White Sox Reunite with Adam Eaton on One-Year Pact

It doesn’t feel like hyperbole to say one of the most important days in the recent history of the White Sox was Dec. 7, 2016, when they traded Adam Eaton to Washington in return for Lucas Giolito, Reynaldo López, and Dane Dunning. Giolito is now the staff ace and one of the best pitchers in the American League, having compiled 7.1 WAR over the past two seasons. López has been less successful as a back-of-the-rotation arm who hovered just below league average from 2018 to ’19 before falling below replacement level last year, but he’s still provided 4.1 WAR over the last three seasons. Dunning was just shipped out to acquire another right-handed ace in Lance Lynn from the Rangers. A lot of wins can already be credited to the Eaton deal, and more will be added to the ledger by the time all is said and done.

Perhaps it’s cosmically fair, then, that Eaton will now reap the rewards of the roster he played such a key role in rebuilding. NBC Sports Chicago’s Chuck Garfien reported on Tuesday that Eaton will be rejoining the White Sox on a one-year deal, with a team option in place for 2022. The signing comes four years and one day after the team traded him to Washington.

Chicago first acquired Eaton after the 2013 season, in a three-team, six-player deal with the Diamondbacks and Angels that also established new homes for Mark Trumbo, Hector Santiago and the late Tyler Skaggs. Eaton, a former 19th-round pick out of the University of Miami (Ohio), immediately broke out in Chicago’s outfield, compiling 13.5 WAR over three seasons thanks to a .290/.362/.422 line (119 wRC+) and sometimes elite defense. His best season — a 2016 that included a 117 wRC+, 26 defensive runs saved in the outfield, and 5.9 WAR — earned him down-ballot MVP votes, but it came on a White Sox team that finished 78–84, spinning its tires despite the presence of stars like Jose Quintana and Chris Sale. Chicago hit the reset button, and with Eaton coming off a career year and having four years left on his owner-friendly contract extension, he became quite a valuable trade chip.

Eaton seemed like a good fit for a championship-ready Nationals squad with holes to fill in its outfield, but his honeymoon with Washington was short-lived. His 2017 season lasted just 23 games before he tore his ACL running out a ground ball, and he missed two more months in ’18 with bone bruises on his ankle. He finally turned in a full season for the title-winning 2019 Nationals and compiled 2.3 WAR with a 107 wRC+, only to return as a shell of himself in 2020, hitting just .226/.285/.384 (75 wRC+) with four homers in 41 games. He was half a win below replacement level, and Washington declined his $10.5 million team option after the season.

Eaton was able to recoup most of that with his one-year deal in Chicago, which was in need of a starting right fielder after non-tendering Nomar Mazara. Filling that spot in the order was seen as a chance for the White Sox to aim high — George Springer and Marcell Ozuna are potentially transformative bats at the top of the market, while other options like Michael Brantley, Joc Pederson, and Jackie Bradley Jr. rank in the top half of our Top 50 Free Agents list. Craig Edwards’ most recent payroll analysis has the White Sox spending much less than their market size warrants, so the resources to add a big name should be available.

Instead, Chicago opted for a 32-year-old with a modest power ceiling and waning defensive skills coming off the worst season of his career. Eaton had various problems in 2020. He raised his swing rate nearly seven points to the highest mark of his career, resulting in a walk rate of just 6.8%, more than two points below his career average. All of that swinging resulted in a lot of contact — he was in the 91st percentile of baseball in whiff rate — but he still posted his highest strikeout rate since 2015.

When Eaton put the ball in play, he also couldn’t achieve the same luck he has in the past. His ability to leg out bunt and infield singles declined, and a career .335 BABIP plummeted to a .260 mark in 2020. Because Eaton doesn’t hit for much power, his offensive value is sustained by his ability to convert line drives and grounders into singles and to work an above-average rate of walks. When he can’t do that and doesn’t have even average defensive numbers to bolster his case, you’re probably better off calling up someone from Triple-A to take his spot in the lineup.

The White Sox clearly don’t think Eaton has reached that point, likely for a few reasons. He just turned 32 this week, an age that typically means you’re past your prime but not one where you expect production to tank completely. Despite the knee and ankle injuries, Eaton can still run pretty well — he was in the 74th percentile of Statcast’s sprint speed metric this year and up to the 81st percentile the year before, which is pretty close to where he was when he was having his best seasons on defense as well as on the bases. He should avoid challenging Luis Robert to pre-game foot races, but his legs and instincts should still help add value.

