Moving Toward a Unified Theory of the A’s Offseason

Perhaps all of the wheeling and dealing is not over just yet, but seeing as it’s been a few weeks since the Oakland A’s have made a trade, perhaps Billy Beane’s manic winter has wound down to something like a conclusion. Here’s more or less what’s happened so far:

In Out
Taylor Thompson Adam Dunn
Billy Butler Daric Barton
Ike Davis Hiroyuki Nakajima
Franklin Barreto Alberto Callaspo
Kendall Graveman Geovany Soto
Brett Lawrie Jason Hammel
Sean Nolin Jed Lowrie
Joey Wendle Jon Lester
Chris Bassitt Jonny Gomes
Josh Phegley Luke Gregerson
Rangel Ravelo Josh Donaldson
Marcus Semien Kyle Blanks
Mark Canha Brandon Moss
Eury De la Rosa Josh Lindblom
Jesse Hahn Jeff Samardzija
R.J. Alvarez Michael Ynoa
  Austin House
  Derek Norris
  Seth Streich
  Nick Punto

I’ve been a big fan of what Beane has been doing this offseason because, heck, it’s entertaining! Things have been so unpredictable in Oakland that no move would surprise us next. Sometimes proponents of different schools of thought are split when it comes to grading transactions, but this is a rare case of universal bewilderment.

It feels like we’ll only truly understand these moves in hindsight, once some actual games have been played. Will Oakland be positioned as a buyer or as a seller during next July’s trade deadline? Either option seems a viable possibility.

While I could be proven wrong if Oakland rolls out a 70-win season, here’s my best guess as to what it all means: Beane is trying to fill up his roster with as many players who are league average or better (2+ WAR) as he can. That is, Beane would be willing to trade away one star-level player (i.e., Jeff Samardzija) in exchange for two players who project as about league-average (i.e., Marcus Semien and Josh Phegley). As Dave has written about recently, the difference in value between a star player and an average one just might be a lot smaller than we think. Perhaps Oakland is operating under the assumption that a lineup without weak spots totally makes up that gap between star and mere starter.

Let’s look at the 2015 Steamer600 projections for all the players who ended the 2014 season with the A’s, and then all the players who are currently on the Oakland roster. I included everybody who was projected for at least 100 PAs or 30 innings pitched in the majors:

2014 A’s in 2015 WAR600 2015 A’s in 2015 WAR600
Josh Donaldson 5.3 Brett Lawrie 4.2
Josh Reddick 3.4 Josh Reddick 3.4
Jon Lester 3.3 Stephen Vogt 2.7
Brandon Moss 2.9 Sonny Gray 2.6
Stephen Vogt 2.7 Scott Kazmir 2.6
Sonny Gray 2.6 Craig Gentry 2.4
Scott Kazmir 2.6 Ike Davis 2.3
Jeff Samardzija 2.5 Marcus Semien 2.3
Derek Norris 2.5 Coco Crisp 2.1
Craig Gentry 2.4 Josh Phegley 2.0
Jed Lowrie 2.3 Eric Sogard 1.8
Jason Hammel 2.3 John Jaso 1.4
Coco Crisp 2.1 Billy Butler 1.4
Eric Sogard 1.8 Jesse Hahn 1.2
Geovany Soto 1.7 Jarrod Parker 1.2
John Jaso 1.4 Sam Fuld 1.1
Kyle Blanks 1.3 Nate Freiman 1.0
Jarrod Parker 1.2 A.J. Griffin 1.0
Sam Fuld 1.1 Sean Doolittle 1.0
Nate Freiman 1.0 Andy Parrino 0.8
A.J. Griffin 1.0 Ryan Cook 0.5
Sean Doolittle 1.0 Eric O’Flaherty 0.4
Alberto Callaspo 0.9 Fernando Abad 0.3
Andy Parrino 0.8 R.J. Alvarez 0.3
Adam Dunn 0.6 Evan Scribner 0.3
Ryan Cook 0.5 Dan Otero 0.2
Nick Punto 0.5 Jesse Chavez -0.1
Eric O’Flaherty 0.4 Drew Pomeranz -0.1
Luke Gregerson 0.4 Sean Nolin -0.1
Fernando Abad 0.3 Eury de la Rosa -0.3
Evan Scribner 0.3 Chris Bassitt -0.4
Dan Otero 0.2    
Jonny Gomes 0.2    
Jesse Chavez -0.1    
Drew Pomeranz -0.1    

So if the A’s returned their exact same lineup for 2015, they would have 13 players who are projected to produce at least 2 WAR over the course of a full season of playoff time. With the lineup the A’s actually have, they now have 10 such players.

Obviously 13 is a larger number than 10. But consider: the A’s end-season roster from last year was the result of some very expensive trade-deadline moves. Lester, Samardzija, and Hammel were purchased at a high price, with both Lester and Hammel due to become free agents at the end of last season. For all of the big names they’ve traded away this offseason, it’s remarkable, then, that the A’s have ended up with almost the same number of average-or-better players they had before their trade deadline action. (Yoenis Cespedes, traded for Lester, was another projected average-or-better player on Oakland’s roster last year.)

