The Real Truth Behind Derek Jeter’s Gold Glove — Revealed!

Yesterday, Major League Baseball announced that Derek Jeter just won his fifth Gold Glove at the age of 36. Many people greeted this news with a grin or an eye-roll; Aaron Gleeman pretended to be incredulous that Jeter was “denied a National League Gold Glove award,” while baseball-reference.com briefly posted a comment that said “We can’t believe it either.”

Unfortunately, I can believe it. To explain the reason that Jeter won his Gold Glove requires me to break the omerta of the baseball blogosphere, Thou Shalt Remind People That Jeter’s Defense Sucks. This creed is the reason that, as Joe Posnanski wrote yesterday, “There are ‘How did Jeter win another Gold Glove’ posts popping up every eight seconds on the Internet (there will be 48 new ones by the time you finish reading this post).”

(In order to renew my Fangraphs membership, every six months, Dave Cameron flies out to meet me in an unmarked parking garage in Washington DC, where I swear a blood oath by candlelight on a stack of Necronomicons never to write anything complimentary about Derek Jeter’s mobility or range. Cameron’s post about Jeter yesterday was faithful to our sworn mission.) The awful secret of Derek Jeter’s fifth Gold Glove requires a little background in a few of the more esoteric domains of human knowledge. This may be the most important blog post I ever write; if it is the last, dear readers, only you will know the truth.

Derek Jeter was born on June 26, 1974, or 6/26/74. Six plus 26 is thirty-two — exactly one less than 33, the maximum number of degrees in Freemasonry. James Downard and Michael Hoffman explored the Masonic conspiracy to kill John F. Kennedy in their controversial “KING-KILL/33°,” perhaps the most dangerous anti-Masonic text ever written. They noted that “Oswald may have undergone biotelemetry implantation in the Soviet Union while a ‘volunteer’ at a Behavior Control Center at Minsk.” “Minsk,” of course, is very close to Minka, as in Minka Kelly, Derek Jeter’s alleged fiance. Kelly has neither confirmed nor denied that she and Jeter are Freemasons of the 33rd degree.

Derek Jeter played his first game on May 29, 1995, but didn’t win his first Gold Glove until November 2, 2004: there were 3445 days in between his debut and his first Gold Glove. The base 10 number 3445 is 2652 in base 11; the base 11 number 3445 is 4526 in base 10; 4526 plus 2652 is 7178. During Derek Jeter’s career, no Yankee has ever worn the numbers 71 or 78.

In fact, this number is a code originated by the heretical Rosicrucian sect: the first is a page number, and the second refers to 1978, the year that both Pope John Paul I and Pope John Paul II ascended to the Holy See. On page 71 of “The Secret Doctrine of the Rosicrucians,” the Fifth Aphorism is revealed: “The One is the Flame of Life. The Many are the Sparks in the Flame. The Flame once lighted kindles everything within its sphere. The Fire is in everything and everywhere; there is nothing dark or cold within its sphere.” Five: the number of world championships and Gold Gloves.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed.
We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member.
1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other.
2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off.
3. Dark mode and Classic mode!
4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them.
5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects.
6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.)
7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only.
8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO.
9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members.
10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features!
We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it.

The Flame of Life” is an Italian romance novel first published in English in 1900. On page 55 — five for the championships and five for the Gloves — is written the essence of the Jeter animus:

Their number is made up of those who have drunk in your poetry, who have breathed the fiery ether of your dream, who have felt the clutch of your own chimera. It is made up of those to whom you have promised a stronger and more beautiful life, to whom you have announced the world’s transfiguration by the miracle of a new art.

Voters were powerless in the face of one with mastery over the transfiguration of the world. Derek Jeter is no mere mortal, and his fifth Gold Glove no mere reward for defensive excellence. It is his very birthright, as foretold throughout the ages.

I only pray that I will survive the revelation of these secrets.





Alex is a writer for The Hardball Times.

78 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Fred
15 years ago

Holy crap.

Fred
15 years ago
Reply to  Fred

I really took advantage of first comment, huh?

Z
15 years ago

Not funny. Pointless.

Matt Defalco
15 years ago
Reply to  Z

Congratulations, you win the “most negatively rated comment ever” award.

Also great work on the article.

It must have taken a hell of a lot of work.

Either that, or you made it all up. Seriously though, who would be crazy enough to fact check this article?

I guess whoever voted for Jeter.

