The Bargains of the 2015 Free Agent Class

In past years, I’ve often compared shopping in free agency to shopping at Whole Foods, in that everything is just more expensive than it should be. But given that I’m currently writing this post at my local Whole Foods — their oatmeal is actually pretty good, and not too expensive for mornings when work-from-home writers just have to get out of the house — I feel like that would be a hypocritical analogy to make today.

So, Whole Foods, you get a one-day reprieve from being the example of an overpriced market. And to be fair, maybe it isn’t the best analogy anyway, given that Whole Foods does sell mostly high quality stuff, while the free agent market is full of things other teams didn’t really want anymore. Maybe free agency is more like a really expensive Craigslist?

Regardless, you get the point. Free agency is expensive. The winner’s curse often applies, as teams are initially happy with their purchases, but eventually realize that the shiny new thing they just bought isn’t shiny or new. The average age of free agents is going up, and aging curves appear to be getting steeper, and that combination leads to a lot of players selling the last few years of their decline phase, which is not a great time to be investing heavily in an asset.

But, occasionally, the market does undervalue a player. Often it’s health related, but sometimes a bad platform year performance can convince too many buyers that decline has already begun to set in, and teams can buy low on a player poised for a rebound. It does happen, so today, I’m going to try and identify five potential bargains in this class. Of course, I tried this last year too, and came away with Brian McCann, the short Chris Young, Roberto Hernandez, Scott Kazmir, and Omar Infante; a whopping 20% of those guys were worth their contract last year. So, you know, take these opinions with as many grains of salt as you think are necessary.

But let me take another stab at this. Here are five guys I think could prove to be decent buys this winter. For reference, I’m going to list both the expected contracts from our Contract Crowdsourcing project and my own expectations. On to the list.

5. Jason Hammel, Starting Pitcher

Crowd: 3 years, $27 million
Dave: 3 years, $30 million

Teams tend to value consistency, especially in veterans. They like to know what they’re paying for, and a nice long steady track record helps makes it easier to set expectations. Hammel doesn’t offer that, as his xFIP- over the last five years show: 92, 121, 83, 115, 96. And those are core skills that are supposed to be fairly steady. Hammel has vacillated between being pretty good and pretty lousy, which is very likely going to drive his price down.

But if you look at the package as a whole, Hammel looks essentially like a league average starting pitcher, and that’s basically what Steamer has him projected as, putting up +1.9 WAR per 200 iP. Of course, Hammel has never actually thrown 200 innings in a season, so perhaps he’s better projected as about a +1.5 WAR pitcher, and $9 or $10 million per year isn’t exactly a steal for that kind of performance.

But there’s also some pretty limited risk, given the short term he’ll likely command, and Hammel comes with a bit more upside than most of the average-innings-eater types. Like Jason Vargas last year, he won’t be a sexy addition, but he’s the kind of moderate cost acquisition who could provide some real value for a team in the regular season.

4. Francisco Liriano, Starting Pitcher

Crowd: 3 years, $36 million
Dave: 3 years, $39 million

Take everything I just said about Hammel’s inconsistency driving down his price and multiply it by a factor of 10. Liriano has occasionally been completely dominant and completely terrible, and he’s been regularly injured in between. He’s been very good for the Pirates for the last two years, but even in something like the best possible context for him as a pitcher, he still only managed 160 innings per year. If you sign Liriano, you’re hoping for quality, not quantity.

And it’s probably time to stop expecting him to perform at the level of his peripherals now, as he’s nearly 1,200 innings into his career and has an ERA (4.07) significantly higher than either his FIP (3.61) or xFIP (3.56). So, that +2.9 WAR per 200 IP Steamer projection? He’s probably going to underperform that both in innings and runs allowed. A more realistic forecast is around +2 WAR, probably, and that’s assuming he stays healthy, which he very well might not.

But, again, there’s upside here, and the corresponding price won’t be outrageous. There won’t be too many other guys who can perform at this level signing for what Liriano will sign for. $12 or $13 million per year buys you an average player these days, but Liriano gives some hope that he might be able to produce more than his price would infer. Especially if he finally gets around to pitching to his peripherals for once.

