An Unhappy Strasmas

“If this was Strasmas, we got coal in our stockings.”

My friends just got married a month ago, moved into their new home together a week ago, and so they did what any newlywed couple who met in college in Atlanta would do: they checked to see when Stephen Strasburg would make his next start against the Braves — Tuesday, July 27, the calendar said — and then they drove four hours to Washington to watch. I rushed home from work to meet them and take the stadium-bound Metro, which was packed to the gills with red-shirted and red-capped Nats fans, nearly all of them wearing some variation on Strasburg #37.

We joined the crimson sea of fans pouring into the stadium, and took our seats at 7:04, just in time to see the pitcher warming up. And just in time to notice that the cleanshaven Latino on the mound did not bear much resemblance to the 6’4″, goateed Strasburg. Realization dawned on us all at the same time. There would be no Strasmas this week. He’d felt sore during his warmup pitches just a few minutes before we arrived, and the team quietly yanked him. Nationals Park, which was filled by 40,043 Strasburg-enrapt fans that night, echoed with boos of confusion and outrage.

The fill-in was Miguel Batista, a wry 39-year old, who understood the fans’ dismay: “Imagine if you go there to see Miss Universe and you end up having Miss Iowa, you might get those kind of boos. But it’s OK,” he told the AP. “Miss Iowa” is putting it mildly: he hadn’t started a game in two years, and has a career record of 96-110 and an ERA of 4.53, in 16 seasons for eight different organizations. (The real Miss Iowa took the analogy in stride: “It was kind of a diss at first. But I think that I’ll handle that.”)

Batista, somehow, then he led the last-place Nationals to victory over the first-place Braves. The sea of red quickly came over to his side as he quieted the Braves for five innings, and my Braves fan friends went from nonplussed to depressed. It’s somehow more thrilling to watch a phenom blow your team away with 100-mile an hour fastballs than it is to watch a geezer lull them to sleep with moxie and guile. “If this was Strasmas, we got coal in our stockings,” my friend’s wife told him. Nats fans must have felt the same way today, when they learned he was making his first trip to the DL. Still, on Tuesday night, the fireworks roared at the end of the game, and Nats fans discovered a new kind of Strasmas: the one where they win on a day that Strasburg didn’t even pitch.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed.
We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member.
1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other.
2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off.
3. Dark mode and Classic mode!
4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them.
5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects.
6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.)
7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only.
8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO.
9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members.
10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features!
We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it.




Alex is a writer for The Hardball Times.

19 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Ryan
16 years ago

I bought tickets for this Sunday’s game at 4pm on Tuesday, and planned an entire road trip weekend around it. Mother fucker.

Souldrummer
16 years ago
Reply to  Ryan

Would you happen to be a Philly fan, sir?

bonestock94
16 years ago

At least one of my favorite sites has acknowledged my major dissapointments this week.

bonestock94
16 years ago
Reply to  bonestock94

dissapointment*

geo
16 years ago
Reply to  bonestock94

You’re close…try “disappointment.”

bonestock94
16 years ago
Reply to  bonestock94

yawn

oh dear
16 years ago

i don’t know, driving 4 hours to see a nats game is borderline psychotic…

and if you don’t go there to support them, other than to see their best player pitch, i can’t feel too bad.

Temo
16 years ago
Reply to  oh dear

I also live 4 hours away and was pretty close to making the same trip myself. I am also a Braves fan– if Heyward vs. Strasburg isn’t worth a roadtrip, then no regular season baseball game is.

Souldrummer
16 years ago
Reply to  oh dear

Not really psychotic. They’re Braves fans. They want to see him pitch against the Braves. They also would like to make a trip up to DC and coordinate when to come see him.It’s just that their plans went awry. I’m one of the few Nats fans who appreciates Miguel Batista. I was at the game and bummed for the first couple of innings that I didn’t get to see Stras. But I’m a Nats fan, I’ve been to all of the home Strasburg starts and maybe 25-30 games overall. As long as he’s healthy next year, things are okay because he’s given us enough hope. If he doesn’t pitch again, they will probably limit him to 120IP next year, though. As long as this doesn’t push his innings total down too much, he’ll still be able to give us 180IP next year as a more mature pitcher, instead of the 80-100IP as a rookie still making some adjustments.

