Why I Voted for Clayton Kershaw For NL Cy Young

For the second year in a row, I was given the opportunity to cast a ballot for the National League Cy Young Award. For the second year in a row, this was a very difficult task.

Last year, I had to pick between three aces who had historic seasons, finally settling on Jake Arrieta by the tiniest of margins over Clayton Kershaw and Zack Greinke. This year, no pitcher pitched a full season at the level that those three reached a year ago, so this year’s task was more about picking between good-but-flawed seasons rather than trying to decide which great year was the greatest.

And there was no shortage of options. In the end, I strongly considered eight players for the five spots we were asked to rank, and the guys who ended up at six through eight all had very strong cases for spots on the ballot. While the ordinal-rank system will make it look I saw a real difference between the guys ranked #3-#5 and the three notable omissions, the reality is that there was a six car pile-up at the back end of my ballot, and I think you have to split hairs to pick between the three guys who rounded out my ballot and the three guys who just missed.

But, it is an ordinal rank ballot, so let’s go through the ballot spot-by-spot so I can explain my rationale.

With Apologies To: Jon Lester, Johnny Cueto, and Madison Bumgarner

These guys were all terrific, and deserve recognition for the years they put together. Bumgarner and Cueto were second and third in the league in innings pitched respectively, while Lester finished sixth, so they all met the workhorse burden. Lester led the league in RA9-WAR, so if you just want to give a pitcher credit for everything that happens while he’s on the mound, you could make a case for him at the top of your ballot.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage

Bumgarner can hit too, and since I believe the award is to reward players at a specific position, not for a specific action, I think that a pitcher’s batting line should be a factor in the voting; it is part of the job description for NL pitchers, and impacts their teams chances of winning or losing, just as their own fielding impacts their team’s run prevention when they are on the mound. So while Bumgarner’s pitching-only numbers don’t quite stack up to the rest of this field, his value at the plate put him squarely in this group, and got him strong consideration for a spot on my ballot.

But for each of these guys, there was just enough there for me to push them barely outside the top five.

For Lester, it was the Cubs defense, and their impact on his run prevention, which made it difficult for me to give him full credit for the run prevention that occurred while he was pitching. While we don’t have perfect tools for separating pitching from fielding yet, the metrics we do have suggest that Lester was a little bit less responsible for the outs on balls in play he got than the other Cubs starter who was part of my top eight.

And the impact of those outs on balls in play couldn’t have been larger; Lester ran a .215 BABIP with men in scoring position, and the contact numbers just don’t suggest that Lester had a lot to do with that. So while his run prevention numbers are excellent, I didn’t want to reward him for the performance of his teammates.

For Cueto, the small marks against him were his performance at the plate and the presence of Buster Posey as his catcher. Cueto was one of the worst-hitting pitchers in the game this year, and so the Giants chances of winning his starts were a little bit reduced. Additionally, Posey ranked as the game’s best framing catcher by almost every framing metric out there, so just like we had to adjust Lester’s run prevention for the players behind him, Cueto gets a small downgrade for throwing to a catcher who makes pitchers look better than they are.

Bumgarner also gets a little bit of a downgrade for the Posey factor, but he also took a hit because 10 of the runs he allowed this year were categorized as unearned. The earned/unearned run categorization is pretty arbitrary, and looking at ERA versus RA as a way to try and account for defensive support is misguided, so Bumgarner’s actual results aren’t quite as good as ERA makes them look. And they were already a bit behind the other five guys, so even with his strong offensive results, Bumgarner just missed the cut for me. A great season, unquestionably, but like Lester and Cueto, there were just enough factors there for me to leave him outside the top five.

#5: Jose Fernandez, Miami

To be clear; this was not a vote to honor Fernandez because of his tragic death. After thinking about our responsibilities as voters, I decided that we were asked to solely determine which pitcher performed the best this year, and that it would not honor Fernandez’s legacy to consider his passing as a factor for this award. So I placed Fernandez fifth because of what he did for the Marlins this year, and not as an attempt at a tribute to a person we’ll miss greatly.