3. Russell Martin, Catcher

Crowd: 4 years, $56 million
Dave: 5 years, $75 million

I know: a five year deal for a 32 year old catcher is what passes for a top-three bargain these days? By the end of the deal, Martin probably won’t be a catcher anymore, even if the crowd is right about the length of the deal he ends up taking. This contract is almost certainly going to result in some dead money in the last year or two of the contract, so for it to be a bargain, Martin is going to have to produce significantly more than $15 million per year worth of value up front.

And I think he very well might. For one, his plate discipline isn’t going anywhere, so even if his power goes away, he’s got a decently high offensive floor, as declining down to the level of Ryan Hanigan wouldn’t make Martin useless. And Martin doesn’t even have to hit for that much power to be a very good player; his career ISO is only .141, and that’s been enough to help him post a 106 wRC+. Martin looks like a pretty good bet to be something like a league average hitter for the next few years, and a catcher who can hit at league average levels is pretty valuable.

Especially because we’re not capturing all of his defensive value. Per StatCorner, Martin’s value by framing runs, by season since 2007: +25, +31, +23, +10, +29, +24, +17, +12. Even if we don’t believe that the actual value of these runs is as high as the current estimates — I’m in that camp — and cut these values in half, Martin looks like about a +1 win framer, and this is another skill that has been show to age well. Steamer’s projection for Martin’s 2015 performance has him worth +3.6 WAR per 450 plate appearances, and that’s without any framing value; include it in the calculation, and Martin might just be the best free agent on the market this winter.

Of course, I made a very similar argument about McCann last year, and that didn’t work out so well in year one. But at $15 million per year for four or five years, Martin seems like a very reasonable bet to me, at least, relative to the other bets that free agency offers.

2. Brandon McCarthy, Starting Pitcher

Crowd: 3 years, $36 million
Dave: 3 years, $42 million

The winner of this bidding will likely be the one who puts the most emphasis on his most recent performance, as the 2014 version of McCarthy is quite interesting indeed. After 110 innings of a great xFIP/terrible ERA combination, the Yankees picked up McCarthy for a song and saw him immediately start pitching like his peripherals suggested, giving them 90 spectacular innings in the process. Even after switching from the NL to the AL, he sustained his increase in strikeouts, and even knocked it a few ticks higher, all while still avoiding walks to an extreme degree.

And there are plenty of reasons to think it wasn’t a fluke. His fastball averaged 92.9 last year, up two miles per hour from his 2013 velocity, and his breaking stuff was coming in harder as well. Velocity spikes and performance improvements often go together, and if he can keep throwing 93, McCarthy can likely sustain more of his recent performance than his career numbers would suggest.

The fact that it was just one year in which his ERA was abysmal for the first half of the season, along with his own injury history, will likely keep this deal short term. Even if he pushes up towards $15 million per year, there’s few players on the market who offer this kind of potential performance without carrying a hefty price tag. His long history of shoulder problems certainly aren’t something to just be ignored, but overall, I can’t see too many better options for a team looking for an impact player this winter.

1. Chase Headley, Third Base

Crowd: 4 years, $56 million
Dave: 4 years, $60 million

While analysis based on n of one is never a good idea, Headley’s situation reminds me an awful lot of mid-career Adrian Beltre. Solid player, monster breakout season based on a power spike, followed by a quick regression to career averages, and then hitting free agency coming off a down year in which his primary selling points were hot corner defense and the hope that a more hitter-friendly ballpark might give him a real boost.

Beltre, of course, went on to become a monster once he left Safeco Field, and his current contract with the Rangers — signed after his big bounce back in Boston — is maybe the best large free agent contract signed in the last decade. We can’t project the same kind of improvement from Headley, but there are reasons to think that he’s more than the average bat/good glove combination that his 2014 numbers would suggest, and you don’t have to expect him to repeat his +20 UZR from last year to think that he could be a valuable piece going forward.

