. I’m surprised these things get overwhelmed so much by the framing. Very unfortunate on the hitting side as he is only a few minor mechanical changes away from consistent 2013 level production.
Yeah so hard to get on board with crediting for what is essentially getting away with something. It’s all too subversive for openers. It’s like crediting a pitcher for having a good balk move. And how long will it be before computers are calling balls and strikes anyway..?
The robots aren’t coming for the next three years, which is all the Twins care about.
Seems a low upside move.
On the one hand, there is an argument for $12m in surplus value (6 WAR over 3 years) if Castro’s framing (around 10 runs/1 WAR per year) is fully valued. One issue with valuing framing, however, is that year-to-year framing is trending towards strong regression to the mean: recent adjusted R-squared on year to year framing is nearing statistical insignificance.
Additionally, as teams and umps adjust to pitch framing data, teams are weeding out poor framers, allocating more time to good framers, while umps appear to be scrutinizing known ‘strike stealers.’ Accordingly, framing advantages tend to regress. Smart teams like the Cubs, Red Sox, Dodgers, et al have been able to find 2+ catchers with similar ‘per pitch’ framing ability to Castro.
Catchers that can save 1 run via framing over 1000 pitches, while posting an 80 RC+, are not particularly rare and are becoming more common- Castro is at the high end of age and wage for such a skill set, therefore unlikely to have much trade value at the deadline.
Castro turns 30 this season and age curves have gotten worse for older players each recent season. Castro’s speed score declined to very poor levels (-3.3) last season, and most 30 year old catchers who are negative on the basepaths have or soon develop low BABIP baselines. With a 30% k rate over the last 3 years (which has gotten worse 5 straight years) Castro isn’t playable if his BABIP drops from current .290 levels to a true-talent .260 baseline.
For a team coming off of 59 wins, allocating PAs, a roster spot, innings played, plus $Ms and years, etc., to a declining 30 year old catcher (when very few catchers over that age remain effective) seems penny wise but pound dumb. Hitting on a Rule-5 flier on someone like Heineman or Chad Wallach could be worth so much more. Finding a 2.0 WAR catcher in the Rule 5 draft is worth something around $70m surplus value. The high waiver and Rule 5 priority that the Twins currently enjoy, plus the opportunity cost of finding a scrap heap hit and the Twins place on the win-value curve, cuts into the 12m surplus that Castro might provide (fully crediting framing). If not for Castro, the Twins might be expected to give a handful of AAAA/high-priority waiver or Rule-5 catching candidates a look over the next 3 years.
Given that the Twins are at the part of the win-curve where added 2017 WAR is worth the least, this move seems like typical Twins: locking in mediocrity, as they’ve done with their pitch-to-contact approach.
IMO they would be better off taking that $24m and putting it towards eating some Mauer money, seeing if they could move/dump him, and thereby having two open spots at 1B (DH) and C, freeing up PAs/Innings to go towards players under 30 who could be part of the next winning Twins team. The Twins are letting Adam Walker types get claimed by Milwaukee, not trading Dozier, and letting the likes of Park, Mauer and Castro take up space- not building for nor or the future.