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage

This is actually a pretty unique piece of roster construction. The Seattle Mariners, which FanGraphs currently projects as having the second-best record in 2015, only have eight average-or-better players (Robinson Cano, Kyle Seager, Brad Miller, Mike Zunino, Chris Taylor, Austin Jackson, Felix Hernandez, Hisashi Iwakuma). The Angels, projected to finish two games better than the A’s, also have eight (Mike Trout, Erick Aybar, Albert Pujols, Kole Calhoun, Chris Iannetta, David Freese, Garrett Richards, Tyler Skaggs). After pushing so many chips in the middle of the table this winter, the White Sox have all of six (Jose Abreu, Alexei Ramirez, Adam Eaton, Chris Sale, Samardzija, Jose Quintana).

Projected to have the league’s best record, the Dodgers have an impressive 13 of these players (Yasiel Puig, Adrian Gonzalez, Juan Uribe, Howie Kendrick, Jimmy Rollins, Yasmani Grandal, Joc Pederson, Carl Crawford, A.J. Ellis, Clayton Kershaw, Zack Greinke, Brandon McCarthy, Hyun-Jin Ryu). The main difference being that the Dodgers will spend about four times as much on their team in 2015 as the A’s will.

By acquiring league-average players in addition to intriguing prospects, Beane just might be giving himself his best possible chance at fulfilling the intrinsically opposite goals of (1) cutting payroll and (2) remaining in contention. On Opening Day last year, the A’s had a payroll that was about 130% the size of their payroll a year previous, and about 160% the size of the payroll the year before that. If reducing payroll was the A’s top priority heading into the winter, well, Beane has definitely made lemonade out of lemons here.

Or, shoot, maybe he’s just rebuilding.





Miles Wray contributes sports commentary to McSweeney's Internet Tendency, Ploughshares, The Classical and Hardwood Paroxysm. Follow him on Twitter @mileswray or email him here.

104 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
DrBGiantsfan
11 years ago

You could have saved yourself several hundred words and just written the last sentence.

Ryan
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

They’re rebuilding. They went all in last year and want to accelerate the process so they can be good again ASAP.

Sandy Kazmir
11 years ago
Reply to  Ryan

Except they still have the talent to compete today. One of 2B/SS looks like it could be a problem, but every other position should produce 2-3 WAR if not more. The rotation is top heavy, but with the sheer number of warm bodies following Gray/Kazmir/Hahn you can be sure that someone will differentiate or Beane will bring in a guy that can.

The second wild card makes the impossible of playing for today and tomorrow a bit more achievable. Build an 85 win team in the offseason, if you catch some breaks early with health and performance then you’re in a position to acquire a player or three and if things don’t break well you have the agility to spin off a player of three so that next year might have an even better chance.

The Rays are doing this same thing quite well. Stock every position with a 2-3 expectation, hope your one star plays well, catch some breaks. The Rays built their best team on paper last year in a long time and had everything go against them early and often. Diversifying your talent in this manner means that you don’t have to be “all in” or “rebuilding” or whatever overly simplistic word you want to use. They have a chance to compete this year and over the next several years. The Rays and A’s know what they’re doing.

channelclemente
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

Ain’t it the truth. God forbid they admit Beane is collecting the vig on his 5% ownership stake in the A’s.

Jen
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

No he could have saved time by waiting until Sat when everything changed! The A’s are NOT rebuilding – if they were why would they have signed Billy Butler to $10 million for 3 years making him the 3rd highest player on the team after Kazmir and Coco if Billy intended on rebuilding … the A’s have a great rotation which will only get better with the additions of Parker and Griffin who will be back from Tommy John surgery soon, the bullpen is solid and now they have enough versatility that they could mix and match players/positions – in the event that they wanted to they could have an entire left-handed or right -handed lineup … Bo Mel has so much to work with esp with the additions of Escobar and esp. Zobrist (who’s ranked 4th in the AL in WAR since he led the league in 2011 – behind only Trout, Cabrera and Cano!) They A’s will compete and if Saturdays trade doesn’t spell out they are NOT rebuilding then you’re crazy!! Just saying!!

Fangraphs Writer
11 years ago

Woah looks like it’s been 2 weeks or so since someone has talked about the A’s! Better write an article tryna provide justification for Billy Beane’s offseason moves *type type type*

Josh I
11 years ago

Or maybe it’s an interesting post trying to decipher a team’s interesting offseason. If the Tigers did this exact thing, there would be a post like this analyzing that as well.

BaseballGuy
11 years ago
Reply to  Josh I

Ha! Nope. There’s a lot of investment among sabre-types in the A’s being smart.

metsican
11 years ago
Reply to  BaseballGuy

Not really, no. Every team in the game is conducting some for of statistical analysis.

