Kris Bryant Might Be the Best All-Around Player in the NL

Yesterday, Kris Bryant did what he’s best known for; hit the crap out of the baseball. In the Cubs 9-6 victory over the Brewers, Bryant went 5 for 5 with a double and a pair of home runs, giving him 30 homers for the season. The big day raised his season line to .296/.392/.564 and pushed him up to a 152 wRC+, second in the NL, behind only Daniel Murphy. This isn’t exactly breaking news, but Kris Bryant can really hit.

But Kris Bryant is also really good at a bunch of other things that don’t get as much attention, and given his monstrous production yesterday, I thought it would be a good time to talk about all the other reasons why Kris Bryant might be the best all-around player in the National League.

Let’s start with a skill that we almost never talk about, but Bryant happens to be particularly exceptional in. As a middle-of-the-order hitter on a team with high on-base guys at the top of the order, Kris Bryant comes up to the plate with men on base a lot, and as such, Kris Bryant has a lot of opportunities to hit into double plays. In fact, according to Baseball-Reference, Bryant has come up to the plate 125 times when a double play was possible, the fifth highest total in baseball, and the second highest total in the NL, behind only his teammate, Anthony Rizzo, who is at 128 double play opportunities.

A league average hitter bounces into a double play about 11% of the time they have the chance to do so, so based on that, we’d expect Bryant to have hit into 14 double plays this year. You know how many Bryant has actually hit into? Three.

So despite having the fifth highest number of chances to hit into a double play of anyone in baseball, Bryant actually has the sixth lowest GIDP total of any hitter in baseball with at least 400 plate appearances. The only guys to hit into fewer double plays are leadoff hitters (Chase Utley, Odubel Herrera, Charlie Blackmon, Matt Carpenter) and Danny Espinosa. Bryant and Espinosa are tied for the league lead in lowest percentage of double play opportunities actually grounded into, at just 2%.

Now, you might say that double plays are often bang-bang plays at first base, so whether a guy happens to be called safe or out on close calls is subject to some variance, and could easily be a fluke. I’d agree with you, except Kris Bryant also posted the lowest percentage of double plays grounded into last year (5%, seven GIDPs in 147 opportunities) too. Over the last two seasons, of hitters with at least 200 chances to hit into a double play, only one player — Chris Davis — has hit into fewer than the 10 double plays Bryant has grounded into, and Davis has hit into nine of them. Bryant is basically at the top of the scale in terms of double play avoidance.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage

Now, you might notice that Bryant and Davis have some similarities. Both are extreme flyball hitters, which is obviously one of the best ways to avoid grounding into a double play; grounding, after all, is the first word in the phrase. Bryant and Davis also strike out a fair amount of the time, so part of their double play avoidance is that they just swing and miss regularly, making one out instead of two. But it’s worth noting that this is the upside that comes with their skillset, and it creates some real value, despite what some announcers will tell you about the need to just put the bat on the ball as often as possible.

Remember, Bryant has hit into 11 fewer double plays than the average hitter based on his number of opportunities this year. Because most batting statistics are only measuring whether a hitter did something successfully divided by the number of chances they had, there’s no room in metrics like BA, OBP, or SLG to capture the additional harm that double plays cause, but obviously, hitting into a double play is significantly worse for a team’s offense than simply making one out, either by strikeout, flyout, or beating out a grounder before the infield can turn two.

That’s why we track a metric called wGDP, which measures the amount of runs created above or below the average for a team’s offense based on how often a hitter grounds into a double play, based on their chances to do so. The spread in value between players in wGDP isn’t that large, but at the extremes, it can definitely add up. And Bryant is definitely at the extreme positive end of this scale.

