Charlie Morton Is the Braves’ Latest One-Year Rental

It’s often said that there are no bad one-year deals, and the Braves have made a particular habit of using them to augment their young rotations — a habit that predates Alex Anthopoulos’ arrival as their general manager. After a season in which they fell one win short of their first trip to the World Series since 1999 despite a rotation thinned out by major injuries, the Braves have been been aggressive in pursuing that short-term approach. After signing Drew Smyly to a one-year contract last week, they’ve inked Charlie Morton to a one-year, $15 million deal, the same amount of money he would have been paid in 2021 had the Rays not declined his option in late October. Though a quirk of timing caused him to miss inclusion in our Top 50 Free Agents list, he’s the first major free agent to come off the board.

Morton, who turned 37 on November 12, is coming off a regular season in which he was limited to nine starts and 38 innings due to a bout of shoulder inflammation that sidelined him for three weeks in August. The Rays kept him on a short leash, but as the postseason reminded the baseball world, that’s how they roll. Morton pitched more than five innings just once (5.2 on August 4 against the Red Sox), and he topped 90 pitches just three times, maxing out at 94. He was used similarly in the postseason, and looked quite good, particularly in a pair of scoreless starts against the Astros in the ALCS; he threw five innings and 96 pitches in Game 2, then an ultra-efficient 5.2 innings while allowing just two hits on 66 pitches in Game 7. His removal while cruising along in that latter game foreshadowed manager Kevin Cash’s ill-fated decision to pull Blake Snell in Game 6 of the World Series, though in Morton’s case things turned out in the Rays’ favor. His lone postseason dud came in Game 3, when the Dodgers roughed him up for five runs in 4.1 innings.

Including the postseason, Morton posted a 4.03 ERA, 3.15 FIP, and 25.3% strikeout rate in 58 innings, a step down from his 3.05 ERA, 2.81 FIP, and 30.4% strikeout rate in 2019. Via Statcast, including both postseasons as well in order to beef up the sample size for 2020, his average exit velocity rose from 86.8 mph to 88.8, his barrel rate from 4.9% to 7.1%, and his xwOBA from .282 to .291. That kind of performance dip might have come out in the wash with a longer season, and so too with regards to his drop in velocity, but the latter is of more concern given his age and shoulder injury. Sticking with Statcast’s numbers and again including postseasons, his average four-seam fastball velocity has fallen from 96.1 mph in 2018 to 94.8 in ’19 and then 93.7 this year. While the velo drop might have figured into the Rays’ thinking in declining Morton’s option, their general tight-fistedness and the fact that Morton himself said that he would consider retiring if they didn’t pick up the option probably loomed larger.

The timing of the Rays’ decision on Morton prevented us from including him on our Top 50 list. As I noted in my roundup of players with declined options, I asked list-maker Craig Edwards where he’d place Morton among the top 50; he suggested 12th, one spot below Marcus Stroman, who since then has accepted the Mets’ one-year, $18.9 million qualifying offer. Some further thoughts of mine from that piece:

I’d put Morton ahead of Stroman based upon their recent workloads and performances; Morton made at least 30 starts in both 2018 and ’19, and totaled 13.0 WAR with a 3.27 ERA and 3.25 FIP in 546.1 innings since the start of 2017, while Stroman produced just 8.7 WAR with a 3.65 ERA and 3.83 FIP in 487.2 innings in that span, obviously in part because he missed this season, though his injury would have cost him a substantial chunk anyway… That said, there’s a 7 1/2-year age difference between the two, and Morton’s fastball velocity has dropped 2.4 mph over the past two seasons… though he’s still bringing more heat than Stroman (92.5 mph in 2019).

