2012 Organizational Rankings: #5 – Philadelphia
Dave Cameron previously laid out the methodology behind the rankings here. Remember that the grading scale for each category is 20-80, with 50 representing league average.
2012 Organizational Rankings
#30 – Baltimore
#29 – Houston
#28 – Oakland
#27 – Pittsburgh
#26 – San Diego
#25 – Minnesota
#24 – Chicago AL
#23 – Seattle
#22 – Kansas City
#21 – Cleveland
#20 – New York NL
#19 – Los Angeles NL
#18 – Colorado
#17 — Miami
#16 — Diamondbacks
#15 — Cincinnati
#14 — Chicago NL
#13 — Milwaukee
#12 — San Francisco
#11 — Washington
#10 — Tampa Bay
#9 – Toronto
#8 – Atlanta
#7 – Detroit
#6 – St. Louis
Philadelphia’s 2011 Ranking: #3
2012 Outlook: 63 (T-4th)
Much like they were in 2011, the 2012 Phillies are a contender built on pitching. With three of the top fifteen starting pitchers in the sport in their starting rotation, arguably the second-best closer in the game, and a combination of solid back-end starters and versatile non-closers, the pitching staff is one of baseball’s best.
While the dynamic duo of Roy Halladay and Cliff Lee is getting to the age of declining skills, it’s hard to imagine either being less than an elite 6.5-WAR pitcher this season. Assuming Cole Hamels continues to develop now that he has a firmer grasp on how and when to use his cutter, the Phillies may well get more out of three starters than most rotations get out of a full quintet.
The Phillies will go as far as their pitching takes them, because this incarnation of their offense isn’t anything to write home about. Ryan Howard will miss at least the first month and a half of the season. Chase Utley won’t be back until at least the end of May, if not later in the season, given the uncertainties surrounding his chondromalacia. Placido Polanco is, at this stage of his career, a ticking injury time bomb, and one has to wonder if regression will rear its ugly head with respect to Shane Victorino, Hunter Pence and John Mayberry.
While he is overpaid relative to his production, Howard is still a fine power hitter whose absence leaves a hole in the lineup. In his place, the Phillies will turn to some combination of Jim Thome, Ty Wigginton and John Mayberry. And while Chase Utley ain’t what he used to be, this watered down version has still tallied 9.5 WAR over the last two seasons. Prospect Freddy Galvis will get dibs on taking over while Utley rehabs, but the fanbase is holding its collective breath that Utley returns around the midway point of the season.
The Phillies have very solid players at important positions in Victorino, Jimmy Rollins and Carlos Ruiz, but a number of players whose playing time at other positions is up in the air. In addition to the aforementioned first base timeshare, there is also a potential three-way platoon in left field with Mayberry, Laynce Nix and Juan Pierre.
If the team can play Thome more often without risking injury and use Mayberry and Nix more often than Pierre and Wigginton, they can make do with the lineup until Howard and/or Utley returns.
But it’s more likely that the team thinks of Pierre as the 2002-05 version of himself and Wigginton as the decent power hitter from several years ago. The Phillies have pieces to perform adequately on offense without Howard and Utley, but could be their own worst enemy in terms of maximizing the utility of their rostered players.
With this pitching staff, all they need is adequate offense and defense to contend, and if Howard and Utley return on time, the offense gets that much better. The Phillies might not have as sunny a long-term outlook as other contenders, but for 2012 they are still favorites to win the NL East Division, and are still considered the class of the National League in our organizational rankings.
2013+ Outlook: 47 (T-19th)
As strong as the Phillies may look this season, the long-term outlook isn’t as positive. The farm system has been depleted over the last few seasons through trades for top-notch major league talent, and the organization doesn’t really boast any polished hitting prospects. The Phillies are strong on minor league pitching — of both the starting and relief variety — and raw, toolsy athletes at the lower levels, but very weak in the more important area of bats and gloves capable of contributing as soon as next season.