His raw tools appear to be holding up in other areas as well. Eaton’s exit velocity in 2020 was down from the previous year, but only by a single mile per hour. He isn’t having trouble catching up to fastballs, as his whiff rate against the hard stuff actually just hit its lowest point since 2014. His line-drive rate has remained steady, as has his distribution of where he’s hitting the ball.

The White Sox, then, are betting that Eaton’s problems are easier to solve than it may appear. If he still runs well, perhaps fixing his defense — where he’s dropped from +27 DRS in 980.1 innings in right in 2016 to -6 DRS in 335 innings in 2020 — could be solved with better positioning, or other subtle tweaks. If his contact skills are still in place, maybe you can salvage his K/BB rates by nudging him back toward his more selective approach of the past. Perhaps there’s a 3-WAR player still here, and it’s just going to take a little elbow grease to bring him back out. The idea of achieving that while reuniting with a former fan favorite might make all that work seem worth it.





Tony is a contributor for FanGraphs. He began writing for Red Reporter in 2016, and has also covered prep sports for the Times West Virginian and college sports for Ohio University's The Post. He can be found on Twitter at @_TonyWolfe_.

27 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
D-WizMember since 2019
5 years ago

I’m hopeful Eaton can bounce back (I think he’s very fun to watch when healthy), but I’d imagine this signing is disappointing to White Sox fans given the other available options mentioned in the article…

dan harmonMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  D-Wiz

Can confirm this was not my ideal choice.

And I know this is Fangraphs but signing Eaton also brings along a question of personality fit. He’s an infamous red-ass, and how that will fit with a group of younger, looser, fun-playing teammates is a legitimate concern.

But then again, they hired Tony LaRussa so maybe the whole point is to make the whole team more buttoned down.

Great work, team!

carterMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  dan harmon

I wonder if that is it, actually. They maybe think the team is too loose in the locker room, and Reinsdorf is getting emotional watching The Last Dance reruns and wants to change the mindset, so he goes and gets LaRussa and Eaton . It is very hard to think of any other reason honestly, those two guys might be the last two guys who would fit in well in Chicago in the entire MLB, so it has to be the point, right?

Connor Grey
5 years ago

I have no idea what kind of money and contract length Joc Pederson and his agent are demanding. But all things bring equal, I’d rather have Joc than Eaton if I were the White Sox.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Connor Grey

In a vacuum, I think this is a pretty good move. But if you believe Joc Pederson isn’t broken (which he might be?) he is by far the most cost-effective upgrade to the roster. The only way to really improve the offense is to upgrade against right-handed pitching, and Joc Pederson has a wRC+ of 131 against righties since 2018, including his truly awful 2020. And I can’t imagine Pederson is going to get much more than Eaton did here.

On top of that, George Springer and Michael Brantley have been even better against right-handed batters, although they’ll probably cost a lot more (and Brantley’s defense is bad). David Peralta is probably available. And among guy with similar batting lines to Eaton against righties but being more durable, but Eddie Rosario is still out there (I don’t think Kyle Schwarber is really an option for a team also playing Eloy Jimenez in the outfield).

I like this move, but I think the main rationale for this move over the others is that they could come to an agreement with Eaton now (maybe because he’d already played there). And White Sox fans will just have to hope they go after Conforto next year. Heck, maybe they could even go after Rosario now and let Eaton play a 4th outfielder role, given all of his many maladies.

OtterMember since 2016
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

It’s highly doubtful, but IF the Sox do sign another outfielder from the Pederson/Schwarber/Rosario group, this signing isn’t as bad. (Schwarber still, in theory, makes sense of the Sox as Eaton’s defense isn’t horrible and he can play either corner, meanwhile Schwarber could DH/play left as well as Eloy against righties once in a while). But I don’t see the Sox spending another $10 million-ish on a fifth outfielder/DH especially with Vaughn probably getting the call up in May/June.

I think I’d rather roll the dice with Mazara for less money one more year than hope Eaton isn’t washed for an extra few million and sign one of Brantley, Pederson, Rosario than Eaton and nothing else.

bradidas
5 years ago

The number of “if”s and “might”s in the conclusion sums up this signing pretty well.