While our Steamer projections have the two pitchers even in WAR despite Stroman being forecast to throw 39 more innings, ZiPS gives the edge to Morton for 2021, though a longer-term projection would likely tilt in Stroman’s favor. This is a Braves-specific projection (of course Stroman never had a chance to sign with Atlanta), though Stroman’s Mets projection only differs by a few hundredths of a run:

2021 ZiPS Projections – Charlie Morton vs. Marcus Stroman
Pitcher W L ERA G GS IP H HR BB SO ERA+ FIP WAR
Charlie Morton 11 6 3.66 26 26 137.2 123 16 45 151 124 3.72 3.0
Marcus Stroman 11 7 4.19 28 28 156.2 162 18 51 129 108 4.07 2.6
Both pitchers are projected with the 2021 Braves.

Morton did fall short of my prediction for either a one-year-plus-option or two-year deal, perhaps because he really is looking to the finish line — and if that’s the case, he’s come full circle. The Braves chose Morton in the third round of the 2002 draft out of a Connecticut high school, and stuck with him as he plodded through two years in Rookie leagues and three in A-ball. Not until 2007 did he reach Double-A, and he made just 16 starts with a 6.15 ERA for the big club, all in ’08, before being traded to the Pirates in the Nate McLouth deal in ’09.

In signing with Atlanta, Morton continues a roster strategy that the Braves — who have been awash in young starting pitchers in recent years — have used liberally since John Coppolella’s tenure as GM. Including Smyly and Morton, since the winter of 2016-17, they’ve signed seven starting pitchers to one-year deals, only one of which was a minor-league contract. Admittedly, the results have been a mixed bag thus far:

One and Done: Braves Free Agent Starters Since 2017
Pitcher Year Salary IP ERA FIP WAR
R.A. Dickey 2017 $8M 190.0 4.26 4.72 1.5
Bartolo Colon 2017 $12.5M 63.0 8.14 5.09 0.1
Aníbal Sánchez 2018 $1M* 133.2 2.90 3.59 2.5
Dallas Keuchel 2019 $13M** 112.2 3.75 4.72 0.8
Cole Hamels 2020 $6.67M** 3.1 8.10 2.89 0.1
Charlie Morton 2021 $15M
Drew Smyly 2021 $11M
Total 2017-20 $41.17M 502.2 4.29 4.45 5.0
* = minor league contract
** = prorated amount

Dickey and Colon were signed by Coppolella during the Braves’ rebuilding phase; they were entering their age-42 and -44 seasons, respectively, and only the former even came close to panning out. Sánchez was a scrapheap pickup who had been increasingly ineffective and/or unavailable over the previous three years, and who had just been released by the Twins during spring training. Keuchel, whose free agency was hampered both by his receiving a qualifying offer from the Astros and by some combination of unrealistic expectations and a slow winter for free agency, didn’t sign until after the draft. Hamels, whose full-season salary would have been $18 million, made just one appearance for the Braves, on September 16, in a season lost to triceps and shoulder injuries.

In the aggregate, the Braves have paid about $8 million per win for these guys, and that number would be higher, and the performance further below average, if I hadn’t included the Sánchez deal. Certainly, they could have chosen better and gotten more bang for the buck; in the realm of one-year deals Lance Lynn delivered 2.8 WAR to the Twins and Yankees for $12 million in 2018, Brett Anderson gave the A’s 2.0 WAR for somewhere between $1.5 and $2.5 million in ’19, and Kevin Gausman — who pitched for the Braves for parts of both of those seasons — turned in a 1.5 WAR season for $3.33 million (after proration) with the Giants this year. But the Braves also could have committed $60 million or more to somebody like Jake Arrieta, Madison Bumgarner, or Nathan Eovaldi during this time period and received a thoroughly underwhelming return at greater cost.

I’m not suggesting this approach would work for every team, or that the Braves have exactly reinvented the wheel, but they’ve now won three straight NL East titles while rolling the dice on a grizzled starter to accompany a stable of young arms that could prove to be particularly formidable. It’s not unreasonable for them to keep going this route given their depth, and Morton, who’s just a year removed from being one of the AL’s elite starters, is this winter’s ideal candidate. He’d help the rotation of any contender, and given that eight to 10 teams were said to be interested in his services, it’s quite possible that he could have been working against the Braves rather than for them.

