The History of Madison Bumgarner vs. Clayton Kershaw

So you want the designated hitter in the National League, eh? Well, you’re going to have to talk it over with this guy first:

madison-bumgarner-ftr-gettyjpg_155j9bewlw8351sfz9t8uzi4e7

Jokes aside, I’m not even sure Madison Bumgarner would mind if the designated hitter took over. It doesn’t seem like he particularly enjoys hitting. He doesn’t work on it in the cages or in batting practice and he wasn’t exactly champing at the bit to come off the bench as a pinch-hitter, as one might expect other #PitchersWhoRake would. And it would allow him to put more of his energy into what he actually does enjoy doing: pitching.

Bumgarner enjoys pitching, and we enjoy watching him pitch, but whether he enjoys hitting or not, we enjoy watching him to do that, too. Bumgarner’s actually a good hitter, and not your typical “good hitter for a pitcher.” No, he’s actually a good hitter. His career 47 wRC+ might lead you to believe otherwise, but between 2013 and -14, he seemed to flip a switch, and since then, he’s been the best-hitting pitcher in baseball. Consider:

That seems good.

There’s a reason I’m writing about Bumgarner as a hitter right now. This didn’t just come out of the blue. The reason is that, over the weekend, Madison Bumgarner faced Clayton Kershaw, undeniably the best pitcher on the planet, and Madison Bumgarner did this:

On its own, a pitcher hitting a home run off Kershaw is noteworthy. Is it postworthy? Maybe. Maybe not. What sends it beyond noteworthy and into postworthy territory is when that pitcher has already homered off Kershaw in the past. A little less than 12 months ago, Bumgarner homered off Kershaw, becoming the first and still only pitcher to do so.

Only 17 players have ever taken Kershaw deep more than once, and so now we start having the “ownage” discussion. Does Bumgarner at the plate own Kershaw? He’s got nine total bases against him in 16 plate appearances; Bumgarner’s teammate and actual hitter, Hunter Pence, has five total bases against Kershaw in 59 plate appearances. Bumgarner must just have Kershaw’s number. He’s got a .750 OPS against him, two points higher than Ryan Braun and 12 points lower than Paul Goldschmidt. All other pitchers combine for a .359 OPS in 486 plate appearances against Kershaw. Bumgarner has been better than twice as productive as the average pitcher facing Kershaw.

But what does that mean? What do these two home runs tell us? They tell us that Madison Bumgarner is big, and strong, and is capable of hitting a baseball for a home run, even in San Francisco, and they tell us that even Clayton Kershaw can make mistakes. They tell us that pitching is incredibly hard, or hitting is incredibly easy, or something? I guess they tell us that baseball is weird and we’ve really got no idea what’s going on most of the time. They also probably tell us that Kershaw is going to pitch Bumgarner differently in the future, because part of the reason he served up those homers in the first place is because he didn’t view Bumgarner as an actual threat.

Let’s go back to 2011, the first time Kershaw ever faced Bumgarner. How do you think Kershaw pitched the 21-year-old starter who, entering the season, was 7-for-41 with one double and zero home runs? Weird question. I have the answer. Why wouldn’t I just tell you? He pitched him like this:

Bumgarner_2011_1

It was six pitches, and six fastballs, between 92-94. The location for five of the six, was high and outside. It couldn’t be more clear that Kershaw had absolutely zero hesitation in giving Bumgarner anything to hit. He was practically begging the 6-foot-5 righty to extend his arms and put everything he had into a swing. Funny enough, Bumgarner singled up the middle. I’m not sure how the swings look — the MLB.TV archives confoundingly only date back to 2014, now — but I’m going to guess that Bumgarner at least showed something to Kershaw here that told Kershaw he was more than your normal pitching hitter. He was 1-for-1 against him, after all.

But that’s not enough. Why would it be? Bumgarner’s still a pitcher. And, like a pitcher trying to hit against the best pitcher in the world, Bumgarner went 0 for his next 11 with seven strikeouts against Kershaw over the span of five years. Through 12 at-bats, Kershaw’d thrown Bumgarner 54 pitches, and 39 of them had been fastballs. Of those, 25 of them had been over the plate. Bumgarner was pitched like a pitcher.

Then, in May of last year, Kershaw pitched Bumgarner like a pitcher for the final time.

Kershaw put a first-pitch fastball over the plate, like he’d been doing for five years, and Bumgarner crushed it. This is where things changed. It’s one thing to poke a single up the middle. That gave Kershaw an inkling that Bumgarner at the plate might be different. This proved it. You take Kershaw deep, as a pitcher, and you’ve got everyone’s attention.

Bumgarner came to the plate two innings later to face Kershaw again, and this is how he was pitched:

Bumgarner_2015_2

First pitch slider, second pitch curveball, then a fastball to put him away. The at-bat was easy: three pitches, three strikes. But it was much more cautious than we’d seen in the past. Bumgarner wasn’t getting that first-pitch heater down the middle.

