Mike Trout and the Credibility of the MVP Award
Tonight, the results of the voting for the AL and NL MVPs will be announced. In the NL, Kris Bryant will likely win in a landslide, as he was the league’s best player, played on the league’s best team, and put up big numbers in the categories that get the most attention. Daniel Murphy and Corey Seager also had terrific years, but I’d be surprised if either got more than a handful of first place votes. And when Bryant wins, everyone will mostly nod along in agreement, as the process will have worked to select the right candidate.
In the AL, though, it’s going to be a different story. Mookie Betts is probably going to win, and instead of celebrating the accomplishments of one of the best young players in the game, there is going to be outrage. There is going to be yelling. There is going to be anger and frustration. Twitter is going to be a dumpster fire, even more than usual. Because once again, Mike Trout is going to finish second, and the best (human-sized) player we’ve ever seen is going to say something nice about an inferior player who got rewarded for having better teammates again.
And then there’s going to be the same arguments that got trotted out every year. “It’s the Most Valuable Player Award, not the Best Player Award”, they’ll say. And then people will point out that it’s a distinction without a difference, and back-and-forth things will go until everyone gets distracted by a trade or something. And then we’ll do all this again in another 12 months, since the Angels don’t look like they’re really in any kind of position to put Trout in the playoffs. And round and round we’ll go.
Tonight, we could be celebrating the fact that we’ve had the privilege to watch a guy who has outgrown the Mickey Mantle comparison. We could be talking about the obvious greatness of one of the very best baseball players who has ever lived. We could be collectively thankful that we happen to be alive at a time where everyone gets to watch Mike Trout play, to see what an all-time great in his prime looks like.
But unless things have changed more rapidly than we currently think, we’re going to end up debating the meaning of the word valuable, and congratulating Mookie Betts for having the good fortune to be drafted by a team that has other good players too.
Because, let’s be honest, no one thinks the Red Sox would have won fewer games had they engineered a preseason trade of Betts for Trout. No one thinks Betts would have magically carried the Angels to the playoffs if he was in Anaheim this year. No one thinks Betts had a better year than Trout, because it’s a demonstrably false claim.
But Betts is likely going to be named the AL MVP because, we’ll be told, the MVP isn’t about recognizing the best player in the game. This award is apparently about recognizing the best player on a winning team, or at least a team that won enough games for voters to feel good about their predetermined decision to vote for him, even though the instructions on the ballot specifically say that’s not the criteria voters should use.
But I continue to not know why anyone would care about an award with that kind of criteria. Who was the best player in the league this year? That’s an interesting question. That’s a question worth answering. Who was the best player in the league among the teams who made the playoffs, excluding all those guys who were individually great in an environment where greatness wasn’t the norm? Who gives a crap. That’s a question that is only ever asked by baseball writers looking for a reason to continue illogical voting traditions, and no one else.
No fan in the world cares about the answer to that question, and yet, we have an award that has been molded to fit that criteria. And so we don’t have an award that answers the question that people actually care about. Who is the best player in the world? Mike Trout. Everyone who follows baseball in any real way knows that’s the truth. Why don’t we have an award that let’s us recognize that fact?
Every year we choose to give the award to someone other than the guy who is clearly the best (non-big-head-division) player we’ve seen in 75 years, the award itself loses credibility. We’re past the point of Mike Trout needing some hardware to cement his legacy; we’re now at the point where the award needs Mike Trout to win in order for a large portion of baseball fans to stop thinking of the voting process as a joke. The BBWAA needs to honor Mike Trout more than Mike Trout needs to be honored by the BBWAA.
This change is coming. Trout’s going to get some first place votes tonight, and maybe even get enough to make it a close race. The electorate is evolving, and the voters are less uniform on this issue than they were even a few years ago. At some point in the not too distant future, there will be enough voters who reject the must-play-on-a-winning-team canard that the award will become a credible piece of hardware again. And hopefully, that will happen soon enough to give Mike Trout another trophy or two, since he should be picking up his fourth tonight.
But I don’t think we’re there yet. I think Mookie Betts is going to win tonight. Mookie Betts had a great season. I wish we could spend the night talking about how great a season Mookie Betts had. But that he’s going to win is incredible, in the sense that it’s not credible. On a planet where Mike Trout exists, spending time honoring everyone but Mike Trout makes the whole thing feel like a farce.
Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.


“Everyone who follows baseball in any real way”
Not your finest moment, IMO. There’s more than one way to be a fan, even if I disagree with them.
Are there actually serious baseball fans who don’t recognize Trout as the best player in baseball? Serious question.
This is the problem with Dave’s tact and yours. You change the question to belittle those that disagree with you. No one is saying that Trout isn’t the best player in baseball or that he didn’t have the best season. The argument is about the MVP award and its traditional inclusion of value to a team as a qualifier. You may prefer an award go to the best player, but that has not been the MVP award now or ever.
The original comment is spot on despite many down votes. Dave likes to think he is so much smarter than everyone else and often takes this approach. Its actually quite ignorant to view things as completely black and white when we know that most of what we discuss regarding sports is anything but. Belittling those that disagree with you is a non-starter in a meaningful debate. This is the same approach Murray Chass gets killed for here.
Then how do you explain Ernie Banks winning two MVP awards and Andre Dawson winning one on non-competitive Cubs teams?
Banks & Dawson won because they drove in more runs than anyone else in the league in their respective MVP seasons.
Didn’t read the article, did we?
100% agreed. The holier than thou, one size fits all mentality too often displayed by both writers and readers on this site gets in the way of genuinely edifying debate. Dogmatism is the enemy not differing opinions and interpretations of the same set of facts.
I’m a serious fan. I think Kershaw is better. What’s up?
The only reason to be upset with that specific quote is if you believe Mike Trout is not the best player in baseball.
Another reason to be upset is if you believe that Real Fandom is a condescending tone that connotes that analyzing the minutiae of player performance is the only way to enjoy the game.