(ba-dum-tish)

Jono
15 years ago
Reply to  Z

Pointless>Humorless

B
15 years ago

Made me think of Cartman in The Mystery of the Urinal Deuce where he is explaining how Kyle stood the most to gain from perpetrating the 9/11 attacks.

Joe Hardly
15 years ago
Reply to  B

I’ve got a raging clue right now.

G
15 years ago

shouldn’t this be a NotGraphs article?

Captain
15 years ago
Reply to  G

this.

Danmay
15 years ago
Reply to  G

I agree. It’s hilarious, but if Frangraphs is goint to create NotGraphs, this seems like the perfect piece for it.

joey p
15 years ago

“(In order to renew my Fangraphs membership, every six months, Dave Cameron flies out to meet me in an unmarked parking garage in Washington DC, where I swear a blood oath by candlelight on a stack of Necronomicons never to write anything complimentary about Derek Jeter’s mobility or range. Cameron’s post about Jeter yesterday was faithful to our sworn mission.)”

truer words were never spoken. realize its a tongue in cheek comment but there is more than a little truth in it. Dave Cameron has made a career damning Jeter and the yankees. no doubt for ruining the Mariners 116 win season in 2000

Fred
15 years ago
Reply to  joey p

Not to nitpick, but that was 2001. 🙂

Jono
15 years ago
Reply to  joey p

There is no more honorable career imaginable.

Drew
15 years ago
Reply to  Jono

Are you kidding?? JOSE CANSECO

phoenix
15 years ago

now that was funny. weird and unnecessary, but funny. seeing as the season is over, there isn’t that much baseball going on, so the odd random post is welcome. props for random research! it may seem silly, but i bet this actually took a lot of work to come up with!

Ellis
15 years ago

Awesome.

Another theory – he had the highest fielding percentage among AL shortstops. We all know that that’s a pretty weak measure of fielding ability. MLB coaches do not.

Danmay
15 years ago
Reply to  Ellis

This kind of explanation kills me. Sure, fielding percentage is cleary a factor to MLB coaches, but to use it as an explanation for why he won misses a lot. Many players have had the highest fielding percentage at their position and not won. Joe Posnanski’s article brings up another possible explanation that goes beyond fielding percentage.

R M
15 years ago
Reply to  Ellis

Why does everyone assume MLB coaches are nitwits? They have their jobs for a reason.

Ellis
15 years ago
Reply to  R M

I don’t think they’re all “nitwits,” but it’s clear they don’t much about how to judge the best shortstop in the AL. I’m a big Yankees fan, but I’m not deluded enough to think that Jeter is more than an average fielding shortstop.

NBarnes
15 years ago
Reply to  R M

We don’t assume they’re nitwits. We believe that they are nitwits based on evidence like, but not limited to, voting Derek Jeter as 2010’s best defensive shortstop in the AL. Which is pretty damning evidence of nitwithood.

Matt Defalco
15 years ago
Reply to  R M

Haha, I remember when Charlie Manuel was coaching the all-star team. Prado made the team, and he had to ask an assistant what his first name was, and how to pronounce it during one of the pre-game interviews that are streamed on mlb.com.

I had a good laugh.

Dan
15 years ago
Reply to  R M

Charlie Manuel…nitwit proof…selected Omar Infante to the All Star team.

Brad JohnsonMember
15 years ago

Wasn’t Harry Truman a double secret 34 degree mason?

Don
15 years ago
Reply to  Brad Johnson

I don’t know about “double secret” mason, but he’s listed on Wikipedia’s (Where else?) list of freemasons.

this guy
15 years ago

This reason for his winning makes more sense to me than the whole “he’s good at shortstop” nonsense.

adam
15 years ago

hahaha this is too awesome.

b
15 years ago

0/10

Jono
15 years ago
Reply to  b

Agreed. I hate humor. I don’t come to Fangraphs to laugh. I come to Fangraphs to be enlightened on very serious, weighty issues that determine the fate of the world. BASEBALL STATISTICS AND ANALYSIS ARE TOO IMPORTANT FOR THIS TOMFOOLERY

55
15 years ago

Petty much? It’s not like anyone campaigned for the award.

this guy
15 years ago

lame. weak sauce. dopey. does not belong. -1. this. just write about the braves. not funny. feeble. pathetic. tired. insubstantial.

TJ
15 years ago
Reply to  this guy

The troll is back for another round.

Danmay
15 years ago
Reply to  TJ

I don’t think this guy is going anywhere, so I guess we may as well learn to communicate with that guy.