On the field, Fernandez was excellent, racking up the league’s best strikeout rate while posting the league’s fifth-lowest home run rate. That’s a pretty nifty combination of offensive suppression. By Baseball Prospectus’ DRA, which takes a stab at untangling all the values that go into run prevention, Fernandez was actually the best pitcher in the NL this year. And he hit pretty well too, running a .242 wOBA in 61 plate appearances, the sixth-best mark in the NL.

But there is one mark against him; that .332 BABIP, which led to worse run prevention than the run estimators would suggest. So, like with the Cubs pitchers, the question is how much of that we think was Fernandez versus his teammate’s performance. Unlike with the Cubs pitchers, though, there are some reasons to think that reflects some poor pitching. For one, Fernandez had a 28% line drive rate, easily the highest in the National League. And while line drive categorization can be subject to interpretation, some Statcast data shows that Fernandez did allow harder average contact than the other contenders for this list, and given that the Marlins had an above-average defense this year, signs start to point to Fernandez’s pitching having more to do with his BABIP than poor defensive support.

Of course, we don’t have all this figured out perfectly, and untangling pitching and defense remains the hardest part of these awards. Perhaps I’m putting too much weight on Fernandez’s BABIP here, and he should be several spots higher on the list, but based on our current understanding of the data, this is where I was most comfortable with him.

#4: Kyle Hendricks, Chicago

I know it looks weird to leave Lester off the ballot while putting Hendricks fourth, given that both succeeded by running low BABIPs in front of the Cubs defense. But at the risk of spending all of our time talking about how to assign credit for batted ball results, let me quote from Tony Blengino’s piece last week.

Kyle Hendricks is our 2016 NL Contact Manager of the Year… Hendricks allowed the least authoritative fly-ball contact in the NL and his average fly-ball velocity allowed was over two full STD lower than average.

Yes, the Cubs defense helped Hendricks this year, but perhaps to a smaller magnitude than it helped Lester. As Tony noted, Hendricks allowed a lot of weak fly balls, the types that are caught by just about anyone. Hendricks also allowed fewer home runs, which are runs that definitively can’t be blamed on the team’s fielders, which is another point in his favor of being the most worthy Cubs candidate this year. Toss in that he didn’t get the benefit of having a personal catcher to help curtail issues with the running game, and I give Hendricks just a few slight nods over Lester as the Cubs best pitcher for 2016.

But, like with Lester, we can’t completely ignore the fact that he pitched in front of one of the best defenses we’ve seen in recent years, and giving him full credit for his run prevention is not something I’m willing to do; his teammates impacted that number in a real way as well. So, combined with the fact that he threw just 190 innings, he fit best on my ballot in the fourth spot. Hendricks was terrific, but in a lower quantity of innings than most of the other excellent run preventers, and the numbers we know were mostly under his control just don’t quite stack up to the three guys in front of him.

#3: Noah Syndergaard, New York

Syndergaard and Fernandez had similar years in almost every respect. Thor was #1 among qualified pitchers in the NL in FIP, at 2.29; Fernandez was second, at 2.30. Syndergaard threw 183 2/3 innings in 30 starts; Fernandez threw 182 1/3 innings in 29 starts. And because extreme batted ball results were present with nearly all of the top pitchers in the discussion, Fernandez had a .332 BABIP; Syndergaard was at .334.

So, really, we’re left with the same question we’ve been wrestling with at each stop along the way; how much blame does the Mets ace get for giving up so many hits? With Fernandez, there were reasons to think that he bore a good bit of the responsibility, but this is where the two differ; with Syndegaard, it looks like the Mets just didn’t give him much help.

It’s not like the Mets made their plan much of a secret. After letting Daniel Murphy leave in free agency, the team doubled down on defensively challenged middle infielders, adding Neil Walker and Asdrubal Cabrera to take over as the least rangey 2B/SS combo in the league. They brought back Yoenis Cespedes and stuck him in center field in order to maximize the number of hitters they could get into the line-up, and when he got hurt, they used Curtis Granderson in center to make room for DH-in-the-making Jay Bruce. David Wright played with a serious back problem, and when he was lost for the year, they signed Jose Reyes and made him a third baseman for the first time in his career.

The 2016 Mets season was one big gamble on defense being overrated. Unsurprisingly, the Mets allowed a .308 BABIP as a team, third-worst in the National League, behind two teams that play at altitude in offensive-friendly ballparks. So, yeah, Syndergaard gave up a bunch of hits, but it probably would have been a surprise if he hadn’t, given what the team decided to put around him.