In 2016, Bryant ranks first with +3.8 wGDP, which means he’s added nearly four runs to the Cubs offense through his ability to avoid double plays. Bryant also ranked first in the majors last year, at +2.9 wGDP. And that’s just compared to the average hitter; many of the guys who hit for power in baseball are really terrible at hitting into double plays, since hitting for power often requires you to be a big slow guy who can’t really run well. But Bryant is giving the Cubs the power of a cleanup hitter with the double play avoidance of a speed guy, which is one of the reasons their offense is a bit more efficient than we’d expect just by looking at their raw batting lines.

Of course, this is a small thing, and no one would claim that double play avoidance is now some critical skill that makes Bryant a superstar. But he happens to be really good at nearly every small thing there is. For instance, you might not look at Bryant’s 21-for-30 stolen base success rate and think he’s a terrific baserunner, but he really is.

This season, Bryant has taken the extra base — as defined by Baseball-Reference as going more than one base on a single or more than two bases on a double — 56% of the time; the league average is 40%. According to UBR, which measures baserunning value beyond stolen base attempts, Bryant has added 4.8 runs to the Cubs offense through his work on the bases since getting to the big leagues, the 12th highest total among qualified hitters. The guy at #11? Mike Trout, at +4.9 baserunning runs.

Kris Bryant isn’t Mike Trout, of course. No one is. But if you look at the numbers over the last year, you might be surprised how close it is.

Trout and Bryant, Last 365 Days
Name PA AVG OBP SLG wOBA wRC+ BsR Off Def WAR
Mike Trout 694 0.310 0.428 0.563 0.416 171 8 67 2 9.5
Kris Bryant 709 0.306 0.392 0.573 0.408 157 5 54 10 8.9

The gap in true talent between them isn’t that close, in all likelihood. The overall gap is shrunk by the fact that Bryant has rated exceptionally well by UZR, while Trout has graded out as about an average center fielder. We have enough data on Trout now that we can be reasonably confident in the fact that he’s not an elite center fielder anymore, but Bryant’s probably not as good with the glove as UZR is making him look. Playing defense behind elite contact managers like Jake Arrieta and Kyle Hendricks could well be propping up Bryant’s UZR a bit, so it’s best not to take that number as a perfect representation of his talent level.

But it’s also probably worth noting that Bryant’s other performance metrics do align with the type of player who would be a good defender. We’ve already talked about his baserunning, which speaks to his athleticism and instincts, but he’s also just faster than people give him credit for. As Owen Watson wrote last year, Bryant is also the best hitter at baseball at turning infield ground balls into hits. Since getting to the big leagues, 15% of Bryant’s infield grounders have led to infield hits, a staggering total for a guy who hits like Bryant hits.

The only other guys even over 10% since the start of last year? Odubel Herrera, Starling Marte, Mike Trout, Jose Altuve, and Xander Bogaerts. Infield hits are largely a function of speed, and Bryant racks up infield hits like he’s one of the fastest guys in baseball. And maybe he just is. Last year, Mike Petriello noted, using Statcast data, that Bryant got up to a top speed of 21 mph on a triple. He just isn’t your typical lumbering slugger; Kris Bryant is a terrific athlete, and that shows up in every facet of the game.

If Bryant was a few inches shorter, I don’t think there’d be that much skepticism about the idea that he might be a very good defender at both third base and the outfield. After all, every other performance metric there is suggests that he utilizes his speed and athleticism extremely well, and he consistently rates near the top of the same leaderboards that are generally dominated by little guys who play excellent defense. Bryant’s unlikely to be as valuable defensively going forward as his current UZR suggests, but with 2,300 innings of very positive data and a lot of other markers that suggest Bryant utilizes his athleticism in exceptional ways, it seems likely that he’s at least an above average defender.

Put it all together, and you have a guy who performs like the classic five-tool superstar. He hits for average and power, he runs well, he fields, and he’s got a strong throwing arm. Given his lower-tier contact rates, he’ll probably never be described as a traditional five tool guy, but performance is what counts, and Bryant’s ability to hit the ball hard when he does make contact makes up for the strikeouts, leaving Bryant as one of the game’s most complete players.