In 2009, the team traded Carlos Carrasco, Jason Knapp, Jason Donald and Lou Marson to the Indians for Cliff Lee. They then traded Kyle Drabek, Michael Taylor, Travis d’Arnaud to the Blue Jays. Last season, the Phils dealt Jarrod Cosart, Jonathan Singleton, Josh Zeid and Domingo Santana to the Astros for Hunter Pence. These were potential impact prospects dealt for impact major league talent, and while the Phillies have a decent development system in place, it’s very tough to replace that much close-to-major-league-ready talent in a short time span.
To that end, Marc Hulet ranked the farm system 20th in his pre-season rankings. Keith Law ranked the farm system 25th in his own rankings. Most prospect mavens agree that the Phils system ranks in the game’s bottom third. Their top prospects are pitchers Trevor May, Brody Colvin and Jesse Biddle, and catcher Sebastian Valle.
The baby aces and Valle are still a couple of years away from the majors, while the toolsy prospects drafted early over the last few years are still finding their way in the lower levels of the minors.
However, the 2013+ category isn’t solely based on farm systems, and moving forward the Phillies still have valuable pieces under contract. Then again, at least two very valuable pieces remain unsigned past the 2012 season: Cole Hamels and Shane Victorino. The Phils are in talks with both players but it’s tough to evaluate the long-term outlook of the organization without knowing whether or not Hamels and/or Victorino will be retained.
It’s also unclear how the Phillies will handle Domonic Brown, who could bolster their standing in this category if given the opportunity. He is somewhere in between a prospect and a major leaguer at this point, and much of that falls on the Phillies poor handling of an important piece moving forward. The current plan is to let him spend the whole season in Triple A but the team needs to develop a formal plan for handling him and stick to it. Otherwise, they’ll end up wasting some very valuable years of a top-tier prospect.
Based on farm systems alone, the Phillies are fairly close to the bottom, but their core members are strong enough to keep them hovering around the league average in this category.
Financial Resources: 64 (T-4th)
Forbes has the Phillies ranked as the fifth most valuable franchise at $723 million, and third in the senior circuit behind the Dodgers and Cubs. The Phillies aren’t as highly leveraged as their National League counterparts, but are the only top-five team currently operating in the black.
Management has acknowledged this fact as payroll began to increase over the last half-decade. The change was based on a conscious decision to spend a lot more in order to improve the on-field product and thereby sustain high revenues over the long haul.
Here are the Phillies payroll figures since 2006:
2006: $88.273 million
2007: $89.428 million
2008: $98.269 million
2009: $113.004 million
2010: $141.928 million
2011: $172.976 million
Over the last six years, the Phillies have gone middle of the pack in payroll to a team whose roster decisions are partly based on the luxury tax. Attendance figures have helped spur the payroll increase as the Phillies have actually posted attendance figures over capacity since 2010. That season, they finished second to the Yankees in average attendance per home game, but posted the highest attendance percentage at 103.5 percent. Last season, they led the sport in average attendance per home game, with a percentage capacity of 104.1 percent.
The Phillies also bring in money from their current television deal, which dates back to a contract with the defunct channel PRISM from 1977. Their television contract expires in 2015, and if the Phillies are as popular then as they are now, they shouldn’t have any trouble obtaining a lucrative deal to increase revenues. By then, they may need the boost if attendance suffers as a byproduct of the on-field product worsening.
For the time being, however, the Phillies have money and are very willing to spend, even if it means operating at a profit. They don’t have a strong outlook in terms of talent already in-house, but they have shown themselves to be buyers and aggressive traders and should have no trouble prolonging this window of contention via external means.
Baseball Operations: 44 (23rd)
The Phillies are not a very progressive organization. That doesn’t render the baseball operations department ineffective, but it does potentially keep the team from making smarter decisions with regards to its personnel. The Phillies were one of the only teams in baseball, if not the only team, not to employ a statistical analyst until last season, and while the front office is high on its baseball people and ability to scout and develop, they aren’t exactly cutting edge when it comes personnel decisions.