In terms of contact management, Syndergaard actually rated above-average by Blengino’s metric. He had the same average exit velocity as Lester. There just isn’t as much evidence that Thor was giving up hard-hit balls that helped lead to his high BABIP, and as such, I didn’t hold that number against him as heavily as I did with Fernandez.

And on a rate basis, he even out-hit Bumgarner, putting up a .292 wOBA in 67 plate appearances. The biggest knock against Syndergaard is that he’s terrible at holding runners, and thus he might always underperform his FIP to some degree, but even with that downwards adjustment for his own fielding deficiencies, Syndergaard was still one of the best pitchers in the National League this year, and ranked at the top of the second tier of Cy Young candidates on my ballot.

#2: Max Scherzer, Washington

And now we get to the big two. When it came down to it, this was the big decision for me, as these next two pitchers separated themselves from the pack based on my analysis.

Scherzer, I think, is going to win. As I write this post, all I know is that he’s in the final group with the two Cubs, and of that trio, he has the best case.

Even if we just went with the simple runs allowed model of evaluating pitchers, Scherzer would be neck-and-neck with Hendricks and Lester because of the difference in innings pitched; he threw 26 more innings than Lester and 38 more innings than Hendricks. By WAR that is based on runs allowed, that innings difference pulls Scherzer even with Hendricks at +6.9, and half a win behind Lester’s league-leading +7.4 total.

But since we can go beyond runs allowed, the other numbers give us more confidence that Scherzer deserves a larger portion of the credit for those results. Not only did Scherzer dominate the strike zone at an elite level — his 25% K%-BB% was second-best in the NL, behind only Fernandez — but he also has become one of the league’s most formidable pop-up generators.

This year, batters hit 34 infield flies against Scherzer, the highest total of any NL pitcher. Generating infield pop-ups is the most obvious way to suppress your BABIP, and these are the kinds of outs that we can certainly credit to the pitcher, not the fielder; that’s why they’re counted the same as strikeouts in our standard version of pitcher WAR. And those infield flies help push Scherzer well ahead of both Lester and Hendricks, even though their FIPs are all quite similar.

Scherzer combined a league-leading number of innings pitched with elite control of the strike zone and a batted ball profile that gave his fielders easier outs to work with than most pitchers. That’s a pretty great combination, and certainly makes Scherzer a strong Cy Young contender. And he almost got my vote. Except for the next guy on the list still exists.

#1: Clayton Kershaw, Los Angeles

Yes, I voted to give the Cy Young Award to a pitcher who didn’t even throw enough innings to show up on the leaderboards unless you reduce the innings minimum. Because, when I sat down and looked at everything, I couldn’t get away from the fact that Clayton Kershaw was, once again, the best pitcher on the planet in 2016.

I know he’s not going to win, since he wasn’t even a finalist, meaning I am in the minority in supporting excellence in a shortened season over slightly-less-excellent in a full-season. But in terms of overall value, Kershaw was still right there with the guys who threw an extra 40 to 80 innings.

By our standard pitcher WAR, based on FIP with infield flies added, Kershaw ranked #1 in the NL this year. By runs allowed, he ranked 4th, but was 0.1 WAR from being tied for second with Hendricks and Scherzer. Kershaw had a full-season’s worth of everyone else’s value; he just did it in four months instead of six.

So, it came down to whether I think Kershaw would have had a better season had he thrown a couple of mediocre months on top of what he had already done. Yeah, he threw 79 fewer innings than Scherzer, but he gave up 46 fewer runs. If he had limped through two extra months of pitching with a 5.24 RA9, would we think his 2016 was more impressive? Do we need to see great players perform not great for a while in order to validate their greatness just to get to some arbitrary number of innings minimums?

I don’t. I’m a peak performance guy. When it comes to the Hall of Fame, I’d already put Kershaw and Trout in, even if they didn’t do anything else the rest of their careers, because they’re two of the best we’ve ever seen. And in 2016, Kershaw was at his best again, until his back put him on the shelf for a couple of months.

