Furcal: The Stopgap Solution
Rafael Furcal is sitting pretty right about now.
While Jose Reyes and Jimmy Rollins are clearly the top two free agent shortstops, each player carries a significant amount of risk. Furcal isn’t free and clear of the risks associated with either player, but he’ll prove significantly less expensive.
Reyes’s inability to stay on the field — he played in 295 of the possible 486 games since 2009 — eats away at his value. If teams aren’t convinced he has adequately recovered from his recent ailments, they are less likely to dole out an iconic type of contract. The talent is obvious, and at 28 years old he is still in his prime. But what good is paying $16+ million per year for the next 4-6 years if he can’t stay on the field?
Rollins, meanwhile, expects to sign a lucrative 3-4 year deal. Sure, he expressed a desire for a five-year contract because, hey, who wouldn’t want that type of deal. But he knows it’s unlikely. Rollins’s performance has been hindered by injuries of late, but his 2011 numbers marked a return to form to his 2004-06 self, the player that produced 4.5-5 WAR. He’s an elite defender at the most important position, a top-notch baserunner, and a league average hitter capable of knocking the ball out of the yard. These players don’t grow on trees, but Rollins is also 33 years old.