Their development team took a hit last season when Chuck LaMar resigned, and the Phils imported Joe Jordan from the Orioles to replace him. Both were trying to fill the void left by Mike Arbuckle when he was passed over for the GM job.
Since taking over, Amaro has made moves both terrific and abysmal, getting Roy Halladay to agree to a three-year, $60 million contract extension yet handing out a five-year, $125 million deal to Howard two years before he was set to hit free agency. He traded for Cliff Lee in 2009 in a steal for the Phils yet dealt him a year later, in quite the unnecessary fashion, and for a subpar return. This is also the same front office that has essentially deflated the value of its top prospect — Brown — through very poor handling.
His front office has a certain flair for the dramatic, and it’s hard to argue with the on-field results. But plenty of those results are attributable to players acquired or drafted by his predecessors, who had significantly less money to work with. Amaro’s true test will be keeping the Phillies competitive beyond the current window.
Right now, the Phillies are a contender because prior front offices drafted well and the current ownership team gave a maverick type of general manager plenty of money to spend. But the front office hasn’t exactly shown a knack for spending that money wisely, and that likely led to the lower ranking here.
Overall: 58 (5th)
The Phillies are still favorites to win the NL East but the division has grown more competitive. Their rotation is the best in the National League and they have enough talent on offense to support the pitching staff. They have money to spend but may see their ability to acquire talent mid-season hampered by their proximity to the luxury tax.
The season won’t entirely hinge on the returns of Ryan Howard and Chase Utley, but those two, even in injury-recovering form, are better options than their current replacements and will greatly improve the Phillies’ odds of winning their sixth straight division title.
Eric is an accountant and statistical analyst from Philadelphia. He also covers the Phillies at Phillies Nation and can be found here on Twitter.


No mention of Domonic Brown? He’s a pretty big part of the 2013+ picture, no?
I thought I did? Though it’s still unclear what the Phils plan on doing with him. The idea is that he’ll spend this year at AAA and make the major league team next year. But their handling of him so far has been pretty abysmal.
exactly what I was thinking
For some reason something from my notepad wasn’t in here. But the section on Brown has been re-added. Weird — sorry about that.
Somewhat of a side topic, but not a single mention of Dom Brown–even in the 2013+ section? I understand he had his struggles last season but he was the consensus #1 prospect just two years ago, a top-10 guy last season and he hardly struggled as much as some top prospects have in the past. It just seems a bit of an oversight to not mention him as a positive chip going forward, no?
Sorry, looks like I was beaten to the punch.
“That season, they finished second to the Yankees in average attendance per home game, but posted the highest attendance percentage at 103.5 percent. Last season, they led the sport in average attendance per home game, with a percentage capacity of 104.1 percent.”
This upsets me just as much as the old sporting cliche, ‘I’m going to give 110%’.
I can’t read “they led the sport in average attendance per home game, with a percentage capacity of 104.1 percent” without thinking that their stadium’s capacity is at least 4.1% higher than they claim.
Does anybody know why teams do this? It seems to be very common practice in the NHL, perhaps so that teams can keep their full capacity crowd streaks intact, but I just don’t understand who is going to be fooled by it.
Standing room tickets. Adding spots to already sold-out gates.
Same problem – you can’t buy tickets to a sold out game. Maybe you can’t buy a seat, but you can get in.
Stadium capacity = # seats+ number of people allowed in luxury box sections+# of standing tickets allowed to be sold. I assume fire regualtions control some of this (no standing room in evacuation routes, etc. ). If Philly is selling 4% more tickets than seating capacity, then it’s fair to say the stadium capacity is 4% more than the # of seats.
I’m pretty sure that when they talk about the stadium’s capacity they are strictly talking about the number of seats the stadium has. SO if they sell every seat for every game, plus some standing room only tickets, then they will be over 100% sold out.
