John Smoltz: Two Half Hall of Famers?

By the admission of the player himself, John Smoltz had a unique career that doesn’t quite stack up against the traditional standards set by past Hall of Fame inductees. He had two careers, and “each doesn’t qualify a hall of fame type career,” as the pitcher said on a conference call after he was inducted on Tuesday.

By definition, his career is now a Hall of Fame career, but is it possible that he stacks up better against his new colleagues if you consider his career as two halves of two separate induction-worthy careers?

Since the Hall of Fame appreciates short peaks, a high peak early in his career may have given him a Sandy Koufax type of resume. But Smoltz didn’t have that kind of peak. He only once had a season that was worth more than seven WAR, while Koufax ended his career with a four-year stretch in which three of the years were two WAR better than the best Smoltz ever showed.

If you remove the four years in which Smoltz wasn’t starting, you only hurt his case from a cumulative standpoint. 8.5 WAR go out the window, and he doesn’t have the peak to overcome his 280 missing innings and lack of counting stat thresholds reached. No 3000 strikeouts, just 207 wins and a good ERA, one stand-out season and extra credit for his postseason. Maybe a little better than Rick Reuschel.

But let’s add those years back in, as if Smoltz was a starter. Take a look at his curve, and those years relieving certainly took a bite out of his overall numbers from a cumulative standpoint.

chart (47)

Of course, he was injured in 2000, so we can’t project him for a full slate in 2001. But he would have just had Tommy John surgery, and Jeff Zimmerman found that most pitchers have a 400-inning ‘honeymoon.’ He might have been able to get through the next three years relatively unscathed, health-wise. (Of course, that might have sped up the arrival of the health problems that he had late in his career, but we’re dealing in would-have-happened anyway.)

Pitchers also have up and down years, so you can’t just connect two dots there. Take a look at his career up against Mussina’s career for some guidance.

chart (48)

They’ve had similar careers as starters, and Mussina had 17.4 WAR during the four years when he was the same age as Smoltz, Reliever. Smoltz had 8.5. Even with some time missed due to Tommy John surgery, you could give Smoltz an extra eight WAR. He would move to 16th all time in that statistic… right behind Pedro Martinez.

What would his traditional stats look like? We’d have to look at ERA and ‘project’ him for those missed years in the rotation. I turned to Jared Cross, creator of Steamer, for advice on projecting John Smoltz, Starter in 2001.

In the three years before the relief stretch (meaning 97-99) and the three years after that all as a starter, Smoltz averaged a 3.13 ERA while facing 5214 batters. NL starters had an average ERA of 4.45 in those years. In the years 2001-2004, NL starters had a 4.40 ERA so if we adjust his ERA to the slightly lower league offensive levels we get a 3.09 ERA but then we need to regress it to the mean. If we add in 800 league average batters faced (since there’s a good amount of time between some of his data and the years we’re projected), that brings him up to a 3.27 ERA projection. We could probably do a little better by looking at components, taking his relief performances in those years into account and weighing years closer to the unknown years in question more than other years but he was pretty consistent as a starter and his FIPs weren’t wildly different from his ERAs so I don’t think any of that would change the big picture all that much.

So we’re talking about 3.75 more years of vintage John Smoltz here, at least by projections. His ERA wouldn’t be much different than his career number as a starter (3.39). He averaged 13 wins a year as a starter, so let’s give him 43 more wins (3.75*13-6). That would give him 256 wins — 14 short of Mussina, the same as Andy Pettite. But he’d also have more strikeouts, and 465 more innings with his career strikeout rate would give him another 410 strikeouts or so. We can also approximate his WAR total better now, using this post by Dave Cameron and some aging.

John Smoltz, full-time reliever, never really had a chance of happening. While Smoltz admitted that he was the one that pushed for the move to the pen in order to help the team (“that was not well received from my manager, but there was a philosophical shift in the front office”), he also remembers fondly the trade from his hometown Detroit because it gave him the chance to start (“I knew I’d get a chance to start more games as a young pitcher in Atlanta.”)

Projecting him out from four years in the pen is more difficult than going the other way, too. But as a reliever, he had a four-year stretch in his mid thirties in which he had a 2.65 ERA, struck out 9.5 batters per nine, and walked 1.7 batters per nine (in 71 innings, on average). He averaged 39 saves per year even if you count the year where he didn’t close all year.

There are five relievers in the Hall of Fame: Hoyt Wilhelm, Rollie Fingers, Dennis Eckersley, Bruce Sutter, and Goose Gossage. Let’s add in Mariano Rivera for kicks. They all played at different times, but if you change their components to indexed stats, we can compare then to Smoltz at the same age. (We had to fudge the years for Bruce Sutter, whose career didn’t last long enough to make the comparison.)

Pitcher, age 34-37 ERA+ K%+ BB%+ SV
Mariano Rivera 218 135 60 160
Dennis Eckersley 210 192 29 175
Rollie Fingers 199 160 68 80
John Smoltz 162 160 58 154
Hoyt Wilhelm 140 123 94 24
Bruce Sutter* 115 89 75 85
Goose Gossage 100 119 105 50

John Smoltz compares… favorably. He’s in the top three in every stat save ERA+, where he ends up fourth. He kept pace with the three best relievers, ever.

We can use this same approach to his career to adjust his numbers for the full-time reliever version. Compared to Smoltz the Starter, Smoltz the Reliever’s ERA was 28% better, his strikeout rate was 26% better, and his walks were 49% better. He got 35% as many innings as he did in his average season as a starter. By looking at it this way, we can piggyback on the ups and downs of Smoltz’s actual career, complete with his actual aches, pains, and aging.

Projecting saves is more problematic, but, even counting the year when he didn’t close, he got .54 saves per inning pitched. Hey, this universe never existed, and saves are a silly stat, what can you do. At least most of those Braves teams were of similar quality (other than the ones at the beginning, as Smoltz himself pointed out in the call). Maybe he wouldn’t have been a closer right away, so we give him three full seasons as a setup man, à la Mariano Rivera.

Add it all up, and here you are.

  ERA Innings Strikeouts Wins Saves WAR
John Smoltz, starter 3.36 3937 3494 256 1 87.5
John Smoltz, reliever 2.42 1378 1541 30 627 37.5

And for fun, lets find some comps for each version of John Smoltz. Using wins, ERA, strikeouts and WAR for the starter, and ERA, strikeouts, saves, and WAR for the reliever, here are a few players that Smoltz would have looked like in this alternate universe.

Starters ERA Innings Strikeouts Wins Saves WAR
John Smoltz, starter 3.36 3937 3494 256 1 87.5
Bob Gibson 2.42 3884 3117 251 6 91.1
Pedro Martinez 2.93 2827 3154 219 3 87.1
Curt Schilling 3.46 3261 3116 216 22 83.2

Right behind two Hall of Famers and in front of a borderline case. Smoltz, starter may not have gone in with such a high percentage of the vote, considering the fact that Curt Schilling has had to wait as long as he is. But Smoltz the Starter would have actually been a little better than Schilling. He looks a lot like the final numbers for Bob Gibson, even if their careers would have had different shapes.

Relievers ERA Innings Strikeouts Wins Saves WAR
John Smoltz, reliever 2.42 1378 1541 30 627 37.5
Mariano Rivera 2.21 1284 1173 82 652 40.2
Rich Gossage 3.01 1809 1502 124 310 30.5
Trevor Hoffman 2.87 1089 1133 61 601 23.0

Now you’re talking. Smoltz the reliever looks a lot like Mariano Rivera, future Hall of Famer. You’d think there would even be a chance for better health outcomes than we have assumed here, since he would have thrown fewer bullets, but we don’t know.

And in the end, that’s the point, we don’t know what could have happened. This was a rough exercise rounded in futility. But there is some plausibility to the idea that John Smoltz had two half Hall of Fame careers. And that real-life career is a career full of “strangeness,” as the pitcher himself put it upon induction.





With a phone full of pictures of pitchers' fingers, strange beers, and his two toddler sons, Eno Sarris can be found at the ballpark or a brewery most days. Read him here, writing about the A's or Giants at The Athletic, or about beer at October. Follow him on Twitter @enosarris if you can handle the sandwiches and inanity.

22 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
tz
11 years ago

I was looking at that exact same WAR graph early this morning, but focusing on Mussina.

I’m really beginning to think that Mussina’s ridiculous consistency basically lulled many fans into forgetting that rolling out 5 WAR seasons over and over again is a sign of greatness. Or, put another way, a 7 WAR from a guy like Mussina would stand out less in our minds than a 7 WAR season from a guy like Smoltz, who’s had more ups and downs.

And by the way, I think this article is the perfect way to look at Smoltz’s combined career.

Lenard
11 years ago
Reply to  tz

Totally agreed on Moose. He might have been the most boring 5+ win pitcher simply because he was so consistent at it and typically didn’t have flashy strikeout rates.