The Cubs have a lot of great players, but Kris Bryant is their greatest player, and given what he’s doing in every part of the game this year, he might just be the most complete player in the National League.





Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.

74 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
victorvran
10 years ago

Can’t wait to see johnforthegiants reasons for why KB sucks

Brians Sticky Sock
10 years ago
Reply to  victorvran

Well it usually centers around how we (most FG readers) don’t understand BAPIP and we shouldn’t question him until we do…

374285942768
10 years ago

now i’m no babip expert like he is but i wonder what there is to be said about a cubs pitching babip that since the break is back to the level of the first two and three quarter months of the season which was a ‘fluke’ as opposed to the three week stretch to end the first half that was their true skill level.

Johnston
10 years ago
Reply to  374285942768

I think everybody here knows more about BABIP than he does. I’m pretty sure my German Shepherd does, too.

Michael Carpenter
10 years ago
Reply to  victorvran

There have been 3 Cubs-related articles this week…johnforthegiants is currently looking at team BABIP and whythecubsarentasgoodaseveryonethinkstheyareandareactuallybigfatdoodyheads.com and he is absolutely rock-hard.

Spartacus
10 years ago

I bet he can’t get hard.

LHPSU
10 years ago

Kris Bryant: 6’5″, 215lbs
Usain Bolt: 6’5″, 207lbs

Manny RamirezMember since 2016
10 years ago

If he played in a bigger market, we could be reading this exact same piece, but about Nolan Arenado.

Brians Sticky Sock
10 years ago
Reply to  Manny Ramirez

Well Bryant is second in the majors in WAR behind only Trout, would love to see the argument on how Arenado is better.

dl80Member since 2020
10 years ago

Arenado isn’t better, but it’s not as far as it seems. He’s better on defense and his WAR is way over penalized for playing in Coors. Arenado ‘s road offense is not nearly as low compared to home as WAR would make it seem. He’s been about.260/.305/.470 away over the last three years. His road splits aren’t much different than any player not playing in Coors. His WAR for the year should be closer to 5 than the 3.5 it currently is.

CosmoMember since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  dl80

Nobody has said that Arenado isn’t good… everybody here seems to agree that he’s excellent… the only thing people are saying is that he’s not the best all around player in the NL.

dl80Member since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  Cosmo

Oh. Well yeah. OK fair enough.

Johnston
10 years ago
Reply to  dl80

Arenado is IMO third or fourth best 3B in the game. He’s good but he’s not good enough to be in this discussion.

374285942768
10 years ago
Reply to  dl80

arenado is a 60% better hitter at coors than he is on the road. kris bryant is almost 40% better on the road than he is at home and at KB at home is 16% better than arenado as a whole. i think it’s pretty far.
not that arenado isn’t a really good player, but metaphorically speaking he’s not even in the same league.

Concerned Reader John
10 years ago
Reply to  Manny Ramirez

Be pretty weird to read how Kris Bryant’s base-running makes Nolan Arenado a superstar.

Doorknob11
10 years ago
Reply to  Manny Ramirez

Market has nothing to do with it, the fact that he plays in Coors is the reason because it’s hard to take his stats too seriously because of that, not saying I don’t but most people don’t

Jaack
10 years ago
Reply to  Manny Ramirez

Arenando’s wRC+ is tied with Yunel Escobar and Jonathan Villar. Good player, great defender, but come on man.

dl80Member since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  Jaack

He’s penalized way to much for the Coors factor. His road woba is .325 over the last three years. Because of Coors, that comes out to a wrc+ of barely 105.

typhill
10 years ago
Reply to  Manny Ramirez

Arenado is 7th in WAR among 3rd basemen this year and again 7th over the last 2 years. WAR isn’t perfect, but he’s not even close to the leaders. He’s not top 3 player at his position (Donaldson, Bryant, machado), let alone the best player in the NL. Exciting and talented? Absolutely. Under appreciated by many because he plays in Colorado? Sure. Best player in the NL? Lol no chance

Manny RamirezMember since 2016
10 years ago
Reply to  Manny Ramirez

Ok, that was a terrible thought. I wholeheartedly retract my statement about Arenado. He is an excellent player but definitely not in Kris Bryant’s class. Just wanted to express my Arenado love but should have found a different arena in which to do so.

