Trevor Story Begins a New Chapter in Boston

Isaiah J. Downing-USA TODAY Sports

It’s been a topsy-turvy, fast-paced offseason, with the swirling vortex of signings and trades spitting out some of the more memorable moves in recent years. A series of trades sent Isiah Kiner-Falefa all the way to the Bronx. Kenley Jansen to Atlanta came out of nowhere, and Carlos Correa, the biggest name of the offseason, ended up at a surprising destination with an odd contract.

But as it turned out, this offseason had one last twist in store for us. After weeks of relative silence, Trevor Story agreed to a six-year, $140 million contract with the Red Sox that contains a player opt-out after four years — one which Boston can negate by picking up a seventh-year option worth $25 million, or pay a $5 million buyout, bringing the total amount involved to $160 million. The deal does not include a no-trade clause, per the New York Post’s Joel Sherman.

So, you’ve just signed Trevor Story. What are you getting out of him? The answer depends on how you think his former home affected his performance, the park which must not be named: Coors Field. On the surface, it’s easy to glance at his home/road splits and check out. Throughout his career, Story has been a 146 wRC+ hitter at home and a 98 wRC+ hitter on the road. Away from an elevated bastion, he walks less, strikes out more, and makes inferior contact. What a fraud!

But this is FanGraphs, and we’re better than that. One of the biggest misconceptions about Coors is that it’s a self-contained phenomenon — in other words, the place merely improves hitters without any drawbacks. In reality, calling Coors one’s home produces a “hangover” effect. Because of how pitches move differently at high altitude, Rockies hitters struggle to adjust to sea level. Furthermore, there’s evidence suggesting this discrepancy widens over the course of a season. The Rockies aren’t just better at home; they’re also much worse on the road. Imagine being the new kid at school every three days or so. The mere thought of it makes me exhausted, and Story and others were constantly subject to the baseball equivalent of that nightmare.

In sum, it’s misleading to suggest Story will lapse into a poor hitter. His altitudinal privileges will get revoked, but at the same time, he’ll no longer have to fear hitting on the road. Take the average of 146 and 98, and you’d wind up with 122, which seems reasonable for what Story might put up in a full season outside of Colorado.

There’s a tiny problem with that assumption, though. Let’s first set the scene: In 2018, Story trimmed his strikeouts and became the hitter he’s known as today. Last season, however, he posted the lowest wRC+ (100) of his post-breakout era. More concerning is that his production has been steadily declining since that breakout year, which is illustrative of a downward trend. It’s a legitimate reason that creates at least some concern; the question is to what extent.

But there are reasons to lean optimstic. For one, there was an injury. In late May, Story began experiencing tightness and pain in his elbow and forearm, causing him to leave mid-game. A subsequent MRI failed to detect any damage to the ligament, and he rejoined the team soon after. Here, it’s good to mention that I have no inside information on Story’s health. Maybe he did feel perfectly fine! But also, there’s a history of players pressing on through lingering injuries and recording subpar results. One has to wonder if the issue with his elbow affected Story’s ability to swing the bat.

Also, as we’re reminded for the umpteenth time, the dang baseball changed. That’s important for a variety of reasons, but especially important when considering how it affected Story’s results on contact. As Michael Ajeto of Baseball Prospectus noted, the new ball’s increased drag reduced the carry of Story’s opposite-field fly balls. It matters because he isn’t just a pull-happy slugger; Story has made a killing so far thanks to his all-fields power. He’s been almost as prolific as in years past, but his efforts didn’t translate into on-field results.

All things considered, it seems like last season is more an aberration than a new norm. But we’ve yet to address that downward trend. Even if Story didn’t suffer an injury or grapple with a new ball, he very well might have been worse than his previous self. And while I won’t rule out this possibility, I’d also like to acknowledge how great Story has been during a supposed decline. To accomplish that, we need to summon another infielder of Coors fame who recently moved out: Nolan Arenado.

As did Story, Arenado blossomed into an All-Star with the Rockies. But let’s take a more granular look at their respective histories. Story became who he is in 2018, so let’s use it as our starting point. (Arenado conveniently established himself in 2015, the advent of public Statcast data.) Getting to the point, here’s how the two have fared in key batted ball metrics since their breakout seasons:

Arenado vs. Story, Statcast Metrics
Player Max EV (mph) Hard-Hit% Sweet Spot% Barrel%
Nolan Arenado 111.2 38.6% 34.3% 7.8%
Trevor Story 112.5 44.4% 37.0% 10.3%
SOURCE: Baseball Savant

Do most people perceive Arenado as a better hitter? I’m not sure. But this comparison suggests we might actually be underrating Story. They have similar top-end power, but overall, Story has hit the ball harder more frequently at angles conducive to success. Sure, some caveats apply: Arenado has a lengthier track record, and the numbers factor in his unusually terrible 2020. At the same time, though, removing it makes virtually no difference, and there’s a reason why projections heavily weigh a hitter’s recent seasons. In his first year in St. Louis, Arenado posted a 113 wRC+; the odds that Story equals or surpasses that mark seem quite good.