I was once a 12 year old playing little league shortstop in central connecticut, debating with my friends whether Jeter’s elite jump-throw defense or Nomar’s absurd idiosyncratic batting averages were more desirable. Sorry I wasn’t a Real Fan for not recognizing A-Rod as the actual best shortstop.
You can still debate about Nomar’s skills or Jeter’s defence. I can appreciate Jeter’s jump throws, while recognizing that, yeah, he misses more plays than he gets too. That he is a below average defender, but when he does make a great play, it looks absolutely stellar. And that he’s got a high baseball IQ, and can make some creative plays on the fly. I can recognize his greatness and his flaws at the same time.
By the same token, I can recognize that Mike Trout is a pretty amazing player, and that nobody else on the planet is on his level.
I’m telling you that 12 year old me thought that Nomar was The Best. MVP. Numero Uno.
Obviously I was wrong, but I guess the way i followed baseball wasn’t “real” enough for FG?
yes, clearly the point of this article was about REAL and non-real fandom.
and your multiple posts about when you were 12 have set Dave straight.
thanks. now stop.
Its okay, most of us were naive at 12.
Bananas, the problem is when you get so lost in sentimentality that it interferes with meaningful analysis.
Jeter was incredible. Nomar was incredible. We should all be able to appreciate them without going the extra length of saying “… and therefore we shouldn’t decide the MVP based on analysis.”
I think that your Nomar support was a perfectly reasonable stance for a 12-year-old to make. Hell, I still think Eric Davis circa 1987 is the best player of all time. (Obviously, I’m wrong about that, too – but it’s a hell of a lot more fun for me to think that way.)
Maybe the point is that we should expect more from sportswriters – guys (presumably adults) who get paid to write about the sport.
I don’t begrudge anyone’s fandom, and I agree with you that trying to characterize any worldview as “REAL FANDOM” is condescending and ultimately counter-productive.
But when it comes to MVP voters, I expect the writers to be smarter than you as a 12-year-old worshiping Nomar and me as an 8-year-old worshiping Eric Davis. (And I recognize that this is just my opinion – I’m not saying it’s WRONG to vote for Betts over Trout. But it IS the type of thing a kid would do.)
I guess my point is this: Eric Davis was amazing.
I thought Barry Bonds was the best player I had ever seen in 1992 when I was 10….wait, I have nothing in common with you two. I killed it at 10. Carry on….
If the question of which player is better than which is minutia to you, you’re probably on the wrong site.
First of all, no one cares about your 12-year old experience.
Second of all, during the combined 1998-1999 seasons those three SS ranked in WAR:
Nomar Garciaparra: 13.6
Derek Jeter: 13.6
Alex Rodriguez: 12.6
So it probably made a lot of sense to debate who was the better player.
Third of all, no one cares about your 12-year old experience.
I think you are confusing “being a fan” with “following baseball.” The difference is big and applies to breadth of thought, not depth.
It does have rather unfortunate connotations of the sort of crap people like Bissinger would emit (http://www.firejoemorgan.com/2005/07/buzz-bissinger-thinks-we-cant-love.html) to show that anyone interested in analysis wasn’t a true fan. I’d like to think we’re better than that.
I guess my comments are a little flowery but this was my point. We can appreciate Mike Trout without discrediting the ways others enjoy the game, and IMO Dave’s language in this article is crossing that line.
Makes it a lot harder to have conversations with less-saber friends when they read articles like this and feel turned off because their view of the world is invalidated from the start.
If you think you should vote for an underserving MVP because you can’t think of how else to venerate a player, that really is a way of thinking that deserves to be discredited.
I don’t know why you’re getting down-voted so hard. I agree the tone is condescending, elitist, and purist, even if the underlying argument is valid.
Discrediting someone’s fandom because of their frame of reference is absurd and should be called out as lazy journalism.
As a long time reader, it’s rare that I deviate from the views of the broader community. That said, I think bananas’ statement is pretty on point.
Yes, Mike Trout is the best player in baseball. Yes, he deserves several more MVPs than he has received. Yes, the voting system does not properly recognize the “best player”. Dave’s argument is rock solid and something I buy into 100%.
That said, calling someone a “real fan” is in fact discrediting and disenfranchising. It’s the same as when Jon Stewart would call out Fox News for describing parts of the US as “Real America”. It’s insulting and discrediting to the rest of the population. It’s elevating one at the cost of the other instead of just highlighting differences.
Article is still dead on, but it is clear Dave was (rightfully) struggling with the emotions of watching an injustice process trot on for another year. This is one of the most passionate articles I’ve seen him right and sadly — in this one instance — I think he misstepped in his articulation of the differences of fans.
I kinda agree. 12-year-olds SHOULD think some halfway decent player on their favourite team is the best player ever.
Why is everyone acting like it’s guaranteed that Betts wins? Is he really favored that much over Trout? I feel like Trout at very least has just as much of a chance of winning the award.
So we could have what happened yesterday in the Cy Young race happen in the MVP race? But only this time, we get the right answer?
Porcello actually deserves the award just as much as either Verlander or Kluber. Same fWAR. His park adjusted metrics were better than Verlander. Really any of the three could have won. Porcello maybe got some points for winning 22 games on top of being statically comparable to his peers.
While Betts was fantastic, it is evident that statistically he wasn’t close to Trout.
The AL MVP might as well be the Grammy’s at this point… not sure I can muster up any sort of reason or argument to even care. We can probably extend this to all the AL awards this year, frankly.
#MVP’sSoNotTrout
Piss or get off the pot. Organize a sabermetrics vote across all of the relevant sites and writers.
This already exists: http://ibwaa.com/about/
I wasn’t aware of this. Thanks!
I wish I understood why Jose Altuve hasn’t been mentioned in this article, or Manny Machado, or Josh Donaldson.