Jono
15 years ago
Reply to  this guy

Single. Word. Responses. Indicate. Lack. Of. Coherent. Thought.

Danmay
15 years ago
Reply to  Jono

Please post this above and below where about 5 people did the same thing, but used single word positive responses. idiot.

Steven Ellingson
15 years ago
Reply to  Jono

There were a few 1/2/3 word responses, but this guy is the only one who managed 11 of them while only writing 20 words.

Danmay
15 years ago
Reply to  Jono

I fail to see the difference. Anyone that writes “This”, or “so much win” is adding as much as someone thet writes “Fail”, or whatever ‘this guy’ was writing. The only thing that the ‘this guy’s’ type add is a lot of negative votes.

fred
15 years ago
Reply to  this guy

If you can’t have a sense of humor about baseball, do what everyone else like you does, and go watch football.

Steven Ellingson
15 years ago
Reply to  fred

Wow. That right there is a put down of epic proportions. Your wit is just staggering. Telling someone to go watch football because obviously intellectuals watch baseball, and only dimwits would watch football. That is pure genius.

Andrew
15 years ago

I did a brief look at the Yankees’ fielders, and it appears that Teixeira, Jeter, Cano, and A-Rod were all significantly below average with range but above average in errors committed. Is it possible that the Yankees have an incredibly biased official scorer? It would not surprise me in the least bit.

JBV
15 years ago
Reply to  Andrew

I believe that there is a pretty good correlation to increased range and increased errors, because if you have a large range, you can get to balls that noone else can. More challenging opportunities=more errors.

Al
15 years ago
Reply to  Andrew

It wouldn’t surprise you because you assume everything in the world is set to align for the Yankees?

Douglas Heeren
15 years ago
Reply to  Andrew

I would not be surprised at all of the Yankees official scorer was biased. I have never liked Jeter at all. Actually, I have never liked any of the Yankees since Mattingly retired except maybe Paul O’Neil.

seriously?
15 years ago

just referencing a lot of weird stuff doesn’t make something funny. not gonna hate, cos no one’s making me read it, but i wish the writers here would stop trying to be steve martin (cos you’re not) and just focus on the baseball.

Jono
15 years ago
Reply to  seriously?

Steve Martin is a dated reference. Dude hasn’t been funny since crack was big (the first time.)

The odd references aren’t what makes it funny. The parody of conspiracy theory is part of what makes it funny, and the other part is that it points out how ludicrous Jeter’s GGs are.

Steve Martin
15 years ago
Reply to  Jono

Steve Martin is god

Alan
15 years ago

hillarious and I’m sure it took a lot of work to do

fredsbank
15 years ago

so much win

djfanon
15 years ago

Awesome article.

Navin V.
15 years ago

Brilliant.

Scout Finch
15 years ago

Not one mention of who got jobbed.

Who deserved the award?

BascinatorMember since 2022
15 years ago
Reply to  Scout Finch

Alexi Ramirez, Cliff Pennington, and Elvis Andrus all were worthy candidates. In fact, half the AL shortstops would have been better choices.

Jono
15 years ago
Reply to  Bascinator

Ramirez was noticeably better than the other two. As an A’s fan, I’d have been overjoyed to see Pennington win, but on the other hand, if this award functioned properly, the entire rest of the A’s infield would have won GGs, so I’d have been able to deal with Ramirez getting it.

Deacon Drake
15 years ago

Hey, it’s not Jeter’s fault the left and center fielders beat him to all those ground balls.

Bradley WoodrumMember since 2020
15 years ago
Reply to  Deacon Drake

Maybe they deserve gold gloves too?

Jono
15 years ago

33 of them.

get it right!
15 years ago

get your stories right before you write derek and minka got married last week november 5th as planned and the other BS not worth writing

pft
15 years ago

The first year of his 10 year deal was 2001

“6/26/74. Six plus 26 is 32 ”

3 squared(2) is 9. 7+4=11. 9/11

Numbers can prove anything.

I think I will stick to my theory that Rawlings prefers GG winners from big market teams and somehow influences the vote.

Los
15 years ago
Reply to  pft

P is the 16th letter in the alphabet, F is the 6th, T is the 20th.

So, if you add 16 and 6 and then subtract 20, you get exactly 2. However, 2 of the letters are not in alphabetical order so you have to subtract 2. 1 letter is in alphabetical order so you have to add 1.

The calculation here is 16+6-20-2+1=1.