But even if Story loses his prowess at the plate, take solace in the fact that he’s adept at a premium position. You’re talking about a three- to four-win player even with a league-average bat. I don’t even need to dive into his defense, but for fun, here’s a GIF of him making a fantastic play:

That was fun! Unfortunately, we do need to talk about Coors again (ugh). If you’ve scrolled through the pages of notable free agents, you might have noticed that DRS rates Story’s glove consistently higher than UZR. He’s not the exception; most Rockies infielders receive the same treatment. I’ve talked to people about this, and it seems like the source is a BABIP adjustment within the DRS formula. Because it doesn’t distinguish between balls hit on the ground and balls hit in the air, Rockies infielders are perennially over-corrected and outfielders are under-corrected.

This isn’t to say one metric is better than the other, but it’s relevant to our discussion. Story has two six-win seasons according to Baseball-Reference and only one such season according to FanGraphs. Depending on which flavor of WAR is chosen, it alters your evaluation. But let’s assume his defensive value is closer to UZR’s approximation than that of DRS. Should we care all that much? Maybe not, because even by the former metric, he still is one of the league’s better shortstops. Since 2017, here’s how his defensive runs above average ranked among qualified shortstops:

Story Among Qualified Shortstops, 2017-21
Year Defensive Runs Rank
2017 7.8 9th of 20
2018 4.8 15th of 22
2019 15.1 3rd of 21
2020 6.5 2nd of 20
2021 9.7 4th of 21

Story’s beginning seemed inauspicious, but UZR gradually started giving him credit; check out his three most recent seasons, in which he’s near the top. It is worth noting that Statcast thought Story’s defense last season was atrocious (-7 OAA), but in these situations, it’s best to trust the track record. One-year blips in defensive metrics are hardly indicative of future success (or failure), and we know from multiple seasons that Story is at least a good, if not great shortstop. Besides, the aforementioned injury might have been contributed to the atypically limp throws he made throughout this year.

Story won’t be at shortstop, however — at least for the time being. Xander Bogaerts can opt out after this season, but as long as he’s on the Red Sox, the plan is to keep him at short and place Story at second.

This decision elicited a mixed response, and understandably so. Bogaerts’ defensive shortcomings are well known, so it would make sense to move him to a less rigorous position and let Story, a more dexterous fielder, take the helm. But when I consulted our resident prognosticator Dan Syzmborski, he found out that doing so nets the Red Sox three runs — not wins, runs. What’s the reason behind such a small gain? We know Bogaerts is a terrible shortstop, but we should also consider that planting Story at second makes him a much better defender in the eyes of ZiPS, even after factoring in positional adjustments. Inversely, while changing their respective positions would increase Bogaerts’ value, the total amount is similar to that produced by the former option. Above all, it’s best not to alienate your star player in exchange for a fraction of a win, and Story presumably didn’t mind giving up shortstop, so all is well here.

While we’re on the topic of ZiPS, here’s how it forecasts Trevor Story for the duration of his contract:

ZiPS Projection – Trevor Story (2B)
Year BA OBP SLG AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SB OPS+ DR WAR
2022 .265 .338 .494 543 88 144 37 6 25 77 54 22 117 8 3.9
2023 .269 .342 .507 509 83 137 37 6 24 74 51 19 121 7 3.9
2024 .264 .338 .490 492 78 130 35 5 22 69 49 18 116 6 3.4
2025 .263 .335 .485 472 73 124 32 5 21 65 46 15 114 5 3.0
2026 .260 .329 .467 450 67 117 29 5 18 59 42 13 108 4 2.4
2027 .254 .321 .445 425 61 108 26 5 15 53 37 11 100 3 1.7

As a bonus, here’s how those six years look like with Story at shortstop:

ZiPS Projection – Trevor Story (SS)
Year BA OBP SLG AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SB OPS+ DR WAR
2022 .261 .334 .488 545 88 142 36 5 26 77 54 23 114 4 3.8
2023 .264 .337 .498 512 82 135 36 6 24 73 51 19 117 3 3.7
2024 .260 .335 .488 496 78 129 34 5 23 70 50 17 114 2 3.3
2025 .258 .332 .479 476 73 123 32 5 21 65 47 15 112 1 2.8
2026 .256 .326 .465 454 68 116 28 5 19 60 43 12 107 0 2.3
2027 .249 .319 .443 429 61 107 25 5 16 53 39 10 99 -1 1.6

That’s a pretty optimistic projection, all things considered. Fenway is one of the better parks Story could have ended up in; although it’s slightly unfavorable environment for righty hitters in pursuit of home runs, it’s also a doubles haven owing to its unequal dimensions. ZiPS recommends a six-year deal worth $137 million based on these numbers, which is about as accurate as we’ll get to a real-life figure. Story did extremely well to fetch himself sixth year this late into the offseason, and I suspect the late-night Correa bomb had teams scrambling for the last remaining impact player (no offense, Michael Conforto).

There’s one questionable part about Story’s contract, and that’s the opt-out. Barring otherworldly numbers across a four-year span, he’d be hard pressed to enter the open market as a 33-year-old shortstop. And if Story does exceeded expectations, it’s in the team’s best interest to lock him up. So who is this opt-out for? A scenario in which the opt-out goes through requires two elements: Story underperforming, and the Red Sox initiating a teardown after falling out of contention. Therefore, my guess is that it ensures Story is free to search for another contender even if his tenure in Boston goes south. He reportedly rejected a higher offer from the Rockies in pursuit of an opportunity to win, so this does make a whole lot of sense.

