Adrian Beltre Joins the 3,000-Hit Club

Take a knee for a minute to appreciate just how great Adrian Beltre is. (Photo: Keith Allison)

When you think of Adrian Beltre, the first thought that comes to mind might just be his defense. In the early parts of his career, that was his bread and butter. He does, after all, rank 19th all-time in Def, and 10th since the color barrier was broken in 1947. By the time he retires, top 15 in Def is well within his reach.

And yet, Beltre is just as prolific as a hitter! He’s been one of the best players ever on both sides of the ball. Yesterday, he became just the 31st member of the 3,000-hit club. That’s pretty amazing. It’s pretty much an automatic ticket to the Hall of Fame (don’t worry, Rafael Palmeiro will get there some day via some Veteran’s Committee). Beltre also ranks 15th in doubles, 38th in home runs, 21st in total bases and 21st in extra-base hits.

He doesn’t rank quite as high in rate statistics — his .195 ISO ranks 308th out of 3,953 qualified players, for instance. That’s still really, really good, but it doesn’t stand out quite as much. But he has been really good for a really long time. And he’s still playing well. If he’s not at the top of his game, he’s pretty close, and doing a lot better than a lot of other players at the time of their 3,000th hit. Let’s take a look:

3,000-Hit Club, Select Details
Order Name  CareerHits Date of 3k Hit Age at 3k hit wRC+ in 3k hit yr Seasons After
5th Tris Speaker  3,514 5/17/1925 37 167 3
4th Ty Cobb  4,189 8/19/1921 34 164 7
9th Hank Aaron  3,771 5/17/1970 36 146 6
10th Willie Mays  3,283 7/18/1970 39 141 3
8th Stan Musial  3,630 5/13/1958 37 141 5
31st Adrian Beltre  3,000 7/30/2017 38 140 TBD
6th Eddie Collins  3,315 6/3/1925 38 139 2*
11th Roberto Clemente  3,000 9/30/1972 37 135 0**
29th Alex Rodriguez  3,115 6/19/2015 39 130 1
20th Eddie Murray  3,255 6/30/1995 39 128 2
22nd Tony Gwynn  3,141 8/6/1999 39 123 2
13th Pete Rose  4,256 5/5/1978 37 120 8
21st Paul Molitor  3,319 9/16/1996 39 114 2
7th Paul Waner  3,152 6/19/1942 39 113 2
26th Rafael Palmeiro  3,020 7/15/2005 40 107 0
12th Al Kaline  3,007 9/24/1974 39 106 0
15th Carl Yastrzemski  3,419 9/12/1979 39 105 4
28th Derek Jeter  3,465 7/9/2011 37 104 3
14th Lou Brock  3,023 8/13/1979 40 103 0
19th Dave Winfield  3,110 9/16/1993 41 103 2
25th Rickey Henderson  3,055 10/7/2001 42 102 2
16th Rod Carew  3,053 8/4/1985 39 101 0
18th George Brett  3,154 9/30/1992 39 100 1
1st Cap Anson  3,011 07-18-1897 45 100 0
30th Ichiro Suzuki  3,060 8/7/2016 42 99 1***
17th Robin Yount  3,142 9/9/1992 36 97 1
23rd Wade Boggs  3,010 8/7/1999 41 97 0
24th Cal Ripken, Jr.  3,184 4/15/2000 39 92 1
2nd Honus Wagner  3,430 6/9/1914 40 92 3
3rd Nap Lajoie  3,252 9/27/1914 39 83 2
27th Craig Biggio  3,060 6/28/2007 41 70 0
* – Eddie Collins appeared in a couple of subsequent seasons as a pinch hitter as a player/manager, but I’m not going to count those.
** – Roberto Clemente likely would have played for several more seasons had he not tragically died.
*** – Ichiro Suzuki is still active, which if you visit this site regularly you already know.

Sixth-best on this list is something worthy of admiration. Now, Beltre might slide a little — there’s still two months of season left. But he probably won’t fall far — his updated full-season Steamer projection pegs him for a 132 wRC+, which would leave him firmly in the top 10 here.

