Michael Brantley Is Good and on the Astros Now

Last year, in all of baseball, the lowest team strikeout rate was 18.7%, and it belonged to the Indians. This is considering only non-pitchers, so as to put the National League on the same level as the American League. Projections, as you know, are by their very nature conservative. And now the 2019 Astros project for a team strikeout rate of 18.4%.

Last year, in all of baseball, the highest team wRC+ was 118, and it belonged to the Dodgers. The second-highest team wRC+ was 111, and it belonged to three different ballclubs. This is considering only non-pitchers, so as to put the NL on the same level as the AL. Projections, as you know, are by their very nature conservative. And now the 2019 Astros project for a team wRC+ of 115.

This is where the Astros stand after having come to a two-year agreement with free-agent Michael Brantley, worth $32 million. It’s not yet official-official, and I guess there’s some chance it all blows up, but I wouldn’t count on that happening. Brantley is good, and he’ll be the Astros’ newest regular.

From the Indians’ side, this might be doubly painful. Brantley was a big reason why the 2018 Indians hit, and why they seldom struck out, and now he’s gone, joining another AL rival. The Indians didn’t extend Brantley a qualifying offer, citing payroll concerns, so there’s no compensation going back, and the Indians are also presently looking for outfield help as they try to round out their roster on a budget. It’s true that $32 million for the Astros isn’t the same as $32 million for the Indians, but the Indians could use a player like Michael Brantley. That specific player is no longer on the market.

For Brantley, 2018 was a critical season. Some players get labeled as health risks for reasons that aren’t very fair. The reasons were fair, in Brantley’s case. He needed ankle surgery following an injury in 2017. Before that, he needed a pair of shoulder surgeries, which limited him to 11 games in 2016. This past year, however, Brantley batted 631 times, and he posted a 124 wRC+ with a line that looked like what he did in his prime. He even stole a dozen bases while playing most of the time in left field. Back when Brantley’s shoulder wasn’t right, I’d been told it was “shredded,” and it wasn’t clear whether he’d ever be the same guy. Brantley now resembles the same guy, only with a few extra scars.

Brantley’s game isn’t showcasing upper-deck power. Rather, he’s one of the game’s premier contact hitters, and he’ll clear the fence when he gets it just so. Here’s a plot covering five seasons, showing isolated power on the y-axis, and strikeout rate on the x. Brantley is the point in yellow.

This next plot looks a lot like that one, except that this one is forward-looking. Here are all projected regulars and semi-regulars for 2019, expressed through the same statistics:

Brantley, again, isn’t a power hitter, so much as he’s a good hitter who has some power. He has about the same projected isolated power as Adam Jones and Yangervis Solarte, but out of this sample of 338 players, Brantley’s projected strikeout rate ranks fourth-lowest. Yuli Gurriel ranks ninth-lowest. Jose Altuve ranks 15th-lowest, and Alex Bregman ranks 18th-lowest. The Astros have four of the 20 lowest projected strikeout rates, and that’s one way in which Brantley is a fit.

There’s also the fact that Brantley’s left-handed. It remains unclear to me how much it actually matters if a team leans too heavily in one direction, but managers always love balance, and the only other lefty hitters on the Astros are Josh Reddick and Tony Kemp, not counting guys like A.J. Reed, Kyle Tucker, Derek Fisher, and Garrett Stubbs. Don’t get me wrong, they’re all left-handed, too, but none of them are proven, and none of them project to make the opening roster. Those players can’t be taken for granted as the Astros think about 2019.

One thing Brantley isn’t is a premium defensive corner outfielder. According to Statcast’s sprint speed, Brantley was actually the second-slowest sprinter last year, among left fielders. He ranked behind names like Matt Kemp, Rhys Hoskins, and Trey Mancini. On the other hand, the guy in dead-last place was none other than Alex Gordon, who’s been one of the best left fielders in recent history. Brantley isn’t Gordon, but he’s not Kemp or Hoskins, either. Relative to league average, he probably profiles to be a few runs worse. The short left field in Houston could somewhat mitigate things, and so would slotting in every so often at first base and DH. I don’t think the Astros yet know exactly how they’re going to look.