Signing Story doesn’t ensure the Red Sox make the playoffs, but it at least grants them a fighting opportunity. The Blue Jays were aggressive throughout the offseason, adding players both big and small via free agency and trades; surpassing them seems like a tall order. But the Yankees passed on multiple chances to make major upgrades, and the Rays mostly stayed put. It’s a small window, but it’s a window nonetheless for the Red Sox to squeeze through. Right now, their projected 2022 win total equals that of the Rays, with the Blue Jays and Yankees a few games up. But it’s a tight division, and anything can happen. As the offseason winds down, Story to Boston reminds us that baseball is just on the horizon.





Justin is an undergraduate student at Washington University in St. Louis studying statistics and writing.

114 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago

“the park which must not be named: [name of park]“

tomerafan
4 years ago

All of these shortstop deals make me so frustrated that the Mets overpaid Lindor.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  tomerafan

When it was signed, I thought the Lindor deal made more sense than the Seager deal does now. Of course, that’s partly because Seager also got a ridiculous payday, and partly because we have new information about Lindor since then and it’s not good.

This is probably the deal that has the best shot of working out for the team that signed them. Baez is pretty scary, Seager got way too much money, Semien is older, Lindor got way too much money and might be declining already, and Correa will probably opt out pretty soon. That’s not to say that Story is going to work out the best, since it’s 5 vs 1, but if I had to pick one, I’d pick this one.

FrancoeursteinMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

What “new info” about Lindor are you referring to, ST?

joe_schlabotnik
4 years ago
Reply to  Francoeurstein

that he has played a season since signing his extension and it was… not good!!!

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago

It’s worth noting that every projection system has been convinced the last two years that Lindor’s decline previously was too steep and that he will rebound. While I would also think he’s likely to put up more than 2.7 wins next year, it sure seems like the arrow is trending down (or at the least, is not necessarily trending up) long-term.

johansantana17Member since 2026
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

The Correa deal could still work out very well for the Twins even if he opts out after 1 or 2 years. I would pick that one as the most likely to work out

Dmjn53
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Eh I don’t know about that. Seager’s the worst defender by a wide margin but he’s also the best hitter by a pretty wide margin. We can debate how much longer he’s going to be viable SS (if he’s even one now), but over a long term deal I’ll bet on the best bat over defense

joe_schlabotnik
4 years ago
Reply to  tomerafan

when i think about the potency of the NL east right now, and i do a mental scan of each team and what makes them special, i honestly forget lindor exists. huge yikes of a contract. hilarious that correa ended up being the most team friendly contract

carterMember since 2020
4 years ago

I am not in on Lindor per se, but I think offensively the issue was whatever he was trying to do with LH at the start of the year last year. He was flailing out and had no power whatsoever. He honestly looked ridiculous. Towards the end of the year his numbers came around a bit, and I would imagine he will have a semi-bounceback. But still, a bounceback is like a 110wRC+, which is making him massively overpaid.

OddBall Herrera
4 years ago

Do projections take into account not only home field but the games you will be playing away? Not only are you losing the need to adjust every time you leave Coors, but you are replacing a ton of games visiting pitchers parks with games in Baltimore, Toronto, and NY. This seems like a win for Story twice over.

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
4 years ago

This is a part of the question about Coors that is not well understood and needs to be investigated. Every road trip requires adjusting to a different break to the breaking balls and off-speed stuff and, probably to a lesser degree, again upon returning to Coors. LeMahieu made the Coors effect look ridiculous. Arenado was within the rounding error and we can only wait and see what Story does.

brothermathias714
4 years ago
Reply to  bosoxforlife

I think it would be more accurate to say Arenado’s road record last year was within the rounding error of his career road stats (.855 OPS vs. .805). His home record however at Busch was far worse than his career home record (.722 OPS vs. .954). That’s only one player in one season so it doesn;t mean a lot but I’ll bet that trend continues for him. I don’t think the Coors hangover is as big a factor as some people believe it is. .

LesVegetables
4 years ago

It’s a solid signing and think he is a good fit for both the Red Sox and Fenway. It gives them protection at short if Xander leaves. I think the concerns about leaving Coors are real, but it’s not like he’s going to Petco, he’s going to Fenway, which is arguably the most hitter friendly park outside of Coors.

I think he’ll do well. He reminds me a bit of Pedroia – not elite at any one thing but probably above average across the board and benefits from hitting in a hitter friendly park.

I don’t think he makes the Red Sox much better than they were at the end of last year though, and in the AL East that’s not good.

mariodegenzgz
4 years ago
Reply to  LesVegetables

Only thing I’ll disagree on is that Trevor is actually elite at two important things, those being baserunning and not hitting the ball on the ground.

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
4 years ago
Reply to  mariodegenzgz

I think that hitting for power should added to that. Not many middle infielders have 35 and 37 HR campaigns.

averagejoe15Member since 2018
4 years ago
Reply to  LesVegetables

Pedroia was an elite defender at 2b though…

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
4 years ago
Reply to  LesVegetables

Does it really give them protection if Bogaerts leaves? That is only the case if he still has a SS arm. That, at least at this time, hangs over this deal like a sword. If it is okay then the Red Sox have made the best deal for one of the top infielders available this winter. The Red Sox have him for 4 and the complex opt-outs appear to allow them to keep him for 3 more if they so desire. Seager’s deal is a huge overpay, as is Semien’s and Correa’s deal is too bizarre unless the Twins hit the jackpot this year. I think (hope is the right word but I won’t admit it) that Story will be a key part of the Sox lineup for years to come.