Because Trout is the best player who should win the award, and Betts was the best player on a winning team. Really isn’t an argument for Altuve, Donaldson, or Machado despite how great they were. All 3 were way worse than Trout. All 3 also were inferior to Betts by a significant amount in bWAR and a fair amount in fWAR
The gap between Betts and Donaldson in fWAR is well within any margin of error. You don’t have to get real creative to assume that Donaldson is a better player than Betts. Betts pulls ahead of everyone on defense and of all the metrics out there, defense is the least established and least trusted.
Betts has over +2 win advantage in bWAR which is very significant. According to fWAR both are similar, but as you mentioned Betts does hold the advantage.
In any event, Trout SHOULD be the winner. If we are going the “has to be on a winning team” idea (which I’m not saying you should, but then again its the only way to not give Trout the MVP), then theoretically Betts holds even more appeal as he “lead” the RS over the Jays to the ALE crown.
Really, the only reasonable winner is Trout. If you were going to pick from the rest, Betts probably makes the most sense as he was the most valuable of the others and was on a div winning team.
Trout definitely is the most deserving … and it’s not even close. Total agreement there. However, I would choose Donaldson over Betts. I personally regress the defensive value (especially with someone like Betts who was out of this world) pretty significantly given my skepticism of defensive numbers.
Are you saying that Altuve has been *overlooked*?
But in all seriousness, what is hard to understand. Cameron wrote this article because the best player in baseball is about to lose the MVP vote to the best player on a winning team. And neither on of those players are Altuve, Machado, or Donaldson.
Uhh, they announced finalists and Manny Machado and Josh Donaldson are not finalists. They 100% have no shot of winning this award. Altuve is about a mile behind Trout in any logical thinking for MVP, and he wasn’t on a playoff roster either. If a voter is going to ignore the playoff team aspect, Altuve is dead where he stands.
There is a literally zero percent chance that Machado or Donaldson wins. Slightly higher than zero for Altuve, but still close.
Can someone explain the “human-sized” joke to me?
Is it a reference to steroids, a la the big head thing? Sorry to be dense it’s just a weird line.
Yes, it is.
Barry Bonds. Same as the head-size comment. All of the statements about Trout being the best in x years, etc. don’t work if you include Bonds and his >12 fWAR seasons.
You should never count those seasons. That wasn’t Bonds doing that, it was illegal chemicals.
Bonds was better but his head was huge.
Bonds’ head grew a frightening number of sizes.
And his heart almost certainly got smaller in lock step Grinch style.
Among other parts of his anatomy.
Dickshot always measures….
I had to think for a moment on this one too: there was probably a less oblique way to make the point.
“Best Player (Non-Bane Division)”?
Mere humans cannot conceive of the vastness of the truly greatest player’s head.
It’s not like this is unprecedented. Indeed, what is unprecedented is the seeming belief that he should already have 4 – since the only player who ever had more than 3 in his entire career was Bonds and that should be considered highly asterisky. Willie Mays only won 2 MVP’s (with 20 All-Star starts). Ted Williams only won 2 (with 17 All-Star starts). Hank Aaron only won 1 (with 21 All-Star starts).
Just to say that there’s plenty of ways to recognize all-time great players as all-time great during their careers. It doesn’t change the credibility of any particular award.
I suppose that’s true, but it doesn’t change the point. The MVP voting isn’t any worse than it’s ever been, but there’s a big difference in that we know better now. The credibility loss is in failing to change and improve as knowledge has changed and improved.
Michael Wilbon, who I actually really like a lot, spoke the words on his show PTI, “Francisco Lindor might be the best all around player in the AL right now, today”. While I understand that the sentiment behind this statement was essentially to heap praise on Lindor, a wonderful all around player I’d love to have on my team, my first reaction was… “Did Mike Trout retire or something?” I kind of feel the same way about the MVP award going to anyone else. I fully understand all of the arguments presented for the other side in this article. I acknowledge that other people have the right to feel that way.
But… it’s just… I mean… Trout, dude. Trout.
Sports dudes paid to say stupid exaggerated garbage on TV do exactly that. Its why each of them have 15 top5 players if you actually keep track.
Why don’t you guys just create that award? The site’s name must carry enough weight at this point for you guys to do some fringy awards. I can see a future where the players put “Fangraphs (Actual) MVP Award” as a basis for incentive pay in their contracts
It would be a bit redundant since they already track WAR. Why vote on an award when your site has a leaderboards list showing the people who were, in fact, most valuable/productive?
I agree with this sentiment, but I also think Dave should stop participating in voting for these awards, and the site should actively ignore them. But then they are worth lots of hot internet clicks, and the controversy is worth even more!
I mean the whole game is about making money anyway, so I guess we cannot begrudge Appleman turning his millions into billions on all that sweet sweet MVP controversy lucre.
A Fangraphs MVP Award (or whatever you want to call it) need not be a simple stack ranking of fWAR. There are plenty of other ways to help quantify a players contribution. WAR is a great short hand version of value but it’s not the only one out there. In this case, the gap is so great between Trout and everyone not Trout that it wouldn’t be much of a discussion. However, last year is a good example where fWAR was close enough between Donaldson and Trout that you have to look to other factors in deciding “the best”.
Good column! Two quibbles:
1) You said Trout “should be picking up his fourth” MVP trophy. Did you mean fifth, since he’s led the AL in fWAR and bWAR for the last 5 seasons? Or would you not have given it to him in one of those years?
2) While I don’t think the MVP should be “Who was the best player in the league among the teams who made the playoffs,” I still think it’s a question of *some* interest.
I think people generally accept that Josh Donaldson was a deserving MVP winner. At the very least, people should admit there was a legitimate argument to choose either Trout or Donaldson that year.
