Author Archive

Kiley McDaniel Prospects Chat – 5/19/15

11:41
Kiley McDaniel: I’ll be back in 20 minutes to answer your questions

12:04
Kiley McDaniel: Okay I’m back let’s get started

12:04
Comment From Matt
When are you going to Greenville to see Moncada, Devers, etc?

12:05
Kiley McDaniel: Working out the days, maybe this weekend

12:05
Comment From David
I’m baffled by this Difo promotion. Can you try to explain why they would promote him this early and what should we expect out of him?

12:06
Kiley McDaniel: Sounds like they were short on 40-man hitters to call up and he’s an early-count contact guy that is less likely to be embarassed than other guys. He’s also 23 and was a late bloomer, so you can see what they’re thinking, don’t think this is helpful for his development, though.

Read the rest of this entry »


Kiley McDaniel Prospects Chat – 5/12/15

12:03
Kiley McDaniel: I’m here, sans beer, get used to it

12:08
Kiley McDaniel: Alrighty I’ll get the announcements out of the way about the existing content, in case your question is generall in terms of timeframe

General top prospects questions can usually be answered by the top 200 (though some things have changed for some of these guys already): http://www.fangraphs.com/bl…

Check the team prospect lists for questions on some deeper cuts, here’s the last list with links to the other 29: http://www.fangraphs.com/bl…

July 2 update in three parts: http://www.fangraphs.com/bl… http://www.fangraphs.com/bl… http://www.fangraphs.com/bl…

And, finally, the draft content has been coming fast and furious of late and the 2015 stuff will get updated in a few weeks as the info is still rolling in

Mock Draft: http://www.fangraphs.com/bl…
2015 draft prospects: http://www.fangraphs.com/bl…
2016/2017 draft prospects: http://www.fangraphs.com/bl…

12:08
Comment From joe
how has evaluating prospects changed over the last 10, 20, 30 years?

12:09
Kiley McDaniel: I can only guess since I started in the last 10 years. Lots more phone calls and relationships, along with way poorer scouting info/consensus and stats due to communication via technology and showcases/access to players

12:09
Comment From Bryan
Is Mallex Smith the future starting center fielder in Atlanta?

12:10
Kiley McDaniel: Could be. Has the tools to be a solid starting center fielder, but the bat is seen as just okay, so the speed needs to play in all phases.

Read the rest of this entry »


A Far-Too-Early 2015 MLB Mock Draft

I wrote yesterday about the uncertainty surrounding the #1 overall pick, but that doesn’t keep scouts from trying to figure out who will go in the subsequent picks. It’s way too early to have any real idea what’s going to happen beyond the top 10-15 picks, but the buzz is growing in the scouting community about how things will play out and you people are sustained by lists, predictions and mock drafts. You’re welcome.

I’d bet it’s more telling on draft day to make judgments using the buzz and all the names I mention, rather than the one name I project to be picked, but you guys already don’t read the introduction, so I’ll shut up. For reports, video and more on these players, check out my latest 2015 MLB Draft rankings, or, if your team doesn’t pick high this year, look ahead with my 2016 & 2017 MLB Draft rankings.

UPDATE 5/11/15: Notes from this weekend’s college games: Dillon Tate was solid in front of GM’s from Arizona, Houston and Colorado. Dansby Swanson was even better, in front of decision makers from all the top teams, including Houston, who may still be debating whether they’d take Swanson or Rodgers if given the choice (Rodgers’ season is over). Carson Fulmer did what he usually does and probably has a home from picks 7-17 depending on how things fall on draft day, with an evaluation similar to Marcus Stroman and Sonny Gray as previous undersized righties with stellar track records and plus stuff.

Andrew Benintendi went nuts at the plate again (I’ll see him and Fulmer this weekend). And, finally, Jon Harris was excellent, rebounding from a not-so-great start, so, at this point, I would make Harris the 9th pick to the Cubs and slide Trenton Clark down a few picks, but still comfortably in the top 20. I also updated the 2016 MLB Draft Rankings as a few top prospects came off the DL and impressed, further strengthening the top of that draft, which is far and away better than this year’s draft.

1. Diamondbacks – Dansby Swanson, SS, Vanderbilt
I wrote about this more in depth yesterday, where I wrote it’s down to CF Garrett Whitley, C Tyler Stephenson and CF Daz Cameron with some chance RHP Dillon Tate is still in the mix and SS Dansby Swanson possibly involved. After writing that, I heard that Arizona is definitely considering those prep players, but teams don’t think they’ll pull the trigger on a way-below-slot prep option and they are leaning college, with Tate and Swanson the targets and SS Alex Bregman also getting some consideration as a long shot.