The Rays, who hoped to take advantage of Morton’s desire to remain near his Bradenton home by retaining him at a lesser salary, have work to do to replace Morton in a rotation that still contains Blake Snell, Tyler Glasnow, and Ryan Yarbrough. With Yonny Chirinos out for most if not all of the year due to Tommy John surgery and Brendan McKay recovering from labrum surgery, Josh Fleming and Brent Honeywell Jr. are the leading candidates to round out that group barring trades or signings. The Rays are reportedly open to trading Snell, who’s under club control through 2023 via a five-year, $50 million extension he signed in March 2019, and could conceivably use the return to fill out the rotation.

With Atlanta, Morton joins a rotation that will feature Max Fried, Mike Soroka (assuming his recovery from a torn right Achilles goes well), Ian Anderson, and Smyly, with Kyle Wright, Bryse Wilson, and Huascar Ynoa providing depth. Eyeballing their Depth Chart with the assumption that it’s Wright’s innings he’s cutting into the most deeply, Morton projects to provide about a 1.5-win upgrade for the regular season, and to vault the Braves’ rotation from 16th to 11th in our projections.

With Morton on board, the Braves can now turn their attention to Marcell Ozuna, who himself excelled in Atlanta on a one-year deal and whom the team is reportedly interested in retaining for longer. If he departs, the Braves will have a sizable hole in their lineup to fill, but if they need to trade rather than to shop on the open market, they’re that much deeper in pitching thanks to the addition of Morton.





Brooklyn-based Jay Jaffe is a senior writer for FanGraphs, the author of The Cooperstown Casebook (Thomas Dunne Books, 2017) and the creator of the JAWS (Jaffe WAR Score) metric for Hall of Fame analysis. He founded the Futility Infielder website (2001), was a columnist for Baseball Prospectus (2005-2012) and a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated (2012-2018). He has been a recurring guest on MLB Network and a member of the BBWAA since 2011, and a Hall of Fame voter since 2021. Follow him on BlueSky @jayjaffe.bsky.social.

42 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
TKDCMember since 2016🏆 MVP
5 years ago

The free agency ranking system doesn’t really work for older players. Yes, there is slightly increased risk for the next year when looking at older players, but not exceedingly so. How does this work? Is the ranking based solely on projected 2021 performance or do further years also factor in?

I also think it should not be a surprise that the Braves one year at a time strategy has produced basically an average outcome. They basically have a mutual fund for pitchers when looked at in the aggregate. If you go all in on one stock, you might hit it big, but you can also go bust. It’s less likely to bust when you are just signing guys for somewhat modest one year deals.

airforce21oneMember since 2026
5 years ago
Reply to  TKDC

The Braves have spent a ton of draft capital on pitchers – they just haven’t developed. Giving a long-term deal to a 37 year old pitcher is foolish by the standards of most teams, not just the Braves.

Connor Grey
5 years ago

I have faith in the Rays ability to put together an above average pitching staff for 2021 but losing Morton for the same exact amount of money that his option was worth is pretty disappointing. With that being said, the players that Tampa has moved on from who they’ve gotten good surplus value out of have usually seen a drop-off in performance as soon as they leave (Tommy Pham, Mallex Smith, Ryne Stanek, Chris Archer, C.J. Cron, Jake Bauers, Matt Andriese). So maybe they’ll end up looking smart for not picking up Morton’s option, idk.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Connor Grey

The Rays are also looking at trading Snell (mentioned in the article), which is actually probably a good move in the abstract but kind of absurd in the immediate context of 2021. “Who needs actual starting pitchers? We don’t!”

dodgerbleu
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I hope this isn’t like Archer where we have to hear about him being on the block for 3 years, and just when it seems like he’s lost all surplus trade value and they were never serious about moving him anyway, they fleece some poor team.