This
PREACH
Take away Mookie’s 7.8 WAR from the Red Sox, you end up with a team total that finishes only .7 behind the Blue Jays. Give Mookie’s at-bats to a back-up (Brock Holt, or bring up Benintendi sooner), and the Sox still likely finish on top of the AL East. Take Mike Trout from Angels, and you would have perhaps the hardest-to-watch team in baseball. Just my speculations, of course. But I’ve heard a number of Angel fans say that if it weren’t for Trout, they would not be coming to the ball park or watching on TV. That’s another cogent definition of valuable, for sure.
Man, even though some Angels fans have said that, being a resident of orange county, I have to say that Angels fans are the least deserving fans of Mike Trout in baseball. I think most people who go to Angels games are going for a social media picture op and have no concept of the immense spread between Trout and the rest of their players. I sound mean, but i know i don’t deserve Mike trout either – i find the angels unwatchable and will gladly make the drive up to Chavez over going to an Angels game..
I can understand the down votes on your comment (and the ones I’m going to get) but, I completely agree with you. As a Ray’s fan we didn’t deserve: Price, Shields, Crawford, and now probably Archer and Cobb. They don’t get wins, they don’t make news, and that’s in part due to the Rays offense and playing for a small market team. This year was quite strange, tons of homers, inconsistent pitching but, just as the Angels are unable to support Trout, the Rays are unable to support, really any player that shows they have talent (or atleast for the long term, we probably will trade Longo because 77.5 million for Longo at 31+ is not something the Rays can afford).
I’m a Red Sox fan, and a Mookie fan, but I agree that Trout is more deserving of MVP (and he’d have my vote overall). In fact, I don’t think Betts is necessarily the most deserving player on his team. If we take seriously the idea that MVP might sometimes mean something like “the player who contributed most, in various ways, to his team’s success,” then I’d point out that David Ortiz was good enough to induce his organization to actually try to win this year – and Mike Trout obviously wasn’t.
How many induced wins above replacement was Ortiz worth this year?
You had me with the first sentence, then your whole post went downhill by saying Ortiz (who only bats) was more valuable than Betts who was very good offensively and outstanding on defense.
I think the downvoters may have missed Fred’s point:
If people can (incorrectly, in Fred’s opinion) argue that Betts is “more valuable” than Trout, then one can use the same “logic” to argue that Ortiz is more valuable than Betts.
He is pointing out the folly of the Betts over Trout logic.
He should be about to win his fourth MVP, and he only has one and will probably only have one after today, and he won his only MVP in his worst season to date. Go figure…
As a Red Sox fan, I’ll be happy to see Mookie win, and he had the kind of season that wins you an MVP–in any world where there’s no Mike Trout.
Part of me thinks they should just settle this once and for all by having an award for the best player on a playoff team and another one for the best player in the league, no matter who he plays for. Make everyone happy and stop arguing about it.
Unpopular opinion alert.
Yes Mike Trout is probably the best player in baseball. Yes he deserves a handful of MVPs.
But that said, I don’t really think WAR should be the be all end all statistic, nor should any statistic. Since there is vast differences at times in how the different WAR calculates for different sites, I view it more as a sorting and batching tool. Such as something like players with 10+ WAR are compared to each other 8-10 WAR are comparable, and so on.
I just don’t think WAR is as exact as it could be. We are gaining more knowledge every day, but defense and to a lesser extent, base running are both very inexact and have great variances in ways to grade them, as does pitch framing, positional adjustments, ballpark adjustments and the like. Yes they are getting better, yes we can tell a lot from what we know, but there are other parts of these things we still know just as close to nothing about.
I am also in the camp that “best” isn’t always “valuable.” Valuable is a team by team basis and what each team needs and values is completely different, and often times just as valid, from other teams.
I mean, okay… let’s try and give this a go…
1. are you advocating for Betts over Trout? if so, why?
2. what stat or set of stats would you use to evaluate “best”?
3. if best isn’t valuable, how specifically do you assess valuable?
3. As Branch Rickey said to Ralph Kiner: “We finished last with you, we can finish last without you.”
I don’t have any problem with using the narrative of the pennant races as a large part of assessing this award and don’t what metric Fangraphs is dogmatically using to decide that their definition of valuable is the only correct one.
Yes, Trout was much better. But you know that introduction when someone announces x-time Grammy award winner Paul McCartney? I’m excited because of the Paul McCartney part, not the Grammy part.
soooo… your answer to #3 is: “using the narrative of the pennant races?” if so, that leads me to:
3a. how specifically do you assess “the narrative of the pennant races?”
You don’t? It’s an award created by writers, and is about narratives. It’s not about the best player in baseball and never has been.
So the MVP was Rajai Davis? Or Alan Craig or what? Maybe the MLB official/computer who put together this years schedule?
1. No, I am not advocating for Betts over Trout. I am more advocating that there is a conversation that can be had that can and should happen between the two. Both had MVP caliber seasons, and either one of them is deserving. One just less so. Trumbo would have gotten serious consideration 10-15 years ago.
2. I wouldn’t use any stat or set of stats to determine the “best.” They should be looked at both individually and combined. There is no stat that is infinitely better than the others. Some stats tell us more than other stats tell us. There are just vastly too many variables and possibilities to rely on one thing.
3. Valuable and the best simply are just not the same thing. It is false to assume they are. Yes, most of the time best is more valuable, but there are countless circumstances where best isn’t more valuable.
You don’t have to use WAR to understand that Trout is better than Betts, and does more to help the Angles win than Betts does to help the Redsox win. In fact, the inexact metrics actually help Betts’s case.
If Trout was on the Redsox and Betts was on the Angles, the Redsox would have won more games and Trout would be named MVP unanimously.
Trout is almost most definitely better than Betts. As much as we can say anything with certainty. In fact I think that was pretty much the first thing I said.