Bobby Ayala
11 years ago
Reply to  BaseballGuy

metsican wins “Sentence of the Day” some for of this one.

Richie
11 years ago
Reply to  BaseballGuy

No, I don’t think ‘doing nothing for 2 weeks’ typically brings out any “OK let’s sum up now” articles. Sabre fans are fascinated by Beane, and web sites need to post articles. Nothing wrong with giving your audience what they want. Basis of capitalism, actually.

Jeff in Alameda
11 years ago
Reply to  BaseballGuy

Comments like this miss the point. Sabre-types use data to find new insights on the game. The A’s have been at the forefront of using data to find exploitable advantages, allowing them to field competitive teams at far lower costs than the competition for more than two decades. Its rational to assume , that if said team is behaving in a way that perplexes most analysts, there is a new type of exploitable data model that they’re using to continue to execute their stragegy. Sussing out what that model could be is kind of what Fangraphs is all about dude.

Yirmiyahu
11 years ago
Reply to  BaseballGuy

Then why are most sabre-types criticizing all the A’s bewildering moves this offseason?

You can argue that Fangraphs examines Billy Beane’s moves more closely because of his sabermetric reputation. But in this case, it’s just a matter of the fact that Beane has made a lot of interesting/confusing moves (same goes for the Padres this offseason). The analysis of the A’s (including this one) hasn’t really been for or against; it’s really just trying to figure out what the hell is going on in Oakland.

FMelius
11 years ago
Reply to  BaseballGuy

Quoting Mestician: “Not really, no. Every team in the game is conducting some for of statistical analysis.”

…well, except for the Twins…

Sandy Kazmir
11 years ago
Reply to  BaseballGuy

Agree with Jeff, you could do a lot worse than drafting off the A’s to get an idea of what some new potential competitive advantages might be. I’d rather look at what they’re doing than spend more than three minutes thinking about a team signing Volquez, Rios and Morales after adding what’s probably something like $50M in playoff revenue to their owner’s pocket.

Jen
11 years ago

No he could have saved time by waiting until Sat when everything changed! The A’s are NOT rebuilding – if they were why would they have signed Billy Butler to $10 million for 3 years making him the 3rd highest player on the team after Kazmir and Coco if Billy intended on rebuilding … the A’s have a great rotation which will only get better with the additions of Parker and Griffin who will be back from Tommy John surgery soon, the bullpen is solid and now they have enough versatility that they could mix and match players/positions – in the event that they wanted to they could have an entire left-handed or right -handed lineup … Bo Mel has so much to work with esp with the additions of Escobar and esp. Zobrist (who’s ranked 4th in the AL in WAR since he led the league in 2011 – behind only Trout, Cabrera and Cano!) They A’s will compete and if Saturdays trade doesn’t spell out they are NOT rebuilding then you’re crazy!! Just saying!!

fm
11 years ago

Never doubt what Beane has up his sleeve

DrBGiantsfan
11 years ago
Reply to  fm

There is no doubt. It is quite obvious that he blew up the team and is rebuilding.

Richie
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

Now this getting massively minused is proof that there are a whole lot of Beane fetishes here.

Walter
11 years ago
Reply to  Richie

DrBGiantsfan probably misuses lots of stuff, including his brain.

arc
11 years ago
Reply to  Richie

Derp. It’s proof that there is a deep bias against conclusory statements – as there should be.

channelclemente
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

Maybe Beane’s been beatified unbeknownst to the rest of the baseball world, or they’re just taking money out of the A’s before they go back on the dole.

Ben Zobrist Trade
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

*insert Nelson Muntz picture here*

HA HA!

Walter
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

I guess that’s why Beane just added Zorbist and Escobar….

Mark Williamson
11 years ago

I don’t think we should ever deal in absolutes. I think the ideas of “they’re a team who is definitely rebuilding” or “they’re going all-in for the WS” are too black and white. I agree with the author in that there is a greater purpose to what the A’s are doing, why would you ship out star players when you clearly still have a shot of the playoffs with said players? Is it not reasonable that this team has become too expensive and that a cheaper compilation of talent can be put on the field and preform similarly? We don’t know exactly how the base all operations of any club work so trying to present different hypotheses and look at the situation from different angles is very helpful. Overall an intriguing read which I enjoyed.

DrBGiantsfan
11 years ago

Why would you ship out star players when you clearly have a shot of the playoffs? Because Billy Beane is a restless, impetuous GM with an itchy trade finger. That’s why!

Look, Billy Beane has all but said himself this is a rebuild. I don’t know why people keep trying to spin it as something else when Billy himself is not doing that.

Mark Williamson
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

If this is a rebuild why trade for Ike Davis? Sign Billy Butler? The A’s have a good bit of pitching coming back this year. If they were rebuilding wouldn’t it make sense wait and get better deals via draft pick compensation or deadline trades?