Jon L.Member since 2016
4 years ago
Reply to  LesVegetables

Wasn’t Pedroia elite at making contact and not striking out? I feel like he was running single-digit strikeout rates – in the 2000s!

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  Jon L.

Yup! 9.7% K rate for a career that spanned 2006-2017 – pretty damned good!

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago

Realistically, you got a guy who played half his games in the most difficult-to-model park in all of baseball (perhaps baseball history), who is moving to the second most difficult-to-model park in MLB, whose defensive metrics vary quite a bit (take look at his OAA, it is not pretty), whose arm suddenly became questionable, and whose bat took a major dive this past season.

And yet, if you take the negative look most of these things, he’s still probably a 2-win player because he will very likely be a league average hitter and fielder at second base. Before we get into the upside. What a tough guy to predict.

mariodegenzgz
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I wouldn’t be concerned. 2021 was his first down season since his 2018 breakthrough, and I can tell you for a fact that he played hurt most of it. He also got unlucky a lot early before getting hurt (he had so many warning track flyouts), and I suspect the new baseball messed with the humidor in Denver, because the way the ball carried was unusually bad.

Trevor will be fine. The only question I have is how quickly he’ll get used to second base. If he does, he’s an easy 4+ WAR player because he just does everything well: he hits, fields and runs the bases at a high level. Also, he couldn’t have gone to a better division for his flyball-hitting ways.

FrancoeursteinMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  mariodegenzgz

Not to mention he played his entire season frustrated and annoyed. I’d argue that has a little bit to do with the declining numbers.

mariodegenzgz
4 years ago
Reply to  Francoeurstein

For some players maybe, not for Trevor. He’s too much of a pro and hard worker to have that happen.

Bud SmithMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  mariodegenzgz

Hi Trevor!

carterMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  mariodegenzgz

I know this isn’t about fantasy, but I remember watching most of his at bats last year early in the year. Exactly that, was like an all-time record in warning track lineouts.

mariodegenzgz
4 years ago
Reply to  carter

It was so frustrating. At one point he barely missed like 3 homers in a 3/4-game span.

carterMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  mariodegenzgz

I def watched all those at bats. Was painful. He was leading the league for a while in over 95 outs? Or maybe 110? But like absolutely torched balls getting caught on warning track.

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

He was a 4.2 bWAR player even during a year that most seem to think was a disaster. While it is possible that his decline has begun there is a very reasonable chance that he approaches his high water marks. 2018-20 Story was ranked the best SS in the game at MLB-TV by the likes of Gennarro and Petriello, as dedicated a pair of analytical baseball people as you could ever find.

JimmieFoxxalorianMember since 2020
4 years ago

I’ve been waiting for Bloom to make his one big splashy move, and this one is a cannonball into the deep end of the pool.

I absolutely love the move. Reasonable contract in context of current market, the player’s athleticism and how he may age vs. peak performance, and the instant-can-o’roster-flexibility. Very well done. Spring has sprung, and it is Bloooooming!

Johnnie TMember since 2024
4 years ago

What I also like about this deal for the Sox is that the ABs Story will take are things like Christian Arroyo and Jackie Bradley Jr. vs. lefties, which were like as weak a set of at bats as any contending hopeful was giving out. Its like we should add a WAR to whatever total we give because the at bats that won’t happen were so execrable.

mariodegenzgz
4 years ago

An overlooked aspect of Trevor’s game: he’s also one of the game’s best baserunners! He’s fantastic at taking extra bases and is one of the few players in MLB right now I could somewhat confidently project as a 30-30 guy. He played hurt almost all of last season and was still a productive player, and from ’18-’20 was firmly in the convo for best SS in the world. I think the Sox are gonna be very happy with this deal.

Dmjn53
4 years ago
Reply to  mariodegenzgz

He’s an excellent player but I wouldn’t say he’s one of the game’s best baserunners. 76% career success rate leaves a bit to be desired and he doesn’t rank near the top in baserunning metrics either

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  Dmjn53

Maybe he’s not best in the league, but 76% is still healthily above the minimum benchmark for success. He’s posted continually positive baserunning marks in his career – for a team as inept at baserunning as the Sox were last year, it will be refreshing to see

dl80Member since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  proiste

It’s almost exactly the break even point.

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  dl80

I’ve always heard it’s like 71%. Is that wrong? Besides, stealing bases isn’t the only part of baserunning

dl80Member since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  proiste

I thought it was 75 now because of the plethora of home runs. Maybe I’m imagining that?

SpencerLBMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  Dmjn53

? 76% isn’t going to make you the most feared runner on the base paths but it’s well above the level of “leaving a bit to be desired” for sure

JimmieFoxxalorianMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  Dmjn53

Story’s BsR for past 3 years = 5.9, 4.0, 6.4
Bogaerts, who is fairly decent athlete in his own right, managed 1.0, 2.7, 1.2

Trevor’s a superb baserunner. End of story!

airforce21oneMember since 2026
4 years ago

Why does he get caught stealing at a league average rate, then?

Sooted72
4 years ago
Reply to  airforce21one

ikr, kinda seems like theres more to baserunning value than steal rate.

Tim Mainella
4 years ago

Taking the over on the zips home run projections!

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago

There are just so many angles on this. There’s the fact that Story might move to shortstop if/when Xander opts out, so they get a year to evaluate his arm.

