What Pitchers (and Numbers) Say About Pitching in the Cold

Maybe it was the fact that she spent her formative years in Germany, while I spent most of mine in Jamaica and America’s South, but my mother and I have always disagreed about a fundamental thing when it comes to the weather. For her, she wants the sun. It doesn’t matter if it’s bitter cold and dry; if the sun’s out, she’s fine. I’d rather it was warm. Don’t care if there’s a drizzle or humidity or whatever.

It turns out, when we were disagreeing about these things, we were really talking about pitching. Mostly because life is pitching and pitching is life.

But also because the temperature, and the temperature alone, does not tell the story of pitching in the cold. It’ll make sense, just stick with it.

Jose Fernandez pitched in the cold in New York this year. He struck out five and walked three — this, a game after striking out 13 and walking one at home in sunny Miami. “I couldn’t feel anything,” he said when I spoke with him a couple weeks later in San Francisco. “I couldn’t feel the ball for the first couple of innings.” Jeff Samardzija agreed about cold-weather pitching: “The ball is a pool cue, it’s hard as a rock.”

So it’s no surprise to hear pitchers talk about their fingers in the cold. Red Sox reliever Tommy Layne told our David Laurila that “The biggest problem is that you lose feeling on the tips of your fingers,” and even if you do things to warm them up, “by the time you get out there it’s a moot point. They’re cold again. Anything below 40 degrees, you start to get that numbness in your fingers. You have to really be in your mechanics to make sure that everything is in line, in order to throw strikes.” John Axford, long-time Canadian and short-time Athletic, said that “In cold weather, my focus has been on keeping my hand warm if I could.”

For all that talk about the fingers, you’d think certain pitch types might suffer more than most. People say the changeup is a feel pitch, but recently Zack Greinke and others have admitted that breaking balls require the most feel. And so, maybe the slider is the pitch most affected by the cold. Fernandez agreed — “I’ve noticed you have a little more trouble throwing a tight breaking ball,” he said — and others have concurred, too, like Layne and Danny Farquhar of the Rays as well.

By whiff rates, they’re right.

Pitch-Type Whiff Rates by Weather
Pitch Type Hot swSTR% Cold swSTR% Difference
Slider 16.1% 14.8% 1.3%
Splitter 16.5% 15.5% 1.0%
Change 15.6% 15.1% 0.5%
Curve 12.6% 12.1% 0.4%
Two-Seam 5.7% 5.3% 0.4%
Four-Seam 7.6% 7.3% 0.3%
Cutter 10.1% 10.0% 0.1%
Sinker 5.4% 5.3% 0.0%
Knuckle Curve 13.2% 13.8% -0.6%
2015, Hot is over 60 degrees, Cold under.

But we’re not done yet, because the reason behind these whiff rates is not completely obvious. We can blame the fingers, perhaps, but why is the cutter affected so much less? The negative difference for the knuckle curve may just be a product of sample size, but why is that breaking ball on the other side of the list? What’s the hitter’s role in this?

So you ask pitchers a little more about what they do to stay warm. Pocket warmers in every pocket, joked Matt Shoemaker. Hot breath on the finger tips. Shaking the arms to keep the blood flowing. Even just running. “I like to be sweaty even before I pick up a ball,” said Coloradan Kevin Gausman to Laurila. “I’ll maybe run for an extra 10 minutes than usual. I’ll do stuff inside. Little things to get my body ready.”

But if you think that sweat is just about getting nice and warm, listen again. Some of it is just about getting loose, yes. Muscles take longer to get warm in cold weather. “In really cold weather, it seems like you need about 15 to 20 pitches to really start feeling loose,” said the Rays’ Farquhar. “Sitting around is not a good thing. You have to keep your body moving. Talking to Dana [Eveland] last night, he got cold in the dugout between innings and his first pitch, he plunked Jackie Bradley Jr. He said the eight pitches from the mound weren’t enough for him to get loose.”

On the other hand, the sweat itself has value. Axford’s strategy for the cold gets at it: “More blowing in your hands, trying to get some of that moisture on your fingers.” Samardzija puts it into focus for us, though, when he says “Normally when you’re out there, you’re sweating, and you have something to put on the ball for grip.” Sweat acts as the body’s natural grip-provider in dry, cold weather.