I think that the players Beane has acquired, Lawrie, Semien, Butler, and Davis are who, we could both agree, part of a mediocre group that doesn’t exactly scream WS competition. I just don’t think we should be so dismissive of the moves he’s made as being strictly a rebuild because we don’t know how the A’s as an organization think.

Look at the Royals, with the exception of Alex Gordon, a lot of Royals players finished 2013 close to replacement level, but they improved the following year. Now I know Oakland doesn’t have the same pitching as Kansas, and this is a poor example, but I think there’s more to these moves than meets the eye.

rjbiii
11 years ago

I think this is more about 2016 than 2015. Those pitchers will be fully back by then, and some of the older minor league players they’re brought in will have had a chance to establish themselves. The A’s still still be competitive thus year, though lies then before they reshuffled. In 2016 that team would’ve been to expensive however. So these modes allow them to keep the window open longer.

Brad
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

I think that you are one of those interesting people who are scared that the world loses something precious and irreplaceable if they are wrong for once. Why do you need to post your opinion a hundred different times in a hundred different ways? We get it. You think Beane’s plan is a rebuild. Please don’t bludgeon us with it and act as if no one can possibly entertain a well-developed contrary hypothesis. Sheesh.

arc
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

. This is fun!

arc
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

Hahahah. As if you didn’t look like a big enough idiot before, now the A’s acquire Zobrist.

“Cleeeaarly a rebuild! You guys are so biased!”

Pale Hose
11 years ago

With 16 players in and 20 players out, it is definitely a rebuild. It doesn’t look like the type of project that usually gets the “rebuild” tag. The A’s are not doing what the Cubs and Astros did, and they should still field decent teams.

Mark Williamson
11 years ago
Reply to  Pale Hose

I agree, but I think people are so entrenched in the ideological “rebuild” that they think anything where you trade off a few good players is the sign of a sinking ship when it doesn’t have to be.

DrBGiantsfan
11 years ago

The author started out with the hypothesis that Billy traded top talent for depth, then put up side-by-side rosters with projections that proved that he ended up bereft of top talent AND the team is less deep! How is that not a rebuild?

Mark Williamson
11 years ago

I’ll admit, DrBGiantsfan, that he did trade away talent and the team is less deep, but at the same time there were departing free agents who were never coming back and the Butler signing and Davis and Lawrie trades are confusing.

I’m not saying Beane think he can get the exact same results by losing players like Donaldson, and Samardzija, but maybe they were expendable to a team like the A’s, I don’t know.

I also think you’re forgetting that the “loss of depth” you keep referring to is due to nine players that became free agents at the end of the season. Four of those nine players are those who signed for more money than I personally think the A’s were going to dish out anyway.

Walter
11 years ago

They also lost Lowrie because he is FA, you know the SS, not the guy from Toronto, in that 2+ WAR group.

So Lester, Hammel, Lowrie makes 3. 13-10 = 3. Now they did sign Davis and Buttler, but only Davis is projected for +2 WAR.

Also, the Moss projection is ignorant of his hip problems. Moss himself has said he’s not going to 100% in spring training and still recovering. Expecting a career high WAR from him seems foolish in light of that (though of course I don’t blame Steamer). So, I’d really remove Moss from the 2+ WAR list if Beane had left the 2014 roster alone. That would make 12 for 2014, 3 leaving for FA, makes 9. Now they have 10. Seems like there really is more depth to me once we think a little harder about this.

And the depth isn’t just for 2015, nor is it just for 2+ WAR players. Ie. Hahn, Nolin and Graveman now make for some great SP depth for the 4-5 spots in the rotation, but none of them are projected for much WAR, and they should be good pieces for 2016 and beyond. Shark wasn’t going to be that. Keeping this analysis to 2015 biases yourself towards determining that what Beane did was bad.

I guess we can get into semantics, but to make an analogy, this isn’t a tear-it-down to the foundation, go move in with your bother, rebuild of the house, its more like the live-in, rip out your kitchen and bathroom, while you put in a new counters, sinks, and cabinets rebuild. One word used among A’s fans and the A’s FO is “retool” to try to make that distinction.

Umberto
11 years ago

Part of it stems from the binary that we established prior to the institution of the second wild card and 1/3 of the league making the playoffs; also prior to the overhaul of young talent acquisition. There was a time when “windows” meant more than they did now, and when mediocrity wasn’t something to shoot for. But if you can build for the future *and* make a run at the WC at the same time, e.g. by doing what Beane did here, we don’t exactly have a word for it.

Walter
11 years ago
Reply to  Umberto

So lets make one up. How about we call it “pulling a DrB”.