Brians Sticky Sock
10 years ago
Reply to  Manny Ramirez

To be fair to you, I also agree that Arenado’s an excellent player as well. And totally understand your excitement about him!

AlabamaShake
10 years ago
Reply to  Manny Ramirez

Arenado, at home: .313/.390/.652 OPS: 1.042
Arenado, on road: .246/.313/.444 OPS: .757

Arenado, like most Rockies’ hitters past and present, loves Coors Field.

bluecaboose436
10 years ago
Reply to  AlabamaShake

Bryant, 2015, at home: .311/.408/.629, 1.037 OPS
Bryant, 2015, on road: .243/.333/.360, .693 OPS.

Arenado, 2015, at home: .316/.350/.610, .960 OPS
Arenado, 2015, on road: .258/.296/.539, .835 OPS

Arenado has a career .196 split between home and away, while Bryant has a career .146 split between home and away. I’m not trying to say Arenado is better than Bryant, that’s not true. They both hit for power and field well, but Bryant is better in almost every other category. But you can’t always blame everything on Coors.

jhalpin23
10 years ago
Reply to  bluecaboose436

Bryant’s home/road splits seem a lot more flukey now that he’s actually hitting much better on the road this year.
2016 Home: 275/366/537
2016 Road: 323/419/590

The Coors effect is certainly a real thing and does inflate the numbers but there is no question Arenado is a great player even if he’s not quite Kris Bryant.

Careless
10 years ago
Reply to  bluecaboose436

Ok, you may disagree with this guy, but why the hell is it getting downvotes?

Bronnt
10 years ago
Reply to  AlabamaShake

That’s the reverse Coors effect you’re seeing. Most players for most teams hit better at home. Rockies hitters have a weird problem adjusting on the road, since they see pitches that don’t break very well in half of their games.

reggiethomaslive
10 years ago
Reply to  AlabamaShake

Any hitter who plays in an extreme hitters park is likely to have extreme home/road splits, and it has nothing to do with how the ball breaks home vs. away. It’s basic math caused by the composition of their road parks.

Rockies hitters hit on the road in the toughest hitting parks in the NL because Coors isn’t part of them. Any NL hitter on any other team esp. those in the NL West, gets a boost in their road numbers from games hitting in Coors that narrows their home/road splits.

Its the same reason why it’s not unusual for hitters whose home field is a pitchers park to hit better on the road, their collection of road parks is better than average because their poor hitting home park isn’t among them.

KCDaveInLA
10 years ago

Great GIDP analysis – it’s always great to see a player live up to the insane hype! I can’t wait to see what his monster years will look like.

O'KieboomerMember since 2021
10 years ago

Hard to argue best all around player when he’s not even in the top 10 in fielding percentage for NL third basemen. Eight errors in not that many innings, and those hurt the team and the pitcher. Great hitter, probably a great clubhouse kid, but lets not paper over his flaws. He’ll get there though, he’s a young great player and I’m excited to see him at third for my Cubbies for the next few years until he signs with the Yankees.

mgeoffriau
10 years ago
Reply to  O'Kieboomer

Are you lost?

JoshuaMember since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  O'Kieboomer

As i am sure most FG readers already know, errors and fielding % can be a very misleading stat when it comes to evaluating defense. As Dave noted, the more advanced defensive metrics think pretty highly of his defense.