But what he did before the injury was enough for me to say he was the NL’s best pitcher again this year. Had he stayed healthy, it wouldn’t have even been a race, but he consolidated a full year’s worth of value into the time he spent on the mound. For me, he was the best pitcher in the NL this year, and that’s why I put him at the top of my ballot.





Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.

53 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
YKnotDisco
9 years ago

Because he is Clayton Freakin’ Kershaw!

kingscourt25
9 years ago

How does Kershaw not have like 5 Cy Youngs?

kingscourt25
9 years ago
Reply to  kingscourt25

2.06/2.26/2.60 line since ’11. 12 1/2 wins better than the next pitcher. Basically doing a Trout among pitchers.

beckdawg
9 years ago

While I don’t have an issue with Kershaw getting your vote, it does some what bother me that Hendricks doesn’t get more consideration overall. There’s an article published on this site today talking about a pitchers job being “give the team a chance to win.” This season, Hendricks had 9 starts where he gave up 0 runs. He had 8 starts where he gave up 1 run. He had 8 starts where he gave up 2 runs. And he had 3 starts each where he gave up 3 and 4 runs.

If that isn’t giving your team a chance to win I’m not sure what is. I’m fairly certain he was the most consistent pitcher in baseball. You could make the argument that he 0 “bad” starts. 4 runs over 5 innings obviously isn’t spectacular but that’s a winnable game if you’re hitting. And considering that only happened 3 times this entire season that in of itself is remarkable. I get the argument that the cubs defense played a role. But so much of the conversation about Hendricks from the time he was called up has been about what he isn’t. He doesn’t have several plus offerings. He doesn’t throw fast. He relies on soft contact… ect.

I suppose I just lament the fact that being what you are isn’t good enough to win awards. Instead there’s certain criteria you have to meet. Hendricks to me is what is beautiful about the game of baseball. He’s one of the slowest pitchers in baseball and still managed to lead the majors in ERA. Everyone in consideration for a year end award is deserving. I guess I just want there to be something out there for the over achievers. Scherzer and Kershaw are great pitchers and deserve all the praise they get. But frankly, they don’t need a cy young to trumpet their achievements. Guys like Hendricks so rarely get the spotlight it just would have been nice to see him win rather than see people(not just this article) explain away what he did as luck with balls in play or having a superior defense. Strikeouts are sexy but I think if you asked actual pitchers they would respect what Hendricks is able to do more.

alpha309
9 years ago
Reply to  beckdawg

I don’t think the argument for Hendricks should be that he overachieved. That is not really the correct tact to take.

Personally, the fact that he induced such weak contact takes away a lot from the “their defense is amazing” argument. Unless perfectly positioned on the field, weaker hit balls should be much easier to field since they are moving slower, and probably less on a hard line. A sharp grounder is probably much harder to field than a regular bouncer, and a line drive harder to catch than a soft fly.

Yes, Hendricks had an amazing defense behind him, but the weak contact probably helped the defense just as much as they helped him.

beckdawg
9 years ago
Reply to  alpha309

Yeah I believe Maddon said at one point the arguments people were using against Hendricks seem to be more trying to find a reason not to vote for him rather than looking at what he did. It strikes me as odd to essentially penalize pitchers for being on a good team with a great defense. Think there’s a compelling argument to be made that if you know you have a great defense behind you then you’re more likely to throw pitches that may yield ground balls rather than pitching around guys trying to get strikeouts. If you can get an out with 1 pitch why not take it?

Beel418Member since 2017
9 years ago
Reply to  beckdawg

It’s not penalizing the pitchers for pitching in front of a good defense, it’s more just not giving them extra credit for it, there’s a pretty big difference between the two. It’s really no different than park adjustments, is adjusting for pitchers who pitch half their games at AT&T penalizing them?

beckdawg
9 years ago
Reply to  Beel418

Arguably yes. There’s two ways to view things. The first is to take the stance that largely is taken and view things asking whether or not the results are repeatable. And sure in that view using park adjustments and bb/k ratios makes a ton of sense. However, that’s more an attempt to be predictive. The other way you can view things is as results having happened.