Also, the Rangers and the Red Sox have given up picks that are approximately in the #40 range to sign shortstops. So while we didn’t see the world where Story and Seager and Semien didn’t have QOs, it doesn’t seem to have hurt their market much.

There’s also the fact that the Red Sox were one of the least-vaccinated teams last year, and next year their guys may not be able to play road games in Toronto or NYC, which probably colored who they went after.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Also, now Enrique Hernandez is probably the everyday CF, leaving Bradley as a platoon guy in a corner and backup CF and Verdugo playing everyday. Still short a right-handed bat. Unfortunately, Tommy Pham the only right-handed outfielder who looks like he can still play who is still available. Maybe Kevin Pillar.

I think what they want is for Jarren Duran (a lefty) to seize an everyday job by midseason. Or for Rob Refsnyder to pan out, which seems particularly unlikely.

Mike NMN
4 years ago

This will make the Red Sox better, even if Story doesn’t manage to meet his previous offensive highs. It’s a lot of money, but seems to be in range of the market. In the scorpions in the bottle AL East, it could clearly be worth a critical win or two over the Yankees (who were just weird this offseason, although maybe explainably so) and be a difference-maker in the playoffs.

Johnnie TMember since 2024
4 years ago
Reply to  Mike NMN

The Yanks defied expectations, but if you look how they remade their IF (Voit, Torres, Urshela, LeMahieu vs Rizzo, Torres, Kiner-Falefa, Donaldson, and LaMahieu), it is both better and an extra good player deep. It was weird, yes, but I think that they did a brilliant job of it. Sadly as someone who does not root for the Yankees…

steveo
4 years ago

Kinda surprised he did this well, honestly. His arm is cooked, he’s a 2B only imo. His arm was so cooked he wasn’t really even charging up to throw the ball, he just got rid of it early and bounced it so often. If he’s your SS you need a gold glove caliber guy at 1B with all the bad throws. Still a really good bat though, not exactly a great fit for Fenway since he doesn’t pull the ball a ton. He’ll hit anywhere though, so it doesn’t really matter. This does add 2-2.5 wins to their total, so I think this helps them further pass those mid tier teams to grab the 5th/6th playoff spot. I’ll predict that all the wild card teams come from the AL East, with the Jays winning the division.

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  steveo

With projected performance valued at $137, this deal may be the fairest for both player and team in terms of simple dollars/WAR given this offseason

Chazerbaijani
4 years ago

This is a great article – quite balanced.

A “nitpick” – Matt Gross and I have done some decent research confirming the Coors Hangover with more than top-line metrics. It just hasn’t been in a major outlet – but it would be great if FG and others linked to it and ideally took it and ran. The Coors Hangover is so interesting from a SABR perspective! Obviously, folks care less since the Rockies are such a mismanaged team.

https://www.purplerow.com/2019/4/1/18291723/the-coors-hangover-and-why-the-rockies-should-play-all-their-road

AnonMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  Chazerbaijani

I would love to see the team names on the Home/Road chart. The Rox aren’t the only team with odd patterns. There is one team that goes from 5 points of wRC+ worse at home in June to something like 20 points better at home in July before swinging to more than 10 points worse at home in August.

bohknowsMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  Chazerbaijani

I feel like the obvious article in response to this is to analyze how other NL teams do when visiting Coors. Is there a similar wRC+ gap corresponding to opposing teams unfamiliarity with the Coors environment?

Richard Bergstrom
4 years ago

Recent trends are hard to track for a player like Story. Trading Arenado was pretty disheartening to Story as well. I wouldn’t be surprised if that affected his 2021. 2020’s coronavirus season also made things weird.

Richard Bergstrom
4 years ago

Also I can verify the DRS/UZR discrepancy for Coors infielders has been around for at least 5 years. I’d chatted with BIS/SIS and MGL about it. FanGraphs’ defensive runs component usually underrated Arenado and LeMahieu too.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago

I don’t know this for certain, but I noticed that virtually every outfielder the Rockies have ever employed was rated as quite a bit below average by UZR. This leads me to believe that part of the problem is the metric itself, since I would imagine that someone in Colorado would eventually make it a priority to find someone who could play better defense.

tung_twista
4 years ago

Arenado

2016-2020
23 DRS/150
15 OOA/150
8 UZR/150

2021
6 DRS/150
10 OOA/150
5 UZR/150

LeMahieu

2016-2018
13 DRS/150
15 OOA/150
5 UZR/150

2019-2021 (2B only. Numbers don’t change much if you include 3B)
0 DRS/150
-1 OOA/150
6 UZR/150

The numbers suggest that DRS inflating Rockies infielder stats is likely a larger problem than UZR not giving them enough credit.
And the explanation regarding BABIP in Coors make sense to me.

Brock244
4 years ago

I love this signing for Boston.

I think people are making too much of the arm issues. For one, he still projects as a 4 win player at 2b.

Also, we really have no way to know so there’s no value in speculating. An encouraging sign is that 3 of the smartest front offices in baseball were finalist for him (Boston, Houston, San Fran).

I do like the flexibility this gives them. Now you have insurance for a Xander injury, or insurance for not extending Xander past this year..

Put it this way: I like paying Story 23/yr over Erod and Schwarber 40/year. The roster construction and flexibility is a lot cleaner and intriguing

Richie
4 years ago
Reply to  Brock244

Discouraging sign: The dumbest front office in baseball apparently made him the highest $$$ offer. (just sayin’)

Brock244
4 years ago
Reply to  Richie

That’s fair. But it does tell me they were okay with his medicals.