David Letterman List Generator
11 years ago
Reply to  Umberto

I agree that we should find a good term for it. Some possible candidates:
10. Half-in (as opposed to all in)
9. Half-assing it
8. Playing the small blind
7. Asymmetric WAR-fare
6. Scratch ticket rosters
5. Team adolescence
4. Raging Bullish (coulda been a contenda)
3. Right foot in (ala Hokey Pokey)
2. Just the tip (no comment)
1. and…. (drum roll) Beane-Ball!

stonepie
11 years ago

he’s doing all 3 at once essentially: cutting payroll, remaining in contention, and rebuilding.

DrBGiantsfan
11 years ago
Reply to  stonepie

Except for the remaining in contention part.

Josh I
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

Dude, get a life.

That’s like your fourth comment you’ve posted so far bashing the A’s, or at least saying they’re rebuilding. Which they aren’t, or else why do they sign Billy Butler? Why trade Donaldson for Lawrie (who has LESS team control than JD)? Why not replace Lawrie with Pompey or Stroman or Norris, or talk to Boston about Betts? This isn’t a full rebuild. They’re getting younger, while also giving themselves a chance to contend. Which is pretty much exactly what the author wrote, if you even read the article.

DrBGiantsfan
11 years ago
Reply to  Josh I

Dude! Look at the rosters and projections the author himself put up. Billy did not trade top end talent for present depth. He traded for future talent. The team is less talented now and less deep. How is that not a rebuild?

CM52
11 years ago
Reply to  Josh I

Yeah, Fangraphs/Steamer projections have them remaining in contention, which was the original point. Of course they lost some present value when adding youth and years of control, but to suggest they’re not competitive is retarded. Fail, troll.

Walter
11 years ago
Reply to  Josh I

“Billy did not trade top end talent for present depth. He traded for future talent. “

He traded for both you dolt.

Observer
11 years ago
Reply to  DrBGiantsfan

You continue to use an unnecessary “r” in your name.

jdbolickMember since 2016
11 years ago

The Butler contract continues to make no sense.

Billy Butler
11 years ago
Reply to  jdbolick

Just wait until I hit the hardest grounder ever recorded.

Matt Holliday
11 years ago
Reply to  Billy Butler

Yep, it’s on. LET’S DO THIS!!!!

RichW
11 years ago
Reply to  Billy Butler

For a 9-3 putout?

tz
11 years ago

Or maybe this is just what a small-market team does during an off-season where the free-agent market is so thin. Especially when all three of the teams behind them in the division are poised to improve in 2015.

Mayton Door
11 years ago
Reply to  tz

Exactly! You sign Billy Butler to a 3 year deal.

Pirates Hurdles
11 years ago

I’ll take the under on Lawrie at 4.2 and Ike at 2.3.

Its hard to reconcile your premise that he is trying to get as many league average players as possible, when his moves have resulted in less of such players. More strainin’ to explanin’.

Josh I
11 years ago

Except that he lost those three players (Hammel, Lester, Lowrie) to free agency, and had no reat chance (or desire) to get them back.

Pirates Hurdles
11 years ago
Reply to  Josh I

He could have signed Lowrie or Hammel had he chose too (not that he should have), Lester was the only out of range FA. The bottom line is that no one here has made a compelling case for what Beane is doing. It isn’t purely small market years of control stuff and it certainly isn’t reloading for a run in 2015. The seemingly randomness of the moves likely only fits the plan Beane has which we are not privy to.

Costanza
11 years ago

I think this sentence sums up why people are confused:

> It isn’t purely small market years of control stuff and it certainly isn’t reloading for a run in 2015

Narratives are simpler when they fit a preconceived bucket, makes it easier for our (lazy!) brains to process. When someone doesn’t fit those patterns, it makes our lizard brain hurt. This explains why some commenters feel the need to express their counter-opinion so frequently: they’re shouting as if in some psychic pain because the reality doesn’t fit their categories.

frodd tazier
11 years ago

not that billy beane is not mystifying (he is) and not that i don’t like to read about the a’s (i do), but i’d love to see how many clicks/responses/hatemail you guys get on a’s articles vs. non a’s articles.

free idea: a website called fangraphsgraphs that monitors fangraphs click metrics

Alex K
11 years ago
Reply to  frodd tazier

You mean Clickgraphs…

Jake
11 years ago
Reply to  frodd tazier

Instead, how about a website called NotGraphs that provides “a place to put things that would otherwise not have a place on FanGraphs, that we find interesting and we think you would also find interesting”.

Fangraphs click metrics could fall under that description.

#ReviveNotGraphs

Man Down Hatch
11 years ago

The White Sox have Robertson…not 2+ WAR?

witesoxfan
11 years ago
Reply to  Man Down Hatch

Projected for 1 WAR. He’s a good reliever, but relievers’ values are inherently lower due to the limited number of innings they throw.

I’d call it 7 average or better players as Melky Cabrera is projected for 1.7-1.8 WAR, and that’s close enough to 2 for me to round up, but I’m a homer.

Steve
11 years ago
Reply to  witesoxfan

Then we should probably have a different definition of “average” for relievers. I am probably being pedantic, but David Robertson is certain above average at his chosen position.

