The Most and Least Accurate Infield Arms

John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images

Yesterday, I wrote my second article exploring Baseball Savant’s new first base receiving leaderboard. Today, we’re going to explore a different side of the leaderboard, because as is so often the case with new Baseball Savant tools, it provides way more information to us baseball nerds than the name would lead you to expect. We’re going to take advantage of the fact that it also allows you to look things up in the other direction. That is, we can do more than just look up the stats of first basemen. We can also look up which infielders got the most help from their first basemen, and we can use that information to learn all sorts of things.

In 2026, Brayan Rocchio and Mookie Betts were tied at the top of the leaderboard. Their first basemen saved 4 Outs Above Average by scooping their throws well, which shouldn’t be surprising, seeing as they spent much of the season throwing to Freddie Freeman and Kyle Manzardo, who both graded out very well. Matt Chapman is at the very bottom of the leaderboard, and Phillies Alec Bohm and Trea Turner are also in the bottom four. Again, this is only logical, as those players were throwing to the two worst receiving first basemen in the league in Rafael Devers and Bryce Harper. However, the leaderboard lets us do more than see who got help and who didn’t.

It also lets us see who’s giving their first baseman a chance to make the play in the first place. Each player is given an average expected out rate based on their throws, and if you dig into the numbers further, you can find the players who rack up the most on-target throws. For example, Dodgers second baseman Alex Freeland led all qualified players with a 99.8% expected out rate. He had a smaller sample size, and he was throwing from the easiest position, but he was still pretty impressive. Ninety-five of his 99 throws were classified as on target, and even those that weren’t were catchable. So far as I can tell, this is the throw that Statcast considered his worst of the entire season.

When you saw Freeland crossing all the way over into shortstop territory, you thought it would be an iffy throw, right? Nope, he was still on the money. This throw had a 99.1% out expectancy, Freeland’s lowest mark of the entire year. That was mostly about how close the play was, rather than the fact that Freeland made Freeman stretch a little bit. (As for whether the combination of Freeland and Freeman made this the freest infield in major league history, please know that I plan on looking into it.)

On the other end of the spectrum, we have some very familiar names. Bohm is down at very bottom with an 85.5% expected out rate, so while Harper didn’t make him look good, he wasn’t exactly putting Harper in a position to look good either. Bohm and Bo Bichette (86.1%) were the only players in baseball below 89%. They weren’t just bad, they were the worst by quite a bit.

It’s important to note that Bohm and Bichette are both third basemen, and that’s not a coincidence. To be clear, their arms were genuinely problematic, but they were also dealing with a real positional disadvantage. The throws get harder the farther you move from first base, both because of the distance of the throw itself, and because that distance means that you have to get rid of the ball sooner. Move any player from second base to third base, and you’d expect their out expectancy to drop by 4.6 points.

Average Out Expectancy
Second Base Shortstop Third Base
96.8% 93.8% 92.2%

I wanted to know who makes the best throws in baseball, and I wanted to reduce the margin for error as much as I could. So I grabbed all of the data from 2021 to 2026, and then I controlled for position by calculating a z-score for each player’s accuracy based on the position they were playing at the time. In case you’re not familiar with them, z-scores essentially take things one step further than plus-minus stats like ERA- and wRC+. They calculate not just how much above or below the league average you are, but how many standard deviations above or below the league average you are. It’s just adding some extra context to make comparisons a little bit more fair. To go back to wRC+ as an example, in the shortened 2020 season, the standard deviation was 29 points, compared to just 20 in the full 2026 season, so z-scores would rightly be a little more skeptical of a player who was way better or worse in such a volatile sample.

Now let’s give you an example infielder throwing out expectancy. The slick-fielding Gabriel Arias’ bat may have kept him from playing much in 2026, but he graded out spectacularly at every position. He had a 98.2% out expectancy at second base, which was 1.4 standard deviations above average. His 97.4% expectancy at shortstop was a whopping 2.5 SDs above the average, and his 94.0% expectancy at third was 1.1 SDs above average. To make my final list, I combined each player’s z-scores, prorating them based on how many throws they made at each position. When you combine all three positions, Arias was at 2.1 SDs above the league average. That made him the best thrower of the past five years, but only after I set a minimum of 300 total throws. At first I set a 200-throw minimum, which bumped Arias into second place, behind four-time Gold Glover Andrelton Simmons. He may not qualify, but his presence at the top does make me feel a bit better about my methodology. Below you’ll find the top 20 and bottom 20 on the list, and at this link, you can find a spreadsheet that shows the entire leaderboard here. You’ll find that, as you expected, Nolan Arenado is just outside the top 20 and Trea Turner is just outside the bottom 20.