Lakeside
11 years ago

It can be a whole series, next week we cover Papelbon and then next month Babe Ruth the pitcher and outfielder.

Seriously though great article. – One question though can we assume the full starter numbers or reliever when one thing lead to another. He became a reliever when he didn’t have the health to have a long term future as a starter. As for being a reliever he was to good a starter and healthy to be a reliever.

Darin Erstad
11 years ago

So am I like one 1/100 of a Hall of Famer?

Your "Friend" on Facebook
11 years ago
Reply to  Darin Erstad

fail

Turukano
11 years ago

Growing up in the 90s, Smoltzie was always my favorite Brave player, and second-favorite player of all time (behind Wade Boggs, who is still basically the coolest guy ever). Smoltz was always playing 3rd chair behind Maddux and Glavine (and in the early 90s, probably 4th chair behind them and Avery), so I think young me pulled for him as a sort of underdog.

Anyway, around Thanksgiving 2007, I was flying out of Phoenix on an early flight; it was probably around 6AM, and I was groggily standing in a long security line to get to my gate. Some dude walks up in the 1st Class line, which basically means he gets to cut in front of all of us, and I remember quickly glancing at him and thinking “That’s a tall guy.”

After that, I turned around and started taking off my shoes and belt.. but something was tugging at my brain. That guy looks familiar! So, slowly, I turn back around to get a better look, and standing there is one of my boyhood heroes, John **ckin Smoltz, looking right back at me.

Needless to say, my jaw dropped, and after all those years of watching him dominate hitters on TBS, of me standing on a pitchers mound pretending to be him, and probably having some dreams where we were BFFs, the best my little pea-brain could think to say to him was…. “WHOA.”

He gave me this incredulous look and kind of shook his head, but then politely asked me how I was doing. I mumbled something he probably couldn’t hear (I actually can’t remember what I said), and by that time it was my turn to walk through the checkpoint. I didn’t get to speak to him again.

So, yeah, totally screwed up my one chance to talk to one of my heroes.. but if you’re out there reading this, Mr. Smoltz, sorry I was a bumbling moron that one random morning in the Phoenix airport, and congrats on making the HoF. I’m super happy for you.

Decider
11 years ago
Reply to  Turukano

Would have been better if pants dropped upon removal of your belt and you didn’t realize until you went to walk through, but I still give it a solid A-!

Mike Green
11 years ago

Career fWAR for relievers is (I am sorry to say) not a credible measure of anything. The reliance on FIP for fWAR on a sample of 1000 innings or more isn’t justified.

What we can say about Smoltz the reliever is that he had an ERA+ of 162 in 4 seasons, and was able to throw 75 innings per year. That was worth about 2 BBRef WAR per year (which does reliever WAR much better than here). If you project him out charitably, he’d fall between John Hiller (31 career bWAR) and Goose Gossage (40 career bWAR) on the all-time reliever list which would make him a marginal Hall of Famer on merit. In fairness, the Hall has inducted several lesser relievers than Hiller.

As predominantly a starter, he is clearly qualified, although his career was on the whole of less value than Schilling’s and perhaps Mussina’s. The thing about Smoltz was his fabulous post-season performance, a full season’s worth of top-drawer numbers against more difficult competition. He shares that with Schilling.

Eno Sarris
11 years ago
Reply to  Mike Green

This is weird because.
1) I only used WAR as a grouping device and offered other stats for comparison.
2) Our ‘terrible’ WAR for relievers has Smoltz at around two WAR per seson.
3) The WAR I used was just under that average for his career.
4) I think the stats I showed in the article show that Smoltz’ argument would be *stronger* as a reliever because he would, in fact, be the second- or third-best reliever of all time.

Mike Green
11 years ago
Reply to  Eno Sarris

As a reliever, Smoltz would have been behind Rivera, Wilhelm (because of quantity and quality) and Gossage.

There is a huge knot of relievers including Hiller, Hoffman, Wagner, Sutter, Fingers, Stu Miller and many others who were roughly of the same value. None ought to be in the Hall of Fame but several are. Recent Hall of Fame voters have been captivated by the save statistic…

Walter
11 years ago
Reply to  Mike Green

Even by bWAR and some simple math this doesn’t seem to make much sense. During his 3 years relieving Smoltz averaged 2.23 bWAR. Smoltz was healthy and productive for 18 seasons. 18*2.23 is about 40. Gossage has 42 bWAR, Wilhelm has 47, Rivera 57. Now he’s not in Rivera’s class, obviously, but he’s right with Gossage and not so far from Wilhelm that this would-a/could-a analysis’ error bars couldn’t reach it.