With that in mind, they continue to be linked to Nelson Cruz, even after signing Brantley. And although J.T. Realmuto rumors have generally tried to put him somewhere else, the Astros remain a fit, despite having signed Robinson Chirinos. One thing Brantley does is somewhat close the door on Tucker, who’s one of baseball’s very best outfield prospects. Now, the Astros know that, and the Astros didn’t get to where they are by cashing in all of their long-term potential core players, but if the Astros put Tucker on the table, the Marlins would listen. That would be a little easier to do, compared to a day or two ago.

Or maybe Tucker just eventually bumps Reddick. This can go in a lot of directions. What the Astros have done, by signing Brantley, is add to their impressive pile of talent. The pile provides them with a greater number of options, as they consider the remaining available players.

Michael Brantley is good, and the Astros are better. They got Brantley for less than the Phillies gave to Andrew McCutchen, which might be a deal, or which might be appropriate, given their respective health records. But Brantley is good, and he was healthy throughout 2018. Sometimes making moves doesn’t have to be complicated. Sometimes you just want a good player.





Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.

28 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
HappyFunBallMember since 2019
7 years ago

I’m imagining the Astros signing Cruz to be their full-time DH, trading a package centered on Tucker for Realmuto and it feels like baseball porn.

rhswanzey
7 years ago
Reply to  HappyFunBall

And the rich get richer

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago

Rumor has it that the Astros are trying to move Reddick, which would then put Tucker in right field full time. This is probably the best move if they can pull it off, but they can also let Tucker just hang out in AAA for a while. Or they can move Brantley to DH to save his body and promote Tucker.

Overall, this is a much better deal than the one for McCutchen, who has similar offensive value as Brantley and who got an extra year on the deal. McCutchen is far more durable, and so he fits Philly’s needs a little better, but this is more like the type of deal I would have expected of your average-ish starting corner outfielder on the wrong side of 30. I admit that I have a gut instinct that Brantley will outhit McCutchen next year, but I suspect that is mostly because I can’t shake the feeling that Brantley is still shaking rust off. There’s no actual logic behind it.

Joe Joe
7 years ago

Astros get better, but they were already good. Probably gives them about a 1 WAR increase this season.

Johnston
7 years ago

And the Astros continue to do all the right things and get better and better. Meanwhile the Dodgers have…signed Joe Kelly?

mooshoomayne88
7 years ago

I think signing Nelly Cruz is a moot point. White can split time berween 1B and DH while Nelly never plays the field. Signing Cruz makes rostering Guriel damn near useless especially after signing Diaz as well. White is cheap, under team control, presently has little trade value and could potentially be as good as OR better than Nelson! Dont mess my dynasty team up by signing Cruz Astro’s!!

Kevbot034
7 years ago
Reply to  mooshoomayne88

You think White will…outslug Cruz? And you’re basing that on fantasy keeper league hopes? Good luck

hobbes020
7 years ago

Seems like another sharp move by the club

carterMember since 2020
7 years ago

Brantley helped take me to the promised land last year, so I feel almost bad writing this, but he is slow. He is really, really slow. Molina stole 9 bases in 2017. If they are counting on him taking good routes, and not making mistakes then you can expect him to be a below average defensive leftfielder who hits the ball well. But range he has not.

I would not be of the least bit surprised to see him be the primary DH. He is the son of a former major leaguer (and hitting coach), and is obsessive with his craft. I echo what sadtrombone says as I think last season is his offensive floor, and he is likely one of few guys in the MLB who might benefit from watching tape in between at bats.

OkraMember since 2016
7 years ago

How did the Astros get Brantley at such a low price?! Hard to believe other teams wouldn’t top 2yrs $32M. If he could be had at ~2/35 I’d expect a lot of teams to jump on that opportunity … A’s, Angels, Rays, Braves, Reds, Rockies. Kinda shocking for a guy projected for 2.5 WAR and coming off a 3.5 WAR season.

StatNerdMember since 2018
7 years ago
Reply to  Okra

He’s a *massive* injury risk. As an Indians fan, I think hes worth $12mm per year but $16mm per?

No thank you. I love the guy but there’s a decent chance you’re eating that.