O'KieboomerMember since 2021
10 years ago
Reply to  Joshua

I don’t think the errors are properly accounted for by saber metrics. I’ve noticed more than once an error by Kris or one of his teammates like Javier or Addison have caused the pitchers to become unglued and give up a big inning and ultimately loose the game. Those errors have accounted for 38 unearned runs as opposed to 375 earned runs the Cubs have given up, are you telling me 10% of that won’t affect the season in a big way? They can’t make mistakes like that in the postseason or they’ll fall out of it again like last year.

The announcers talk a lot about this during the game. Is part of that on the pitchers to put it out of their mind? Sure, but these kids are only human.

mgeoffriau
10 years ago
Reply to  O'Kieboomer

“I don’t think the errors are properly accounted for by saber metrics.”

Defend this statement.

“Those errors have accounted for 38 unearned runs as opposed to 375 earned runs the Cubs have given up, are you telling me 10% of that won’t affect the season in a big way?”

Sure they do. But “sabermetrics” (which is not a single thing, by the way) doesn’t ignore errors. Most advanced defensive metrics attempt to properly weight errors as one part of defensive value.

Here:

http://www.fangraphs.com/library/defense/overview/

O'KieboomerMember since 2021
10 years ago
Reply to  mgeoffriau

I think there’s some value in analyzing errors especially for the young kids because they aren’t finished products yet and there’s a big psychological component to what it does to the fielder, the pitcher and the team. It doesn’t surprise me that saber metrics can’t properly quantify that, I’m not sure if I could either! And since we’re talking about a young wunderkind here I thought it was relevant. Dave didn’t bring up errors once in the article so I’m just trying to supplement his excellent argument with a different perspective. I thought that’s what we tried to do in the comments!

Brians Sticky Sock
10 years ago
Reply to  O'Kieboomer

I’m not sure if I agree with you, but totally get your point about offering a different perspective!

mgeoffriau
10 years ago
Reply to  O'Kieboomer

UZR includes errors as part of the defensive evaluation, so the article did mention it…just not directly. Dave chose a metric that attempts to give proper weight to all aspects of defensive performance.

“there’s a big psychological component to what it does to the fielder, the pitcher and the team.”

Sure. There’s also a psychological component to seeing your 3B fail to even get to a ball, or watching deliver a late or wild throw.

That’s why we use UZR and things like it — to put these various components in their proper context.

If you want me to believe that UZR is underestimating the detrimental effect of errors, I’ll need to see some evidence.

WARrior
10 years ago

“We have enough data on Trout now that we can be reasonably confident in the fact that he’s not an elite center fielder anymore”

Was he ever? I think what you mean is that there are enough data so that we no longer think he is an elite CF any more.

WARrior
10 years ago

Bryant may be fast, but his wGDP is clearly enhanced by a very high FB rate and a relatively low GB rate, even for a power hitter. And while he may be good at taking the extra base, his CS is still a problem, and basically keeping him from being one of the top players in total base runs.

Original Greaser Bob
10 years ago
Reply to  WARrior
jianadaren
10 years ago

Generally, you ought to bat your best hitters 2nd or 4th. But does Bryant’s combination of home runs and GIDP-avoision make him the exception who should hit 3rd?

Brians Sticky Sock
10 years ago
Reply to  jianadaren

You’ve also got Fowler, Zobrist, and Rizzo, all with high walk rates in the first four spots… I don’t think order matters much.

Les Vegetables
10 years ago

You didn’t mention his 80-grade eyes.

dtpollittMember since 2016
10 years ago
Reply to  Les Vegetables

My favorite Bryant nickname is “Sparkles” because of his beautiful blues.

Brett
10 years ago

I never heard of wGDP until now. Is it tilted by the fact that the Cubs score more runs than a lot of teams, making his avoidance more valuable than it would be if he played for, say, the Braves?

WARrior
10 years ago
Reply to  Brett

No, just as his batting RAA is not tilted by the fact that hits are more valuable for a player on a team that is more likely to have runners on base when he’s up.