Or maybe I do.

Either way, I don’t think they’ll be quick to move him, I expect to hear his name on the hot stove a dozen times this year but not much more. Hope I’m wrong.

MikeD
5 years ago
Reply to  dodgerbleu

This is the opening shot, but he will be traded. My guess is in one year.

airforce21oneMember since 2026
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Maybe I’m missing something. Why wouldn’t ANY team, even the tight-fisted Rays, want a pitcher of Snell’s age and caliber at 5 yrs/50M?

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  airforce21one

For one, the guy has literally never pitched a full season. They also don’t have faith in him after 5 innings, and whether or not that’s justified that clearly affects how they view him. He’s also definitely peaked with his run in 2018, and even if he can recapture the form he showed back in 2019 for a year they’d probably rather sell high on him than wait and see him lose his trade value. And finally, the Rays might (I’m not sure about this) view all traditional starting pitchers as overvalued and/or fungible.

As for me, I think he’s the kind of guy whose stuff works in the playoffs, so although I’m not convinced he’s your regular season workhorse type I wouldn’t give up on him so easily…guys who are legitimate candidates for a playoff rotation are not that common. But also, if the Rays see an arbitrage opportunity they’ll probably move on it.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Ha, I should have said that he has only pitched a full season once.

airforce21oneMember since 2026
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Snell was on pace for 3+ WAR this year, which would put him at 13+ for the first five seasons of his career. He’s a 27 year old lefty with great stuff.

On the open market, guys like this get 25M plus per year.

MikeD
5 years ago
Reply to  airforce21one

As far as the Rays go, they’re always trying to balance current and future value with a mixture that will allow them to remain competitive today and years on. If they hold Snell until the end, or close to the end of his contract, it will lower their return, plus he could even flame out or get injured. That’s a disaster for a team like the Rays. His salary is also escalating, so holding him will cut into other trades and signings each year his pay rises.

Their belief is Snell’s value is at its highest because he’s young, very good, a lefty, cheap and controllable, so the return for him will be significant. If they identify the correct players to trade for, it will help them maintain being competitive now and beyond Snell’s contract, while lowering their costs.

As I wrote elsewhere, my guess is this is their opening salvo, alerting the market he’s available. If someone blows them away, they’ll trade him now, but likely they’ll assess trade opportunities over the next year until they identify the best package. I don’t see Snell moving just yet.

Antonio BananasMember since 2016
5 years ago
Reply to  airforce21one

FIP has gone up each year since his Cy Young season. He’s 28, so not a lot more upside. Health issues. This is a perfect sell high situation imo. Which the Rays have to be better at than anyone else.

Hypothetically they can probably get what? Two 60FVs, two 45+ FVs, with the 45s being ML Ready.

David Klein
5 years ago
Reply to  Connor Grey

Did they wanna move on from him though? Seems they wanted him back just not at 15 mil and besides for Archer none of the guys did much in their career besides for very short term success. Morton has been excellent since 2017

Connor Grey
5 years ago
Reply to  David Klein

Tommy Pham had been excellent for three straight years when he was traded. I also forgot to mention Evan Longoria. He’s been playable the last couple seasons but Tampa made the right decision to trade him when they did.

And I’m sure they wanted Morton on their team for 2021 but if Morton spends the year injured and/or ineffective then he would just get added to the list of players the Rays have moved on from at exactly the right time. Morton is admittedly in a different tier than most of the other players I listed in my previous comment but that doesn’t change the fact that they’ve generally been good at picking the right time to move on from players on their big league roster.