So, perhaps the weather is affecting their ability to get a grip on the ball. That should change the movement on the pitches. Chris Archer thought it was possible, at least, when he told Laurila that “maybe” there is a difference on pitch types “if you look deep into the data. Maybe there are a couple more inches of break if it’s warmer.”

Pitch-Type Movements by Weather
Pitch Type Cold X Cold Z Hot X Hot Z Diff Z Diff X
Cutter 0.58 5.94 1.27 5.58 -0.36 0.70
Four-Seam -1.51 9.45 -1.70 9.11 -0.34 -0.19
Two-Seam -2.75 6.37 -2.15 6.10 -0.27 0.59
Curve 2.74 -5.01 3.21 -5.07 -0.05 0.48
Slider 1.59 1.32 1.65 1.27 -0.04 0.05
Change -1.49 4.55 -1.50 4.57 0.02 -0.01
Splitter -6.05 2.75 -4.56 2.88 0.13 1.50
Knuckle Curve 3.47 -5.78 3.76 -5.47 0.31 0.29
2015, Hot is over 60 degrees, Cold under. X = horizontal movement, Z = vertical movement.

Huh. The slider is the least changed, really. And the pitches that did about the same in cold and warm from the table above? They get a lot less drop in cold weather. Strange.

Maybe the cold itself is changing the movement of the pitches? I asked Baseball Physicist Alan Nathan about that. “All other things equal (same speed and spin), there will be about 2.3% less movement at 40 degrees than at 90 degrees, assuming 50% relative humidity at both temperatures,” he said. He also translated himself: “That is not a very large effect and not even close to the effect due to the elevation difference between Coors and sea level (that is around 20%).”

Nathan did wonder if weather-induced poor grip on the ball was affecting the ball in a way that the movement numbers aren’t fully capturing. “As you point out, cold and dry exacerbates the slippery-ball issue, making it more difficult to get spin on the ball. Less spin means less movement,” he said. And there is a bit of a weather effect on spin, if only crudely judged by month. Here are average four-seam spin rates by month. You see that they peak with the weather.

4-Seam Spin Rate by Month2

Still, it’s not a big effect, and it doesn’t show in the movement numbers for all of the pitches. Perhaps what’s happening here is that we aren’t studying the right thing when we study only temperature. Oakland’s Chris Bassitt, who is from Ohio and hasn’t had a problem pitching in the cold (“I’ve pitched in cold forever. I’m just warm, I guess.”) does have a problem in a certain warm park in the big leagues. “I feel it big time in Arizona, when it’s dry. Lack of humidity is the worst. Cold doesn’t affect me one bit,” the starter said.

Suddenly you hear that in everybody’s responses. Ryan Dull throws a ton of sliders for the Athletics and agreed that the feel on the ball was the thing, and that humidity always helps there. Sergio Romo grew up in Colorado, and feels the slider fine in cold weather. “I do notice in more humidity that it snaps off better,” he added, though. “So it’s more about physics than feel.”

So we have competing effects here. Cold days are generally drier, yes, but they aren’t always. On a cold, wet day — the kind of day neither my mother nor I would love — pitches move well and pitchers get good grip on the ball. A cold, dry day has weather that would reduce the pitch movement just a bit, and then also makes the grip on the ball tougher to get right.

And while the pitcher is trying to struggle through all of this, the hitter’s even worse off. He loses 3.3 feet off his batted balls per ten degrees in temperature, according to Nathan. And even if pitchers can lose up to a tick on their fastball in temperatures lower than 50 degrees, as Jeff Zimmerman found, hitters may become over-aware of a certain type of fastball in cold weather.

Layne told Laurila the conventional wisdom (“Anything that has good action in on hitters is typically the most successful pitch, because they don’t want to get jammed. It hurts their hands when they get jammed”) and Jeff Samardzija agreed (“But you can pitch inside to hitters more because they don’t want that feeling of hitting the ball off the handle in the cold”).

Turns out, pitchers could take more advantage of this situation than they do. Well, lefties do some, at least. When lefties throw to lefties in cold weather, they go inside 7% more often than in hot weather. When they throw to righties, the go inside 3% more often. Righties, for some reason, throw inside just about the same, no matter the weather.