Now Hoffman is at 28 bWAR, Hiller 30.9, Wagner 28, Sutter 24, Fingers 25, Stu Miller 27.

Maybe you don’t like this 3 year average thing, but remember it did happen when he was 35-37 years old. And maybe if he’d just been a reliever from the beginning he would have lost a season to TJS and maybe he would have been a little more effective in his early 40s. Regardless, between this and Eno’s analysis, its pretty clear Smoltz could have been arguably better than Gossage and Wilhelm, a good step above guys like Wagner, et al., and a good step below Rivera.

Is this anything like a sure thing? Of course not, this is made-up fairyland, but if we have to guess, this seems the most reasonable.

Fergie's boys
11 years ago

Smoltz got in on the first ballot because of the steroid boys on the ballot who the BBWA guys won’t vote for. Really, when you look at he and Glavine’s numbers versus the other first ballot guys they pale in comparison. However, when you won’t vote for Bonds, Clemens, Bagwell, McGwire, Sosa, etc., the guys who normally would have had to wait get pushed to the top.

Paul G.
11 years ago
Reply to  Fergie's boys

I don’t know how much I buy this argument. The roids group is Bonds, Clemens, McGwire, Sosa, Palmeiro, and (allegedly) Bagwell. If there were no roids, McGwire was eligible in 2007 and probably was elected no later than 2010 when Dawson was the only selection. Bonds & Clemens would have been elected on the first ballot in 2013, when in reality no one was elected. That leaves Bagwell, Palmeiro, and Sosa. The first two were eligible in 2011, the latter in 2013, and probably Bagwell would have been elected before 2015. The support for Palmeiro and Sosa has been tepid, even by roid user standards, so they are probably floating around in the 30%-50% support range. Is that enough to make Smoltz wait another year? Maybe. Not convinced. I could believe it would have forced Biggio to wait another year though, given how underappreciated he was while playing.

Phantom Stranger
11 years ago

Smoltz is largely the reason why I followed baseball in my teen years. The Braves never had to worry about a start from him in the playoffs, which I can’t say about Glavine or Maddux.

TKDC
11 years ago

Even as a Braves fan, I was surprised that Smoltz made it on the first try. I do think the Cy Young and the dominant time as a reliever gave the voters an excuse to vote for Smoltz, and they wanted to as it was Maddux, Glavine, and Smoltz for 11 years in Atlanta.

As for Mussina, he never won the Cy Young and he only won 20 games once (his last season, which was his 8th best by bWAR). He was also better (though not as much as perceived) when he was playing in relative obscurity in Baltimore than when he was a Yankee.

Bpdelia
11 years ago
Reply to  TKDC

Barely better. That was just the natural aging curve. His career basically is a textbook example of a perfectly laid out career. Very little up and down. Just very very good every single year but one. With was then followed by his final season in which he won twenty games.

I understand the “but if smoltz wasn’t and then didn’t” but fact is he was and then did.

On what happened there is no way to argue smoltz had a better career than schilling or mussina and once again the HOF has served no purpose other than pissing me off

TKDC
11 years ago
Reply to  Bpdelia

Yep, no possible way. A way does not exist.

Bobby Ayala
11 years ago

Can you link to Jeff Zimmerman’s findings of the 400-inning Tommy-John “honeymoon”?

octelium
11 years ago

The title sums up my thoughts on Smoltz exactly. I watched alot of his games on TBS growing up. And I felt after he retired that he had a half career as a starter that would be HF if there was a second half, and half of a career as a reliever that would have been HF with a second. So I think the votes were basically saying that two halves do make a whole. A good comparison for a non-pitcher would be a player primarily a defensive value catcher/ middle IF for one half of career then a solid+ DH the other half… Not sure if any are out there?

Brian L
11 years ago

If you had just inserted the word “one” somehow, would have been an amazing 4-3-2-1

“Koufax ended his career with a four-year stretch in which three of the years were two WAR better than the best [one] Smoltz ever showed.”

joser
11 years ago
Reply to  Brian L

And a 4-3-2-1 is one hell of an unusual double-play.

Bpdelia
11 years ago
Reply to  Brian L

Ha. One of my very favorite song lyrics ever written is by the band Cap ‘n Jazz:

“CANINE ATE SEVEN SICK FIVE YEAR OLDDDDDS!”