I would put the Phillies ahead of the Angels (who I presume will be the next team on the list), but this strikes me as basically correct. Kudos to the Fangraphs team for altering their model to get results that appear (to me anyway) more likely to actually reflect which teams will be good this year and in future years en lieu of the old method, which seemed far too close to a GM popularity contest. I wonder if the Phillies 27th ranking after their first (and before the next four consecutive) division title had anything to do with altering the methodology?
http://mobile.philly.com/sports/phillies/?wss=/philly/sports/phillies&id=141134073&viewAll=y#more
It clearly states they employ someone as a statistical analyst. Just think you may want to fix that.
He’s sort of a statistical analyst but not in the way we think of it, and the Phils are far more-observation prone than in tune with analytics. He’s also fairly new. In any event, revised to avoid confusion. Thanks.
they also clearly ignore any advice he may be giving
Seems like a reasonable picture. I think the 2013+ outlook is somewhat pessimistic, but on the whole, a fair ranking.
I just want to point out that people have been calling the Phillies “old” and “injury prone” and “due for a collapse” since 2008.
Hit “post” too soon.
…since 2008. And while that’s certainly true, there’s little reason to expect it to be this year, given their recent track record.
Well the Phillies were getting old after the 2008 season. With Jamie Moyer, Chan Ho Park, Pedro Martinez, Raul Ibanez and Jayson Werth playing key roles. They just fixed and papered over the problem by increasing payroll dramatically.
The problem is as real now as it was real then. Just now I don’t think they can increase payroll by very much more.
Not to mention getting younger by replacing Jamie Moyer and Chan Ho Park and Pedro Martinez and Raul Ibanez with younger guys.
Jayson Werth? He was only 29 after the 2008 season.
I think it’s tricky there, because the Phillies have money to spend on free agents, but we were evaluating teams more on players under contract in 2013+ and in the farm.
“I just want to point out that people have been calling the Phillies “old” and “injury prone” and “due for a collapse” since 2008.”
Really? Funny they were heavily favorites before 2010 and 2011 seasons among both the local Philly media and nationally especially in Vegas.
Let me know if I’m reading this right- the Phillies are a pretty bad franchise, except that they have Roy Halladay, Cliff Lee and a lot of money.
That doesn’t strike me as a good bet going forward, especially when you guys just ranked the guy in charge of spending that money as one of the worst in baseball at doing his job.
Will, couldn’t agree more. I can count 4 or 5 teams ranked lower that I’d pick to be more successful going forward. This ranking has the potential to look very silly next year.
yep, agree whole-heartedly. this ranking is a joke. Phils MAY win 90-93 games this season (I’ll take the under myself), and then will fall of a cliff next year.
Just ouot of curiousity, John, where did you predict the Phillies to finish last year?
The data points supporting the FO as 23rd are utterly nitpicky, especially when weighed against this: 93 wins in 2009; 97 wins in 2010; 102 wins in 2011.
What other metric is there for a FO besides results on the field? People need to break through this conceptual wall of ‘there is only one right way to do things’ and bring some humility to the table. The Phillies must be doing many things well to get to where they are.
I think they kind of cover that though when they point out that the majority of the great players on Amaro’s teams came from the Gillick years. Besides Halladay and Lee, what difference makers has Amaro brought in? And you can’t even give him full points for Lee since he gave him away for almost nothing once.
Hunter Pence. Roy Oswalt. Jim Thome. Jonathon Papelbon.
What more do you want? All Stars and a Hall of Famer who is still a good hitter.
Since the talent that remains from the Gillick era is currently playing worse than the talent that Amaro, Jr. has brought in, I don’t think it’s a valid point.
It would be a valid point if Chutley, Howard, et al were still 5 win players, and Amaro Jr. was simply adding overpriced filler to the mix, but the 2008 core is now mostly supporting (instead of leading) the core that Amaro Jr. brought in.
I’m sorry, is this a joke?
First off, “Besides Halladay and Lee, what difference makers has Amaro brought in?” Gee, other than that Ms. Lincoln, how did you like the play? How many other GMs can say they have brought in 2 of the top 5 pitchers in baseball, and probably 2 of the top 15 most valuable players overall?