BigChief
10 years ago
Reply to  Brett

Well, he does get more opportunities to GIDP, if he is hitting more often with a person on base.

Sort of like if 2 people both had successful stolen bases 85% of the time, but 1 player attempts 50 and the other attempts 20. The player that ran more, because they both have above average SB%, will have a higher run value for stolen bases.

WARrior
10 years ago
Reply to  BigChief

The FG library doesn’t actually explain wGDP very well, but it does say this: “This metric is scaled to their number of opportunities, so if you never hit with men on base, you aren’t at a disadvantage”

http://www.fangraphs.com/library/offense/wgdp/

It seems, based on this, that wGDP is determined by multiplying the % by which a player differs from the league average % by the league average number of opportunities. The article says the league average is 11%, and Bryant’s average is 2.2%. So one would multiply the league average number of opportunities by (11 – 2.2)%. From a probability table, a runner on first with no or one out occurs about 12.7% of the time, so the league average number of opportunities over a full season (say 700 PA) is about 90. So Bryant would be credited with 90 x .088 = 7.9 outs saved (above average).

http://stats.seandolinar.com/pirates-bases-loaded-no-outs-no-runs/

What’s the run value of these outs saved? From the RE24 table, a runner on first has a run value of about .83 if there are no outs, and .49 if there is one out. If you GDP, the end result is no runners are on base, and the run value is now .10 with two outs or course 0 with three outs. If you make an out but avoid the DP, the run value is .49 with a runner on first and one out, and .21 with two outs. So avoiding the DP saves your team .49 – .10 = .39 run if there are no outs, and .21 – 0 = .21 run if there is one out. From the probability table, runner on first with on out occurs about 17% more often than runner on first with no out, so avoiding a DP in general or on average is worth about [(.39 x 1.0) + (.21 x 1.17)]/(1.0 + 1.17) = .29 run. So Bryant’s 7.9 outs saved is worth about 7.9 x ,29 = 2.3 runs saved. That would be assuming he continued his current rate to the end of the season.

His actual wGDP, however, is currently listed at 3.0–and the season is not over. So it appears one does not in fact use the league average number of opportunities, but the actual number of opportunities. For Bryant, that is 125, multiply that by .088 x .29 = 3.2 runs. The slight discrepancy could be due to the league average being slightly below 11%, or using a run value based on the actual base-out situation, rather than an average.

WARrior
10 years ago
Reply to  WARrior

Oops, Bryant’s average is 2.4 %, not 2.2%. So .086 x .29 x 125 = 3.1 runs, very close to the actual value of 3.0.

WARrior
10 years ago
Reply to  WARrior

I now realize that I included man on first only, for simplicity. If one includes all situations with a runner on first, it changes the calculations. The total number of such situations is about 17% of all base-out states, so the league average number of opportunities would be around 120, 122/720 PA. The other situations also change the run value of avoiding a DP. I did not calculate the exact value, but it turns out that the 1-2, 1-3 and 1-2-13 states are far more common with one out than with no outs. Just including those, the run value is about .45 for avoiding GDP. Thus using Bryant’s current 2.4%, and that run value, and 526 current PA, one gets a wGDP of about 3.5. That is a little high, but it seems to indicate that one does use the league average number of opportunities, not the actual number a player has.

BigChief
10 years ago
Reply to  WARrior

Thanks! It’s stuff like this that makes the FG comment section one of the very best on the internet.

jakelauer
10 years ago

I think, since the article mentions his low contact rates, it’s worth mentioning that Bryant has also made major strides in that department year-over-year. His K% has dropped to 23% this year, after being over 30% last year. He has also raised his contact rates by 6% in that time.

johansantana17Member since 2026
10 years ago
Reply to  jakelauer

also, he is described as a traditional 5-tool player because he hits for a high average (.275 in 2015 and .299 in 2016).

carterMember since 2020
10 years ago

If you look at Kris Bryant’s performance since HS he has seemingly taken one facet of his game and improved it every season without it negatively affecting other parts of his game. That in itself is remarkable. Before the season when I read that he changed his swing plane to not K as much I was worried because “if it ain’t broke don’t fix it”, but the results show that he has hit for more power while reducing K’s.