Maybe we don’t know exactly why the slider is worse in bad weather. Or if it’s actually worse in practice, or just in the heads of pitchers. But we do know that the marketplace of baseball has shown us that the slider happens less in cold weather. As Fernandez said, “A fastball, you always feel good with. In cold weather, you’re going to use your fastball more.”

He’s right, but mostly about the sinker, which gets the most love in cold weather. To wit:

Pitch Type Percentages by Weather
Pitch Type Hot% Cold% Diff
Four-Seamer 36.6% 35.9% -0.7%
Slider 16.6% 16.1% -0.6%
Cutter 5.6% 5.4% -0.2%
Knuckle Curve 2.0% 1.8% -0.2%
Splitter 1.1% 1.1% 0.0%
Change 9.5% 9.5% 0.1%
Curve 7.5% 7.7% 0.2%
Sinker 7.3% 7.6% 0.3%
Two-Seam 13.4% 14.4% 1.0%
2015, Hot is over 60 degrees, Cold under.

Don’t feel bad for a pitcher out there. Not only are they living the life, but they actually probably don’t feel that cold. As Dull said, “There is an adrenaline thing, though, out on the big-league mound you don’t usually feel cold.” We aren’t whining about pitchers feeling bad on the mound.

We are talking about the way weather can affect the pitcher, though. And it looks like the cold means fewer sliders, more sinkers, a little less drop on a few pitches — and yet despite all this, the advantage still goes to the pitcher, as runs per game move slowly up as the temperature rises. Looks like pitchers side with my mother in a weird way: the temperature is irrelevant. They just want moisture.





With a phone full of pictures of pitchers' fingers, strange beers, and his two toddler sons, Eno Sarris can be found at the ballpark or a brewery most days. Read him here, writing about the A's or Giants at The Athletic, or about beer at October. Follow him on Twitter @enosarris if you can handle the sandwiches and inanity.

22 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
raws
10 years ago

Glad to have some answers for this early season question!

I am under the impression that time of day matters for some players and assumed Fangraphs does not offer day/night splits because statistics are not significant enough to support that claim. Elsewhere I read about the relationship between blue eyed hitters and the effect of the sun on vision. The cold affects players differently, as demonstrated above, it stands to reason that time of day might have an affect on a player. Prevalence of flu like symptoms for day games in big cities?

raws
10 years ago
Reply to  raws

*an effect

RB242
10 years ago

Eno – every original, new idea article we get to read from you is fantastic. Going to enjoy you for as long as your work is for free. I’m sure you’ll be an employee of an mlb team soon enough.

free-range turducken
10 years ago

So now we have a number for the impact of number pitching fingers. Very cool.

Dick Monfort
10 years ago

*number of

bjoakMember since 2020
10 years ago

Really good stuff. I’d like to see the bottom lines even if they’re generalizations. Every 10 degrees warmer raises ERA by how much? K/9, BB/9, K%, BB%? Also, there’s little mention of home runs, which would account for most of the hitter advantage in warmth, I’d think.

igloo
10 years ago

Might just be my favourite fangraphs article!

raws
10 years ago
Reply to  igloo

Another positive to the article is the use of player perception with the data. This sort of parallel text is useful. Hope to see more work like it.

Swfcdan
10 years ago

““The ball is a pool cue, it’s hard as a rock.”

I don’t know how you could use the ball as a pool cue Shark, I think you mean a cue ball.

Emmett RoseMember since 2017
10 years ago

I wonder what production is like for hitters like on pitches inside on cold days? Does it decrease significantly?

Nathaniel Dawson
10 years ago

Awesome stuff, Eno. It makes me want to look at this for a few hours and try to piece together what’s going on.

Confusing, though, when you have the x axis presented before the z axis in the first two sets in the second table, then switch it to z axis before x axis in the summary set.