But to your point those inexact metrics do help Bett’s case. And 5 years from now they may help his case even more looking back. I doubt it. But looking back through time, we used to value different things at higher rates. A hit was more valuable than a walk to people in the past. While some hits (HR, 2b, 3b) are better than walks, getting on base is the goal and OBP has become more important. Offense used to be better than defense, and defense was just icing on the top, with exceptions to positions like C and SS. The basic point is the only thing we really know, is that we know very little.
“A hit was more valuable than a walk to people in the past. ”
Has that changed? Even switching it to “a single was more valuable than a walk”, I’m not sure it has changed.
A single is more valuable than a walk with runners on base since the runners sometimes get to take an extra base.
An average single is also more valuable than an average walk, because the defense, to some degree, chooses when a walk happens based on how they pitch to the batter, so besides the extra advancement possibilities, some number of walks are essentially strategy by the defense.
alpha, if you believe the Sox would say no to a Trout-Betts trade, then I have a whole lot of stuff I’d like to sell you…
c’mon. Its Mike Trout. He’s Mookie Betts best ever year, plus 3x the walks (so 80 points more OBP), and slightly better power, in a tougher hitting environment.
I made no mention of Betts in my post, nor do I think he should win the MVP. I merely posted that I think WAR is a better tool to group players into tiers and then have a discussion on who is better in those tiers, due to items being incorporated into it that are difficult to tell, rather than using it to say who is better.
Alright, Trout’s fWAR was more than 20% greater than that of the next-best player in the American League, and 10% better by bWAR. we can start this discussion by rightly determining that he is all alone in the league’s top tier, and argue over who the best player is in the league’s second tier.
It is ridiculous to say that an 8 WAR player is in the same “tier” as a 10 WAR player. An 8 WAR season is really great. But a 10 WAR season is historically amazing. Trout has AVERAGED in his 5 full seasons 9.4.
“I don’t really think WAR should be the be all end all statistic,”
Then you’re in luck, because no one, least of all Dave Cameron, has ever asserted that to be the case. Now take your strawman and go scare some crows with it.
A straw man would imply that I disagree with what was posted and am trying to negate the argument by simplifying the position to an easily arguable point.
I in fact agree with everything that was written minus the best = valuable point. Which most of the time it does, and sometimes it doesn’t.
My post was more of an ill timed complaint in a position that it shouldn’t have been posted, and held on to for a different time.
It won’t make any sense in a different time, either, though.
–
“I wish we could spend the night talking about how great a season Mookie Betts had”
you can Dave
I have no problem agreeing to Mike Trout being the Most Outstanding Player. Most Valuable? That makes everything weird. I wish they would just change the name and answer that question. I agree with Dave, that question is interesting.
The BBWAA is an institution that has its own interests at heart. By adding informal criteria like plays on a winning team or positive clubhouse influence or whatever other rationalizations they use to avoid voting for the best player, they keep the debate going and keep themselves relevant. It kind of reminds me of the electoral college.
Thank you for this article. For what its worth someone needs to throw that Chris “mad dog” off the air (MLB network). He is illogical and archaic in his thoughts toward the game. His segment on Betts over Trout is the MOST frustrating and down right insane argument I have ever heard. He speaks with no Stats, ignores OBP and goes strictly with the winning team standard. So much more to say but boy o boy it riles me up.
I think Trout’s clearly the best player in the AL and that he should win the award–personally I don’t think it’s fair to penalize the league’s best player for not being on one of the league’s better teams.
That said, I disagree with the way Cameron’s framing this. It’s one thing to argue (correctly) that Trout’s objectively better than everyone else in the AL, and should therefore be the MVP. It’s another to argue that, as a matter of objective fact, giving a trophy to a great player on a bad team is inherently more interesting than giving it to the player who did the most to help a good team contend for a World Series title. The analytical argument here (“Trout’s clearly best”) shouldn’t bleed into a subjective argument about entertainment (“If you’d rather pay attention only to contending teams, and argue about which player on those teams is most valuable, you are objectively an inferior kind of baseball fan”).
I think you are missing the point a little bit. Dave is saying that if there were an award that could only go to a player on one of the six (technically) teams that make the playoffs or one of the four that make the DS, then people would simply not give a shit about it, especially if there is also a rival award that goes to the best player in the league overall. I definitely agree with that statement. Why would the baseball fan public at large care about such an award?
We see these articles every year, and I’m getting closer to being in the Trout camp (but I’m not fully there yet). I know that’s not a popular opinion around here, and the truth is, I’m embarrassed to think the way I do.
I am the most sabermetrically-inclined person there is, except for this issue – because I just can’t seem to get past what has been the norm for decades as I grew up watching baseball.
I WANT to be persuaded that the MVP should go to the best player in the league – i.e. that value should be defined as “added the most wins to his team’s record” – and it’s happening, albeit slowly.
I have a serious request – I assume at least some of you felt the same way as I did at some point in your lives. Whether it was 10 years ago, 5 years ago, or last year, what finally made you believe that Trout should be winning the MVP over other excellent players (but not quite as excellent) who were on winning teams?
For me it was when I actually read the voting criteria for the MVP award:
Dear Voter:
There is no clear-cut definition of what Most Valuable means. It is up to the individual voter to decide who was the Most Valuable Player in each league to his team. The MVP need not come from a division winner or other playoff qualifier.
The rules of the voting remain the same as they were written on the first ballot in 1931:
1. Actual value of a player to his team, that is, strength of offense and defense.
2. Number of games played.
3. General character, disposition, loyalty and effort.
4. Former winners are eligible.
5. Members of the committee may vote for more than one member of a team.
You are also urged to give serious consideration to all your selections, from 1 to 10. A 10th-place vote can influence the outcome of an election. You must fill in all 10 places on your ballot. Only regular-season performances are to be taken into consideration.
Keep in mind that all players are eligible for MVP, including pitchers and designated hitters.