BradleyZimmernsBizarreHitsMember since 2025
7 years ago
Reply to  StatNerd

I agree that the risk puts his value a bit below. Maybe 14-15 million if you can guarantee health.

HappyFunBallMember since 2019
7 years ago
Reply to  Okra

Also there aren’t many (any?) teams with a better shot at a ring than HOU. Brantley may very well have taken the 2nd (or 3rd) best offer because he thinks is his best chance to win a World Series. $32M is quite enough to avoid sleeping on the streets during retirement, thank you very much!

emh1969
7 years ago

Last year the Indians has exactly 6,300 PAs. The players they’ve lost or traded away accounted for about 3,400 of those PAs or roughly 54%. Meanwhile, the players they’ve acquired had about 1,200 PAs least year or barely 1/3 of the lost PAs. For better or worse, the Indians will definitely be a different team next year. But they have accomplished two of their main off season goals: get younger and reduce payroll.

bhacking
7 years ago

Cleveland is probably doing the right thing for the long-term, but if I was running the ship the there I would have been really tempted to go all in for 2019 with that rotation and the weakness in the division.

Kevbot034
7 years ago
Reply to  bhacking

The weakness of the division is why they can do this, though. They’re still planning to get 1st place in the AL Central. I do agree, though, that paying up and winning it all in 19 sounds more appealing, but maybe they aren’t wrong to be getting younger and paying less to make sure they keep winning long term. I don’t know.

Jimmie Foxxalorian
7 years ago

Re: sprint speed, in the case of Alex Gold Glove Gordon being dead last, could it be due to his position being so gosh darn perfect that he seldom needs to sprint?

CC AFCMember since 2016
7 years ago

Naw, sprint speed is based on the player’s fastest single sprint, it’s not an average.

Captain MoonlightMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  CC AFC

It actually is an average:

Sprint Speed is Statcast’s foot speed metric, defined as “feet per second in a player’s fastest one-second window” on individual plays. For a player’s seasonal average, the following two types of plays currently qualify for inclusion in Sprint Speed. The best of these runs, approximately two-thirds, are averaged for a player’s seasonal average.
* Runs of two bases or more on non-homers, excluding being a runner on second base when an extra base hit happens
* Home to first on “topped” or “weakly hit” balls.
The Major League average on a “competitive” play is 27 ft/sec, and the competitive range is roughly from 23 ft/sec (poor) to 30 ft/sec (elite). A player must have at least 10 competitive runs to qualify for this leaderboard.

CC AFCMember since 2016
7 years ago

Oops, my b. I knew the fastest one second part, but didn’t realize it was an average of those.

Jimmie Foxxalorian
7 years ago

Thank you! I understand it better now

Billsaints
7 years ago

Remember when the Astros struck out the most in all if baseball, it wasn’t long ago

Jetsy Extrano
7 years ago

Who’s the dot out at the low-K extreme of the 2019 projection?

ejchrist
7 years ago
Reply to  Jetsy Extrano

I believe that is Willians Astudillo. 6.6% K, .151 ISO in 267 projected PA.

FeathMember since 2021
7 years ago
Reply to  ejchrist

Jeff must still be tired after Vegas to not have called this out. I’m guessing it will be item 1 on the next Effectively Wild podcast in an attempt to make up for it.

Jetsy Extrano
7 years ago

Pet peeve: you could project “max team wRC+” and that would not be conservative, it’s not that the spirit of projection itself is conservative. It’s just that “max of projected values” is different than “projected max of values”. Different meaning a bad way to go about it, specifically.

Groundout
7 years ago

I find it interesting that Brantley ended up signing such a similar deal to Charlie Morton. You’d think that most teams in the market for a 2-year, $30m player would prefer the pitcher, given the abundance of good corner outfielders. The Astros obviously disagreed.

jkaflagg
7 years ago

This move made so much sense I figured it would never happen – and only a two year commitment to boot. Hoping the Astros get Cruz on another two year deal, keep Tucker and move Reddick, even though they’ll likely have to eat some salary. With the bats of Brantley and Cruz and the return to health of Correa and Altuve, the Astros will be able to carry catchers like Chirinos and Stassi that can concentrate on handling the pitching staff and not worry about offensive contributions.