Jason B
11 years ago
Reply to  Steve

2 WAR is by no means average for a reliever, not to worry. A 2 WAR season for an RP is an outstanding season.

oh Hal
11 years ago

He “definitely” made lemonade? You better take a sip. That yellow liquid might be something else.

Shingo's Cheeseburgers
11 years ago

Sometimes you just have to hope that when you plant magic beanes they will bear productive fruits.

Old Man
11 years ago

And to think, I traded them for a cow.

Kirk
11 years ago

That’s a pretty week group of 2 WAR players. Half of them probably get <1 WAR. This is not a great team and will be lucky to be .500.

Pirates Hurdles
11 years ago
Reply to  Kirk

Steamer seems to irrationally love their offense, maybe its the magic A’s power boost, hard to tell why. Zips had much more realistic numbers IMO –
http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/2015-zips-projections-oakland-athletics/
Those point to a team in the high 70s in wins.

Bobby Ayala
11 years ago

Steamer is a poor projection system. Articles justifying moves and projecting team wins based on Steamer Projections should be taken with a shaker of salt.

arc
11 years ago
Reply to  Bobby Ayala

Unlike your conclusory statements, which should be accepted as is.

tjrl
11 years ago

Zips looks more realistic because the author is using Steamer600 projections. Steamer does not see Phegley or Gentry as 2 win players.

Joshua_C
11 years ago
Reply to  tjrl

Bobby Ayala: Most empirical investigations include that Steamer is, in fact, quite solid, and that ZiPS has a minimal advantage, if one exists.

TheVerbalFan
11 years ago

I don’t think that Fangraphs has any particular bias for Billy Beane as such. I think he just does something different, consistently, and that’s why he gets covered.

That said, I wish Notgraphs was still around, because it would be funny to see an Onion-style farce about this.

“Billy Beane Goes on Deranged Rampage with Baseball Bat.”
Critics: ‘Psychotic violence is clearly the new market inefficiency.’

Pirates Hurdles
11 years ago
Reply to  TheVerbalFan

“Something different” has equaled something not very smart by our preconceived notions here. Trading Russell for anything in his market situation was crazy by our value standards as was signing Butler and trading Donaldson. Thus we get 15 articles trying very hard to tell us why Beane is testing our ideas of smart and dumb.

TheVerbalFan
11 years ago

I make no value judgment about his moves. Or at least I won’t until they don’t pan out at which point I will say that I did make a value judgement in the past, for which I was vindicated. Actually, I’ll do that no matter the outcome.

Joshua_C
11 years ago

I wish we could simply entertain these two concepts simultaneously:

~By our current methods of analysis, Beane’s moves have been rather poor, starting with the Russell trade. If, say, RAJ made them, we’d be mocking him relentlessly.

~Beane presumably had a reason for making the moves, and it’s quite possible that he simply has access to/uses data that we don’t.

I hate several of the moves he’s made (Butler, Russell, Lester, etc). But I think it’s still interesting to try and figure out what he might be doing while acknowledging that by our current methods of analysis it doesn’t look particularly smart.

Chris
11 years ago

There’s a little bit of arbitrary end points (understandably) here when comparing them to the Mariners and Angels though.

For instance, if you put the cut-off at 1.7 WAR, then the Angels have 10 players meeting that criteria, A’s – 11, and Mariners – 12 (not including Hultzen who Steamer has for 1.9)

If the cut-off is a little lower at 1.4, then the Angels have 14 players, A’s – 13, and Mariners – 16.

Costanza
11 years ago
Reply to  Chris

This is very interesting — I wonder what the distributions look like and how they correlate to overall team WAR when “counting X WAR players”.

DrB Giants fan
11 years ago

Has anyone read the torture report?

Jason B
11 years ago
Reply to  DrB Giants fan

Yes, we saw all of your earlier posts…

Mark Gray
11 years ago

Generally, Beane traded players on the wrong side of the age curve for players on the right side of the age curve. Any of these young players could easily outperform their projections; the risk is higher variance, but I think that’s necessary when you reduce payroll.

mettle
11 years ago
Reply to  Mark Gray

Is that actually true? What are the average ages for these two (’14 v. ’15) rosters?

I am Sam
11 years ago
Reply to  mettle

Well of the players we are mostly talking about that Beane traded or lost to FA their 2015 ages will be:

Moss: 31
Donaldson: 29
Shark: 30
Lowrie: 31
Lester: 31
Hammel: 32

But there are others:

Dunn: 35
Callaspo: 32
Soto: 32
Gomes: 34
Puntu: 37

Now the pieces he got (leaving out the prospects that are fairly far way and almost certainly won’t play for the A’s in 2015, which might be right or wrong for this but so goes):

Butler: 29
Davis: 28
Graveman: 24
Lawrie: 25
Nolin: 25
Bassit : 26
Phegley: 27
Semien: 24
Hahn: 25
Wedle (a maybe for 2015): 25

Its pretty hard to see how the 2015 A’s aren’t younger than the 2014 A’s would be in 2015 without the moves.