I was never solidly on the other side of the issue, but I think a good starting point is to ask, “What’s the purpose of having these awards in the first place?” For me the answer is that, while baseball’s a team game and ultimate success involves winning the World Series, there should be some official recognition of truly exceptional individual performance (Gold Gloves, Cy Young, MVPs, etc.). Viewed that way, I think the “but he didn’t play on a contender!” argument stops being compelling. Mike Trout being on a bad team isn’t a reason to deny him recognition. It means that the only official recognition available to him are individual awards. It seems wrong to me to deny him an award that his individual performance justifies, when circumstances are already denying him team success.
Mike Trout’s rookie season did it for me.
No mention of Nolan in the NL MVP race?
http://www.fangraphs.com/library/offense/wrc/
In his chat today, Enos mentioned that the BBWAA may not have a huge incentive to change their voting process. He was speaking of the controversy over the AL Cy Young awards, but I believe it applies here. If they give the award to Trout, everyone pretty much nods their heads in agreement and moves on. They give it to Betts, and they generate their own news cycle for the next few weeks.
Yes, but if the news cycle is “The MVP voters are idiots”, I don’t see how that helps them.
People! People!
No one said anything about “Real Fans” or “Fake Fans” or anything at all about fandom in this article.
Dave said, “follow baseball in any real way”. “Follow baseball”…as in the whole thing. Not following a certain team, not following a certain player, following baseball. He’s saying anyone who really follows the whole sport, has the perspective to realize that Trout is the best player. You may not like him. You may not be a Mike Trout fan. You might not even know who he is. But you aren’t any less of a fan if any of those are the case.
The biggest, best, most die-hard fan in the entire world may not necessarily follow, say, the American League because their team is a National League team. That person is no less of a fan because they might lack familiarity with the rest of baseball. But they might, however, lack the perspective to make a real objective claim to who the best player is. I think that is all Dave was saying.
Well, he did say that “Who is the best player on a winning team?” is a question that “no fan in the world cares about.” If we’re talking 82-80 then, yes, I personally don’t care who the best player is on teams that finished above .500. If we’re talking (as MVP voters tend to do) about “best player on a contending team,” then, sure, I care about it. “Which of these guys is more responsible for his team making the playoffs” is a fun discussion to me. I agree with Cameron that it’s the wrong way to look at MVP voting, but I think he made his argument too strongly in places.
Only a sith deals in absolutes.
“You were supposed to bring BALANCE to the lineup!”
No, he is basically saying that you are not a real fan unless you agree with him. Standard Cameron world view.
Can’t believe I’m the first overzealous Braves fan to say that Freeman should get votes over Murphy. Bryant and Seager are the clear 1-2. I’d have zero problem with Bryant winning unanimously.
After #1 does it matter?
I guess after the AL Cy Young vote it does!
It’s a moral victory after a full season of watching a team composed of mediocre vets, mediocre young guys, and Freddie Freeman.
Also, don’t think it applies here but in some instances players can get incentives for top 3 or 5 finishes or whatever.
Murphy shouldn’t be in the discussion unless we completely discount fielding.
Murphy finished 6th in NL WAR. 6th. It’s why I said he shouldn’t be in the discussion for winning MVP. I get his offense was top notch, but defense counts and he was arguably the worst defensive 2B in baseball. 21 guys qualified in the majors at 2B. Murphy was 19th in UZR, tied for last in DRS at -9, and 20th in RZR (range).
Certainly should have at least wound up ahead of Rizzo
Does Mike Trout’s significant other have a Twitter account? Is the Tweet already locked and loaded in anticipation of the outcome?
You know what never gets brought up in these conversations? The fact that even if you’re on a losing team, you objectively impact the pennant race because you play the teams in the pennant race. In other words, Trout’s value to the whole league was shown every time he beat up on Boston, Seattle, Houston, NY, Toronto, Cleveland, etc. Those teams had to contend with him up to 19 times this season. Those at bats and games counted and made a difference, if not for the Angels specifically, against the other teams generally. The biggest impact on the AL as a whole was shown by Mike Trout; whether it impacted his own team or not should be irrelevant.
When all is said and done, the fact that Houston and Seattle both missed out on the playoffs very well may have been a result of Trout’s Excellence against them. Or not. But every time he stepped on the field, he impacted the pennant races in one way or another, either positively (for his team) or negatively (for another).
Why the whole picture is never considered beats me entirely.
It’s really not that hard to figure out the “Valuable” part of MVP. Simple dictionary definition of the adjective:
1.having considerable monetary worth; costing or bringing a high price:a valuable painting; a valuable crop.
2.having qualities worthy of respect, admiration, or esteem:
a valuable friend.
3.of considerable use, service, or importance
Which of these 3 does ANY PLAYER in the AL, nay nay, MLB, come out on top of Mike Trout?
Hay, well said Mr. Dickshot. To anyone who trots out those same old long-in-the-tooth arguments against Trout I can only say nay, nay, NEIGHHHHHHHHHHH!
It drives me insane when I see these type of small minded articles as though WAR is the only way any intelligent fan can possibly ascertain value and hence vote on MVP and that the best player should always win regardless of context. Just the way Juan Gonzalez won in a year he probably didn’t deserve it based upon updated understanding of the importance of defense and baserunning is it so impossible that future information would show that Right Field defense is undervalued? Or that playing elite Short Stop while also hitting is far more difficult that playing Center Field? It’s not the responsibility of voters to write down the name of the consensus best player, that is NOT in the instructions just the way Dave points out that the instructions specifically mention that the player need not play on a winning team. I agree from an eye test that Mike Trout is likely the best player in baseball and that current stats back that up, but when Willie Mays (a player many consider the best player of all time) won twice, Micky Mantle won 3 times, and Babe Ruth won only one (I know, that one’s cheating, look it up if you don’t know the story) it’s not crazy that people find reasons to give it to Not Mike Trout. As a cross sport parallel, LeBron had won 4 wines despite being the best player in the NBA for most of the last decade.
