They Got Rid of One Measly Off Day, But the Playoffs Still Need to Be Improved
Baseball’s playoffs stretch on far longer than they ought, into the sleet and snow of November. Major League Baseball finally has begun to admit its problems and to address them. In this fall’s League Championship Series, there will no longer be an off day between games four and five, thanks in part to Mike Scoscia’s complaints a few months before. “The removal of the off-day during both League Championship Series,” said Bud Selig, “marks the first step in a process that will ultimately result in an improved postseason format for our game.” In other words: the format isn’t quite improved just yet. I tend to agree.
It was not a day that made sense to have off, considering that it was not a travel day, and a scheduled travel off day occurs after the fifth game anyway. It’s good that it’s gone, and that particular series will have greater continuity. But the monthlong playoffs have not been shortened. Even a fan of the team that won it all last year, Benjamin Kabak of River Ave Blues, complains: “The truth is that the Yanks played 15 games over 30 days in October, and that stop-and-start schedule disrupted the flow of the games.” Yankee fans join players and managers like Mike Scoscia in their general dissatisfaction with the present state of affairs.
The reason, of course, is the same as always: television revenue. As Tyler Kepner of the New York Times writes: “The World Series is still scheduled to start Wednesday, Oct. 27, because Fox wants only one scheduled weekend, not two, and does not want to broadcast a game on Friday night.” In other words, if baseball is serious about “an improved postseason format,” they’ll have to ruffle Fox’s feathers. Thanks to its share of a $3 billion deal signed in 2006, Fox retains exclusive control of the World Series through 2013, and will split the rest of the postseason with TBS for the rest of that timeframe. It’s hard to imagine that MLB will reduce the number of days in the playoffs while that deal is still in effect.
However, change is necessary, particularly since Selig is serious about regularly holding the World Baseball Classic. Because baseball is an outdoor sport, and the baseball season stretches from spring training in February to the World Series in November, there’s really no healthy time to hold the WBC. Shaving a few extra days off the playoffs would permit far greater leeway to hold the Classic before or after the regular season.
But the Classic only occurs every four years. The most compelling reason for change is the simplest: the playoff format is widely recognized to be flawed, and even the Commissioner of Baseball recognizes that his sport needs “an improved postseason format.” Seldom is there an issue on which everyone agrees, as they do on the need to fix the playoff schedule. That rare fact ought to lead to action.
Alex is a writer for The Hardball Times.


FWIW, Japan and Korea usually wind up their postseasons within a couple of weeks of MLB. Then winter ball starts, and the Serie del Caribe usually ends within a couple of weeks of spring training.
If they were to play the WBC after the season, I don’t know if the players of MLB, NPB and KBO would be up to it. I don’t know how the winter leagues in VZ, DR, MX and PR would be affected either.
As for the playoff format, as long as there are 3 rounds, the risk of playing baseball in November looms. I don’t see them starting earlier in the year, either cutting games during the regular season, or playing day night doubleheaders.
There’s “really no healthy time to hold the WBC” because the tournament has 16 teams. Pare it down to the best 8 in an “A” group and that sked. becomes more workable. It’s not hard to figure who the best 8 are. The bottom 8 (or whatever) can hold their tourney someplace else. Top 2 of B go to A group in next tourney, bottom 2 of A go to B. Or don’t bother with a B group. No matter how you slice, 16 teams with 8 dogs at one time is ridiculous.
It all comes down to TV. They want every game to be televised, but they don’t want any of the games to interfere with each other. Until they start playing games at the same time, this will always be an issue. And stop giving networks total control over scheduling, they don’t care how long the playoffs take, just how much return on there investment they can get. There is no reason to have 3 off days in a 7 game series.
I’d like to see the four teams in each league play three sets of three games against each other in a single playoff round, with the two winners advancing to the World Series. Highest-seeded team gets six home games, next gets five, then four, then three. Every team would be guaranteed three home playoff games, and there would be more games in less time, followed by a traditional World Series that would conclude in October.
The fewer the games in any given playoff series, the higher the chance that the worse team will advance.
I think the WS has to be held between the pennant winners of each league. To make it so that two teams from the same league face off in the WS would not have a beneficial effect that anyone would want.
i agree not a day off that make a big change.
What are your biggest problems with the playoffs? Is it the length of the series, the fact that it goes into November or just the total length of the playoffs themselves?
Total length of the playoffs.
Total amount of off days. When there are soooo many days off a team can get by with 2 starters. Not that I want to see 5th starters in the playoffs, but I would like to seem teams have to display and play their depth a bit.
I think the playoffs are fine format wise but I don’t like it getting into the cold season.
That’s how I am too. I like the format(by that I mean the amount of teams and the 5-7-7 series) but I just wish there was a way that it didn’t stretch into November like it does now. Especially with so many playoff contending teams playing in cold weather climates like NY, Boston, Philly, Minnesota, Chicago, Stl among others. I just don’t think the World Series should be decided by which team plays better in sub freezing wind chills like how it can be now.
Now I really don’t know how they could do this unless they shorten the regular season or playoffs but obviously neither of that is going to happen.
Hopefully they won’t come to the conclusion that World Series games will need to be played at a neutral warm weather location.
I don’t understand why the WBC is so important. It shouldn’t be a reason to make to regular season shorter.
It’s basically an international promo for baseball. Now that baseball’s no longer in the Olympics, it’s the highest-profile international baseball competition at the country level.