As a pull-power hitter who most frequently bats from the left side, Petco Park was maybe the very worst environment for him to come up in. The fence adjustments of 2013 mitigated it’s extreme pitcher nature to some degree, but it’s still a west coast ballpark where the ball doesn’t fly, and for most his career, the right-center gap was cavernous. Like Beltre in Seattle, Headley’s skillset was just an awful fit for his home park.

And yet he still managed to be an above average hitter during his time in San Diego. His career wRC+ is 114, almost the equal of Pablo Sandoval’s career 122 wRC+, yet perhaps because of the up-and-more-recently-down nature of his offensive performances, the generally accepted view is that he’s a glove-first acquisition. But Headley’s track record is pretty solid, and if he gets to a park that inflates doubles or is generally friendly to left-handed pull hitters, Headley could be a nice offensive piece as well.

I’d probably take the under on Steamer’s +3.9 WAR per 600 PA forecast, but expecting +3 WAR with some hope for a bit of a boost isn’t unreasonable at all. I don’t think it’s completely insane to prefer Headley to Sandoval even without factoring cost in, and it seems quite likely that Headley will be the cheaper of the two. If you’re looking for power, you probably want to look elsewhere, but if you’re looking for overall value this winter, Headley might be the best target out there.





Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.

58 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Jaack
11 years ago

I think signing Brandon McCarthy is part of every fan’s ‘reasonable’ plan for their team this offseason.

Basebull
11 years ago
Reply to  Jaack

Yeah, at this point all the “he’ll be a steal” articles have probably driven his price past the point of him being a steal.

Jeremy
11 years ago
Reply to  Basebull

Sorta like how “he’ll be overpaid” drove Nelson Cruz’s prices down to the point where he was underpaid last season.

Henry Newhouse
11 years ago
Reply to  Basebull

I don’t think its “He’ll be a steal!” so much as “His contract won’t be an albatross if he completely bombs!” like other higher profile pitchers. McCarthy is a solid pitcher with the potential to be better, and won’t be getting paid the $20-$30m a year pitchers like Scherzer and Lester are likely to get.

Eno's Fro
11 years ago

I think Andrew Miller and Jed Lowrie fit the objective better than the ones mentioned. Miller for the obvious reasons, but Lowrie at just 31 seems like a reasonable bounce back candidate. Had he had a 2014 in line with his previous year or 2, he’d have been looking at a 4 yr 60M deal right now. He’s going to be a good value for someone most likely.

Henry Newhouse
11 years ago
Reply to  Eno's Fro

I think its likely Miller will be overvalued actually, he hasn’t put up the kind of numbers he did this year in any other year. He put up over 2 WAR as a reliever in a contract year. He’s going to get a ton of money for that, and likely not live up to it.

Spa City
11 years ago

I expect you will wind up with another 20% success rate in next year’s article. The only player on your list who seems likely to be a bargain in any way is McCarthy… but every team is looking for McCarthy as a discount-bin starter with upside, so the market will drive his price up o the point where there is not much excess value.

The only free agents on the market currently who I expect will offer true “bargains” are the players who will get shorter-term contracts due to potentially correctable flaws: Brett Anderson, Brandon Morrow, Justin Masterson, Colby Rasmus, Stephen Drew, and Jed Lowrie.

When the non-tendered players hit the market, you will see some potential bargains in Ike Davis, Josh Tomlin, Ruben Tejada, Yonder Alonso.

Gareth Harris
11 years ago
Reply to  Spa City

The Indians won’t be non tendering Josh Tomlin.

Klatz
11 years ago

I’d compare free agency to an art auction or Ebay for unusual/unique items, except with a hidden bidding system.

Catoblepas
11 years ago
Reply to  Klatz

An auction for unusual items with a hidden bidding system? So you would compare free agency to… free agency?

Los
11 years ago
Reply to  Catoblepas

How much more fun would free agency be if we got to see live auctions in real time where the player is allowed to reject offers made but the bidding is public. That would be a lot of fun to watch. You can watch a team try to price enforce and end up with a player who isn’t as good of a fit.