The problem I have with essentially suggesting Hendricks’ results aren’t repeatable and then using that as an argument against him is that shouldn’t really matter. For example, should a hitter not win a batting title if he has a monstrous month where his BABIP is insanely high? Baseball is a game about flukey things. Some years the bounces go your way. Hendricks played the hand he was dealt quite well and all the complaints about him were things entirely outside his control. He has little impact on his teams’ defense other than leading the league in soft contact. It wasn’t his decision to go with a 6th starter late in the year costing him 3 starts. It wasn’t his decision to get pulled almost every game under 100 pitches.

If people want to take the first view… I mean that’s their opinion. But for me the question will always be how do you know Hendricks isn’t this good in front of an average defense or how much worse would he be? Does he even pitch the games the same way with a worse defense? You start asking these questions and you’re basically going down the predictive path rather than looking at what actually happened. And as we all are well aware, predictions are often wrong because we either don’t understand the data enough which in Hendricks case could be quite true about soft contact rates or because baseball is a flukey game.

That’s not to say there isn’t rationale for Scherzer or Kershaw or whomever. But Scherzer had a .255 BABIP against and because he looks the part of a cy young pitcher I don’t hear anyone talking about that with regard to him. Hendricks was .250 BABIP. I feel like writers in general don’t give enough credit to the art of pitching. And I get it. It’s hard to sit here and quantify that. It’s far easier to look at k rates and understand their impact. However, Scherzer ran away with the voting. That really shouldn’t have been the case. At the very least the race should have been close. Had Scherzer narrowly won I’d probably cared less.

Wu-Bacca
9 years ago
Reply to  beckdawg

I don’t think that’s quite accurate. I agree with your overall way of seeing things – for retrospective awards, you want to award what a player actually did as opposed to what they should have done, or their true talent level. But what Dave is talking about has nothing to do with retrospective vs. predictive. He’s saying, of all the things that show up on Hendricks’ stat line, how much can be attributed to him (including, yes, his weak contact #’s) and how much can be attributed to his teammates (their fielding, pitch framing, and the like). That has nothing to do with being predictive.

Now, you make a useful point about players being ultimately unextractable. They intentionally work in concert with their teammates, their surroundings, and so on, and you can never totally isolate them. Nevertheless, Hedricks was still given a set of environmental factors not available to Kershaw, so even if we don’t want to completely erase those factors, we don’t want to pretend Hendricks wasn’t given a boost by them either. At the end of the day I don’t think you’ve made a great case that Hendricks did more than Kershaw.

Beel418Member since 2017
9 years ago
Reply to  beckdawg

I get what you’re saying, but some of your concerns were addressed in the BP piece that Dave linked in the article. Scherzer and Hendricks had similar BABIPs, but the Cubs as a team only let up a .255 BABIP. Hendricks’ soft contact didn’t appear to make his defenders catch a significant amount more of his balls in play relative to his teammates. Both Lackey and Hammel gave up well above-average hard contact, but they were both still in the top 10 for lowest BABIP allowed. Regardless of the quality of contact, the Cubs defense turned a well above-average number of balls in play into outs.

As for your other point, is there any evidence to suggest pitchers change their pitching styles based on the defenses behind them (honest question, not saying there isn’t)? That might be something interesting to look into.

PHW
9 years ago

can we expect an angry article on porcello winning over verlander?

jsc1973
9 years ago
Reply to  PHW

Why should anyone be angry about one of the three guys who tied for first in the AL in fWAR winning the CYA? Just because Porcello hasn’t ever been that good before? I don’t think that’s a criterion.

bananas
9 years ago
Reply to  jsc1973

He just wasn’t in the same vicinity as verlander or kluber in managing contact, which means his FIP-beating is probably mostly luck/defense.

jsc1973
9 years ago
Reply to  bananas

And also attributable to his legitimate skill of striking out almost six men for every walk he issued, something that JV and Kluber didn’t come close to. Roy Halladay did this for years–striking out seven and a half per nine and not walking anybody, and piling up wins. Porcello’s only done it once, but he did do it.