Granted, how much reinsurance thats worth, I don’t know. But it’s certainly better than seeing them have no interest then pivoting to Bryant

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  Richie

This, BTW, is why you cannot just say “smart guys are doing this, we can’t know better than them.” Smart teams and not-smart teams often will make the same moves.

Brock244
4 years ago

Also, second thought.

If Boston is going over the lux tax, they might as well snag Conforto while they’re at it, no?

Or at least, take on Myers and snag a prospect or two

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  Brock244

My understanding is that part of the reason why the Red Sox weren’t in on Conforto is because he isn’t vaxxed, meaning he wouldn’t be available for half of the AL East road games. (And that this is also the reason the Mets made zero effort to re-sign him)

Brock244
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Oh wow, that’s interesting. That’s gotta be the reasoning for his lack of market.

Still, if they are going over the tax, they should take advantage. Their RF situation is not great.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  Brock244

I heard a couple days ago that “why certain guys wound up in certain places” was partly because some teams refused to sign unvaccinated players. I don’t know Story’s status, but I’ve now read a couple of things about the Mets and Red Sox indicating that improving their vaccination rate is a priority for them so it would seem unlikely that Story is going to be unvaxxed on opening day.

As for Conforto, I looked it up: He has made some statements suggesting he is not, and although it’s not confirmed, it would line up with him still being out there. It also might make sense why Correa was out there for so long, although who knows what the deal was there–it’s just as likely that Correa just misread the market.

Brock244
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

That Correa wrinkle is fascinating.

Could explain the odd contract he took.

carterMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I would imagine a lot of the players are going to end up vaxxed, albeit for real, or not. Cannot imagine it is hard for a pro athlete to find an alternative, but if they do they should probably remember to pay their chef.

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  Brock244

I think Tommy Pham might be in the cards for them

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  proiste

Pham would probably be their best bet left on FA market. By a lot.

“buying” a prospect from the Padres for Wil Myers certainly would be fun, although since that means the Padres would need two corner outfielders instead of one it might not be quite as straightforward as it appears. David Peralta could be available though. Or Charlie Blackmon, although who knows what the Rockies are thinking now.

carterMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I feel Pham is getting a bit of a bad wrap. I think he is still an everyday player at worst. He hit the ball hard last year, very little changed. He seems a tad worse than prior, but most indicators seem to think he got pretty unlucky offensively. Also he was stabbed right before the season which might have hurt production and/or affected training regimen leaning up to the season.

Richie
4 years ago

Can someone explain to me how, given that Story is a good shortstop, how in the world his projected WAR is higher at 2nd Base than at shortstop? I just don’t see how that can be.

Richie
4 years ago
Reply to  Richie

Possible explanation #1: Sure you didn’t mix those 2 tables up? Seriously.

#2: A bug in the ZIPs defensive adjustment. ‘2nd Base is easier than shortstop, so he’ll automatically be so much better at the easier position that it’ll more than make up for now being at the less valuable position’

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  Richie

Could be a case of the Marcus Semien effect. I don’t know the breakdown of how Story does on plays to his arm versus glove side, but if there’s a big difference there he could get a huge boost in defensive value by moving to second that makes up for the positional penalty

si.or.noMember since 2017
4 years ago
Reply to  Richie

Not sure why you were downvoted here — I think it’s a reasonable question.

I’m curious about it too, but from another angle — it seems like his offensive line is better as a 2B. Is this kind of like the DH effect, where there is a noticeable difference when players play different positions? Is there somewhere where I can read about it?

hughduffy
4 years ago
Reply to  Richie

Story is projected to have twice the DR at 2nd as he does at SS. That’s the cause of the difference. It’s worth 0.8 WAR over 6 seasons, which is not that much overall.

Richie
4 years ago

I think this is where in-person professional scouting comes in. That’s who I’d trust to surmise ‘looks like throwing through an injury to me’ as opposed to ‘looks like age + wear-and-tear have done his arm in to me’.

joe_schlabotnik
4 years ago

absolutely no idea what to think of it. never been blown away by story but also his payday isn’t mind boggling. all that this does is make the semien and seager contracts look absolutely ludicrous.

joe_schlabotnik
4 years ago

and i can’t help but also just be more confused vy arenado after reading this. this website is filled with arenado truthers, but i can’t help but… i don’t wanna say it… if hes a 113 wrc hitter… i dont know. its an awfully big contract for that

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago

Arenado’s BABIP completely collapsed, leaving him as a low-OBP, high-power type of guy. With a good glove at third base, that’s still pretty valuable, but the offense is a bit disappointing. And it’s probably not due to bad luck either, since he outperformed his xwOBA by 20-some points.