I think Harper has some more monster years in him, and maybe he has been playing hurt this entire time…but if I had to pick a guy to be the number 2 player in the game giving Trout a run for his money, it would be Bryant. He does every single part of the game well (with the exception of “clutch” hitting), and cannot wait to see what he improves this off-season.

Matt
10 years ago

The Trout/Bryant comparison is interesting, especially regarding defense. I honestly believe Kris Bryant can be at least an above average defender at every position on the field, including CF. He’s “big” but he’s a lean big with a ton of athleticism. If the Cubs really wanted to, they could throw Bryant in CF to replace Fowler next year and have zero drop off in defense. They’d probably have a net gain on defense because Baez’s glove is best at 3B.

Fowler and Bryant are the same size with the same body type and similar athleticism and the Cubs turned Fowler into a pretty solid CF after years of being below average to average at best. I doubt the Cubs do it of course, the likely option is Heyward plays CF and some combo of Schwarber/Soler/Bryant/Baez/Zobrist are spread around LF/RF/3B/2B but the flexibility is there and Joe Maddon is a sucker for flexibility.

On the flip side, I don’t see how Mike Trout can stay in CF much longer. Mike Trout is a HUGE dude. Fangraphs has him at 6’2″ 230 pounds, for comparison, David Ortiz is listed at 6’3″ 230 pounds. I’m not sure either of those numbers are accurate and I’d bet the over on both. Players with Trout’s body type just do not age well in the speed/athleticism department. That isn’t to say Trout won’t continue to be a great athlete, but he is probably destined for LF. Of course he’ll still hit the cover off the ball for the next 400 years so who cares?

The fact that Bryant hits the way he does, runs the way he does AND rotates through 4 different positions with ease is impressive as hell.

Andrew T. Fisher
10 years ago

And on the night this article is posted, Bryant gives the Rockies one run on defense and indirectly three more in a one run loss. One errant throw led directly to a run. Another somewhat difficult play turned into a “double” off his glove, turning a 1-out 2-on and 3-run lead into a 0-out 2nd/3rd and 2 run lead. Rockies tied the game without the benefit of a hit after that.

johnforthegiants
10 years ago

He’s obviously a great player but he does have the 2nd worst Clutch rating in the majors (-2.70) behind Michael Saunders, and his WPA of 1.49 is #71 in the majors, which isn’t bad but it isn’t great. In high-leverage situations he’s batting .216 and striking out 34.9% of the time, with 8.9% line drives, 27.3% infield flies, 26.1% hard-hit balls, an ISO of .054, and a wRC of 2 (that’s not a misprint). In response to the article about Michael Saunders on Wednesday, someone wrote (and I quote):
‘Idk about Michael Saunders but I do watch a lot of Cubs games and I think Kris Bryant often times gets anxious with high pressure situations and expands his zone. He usually has a very good eye, laying off breaking balls down and away, until a simple put-it-in-play situation, then I feel he often gets anxious and expands. Its noticable when the next two hitters are Rizzo and Zobrist who seem to let the game come to them. I think it is something to be concerned with come October.’
I think I’ve said this pretty objectively, no? Let’s see how people react.

jhalpin23
10 years ago

Well he was 6th in WPA last year, and his stats across the board were very high in clutch situations all through 2015 which pretty much tells me what I already thought. Clutch stats are random.

johnforthegiants
10 years ago
Reply to  jhalpin23

Apparently that isn’t what this fellow who watches a lot of Cubs games thinks. And as I wrote in response to the above post, I noticed the same thing about Buster Posey in the first few months of the 2015 season, although it hasn’t been characteristic of his career–he was clearly pressing and expanding the strike zone in clutch situations. People who watch the same batters hit many times and pay attention notice these things. The fact that some clutch data is random doesn’t mean that all clutch data is random. And batters can expand their zone in clutch situations for some parts of their career but not others.