PHW
9 years ago
Reply to  jsc1973

some people think verlander deserved it more because of his lower ERA, higher innings pitched, and higher strikeouts, along with being better in almost every other pitching stat

burts_beadsMember since 2016
9 years ago
Reply to  jsc1973

Any of the three deserved to win it as much as the others. I think the controversy will be with the voting, where Verlander got 14 first place votes compared to Porcello’s 8. Seems a little fucky to most people since two voters left Verlander off their ballot completely, which is pretty unacceptable. I’m assuming those are the type that won’t vote for a player if their team wasn’t good. AKA the people that have robbed Trout of a couple MVP’s and probably somehow will again this year.

Famous Mortimer
9 years ago
Reply to  burts_beads

I’d certainly be interested to know their justification.

jsc1973
9 years ago
Reply to  burts_beads

I’d question the credentials of anyone who left Verlander out of the top five. I would have been fine with any of them, and probably would have voted for Kluber myself, but Porcello was a deserving winner.

The argument that a player can’t be MVP if he played on a losing team, regardless of its merit, doesn’t apply to the CYA. It goes to the best pitcher, period.

brad.vargas
9 years ago
Reply to  burts_beads

I heard Chastain submitted his ballot a week before the season ended. Verlander pitched 2 games after that in which he went 1-1 (again no run support) 14.2 IP, 10 H 1 R, 2 BB and 20 K’s.

csw117
9 years ago
Reply to  PHW

I’m afraid Kate Upton’s not willing to take the pay cut to work here.

vicfirth98Member since 2017
9 years ago

No issue with Kershaw, but how is it possible that Scherzer > Syndergaard? How can it be possible that out of 30 people, not one voted for objectively the best pitcher in the league. How does the best pitcher in the NL by WAR finish 8th in the voting? I think it’s a joke.

Kyle Hendricks and Jon Lester weren’t even top-5 pitchers and finished 2nd and 3rd? I mean it’s crazy…how are Cueto and Bumgarner not ahead of them, let alone the true top 3 NL pitchers? I think the outcome of this process indicates how out of touch most of these voters are. Scherzer took his 20 wins to the bank despite having worse ratios across the board than Kershaw, Jofer, Syndergaard, or really any other contender in the process! I forgot how important the W-L record was in 2016. I thought baseball society had actually made progress.

vicfirth98Member since 2017
9 years ago
Reply to  vicfirth98

Syndergaard appeared on 7/30 ballots. Really? The leading pitcher in WAR in the NL isn’t even a top 5 pitcher for 23 of 30 writers? One writer included Tanner Roark over Syndergaard. Are these voters qualified…I say absolutely not…it’s pretty evident based on the voting outcome. I think that FG members have more of a right to vote for this than some of these writers

vicfirth98Member since 2017
9 years ago
Reply to  vicfirth98

I am a Mets fan, so I am biased. But really, this could have gone to Kershaw or posthumously to Jose Fernandez and I would have applauded it. It has less to do with Syndergaard’s not winning specifically and more to do with just objective incorrectness on behalf of these voters…

piddy
9 years ago
Reply to  vicfirth98

Just to be clear, Kershaw led the NL in pitching WAR, narrowly beating out Thor.

vicfirth98Member since 2017
9 years ago
Reply to  piddy

That’s why the first thing I said in my post was “no issue with Kershaw.”

EnormousHatred
9 years ago
Reply to  vicfirth98

Yeah, I don’t understand this. I’m OK with Kershaw (despite the innings) and even Fernandez, but with Thor/Scherzer the margin just isn’t very close. Thor’s K/9 isn’t much lower (which is supposed to be Scherzer’s main feature), and he allowed a fraction of the home runs and fly balls, which makes it silly to even question how easy it appears to be to hit Thor. I would say that outweighs a few extra stolen bases here and there, doesn’t it?

hardboiled_snow
9 years ago
Reply to  vicfirth98

The WAR metric that you’re referencing is based on FIP, which doesn’t do anything to account for contact management. Advanced metrics that go beyond simple counting stats are specific interpretations of data that are weighted to tell us something that, when read in this context, can be useful for better describing the performance of an athlete. These are contextualized interpretations of data that show that, in this case, by one interpretation Syndergaard outpaced other pitchers. Other metrics that weigh and evaluate different data or the same data differently will yield different results. Calling it objective is missing the point of these metrics.