Also, as a poster points out, Pence, Oswalt and Papelbon say hello, but I guess they don’t count as “impact”? So I guess we’re now looking at above All-Star level production as “impact”?
Look, I think Amaro has some serious flaws that are likely to hinder the franchise going forward. But bringing in “impact” players is the least of them–in fact, it’s his biggest strength. Come on.
By your logic, they should change the category to “recent past success.” The “other metric” is process, not strictly W/L results.
It looks like ‘the process’ has led to three years (which is to say, every year Amaro, Jr. has been in charge) of 90+ wins, and the team has been better each year he has been in charge. In fact, the Phillies have had the best regular season in baseball the last two seasons.
So what’s the beef? Is winning divorced from the process? To argue that the FO that has produced the best regular season record the last two seasons is not just meh, but so bad that it ranks 23rd, you have to give me something about process that can reasonably discount everything that has happened on the field. I’m skeptical that anyone can.
How is the W/L record *not* the result of process? The scorn for this FO is completely divorced from the reality of the team’s success. Can we really imagine commentators in the Angels thread writing things like, “Besides Albert Pujols and C.J. Wilson, what other difference makers have they brought in?” The bottom line is that Amaro has completely remade the team he inherited, turning it from an offensive powerhouse to a defensive one, and the organization’s win total has increased every year he’s had the job. This is not the resume of a failing organization or a weak FO.
Phillies operating in the red or black?
“Except that” they employ 2 of the best players in baseball and have a sustainably high payroll based on attendance is a pretty big “except that” no? (Even excluding the fact that you’re leaving out several other 3-5 WAR players.) I don’t agree with every decision they made, but the annual predictions of doom right around the corner has gotten exaggerated in the comments here to near parody, and I’m glad that the Fangraphs staff is not buying into them in these rankings.
Eric knows more about the Phils that just about anyone, hence the very balanced review here.
#6org
The whole appeal to “process” seems nothing more than a way to smuggle in subjective allegiance.
how is a team who’s best shot at winning is this year and that depends on 2 pitchers in their mid 30s, a bad farm system, and bad baseball operations ranked this high? Their financial resources aren’t that great. Payroll is high but they aren’t the Yankees. Once they start to fail, attendance will drop. This is Philly, not Chicago.
The farm *system* isn’t bad, it brought up Rollins, Hamels, Utley, Howard, Worley, Madson, Kendrick, Ruiz and produced prospects good enough to bring in Halladay, Lee, and Pence. That certainly doesn’t seem bad. It may be low on hitting prospects and down overall currently but the *system* itself seems to produce.
And if depending on Halladay and Lee is bad for this year then sign me up for awful. Also, Lee is 32. Since when is that mid-30s?
They aren’t the Yankees but they are outspending the Red Sox. And with what we saw the Angels do and how the Dodgers were valued the impact of impending TV contracts has never been more evident.
Last year the Phillies suffered through a full year’s worth of half-replacement-level production from the trio of Orr, Martinez, and Valdez and still won 102. That ain’t bad.
Cliff Lee is 33, and will be 34 at the end of this season.
The current system is bad, because it doesn’t have much talent. Past results do not mean the current one is good.
Yeah the farm system is pretty bad right now unless you consider ‘toolsy’ prospects like James in the Reading OF legit MLB caliber players
Philadelphia is the fourth largest media market in the country, and the largest MLB market in the country not shared among two teams.
As for the aspersions on the current team, having Roy Halladay and Cliff Lee to depend upon is obviously a strength and doesn’t really need a rebuttal. This also ignores several other 3-5 WAR-level players (Pence, Victorino, Rollins, Hamels, Ruiz). Utley and Howard are likely out until June, not the whole season. While the minor league system is currently down, the personnel that acquired and developed the prospects that were deemed valuable enough to acquire top MLB talent is still in place. They seem at least a decent bet to acquire new prospects and rebuild the system.
Oh right, but Ruben Amaro referenced RBIs in an interview once without smirking. Guess they should be 30th.
