Weeks Files: Jemile Is Not Rickie

Whenever the younger half of a brother-brother tandem is called up, the comparisons are unavoidable. Billy and Cal Ripken, Jose and Ozzie Canseco, Jason and Jeremy Giambi, and, of course, Ryan and Steve Braun. Most recently, we’ve had the combination of B.J. and Justin Upton, one of the least one-sided brother tandems in MLB history. With the Oakland Athletics’ recent call-up of 24-year-old Jemile Weeks, younger brother (by four-and-a-half years) of Milwaukee’s Rickie Weeks, we may see yet another balanced brother combination. Jemile is poised to put together a solid big-league career, but he’ll be doing it with a different approach than big brother beyond just his switch-hitting.

Jemile will certainly have some work to do to equal Rickie’s performance at age 24. Rickie’s age 24 season produced 3.4 WAR for the 2007 Milwaukee Brewers, thanks to a .235/.374/.433 batting line in 506 plate appearances. As that line suggests, Rickie strikes out a ton (28% in 2007, 27% career) but evens it out with walks (15.4% in 2007, 10.6% career) and power (.198 ISO in 2007, .179 career).

The younger Jemile specialized in patience in his minor league career as well. Walks were a key in his swift climb of the ladder of the A’s system, as he notched 113 free passes in his 1018 minor league plate appearances (11.1%). When they’re not jogging down to first base, though, the brothers take completely different approaches. The smaller Jemile just doesn’t have the kind of pop to hit majestic bombs like this one of Rickie’s; instead, he lives to spray the ball around the diamond. Between AA and AAA, Jemile notched 529 plate appearances and recorded only six home runs, but he also only
struck out 69 times (15% of at-bats). His power wasn’t completely negligible, either, it just usually came inside the park: Jemile recorded 20 double and 11 triples in these two stints., good for a .132 ISO.

Just looking at Jemile compared to Rickie, I don’t think we can really expect Jemile to develop the kind of power Rickie flashed in 2010, when he mashed 29 home runs. Despite being the same height (5’10”), Rickie packs much more power inside his frame, at 213 pounds against Jemile’s 175. I think these pictures illustrate it pretty clearly (particularly the lower-half strength of Rickie compared to Jemile):

Over the past season and a third, Rickie has compiled a stunning 9.1 WAR and has positioned himself as a perennial All-Star second baseman. Jemile has a ton of work in front of him to equal his older brother, as it remains to be seen if his contact-central game can fully translate to the big leagues. If it can, big brother may have some company at the All-Star Game in the near future.

We hoped you liked reading Weeks Files: Jemile Is Not Rickie by Jack Moore!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs

Jack Moore's work can be seen at VICE Sports and anywhere else you're willing to pay him to write. Buy his e-book.

newest oldest most voted

As an A’s fan, I was surprised at the selection of Jemile Weeks as a first rounder. One of the theories of Moneyball was that players could develope power, but were less likely to develope plate discipline. Look where they are now.