David Klein
5 years ago
Reply to  Connor Grey

I forgot about Pham so you are correct there- and yeah they fleeced the Giants by getting them to take on a declining Longoria’s contract.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  David Klein

They actually paid some money to the Giants to take the contract and took back a bad contract as well. But they really wanted him gone (even if they were still on the hook for some money) before he hit the decline phase and before he got 10-5 rights, and they more or less got that. So I wouldn’t call it a fleecing.

carterMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Connor Grey

I don’t think Pham is some done deal either. He has had 1 bad injured season, that is it. It was only 125 plate appearances as well, basically 1 bad month when he was playing through an injury. It would not surprise me at all to see him bounce back to somewhere around his career wRC+ of 126.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  carter

It’s also worth noting that the entire return for Pham rests on Xavier Edwards now. Cronenworth looks great, Pham very well might bounce back (I agree with carter here, I think he’ll be good again), and Hunter Renfroe looked like a non-tender candidate even if he was good in 2020 and he really, really wasn’t. There is a real belief that the Rays win every single one of their trades and that clearly isn’t correct (although they do clearly win more often than not).

Roman AjzenMember since 2020
5 years ago

I think the analysis of the Braves’ preference for large value one-year deals for veterans would be more interesting if you include the position players in the analysis (donaldson + ozuna, off the top of my head). The Braves have clearly done well in this market and continue to go back to the well this year.

FrancoeursteinMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Roman Ajzen

I love the way AA operates. It’s been a pretty consistent theme the past few off-seasons: strike early with a high-upside signing (Donaldson, Will Smith, Hamels, D’Arnaud, Morton) and then re-assess the market for inefficiencies late in the off-season (Ozuna, Keuchel, etc). He also attempted to sign Puig right before the season before the physical fell through.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Roman Ajzen

I am of the strong opinion that this approach is not just AA’s approach but also due to their corporate ownership. This tendency seems like a corporate philosophy to minimize long-term commitments and costs, and in a context where perhaps budgets are not always known many years in advance.

That said, it has worked out exceptionally well for them. So it’s hard to complain if you’re a Braves fan.

hughduffy
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I think the approach is AA’s, and it just fits in well with the Braves organizational philosophy. When he first became GM, AA said, “I believe wholeheartedly there are players who can make other players better.” Josh Donaldson was one such player, and he made an impact during the year he was with Atlanta. Many of the free agent pitchers that the Braves have signed or brought back are pitchers they think can contribute to the development of the younger pitchers.

The Braves have been an organization that divides players into foundational players and assets. For the most part, you build up your foundation through your minor league system, signing and holding onto them long term. Free agents rarely become foundational players because that’s just not where the Braves are looking for those players. The last foundational player the Braves signed in free agency was Greg Maddux.

docgooden85Member since 2018
5 years ago
Reply to  Jay Jaffe

They have been obsessed with Markakis and his consistent ability to look professional while being below average for several years. Just hire him as a damn coach already considering Acuna is not a CF.

tomerafan
5 years ago

This is going to be a wacky year for FA signings when the same organization is able to sign Charlie Morton for 1/$15 after signing Drew Smyly for 1/$11.

This is a tremendous signing for the Braves… there is risk in every pitching deal, but Ground Chuck on a 1/$15 in front of that infield, for the division favorites, is about as low-risk as you can get. I can already see the “grizzled veteran” narrative in the playoffs next year – the clubhouse leader of the pitching staff who put the Braves over the top. As a Mets fan, it hurts.

FrancoeursteinMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  tomerafan

I’m hoping we’re a little more liberal with his pitch counts. I’d like to see him consistently throw 90+ pitches a game assuming intact health.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Francoeurstein

I actually am wondering if we’ll see it go the other way, whether we’ll see Morton and Smyly piggyback at some point. You could really have an awesome 8 innings out of that duo.

bluerum29
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Make it the solid 9 and I fully support that idea. 5 and 4.

airforce21oneMember since 2026
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

That’s actually an interesting question. Is it worth 26M/year to have, say 1/6 of your total innings pitched (assuming the Morton/Smyly 5/4 split once a week) be good (perhaps not great)?

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  airforce21one

I think the key is that you hope they really are going to give you, say, 225 innings and 5 wins, between the two of them. If that’s the case, then it’s a great deal and the main thing you worry about is giving up two roster spots.