Odd results, in that you would expect less drop from pitches in cold weather, as most pitches have some kind of backspin, and movement (up) should be amplified in denser air. Opposite for the curve, you would expect more drop in cold weather, and we see it actually gets less drop in cold weather, although the difference seems trivial. Man, there’s a lot to parse through here.

jlongrc
10 years ago

I wonder if PITCHf/x can capture the lateness/tightness of the break on the pitch, which may be too subjective. I would suspect that you could have a similar total break but less deception.

ryangillman
10 years ago

Did you try looking at the same differences except adjusting for humidity instead of temperature?

chasfhMember since 2018
10 years ago

As great a subject for research as this is, I don’t think using a strict cutoff of 60 degrees as the difference between “cold” and “hot” is good enough. In this scenario, 61 degrees is “hot” and 59 degrees is “cold”, when in reality they are practically the same.

Any chance you could split it up into three bands? Maybe 80 and over would be “hot”, 45 and under would be “cold”, and everything in between would be average. Or maybe even four bands: 46-59 is low average, 60-79 is high average, given that 46 degrees and 79 degrees aren’t the same, either.

Point being, I would like to see the difference between actual cold temperatures and actual hot temperatures, to see whether the difference is more stark.

Owen PoindexterMember since 2016
10 years ago

By gum, Eno, you’ve done it again! Did people really use to say “by gum”? Either way, fantastic article.

jjhall
10 years ago

Not sure what Nathan meant when he said movement would only change by 2.3%. Going from 40F to 90F is a 10% change in absolute temperature (~500R to ~550R), which means a 10% change in density. That’s not quite as much as the ~18% decrease in density going from sea level to Denver, but it’s significant.

MGL
10 years ago

“All other things equal (same speed and spin), there will be about 2.3% less movement at 40 degrees than at 90 degrees, assuming 50% relative humidity at both temperatures,” he said.”

Allan, shouldn’t there be MORE movement at cold temperatures. Higher density means more magnus force right?

Although depends on what we mean by “movement” and what pitch. An overhand fastball will “move” downward more in hot weather because there is LESS upward magnus force, right? An overhand curve will “move” downward more in COLD weather because there is MORE downward magnus force.

Horizontal movement should always be MORE in cold weather right since there isn’t any gravity acting on it.

Alan NathanFanGraphs Staff
10 years ago

My apologies to Eno and the rest of you. I must have been half asleep when I talked on the phone with Eno about this topic. Let me correct some serious mistakes:

1. There is more spin-induced movement in cold weather, not less. Cold air is more dense than warm air.

2. As jjhall correctly said, the air density is ~10% larger at 40F than at 90F (not 2.3% as I said).

Mea culpa!

MGL
10 years ago
Reply to  Alan Nathan

Alan, you said “2.3% more movement.” Does a 10% increase in density correspond to 10% more movement, i.e., is movement proportional to density.

Alan NathanFanGraphs Staff
10 years ago
Reply to  MGL

Yes, movement (due to spin) is proportional to air density. So, for a given spin and speed there is 10% more movement at 40F than at 90F. Of course, it could very well be true that a pitcher can’t put as much spin on the ball in cold and dry weather because of the slippery surface. If we had Statcast/Trackman data on spin (measured but not publicly available), we could possible measure this effect.

jjhall
10 years ago
Reply to  Alan Nathan

Thanks for your response. Based on your other work, I assumed that was just a mistake.

Personally, I think this is a fascinating topic that deserves a lot more investigation, and perhaps ultimately adjustments to metrics. For example, we know that the water content in the ball has a significant effect (see Colorado’s humidor). How does temperature affect the rate at which a ball gains or loses water? How does temperature affect coefficient of restitution? How does water content affect a ball’s seams and therefore lift/drag coefficients? These are probably more science project questions, but I think the answers have an effect on outcomes in the game.

Alan NathanFanGraphs Staff
10 years ago
Reply to  jjhall

You bring up some interesting points, some of which have been investigated. See http://baseball.physics.illinois.edu/AJP-June2011.pdf, part V, for affect of humidity and temperature on the COR and weight. Also, see Ref. 17 of that paper, where the effect of humidity on the size and weight of the ball was investigated. When the ball absorbs water, it gets a bit larger and heavier. Larger decreases the carry; heavier increase the carry. As far as I know, there have been no investigations of how temperature affects the rate at which the ball absorbs or loses water.