Antonio Bananas
11 years ago

It’s a reload. Not a rebuild. They won’t be much worse. Just presumably younger. He’s sacrifice being a little worse in 2015 to be a lot better 2016-2020.

AF
11 years ago

If the theory is that Beane’s goal was to maximize 2 WAR players *in 2015* (for a given payroll), it isn’t supported by the evidence. The A’s only gained three new 2-WAR players: Davis, Semien, and Phegley. Davis was claimed off waivers and Semien and Phegley were picked up in the Samardzija. None of the other transactions — the Butler signing, the Donaldson trade, the Moss trade, etc. — yielded any 2-WAR players for 2015. Nor did they free payroll for the acquisition of cheaper 2-WAR players. They could have had just as many 2015 2-WAR players, and approximately the same payroll, just by standing pat, or at any rate doing a lot less reshuffling than they did.

I think your real argument is that the players the A’s acquired — both prospects and young MLers — included a lot of potential (not necessarily 2015) 2-WAR players, rather than a smaller number of potential stars. This is a plausible argument, but: (1) it isn’t supported by your 2015 projections tables, which seem beside the point, and (2) more importantly, it can’t really be contrasted with the theory that Beane was just rebuilding. He definitely is rebuilding; he just seems to be rebuilding based on quantity rather than quality.

AF
11 years ago
Reply to  AF

To clarify, I recognize A’s picked up Lawrie as well, who is also a 2-WAR player, but they gave up Donaldson for him, so that was a wash in terms of the number of 2-WAR players they have returning for 2015.

BenRevereDoesSteroids
11 years ago

“Beane is trying to fill up his roster with as many players who are league average or better (2+ WAR) as he can.”

And also Billy Butler, Ike Davis, Taylor Thompson, Josh Phegley, and Sean Nolin.

Al Avila
11 years ago

Of the 10 Oakland players with a projected WAR >2 for the 2015 season, 3 have yet to do so in any MLB season.

The 7 remaining players combined for 23 MLB seasons > 2 WAR, with Kazmir & Crisp accounting for a combined 14 of those.

What you’re left with is 5 players who have achieved on average only 2 MLB seasons > 2 WAR. My point, predictions in January are just that… Come September the number of players > 2 WAR could be closer to 12/13… or more likely 6/7.

Semantic Pedantic
11 years ago

What’s with all the hair-splitting over ‘rebuilding’, ‘retooling’, ‘upgrading’ and the like? Last I checked, ‘Wins’ were pretty important, and Beane’s teams have a fair record of compiling those over the last decade. Roster construction can take myriad forms, and this weird groupthink desire for handy pigeonholing is getting absurd.

I think what DrB and these other obnoxiously repetitive sports-radio polemicist guys are struggling with is that the business of baseball has evolved a bit more quickly than their ability to adapt to the ongoing changes. It’s not quite grandpa fumbling with a smartphone, but it’s beginning to smell alot like that around here.

Buck Rotgut
11 years ago

Well said.

A sighting!
11 years ago

We have a “push the chips into the middle of the table” reference!

Dale
11 years ago

I think billy seen that he can’t win with the players he had I think he wanted to shake it up and I believe he has a big trade coming for tulo and Allen Craig while signing olive from Cuba to play 2nd in beane we trust

Pat
11 years ago

The problem I see in comparing the 2014 WARs from the projected 2015 WARs is that 3 of the top 10, including the top 2 (Lawrie, Reddick, Crisp) have rarely, if ever, shown an ability to be healthy enough to reach 600 at bats. If you take about 200 at bats from each their WAR, and the A’s as a whole, appears a lot less impressive.

mlbfan23
11 years ago

the moss trade was puzzling, 7 mill injury risk is not that much and joe wendle, i wouldve liked to get more.
im skeprtical on lawrie’s health.
i liked the norris trade if hahn can turned into a #2/3 type. Stuff wise he’s the best of all the poitchers they acquired.
i dont see the point of keeping jaso, kazmir, cook, o’flaherty, they couldve save at least 20 mill if traded

Walter
11 years ago
Reply to  mlbfan23

If things go south early in the season, Jaso, Kazmir and Cook can all still be traded. Beane can take a look at what he’s got for a couple months before committing to a full out rebuild.

bjoakMember since 2020
11 years ago

If you don’t like the A’s moves, here’s a good standard for whether you’re being objective and smart about this: Were you on Fangraphs talking about how great the A’s offseason moves were in 2011/12 (before trading Gio Gonzalez, et al. and then subsequently making the playoffs for the first time since 2006)? It’s somehow hard to imagine Drb was here celebrating the ingenuity of the A’s at that time, though if he or anyone else can point us to their Pro A’s posts I’ll only be too happy to quit unliking poorly thought out comments.