MikeSMember since 2020
5 years ago

Looking at his whole career, he checks a lot of boxes. He hits lefthanded. He walks some. He plays good defense, so between having him and Robert patrolling > 80% of the outfield you don’t have to ask Jimenez to do much defensively, which is the right amount for Jimenez to do in the field. If he can still do that stuff he’s a good fit. Even if he can’t he is still probably an upgrade. The White Sox have gotten 2 WAR out of RF in the four years since he left and that includes the 4.2 they got from Avasail Garcia in 2017.

Still, I can’t help but notice that teams like the Dodgers go get Mookie Betts in his prime and the White Sox go get a pretty good guy on the downslope of his career.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  MikeS

To be fair, Adam Eaton costs about $350M less than Mookie Betts, and the circumstances that led them to acquire and extend Betts were a bit hard to predict in advance. George Springer would be better for them than Eaton and is a much more relevant counterfactual. But Yasmani Grandal (and to a lesser extent, Keuchel) worked out pretty well for them. And the Abreu contract didn’t make sense at the time but seems to have worked out well for them in retrospect.

I guess I don’t really see how Mookie Betts makes a lot of sense as a reference point.

MikeSMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

You can sub Springer in there, that works fine too. The point is, a few teams identify a need and then do everything they can to fill that need with the best possible upgrade and most teams look for bargains and hope for bounceback years. Even Grandal and Keuchel were relative bargains after they had trouble getting the deals they wanted the year before.

I’m not labeling them as cheap, that’s outdated, unfair, and reductive. They offered a lot of money to guys like Wheeler and Harper. They gave Abreu a lot more than anybody else would have and I agree that has already gone better than expected. It’s just that they clearly still aren’t really playing by the same rules as the big boys.

Kevbot034
5 years ago

I think this is a fine signing; not what Sox fans probably hoped for, but still an improvement to what they had. Robles fielding was not good last year, and so likely made Eaton look worse. Getting into the OF with Robert will probably help him out a good deal.

TribeToTheEndMember since 2016
5 years ago

Isn’t the elephant in the room here team culture / cohesion as an organization? The Sox have a core of young, fun players, and I can’t imagine that group would have had TLR or Eaton as their first choice, given the latter’s questionable comments about minor leaguers or random strange feuds in the past few years. It seems like a weird move given how small of an on-field upgrade it will be.

r24j
5 years ago

I’m not sure dumpster diving for Adam Eaton, when there’s many OFs on the market who aren’t abhorrently bad people, is a good idea. Seems like the White Sox are dedicated to tainting their young and exciting roster with poor cultural fits. I don’t know. He could be fine, but that’s it. At a point, I’d just go for Jackie Bradley or something instead.

Max Power
5 years ago
Reply to  r24j

Question: Why would JBJ go to a team that won’t play him in CF and would value him as a corner OF instead of a team that needs a CF and would value him as such?

VinnieDaGooch
5 years ago
Reply to  r24j

Abhorrent seems like a very strong word. Did I miss Eaton committing a serious crime or something?

Psychic... Powerless...
5 years ago
Reply to  VinnieDaGooch

Agreed. I keep seeing negative comments about him, but they’re all very general. What specifically has he done or said that is objectionable?

Cave Dameron
5 years ago

Eaton said that Chicago style pizza is better than NY style. Unacceptable.

Max Power
5 years ago

In a discussion about the pay and quality of life for Minor Leaguers, he said something about how his MiLB experience was a positive because it toughened him up and made him hungry/relentless/athlete cliches yadda-yadda. A bit out of touch perhaps.

He also didn’t get along with Todd Frazier because he thought he was a tool, but that qualification would make like 75% of baseball fans abhorrent.

And he was vocally pro-Drake LaRoche.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Max Power

I just googled Drake LaRoche and Adam Eaton and wow, the White Sox in 2016 really were stuck in the dumbest timeline, weren’t they? Sounds like Eaton had a lot of enemies in the White Sox clubhouse. Normally I think personality stuff is overblown but that does make me like this deal less.

natsfan1
5 years ago
Reply to  Max Power

LOL. Eaton called Drake “a leader.” I missed that at the time. But all I know about Eaton is he had two excellent, almost identical seasons in Chicago (2015-16), and after finally getting over serious (ACL) and nagging injuries, he was a major cog in an amazing 2019 Nats World Series win. Both on and off the field, he was a winner in DC. Hard to know what his 2020 means (heck, even Yelich batted .205 last year). I suspect Eaton still has some game at 32, and perhaps he has been brought in as a “maturing” influence on all those youngsters. However, I do agree that his signing, this soon, with the Sox, seems surprising. Maybe they just loved having him around before, but his road as a baseball journeyman may be beginning.