That’s not to say he’ll have another disappointing year going forward, but it would help his case a lot if his OBP went more into the .330 range instead of the .320 range, and certainly needs to improve from the .310 range.

joe_schlabotnik
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

i don’t see one of the slowest guys in the mlb suddenly getting any “better” at BABIP. so yeah… exactly.
two things can be true at once: the rockies management is a circus, and the arenado contract might have been a pretty big overpay.
i think we’ve become conditioned to just automatically assume that the rockies do everything wrong, which they kinda do, but both arenado and story are huge question marks

carterMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Arenados spray chart is…umm, something? I don’t even know what to say about it. Not even can he not go the opposite way with power, he can’t even hit it to center field with power. And the year after year of decreasing quality contact is strange as well. He seems to be doing the sell out for pull side power thing that a lot of guys do late in career, but by the looks of it he cannot even hit it to center field. It’s such an odd spray chart…couple doubles to right field, probably oddly hit balls that rolled to the wall, all pull home runs, then just nothing to center. Whereas if you look prior to 2020 he at least occasionally went oppo/cf with power.

brothermathias714
4 years ago

Arenado has always been a much better road hitter than Story — .805 OPS vs, .752. — so it will be interesting how they compare this year. Arenado’s road numbers were a bit better last year than in his Colorado years but he was bad at Busch. Fenway should work for Story but he hits a lot of balls to center and right so maybe it won’t be as good a fit as it seems at first glance. It’ll be fun to watch how this unfolds.

proiste
4 years ago

The combination opt-out/team option adds another wrinkle to this deal. Most of the times, opt-outs unilaterally favor the players. But for this one, if Story is still good at age 33 and the Red Sox are contending, they basically get a 3-year team option on him. Seems like it puts most of the leverage in their favor, which makes this deal seem even better relative to Semien and Seager

Brock244
4 years ago

I don’t think the Semien deal is too bad. 7/170 for a guy coming off an MVP type year ago projects as a 4+ win player is fine.

I think the problem is more so the real who gave it to him. Those types of deals are usually for slam dunk contenders that can afford the backend overpayment in return for an all star player for 2-3 years.

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  Brock244

Semien has roughly the same projections as Story, but is two years older. Seems kinda weird to give him an extra year and a higher AAV, especially for a team that probably won’t be good for the first couple years of the deal

fjtorres
4 years ago
Reply to  Brock244

Texas can afford it and they *expect* to be contenders by ’23. Maybe second half ’22.

Think of Pudge going to Detroit while they were…not so good…but still around and productive when they were.
Remember they moved into a new park just a year ago. They’re trying to catch up before the new park effect fades.

esperadok
4 years ago

Glad you included that bit about DRS at Coors Field. It’s weird because we have lots of data to suggest that Coors hitters might be underrated because of the hangover effect, but I think the DRS thing is dramatically affecting our evaluation of Coors infielders and might cause us to significantly overrate them. I’d like to see more research on it for sure!

okteds
4 years ago

Great article! But the real question is, do I keep Story at $22, or just go with Adames at $3? That’s what everyone wants to know!

Sooted72
4 years ago
Reply to  okteds

great question! we care about your fantasy team.

-nobody

carterMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  okteds

Adames career 111wrc+, Story career 112wrc+

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
4 years ago

I doubt if anyone else on this blog has been a Red Sox fan since 1948 so I just might have the most skin in this game. I agree with the belief that the real factor about hitting in Coors Field is the effect that the elevation has on pitch movement and not the simple fact that the ball carries further. Will Story be able adjust to seeing more consistent movement when he plays the majority of his games at sea level? There potential for wildly different outcomes, while present in every situation, is extreme with Story. .290/.360/.550 with 35 jacks like 2019 and the Red Sox average 7 runs a game and win 100. Even last year’s performance earned him a 4.2 bWAR and that was seen as a really bad season by most. At this time I will admit to being giddy about his arrival and as, is always the case, I will wait to actually watch the games before declaring the deal to be a success or failure.

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
4 years ago

I will again admit to being confused by how WAR is figured out. I am told that it isn’t simply done by adding offensive and defensive WAR together and that baserunning is included. That seems easy enough to understand so I take a look at Trevor Story. 20.1 offensive WAR and 10.6 defensive WAR but only a 26.7 overall WAR. On the bases he appears to be a superb baserunner with a base stealing percentage of .769 and even leading the league. His all-around game is constantly admired so I would think his overall WAR would be well in excess of simply his offensive and defensive numbers. Where does this garbage number of 26.7 WAR come from? Arenado, a similar player to Story with outstanding defense and power, still has a penalty but it is less despite not being close to the baserunner Story is. They played together so the park shouldn’t be the reason. Is it just pulled out of the ether, or is it the honest answer, garbage in, garbage out?

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
4 years ago
Reply to  bosoxforlife

I expected a lot of down votes from the analytically minded but what I really want are answers. I see no area of the game that could bring down Story’s WAR from his basic offensive and defensive numbers.

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  bosoxforlife

I don’t really know, but one possible explanation could be that defensive war is weighted less than offensive WAR in the calculation of total WAR. That’s just a guess though

Left of Centerfield
4 years ago
Reply to  bosoxforlife

Personally I dislike it when people get downvoted for asking a question. I gave you an upvote to help compensate. 🙂

Anyway, to answer your question. Go to Story’s page on Baseball Reference and go to “Player Value – Batting”. Then hover over the column that says oWAR. You’ll see a popup that gives you the explanation. Basically, adding oWAR and dWAR would include the position adjustment twice which is why they don’t add up to WAR. (the position adjustment is the column labeled Rpos).

Captain Tenneal
4 years ago
Reply to  bosoxforlife

The position adjustment is counted in both oWAR and dWAR. Since Story plays a position that gives him a positive adjustment, adding his oWAR and dWAR together gives him 2 of those positive positional adjustments, so when finding his total WAR one of them needs to be removed. This means that every single catcher, shortstop, second baseman, third baseman, and center fielder will have their total WAR be less than the sum of the oWAR and dWAR. Meanwhile, everyone who plays a position with a negative adjustment will have their total WAR be higher than the sum of their oWAR and dWAR.