“It drives me insane when I see these type of small minded articles as though WAR is the only way any intelligent fan can possibly ascertain value and hence vote on MVP and that the best player should always win regardless of context.”
No one is saying that, and Cameron wouldn’t say that either. This site frequently acknowledges the faults of WAR and constantly writes about other ways to ascertain value. I don’t really understand your argument. You seem to be saying that Trout was indeed the best player, but since mistakes were made in other sports or in the past about the MVP voting, then we should be OK with mistakes being made now.
It makes me mad when I see the little things, such as the type of brain that only some smart fan means war be finally determined value, and the results of voting MVP and the best player always wins regardless of the context. Juan Gonzalez updated path has less than a year, you probably do not deserve based on the understanding of the importance of defense and the driver can not be in the future, the data show that there is an energy field protection underestimated. Or briefly detained elite player batting is also very difficult to play the point? It is not the responsibility of the voter to write the names of the players are better consensus, which is not included in the guide as Dave pointed out that the special importance of the players do not play in leading the team winning. I agree with the vision that Mike Trout is probably the best baseball player and current statistical support, or when the volume (players considered the best player of all time), winning twice, Mickey Mantle won 3 times, Babe Ruth won only one (I know when cheat, I do not know the story) is that crazy people do not search for reasons not to give MIKE a. As a parallel cross sport, Lebron will win 4 Yes or best NBA players for most of the past 10 years.
I mean I am going to keep lobbying for the position of “Who the fuck cares about these stupid awards that are so badly evaluated”. No one can determine who you know is the best player.
I mean I know why fangraphs talks about this, those hot internet clicks, but really if not for that why talk about this at all? It is meaningless.
We all know Trout has been the best player for several years, who cares what the plebs and the writers who love RBIs and WINs think?
This post definitely hits home for me. I haven’t cared about any of these end of the season awards since Mike Trout lost to Miguel Cabrera for MVP
which time? 🙂
If people were really going to take the ‘most valuable’ part seriously, the award would go not to the best player on a good team, but rather to the player who made the most difference in terms of getting his team to the playoffs, which would mean the highest WPA on the Blue Jays or Orioles, which means…Zach Britton.
Uh, no.
If these writers who don’t vote for Trout because he’s not on a winning team and, therefore, not valuable, then why put him on their ballot at all? Seriously. If their criteria is about saying ‘If so and so was really valuable, his team would have a winning record or be in the playoffs’, then it makes no sense to vote for him at all.
There is a reason why being on a winning team or a playoff team isn’t put in the criteria for winning the award, because one man can’t will a baseball team to the playoffs in a 162 game season.
Did its credibility just go up?
Except the person who gave Trout a 7th place vote.
In addition to the guy who had Trout 5th and the other guy who had Ortiz first.
The guy who gave Troui
The guy who gave trout a 7th place vote is John Hickey of the Oakland Tribune/Bay Area. He should lose voting privileges NOW!
Mike Trout wins the MVP!
CREDIBILITY SAVED
They’re credible! They really are! Sort of.
As much as this was 100% wrong, I think the constant “C’mon guys, vote Trout as MVP and quit making excuses” had an impact on the results. Of course this specific article was written AFTER this year’s voting was in the books.
Trout deservedly won MVP
“Twitter is going to be a dumpster fire, even more than usual.”
That’s not possible.
I have always distinguished between best player and MVP. Best player is w/o context. MVP you add context and clutch stats and meaningful games come into play. I sometimes think a leverage index based on how meaningful games are to a teams post season chances would help clear this up.
Its just sad that Trouts 8-10 WAR every year are wasted on a team that just is not very good. Kind of like Ted Williams the last 10 years of his career. On a better team he probably wins 3 more MVP’s in those 10 years
Speaking of clutch stats, look who’s the AL leader in WPA this year….by two whole wins!
http://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=all&stats=bat&lg=al&qual=y&type=3&season=2016&month=0&season1=2016&ind=0&team=0&rost=0&age=0&filter=&players=0
Happy, happy day.
Mike Trout is the 2016 AL MVP. Oops! Congrats to Trout winning his second AL MVP Award. Also, I don’t believe that Trout has surpassed Micky Mantle quite yet. He probably will but he still has some work to do.
Mickey Mantle, best five seasons in fWAR: 51.8
Mike Trout, first five seasons in fWAR: 47.1
Yep, he is still about half a typical Mike Trout season behind.
that’s one way to look at it
mickey mantle 112.3 career fwar would be another.
Thank god you were wrong in the award prediction!!!
Betts arguably was not even the MVP of his team. He also had huge H-A splits with 30 doubles at doubles friendly Fenway and 12 on the road, and he had a rather tepid finish to the season which cost his team the HFA. This is one of the years where the best player should be MVP regardless of team, and the writers got this one right.
Well, anything is arguable I guess. It wouldn’t be a legitimate argument. He WAS the most valuable player on the Red Sox for sure. It wasn’t Ortiz, who only hits (and defense counts, especially great defense like Betts provided), and it wasn’t Pedroia (who, since you mentioned tepid finishes, was even worse than Betts in Sept).
It’s interesting you want to blame Betts for losing HFA though when it’s likely they aren’t even in the running for HFA without him to begin with.
And we’ll try to remember games in April count the same as games in September.
Betts was 2nd in the AL in WAR, Pedroia 13th, Ortiz 22nd. Betts was Red Sox MVP by a landslide.
“. Twitter is going to be a dumpster fire” We just endured a campaign where tweeters were regularly hounded by hate symbols, doxxing, and death threats. I suspect the arguments over Betts vs. Trout will pale by comparison (and thank goodness for that).
Two writers didn’t even have Trout in their top 3. It’s be funny if both came from Tampa Bay (where neither writer had Verlander on THEIR ballot at all).