Maybe that’s optimistic, but I do think that 225 innings and 4 wins is possible; that’s a bit worse than what Smyly was doing before he blew out his arm and what Morton was doing with the Astros.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  tomerafan

I like this deal way more than the Smyly deal, although I’m not sure why. I think it’s because I am more worried about injury / regression from Smyly than continued decline from Morton.

Antonio BananasMember since 2016
5 years ago
Reply to  tomerafan

Signs Morton for $15M, signs Smyly for $11M, trades Waters, Langeliers, Touki, and Wright for Snell (making $11M)

carterMember since 2020
5 years ago

I like Smyly for some reason. No real reason for it, just feels like it is going to work.

carterMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  tomerafan

I’m pretty certain Morton could of gotten more if he had held on for a little. I’d imagine coming up with Atlanta and living there iirc is a big factor. He strikes me as the type of guy who isn’t all about money, and would sign quickly and for less.

bluerum29
5 years ago
Reply to  carter

Never understood why players sign on with teams in one place, but live somewhere else. Sign on with teams where you want to live so you can have both. I wouldn’t sign somewhere if I didn’t want to live there.

docgooden85Member since 2018
5 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

You should email your preferences to the MLBPA.

Antonio BananasMember since 2016
5 years ago

The Keuchel WAR is skewed by FIP vs ERA. He’s not a high K guy and yes “those are still real results. But would you rather have a 3.75 ERA with a 4.72 FIP or a 4.72 ERA with a 3.75 FIP on a 1 year deal?

Also, 2017 was rough as a Braves fan. Nothing worse than when your Colon falls apart and your Dickey under performs.

docgooden85Member since 2018
5 years ago

This is a huge signing for the Cobb County Crushers. ZIPS may or may not be smoking crack, but the concept that Kyle Wright and his pure trash AA 1998 fastball or Toussaint and his absolute lack of control much less command will be at 1.7 WAR…I’ll gladly take the under on both, please. This at least gives them 4 legit starters going into the season, even if 2 of them recently started shaving which is scary but a deep bench has always been their thing. A deep bench is only good if you have people better than that to actually play most of the time.

docgooden85Member since 2018
5 years ago
Reply to  docgooden85

Kyle Wright never did anything to me but the draft philosophy on him was his ceiling (#4 starter) is also his floor! Can’t lose! Well guess what? (a) That is a negligent strategy for a first round pick no matter how much you’re budgeting for later rounds & (b) what if you Mr. Scout are not able to predict the future and have no idea what a pitcher’s floor is? (hint: you aren’t and you don’t because it’s catastrophic arm failure, relatively common among humans). But if there was a contest to see who can have the most 6th starter candidates with unfulfilled potential, Advantage Braves! Coasting on reputation for far too long like Mazzone used to get away with.

Connor Grey
5 years ago
Reply to  docgooden85

Wright has definitely been a disappointment so far but he’ll be 25 until October of 2021. And he still hasn’t hit arbitration yet. And he has a solid 3.83 ERA in 141 Triple A innings (112 1/3 inn. in 2019 when the International League was ridiculously hitter friendly). And the Braves have to be encouraged by his final five starts of 2020 when he put up this line:

4.21 ERA 19.8 K% 9.4 BB% 1.4 HR/9

That includes that disastrous NLCS start against LAD when he gave up 7 runs and only got 2 outs. I’m not saying Wright’s a future ace but he’s Atlanta’s 6th best starting pitcher. He’s a lot better than most teams’ 6th best option.

fredsbankMember since 2020
5 years ago

Maybe Morton will do like he did in Houston and just “decide to throw harder.”

bangbang617
5 years ago

“In the aggregate, the Braves have paid about $8 million per win for these guys, and that number would be higher, and the performance further below average, if I hadn’t included the Sánchez deal.”

Why would you do that?