Either way, Beltre is still going strong as he enters the 3,000-hit club. That was certainly not the case for several of its members. Craig Biggio stands out, as his 3,000th hit was little more than a marketing ruse by Drayton McClane & Co. to wring a few extra tickets sold out of the Killer Bs. Biggio is one of six players (not counting Roberto Clemente) who retired after the season in which they logged their 3,000th hit. Beltre won’t be doing that. He’s on the books for next season, and I won’t at all be surprised if he keeps playing in 2019 and beyond. Certainly, the Rangers would be wise to keep him around. The three teams that let Beltre slip away probably wish they could have a mulligan on that decision.

Team’s 3B WAR Since They Let Adrian Beltre Go
Team Years Team 3B WAR Beltre WAR Difference
Dodgers 2005-2017 42.8 57.8 15.0
Mariners 2010-2017 21.4 41.9 20.5
Red Sox 2011-2017 1.8 35.5 33.7

The Dodgers have done OK, as have the Mariners, but they would still have been better off keeping Beltre. The Red Sox, on the other hand…damn, damn, damn. These sorts of decisions are sometimes hard to compare, and certainly it pales in comparison to Tom Yawkey refusing to sign Jackie Robinson and Willie Mays, but in modern times, it’s hard to think of a worse Red Sox decision than letting Adrian Beltre walk in free agency. Third base may finally be in good hands now that Rafael Devers is up, but it’s been a very long time coming, and a lot of resources have been poured down a bottomless hot corner hole since Beltre left.

Beltre has become an all-time great specifically because he has improved as he has gotten older, in almost complete defiance of what we would consider a normal aging curve.

Adrian Beltre, WAR by Age
Age WAR Rank 3B Rank
14-29 39.1 98 17
30-58 44.0 30 5
Beltre specifically played from ages 19-29, and has played so far from ages 30-38.

That 30th overall rank from age 30 on is also a little misleading. Assuming he stays healthy for the remainder of the season, he’ll be up to 25th by the end of the season. That’ll also move him up to third at third base. And that is a little misleading as well, since Pete Rose finds himself here. From age 30 on, Rose did play full seasons at third base, but he spent more time at first base and in the outfield. (If you want to play around, I made a custom leaderboard with all 31 3,000-hit club members. Enjoy!)

You can see what I mean about Beltre’s improvement in his 30s in this graph:

As you can see, seven of Beltre’s 10 best seasons by wRC+ have come in his 30s. That general shape to a graph is not something you usually see, even from great players. Look at some of the other players in the 3,000-hit club, like Wade Boggs or Alex Rodriguez. It’s not remotely the same shape.

Of course, players can get to the same result in different ways. I grew up believing a 200-hit season was the best achievement you could have as a hitter, probably because I grew up watching Wade Boggs. And indeed Boggs has seven of them, one of the highest totals of all-time. Beltre has just one, which pales in comparison. And yet, Beltre’s way is the more common path.

Would you have guessed that nearly half of the players here only had zero or one 200-hit season? I certainly wouldn’t have. Obviously 200 is an arbitrary number, but I would have thought these guys in particular would have had more of them. I mean, Michael Young has six 200-hit seasons!

Adrian Beltre has left an indelible mark on the game of baseball. Some of his lasting impressions are things he does often, like bare-hand a bunt or dribbler down the third-base line, get mad when someone tries to touch his head, or drop to a knee after a very healthy swing. Some have also surely come in specific moments, like the three times he hit for the cycle, his three-homer performance in the clinching Game 4 of the 2011 ALDS, or even something more random, like that one game back in 2000 when he stole three bases. A few years ago, his Hall of Fame candidacy was debatable. Now, it’s a sure thing, and his residence in one of baseball’s most exclusive clubs is just another reason why.

We hoped you liked reading Adrian Beltre Joins the 3,000-Hit Club by Paul Swydan!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs




Paul Swydan used to be the managing editor of The Hardball Times, a writer and editor for FanGraphs and a writer for Boston.com and The Boston Globe. Now, he owns The Silver Unicorn Bookstore, an independent bookstore in Acton, Mass. Follow him on Twitter @Swydan. Follow the store @SilUnicornActon.

newest oldest most voted
Los
Member
Los

All counting stats when you start playing at 14 and hang on until you are 58.

Los
Member
Los

Note to self. Don’t make unfunny jokes about ages in graphs lest I suffer from the shame of down votes. 🙁