vicfirth98Member since 2017
9 years ago

Contact management goes against Scherzer if anything. 1.22 HR/9 (he and Robbie Ray aren’t all that different). But you make a good point about interpretations of data! Scherzer had 20 wins and Syndergaard had 14. I stand corrected. By that analysis, Scherzer is clearly the better pitcher

Wu-Bacca
9 years ago
Reply to  vicfirth98

Interesting that you choose to focus on ratios for Syndergaard while overlooking the fact that Scherzer pitched 45 more innings. I mean, if you only care about ratios, why not vote for Kenley Jansen for Cy Young? (And for the record, WAR is not the best tool to size up pitchers, for about umpteen different reasons.)

vicfirth98Member since 2017
9 years ago
Reply to  Wu-Bacca

Jeff Samardzija threw 203 IP. I guess that means he’s also better than Syndergaard? Trying to argue innings pitched means more than actual statistics has to be one of the more disappointing counterarguments I’ve ever heard

vicfirth98Member since 2017
9 years ago
Reply to  Wu-Bacca

you’re right. let’s not use WAR. let’s use other stats.

ERA: syndergaard 2.60, scherzer 2.96
FIP: syndergaard 2.29, scherzer 3.24
xFIP: syndergaard 2.67, scherzer 3.37
SIERRA: syndergaard 2.95, scherzer 3.05
HR/9: syndergaard 0.52, scherzer 1.22

and then here are the best stats in scherzer’s favor:

WHIP: scherzer 0.97, syndergaard 1.15
K-BB: scherzer 25.3%, syndergaard 23.5%
Wins: scherzer 20, syndergaard 14
(BONUS!!! innings pitched, the most important measure of a pitcher’s success)

This choice strikes me as being easy.

JS7
9 years ago

Clayton Kershaw is the Mike Trout of pitchers.

Steve SD
9 years ago
Reply to  JS7

Mike Trout is the Clayton Kershaw of position players.

Mahoney
9 years ago
Reply to  Steve SD

Two of the three fundamental laws of baseball.

“Youneverknow” (the late Joaquin Andujar) is the third.

JS7
9 years ago

Remember when Rick Porcello won a Cy Young?

Captain Tenneal
9 years ago
Reply to  JS7

Ooh, I ‘member!

MustBunique
9 years ago

Yeah, I member too! Member Chewbacca?

RadermecherMember since 2018
9 years ago

Kershaw had a historic,albiet short campiagn.
He is simply the best.

Psychic... Powerless...
9 years ago

Kate Upton wants MLB to “fire those writers” who didn’t vote for Verlander, and she tweeted about Porcello, “Sorry Rick but you didn’t get any 1st place votes? you didn’t win.”

Psychic... Powerless...
9 years ago

I guess it’s not really a relevant comment, but I was so shocked.

Matt
9 years ago

How much did those last 20-30 innings come into play? If Kershaw didn’t come back from injury and ended up at the 120 mark, presumably that would have pushed him behind Scherzer, but would that be enough to push him out of your top-5?

Samuel
9 years ago

Seems that throwing more than 200 innings is almost a death sentence when it comes to Daves cy young vote

willl
9 years ago

Dave, I’m curious who you’d have voted for in the AL ROY. Many of the arguments people use against Kershaw and the same used against Sanchez- not enough playing time. Given your argument for Kershaw, I’d expect you’d make the same case as to why Sanchez was most deserving?

To push it a bit further, how does your opinion of peak performance apply to relievers like Britton? Do we dock him for not being given the opportunity to throw ~200 innings? In those 67 IP, he was just as good as Kershaw (Britton: 1.94 FIP/2.09 xFIP vs Kershaw:1.80 FIP/2.28 xFIP) was in 149 IP, and leagues better than any SP in the AL. But at what point does playing time actually matter? 149 IP of dominance is enough, but presumably 67 IP isn’t.

DavidBowser
9 years ago
Reply to  willl

I thought this exact thing.

Not arguing the greatness of Kershaw (because he is an all-time great), but the logic by which Dave justified the decision. That logic seems either a slippery slope argument or incompletely explained.

In essence, Dave should have said, “I picked Kershaw because of pitcher WAR.” and been done with it, because following that with “I’m a peak performance guy” and the rest of the justification is an argument that Dwight Gooden should be in the HOF.