jhalpin23
10 years ago

I have watched over 90% of Cubs games this season, he has had a total of 85 PA’s in high leverage situations this year and has batted 274/357/438. Not too bad but not up to his normal numbers but I think less than 100 PA’s qualifies as a small sample don’t you?

johnforthegiants
10 years ago
Reply to  jhalpin23

Those aren’t the data on fangraphs. It’s true the number of hl pas us small, this is what the clutch stat is for, its global and hes pretty poor at that this year

jhalpin23
10 years ago

Those numbers are from baseball reference, but once again last year in clutch stat he was 5th in all of baseball. So he went from being elite at it as a rookie but now he forgot how to hit in clutch situations? You’re grasping at straws.

Also, Mike Trout is 110th this year and was 87th last year in clutch.

jhalpin23
10 years ago

And how do you explain his exemplary numbers in those situations last year? Or are we just ignoring those…

johnforthegiants
10 years ago
Reply to  jhalpin23

In the case ofl posey in 2015 ir actually started in the 2014 postseason when he was blatantly pitched around in clutch situations and started swinging out of frustration, and it got worse when sandoval left and pence went on the dl so he felt like he had to get hits when the game was on the line. It got better after pence came back and the mess at 3b got resolved.

johnforthegiants
10 years ago
Reply to  jhalpin23

I don’t look at the cubs much so i don’t know what factors account for this in bryant’s case. You have to look at a lot of games the same team and pay attention to what’s going on to understand thomgs like this.

374285942768
10 years ago

for not watching the cubs much you sure have a lot of shit to say about them

Spartacus
10 years ago
Reply to  374285942768

to be fair to john, he has been quiet during the Cubs’ latest winning streak… maybe he’s learning the ebbs and flows of a baseball season and realizes it’s best to stay quiet and critique the season as a whole rather than overreact to a small sample size… maybe…

Nathan
10 years ago

I’m a little surprised not to see any mention of Corey Seager in either the piece or the comments. Past calendar year:

Bryant: 8.6 WAR in 710 PA, 7.27 WAR/600 PA.
Seager: 7.5 WAR in 630 PA, 7.14 WAR/600 PA.

BritishCub
10 years ago
Reply to  Nathan

i agree he’s been excellent, and can easily see an MVP in seager’s future if he keeps going as he is, but Dave is looking at all around value and seager isn’t providing it on the basepaths as of yet (has a BsR of o.3 this year compared to the 1.0 he had in his cup of coffee). Doing great at the hitting and the fielding though!

RadermecherMember since 2018
10 years ago

Royals fans really do have a beef.
Two great years and very little love.
Cubbies are having a great year,Kris Bryant is a great player.
.So Dave when do you balance the ledger.

CosmoMember since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  Radermecher

Actually the Cubs were pretty good last year as well… 97 wins, 3rd best record overall.

nodak
10 years ago

I think Bryant’s speed on the bases surprises a lot of guys. They assume, “This guy hits 30+ HR, I have time on this 3 hopper to SS,” only to have him beat the play.

To me, though, he is one of my examples of the difference between “fast” and “quick.” His speed really kicks in after about 4-6 steps. Which is why he can run the bases so well. For this reason I can imagine him in the OF not because he is a bad 3B but that kind of speed in RF or LF can be a huge asset, especially when the Cubs visit places like PNC Park and their cavernous LF. If he can track down the ball before it gets into the LF corner/triagle that can save the pitcher a couple bases quickly. It’s no accident that the Pirates have Marte as their LF.

bluerum29
10 years ago

He might be the best hitter, but he is not the MVP at this point. This time of year, that is the most important argument.

eyesoverthecity
10 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

I would love to know who the current MVP is then?