The pitch Bumgarner hit out this weekend was a 1-1 fastball, and here’s how the next at-bat went:

Bumgarner_2016_2

Fastball, slider, slider, slider, slider. Let’s break the entirety of Bumgarner vs. Kershaw at-bats into two-halves: before the first home run and after the first home run. All pitches are considered either fastballs, or not:

Kershaw-to-Bumgarner pitches

  • Pre-homer: 54 pitches, 39 fastballs (72%)
  • Post-homer: 14 pitches, five fastballs (36%)

The fastball rate has been cut in half. Kershaw has actually thrown more breaking stuff than hard stuff since seeing Bumgarner take him deep. Madison Bumgarner has forced Clayton Kershaw to make an adjustment. What is usually a time for Kershaw to catch his breath is now just another at-bat. Kershaw vs. Hunter Pence used to be one of my favorite pitcher vs. batter matchups. I think I have a new one.





August used to cover the Indians for MLB and ohio.com, but now he's here and thinks writing these in the third person is weird. So you can reach me on Twitter @AugustFG_ or e-mail at august.fagerstrom@fangraphs.com.

16 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
stuck in a slump
10 years ago

I think that home run inflicted actual physical pain on Kershaw given the look on his face in the still for the clip.

BipMember since 2016
10 years ago

https://vine.co/v/iTKgBwvbeZL

A more straightforward reaction.

Hurtlocker
10 years ago

That smile on Kershaw’s face was priceless. You have to give Bumgarner credit, he put his head down and circled the bases, didn’t even look at Kershaw.

BipMember since 2016
10 years ago
Reply to  Hurtlocker

Considering how he reacts to any batter who does literally anything else, you would hope Bumgarner would at least behave up to his own standards.

MetsoxMember since 2016
10 years ago
madfencerMember since 2017
10 years ago

Nine total bases, right? Two homers and a single?

JediHoyer
10 years ago

And jake arrieta hit one 450 feet off Shelby Miller. Good weekend for pitchers hitting.

johnforthegiants
10 years ago

Kershaw got a bit of revenge in the 13-pitch AB which ended with a K but played a big role in wearing Bumgarner down in the pennant-clinching game in September. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lgeAm-5j7-M

Adam C
10 years ago

I’n not sure Bumgarner has become a good hitter “period” as opposed to being a good hitter “for a pitcher”. I put a lot of stock into a hitter’s BB/K ratio as a solid indicator of a “good” hitter. For his career Bumgarner has just 19 walks and 142 strikeouts in 429 PA’s. Even just focusing on 2014-16 Bumgarner has just 6 walks with 57 strikouts in 164 PA’s.

BipMember since 2016
10 years ago
Reply to  Adam C

Out of 512 players with at least 160 PA since 2014, Madison Bumgarner’s ranks:

HR/FB: 2nd, right in front Giancarlo Stanton. Seems legit.
K%: 10th.
BB%: 486th, 3 spots behind Kershaw.
BABIP: 78th.

Adam C
10 years ago
Reply to  Bip

Bumgarner’s raw HR power is legit IMO. He’s a big guy and takes a bit cut. He can crush a good fastball if he can extend his arms for sure. But at least to me I can’t accept a hitter with a 19 BB/142 K ratio as a “good” hitter in the more general sense. It seems that the past 15 years or so “good hitting pitchers” tended to be pitchers who hit for home run power but still strike out a ton and hardly walked. Carlos Zambrano hit 24 career home runs which is tied for 7th all-time among pitchers and the highest total since Don Drysdale (29 HR). Yet Zambrano hit just .238 with a .248 OBP. In 744 career PA’s he drew just 10 walks with 240 strikeouts. We never seem to see a good hitting pitcher who has zero power but slaps at the ball, hit for a solid batting average, and can draw a few walks. Kind of like a Richie Ashburn/Brett Buter type of hitter.

jeren17
10 years ago
Reply to  Adam C

I really don’t think that is possible. To be a high contact, high walk type of hitter takes an awful amount of practice and repetition, which pitchers don’t have the time, nor the prioritization from their teams to allow. I’m sure the philosophy of “swing hard in case you hit it, otherwise come on back to the dugout and rest up” is completely tolerated by every coaching staff in the majors.
So yeah, if you believe a good hitter is a batter with an acceptable k/bb % while displaying all other traits of a good hitter, then there’s never going to be a pitcher who meets your criterea. In my mind, Bumgarner’s flaws at the plate are definitely outweighed by the power numbers he puts up, which gets reflected in his offensive metrics.

JediHoyer
10 years ago
Reply to  Adam C

Mike Hampton had 47bb to 195k… Good enough for you?

ElJimador
10 years ago

As great as Kershaw is both pitches Bumgarner hit out were straight fastballs thigh high and right in the middle of the plate. Everyone in baseball should know by now that Bumgarner can hit those. Where he’s getting better as a hitter is in laying off breaking stuff early in the count to try to get a fastball to hunt. Even so I still wouldn’t call him a good hitter yet (except for a pitcher of course). I’d say he’s a good mistake hitter, but still an easy guy to pitch to at least for anyone who can locate any pitch with movement for strikes. The only thing you can’t do is serve up fat fastballs to him, even if your name is Kershaw.

forestation
10 years ago

There seems to be some revisionist history in this article. Kershaw did not throw fastballs down the middle to Bumgarner in 2015 and 2016 as simple fastball challenges. They were meant to come down and in on Bumgarner but missed their location.

Whether through luck or talent, Bumgarner did what a good hitter is supposed to do, take advantage of pitching mistakes.

It’s certainly true that Kershaw could’ve given Bumgarner tougher pitches that would have also require more effort to deliver, which he indeed did in later at bats.