Let Us Proclaim the Mystery of Faith
Dear Wide Readership,
This is Carson Cistulli. You may know me from such films as “How Stella Got Her Groove Taken Away in the First Place” and “Haters Gonna Hate: The Life and Times of Jimmy Stewart.” Also, I contribute with some frequency to this site.
Tonight, as you probably know, we, the Baseballing Enthusiasts of America, have the opportunity to watch Colby Lewis pitch a potentially ALCS-clinching baseball game against the New York Americans.
Alot of people have asked, and attempted to answer, the question “Who is Colby Lewis?”
The answer to the question is obvious: there is no answer. Or, rather, there is no one answer. Allow me to explain.
It is not uncommon for theologians — and this extends across multiple faith traditions — for theologians to describe God by describing, instead, what God is not. The practice, called apophasis, is predicated on the belief that God is ineffable*, and therefore cannot be apprehended directly.
*I once had a girlfriend who was ineffable, but in a totally different way.
The Mystery known as Colby Lewis is also ineffable. Yes, we can point to him and say, “There is Colby Lewis on the baseball mound” and, yes, we can look at his player page and say, “His slider has been considerably above average (+1.56 runs per 100 thrown) while his curve has been below average (-1.54 per 100).” But that is to ignore the entirety of Colby Lewis.
Jorge Luis Borges comes closest to representing this dichotomy in his very short story “Borges and I.” In said text, Borges struggles to see the similarities between Borges the Man and Borges the Famous Argentine Author. “I do not know which of us has written this page,” he ends by saying.
Similar is the case with Colby Lewis. Sitting here, in Madison, Wisconsin, I imagine Colby Lewis. Later, in front of a television, I will see someone named Colby Lewis, pitching against the Yankees. But that man, throwing from that mound, is only part of the Colby Lewis I imagine.
My colleague Joe Pawlikowski has suggested, via Twitter, that Lewis will fail tonight versus the Yankees and that I, among his (i.e. Lewis’s) biggest supporters, will be crushed.
But I have the leg up on Joe Pawl here, on anyone who’d adjudge Lewis’s success by mere wins and losses, by swinging strikes and groundballs-induced. For the Mystery of Colby Lewis is unassailable. As Walt Whitman has stated, it is large and contains multitudes. One game will have no effect on it. Colby Lewis has won already.
Humbly Yours,
Carson Cistulli
Carson Cistulli has published a book of aphorisms called Spirited Ejaculations of a New Enthusiast.


Ontology of personhood + baseball = awesome
But it’s not a clever or interesting connection between ontology and baseball. It’s a reference to Borges followed by the author saying Lewis “is only part of the Colby Lewis I imagine.” Huh? What? Care to elaborate or develop that? No, never mind, just switch to a pretentious reference to Walt Whitman.
Can’t we tell the difference between genuine creative insights and ego-stroking narcissism?
who’s colby lewis??
did you wipe up after you finished writing this self serving drek?
This just may set a record for number of thumbs down ever
Well at least it was more witty then pointing out #6org or something like that; Give the guy credit for that.
http://twitter.com/jaydestro
ahahahhahahahahahhahahahahahhahahahahhahahahahahaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
No, didn’t you see how he wrote “Humbly yours” at the end? It wasn’t self-serving! The references to Borges and Whitman weren’t Carson stroking his own ego, he was making relevant and understandable connections between baseball and literature/philosophy. …right?
I first read “I once had a girlfriend who was ineffable” as “I once had a girlfriend who was in-F-able”. I assume that was by intention
Jokes, like magic tricks and Dylan lyrics, are always better left unexplained.
Sorry, disagree with you on the latter two, Jokes yes, but most people love figuring out magic tricks…
Isn’t that the appeal of magic tricks, to firgure out the how?
The pleasure of magic is from the mystery.
Figuring out the tricks, or trying to, is part of the fun. Having them explained is…not.
I love it, Carson.
That is beautiful AND hilarious.
Let us proclaim the mystery of Colby.
Colby has died. Colby has risen. Colby will come again.
Colby is dead, Berkman is free.
lame
A man is not fully a man until he has a man-crush.
Carson. I am not sure if I love you, or hate you, but I will surely read every word you put on this site.
I, however, will not. Everything he writes is just utter randomness in the guise of genius. It’s the equivalent of punk bands giving sentence long names to songs. It’s not creative or exciting, it’s garbage.
Best laugh I’ve had in quite a while, with that ‘ineffable girlfriend’ crack (the rest of the piece was pretty good, too) — thanks.
Next, Carson, let’s think about the whether you or I or any of us have any free will in discussing Colby Lewis, or whether it was predetermined that we believe we have the free will to discuss Colby Lewis.
I believe you two are among The Chosen.
The rest of us have had our hearts hardened, our eyes shut, our mind shielded, and may never be allowed to see.
ineffable girlfriend.
Classic.
Impervious* is another good one.
* unable to be penetrated.
Good* point* sagely* pedant**
*Useful
**Most worthless class of humanity***
***Homo**** Sapiens****
****Humanity
Unable to be perved?
Carson, your WAR in the game of life is somewhere around 10000000000.
Once again, beautiful.
Carson – big sabermetrics and baseball fan also in Madison at UW-Law. Wanna meet up for some beers and watch the game? I always love watching with other students of the game.
Pass…you sound like a tool shed
Don’t appreciate being called wide.
5/5
Query: If this game is rained out and L-wis doesn’t descend onto the field to deliver his pitches, do we all remain agnostics? Or, by not appearing tonight, would C-lby be proving the need for faith and testing his believers?
Carson, you are amazing.
this was awesome. like wow… most of the things you read on this site is analytical (duh) and these rare moments of levity are fantastic! i don’t know why you love lewis so much, and i hope the yankees win, but for your sake, i hope he strikes out 20.
Perhaps the greatest post ever.
Keep up the great work Carson … where do you come up with this stuff?
Dying Colby destroyed our death, rising Colby restored our life, lord Colby come in glory!
Great article, it’s a solid 31/32 star rating. It would get bonus points for mentioning the following things:
Matt Stairs
Russ Adams’ grand slam off of Jonathon Papelbon
Sal Fasano’s Mustache
Brandon Morrow’s slider
Rollie Fingers Mustache
Ryan Franklin’s Goatee
Colby Lewi- wait, never mind
Selah
I salute you on the first known (to me anyway) reference to Borges in a (however ineffable) baseball article. May there be many more.
Mick
Garden of the Forking Paths
Ithaca, NY
I am not sure which one of us pitched tonight, but one of us will be pitching next week.
Pretty sure Phil Hughes wishes he was Colby Lewis, and Girardi too..
Whatever the case may be, Colby performed a miracle when needed.
We’ll probably find out later that he laid his hands on Hamilton’s ribs.
Just came back to find this. In my opinion the best all time fangraphs post.