The 1 represents pft as the 1 person who thought Alex was actually trying to use those numbers to prove something.

bill
15 years ago

On Bill Simmon’s podcast Buster Olney said that coaches basically don’t Gold Glove voting seriously at all (surprise surprise) and just go by basically whoever they can remember as a decent fielder (who’s an good shortstop? Jeter? ok, soounds good).

Anyway it’s fun to make of this stuff, so no complaints there really.

Someone from Nowhere
15 years ago

What is going on? It’s 2010, but Derek Jeter wins a GG and then someone references Steve Martin as a comedian to emulate. The end of the world must be nigh.

Danmay
15 years ago

Please go back to nowhere. Anyone that uses the word ‘nigh’ is just trying to hard.

Someone from Nowhere
15 years ago
Reply to  Danmay

At least in Nowhere we are aware of the proper use of the preposition “to” and the adverb “too”. Feel free to visit anytime.

What’s with the number of readers as this site being so anti-intellectual? Why follow a site dedicated to educated analysis if you are going to be hostile toward education, in any format, in the first place? Disagree with the analysis or insight, sure, but to constantly rip on people for offering up thoughtful and informed observations or for using their faculties for an entertaining purpose (i.e., this article) is just ugly philistinism. And some of us know what the word “nigh” means because we read books–heaven forbid we have the gall to use it in a sentence.

Jono
15 years ago
Reply to  Danmay

What is with readers of this site all trying to outdo each other. Wait, look at how smart I am, look at look at me, I am the smartest in all of nowheresville. Look at me I’m so smart!. I use words like nigh and philistine in every day discussions, at the dinner table, and often on the subway, and by forcing them into a two sentence comment about a baseball article smacks of coming across like an elitist douche.

Ace
15 years ago

Nice! It reads like the Foucault’s Pendulum of baseball blogging. (Which book I highly recommend to fans of this post, who are looking for 500 more pages of this sort of thing.)

Bigmouth
15 years ago

Personally, I blame the creators of LOST.

SOB in TO
15 years ago

Meh.
As soon as some valid and credible award is created for fielding excellence, expect clueless coaches to continue voting for these irrelevant awards.

bSpittle
15 years ago

Glen Beck watchers will LOVE this.

JD
15 years ago
Reply to  bSpittle

Gah! You beat me to it. I imagined this entire thing being scribbled on a giant white board.

The Cutter
15 years ago

Hey Ellis, if you’re a huge Yankees fan…than you probably did not watch too many Yankees game. Come on…are you serious? Are you saying every coach and manager that voted for Jeter do not know how to judge a very good shortstop?

turrdog
15 years ago

Jeter was definitely slower this year than last. He looked slower in every facet of his game – running the bases, swinging at the inside pitch, it was just a bad year. Last year I thought he really looked pretty good in the field actually, more often getting balls up the middle.

Whether you think he’s the worst fielder or not, there’s something to be said about only 6 errors from the SS position.

JD
15 years ago
Reply to  turrdog

Yes, the thing to be said is “He can’t reach enough balls to flub them more than six times.”

James
15 years ago

I like how simply saying the post wasn’t funny got 155 negative votes. What a bunch of sheep.

z
15 years ago

Seeing my comment get negative 155 is way funnier than this piece. I wonder if a few people refresed the page and gave ne a lot of minuses or 150 people actually read it and decided it deserved a thumbs down. Also I’m not sayib baseball sites have to be serious I’m just sayin its not funny. Lookout landing is funny (usually).

Andrew
15 years ago

Where’s Glenn Beck telling us that all the voters are on George Soros’ payroll and that this is saying that Jeter is an agent bringing about a one world government?

Gobstopper
15 years ago

Excellent.

Travis
15 years ago

Not enough dinosaurs.

Brian
15 years ago

How about a much easier explanation of Derek Jeter’s golden gloves…since he has gotten his paws on another sexiest woman alive he deserves the gold glove…I mean a guy who can rock out with as many 10’s as he does clearly deserves an award from the players, coaches, and managers in baseball.

Mike
15 years ago

This article has some of the many obnoxious and arrogant undertones seem to plague the advanced metric culture. Completely unnececessary. How about providing an in-depth analysis on why Jeter didn’t deserve the award, instead? What a tool.

Micah
15 years ago

An article showing in-depth analysis on why Jeter didn’t deserve the award? Try looking at any advanced metric recently? It doesn’t take in-depth analysis to show that Jeter doesn’t deserve a 5th gold glove. I prefer the over the top free-masonry approach.