Eric R
11 years ago
Reply to  Los

Each FA goes on the block in a random order and televise it like a Mecum auction 🙂 I would **love** to watch that.

Basebull
11 years ago

One of these years an AL team will pick up Mike Morse, leave him at DH where he belongs and benefit from a monster year.

Gareth Harris
11 years ago
Reply to  Basebull

If he’s cheap enough, I wouldn’t mind the Indians going after Morse. Power is hard to come by and I could definitely see him having a nice year in the AL, health permitting. The only drawback to the Indians signing him would be that either Swisher or Morse would be in the field regularly, which would hurt them defensively.

bookbook
11 years ago
Reply to  Gareth Harris

Morse would injure himself on the dugout step. Whatever your over/under on Morse, I’m betting the under.

Costanza
11 years ago
Reply to  bookbook

I put the line at 350 PA. Still taking the under?

Henry Newhouse
11 years ago
Reply to  Gareth Harris

The problem with the Indians, is that their entire lineup would benefit from being placed in the DH spot…

mgraves
11 years ago
Reply to  Henry Newhouse

I’d say that describes the Twins also, but a solid number of them shouldn’t have either a bat or a glove.

Anthony
11 years ago
Reply to  Henry Newhouse

This isn’t really true. Bad fielders =/= bad enough fielders to necessitate a switch to DH. Being bad for a 3B or bad for a 2B isn’t being a bad actual position player out there. You’d have to be a pretty terrible 3Bman to warrant being a DH.

Gareth Harris
11 years ago

I’d love to see the Indians open their wallets and sign Headley. However 15 million a year for 4 years is just too rich for their blood – especially with the Swisher and Bourn millstone contracts on the books for another two seasons.

It’s a shame too, as the Indians infield defense was their biggest weakness last season and would improve immensely with the addition of Headley. His left handed bat walls be a plus (progressive field favors lefties) .

Having Gomes, Santana, Kipnis, Ramirez and Headley would make a bad defense become very sound, then become elite when lindor is promoted to play shortstop. Ramirez would go to second with Kipnis goimg to right field. In this scenario Chisenhall and Murphy would be bench bats / part timers / DH’s or traded.

Sam Fuld
11 years ago

How about 5 years $82 million?

srpst23
11 years ago
Reply to  Sam Fuld

For Russell Martin.

GBSimons
11 years ago
Reply to  srpst23

That’s crazy talk! Never gonna happen.

Mike
11 years ago
Reply to  Sam Fuld

I think the appropriate response is “My eyes. The goggles, they do nothing.”

yeah
11 years ago
Reply to  Sam Fuld

let’s let’s play play ball!

Psy Jung
11 years ago

Actually the McCann prediction still holds, Dave, and provides a good justification for the (likely less expensive) Russell Martin contract. If you estimate that McCann as a +5 framer he was worth about 20 million at 7 million/WAR, even though he sucked mightily at the plate.

Costanza
11 years ago
Reply to  Psy Jung

As bad as Mccann was, he put up 2.3WAR in 2014. I don’t think it’s a stretch to say if you add in pitch framing, he’s closer to 3 WAR than 2. That’s worth what they paid him this year, at least.

Steamer likes him for a 111 wRC+ and 4.2 WAR. Again, add in a bonus for pitch framing and he’s a 5 win player, being paid like a 2.5 win player.

I would hold off on calling the Mccann contract a bust, at least until we know if 2014 is a new standard of performance, or if he can regain some of his bat. If he’s above average with the bat (110wRC+ or so), he’s a 4 win player.

I actually think he’s a lot like Chase Headley — if their bat is slightly above avg, their defense adds such value that they’re a star even with a pedestrian batting line.

I think most fans, including those on this site, react too strongly to a terrible batting line.

All I wrote will become useless as soon as DC adjusts catcher replacement level, like he’s hinted.