I’ve heard Arizona wants a hitter here and GM Dave Stewart was in to see Vanderbilt last night. I had heard they were laying in the weeds on Swanson, so, for now, I’ll go with Swanson here. To be clear, Arizona hasn’t made any decisions yet, so this group could still grow or they could change course. One scouting director told me yesterday when asked what he thought Arizona would do that “it sounds like they are going to do something crazy.” Until a few hours before this published, I had Arizona taking Whitley, so this is still very much in flux. There’s also some thought that Tate or Swanson were the targets all along and the rumors of cut-rate high school options have just been a ploy to get the price down–you can pick your own theory at this point.

Read the rest of this entry »


D’Backs Plans For the First Overall Pick Come Into Focus

I’ve written many times in the past eight months that this draft class is pretty weak and that, combined with the bonus pools that limit each team’s draft spending, will make for an unpredictable draft day filled with below-slot deals. That talk has continued here and in other places but, in the last few weeks, teams’ plans have come into better focus and the question marks now start at the very top.

I called Orlando-area prep SS Brendan Rodgers the best prep player in the 2015 class a full two years ago and he’s held serve since then, standing today as the consensus top player in the whole draft for the industry and in my recent rankings.  The assumption for most of the spring was that the Diamondbacks would take Rodgers #1 as the consensus top player in a down class. Another reason this made sense is the embattled first seven months of the Dave Stewart/Tony La Russa regime in Arizona, which have gone about as bad as possible so far, so they don’t need another off-the-board, bucking-industry-consensus decision that could draw more bad PR.

I had heard in the last few weeks that Rodgers was out of the mix for the D’Backs at #1, but until I had heard who the target was, I didn’t feel comfortable reporting that, since it could just be misdirection for negotiating purposes. I had also heard the D’Backs weren’t at many of Rodgers’ games this spring, so that put more momentum behind that buzz being real.  hen, in the last few weeks, D’Backs GM Dave Stewart and VP of Baseball Ops DeJon Watson have been seen all over the country scouting amateur players, but not Rodgers.

Read the rest of this entry »


Kiley McDaniel Prospects Chat – 5/5/15

12:04
Kiley McDaniel: I’m here. Let’s start.

12:05
Comment From Tim
How can the Braves get Josh Bell from the Pirates?

12:06
Kiley McDaniel: The Braves have 8 prospects that I deem to have the same or more trade value than Bell, so there’s 8 of the ways they could do it.

http://www.fangraphs.com/bl…

12:06
Comment From Jeff Gross
With Bryant/Russell graduated to the majors, where would the Cubs farm system rank now? Have the performance of enough guys like Vogelbach and Schwarber ticked up/maintained more grades overall than have disappointed (e.g., Johnson) to keep the Cubs in the top 5 overall?

12:07
Kiley McDaniel: More on this in the coming weeks

12:07
Comment From Peezus
How high are you on Tyler Glasnow and when do you see him coming up?

Read the rest of this entry »


Kiley McDaniel Prospects Chat – 4/28/15

12:06
Kiley McDaniel: I’m in Nashville right now, so let’s have a country music theme to this week’s chat. Just kidding, that would be terrible.

12:09
Comment From John
Come to Memphis sometime: far better food, music, and history than the overrated Nashville. I’ll even buy you some Memphis BBQ.

12:10
Kiley McDaniel: Almost went there during the opening series of the year to see Iowa (Bryant, Russell, Baez). Got ribs at Rendezvous last time I was there, when I saw Shelby Miller in AAA in 2012 for ESPN.

12:10
Comment From Pale Hose
In general, does org filler know it is org filler?

12:11
Kiley McDaniel: I know I don’t ask them that, but usually around their 3rd or 4th year they figure out who is getting the attention, who is on prospect lists, etc.

12:11
Comment From Guest
Does Bradley Zimmer have the tools to go 25/25 in the majors?

Read the rest of this entry »


2016/2017 MLB Draft Rankings: Ridiculously Early Edition

Over the last two weeks, my insatiable desire to rank everything manifested itself in a threepart roundup of the buzz, rumors and scouting reports of this year’s top international amateur prospects and an excessively long ranking of the top prospects for this summer’s domestic draft. Earlier this year, I mentioned the top two names already making buzz in the 2016 July 2nd class, so it only seemed reasonable to also dive into the next two draft classes as well.