It is not a penalty to Story, and has nothing to do with his baserunning. His baserunning has been 12 runs in his career, which is reflected in his oWAR. If he were a totally average baserunner he would have only been worth 25.5 WAR thus far instead of 26.7.

oWAR = Rbat + Rbaser + Rdp + Rpos + Rrep (then roughly divided by 10)
dWAR = Rfield + Rpos (then roughly divided by 10)
WAR = Rbat + Rbaser + Rdp + Rfield + Rpos + Rrep (then roughly divided by 10)

WAR is basically oWAR + Rfield. That’s why David Ortiz has basically the same WAR as oWAR, even though he has -20 dWAR. The -20 wins is all positional adjustments and his actual fielding only cost the team 1.6 wins.

gottaIch116Member since 2020
4 years ago

Where the hell were the Angels this offseason? What a bummer. And I say this as a Mariners fan.

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  gottaIch116

They signed Noah Syndergaard, which was cool!

gottaIch116Member since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  proiste

I thought it was cool, too! But they are still around 30 mil under the luxury tax and are projected to be about a .500 team. Trout, Rendon getting older. Shohei is a free agent in a couple of years.

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  gottaIch116

Yeah, totally agree. Arte Moreno’s inconsistent spending is really killing them. Obviously they still have the big three, and Stassi and Walsh are good players, but there’s huge question marks around the rest of the lineup. How can a supposedly contending team run Tyler Wade out as their starting shortstop?

Envy AngelMember since 2017
4 years ago
Reply to  proiste

The Angels’ MO for the last decade has been to make one big acquisition early and then sit out the rest of the off-season. I thought last year the reason they picked up José Iglesias was to position themselves for this free agent class of shortstops. Guess I was wrong. I envy a lot of teams right now.

fjtorres
4 years ago
Reply to  Envy Angel

Beats doing nothing until everybody else is done and then picking over the leftovers.

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  fjtorres

I mean, obviously being mediocre is better than being bad, but if they want to win they need to actually invest time and money towards building a complete roster beyond their stars

Envy AngelMember since 2017
4 years ago
Reply to  fjtorres

The Angels have had Mike Trout for that decade, though, and have yet to build a team around him by doing what they are doing. One decade, one playoff appearance, no playoff wins for this drip, drip, drip approach.

fjtorres
4 years ago
Reply to  Envy Angel

Angel fans at least get to watch Trout over the bulk of his career.
Others trade their franchise players as soon as they get expensive, often for little more than dreams. And in the process waste their own stars.

johansantana17Member since 2026
4 years ago
Reply to  gottaIch116

They probably didn’t spend more money on payroll because they didn’t think doing so would increase profit margins.

MorboTheAnnihilator
4 years ago

One important point to add is that a full -6 of the -7 OAA that Story put up in 2021 came against LHB and only -1 against righties. This along with the general knowledge of the Rockies suggests an organizational incompetence in fielder positioning that somehow negatively impacts Story’s performance against LHB. There are likely sample size issues contributing to the issue as well, but that’s less fun to discuss than making fun of the Rockies. So story is probably not as bad defensively as OAA suggests.

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
4 years ago

This is a perfect place for a poll. Trevor Story and Javier Baez both signed contracts this winter of 6 years for $140 million dollars. Who is going to provide more value to his new team? I cast my vote for Story.

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  bosoxforlife

The more likely bet is 100% Story. I will say I think Baez has a better chance of having an absolutely ridiculous MVP year out of nowhere. But conventional logic says the black magic he uses to be a good hitter with those contact and chase rates seems like it has to run out sometime

fjtorres
4 years ago
Reply to  bosoxforlife

Same age within weeks, too.
Different questions about each, though.
Baez discipline is questionable but his fielding is unquestionable.
Should give him a solid floor.

proiste
4 years ago
Reply to  fjtorres

Baez is definitely a solid defensive shortstop, but there are real questions to just how good he is. Yes, he makes lots of dazzling plays, but he’s also very error-prone. The metrics kind of reflect this – DRS think’s he’s amazing, but OAA and UZR think he’s just average.

Of course, Story has the same questions. DRS loves him, UZR likes him, and OAA hates him. There’s a lot of gray area on both of them

sadtromboneMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  bosoxforlife

Baez scares the heck out of me. Just because he’s going to give you monster months (and maybe even a monster year) does not mean he’s going to be consistent enough to give you full value. Slow and steady wins the race.

fjtorres
4 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Makes the comparo interesting.
High risk, high reward vs consistency.

Uncle SpikeMember since 2020
4 years ago

I think there’s a solid argument to be made that Trevor Story’s bat didn’t actually decline last year and there’s no real cause for concern. Yes, the raw numbers were down but a look under the hood shows incredibly consistent performance over the last 4 seasons. Plate discipline, hard hit %, max EV, AVG EV, barrel % are all right in line. He either 1) had been extremely lucky his entire career up to last year, as he always had an xWOBA quite a bit higher than his actual WOBA, or 2) was unlucky last year. I tend to think it was #2. Either way, he’s the same hitter he’s always been.

Last edited 4 years ago by Uncle Spike
Baseball Analyzed
4 years ago

Toronto is extremely overrated. Neither Berrios or Manoah is better than a #3 starter, Gausman can blow up there and the bullpen is average.