Costanza
11 years ago
Reply to  Costanza

Using Steamer’s 4 WAR projection for 2015 (with a reasonable 111 wRC+ projected w/ the bat), and the .5 decline per season, McCann would be worth 4, 3.5, 3, 2.5 wins without including framing. That’s 13 wins in 4 years, getting paid $60 million. Again, not including pitch framing.

If you give him a 3 WAR season this year by including just under 1 WAR from framing, his contract looks like: 3 (2014), 2.5, 2, 1.5, 1 for 10 WAR for $75 million.

I think it’s going to be hard for that contract to be an albatross; even if 2014 is his established level of play, it’s still just a bit of an overpay ($7.5 million per WAR is probably the high side of average for 2014-2018 $/WAR). Doesn’t take much for it to be a solid signing.

Wobatus
11 years ago
Reply to  Costanza

19 homers at home. Boy, without Yankee Stadium he’d have really had a crap year. Low groundball rate, high IFFB%. I could see him bouncing somewhat. He might even have a monster year in him (relatively speaking) with a bit of babip luck.

Gareth Harris
11 years ago

My top 5 bargains would be:

Headley
Masterson
Rios
Morse
Neshek / Gregerson – I’d take either guy.

Eno's Fro
11 years ago
Reply to  Gareth Harris

Rios is cooked. If any team gives him more than $4M for 2015 they are insane.

Thanks, Comcast
11 years ago
Reply to  Eno's Fro

I’d gladly pay that. I don’t expect him to be a slugger, but a 2.9% HR/FB rate isn’t gonna stick.

Eno's Fro
11 years ago

well his warning track power will only play in a few places like Cinci for example. Aside from that he doesn’t walk, doesn’t hit for XBs anymore and is becoming a liability in the field. That’s a nice package for an OF corner!

PackBob
11 years ago

The bargains will probably be a random selection from players that have some real issues, either performance or injury related, but have a good year anyway. There is not much to base a prediction on other than a few of these guys happen each year. But low, hold on, and hope for the best.

Giants Dynasty
11 years ago

Mccarthy stink stunk stank.
Masterson > mccarthy
Liriano > mccarthy
Peavy > mccarthy

Los
11 years ago
Reply to  Giants Dynasty

What is your problem with Brandon McCarthy? Either say something productive or stop trolling every single page he is being mentioned in.

gg
11 years ago
Reply to  Giants Dynasty

liriano is. masterson is not good. peavy is crap.

Giants Dynasty
11 years ago
Reply to  Giants Dynasty

Over 325 IP last 2 seasons Mcccarthy has a era of 4.3. Even including any of his “new skills”

That’s not enough to say he suck? then I don’t know what is.

Giants Dynasty
11 years ago
Reply to  Giants Dynasty

He has career Era of 4.09
He has Era over 4 last 2 seasons
He is 31 years old and is not going to get better

Don’t any of you think it is insane to project him to have a Era under 4 next year

His sinker ball homer prone tendencies reminds me of Roberto hernandez/Ricky nolasCo the fangraphs crowd go gaga over

Giants Dynasty = Troll
11 years ago
Reply to  Giants Dynasty

.

Los
11 years ago
Reply to  Giants Dynasty

Wow…you are using the fact that he is a sinkerballer who is homer prone with a career ERA over 4 to argue that MCCarthy is not as good as Masterson. Are you serious?

Giants Dynasty
11 years ago
Reply to  Giants Dynasty

He is comparable to Masterson. About equal, equal contract 1 Year 8 million.

Giants Dynasty
11 years ago
Reply to  Giants Dynasty

Last 2 years

F Liriano FIP 3.26 ERA 3.24
Brandon Mccarthy FIP 3.63 ERA 4.24
Justin Masterson FIP 3.84 ERA 4.52
Peavy FIP 4.05 ERA 3.91

First, obviously Liriano > Mccarthy.
Second, since Masterson is 2 years younger, (29 instead of 31), you are not telling me, as a GM, would give both similiar contracts going forward based on stats and age?
Third, Peavy has put up better stats (career and recent) than Mccarthy. He is older so I would say they are about equal for 2015.

