Mathemadage: Rusty Bats

I have a problem. During the broadcast of Game 1 of the World Series, John Smoltz made an offhand comment that contact hitters do a better job of handling long layoffs between series than power hitters. “The eight to nine days off would… cause havoc on most offenses. But this offense is different, it’s not built on slug,” he said before quickly moving on. His partner in the booth, Joe Davis, didn’t even respond; he just pivoted back to the first inning’s action. Smart move – it’s the World Series, no one wants to debate truisms. But while Nick Martinez faced off against Jake Bauers, I was sitting there turning over that pearl of analyst wisdom in my head.
So do contact hitters handle rust better than power hitters? You could tell an intuitive story in the affirmative. They don’t need to connect perfectly with the ball to get to their good results, so they’re less affected by losing their timing thanks to a long gap between games. But you could tell the opposite story using intuition as well: Contact hitters rely on feel and placement. Tiny margins make the difference between flailing at bad pitches and punching them the other way, so being out of sorts might really hurt.
Some quick Googling didn’t settle things; AI mode told me that contact hitters really do suffer less from rust than power hitters. But when I asked to see the statistical evidence, the AI helpfully told me that it could find none and that it had relied on anecdotal evidence to reach its conclusions. Sounds like a job for Mathemadage, my column that investigates conventional wisdom using numbers. Read the rest of this entry »