Smiling PolitelyMember since 2018
5 years ago

Replacing Mazara with Eaton is like replacing my 1978 Yugo with a 1979 Ford Pinto. You’re 1-2 players away from a championship run and your big push is…Adam Eaton? With Ozuna out there? Uf.

Max Power
5 years ago

Eaton is hardly the best option to fill RF, but I get confused at a lot of the names thrown out here and other places as better options.

On the one hand, Springer and JBJ can clearly play above-average to great defense in CF. That’s a position the White Sox don’t need. Teams that do need a CF (e.g., TOR/NYM/HOU) will put higher value on players like that, not to mention the players themselves would likely rather play CF.

On the other hand, guys like Brantley/Ozuna/Schwarber/Rosario are not RFers, especially not on a team with Eloy already in LF. The White Sox need a DH and reportedly are still interested in Brantley, but DH seems like a position you’d address later in the offseason, with the players having incentive to wait and see what the NL DH situation is going to be like.

It’s not that Eaton can be counted on as a great defender or player. Pederson, depending on what he signs for, really stands out as a better option, though it seems either Eaton or Pederson would be platooning with Engel. But it’s hardly as if there were 10 options and they picked the worst one.

OtterMember since 2016
5 years ago
Reply to  Max Power

I think it’s more that the names mentioned are better or have higher upsides than Eaton… and someone like Eaton is probably still available in February. The Sox rushed to sign someone who they could probably have for less in a few weeks while also potentially/likely preventing themselves from signing someone better. Signing Brantley/Schwarber/Rosario would make the Eaton signing a lot less bad… but there are no signs the Sox are going to do that.

35 Kittle 83Member since 2022
5 years ago

My WSox are 0-2 in signing various Adams from Washington this century. ( LaRoche and Done) Hopefully Eaton can rediscover his 2016 magic for this year. This is just a one year contract rather than those toilet flushes of a contract given to those prior Adams that were four years each. White Sox are going for it this year so that roster spot does need to be productive. If Eaton is bad cut bait and work a trade mid season.

MRDXolMember since 2021
5 years ago

Would be worth mentioning that Eaton will likely be a strong-side platoon player. He’s not a huge platoon split guy for his career, but he was last year, with a 100 wRC+ against RHP and a -1 (!) wRC+ vs LHP. Meanwhile, Sox 4th OF Adam Engel has hit lefties pretty well the past two years (122 wRC+, albeit in a SSS), and as a true CF should provide well-above-average RF defense.

Joc Pederson would’ve made more sense for this role, since he’s been a strong-side platoon RF his whole career, but probably better at it than Eaton will be. I would have to guess that he wants significantly more money than Eaton. That said, I didn’t love Springer, Ozuna, or Brantley in RF for the Sox, mostly because 1) the Eaton + Engel platoon should produce 2.5-3.5 WAR in total, and the added price of Springer would be better spent on pitching for this team, and 2) defensive concerns for the latter two with Eloy’s misadventures in LF already.

There’s been some comments about Eaton’s culture fit, which are entirely fair given his history with the White Sox; that said, the Athletic piece on this move indicated that the CHW FO asked the players how they felt about adding Eaton, including “veteran leaders” who played w/ him in 2016— which could only be Abreu & Anderson, the faces of the franchise— and they greenlit it.

pedeysRSox
5 years ago

If I was the White Sox I’d rather have Mel Rojas Jr who just signed with the Hanshin Tigers on a two year $5 million deal.

Chris KMember since 2020
5 years ago

Acquisition of a platoon partner for Engel at $7MM for one year looks a whole lot worse now that the Rangers have Dahl for $3MM.

Coupled with the Lynn rental fleecing, I’m steeling myself for disappointment until Reinsdorf’s kids sell the team and new ownership fires the garbage fire KW/Hahn tandem. This may be the worst FO in baseball, and ownership is far too cheap to patch over their incompetence. Hopefully the second core they obtained as a reward for sucking for so long after waving the last white flag will at least make it interesting. But this FO will never have the competence or money to put them over the top, so at this point Sox fans have to bank on all of the young guns to take another developmental step.