A smart GM would expect similar performances out of Peavy, Mccarthy and Masterson for 2015. To give one guy , as Dave cameron, says 40 some million, while the other 2 guys are expected to get 1 year-10 mil type deals, would make it obvious where the bargins are at.

To focus on 90 IP of mccarthy is like choosing the 90 IP of Liriano in 2013 where he went 7-0 with a 1.85 ERA and saying that’s his real talent level.

Los
11 years ago
Reply to  Giants Dynasty

Fact: McCarthy out-performs Masterson over last 2 years
Your response: Masterson is 2 years younger so he will be better next year

Fact: McCarthy out-performs Peavy over last 2 years
Your response: Well sure Peavy is older so they will probably be the same going forward.

Peavy has had the best career out of any of those but you are not signing 2007 Jake Peavy. Liriano is the best right now. McCarthy is second because while he is a somewhat similar pitcher to Masterson, he doesn’t have the ridiculous platoon split. Any team signing Masterson needs to watch out for teams in their division who can stack left handed bats against them. Masterson can be a really good pitcher but if you don’t see why a team would prefer McCarthy to Masterson you are missing something. Peavy doesn’t belong in this discussion on a going forward basis.

Turd Ferguson
11 years ago
Reply to  Giants Dynasty

Typical doofus Giants fan, just ignore him.

Leave it to a Giants fan to come to FanGraphs then use ERA as the basis for his argument… hey moron, there are only about 93657 metrics on this site that measure a pitcher’s performance better than win-loss record & ERA. smh

ElJimador
11 years ago

“Like Beltre in Seattle, Headley’s skillset was just an awful fit for his home park.”

This was certainly true through Headley’s great 2012 season however has it really been true since the fences at Petco were brought in after that? Fangraphs handedness park factor scores show Petco has actually been a homer-friendly park for LHH the past 2 seasons (HR as L scoring 103 in ’13 and ’14). So why wasn’t Headley able to benefit from that?

I would really like to see Tony Blegnino apply his granular batted ball and park factor data not just to Headley but to Sandoval also. I suspect given the extreme nature of his own home park that Sandoval may be being undervalued as a hitter at least as much as Headley however I’d like to see more data on how their batted ball tendencies have fit their park’s dimensions to have a better idea of that.

Catoblepas
11 years ago
Reply to  ElJimador

This doesn’t totally clear up your question, but I know when the dimensions of a park change seriously, Fangraphs’ park factors are based off only the years since the change, as opposed to the normal longer averages. The Petco numbers are likely to be fairly noisy for the next few years, and so unintuitive results stand a good chance of going away soon.

witesoxfan
11 years ago

The MLB free agent market is like a used car dealership. If you’re smart, conservative, and do your homework, you could be rewarded with a nice deal (or you could get screwed). If you buy the most expensive shiny toy they have, you will almost certainly get screwed.

Ehhhh
11 years ago
Reply to  witesoxfan

Deep.

stonepie
11 years ago

whole foods is onto you. if you see men following you in hybrids, wearing sustainable suits, leave the country asap.

Baltar
11 years ago

If $30M and up constitute the free-agent bargains, I pity the poor teams.

DNA+
11 years ago

Russel Martin apparently got 5 years and $81M from the Blue Jays. They will regret that one.

yeah
11 years ago
Reply to  DNA+

nope. pretty good value IMO. he should likely get 4-5 WAR this year including pitch framing.

king buzzo's fro
11 years ago
Reply to  yeah

NOPE. Not in someones opinion

Cooper
11 years ago

Thanks for focusing on the game itself and not the media, fan engagement, ticket prices side of things. This is good stuff!

king buzzo's fro
11 years ago
Reply to  Cooper

Yeah, what this arse said…

Gareth Harris
11 years ago

Small market teams are quivering at that Giancarlo contract.

Meanwhile, Jason Heyward is having a very good day……….

ASK
11 years ago
Reply to  Gareth Harris

I thought the Marlins were a small market team.