Darius
11 years ago

Will be interesting to see how the saber metric community reacts to this when the A’s are terrible next year.

What the Royals go to game 7 with the worst walk and home run rate in baseball and now the A’s are terrible?

Time to put down the math books boys.

Billy Beane
11 years ago

Gotcha! I just traded for Zobrist and Yunel Escobar.

Fooled you, didn’t I?

Sandy Kazmir
11 years ago

LOL

Jon
11 years ago

Dear “Fangraphs writer” and “DrBGiantsfan,”

You’re both limited intellects. I don’t have to know either of you personally to know this. How? You knee jerkedly bash Beane and the A’s, and the attention they get.

Why do they get attention? Because in MLB, the ONE major US sport with VASTLY differing monies spent in forming a team, the A’s under Beane for 15 years have made the playoffs, in the much tougher AL, 8 times.

That is a great underdog story, and is why so many people RIGHTFULLY praise Beane’s A’s.

But here’s where you two neanderthals (and SOOOO many others who “think” like you) go wrong. Correct me if i’m wrong, but you two bozos actually don’t buy the fact the playoffs are a crapshoot, you underacknowledge the huge monetary differences teams like The A’s under Beane face, amirite?

You two likely think something that boils down to “Beane and the A’s haven’t won it all!!” Well, what can us reasonable minds say to that? It’s not incorrect, but….it just fails SO COMPLETELY to understand the bigger picture.

Has Beane or has he not formed many different playoff teams despite WAY less money than most winners? Yes, and in the AL all this time. So, the man is somehow getting TO the playoffs despite this huge disadvantage, yet because once there his ragtag bunch of no-names fail, you somehow blame Beane?!! Why? Why the lack of intelligence there? Why the visceral hatred of Beane?

Is it simply because you kneejerkedly hate anyone getting a lot of publicity for overcoming great odds (when you obviously think, somehow, that he does not….simply because in the crapshoot of the playoffs his teams, not him, his teams fall short?

What is a GM supposed to do? Beane has formed power and pitching teams, he’s formed speed and D with pitching teams. He’s made the playoffs 8 times with differing teams. Sometimes even the underdog gets bad luck, or at least doesn’t get good luck.

In at least 6 out of those 8 playoff years for Beane, the A’s lost the first round 5 game series (each one went the full 5 games pointing out moreso that they were never just blown out, always came down to a play or two) due to some incredibly rare dumb boneheaded move by Byrnes, Tejada, Je Giambi, Crisp dropping pop up, etc. How is Beane responsible for that? Really, i’m waiting for your lack of logic answer….

For ANY GM the amount of times Beane’s made the playoffs is impressive, let alone a GM GM-ing from such a built in disadvantage.

I won’t say it was all just bad luck in the playoffs for Beane’s A’s, but they sure didn’t get lucky. Last year he gets Lester who until that KC playoff game had the 3rd best all time playoff ERA. The Byrnes, Giambi, Tejada, Crisp plays as well. What was Beane supposed to do about those plays that largely is why the A’s rarely got out of the 1st round? Those are the bargain players he used to get to the playoffs in the first place, is he supposed to have some magic elixir to know ahead of time and not play them that game when they got him there?

I won’t say the Giants got only lucky to win three, but they sure as hell didn’t get unlucky. Their timing was amazingly good. None of those champ teams of the Giants were particularly great. Each time they just got hot at the right time, and the exact opposite is true of Beane’s teams, and then now the pressure from past losses is hurting them too i feel.

But there is no way you can blame a GM who gets his teams in position to win it all SO OFTEN, especially when he’s one of the GMs with WAY less money to spend on his team.

It’s headshakingly, poignantly pathetic how many people think like you two.

here goes nothing
11 years ago

As of today, I think we can put this whole “the A’s are rebuilding” thing behind us. #Zorilla #YouKnow #YuNel

La Dee Da
11 years ago

Seems the lesson here is that the time to develop a unifying theory of the A’s offseason would be at the end of the offseason. Not in early January when the A’s projected payroll sits approximately $20M under where it is likely to be in early August.

Prior to the Zobrist trade, the A’s 25-man roster was projected at about $62M (with another $2.75M going to Punto). The A’s had revenues in the $170-180M range last year (per Forbes), and they set payroll at around 50% of revenues. That left Beane with about $20M of money to play with before this article was written (or about a quarter of his projected payroll). Beane’s probably still not done. He’s still got money to play with, and he could still trade pieces to create more salary wiggle room (before or during the season). Beane is like water; try to figure what he’s doing at any moment and he’s already changed direction.

Kimbo
11 years ago
Reply to  La Dee Da

What the hell kinda water you lookin at

Cable Finished
11 years ago
Reply to  La Dee Da

Seems the lesson here is that DrBGriantsfan is not only a spammer but incredibly biased about a rival.

And stupid.