It was deeply, deeply satisfying to see Miguel Batista shut down the Braves tourists. A lot of Virginia south of the DC suburbs is Braves country and I imagine many of them thought they’d catch a Strasburg start and a series win. Instead, they got a loss at the hands of Batista while the Nats ran wild on Brian McCann. And then they lose the series today. Not but so many bright spots this season besides Strasburg for the Nats, but starting out this homestand well provides hope that we can at least be division nuisances down the stretch.

CircleChange11
16 years ago

I know that WSN said that they were going to limit Strasburg’s IP this year.

From what I gather from the report is that there is not an “injury” as we traditionally think of it, but rather “tightness” or “unable to get loose” in the BP.

Did this situation present an “opportunity” for the organization to “limit his IP” without backlash from the fans?

If they sit him on the bench for 3 or 4 starts, the fans go crazy because of all they’ve done to get to the game (similar things as presented in this thread), and would field “Those bastards, I sacrificed so much to go to the game” comments.

Now, they get to rest him for 2 weeks, which helps limit his IP, and then pitch him through the remainder of the year, without being the “bad guy”.

Is this possible?

Souldrummer
16 years ago
Reply to  CircleChange11

No. They were determined to pitch him to his pitch limit for IP as quickly as possible. They believe that they will have multiple people coming off of the disabled list to help take his spot in the rotation when his innings limit arrives. Right now, by stopping him now, Jordan Zimmermann, their top prospect before his debut last year, will not be able to take his rotation spot because Jordan Zimmermann will not be ready until mid-August. They are either going to have start Jason Marquis before he’s shown he can get people out in his rehabs or bring up stop gap like Matt Chico.

swheatle
16 years ago

Is this the dreaded ‘inverted w’ raising its head?

CircleChange11
16 years ago
Reply to  swheatle

He lost the inverted-W in college. He uses more of a horizontal-W now, like Jake Peavey (relax), only without the over-rotatation (there’s the big difference). His mechanics are actually pretty good.

IMO, it probably has to do with hitting the 110 IP mark over 20 starts in 5 months. He hasn’t had the “typical” progression. He pitched in the minors to put off service time, and then was placed right in the rotation in ML.

Mechanics guys often predict doom on any prospect, and are often right because all pitchers do get hurt at some point. But, no one ever accepts the additional workload in the pros as a key factor.

Jamie Garcia was a major injury concern as well, while Mark Prior was perfect and efficient.

I am open to being wrong about this, but I’d like to see that it’s an actual injury, and not just some tightness or standard inconvenience of pitching, before I accept the gloom and doom.

I’m sure the pitching mechanics blogs are blowing up today, and a few guys are likely throwing themselves a parade. But, my view is “let’s wait and see”. It could be nothing that we all forget about, or it could be the start of his demise, but it’s probably something in between.

I could believe that WSN is being hyper-sensitive about it as well.

Boots
16 years ago

Goodness people, worse things have happened in life. These kind of stories are ridiculous. How dare Strasburg injure his arm. How selfish. THE TRAVESTY!

oompaloopma
16 years ago

Its called a baseball game, and its not called a pitcher throwing a ball. If you can only enjoy a game when you favorite player is in the game you are not a real fan of baseball.

PJ
16 years ago

This is why there is Strasburg hype backlash. Seriously?

Ali
16 years ago

You people are pathetic.

this guy
16 years ago
Reply to  Ali

this

Ricky True
16 years ago

Listen guys, all I know is if I had gone to see Strasburg pitch, and then he didn’t, I would have farted right where I stood and not even said sorry.

payday0023
16 years ago

Miguel, you’re vastly overrating yourself by even considering the Miss Iowa comparison. This would be like going to see Miss Universe and getting a husk of corn instead.