For obvious reasons, there’s a lot more information available for future draft classes than for future July 2 classes, but there are still limitations to what we can know at this point.

– It’s easier now to scout non-draft eligible high school players because of the showcase circuit, but scouts aren’t focusing on them so many don’t have strong opinions, much less rankings of these players. An average scout’s knowledge about guys on this list is limited to a handful of guys that are on loaded high school teams they see regularly, a guy that really stood out at one summer event they went to, collegiates that play at major programs or that were known prospects out of high school. We have video of most of these players and will start adding it to the FG YouTube page in the coming weeks.

That means making this list is combining what I’ve seen, what scouts tell me, notes from various other sources and which underclassmen are attracting interest from advisors, which is a surprisingly good indicator.

Read the rest of this entry »


Lucius Fox Throws A Wrench Into July 2nd Signings

As I tweeted yesterday, Bahamas-born and recently but shortly American-educated shortstop Lucius Fox was declared an international free agent by Major League Baseball. He won’t be eligible to sign until July 2nd when the 2015-16 signing period opens and the team bonus pools reset, but he would’ve waited until then to sign anyway, since most of the 2014-15 signing pool money had been spent.

Fox was always seen as likely to land as an international prospect since he was born in the Bahamas and moved back home, but it wasn’t a slam dunk because MLB is very aware of player moving out of the U.S. to potentially get more money by ducking the draft. Many elite domestic prospects have investigated this process and found the red tape to make it nearly impossible to work through.

As I wrote last week, the 2015 international signing markets, which opens on July 2nd, is already mostly shaken out at this point. I currently project 25 players to get $1.2 million or more and it appears that 22 of them have deals already. Of those three, the highest bonus should be about $1.5 to $1.7 million while the five top bonuses in the class range from $3.0 million to $4.4 million.

Read the rest of this entry »


Kiley McDaniel Prospects Chat – 4/20/15

12:08

Kiley McDaniel: This is a chat. Let’s chat.

12:10
Comment From Keeper? I hardly know her
Does Uribe’s slow start make it likely that Corey Seager comes up early?

12:10

Kiley McDaniel: Don’t think they’re going to rush Seager based on short-term need.

12:10
Comment From KD
Wisler- up in 2015? Starter or reliever?

12:11

Kiley McDaniel: Starter. Don’t think they bring him up in relief unless he sits in AAA all year and a spot doesn’t open up and they just want to get him worked in for Sept…but a spot will open up at some point.

12:11
Comment From Bojack Horseman
Has your opinion of Matt Wisler changed significantly since you wrote up the Padres in December?

Read the rest of this entry »


2015 MLB Draft Rankings, April Edition

This is the update to September’s list and a lot has happened since then. I chose to rank as many players as there are first round picks and to give reports on them, since those are the guys that matter at this point. I obviously have lots of info beyond that to pass along, but opted to be more general at this juncture.

The next couple section break down plays as sandwich to 2nd rounders or 3rd rounders or others of note, with varying definitions from each group that I note below.  The reason I’m less detailed about the lower rankings is because 1) we’re still six weeks from the draft, so this will change 2) it’s kinda silly to act like 45 and 65 are that different at this point and 3) there’s inherent secrecy from scouts about draft rankings, so these will likely change again in the summer when we see these guys compete on an even playing field. For these next two groups, players are presented in order of preference, so you can shift them around a few spots if you want, but the final section of others is in no order at all.

As I’ve said in many places already, this class is very weak up top. The top 15 players listed below have anywhere from six to ten players worth of being picks in the top half of the first round in a normal year. This amounts to 5-9 elite players missing, which doesn’t seem like a lot, but means teams picking in the top 20 will likely notice they’re getting less than they may have expected to get a year ago when the draft class was less clear.

Again, since the draft is inherently secretive at some level and I can’t see every player multiple times this spring, these rankings are a mix of what I’ve see and think and what scouts are telling me. I’d like for it to be 100% my opinion, but that would be foolish, so I have to side with the preponderance of scouts, even when they disagree with me.  I’ll link to video from the FG YouTube page where we have it, which is still a lot, but there will be a lot more in the coming weeks, as we have video of nearly every player I put in the top 3-4 rounds.

Read the rest of this entry »