I actually respect the folks who gave Trout #1 and the person who gave him #7th and have no respect for the people who gave Trout 2nd place. This goes along with Dave’s column a month back about: Just be consistent. If you think Trout playing on a bad team makes him ineligible for 1st, then he is also ineligible for 2nd, 3rd, 4th. That’s why, you gotta hat tip the person who gave him a 7th rank. At least dude is consistent.
Trout is the first player to finish in the top three in MVP voting in each of his first five full seasons in the Major Leagues.
The arc of history is long, but it bends towards justice.
I’m guessing he’s also the first to finish in the top two, also.
Gosh mlb.com is really good for nothing.
… and it appears the baseball gods decided to prank Dave Cameron.
Well, now don’t we feel just a little bit silly?
Time to peel that Betts/Kaine bumper sticker off of your Subaru, Dave!
John Hickey, who used to cover the As and is now based in Seattle, had Beltre 1st and Trout 7th. CLEARLY not taking his voting seriously.
DEWEY DEFEATS TRUMAN
I agree with what Dave is saying (although I really hate the arrogant way he delivers the message), and from statistical measures Trout was the best player in baseball but I don’t think you can go wrong with Trout, Betts, Donaldson, Altuve or Machado. These are all great plays, the margin between them is thin enough that its not a travesty if any of them had beaten out the other. I would also like to point out that I personally find Trout to be kind of vanilla, a boring kind of great and I’m not the first person to have made this statement, I can’t help but to wonder if that plays a part in the voting.
Whoops!
Good to see even a Dave Cameron miss with his predictions once in a while 😉
And congrats to the big dude on his (long overdue) second of many more MVPs.
Funny thing was, the first “network” I saw the results on was Instagram, and 95% on there were “boo, Betts should’ve won”, “boo, Mookie was robbed”, “#notmyALMVP”, “MLB with their Trout bias is trying too hard to make him into the next Jeter” and all that nonsense.
So either people on there are really into trolling, or the fanbase that’s generally populating instagram is far from the one that we see over here.
I especially chuckled at the “Trout bias, next Jeter” thing…seriously, man? Seriously?
Rank BBWAA FanGraphs
1 Mike Trout Mike Trout
2 Mookie Betts Mookie Betts
3 Jose Altuve Josh Donaldson
4 Josh Donaldson Jose Altuve
5 Manny Machado Manny Machado
6 David Ortiz Francisco Lindor
7 Adrian Beltre Adrian Beltre
8 Robinson Cano Adam Eaton
9 Francisco Lindor Robinson Cano
10 Miguel Cabrera Brian Dozier
Good job BBWAA!!
Trout won.
Trout won in a landslide.
Good analysis Dave.
Mike Trout won, so I guess the “electorate has evolved” and we can start to put this debate to bed.
The definition of valuable seems to be dividing the commenters, as well as the baseball world at large. Nobody seems to respect other people’s opinions — no matter what the subject.
Let me argue that Betts would have been entirely worthy of the MVP over Trout even ignoring entirely team performance.
The fact is that both players play out of their natural positions, which tremendously benefits Trout.
Suppose Trout had been added to the Red Sox roster April 1. Bradley would stay in center, Betts in right, and Trout would become the LF (where he belongs). If I understand the positional adjustment formula, that would cost him ten runs, which would reduce his WAR from 9.4 to around 8.4 (if I have those calculations wrong, please let me know).
Now if Betts had been similarly tacked on to the Angel’s roster, he would surely playing center (where he belongs). That would have added the same ten runs and 1.0 WAR to his stats – and now Mookie leads the league with 8.8 WAR, outpacing Trout — even if their actual performance in 2016 had been precisely the same.
On the vast majority of teams, Mookie would be the CF; his bad luck he plays next to Bradley. Trout would be a corner outfielder on most teams. His good luck that he plays for the Angels. That quirk in the calculation of WAR flips their relative contribution because each is forced away from their natural position due to the makeup of the team.
Did you factor into your calculation how much extra value from his defense Trout would have earned and how much value from his defense Betts would lose from such a switch? Surely Trout would save more runs in left field than center and Betts would save fewer runs in center field than right.
Just adding or subtracting positional adjustment while assuming defensive value (and hell, offensive value) would have remained constant is naive.
What is the value of mike trout to the angels? In other words, what were the teams’ accomplishments to which Trout’s talent wereso instrumental in reaching? That’s what I thought… Not my MVP by a long shot. Lindor maybe?
One factor being overlooked on Betts’ resume is how he did against the Red Sox most important competition. The Baltimore Orioles were leading the AL east for most of last season. They were the RS most important rival for the division crown in 2016. How did Betts do in these crucial intradivisional contests? He crushed the birds. Mookie beat Baltimore like a rented mule all season long and single handedly won several of the contests. That will strike some, especially those comfortable with nuance, as very valuable. Maybe even more so than a few dozen BB’s racked up while playing in meaningless games against faceless opponents for a nothing team.
Mike Trout is a great player, no one is denying that, but in 2016 Mookie Betts was better. Trout walked a few more times but struck out, I know it doesn’t matter how you make an out but K’s seldom advance runners so maybe it does, many more times. Betts hit more HR’s, had more RBI’s, I know it is probably because he had more men on base but he batted leadoff for most of the season so that argument doesn’t hold water either, a better steal percentage and ran rings around Trout on defense and the bases. Pre-existing bias is the only reason that Trout should be considered the best player in the AL in 2016.
-Trout led the AL (and the majors) in wRC+ at 171. Betts was 9th in the AL at 135.
-Trout led the AL (and the majors) in OBP and his OBP was 78 points higher than Mookie’s (tied for 10th in AL).
-Trout’s SLG% (4th in the AL) was 16 points higher than Betts (8th in AL).
-Trout’s OPS (2nd in the AL) and was 94 points higher than Betts (8th in AL).
These are big differences. And Trout plays in a pitcher’s park and he plays a premium position. Betts plays a corner spot. Betts shouldn’t get bonus points for being drafted and/or playing on much better team.
it’s football season, y’all