Jim Lahey
9 years ago

Kershaw before ASB: 121.0 IP 5.5 WAR
Kershaw after ASB: 28.0 IP 1.0 WAR

He skipped all of July and August – typically when pitchers give up the most HR / Runs. Sure, he was amazing, but in context, I’m not THAT amazed by it. Walks, ERA, and 3 CG SHO are the whole Kershaw story.

He faced…. removing the pitchers hitting which isn’t true for all but 2 of these:
Giants x5 wRC+ 98 (much better vs RHP than LHP)
Mets x2 wRC+ 97
Marlins x2 wRC+ 91
Braves x2 wRC+ 86
Padres x2 wRC+ 85
Pirates x1 wRC+ 99
Nationals x1 wRC+ 97
Dbacks x1 wRC+ 93
Rockies x1 wRC+ 92
Reds x1 wRC+ 89
Interleague:
TOR x1 wRC+ 102 (Away game)
NYY x1 wRC+ 92(Away game)
LAA x1 wRC+ 100(Home game) (lol – the Angels were not bad offensively? thanks Trout)

10 home starts, 3 in SF during the non-summer, and 1 in SD. Didn’t face the Cardinals or Cubs once.

It’s tough to vote for that over the guy who actually lead the league in W, GS, IP, K’s, among the best in ERA/WHIP. Mostly just facing another 358 batters through the summer.

roputnts
9 years ago
Reply to  Jim Lahey

Would love to see an analysis that sought to correlate weather conditions to pitching effectiveness. Love Kershaw, but pitching in SoCal vs. northern states such as CHI, DET, CLE, etc. is a real factor.

Baltar
9 years ago

Good for you. Kershaw was the right choice.

Poster To Be Named LaterMember since 2020
9 years ago

Dave,

In a world where we discredit the pitcher’s results for quality pitch-framing ability and stellar defense (all valid), when does one begin to credit a pitcher for getting results despite a lack of pure stuff? If we want to paint the most accurate picture, would it have been unfair to include that concept in your reasoning for/against Kyle Hendricks?

That said, I realize that this can’t be evaluated from a statistical point, however it doesn’t necessarily need to be. All of the pitchers you ranked ahead of him got arguably inferior results with much greater physical tools. Just some food for thought.

Sam Choung
9 years ago

Daniel Walker? did you mean to type Neil Murphy?

Matthias
9 years ago

Logically, it seems as though athletes in any sport who pack a lot of value into a disproportionately few number of are likely to “waste” some of that value (making it not-value?). A great starting pitcher in baseball might be the best example, where he can produce WAR values similar to some of the best hitters, but packed into about 20% of the games.

Jeff noted in an article today that five of the top ten blowouts of the season were Kershaw starts, indicating that much of his awesomeness was of little use to the Dodgers in the later innings of those games. However, I would be remiss not to note that his net WPA is still the second highest in baseball (among those with > 100 IP), so he may gain “value” by doing other things like pitching later into games.

Perhaps I have shot my own argument to hell with that last point, but I still have a question. If value is an important component to an award, should we even consider that because Kershaw pitched many fewer innings than Scherzer that it’s possible more of his value (as measured by what we have available) be wasted?

edgcarMember since 2024
9 years ago

Sorry Dave, but in my humble opinion those 80 innings do count. The Dodgers had to go with rookies and journey men to cover those 80 innings which is basically 10 games/starts. I get that you want the best pitcher winning the Cy Young, but I’m more inclined to give it to the pitcher that contributed the most to his team, and that’s Scherzer.

Rollie's MustacheMember since 2017
9 years ago
Reply to  edgcar

Except there are better ways to measure a pitcher’s contributions to his team than innings pitched. And by those measures, Kershaw was right there with the best. So given his superior rate statistics, along with the historic K/BB ratio he was on pace to set, I’m inclined to agree with Dave 100%.

mateodh
9 years ago

When it comes to time missed, I ultimately use the logic that, at some small cost, someone is going to pitch the innings you otherwise would have. As mentioned in the article, you don’t have to be very good filling in for Kershaw(replacement level, really) to “limp” to the same value added over a longer period. Even if it’s not you pitching, the cost to the Dodgers isn’t much more than it would be if Kershaw had, say, pitched right-handed just to make it to the finish line.