No, it has nothing to do with Amaro’s reference to RBIs, but to Amaro giving a 32 year old Ryan Howard a 5 year $125mil extension. Howard has averaged 1.5 WAR per season over the last two years, and will now miss half the season due to injury. That contract is going to be one of the worst in history. I would be very surprised if Howard is worth even 8 WAR total over the extent of the contract.
The Phillies Organization is operating in the red? Are you familiar with what this term means.
Can I see a source on that?
Here’s the thing… I think people overexaggerate the Howard extension. Look at the deal Votto just signed. How about Pujols (who will be making what Howard is making per year when he’s 40)? How about Fielder? You can’t justify any of those numbers and I know they seem crazy but you all need to face the facts – that’s the cost for signing a power-hitting first baseman. The saber-dudes will say what they want about Howard but the fact is he drives in runs. Hindsight is always going to be 20/20 and the achilles makes this thing look bad but in Howard, you’ve got a hard working guy that has meant so much to the franchise already (who prior to this season had no injury history)… I have a soft spot for this team because they did what no other team has done for Philadephia in a long time and I’m partial to keeping those guys around as long as they’re willing and able to go to bat for us.
I hate your assessment of baseball operations and +2013 outlook… because they don’t have a statistical analyst they deserve a ranking of 23, really? Not everyone subscribes to the sabermetrics stuff and that’s ok. Billy Beane’s methods haven’t worked for years… at least, not that I’m aware of (last time I checked, they weren’t hanging banners in Oakland). Some teams, like Tampa, can do it by growing talent but Tampa’s not filling seats, either (the second lowest franchise valuation, according to Forbes). The Phillies have done an exceptional job of turning their talent into players that will help fill the seats and put notches in the win column. It’s not as much about what they’ve gotten as it is about what they’ve given away. None of those guys you mentioned was going to help the Phillies make it to the World Series or hang their third, fourth, fifth consecutive NL East banner but Cliff Lee, Roy Halladay, Hunter Pence et al certainly have. Looking at the list of guys they gave up, I have NO sellers remorse… none. They’ve got a home grown talent playing second base right now who is probably better than anyone they gave away and Domonic Brown waiting for his chance (I tweeted to Eric my feelings about that – yes, they messed up big time with Dom but he’s still a diamond in the rough and they still have a chance to make it right). I feel pretty good about our chances for the next few years with a rotation centered on Halladay and Lee (and hopefully Hamels). I am excited to see what the front office does with some expiring contracts coming off the books (Blanton, Contreras and maybe Victorino).
The team is operating in the red, yes but the increase in franchise value will pay the investors back back one hundred-fold… you can’t go off those Forbes numbers, either (the Dodgers were valued at $700 million by Forbes in 2011 and then Forbes went up to $1.4 billion in 2012 because they realized that there were bids out there for that much… the franchise actually sold for $2 billion which shows you that Forbes has no clue).
You guys really needed to fudge the numbers on this one. Philadelphia is the definition of #org6. They’ve had a front office in place that has been screwing the pooch for quite a while and a bunch of aging players. Howard and Utley are complete questions marks for this team this year. How long can they expect Thome to play in the field before wrenching his back and being done for the season. They are a couple major injuries to their 30+ year old players from a disaster. I think they are already a 10 win worse team for 2012, and they only need a couple more strokes of bad luck to be 20 wins worse.
Every team is a couple major injuries away from a disaster. Actually, a lot of teams are disasters without a couple major injuries.
If Thome plays in the field it will be at most one or two games a week.
I am not sure how people reconcile Ryan Howard the overrated RBI-man with the Ryan Howard who’s injury will sink the season.
So you’re not seeing much of a dropoff between Ryan Howard (.275/.368/.560) and Ty Wigginton (.265/.324/.443)? Okay then.
Came for the whining from philly fans, wasn’t disappointed. Keep telling yourselves Amaro is a good GM, though. Maybe it’ll come true one day!
So St. Louis is #6org? Oh boy…