Best and Worst Infield Throwers by Adjusted Expected Outs
Rk Player zExpectancy Rk Player zExpectancy
1 Gabriel Arias 2.1 118 Alec Bohm -1.0
2 Matt McLain 1.8 119 Oswald Peraza -1.0
3 Ke’Bryan Hayes 1.8 120 Rougned Odor -1.0
4 Taylor Walls 1.6 121 Jazz Chisholm Jr. -1.1
5 Josh Donaldson 1.5 122 Jose Iglesias -1.2
6 Austin Riley 1.4 123 Caleb Durbin -1.3
7 Jared Triolo 1.3 124 Eduardo Escobar -1.4
8 Wander Franco 1.3 125 CJ Abrams -1.4
9 Tommy Edman 1.2 126 Brandon Crawford -1.7
10 Max Muncy 1.2 127 Willi Castro -1.7
11 Emmanuel Rivera 1.2 128 Jon Berti -1.7
12 Carlos Correa 1.1 129 Gavin Lux -2.0
13 Mauricio Dubón 1.0 130 Luis García Jr. -2.0
14 Zach Neto 0.9 131 Bo Bichette -2.1
15 Dansby Swanson 0.8 132 César Hernández -2.1
16 Gio Urshela 0.8 133 Tim Anderson -2.1
17 Ketel Marte 0.8 134 Nick Gonzales -2.1
18 Brice Turang 0.8 135 Miguel Vargas -2.2
19 Jackson Holliday 0.8 136 Enrique Hernández -2.3
20 Brendan Donovan 0.7 137 Luis Urías -2.6
Source: Baseball Savant

One thing that makes me worry about this methodology is that we seem a bit overindexed on third basemen. Even with the safeguard of using z-scores, because the average out expectancy is so much lower at third, a very good or bad third baseman can really run up the score, whereas it seems harder for second basemen to stand out (though Luis García Jr. gave it a shot with a career 95.7% out expectancy at second base over a very large sample; no wonder he got moved off the position for good). However, that’s probably not that big a deal, because as all these numbers make clear, there’s just not as much variation at second base. Everybody tends to make good throws because the throws are easier.

Still, this was just one way of calculating things. I also went through the leaderboard and got rid of any play that was remotely close by only looking at plays where the ball got there at least half a second before the runner. It’s not a perfect proxy for throwing accuracy, because it’s only looking at the easiest plays, but it’s reassuring to see that a lot of the same names pop up at both the top and bottom of the list. Ke’Bryan Hayes and Matt McLain really are good, and Bohm, Bichette, Urías, and Abrams really do have issues. You can view the whole leaderboard here.

Best and Worst Infield Throwers on Non-Close Plays
Rk Player Expectancy Rk Player Expectancy
1 Michael Massey 99.7 107 Alec Bohm 97.9
2 Adam Frazier 99.7 108 J.P. Crawford 97.9
3 Miguel Rojas 99.6 109 CJ Abrams 97.8
4 Jackson Holliday 99.6 110 Willy Adames 97.8
5 Bryson Stott 99.5 111 Joey Ortiz 97.8
6 Ke’Bryan Hayes 99.5 112 Ryan McMahon 97.7
7 Brice Turang 99.5 113 Manny Machado 97.7
8 Matt McLain 99.5 114 Luis Urías 97.6
9 Geraldo Perdomo 99.5 115 Bo Bichette 97.4
10 Xavier Edwards 99.5 116 Yoán Moncada 97.0
Source: Baseball Savant

It’s a bit wild to realize that even when the play isn’t close, even players like Bohm, the least accurate regular players in baseball, are still on target 97-98% of the time. Still, maybe he’d be a bit more comfortable a bit closer to first base.





Davy Andrews is a Brooklyn-based musician and a writer at FanGraphs. He can be found on Bluesky @davyandrewsdavy.bsky.social.

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted